U2-Live-With or Without the best version

[GilmaraAraujo88]

Maravilhoso,toca profundamente.

[marisavinagre]

beautiful

[JohnyMaxen]

it is the best version

[wilow001]

BIEN..........

[muchasbuenaschicas]

Moi,j'aurais pas perdu le nord,je lui aurais fait les poches?directe......

Bon comme je suis pas une meuf,je pense pas qu'il m'aurait invité.......

Sinon il se demerde pas mal Bono!

[comanderf1]

unglaublich unfassbar einfach Geil BEST BAND IN THE WORLD

[My19Game]

Oh.. my.. God.. this Song is great

[lilabenalema]

LO AMO

[halodlink002]

every time i hear this it reminds me of that one girl .STM~

[cmbdragon666]

YAYYY!!! GRAB RaNDOM CHICK TIME!!!! :D

I'LL JUST RANDOMLY FIND JENNIFER LOPEZ NOW AND JUST START DANCING!!! -:D

[xpert9001]

why did you take the song and make it black and white. it was shot in color

[abrujitoz]

Reverencia ante bono ,, q, maestria por dios ,, algun dia kiero ser como el..

[foreverantige]

Einfach ohne Worte,auch als Mann..Entenpelle pur!!!!!!

[mshaleyjaneburke]

Forever fan3

[re20nka]

U2-wspaniala muza, ponadczasaowa, to jest i bedzie klasyk superrr

[sundance10016]

She looks just like Allie

[deejayteecee]

alles live

[Xebtria]

I wonder if that girl knows that she is on youtube. :)

[TheUnknownVisiterX]

Best ! Ever !

[sisterhoodsweetgirls]

where would bono be without the edge

[1275Joel]

Bit seedy when he gets the girl on stage... Amazing song though.

[MikeNRW33]

write in german ya spackkkkkkkkk

[joyleng]

Oh so beautiful...

[NilDawagne]

Oh.. My.. Gosh... This video doesn't need comments.. Speaking by itself..

[nala380]

Hab ich heute auch gehört!



[christophershaw79]

these guys know how to work a song

[TheBlushingPumpkin]

The best version I had ever seen. I was crying a bit along when Bono's voice also got chocked a bit in cries... sweetest moment ever

[Tulcas002]

the girl will never forgett this concert :)

so great

[orfeas24]

@Tulcas002 i think she is his wife or something like that...family ;)

[collinzizou]

@Tulcas002 I think nobody would forget a U2 Concert :)

[Izzycuddles09]

@Tulcas002 yeah 

[TonyoTool]

Yeah it was. This is the first time i'v seen this vid. I have goosebumps... I miss you, Taylor. 

[arcenciel3]

rHeS oS hCiD eSsImReV ....u HcId EbEiL hCi ...S

[Alyson26997]

It's great.<3

[JeremiahDaryl89]

This performance is amazing.

[JeremiahDaryl89]

Was he crying a little bit? If he was, that's awesome. It's that much more powerful.

[FantazmagoricalOne]

He still reminds me of Robin Williams...

[NoNameMcStickles]

@FantazmagoricalOne No, Robin Williams reminds you of Bono.

[Aristosek]

finally working version (out US & Canada). F**K VEVO !!

[mikedpker45]

This is the best live version I have seen !

[NicolasCharly]

I left 9 months for New York, she broke up with me after 2 years because of that...

But I won't be able to let her go, never ...

I'm still waiting for you ...

[lebainiste13]

il y a défois , ou avec peut de choses , pas de soleil , dans des endroits tristes et mauches , de bref instant si bon si fort si passioné , font oubliers tout se qui n ai pas bon , un petit moment avec une beautiful mermaid smeel good nous transporte loin de tout , loin de tout , merci pour c est quelque seconde ou j avais disparut j etait seul avec toi ,,,,i love you ,,,8-13 heart....

[Kwales66]

That girl must have.......

[bAVkito]

IF YOU HEAR THIS-----I AM ALREADY LYING ON THE FLOOR-----WAITING

[alicordoba]

Damn beautiful song but too weird video for me lol

[sarakop85]

ky version me pelqen shume..e kam degju 10 here sot..per fajin tat..gjithmone me ka pelqy kjo kenge, tani me pelqen edhe me shume

[SalsaFreakElla]

lucky girl...

[hessekoppeiguudewie]

Forever great !

[itsmedealwithitnz]

STUPID WHATS THIS CHICK DOING ON STAGE THIS GUY NEEDS DEPRESSION PILLS

[CalebTheGuitarist]

is that some random chick?????

