@Monculcedupoulet ... LOL! You'll be pleased to know I haven't remixed anything for a long time and don't intend to again. However, you'll probably be horrified to know that I now make my own music and play bass for two bands! I know how it is when someone ruins a favourite song of yours, and I'm sorry I ruined it for you...
Need to put this on my ipod asit is so cool!Like the original+extended and this is so good.My email is alistairpayne@hotmail.co.uk if you wanna email it.
@gcard79 Hey mate just heard the original of this and though id look for a remix, this is deadly, any chance you could share? Id play this to death in my sets.
@MrJlee5050... Of course. Drop me an email address to send it to and I'll try to get it over to you as soon as possible. Glad you like it. Many cheers. :-)
Click on my name to view the rapper remake of this song. I'm just wondering who it is as it's bugged me since 1996. Apparantly I can't provide the link in the comments...
FOR ALL YOU LOVELY CARLY SIMON "WHY" FANS - Like myself - who have a passion for this song. Here's what I researched on all "WHY" REMIXES: Carly Simon & Funk - "Why Must Your Love Vinyl - Year 2009
PS Anyone here used to subscribe to ItaloDiscoGod before his chanel got wiped into oblivion? The reason I'm asking is cuz he had an AWESOME club version of this song! And I'd love to be able to find it again!!
Whoa, this is really weird cuz I was just checking to see if anyone replied to my (now defunct) old account! Haha. And I'm glad I did because I had no idea that ItaloDiscoGod had a Myspace. So thanks for the info! AS for the club/house version of "Why" I just posted the same Q on a "Carly Simon - Why (12" Mix)" video...yes I am that shameless and desperate. It would be so much easier if I only knew the damn name of the club song and the artist/DJ!
Once again . . . I LOVE IT !!! It's the best remIx I've ever heard. It gets me EXCITED!! Yeah, really! Only if you are a true Fan of this song and enjoy club music, you will appreciate this remix. I first heard it months ago and I still love to hear it! I play it and blast it on my truck as I'm driving in New York City. My friends enjoy it too. GREAT REMIX!! My compliments to the DJ gcard79.
this shouldn't work at all and could be seen as an attempt to bastardize a totally cool song - but, it does work - and actually keeps it's integrity intact.
I'm a big Carly Simon Fan but now I'm a BIGGER Fan of gcard79! I love this re-mix! I play it every night as I'm driving through New York City! OH YEAH!! Love it! Great work GC!
OH MY GOD - OH MY GOD - THIS IS FABULOUS!!! IT'S TURNING ME ON!! I LOVE IT!! I've always wanted to hear a remix even though the original is THE BEST!!!!! M M M WOW!!!
love this track ,doesnt sound right,its too fast!
soulspinner99 1 month ago
good job. great tune
philsanti 3 months ago
@philsanti. Many thanks. :-)
gcard79 2 months ago
@Monculcedupoulet. Haha, thank you! :-D Hellos from London!
gcard79 3 months ago
@Monculcedupoulet ... LOL! You'll be pleased to know I haven't remixed anything for a long time and don't intend to again. However, you'll probably be horrified to know that I now make my own music and play bass for two bands! I know how it is when someone ruins a favourite song of yours, and I'm sorry I ruined it for you...
gcard79 3 months ago
@Monculcedupoulet... Thanks, I'm so glad you like it...
gcard79 3 months ago
Total Rubbish
DaKraftyFella 7 months ago
Awful, ruined a great song
MonkeyZorr 8 months ago
goovey mix she has rellay nice smilie
whirlyfan 8 months ago
Need to put this on my ipod asit is so cool!Like the original+extended and this is so good.My email is alistairpayne@hotmail.co.uk if you wanna email it.
JoandAlly1 11 months ago
it's just faster than the original..
danixboss 1 year ago
this is the best 10 out of 10
MrAUTOMATICINTL 1 year ago
@MrAUTOMATICINTL... Wow, many thanks dude. :-)
gcard79 1 year ago
@gcard79 Hey mate just heard the original of this and though id look for a remix, this is deadly, any chance you could share? Id play this to death in my sets.
MrJlee5050 9 months ago
@MrJlee5050... Of course. Drop me an email address to send it to and I'll try to get it over to you as soon as possible. Glad you like it. Many cheers. :-)
gcard79 9 months ago
this is the best 10 out of 10
MrAUTOMATICINTL 1 year ago
anyone know what the basic chords for this wud be? i really want to do an acoustic cover of it
Bubbles4uk 1 year ago
hey I may have already written this but is there anywhere I can download this track.
IHaveSexWithTheEarth 2 years ago
PM me your email address and I'll send it over to you.
gcard79 2 years ago
SeaDogg89:
Darryl - Darryl Express
TheSonjadean 2 years ago
It's just faster...
hideousfreke 2 years ago
Click on my name to view the rapper remake of this song. I'm just wondering who it is as it's bugged me since 1996. Apparantly I can't provide the link in the comments...
SeaDogg89 2 years ago
Does anyone know who if there was a remake of "Why" by a Dutch rapper (with the Carly hook)?
