Added: 1 year ago
From: Cade78
Views: 40,101
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (464)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • People keep saying: "DA OPENING CINEMATIC IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO BETTER ON THE PSX VERSION!!!!1!!"

    Well, that's because the PSX cinematic is pre-rendered, while the Wii one is rendered in real time (that is, it's not video playback).

    Also, as far as I can tell, the characters on the PSX version are sprites with pre-rendered 3D graphics, while the on the Wii, they are polygon rendered.

    So, the only major diference is that the PSX one looks brighter and the text on the intro is more poethic.

  • the playstation cinematic looks like it had actual effort put into it...

    

  • Klonoa>Sonic

  • on playstation the clonoa is cute but the wii is more good

  • but hey, klonoa is klonoa. im glad its been remastered for the wii, everything looks so realistic and brought back to life. ^_^

  • i really like how the ring at the beginning looks for the playstation. the cinemagraphics look better too.i played the demo when it first came for the playstation, but so far i have the wii one. currently working for playstation one. its just so high on ebay or amazon since its rare.

  • Thank god this game is available on PSN, now if we can get the second game on there too

  • Seriously, they fucking butchered the Wii version.

  • @Svesve777 its not all that bad.

  • I had a lot of memories from this game

  • klonoa looks older in the wii version.

    psx version is the best

  • Klonoa 3 should be for 3DS!

  • They got rid of some things and changed other ones, for better and worse, but that happens with every remake. Wii remake comes out ahead only because of better technology and design.

  • Comment removed

  • PSX VERSION IS THE BEST !!!

  • Wow. I never thought I would say this but the playstation 1 version is much better than the Wii version. In fact, I want to play the playstation version ^.^

  • @TalesOfGod Well, prepare to write out a big, fat check because the PlayStation version is considered fairly rare, so it costs an average of ~$65 (American) on eBay used. And if you want it brand new, that's a whole different story; you have to pay ~$1000 to ~$2000 for a copy that's new in the original shrink wrap. Good luck.

  • @SonicTehAwesomeFace I've got only four words for you!

    Emulator or burn disk! ^.^

  • @TalesOfGod I don't use emulators (at least not anymore), as they don't have the original feel of the game, and I don't feel comfortable modding my PS-One/PS2 fat, as that can potentially break my console.

  • playstation wins

    

  • Klonoa...omigosh he's the cutest character in the world. .

    I like the moos and the characters in the wii (but not klonoa...he is much better in the playstation<3) but that's all. The playstation is BEAUTIFUL

  • instead of the charactors just making a stupid noise with subtitles,why did'nt they just speak in english in the first place,would make it less annoying,the games brilliant though

  • @bigdonkey1000 but then it wouldn't be as cute !

  • better color on the playstation

  • playstation version is much better ^^

    Realy Good synchronised

  • Lights on ps are better but I prefer that on the wii cause of the athmosphere and the design of the main character. Abouth the athmosphere... On the wii there are those trees, the woods, it's somehow dark inside. It's about that therefor is only my personal opinion. I would like to have this game, seems nice... But don't have ps3 - wii. Too bad

  • AHAHAHA WII GOT OWND

  • I have to agree with many others here.

    The PS's cutscreens are far, far better. Even the bit with the moon, the writing for the PS version was more poetic. The Wii's level's however look great, and looks like they kept the level design close to the original.

  • First cutscene was sort of surprising. The you'd think they'd try to make it look BETTER, not worse. The rest of the game, though, looked as expected.

  • I liked the Wii version by the graphics, but for my taste, but the film of the play station I would go to more consoles

  • Now THIS is what a wii-version of an old-school game should be like.

  • majoras mask anyone? 3:14

  • I've never played a Klonoa game before, but he looks pretty cool. Just who is the...Bunny, Cat looking creature and what makes him so popular?

  • Thats a good looking Wii game

  • Playstation, WAY better than wee (mainly for the time of release), alsol, loved the fact that yo never understood the title on the screen untill you have ended the game, WII took that out and so, they suck!

  • If you didn't have the labels at the bottom, i wouldn't be able to tell the difference.