[GutarHero1993]

The best live performance ever...and it's rly gayish to cry 'cause of the song. -.- U can cry because it have woke up ur memories, but not because the song is nice...^^ I had a wish to cry, but only because this song reminds me of my girl...<3

[marian81br]

absolutely incredible live performance !!! u2 the best !!!

[coug524]

Tres bien !!!!

[reddjonn68]

To these idots talkin bout cryin I have cried when needed to, if you hold anything in to long you will die of stress idiots !!! When my grandpa died, when my son graduated, when I lost my best friend, I cried hard, had to let it out or it would have killed me inside. What the hell does sexual preference have to do with emotions you f***ing idiots, get a life, oh I'm sorry you don't have one !!!!!

[edu2004eu]

those 4 persons who clicked dislike are retarded faggots x(

[StalkerJamforx]

Why is this song so low rated compared to their other songs? It was my favorite song growing up and at one time was the number one radio song of all time. Can't figure it out...

[WarmPBR1]

Yay U2!  Fuck VEVO!

[banndell]

real man do cry

[hopehope4]

...I CANT LIVE WITH OR WITHOUT YOU.......

[MsDampfLok]

oh geil... O.o

das ist mal echt genial!!!

[luvincapecod]

That girl was NUTS. On stage...WITH BONO....to the song With or Without You and she was like a dead FISH. Obviously star struck and unable to connect. Tsk tsk. Wish it hadda been me.

[TheWtfkitty]

@luvincapecod

you'd have ruined the moment for the rest of the fans. She did just fine.

[T97Frida]

@luvincapecod I don´t think she was like a dead fish, not at all. She simply enjoyed that GREAT moment. She was totally one with Bono. And I would do the same instead of thinking about giving any silly performance that would only ruine it. I´ve once been in a concert where Bono took a girl on the stage, she acted like she wanted to fuck him and he kept on defending himself, it was so embarrassing.

[keomenos1]

ΜΟΥ ΑΡΕΣΕΙ ΤΡΕΛΑ! ΑΣ ΔΙΑΒΑΣΟΥΜΕ ΤΟΥΣ ΣΤΙΧΟΥΣ See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side. I wait for you. Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails she makes me wait And I wait without you With or without you Through the storm, we reach the shore You gave it all but I want more And I'm waiting for you With or without you. I can't live with or without you. And you give yourself away And you give, and you give And you give yourself away.

[tracymayson]

WOW, XXXXXXX

[danieljohnfleet]

GOOD FOR YOU NARREN.THIS IS CRY BABIE SHIT.I LOVE YOU GUYS.ALL OF US.EXCEPT THE PEOPLE I HATE.

[marcoslrivera]

One word- breathtaking

[DimitriPeruzziOnline]

without words in front of so much beauty

[valda208]

t hat was breathtaking

[BloggerMusicMan]

Hearing this as a finale with 58 000 people attending in a big stadium like the Rogers Centre in Toronto is awesome.

[PATAN325]

There are places in life... were you can go back to... when you have been walking so far and all you get is a no way out alley... U2, "With or without you" is one of them...

[PATAN325]

There are places in life... were you can go back to... when you have been walking so far and all you get is a no way out alley... U2, "With or without you" is one of them...

[Nelarios]

Oh god, I'm not even a fan of U2( But i love this song among others of them..) but I got goosebumps all over right now.. hold me!:O

[mariafeliz88]

this song is a classic... never fades.. and never will.. :)

[slinkykel]

wow amazing video! wish I was that agirl and so does every other female! ha GRAND VIDEO!!! LOVE U2 ohhhhh and this SONG!yeah i think of this song when I am with a guy.. with or without HIM .. def works both ways and wow for Bono to show that emotion.. kiss a girl.. need that real touch factor I mean we all are human, even U2 just like U and Moi! I am shivering! heheheh tear in me EYE

[matteooofull]

stupendaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[chechomode]

esa mujer tuvo que tener por lo menos 10 orgasmos en 5 minutos

[FinalContester]

Gänsehaut!

[MrValerio1986]

I LOVE THAT SONG!

[RVplatinum]

I like how U2's songs have a lot of depth to them, unlike other artists. They sing the songs that medicate the soul :)

[timtipton5071256]

@RVplatinum I think that's very well said..they know how to build a wall of music & lyrics that give the soul something firm to lean against...thanks RVplatinum....

[slinkykel]

@RVplatinum Touche'... they sing songs that medicate the soul well said!

[Goldenandy1]

U2 Only, always now and forever!!!!!

