Its OK to publish different tempi - then we can hear which is too slow, and which (as this one) that are too fast.
This song is the last part of "Academic Festival Ouverture" by Brahms - he preseted the songs as he heard them by the students at his time. I think his tempo is correct.
The fresh approach - conveyed by the pace - makes us aware of the fact that it is an anthem of young academics, leaving an amazing final period of their youth behind and starting into optimistic adulthood!
BRAVO!
(I wish I could sing this way.
I'll have my graduation ceremony in July. Unfortunately we only do the first stanza, at Vienna University.)
Having listened to at least a dzn versions of this on YT, and having sung it myself, I personally like the Moscow perf the best overall. However, I do like this one, too, even tho at 140 it's rather faster than most versions at about 100. The most important part of this song is singing it with gusto- this is not a dirge!! 3inrifle gets it- this is a FUN song!! Listen to the end of Brahms' Acad Fest Overt- THAT's the spirit of it! (BTW- I esp like the sop line at the end of each verse.)
I've never understood why something that starts "Let us rejoice" is most often sung as a funeral dirge. And with lyrics like 'Long live the girls, so beautiful and willing, and the mature ladies, so tender and accommodating" it is hardly addressing the sacred. This is more an endorsement and celebration of the bacchanalian proclivities of students than anything else. As I posted before, nice to hear it as students may have sung it on the way back from the tavern rather than in chapel.
The composition and design of the Roosevelt Academy Choir has been changed in such a way that this video does not resemble the current RA Choir any more. For videos made by the current RA Choir we would like to point you towards the channel of TheRAChoir.
Give these guys a break. The pitch was very good, and I for one believe music is an expression that is very much alive. Without interpretation and experimentation there is no progress, and while individual tastes vary - if the most important part of your day is whether a choir performs a song too quickly for your liking, that's an issue. I applaud them not only for their vocal talent, but also the bravery to perform and post.
what are they thinking? I was looking for a version of the Gaudeamus Igitur like we sang it when I was a student. We stood up proud hand on our heart and sang it stately and proud of every sylliable. After all it is one of the official songs that are ALWAYS sung on a cantus.
Fooling around while it is sung will get you trown out of the cantus and people will hold it against you for a long time. Almost (or worse) like disturbing a national anthem.
Flippant. Half star at best. This was an absolutely frighteningly awful rendition of this song. Now see if you can read and recite this comment in one breathless second just like you sang the song. I hope you don't have a version of the Hallelujah Chorus somewhere on here...
to the person who says too fast it is a German Student drinking song not a dirge it sounds like a hymn as they were taking the mickey. Nice fresh choral tone
Seriously, telling me you don't like it that way doesn't help, so stop it. Sing it differently for all I care, but since our conductor and our audiences like it, posting for the 15th time that you think it's too fast doesn't change a thing.
Right, but practically we (Meaning my fraternity) sing it more slowly. The 7th stanza is sung in the style of Roosevelt Academy, this is where it says "pereat tristitia, pereant osores, pereat diabolus, quivis anti-burschius, atque irrisores"
Oh well, if that's the way you sing it, there's nothing I can do about it, and the same way, you'll have to live with it that we sing it the way we do, and the way we think it should be sung.
I know what you said, and what I meant to say is that it's not supposed to be slow, since it's a prank song sung by students saying "be happy because life is short".
De Brevitate Vitae (on the Shortness of Life) is a song in Latin that is a popular academic commercium song in many European countries. In many modern Western nations it is sung as an anthem at University graduation ceremonies. The melody is inspired by a medieval hymn. (!)Although this sounds very dignified, the song has been adopted by students as a form of prank and the lyrics are not very dignified.
Quit fast. But who says you can't interpertate sheet music! :)
I, for one, prefer a more calm tempo for the Gaudeamus...
RobopYT 6 months ago
IT IS TOO FAST.
unalpalmira2301 6 months ago
IT IS TOOOOO FASTTTTTTTTTTT!!!! lol
gary52100 8 months ago
Its OK to publish different tempi - then we can hear which is too slow, and which (as this one) that are too fast.
