Not a bad remake, but Cat Steven's original is just that -- the best! Regardless of name or religion change, his music rocks. Now Natalie, put your version back on your albums.
Who cares about the lack of a guitar solo? Did you expect anything epic from 10,000 Maniacs? Just enjoy this great performance or troll somewhere else losers.
After Cat Steven stated that he thought that Salmon Rushdie should be executed because of the "Satanic Verses", they pulled it from subsequent publishing of the album and stopped performing it live. Given that Cat Stevens (or Yusuf Islam) stated that someone should be executed for writing a piece of fiction about Mohammad, it makes sense not to perform or sell a song called "Peace Train".
With that said, Natalie has vocal cords of gold and I love the Maniacs.
@aarongman He was misquoted. He didn't advocate the fatwa. He simply answered the reporters question about what the Koran says pertaining to what Rushdie wrote.
I agree. Great cover, great song, great sound. I admit I was a little confused by "Amazing guitar solo" in the title. I watched it twice thinking I missed something. No big deal tho. It deserves to be watched twice, and more. Great job, amazing guitar solo or not.
o.k yunng'ins...natalie is striaght (that's why her relationship with Michael Stipe didn't work out) ...and if you like this song...enjoy it here because when Cat Stevens went Muslim she retracted this recording and re-released this album without the track of Peace Train.
@richjash well, cat stevens has been a muslim since the 1970's. what he did was agree with the fatwa against salman rushdie. when he did that, she took the song off of the album.
@richjash: He didn't so much as go Muslim as agree with the need for a fatwah against a writer for writing a book. I love their version of the song but I understand and can respect why the Maniacs took it off their album.
@queenstorm Yeah, she's sexy. But what is her sexual preference? I've gotten the impression she likes women about as much as I do. Does anybody out there know her status, not that it makes any difference, just interesting. She's a fantastic musical artist with a lovely voice.
Natalie M impresses me enough to make up for the "amazing guitar solo"
FlatLand43 2 months ago
@perther3 I've been able to find several on import CDs.
squeakel 4 months ago
Not a bad remake, but Cat Steven's original is just that -- the best! Regardless of name or religion change, his music rocks. Now Natalie, put your version back on your albums.
KAZrocks60s 6 months ago
great song!
AboSaud33 6 months ago
The title is obviously ironic.
dbone024 7 months ago
i love this girl
Sirocco97 8 months ago 2
Who cares about the lack of a guitar solo? Did you expect anything epic from 10,000 Maniacs? Just enjoy this great performance or troll somewhere else losers.
deepsub11 9 months ago 2
R.I.P. Buck...
ejstamey 9 months ago in playlist 10000 maniacs
AMAZING GUITAR SOLO? WHAT KIND OF CRACK WERE YOU SMOKING WHEN YOU POSTED THIS? I'M SURPRISED THE REST OF THE SONG DIDN'T SOUND AMAZING AS WELL.
HEARTHEANGELSVOICES 10 months ago
After Cat Steven stated that he thought that Salmon Rushdie should be executed because of the "Satanic Verses", they pulled it from subsequent publishing of the album and stopped performing it live. Given that Cat Stevens (or Yusuf Islam) stated that someone should be executed for writing a piece of fiction about Mohammad, it makes sense not to perform or sell a song called "Peace Train".
With that said, Natalie has vocal cords of gold and I love the Maniacs.
aarongman 10 months ago
@aarongman He was misquoted. He didn't advocate the fatwa. He simply answered the reporters question about what the Koran says pertaining to what Rushdie wrote.
torikali2 4 months ago
Every cover they've ever done has been amazing.
squeakel 11 months ago
I agree. Great cover, great song, great sound. I admit I was a little confused by "Amazing guitar solo" in the title. I watched it twice thinking I missed something. No big deal tho. It deserves to be watched twice, and more. Great job, amazing guitar solo or not.
crunchyorange 1 year ago
thank god I bought In My Tribe the day it came out so I have this on the CD
capndavey1 1 year ago
Cat's version is the best:
watch?v=7sjSHazjrWg
tubular618 1 year ago
Thanks For Sharing Can't believe they pulled from the re-release of "In My Tribe>>"
I Really enjoy their version
Juliotree 1 year ago
Rarely does a cover make the song "theirs". - 10,000 ms and Natalie Merchant very much do it here. Awesome.
fulcrum100 1 year ago
Dose anyone have the video of peace train ?