[freeman6264]

U2... the best band ever

[Jp4955]

yeah the best IRISH band 2

[affenkopf005]

geillllll

[oggy804]

i posli pusti godin, jos me ovo trese..

znan da niko ovo ne razumi, al' *ebe me se.. :)

[helio123]

bono is a clown

[giankithesoul]

what the fuck are you saying?

[erkenso]

Unbeliveble ... its a number two in my best of ... first is "Yesterday" ... but ... after then times listening it was maibe number one

[paddypaddy]

sit back, relax, enjoy life!

[matrix4022]

The song gives me hope that humanity really is special. It's amazing how music can do that.

[marcusalbertthomas]

Nice video quality. U2 are masters.

[MerloMorghi]

Guarda la pietra nei tuoi occhi Guarda la spina nel tuo fianco Io ti aspetto ....

[BADCOMPANYTILLIDIE]

take me with you on your spaceship BONO!!!!!!!

[penpakpakkumlao]

yeah! all I can do just waiting and waiting even I know that he's never gonna change his mind to love me anymore anymore but deep inside I do still hope that we can get back together again if I could just pray for something just to get you back I'll do it or what can i do to get you back I'll do it

[prowresler]

thats deep man

[penpakpakkumlao]

but how I can do that when don't even love me any more and he told me his felling has been change, he doesn't love me the same way like I love him, that what he told me, but what can I do when I still in love with you, honey.

[penpakpakkumlao]

I don't know how I gonna live with out him and I can't even go back and see him anymore, I meant forever and I know he' s not gonna come and see me. I with I could go back there and see him even one more time, please just one more time, I would never be sorry and I would never want anything.

[mellowjper]

It's pure love he radiates... ! Beautiful ~

[stilly2009]

fantastic.. one of my favourite u2 songs.. lucky girl she looks like she enjoyed that.. By the way my version is in the video response above.. check it out!!!

[puputube]

I wan to be that girl too!!! U2 rocks!

[siobrit]

that was such a beautiful performance- bono makes me proud to be irish right now!

[danieru1979]

she looks a little bit asian... hey ... i bet that she didn't sleep that night... ^^

[fantassys]

Sencillamente ESPECTACULAR transmites tanto Bono eres lo máximo te admiro y además esta canción significa muchísimo para mi....... TE AMO!!

[carlbenninghausen]

god that girl was lucky :D great song ;)

[davidaliaga1982]

se la queria tirar no?

[honzek68]

beautiful !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Mintycinty]

That was amazing..

[KaitEeLouise]

Luckky bitch im onlyy 12 n i was 4 standing i mancester airport singng this song with my earfones in.

my hero and a true legend. Always will be and always has been.

[pumasporvida]

Bono has a majestic and magical way of connecting with his audience..which no other singer has...live on U2!!

[Dosya1234]

I cried like a little girl! It was beautiful, it was excitingly,It was gentle, it was as in a life. And I would give all to be on a place of that girl

[HoneyH1]

I just caught the last 20 seconds of this song on TV so I wanted to hear it again all the way through.

Now that I have, I have 2 words to say...

LUCKY BITCH ! !

That woman Bono was lying with! Experience of a lifetime! He's a legend! Haha, ah well... Song rocks!! :D

[DerWiese2305]

gänsepelle

[viktoriabobby]

This was ace from B.

really really really good song!!

[fifty51one]

Od Chorzowskiego koncertu jest to "nasza piosenka" Od kiedy moja panna wyjechała, słysząc ten kawałek aż ściska za serducho! KOCHAM CIE!

[narrengold]

Holy crap! I'm a man, but I'm cryin like a litte girl...

[Jdmeier13]

Arn't we all!!

[1click2fast4u]

@narrengold you are not alone ... :(

[broodjewout]

@narrengold That means your not only a man. But a Good Man. I'm Also crying

[narrengold]

@broodjewout So, welcome in our club...brother. Some women can't handle with men showing their feelings, but the few who does, are also really women.

[BE4TNGU]

@narrengold

I have nothing against gay people but crying is pretty fag-style...

[narrengold]

@BE4TNGU The question is not "Are you against gay people or not?", the question ist "Are you an iceblock?" my friend. The whole performance is so touching. I think if a man weeps while seeing this honors him, because he shows he's a man. Not a callously macho, listening to any "pogo in togo"-music.

[BE4TNGU]

@narrengold

If your not crying your not immediatly a macho. Im not a macho but I dont even cry when family-members die. But crying when you watch a clip like this is girly.

