@CarrotDoctor As alluded to in the description I'm using "Neo Black Speech" - created for use in the movies - seeing as only one line of Black Speech was ever written by Tolkien.
@CarrotDoctor Orcs do borrow a few words from the Black Speech (like 'hai' and 'olog') but mostly they use Westron when communicating with each other.
@piki68 There are many different version of 'Black Speech' seeing as Tolkien never gave us more than a few lines of the language. The version used in the video is that of David Salo - which was used in the films. I am however working on another video with the other version of Black Speech that contains the word "gakh". Thank you for the Feedback.
@MrFunkyBoogaloo Thank you to the reference, I don't know this version. I'm using a version from a spanish site ( i think is spanish). Can you tell me where can I find your version?
I using this: lambenor.free.fr/tengwar/lengneg.html
and with some effect like the film??it could be great..XD with the dark echo and something like that,im sure you can do it and it could be better,i think,but 5 stars now XD
@3X0N Kinda... except Arabic is one of those "rolls off the tongue" languages. I think Tolkien probably wanted a clash with the flow of Middle Eastern and the rock hard feel of Nordic languages when he did Black Speech.
@MrFunkyBoogaloo Ah, I thought that was probably the case. And yes, I know that s+h is pronounced "sh". My spelling it as "zsh" was only an (obviously bad. lol) attempt to empahise that it had a slightly more gutteral sound than in the typical english pronunciation of those letters. So, sorry for any confusion there. Anyway, thanks for taking the time to reply. I shall look forward to the updated version. :)
I notice that you're pronouncing the s+h combination in -ishi as a "ss" (i.e. "-issi") though. Is there a reason for that? or are you just basing your pronunciation on Ian McKellen's in FOTR? You see, I thought s+h was always "zsh" in Black Speech (as, for example, in Alan Howard's lines as Sauron/The Ring)?
pretty sure its "gakh (Shre) nazgu" u is the plural suffix in black speech
CarrotDoctor 4 months ago
@CarrotDoctor As alluded to in the description I'm using "Neo Black Speech" - created for use in the movies - seeing as only one line of Black Speech was ever written by Tolkien.
MrFunkyBoogaloo 4 months ago
@MrFunkyBoogaloo is there not a bunch of fancy orc slang?
CarrotDoctor 4 months ago
@CarrotDoctor Orcs do borrow a few words from the Black Speech (like 'hai' and 'olog') but mostly they use Westron when communicating with each other.
MrFunkyBoogaloo 4 months ago
Not bad! But i have a problem. The Black Speach dont using "e". The three in Black Speach is not "shre". It is "gakh" .
piki68 6 months ago 2
@piki68 There are many different version of 'Black Speech' seeing as Tolkien never gave us more than a few lines of the language. The version used in the video is that of David Salo - which was used in the films. I am however working on another video with the other version of Black Speech that contains the word "gakh". Thank you for the Feedback.
MrFunkyBoogaloo 5 months ago in playlist More videos from MrFunkyBoogaloo
Comment removed
piki68 5 months ago
@MrFunkyBoogaloo Thank you to the reference, I don't know this version. I'm using a version from a spanish site ( i think is spanish). Can you tell me where can I find your version?
I using this: lambenor.free.fr/tengwar/lengneg.html
piki68 5 months ago
@piki68 elvish.org/gwaith/movie_soundtrack_fotr.htm
MrFunkyBoogaloo 5 months ago
and with some effect like the film??it could be great..XD with the dark echo and something like that,im sure you can do it and it could be better,i think,but 5 stars now XD
isubastars 7 months ago
@abelcardenas05 None of it is elvish; the entire poem is in Black Speech, which Sautron created himself for his minions to speak.
Masterferret7 7 months ago
I'm very impressed. This is being favorited.
RulerL0rd 7 months ago
You have a sexy voice...;)
teshanovic1 7 months ago
If only this was an actual foreign language course... :P
TheCursedChosen1 7 months ago
sounds like an arab language.
3X0N 9 months ago
@3X0N Kinda... except Arabic is one of those "rolls off the tongue" languages. I think Tolkien probably wanted a clash with the flow of Middle Eastern and the rock hard feel of Nordic languages when he did Black Speech.
EdikShepherd 8 months ago
Man, i'm almost afraid to speak it.
I mean, it IS the language of Mordor.
Fab4Sunrises 10 months ago
you have a wonderful pronounciation, from where do you get these 'translated' speeches?
gabrielmicallef 10 months ago
@MrFunkyBoogaloo Ah, I thought that was probably the case. And yes, I know that s+h is pronounced "sh". My spelling it as "zsh" was only an (obviously bad. lol) attempt to empahise that it had a slightly more gutteral sound than in the typical english pronunciation of those letters. So, sorry for any confusion there. Anyway, thanks for taking the time to reply. I shall look forward to the updated version. :)
PassionatelyPurple 1 year ago
This is beautiful. You have a wonderful voice. :)
I notice that you're pronouncing the s+h combination in -ishi as a "ss" (i.e. "-issi") though. Is there a reason for that? or are you just basing your pronunciation on Ian McKellen's in FOTR? You see, I thought s+h was always "zsh" in Black Speech (as, for example, in Alan Howard's lines as Sauron/The Ring)?
PassionatelyPurple 1 year ago 2
YES!!!!! :D perfect! pronunciation, the raining in the background, AND you had the translation with the original script! this made my day better :]
zetadiamond063 1 year ago
I'm gonna put on some black hooded robes and follow people down dark alleyways while not-so-subtly muttering this to myself.
Not really.
cuallito 1 year ago
AMAZIN stuff! wonder if i can get an mp3 version from you!
tallboysmith 1 year ago
Yea sounds like it could be a Caucasus language:)
Cybelian83 1 year ago
Comment removed
Cybelian83 1 year ago
Even though this is a made up language ... the letters look very similar to Georgian Language
Cybelian83 1 year ago
@MrFunkyBoogaloo very cool. Are those appendices in the back of the trilogy books?
ddduncan7 1 year ago
awesome!! where did you learn to speak?
ddduncan7 1 year ago
"Ashi!"
flojo83 1 year ago