  • I used to play this game in ps , now I play in wii

  • graphics in-game, the wii kills ps lol. the cutscenes of ps version has a lot of blur effect

  • Just got it from gamestop. I'm loving every minute of it. It stays true to the original(though, hearing the English voices, while not bad, is sort of awkward. I switched it to Phantomile since I've grown up hearing it) and I'm happy to play this again since I've never beaten it and it was given away. And seeing how every scene was recreated almost exactly like the original makes me say "THE NOSTALGIA'S KILLING ME!" :D

  • I'm the proud owner of both versions and both are equally amazing :)

    ( though I prefer the PS1 version, if only because it's the original ♥ )

  • For gameplay and sharper graphics i would say wii but for the key feautures and originality i would say ps1.

  • Thanks for this comparison! Love it!

    

  • @noobdief yeah thats right

  • he's soooo cute

  • Classic is where it's at but the Wii version shows more detail *shrugs* They are both good imo.

  • i love how it takes FOREVER to access the memory card lol

  • Okay, this might be a stupid question, but why is that the Klonoa on the wii I have sound like he does from 1 and 2? He actually speaks english in mine.

  • @BadApple64 I haven't played in quite some time, but if I remember right when your in the title screen you can go to options and choose which language you'd rather have.

    I hope that wasn't too vague! ;;

  • @Rozenpoke100 Yeah, I figured that out yesterday, thanks though.

  • both versions are great

  • so in ps he was younger in wii he was older

  • Klonoa very beautiful game my fovorite version ps1

  • very otaku in the wii, ps1 the best ever!!!

  • klonoa is smarter in ps!

  • snrk!Klonoa Generations anyone?

  • @kolbysmith5239 oh! don't go there!

  • wii

  • I played both at one point, but I was so young when the PS1 version came out that I didn't quite know how to play and ended up failing at the Moon Kingdom. But the Wii version I beat easily. Got all the citizens from the visions too.

  • I prefer how the cut scenes look on the PS1, but the Wii version doesn't look bad either. I did like the choice of words better in the PS1 version, as well as how they wrote the speech out. But it's definitely worth getting the Wii remake if you can't get your hands on the PS1 version, based on what I can tell from this comparison.

  • Damn, that soundtrack really brings back so many awesome memories. Love this game.

  • the cutscenes are better on ps1

  • What did they do to Balue!? His personality has completely changed!

  • I wish they would remake it for the PS3 :)

  • @TanookiBear & 3DS!

  • it might just be me but did the phantomilian language sound less like garbled nonsense in the playstation version?

  • not to affend klonoa fans, but this game looks alot like a sonic clone.

  • @pokemon200016 But klonoa is 1billion times more epic than sonic! js :D

  • @pokemon200016 Would you mind clarifying your statement? Apart from the use of an anthropomorphic character as the main character (which is par for the course for platformers) I can't see much similarity between the two

  • @TheOriginalBoman well, he has sonics eyes(even though they are not green), tails mouth fur, cream the rabbits(just fluffed up a bit), big the cats gloves(playstation kolonoa). and please dont swear at me, im only stating my opinion.

  • @pokemon200016

    I don't believe I swore in my previous comment. Also, you stated that the game was a sonic the hedgehog rip-off, while your reasons for saying this are based on character design, not gameplay. Additionally, your argument for the similarity in character design is also flawed, as you state that Klonoa has eyes similar to Sonic, even though Sonic's eye design is one white shape with two pupils, while Klonoa has two Yellow shapes for eyes.

  • @TheOriginalBoman im talking about the wii version.

  • at first i thought it was ps3 cose the cutscene looked amazing

  • the playstation*

  • The kinematics of the beginning of the playstation 2 is much better made​than the wii!

  • The lighting and angles in the cutscenes are WAY better in the PS version.

  • @Kirbychu1 And that rustles my jimmies >:|

  • @Kirbychu1 lol thats cuz they computer generated its not the games visuals anyone can make a cut scene like that

  • @Kirbychu1  also the fact that some parts are completely missing from the wii version like the colored trees

  • @Kirbychu1 It's because the PS used CGI and the Wii used models.