[Cha0sPr0ductions]

@BE4TNGU Ok you dont cry when your family members die. sir you are heartless. this clip is quite touching but i did not cry but not crying when family dies is just heartless. those people are the only people who wont be jerks to you, your last hope and when those people who have been there with you for ages... are gone. the times you spent with them,when you were picked up from a low by a family member, your upbringing. that dosent matter to you? thats not macho that is heartless

[BE4TNGU]

@Cha0sPr0ductions

Im not macho. Some people cry a lot, others never cry. Its just your personality.

But a guy that cries watching a movie or a videoclip is kinda gay. Not real gay but faggy.

[Luff55g]

@BE4TNGU Real men cry.

[BE4TNGU]

@Luff55g

Real man cry? It must have been a gay who came up with that line.

[Cha0sPr0ductions]

@BE4TNGU and it must of been a soulless basterd who clearly has the social skills of a rock to say that crying at all is gay. then ask me this tough guy if i take all you ever cared about away (house, family, car etc) would you cry or would you be mindlessy optimistic about it all and say "well no one to piss me off anymore"

I think the guy who hides it all behinde a shield of optimism is the guy trying to hide the fact he is gay because he can't face the truth

[BE4TNGU]

@Cha0sPr0ductions

If you take away everything from me im gonna take everything away from you.

I cant cry. Maybe its a disease but im not heartless. You are girly.

[kanodourden]

@narrengold

du bist auch 'n Lutscher

[scottydesthegooner]

@narrengold I'm with you dude. I'm a man and I dont cry easily, but I'm not afraid to admit I'm in floods of tears here. Something about this version and the video that hits something inside, weird. Epic tune!

[narrengold]

@scottydesthegooner You are one of many men around the world. Welcome brother.

[ConorGuitar94]

tune

[st8304166]

I want to sing like this with Vea

[MikkelThaUberHomie]

I wish i could share this song with a girl. everytime i here this song, i think about it.

[MikkelThaUberHomie]

hear*

[SalsaFreakElla]

@MikkelThaUberHomie very romantic:) ur girlfriend/wife is a very lucky woman

[chronicleone]

@MikkelThaUberHomie makes me think more about the stuff I need, my boots, my car, and my knife. You won't ever see me getting hung up on a girl like I need them. Your not a real man if you can't stand on your own without a lady- or whatever your into it's cool.

[narrengold]

I bet many girls wish they could be"her" ;-)...Anyway. Great song and performed with so much passion. Always and always worth 5*

[orangepeelify]

She is one lucky girl :)

How happy she must've been !

Love this song

[condorrichthofen]

one of the best music videos and songs

[J1211C]

I think this was in Boston, MA USA....2001 This is a great live version....I recently saw video of WOWy where Bono himself gets really emotional towards the middle to end...Video at Notre Dame in October of 2001...check it out.

[J1211C]

I believe it was in Boston, MA USA....2001

[vishmastaa]

love U2,love Bono...Could this guy be god?

[Vampireprincess1100]

u2-live - with or without you by nashex24 is exactly the same concert in colour

[hjsxxx]

where was this live at?

[Seliumx3]

why cant you look in the description?

[joijoej]

love U2 .

[megjane4]

wow this is the BEST version ive seen eva!! I love this song so emotional.

[svebee11]

one of the best music videos and songs... =) very emotional...

[csampi]

my god.....

[ThatsSoYesterday]

its the best <3

[mmm272727]

with or without you (rattle and hum) is the best live version hands down.

[ericcartmanrulez]

This girl has the best day of her life here. (I would if I was a girl)!

[vixanlyyours]

i have to disagree TW, i have watched many versions of this song, and this version is the most heartfelt of any. it is music as art, music with feeling, music how it should be performed. the boston version of this song is one that i can watch and listen to over and over and never grow sick of.

[lalidevil]

you give it all but i want more..

[TWern9]

I'm not dissing this version in any way... but this is not the best version, in fact there are many other performances on here in my opinion that beat this version.

[avielp]

I wonder does is his wife jaleous when he sings it to a girl :P

[Foxxyboy61]

Its not his wife. Its a fan. He has done that at a few shows. Its a love song and singing it to a girl is appropriate. Simple. U2 are the best band in the world by a mile x

[rohm274]

Lucky girl... -JEALOUSY-

[TheSKeB]

Is that really his wife? Or who is that female?

[Junije1]

If that's his wife I'm his son...

[TheSKeB]

Was that your mom?

Or are you saying that it is not his wife.

Haha I thought that was funny.

But yeah, that was a stupid question... I didn't see the beginning where she came from the audience.