This song is the last part of "Academic Festival Ouverture" by Brahms - he preseted the songs as he heard them by the students at his time. I think his tempo is correct.
Jegermeistern 9 months ago
Lovely performance!
The fresh approach - conveyed by the pace - makes us aware of the fact that it is an anthem of young academics, leaving an amazing final period of their youth behind and starting into optimistic adulthood!
BRAVO!
(I wish I could sing this way.
I'll have my graduation ceremony in July. Unfortunately we only do the first stanza, at Vienna University.)
princecrocodyle 9 months ago
It is not too fast.
DivorceGoddess 10 months ago
this is a very sentimental and moving ditty... ergo poco, poco!!
TheJbach 1 year ago
As a final comment, I would like to add that it it is too fast.
Studentenfanfare 1 year ago
Having listened to at least a dzn versions of this on YT, and having sung it myself, I personally like the Moscow perf the best overall. However, I do like this one, too, even tho at 140 it's rather faster than most versions at about 100. The most important part of this song is singing it with gusto- this is not a dirge!! 3inrifle gets it- this is a FUN song!! Listen to the end of Brahms' Acad Fest Overt- THAT's the spirit of it! (BTW- I esp like the sop line at the end of each verse.)
eclecticscot 1 year ago
Comment removed
alephseries 1 year ago
I've never understood why something that starts "Let us rejoice" is most often sung as a funeral dirge. And with lyrics like 'Long live the girls, so beautiful and willing, and the mature ladies, so tender and accommodating" it is hardly addressing the sacred. This is more an endorsement and celebration of the bacchanalian proclivities of students than anything else. As I posted before, nice to hear it as students may have sung it on the way back from the tavern rather than in chapel.
3inrifle 1 year ago
The composition and design of the Roosevelt Academy Choir has been changed in such a way that this video does not resemble the current RA Choir any more. For videos made by the current RA Choir we would like to point you towards the channel of TheRAChoir.
TheRAChoir 1 year ago
Too fast for my liking.
welshsoldier211 2 years ago 4
Not every hymn must be sung as a dirge. This is about youth and a celebration of life, not passing the open casket of lost youth.
3inrifle 2 years ago
WTF?? Is that race or hymn?
DrCharlie89 2 years ago
Dreadful. Apart from that eager school choir (a bit flat?) and their parents' rightly delighted response, why is there no decent version on Youtube?
didsburyduck 2 years ago
Comment removed
ttogafer 2 years ago
Give these guys a break. The pitch was very good, and I for one believe music is an expression that is very much alive. Without interpretation and experimentation there is no progress, and while individual tastes vary - if the most important part of your day is whether a choir performs a song too quickly for your liking, that's an issue. I applaud them not only for their vocal talent, but also the bravery to perform and post.
akayume13 2 years ago 4
De gustibus non disputandum est.
ognisperanza 2 years ago
what are they thinking? I was looking for a version of the Gaudeamus Igitur like we sang it when I was a student. We stood up proud hand on our heart and sang it stately and proud of every sylliable. After all it is one of the official songs that are ALWAYS sung on a cantus.
Fooling around while it is sung will get you trown out of the cantus and people will hold it against you for a long time. Almost (or worse) like disturbing a national anthem.
this version is awful.
QuintanaZoray 3 years ago
feels like there is no proper version of "Gaudeamus Igitur" on Youtube....
:-(
neroclavd321 3 years ago 2
Flippant. Half star at best. This was an absolutely frighteningly awful rendition of this song. Now see if you can read and recite this comment in one breathless second just like you sang the song. I hope you don't have a version of the Hallelujah Chorus somewhere on here...
GLG47 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They're Roosevelt students....
They are inferior....
theriddler55 3 years ago
Nice harmony, but slow it down. The tones are to be savored, like a fine wine.
BenAliGtor 3 years ago 2
Why don´t they ever sing the "Vivant omnes virgines" stanza?:D
satelit1984 3 years ago 3
Too Fast!! troppo veloce!
simocyber 3 years ago 13
slower damn it. I'm Romainan and my ancestors are the Romans I think they would be ashamed to hear it like that
larevepa 3 years ago 5
That is WAY WAY too fast for Gaudeamus Igitur. What the heck is that guy thinking?