SeaDogg89 2 years ago
I LOVE YOU "WHY by Carly Simon" lol
sdneirf999 2 years ago
FOR ALL YOU LOVELY CARLY SIMON "WHY" FANS - Like myself - who have a passion for this song. Here's what I researched on all "WHY" REMIXES: Carly Simon & Funk - "Why Must Your Love Vinyl - Year 2009
Carly Simon - Why Remixes - Year 2005
Why (A1) (B1) (B2)
Why Remixes (Why001) Year 2005
Why (A1) (B1) (B2)
(*all at M P 3 G I G A NET)
sdneirf999 2 years ago
ALSO MORE REMIXES:
Carly Simon _-_ Why (Fromage Edit) - (GOOGLE SEARCH)
Why (In the Styles of Carly Simon) - (iTunes)
Bonita Apple Baum Why Remix - (YouTube)
Rampage Tell Me Why - (YouTube)
and the search continues . . .
If YOU find something - post it! Want to hear it! - Smiles!!!
sdneirf999 2 years ago
Carly Simon RULES!!!!!! This is AMAZING!!!!!!!!
jh621 2 years ago
Hehe cool... many thanks!!
gcard79 2 years ago
Wow!! Again, thanks for all the great comments!! :-)
gcard79 2 years ago
Out of all the remixes for this song, this one is the best! Great job!
PHX99 2 years ago
Thanks for uploading this remix. I listen to youtube songs, and this song brightened many boring afternoons!
KRIENEPIEN 2 years ago
Comment removed
KRIENEPIEN 2 years ago
Great remix! Sounds like early Hi NRG almost!!
PS Anyone here used to subscribe to ItaloDiscoGod before his chanel got wiped into oblivion? The reason I'm asking is cuz he had an AWESOME club version of this song! And I'd love to be able to find it again!!
IKAIKA12345678 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
sdneirf999 2 years ago
Whoa, this is really weird cuz I was just checking to see if anyone replied to my (now defunct) old account! Haha. And I'm glad I did because I had no idea that ItaloDiscoGod had a Myspace. So thanks for the info! AS for the club/house version of "Why" I just posted the same Q on a "Carly Simon - Why (12" Mix)" video...yes I am that shameless and desperate. It would be so much easier if I only knew the damn name of the club song and the artist/DJ!
ivanaishere 2 years ago
Cool... many thanks for all the great comments people!! :-)
gcard79 2 years ago
This is the 'Ultimate Bad @ss Song'. Couldn't been done any bettter ...keep 'em coming.
bigXconman 2 years ago
Best thing I've heard yet! Great job.
lisrodd1 2 years ago 2
GREAT STUFF gcard - would love to hear more!
satinsilklatina 2 years ago 3
Once again . . . I LOVE IT !!! It's the best remIx I've ever heard. It gets me EXCITED!! Yeah, really! Only if you are a true Fan of this song and enjoy club music, you will appreciate this remix. I first heard it months ago and I still love to hear it! I play it and blast it on my truck as I'm driving in New York City. My friends enjoy it too. GREAT REMIX!! My compliments to the DJ gcard79.
sdneirf999 2 years ago 2
Hehe, thank you very much... glad you like it.
gcard79 2 years ago
nice done, but sounds a little bit too fast
GinoCaptain 2 years ago 5
click this away really fast!!!
Rotemetoot 2 years ago
I can't hear bernard's bassline, which was why the original was so good.
MR. FUNK
MARANTZamp 2 years ago
Out of sync mate, better luck next time, leave it to the pros.
thenamesdave 3 years ago
All you've done is speeded it up and added yeah yeah in the background?
What a sack of shit. Not even worthy of remix status.
Seany06 3 years ago
too bad the awesome drums are gone
mmmrenkas 3 years ago
excellent really good job xxx
huckholt 3 years ago
this shouldn't work at all and could be seen as an attempt to bastardize a totally cool song - but, it does work - and actually keeps it's integrity intact.
GRIFF74 3 years ago 2
Excellent... Thanks for the compliment!! :-)
gcard79 3 years ago
I'm a big Carly Simon Fan but now I'm a BIGGER Fan of gcard79! I love this re-mix! I play it every night as I'm driving through New York City! OH YEAH!! Love it! Great work GC!
sdneirf999 3 years ago 2
Cool, I'm glad you like it. Thanks for introducing me to NYC!! :-)
gcard79 3 years ago
Well now.....
I'm a big Carly fan and always loved this song.
But i'm so sure how i feel about this.
Nonetheless, KUDOs to you for this great effort.
As for your Reverbnation, As You Were and Dose are the ones i enjoy most.
StretchinOut 3 years ago 2
Be sure to keep an eye out... I'll be posting more remixes here, and more of my original stuff on ReverbNation very soon.
Many thanks for your support.
gcard79 3 years ago
groovy - from a huge carly fan.
swampzoid 3 years ago 3
OH MY GOD - OH MY GOD - THIS IS FABULOUS!!! IT'S TURNING ME ON!! I LOVE IT!! I've always wanted to hear a remix even though the original is THE BEST!!!!! M M M WOW!!!
sdneirf999 3 years ago 2
pukka remix green card need some more of your stuff on youtube ! got any original tracks you have made yoursyelf ?
divinesystems 3 years ago 2
Check out my ReverbNation page for some of my own tracks... YouTube won't let me post a link here, but there's a link on my channel page!!
gcard79 3 years ago