  • im sorry but if u wana go there u should do nintendo 64 and compair it to a playstation nes looks better than playstation in 8 bit

  • @MrSmokinhotdude Uh, the video is comparing the Orginal Klonoa with it's remake on the Wii to show the difference. It's not a 'this is better than this'.

  • The only thing that irks me about the Wii version is that they don't spell most of the names correctly ;w;

  • Wii version looks darker and more dull

    What a shame

  • @Muffincakeswithsugar

    What a shame.

    You didn't even try to skip the cutscenes.

  • the wii version only got better graphics...the gameplay look exactly the same

  • i prefer the playstation version. because i just have playstation verison don't have wii verision

  • @Exilelangely

    You can't say you prefer something if you don't have the latter of both.

    It's not called ''PREFERRING''

    It's called I never ever bought the wii, and I apparently have the PS version, and I liked it.

    Also, THE GAMEPLAY FOR THE WII IS THE TOTAL SAME.

    Except it has better graphics, so it's a bit better on your eyes.

    Wii version is clearly better, it's like comparing gamecube to PS3.

  • ese es ps 1

    

  • platstation!

  • both the gameplay is better in the wii 

  • hello childhood <3

  • I'll admit, the opening cutscene for the PS version caused me to laugh my ass off. Klonoa's face while he was trying to pull the ring out of the ground is just priceless...

  • Yes PS is Better, but, the video before the videogame gameplay in PS is one video made in PC and the wii are Graphics 100%

  • I wish they would release a remake of that PS1 game called TOMBA for WII & update the graphics for it similar to how they did this game. Thumbs up if you remember that awesome game!

  • @vertigoboy75i yeah....I miss that shirtless guy with PINK! hair and his ability to learn the dwarven language simply by biting dwarves...

  • @vertigoboy75i it will be a dream comes true !

  • @vertigoboy75i 2d side scroller right???

  • @vertigoboy75i tombi was a real cool game :D

  • @LuksRokZ the reason the cut scenes look more brighter & colorful on PS1 then the WII version is becuz at the time they used CGI graphics for the opening scene with the PS1 while the WII version used the game's actuall gameplay graphics during the opening scene

  • in the wii version it said klonoa was a "He"

  • The PlayStation footage looks more interesting.

  • wow, sony fanboys denying that the wii has better graphics. sad.

  • @harmfulifconsumed

    actually, if you read before being a dick, they said that the ps game was more colorful. actually it came out alot better, because klonoaworks couldn't rely on graphics. they had to put effort into making a game.

  • @OobydoobBanoubie Have you even played the Wii version? The game itself is better than the PS1 version not just the graphics.

  • @harmfulifconsumed lol your obviously not getting the point, the ps1 version still looks good. When the ps1 came out all nintendo had was the snes. then ps2 to n64 lol then ps3 to wii. Nintendo has been 4 years behind since i can remember. Nintendo just sucks and Im not a fanboy of any consoles im a pc gamer

  • @PsiloCybinDreamX You mean they had the Nintendo 64 which was better looking than the PS1, and then the GAMECUBE which was better than the PS2 graphically (facts, look it up). You thought they jumped from N64 to Wii? What a fucking idiot. The only console where Nintendo was behind graphically was the Wii, but kids like you don't remember any of Nintendo's previous consoles. You just suck and you're a fucking PC elitist fanboy. Nintendo makes games worth playing.

  • @harmfulifconsumed lol dumbass ps1 was out way before n64 but when it came out is when ps2 was which blew its ass out of the water same with the ps3 destroys the wii. The gamecube and wii share the same gpu lol dumbass just over clocked on the wii. the gamecube couldnt handle games like god of war and shadow of the colossus.i dont even need to look anything up and already know more than you, and im no kid my first console was the nes and the original gameboy which i still have

  • @PsiloCybinDreamX You've got your history so fucking wrong it's not funny. You DO need to look it up but you're such a close-minded moron that you won't so you aren't worth my time. I can't teach idiots anything. I have actual GOOD games to go play on my Wii right now, like, I don't know Zelda and then maybe some Galaxy 2. Go enjoy your generic, shitty shooter games with your 'dude bro' faggot friends.