That was the first time I heard and see her video ..
TheBarefoot4life 1 year ago
I used to have the CD, that sucks that in these times she wouldn't re-release it.
squeekyp10 1 year ago
So, I guess since I have the CD with this song on it I'm one of the lucky ones.
enolbos 1 year ago
o.k yunng'ins...natalie is striaght (that's why her relationship with Michael Stipe didn't work out) ...and if you like this song...enjoy it here because when Cat Stevens went Muslim she retracted this recording and re-released this album without the track of Peace Train.
richjash 1 year ago
@richjash well, cat stevens has been a muslim since the 1970's. what he did was agree with the fatwa against salman rushdie. when he did that, she took the song off of the album.
tranurse 1 year ago
@richjash: He didn't so much as go Muslim as agree with the need for a fatwah against a writer for writing a book. I love their version of the song but I understand and can respect why the Maniacs took it off their album.
bastardlybastard 1 year ago
Amazing guitar solo my cupcake. All he did was play the melody. We've been Rick Rolled, here!
12ut5 1 year ago
@Deliticola...........somebody better tell her husband and children!!
dandydan7189 1 year ago
this is such a great cover of Cat Stevens' song.
357mes 1 year ago
does anyone have this show bootleg?
rileymayhem20 1 year ago
She is so sexy....
queenstorm 1 year ago
@queenstorm Yeah, she's sexy. But what is her sexual preference? I've gotten the impression she likes women about as much as I do. Does anybody out there know her status, not that it makes any difference, just interesting. She's a fantastic musical artist with a lovely voice.
Delticola 1 year ago
@Delticola She is married and i believe she has a 7 y/o daughter ... What does it really matter ? She is fucking amazing gay or strait ....
cubfan08 1 year ago
@cubfan08 Like I said, not that it makes any difference, just an interesting matter. Yeah, she's great.
Delticola 1 year ago
@Delticola She's married, is into men, and has a child already.
fineskylark21 1 year ago
@fineskylark21 Yeah, that's what the previous message said.
Delticola 1 year ago
I first saw the music video of this group doing this song and I loved it. The live performance here isn't as good but I loved the first one I saw.
lasktguy 1 year ago
Natalie Merchant does a great job on this tune.You go girl.
OgPsQd 1 year ago
Natalie isn't conventionally beautiful.She is very sensual though and has an amazing voice and her dance moves are very delicate and nicely executed.
iw32 1 year ago
Good lord, she was so young looking in this. :)
Volfie999 1 year ago
where was the awesome solo?
TheWordsinred 1 year ago
luv this band and her thanks for sharing
dtoolis 1 year ago
Now removed from the original Maniac's track.........she did an awesome job!
daase184 1 year ago
5000 maniacs.....?
they put alot of effort into this performance but the studio full ensemble was beautiful
upsdewd 1 year ago
The video she did back in the 80's to this song and the song when it was on the CD before she reissued it and removed the song WAS good though!
funny0000000 1 year ago
I love 10KM, but this is not a good cover.
tillerman35 2 years ago
@tillerman35 It's a great cover, it's not a good recording of this live performance. But the original recording (cover song) on that album was great.
Delticola 1 year ago
ok so you slaughtered a classic whoop diz im only seventeen and i see that
sambamthemonkeyman 2 years ago
nothing amazing and Not "solo".
zombiegirl2113 2 years ago