i agree with tubamarc, great job with the arrangement. unlike all the million other videos of this song being done by bands, this is closer to the originally written, meaning the chords are fantastic :D
WHY is there a dominant 7 at 1:38?? That practically destroys the meaning of Whitacre's music. If it's a mistake, okay, but if not, I think I may have to kill an arranger.
i was the arranger, and after reading this, i went back to check the score because you are right, IF it is a dom7 chord, that would be just plain wrong. but in fact it is an E-flat major chord with no 7. you scared me for a second because i was afraid i screwed it up. but i must be an overtone you are hearing because everyone has an E-flat, G-natural or B-flat.
thanks for the feedback
Jc
ps. this is just cuts from the performance, the whole performance was approx. 4 min
@jazzbassoonist I think he/she was talking about the A-flat chord right before the E-flat. And I listened closely and indeed heard a dominant 7th (G-flat) within that chord). So that one chord did catch me off guard...
Yep, that chord is a mistake, it sounds like it was meant to be played, but unfortunately it takes away from the original music. Totally agree with you
it's better played with a complete band. gives the best dynamic ranges. played this at a concert, very hard pice for it's very open...or, if you mess up, it's easy to hear
This has to be the best instrumental recording I've heard so far of this piece. I liked it very much! The players did the piece a lot of justice - the conductor must know what he's doing as well.
lol i really wanna perform this peice now but maybe a tuba solo instead ????? that would be really cool
DagamonEx 2 months ago
i agree with tubamarc, great job with the arrangement. unlike all the million other videos of this song being done by bands, this is closer to the originally written, meaning the chords are fantastic :D
jayce2728 1 year ago
Comment removed
tubamarc8891 1 year ago
were can I find the scoring for this arrangement?
RPToomey 2 years ago
WHY is there a dominant 7 at 1:38?? That practically destroys the meaning of Whitacre's music. If it's a mistake, okay, but if not, I think I may have to kill an arranger.
I love this sound though.
Bbobe900000 2 years ago 5
That's not supposed to be there!
ughxugh 2 years ago
I think you're hearing a hint of an overtone. I have the audio recording from this concert and it's just a major chord.
khammondbrass 2 years ago
It does sound weird. I think this is a slightly rewritten version of this song because the version I have doesn't end like that
drawingshadows 2 years ago
i was the arranger, and after reading this, i went back to check the score because you are right, IF it is a dom7 chord, that would be just plain wrong. but in fact it is an E-flat major chord with no 7. you scared me for a second because i was afraid i screwed it up. but i must be an overtone you are hearing because everyone has an E-flat, G-natural or B-flat.
thanks for the feedback
Jc
ps. this is just cuts from the performance, the whole performance was approx. 4 min
jazzbassoonist 2 years ago
@jazzbassoonist Great job with the arrangement!
tubamarc8891 1 year ago
@jazzbassoonist I think he/she was talking about the A-flat chord right before the E-flat. And I listened closely and indeed heard a dominant 7th (G-flat) within that chord). So that one chord did catch me off guard...
CharlieBladeRemus 7 months ago
Yep, that chord is a mistake, it sounds like it was meant to be played, but unfortunately it takes away from the original music. Totally agree with you
derbydrummer 2 years ago
ew... it sounds terrible
FeLiX13sLaVe 1 year ago
@Bbobe900000 That minor 7th destroys the effect. I shudder when I hear it. This is why IV7 > V7.
itsmrGuy 1 year ago
in my opinion, all a good band needs is french horn, euphonium and tuba. Those 3 make anything perfect =)
05Forenza 2 years ago
eh. they make anything mellow. i mean they have a nice sound but you need some timbre in there from trumpets or trombones.
Godbey 2 years ago
i am not gonna say that this is not great. but there is a key part missing or i am not hearing it correctly.
jerkwas 2 years ago
The videos are just snippets of the concert. Can't give it all away for free - just a taste.
khammondbrass 2 years ago
it's better played with a complete band. gives the best dynamic ranges. played this at a concert, very hard pice for it's very open...or, if you mess up, it's easy to hear
Jasra18088 2 years ago
FRENCH HORNS!!! My instrument!!!
chucktownboi843 2 years ago
I heard a drum and bugle corps play this. I was the most amazing brass sound i have ever heard
valpofan 2 years ago
As far as I know only one corps has performed it. If it's the same one it was an amazing sound, but i guess that is a biased opinion. :D
Aaron5ash 2 years ago
Gah! Who was the DCI group that did this? I almost want to say it was JSU...or was it a Div. II band that did this? I can't remember.
isudude0913 2 years ago
Glassmen played this in 2008
bunyancutincrew 2 years ago
Really?! I did not know that! I must look that up.
Aaron5ash 2 years ago
glassmen is doing it again this year for 2009 and it sounds even better.
jerkwas 2 years ago
actually, it's just one of the Glassmen's warmup and encore pieces, of which they perform beautifully.
MusicandInsanity 2 years ago
Who was it? I heard that Spirit may have done it a few years ago.
isudude0913 2 years ago
dayam thats amazing the trumpet vibrato at 23 sent chills. down my spine
ryantoomster 2 years ago
im crying now.
Hunta344 2 years ago
I felt like i had an orgasm with the chord at 0:30
seyneux 3 years ago
I'm more of a 0:35 person myself. Or 1:08, for that matter.
sobeita 2 years ago
WOOO GO HORNS!
ConnorM120992 3 years ago 3
Damn!wow
French horns
frenchhornqueen 3 years ago 2
This is absolutely beautiful!!! Wonderful tone! Great arrangement! Would love to hear a live performance!
Aaron5ash 3 years ago
is there any way that i could get the full recording of this? its by far the best recording i have heard to date.
drayce523 3 years ago
so good so good
midgetsy 3 years ago
phenomenal sound
slapdashbr 3 years ago
great conductor, but the whole piece would be nice.
bluedotantics20165 3 years ago 2
It sounds like there are 10 tubas up there.
alexyaden13 3 years ago 2
Whole piece, please.
BizCasFri 3 years ago 9
Lovely.
PeaceFrog1234 3 years ago 2
This has to be the best instrumental recording I've heard so far of this piece. I liked it very much! The players did the piece a lot of justice - the conductor must know what he's doing as well.
JPSaxMan 4 years ago 6
Interesting Arrangement. I've never heard it in this key before. Very beautiful though
Jeef27 4 years ago 2