Pia Toscano, All is Fair in Love, Motown, American Idol, 10

[ShawnMyersMusic]

All the judges did was tear her down. Theyd either say "that was amazing but why do you keep doing the same genre" or that "you werent connecting"

she was obviously the most talented on the show. americans are stupid and just listen to the judges sometimes. this was one of the best vocal perofrmance in idol histroy

[Lightmane321]

No way is Celine WAY ahead of Pia. No freaking way. I'll take Pia right now over Celine, but I know that Celine is amazing. If you wanna say Celine is still better than her, fine, but way ahead??? Not a chance.

[lushfauna]

Steve tyler is the best

[inthelao]

well, she sings better then JLO, but Celine is still wayyyyyyyyyyyyy ahead of her.

[LitZena]

She has a beautiful voice but she holds too many notes too long and it's kind of annoying like she keeps trying to top herself in note holding time.

[SuperSeaweedSoup]

I think she sounded better when she sang this song live. The studio version is good, don't get me wrong, but I think when she sings this live there is more feeling, more raw passion in her voice. I don't know how to explain it. All I know is, when she sings live, her voice holds me spellbound from the first note to the very last. She is out of this world, and I can't wait to see her in concert someday...

[superk734]

@SuperSeaweedSoup I think, what you may mean by that is when you listen to her live for the first time, we sit anticipating every note and waiting to see what she will sing, how it will sound, etc., and when she hits those notes it's so exhilarating to watch and then when you listen back to the videos it doesn’t have the same effect, but for ME, every time I watch her, and some of the others, I still get stimulated by their electrifying performance(s) all over again.

[superk734]

She is a natural with the whole package, could listening to her all the time

[sunfunmancanfan]

THAT WAS SPECTACULARLY BEAUTIFUL!

[Clifton100]

I wanna boink her. sorry