    "Durr Nintendo sucks ima go play my 300th shooter" lol fucking hilarious.

  • @harmfulifconsumed lol funny your stuck using just a wii I could simply emulate them on my computer which I have done but funny your stuck on console ROFL. PC ftw Kid you've lost the argument enough said

  • @PsiloCybinDreamX STUCK on a Wii? I have a PS3 and a fucking high-end computer you dumb ass, I PREFER the Wii. I'm not stuck on anything, I play good games no matter what console they're on. And I'm not a worthless thief that pirates games. I don't go around saying the Wii sucks without knowing anything about good fucking games.

    And not "PC ftw" everybody can game on the PC it doesn't make you special you fucking retard. You've lost life enough said.

  • @harmfulifconsumed uh huh, excuses excuses

  • @harmfulifconsumed oh yeah thats right lol....the wii doesnt even have online gaming. Wow just keep saying stuff to back up your lame excuses and make yourself look even gayer that you already have

  • @PsiloCybinDreamX The Wii doesn't have online gaming? ARE YOU FUCKING STUPID? (Yes), wow I just wasted my time with a moron who doesn't know anything. Goodbye and enjoy your block you fucking idiot.

  • @harmfulifconsumed funny you can only block me from your channel, you must be new to youtube. well obviously when someone gets that cry babyish of a basher of nintendo. Doesn't seem to amaze me but is a little comical

  • @PsiloCybinDreamX The PS1 released 9\1995 and N64 in 9\1996. 1 year difference. PS2 released 10\2000 and Gamecube 11\2001. N64 only competed with the PS2 for only 1 year.

    FACT: PS2 was the least powerful console spec wise last generation. God of War is an amazing looking game, but PS2 could never do F-ZeroGX nearly as clean at a constant 60fps.

    Wii is pretty much an overclocked GC, but has many great games despite it's technical inferiority to the PS3 and 360.

  • @OldsXCool yeah I know the wii is an overclocked GC, but their still making games for the ps2 also I dont know if i can say that about gamecube

  • @harmfulifconsumed Nintendo hasn't made a game worth playing since Ocarina of Time...

  • @harmfulifconsumed how? i could feel the emotions from klonoa in the original. the dialogue, the voices and... everything flowed. from the beginning of the remake and on, i wanted the game to end. how could a remake possibly be made better than the original?

  • @harmfulifconsumed And how many years after the PSX did the Wii come out? What's your point? "durr, my Dell Dimension 8100 has better graphics than the Macintosh Apple II, LOLZ!!!" No shit... The Wii is TWO generations ahead of the PSX. If it didn't have better graphics, something would be terribly wrong.

  • you can't compares the PS1 with the Wii,obviously the Wii have more graphics than the PS1.

  • Ps1 looks more lively in the cutscenes, in my opinion.

  • jesus the wii is all about remakes try to be original and new for once

  • Comment removed

  • PS1 version has that dreamy feeling while Wii version has sharper graphics and whatnot. Still love the PS1 better though. So many childhood memories lol

  • why does Klonoa have a pac man thing on his hat? haha PS1 all the way

  • @Arenalarmyof1 it's namco's mascot

  • @Arenalarmyof1 Pac-man was created by Namco, and so did Klonoa so the Pac-man is probably an easter egg from Namco.

  • playstation cutscene graphics look way better and wii in game graphics look better but the playstation version is better then the wii version. the original version is always better then the remake

  • ps1 has such cute voice acting... 

  • dat ps1 klonoa

    He looked so innocent and cute an all, makes the ending even more sadder ._.

    Wii has better graphics, but those prerendered cutscenes, i dunno, it felt more movie like and awesome then the ingame engine

  • Wii's version is nothing but sonic ¬¬

  • ps one is better

    

  • The official Playstation podcast stated that Door to Phantomile will be released on the Playstation Network in the United States next week, Tuesday December 27th 2011 to be exact!