TarsTarkas21461 3 years ago 4
u got nothing on my latin class ;)
joker71294 3 years ago 2
IT IS TOO FAST!
trumpet1977 3 years ago 10
This is the best Gaudeamus igitur i have found here on youtube.
Try to hear this on your inauguration of study- you will understand then
jmmisiek 3 years ago
there is no passion at all... sorry
we sing it better ^^
Holowachuk 3 years ago 3
too fast!
kakkamaki 3 years ago 2
to the person who says too fast it is a German Student drinking song not a dirge it sounds like a hymn as they were taking the mickey. Nice fresh choral tone
dermie12 4 years ago 2
Not really medival, more early modern-ages/ 18th Century. But it's origins are in the medival, that's right.Still a far way to its "modern" form.
pereat diabolus
quivis antiburschius
Aenur1986 4 years ago
It's a mediaeval student drinking song. In light of the spirit of it, it doesn't really matter on the speed, so long as it is quite lively.
garbhd 4 years ago 3
it's too fast..!!
Cereisa 4 years ago 3
it is the only proper version of this song that we still sing in our Latin lessons... ^^
quicquam 4 years ago 3
exactly :P...
svwkip1222 4 years ago
Schön! Kompliment! Bellissimo grazie!
Thanks.
larsvenils 4 years ago
agreed, my men's ensemble (the crane men's ensemble) is performing this and i should say it should be taken much slower, but its all opinions
MNM1018 4 years ago
OMG!!! Does it really matter how fast or slow it is sung?? The point is that it sounds good. We [my choir] sing it slower. But this is nice too.
Danana28 4 years ago 2
Seriously, telling me you don't like it that way doesn't help, so stop it. Sing it differently for all I care, but since our conductor and our audiences like it, posting for the 15th time that you think it's too fast doesn't change a thing.
Joermungard 4 years ago
I think it is too fast. The second verse is meant to be fast and staccato the rest should be slower.
UkiWonderGal 4 years ago
Dudes, if you think it is too fast, don't listen to it for heaven's sake, this is the way we perform it.
Joermungard 4 years ago
We listen... if we don't, how to say "it's too fast"? ;)
You perform it, ok. But.. too fast. ;)
4ntigone 4 years ago
It is too fast...
mihaiherda 4 years ago
Right, but practically we (Meaning my fraternity) sing it more slowly. The 7th stanza is sung in the style of Roosevelt Academy, this is where it says "pereat tristitia, pereant osores, pereat diabolus, quivis anti-burschius, atque irrisores"
DJTurnerNo1 4 years ago
Oh well, if that's the way you sing it, there's nothing I can do about it, and the same way, you'll have to live with it that we sing it the way we do, and the way we think it should be sung.
Joermungard 4 years ago
Thats it.
DJTurnerNo1 4 years ago
I know what you said, and what I meant to say is that it's not supposed to be slow, since it's a prank song sung by students saying "be happy because life is short".
Joermungard 4 years ago
OMG Too fast!!
DJTurnerNo1 4 years ago
So not true - it's a drinking song after all, it's supposed to be happy and springy!
Joermungard 4 years ago
No it`s a song which describes the shortness of our lives - it should be slow.
DJTurnerNo1 4 years ago
Does this sound slow to you? Read this:
Joermungard 4 years ago
"From Wikipedia
(Redirected from Gaudeamus Igitur)
De Brevitate Vitae (on the Shortness of Life) is a song in Latin that is a popular academic commercium song in many European countries. In many modern Western nations it is sung as an anthem at University graduation ceremonies. The melody is inspired by a medieval hymn. (!)Although this sounds very dignified, the song has been adopted by students as a form of prank and the lyrics are not very dignified.
Joermungard 4 years ago
No, read my first post, where I say that it is too fast.
DJTurnerNo1 4 years ago
LOL true
SpainSpitFire 4 years ago