  • @ebbhead1991 i hope ur right

  • @ebbhead1991 i hope ur right

  • Comment removed

  • the music makes me happy and nostalgic=]

  • its clear that the wii has better graphics in gamplay, but in the cutscenes, the ps1 ver looks so much more colorful and brighter.

  • @LuksRokZ yea i 100% agree

  • @LuksRokZ That's because it's cgi, while the Wii they used the in game graphics. On the Wii version they were kinda lazy to make it.

  • @LuksRokZ thats because ps1 uses movie sequence while wii is a fully rendered sequence

  • Comment removed

  • @LuksRokZ Thats obviously pren-rendered! The Wii is rendering live. OMG are you seriously that stupid!?

  • hmmm i cant decide the wii has beautiful graphics the ps1 has cute looking graphics

    cant decide cant decide..................

    ill think about it later

  • the best classic console is nes.the best modern console is nintendo 3ds

  • ps1 sucks! go wii!

  • The Ps one version makes the wii version look stupid.

  • excellent vid, how you do that, must took a lot of work

  • 2:47 - Holy shit, look at his teeth! (Left Panel)

    Overall, I thought the character looked better along in the PS version. He took on a more generic anime appearance in the Wii version.

  • Comment removed

  • The display at the bottom of the first game adds to the look of the game a lot too. I also really like how the platforms wobble. Another thing about Klonoa's look in the PS1 version, he's shorter and wider. Cartoon artists genereally use this proportion to make characters look cuter. In the Wii version, he's kind of long looking, and awkward.

  • @Eifler121 very well said I'm a cartoon artist (non professional) and what you said is 100% spot on. When I want someone to look cute I make them short chubbey and give them big heads with huge eyes to match :3

  • @XxAngiexXRPI Yeah, I think that artistic style suits the dream-world and child demographic they are trying to appeal to the most. What kind of cartoons do you draw? Is there somewhere we can see your work?

  • I'm impressed, actually. The cutscene graphics on the PS1 are actually better than those on the Wii. The PS1 version looks a lot more whimsical and childlike, even after the cutscene it has more of a storybook quality to it. The yellow in his eyes being a lot bigger really adds to his look, I think, and his costume overall is better looking in the original. The Wii version has cooler backgrounds and animation, just because the buildings look bigger, and the water texture is better. PS1 wins this

  • NINTENDO WII THE BEST!!!!!!!!!

  • hy the story looks better in ps2 but when you play wii is better ...thanx for the video...sorry for my english

  • wii sucks!! psx is better!!! 

  • myself 22 year old man: *sniff.... missed this game

  • psx mejor

  • Wii version has better graphics and better controllers, but PS1 is over 11 years older console.

  • i had a klonoa 2 demo disc but on the select game screen it said kalonda2 confused the fuck out of me for years

  • can some1 gimme the game D:! (for ps1 :3)

  • The one difference that strikes me the most is that Klonoa has less dialogue in the Wii version. I think it's because his Japanese seiyuu (voice actor), Kumiko Watanabe, is having trouble trying to reprise her role after like 10+ years, his voice isn't exactly easy to do, especially when you're speaking gibberish XD

    Well, that's my opinion...

  • the ps one version makes the character look less badass then ever and he doesnt look too badass to begin with

  • wii looks like ps3

    

  • Playstation still has better graphics XD however i prefer the klonoa modernized. only because his eyes are huge in Playstation lol

  • Yeah! Klonoa rules no matter who designs it

    Sí! Klonoa es es genial sin importar quién lo diseñe

  • Aww, the Wii is so cute, it's like watching a kid trying to drink beer to look like a grown-up then failing and getting shitfaced xD

  • the PS one is better in my opinion

  • @chivasboy451

    YOU 'RE CRAZY MAN

  • I think the wii version is better, but that is just me :)

  • Looking at this, it reminds me that the PS1 version looked very good, better than most other PS1 games.

    I like the Wii port still, being bumped up a generation-and-a-half in visuals [and using 3D models for objects and characters instead of just the level].