Added: 5 years ago
From: MrsCake
Views: 304,533
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (823)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Doctor sure does like to hold her hand. <3

  • Rose was not the only one clinging in this relationship. The Doctor held onto her almost desperately. She centered him by just holding his hand while at the same time holding her own ground. Loved her.

  • rose returned in the end so thats good

    she comes back with matt smith aswell

    so does captain jack and mickedy mick mickey as jack calls him cheescake

    

  • is rose aver going to come back?

  • That song was made for that brilliant companion. Great tribute.

  • Omg. Excuse me while I cry myself to sleep.

  • This was so adorably FANTASTIC! ;) Great work!

  • Your username is MrsCake, and you don't have any pony-related material on your channel? Disagreed.

  • :))

  • rose got a shitty deal with the human doctor

  • This has been in my top favourite videos for 4 years now.

  • how did I not see this in the last 5 years?!?

    I swear I'm blind

  • So I looked on Geoff Smith's website and it said that it was written about Doctor Who. Which really makes a ton more sense. :) I love this song so much. It's on repeat on my itunes.

  • Wait this song isn't a trock song? WHAT? This fits perfectly!

  • I always get an empty, sinking feeling when I remember the end of Rose-Doctor. All three times..... TT_TT I loved them together so much, and it's so sad to think of it as over and done with. they were really fantastic....and it was so hard to say good-bye to both of these amazing characters. Long live Rose and the Tenth !! (was this song *created* for this show....? O: )

  • "Remember how it all began? All you had to do was take my hand, and we've been running ever since" OK that does it, this can't just be coincidence. I refuse to believe that.

  • @imissrose123 it's not. he wrote it based on the series as a tribute to Doomsday

  • HOW was this song NOT written for them?! SERIOUSLY!

  • We never did get that "I love you too" :(

  • Awesome song and editing! Great job! 

  • this video is amazing.i watched it 100 times and i still like it...

  • 39 people accidently missed the like button.... You video is awesome!

  • this had 2 be made for Rose Tyler

  • @DoctorWhoStar100

    It was. :)

  • Awesome song and awesome video! Best companion with besttwo doctors... It's so sad they're not in the series. It still has to move on, though. :/

  • am i the only one who finds it interesting that the artisit's last name is smith? XD

  • i love this vid.it reminds me why rose was and always will be my fav companion ever.

    amiazing vid

  • aa, man. that's epic, i love it. tears. amazing.

  • FANTASTIC!

  • it is fantastic!love rose,love doctor,love them togeather,BRILIANT!

  • At the beginning I hated Rose soooo much. I thought she's just annoying. But when she sliped into Piet's World I had to cry sooo had. Rose was an amazing companion.

  • @gelingelingx

    you spelt pete wrong soz I couldn't help noticing

  • @gelingelingx She used to annoy me too at first. But during the first season I slowly started liking her better. By the Time of Bad Wolf/Parting of Ways, I thought she was awesome. And I loved the flirting between them in the second season.

  • This is such a fantstic song. its just amazing.

  • This is a trock (time lord rock) song. That means it WAS made for Rose Tyler.

  • this the same guy that did I'm a TWiT?

  • Aw, I'm a sucker for these kinds of videos. I love Rose. :)

  • <3 the video.. this song is unreal, btw!! It's as if it were made for Rose Tyler XD

  • @JanuaryWonder It WAS made for Rose Tyler

  • donna noble: whos clothes are these?

    doctor: errrrr ill teel u later. WHEN THEY SAY GOODBYE

    donna noble:whos clothes WERE they?

    doctor: my old companion...Rose.

    'gives a sad smile'

  • This made me want to cry. I'm not even a huge Rose Tyler fan, but this made me remember why I do actually love her sometimes. :)

  • omg...this song is for real? I was reading fanfiction when it mentioned this song and the lyrics, but I thought they were kidding! Wow!

  • i love doctor who so much i now refer to my life as before i discovered doctor who and after. Thumbs up if u agree!!!!!!!! :)

  • Rose was my favorite Who companion. :(

    Nice video!

  • @sarahnpeck mine too!

  • @sarahnpeck yes, the doctor says to donna noble, my companion was........... Rose. with a sad smile. :)

  • serioulsy, was this music made with doctor who in mind, or is it just coincidentally amazingly acurate and fits terrificly?

  • One more thing, was the music made for the show?

  • I'm not a person who usually cries in these things but when the 9 doctor regenerates and the 10 I spent a night crying I FUCKING LOVED THE NINTH DOCTOR! David Tennant may be prettier but the other one was such a great actor and with a better personality... ;(

  • @TheDianaJC OMG, couldn't agree more. I thought I was the only one thinking 9th was better. I actually also love DT and 10th doctor and I know eventually he has to change but it was too early to say goodbye to nine. :(

  • @havuch

    yeah chris was great so was david and matt's pretty good but chris and david were the best Doctor's. All i can say is matt's gotta load to live up to:-p

  • Love song, love ten, love rose. After weeks of watching 11, I watched this and was actually shocked at how FIT 10 was!!! Mmm those eyes, that hair! Thanks for posting!

  • did someone right this song of doctor who or something and i love the vid

  • This was amazing! I miss the Doctor and Rose so much! Rose is my favorite companion! I went on Geoff Smiths website and it said that he based this song after THIS Rose! Which I think is Brilliant! AMAZING!

  • Rose was Brilliant, Nice Video

  • I love it!

  • I miss her ;;

  • vote this up if you think rose tyler is the best comanion/character docter who ever had!!!!!!!!!

  • Thank you so much for this video. It is absolutely fantastic. :D

  • Seriously, was this song WRITTEN for them???? WOW!!!!!!

  • @MossearofWindClan Yes, actually it was.

    Just saying. ;)

  • @MossearofWindClan Check out a band called chameleon circuit. They specialise in a type of music called trock, or time lord rock. They are brilliant

  • a lovely, lovely video thanks, yes you can see they both loved each other!!

  • david tennant is the best better than the cardboard sets online at justdoctorwho-dot-com

  • It will have to be someone very very special to have the impact that Rose had.

  • This is fantastic video!

  • Im only on season 3 and theese comments are wow messages thinks.lol.

    Did they make this song based on the show?

  • @thatseelyah

    Yes it was specifically written for Rose and the Doctor.

  • whitch episode is at 2:12?????

  • @drfannn the pre-credit sequence from 'Army of Ghosts', S02E12 :)

  • Rose is the best yet. Sexy but nice. Bring her back.

  • I always feel like crying whenever I watch this video. sigh. At least there was somewhat of closure at the end of season 4.

  • @jllouie I agree. Rose is still my favorite. Then Donna and Amy. 

  • This needs to be updated, y/y ;D

  • I LOVE THIS VIDEO

  • Well Rose will be in The End of Time......

    *screams

    can't wait 2 see how they finish of the relationship between her and the doctor

  • hopefully it wont be how the papers have said and rose is pregnant with the human doctors child

  • It's out, look it up.

  • Ohhhh, I love how they handled that and stayed in canon

    It was SUCH a sweet scene

  • is o lvoe thsi video so cute and sweet

  • i love rose!!!

  • I love this song. Favorited.

  • Yay, great remedy for depressyness of waters of mars ending.

  • amazing! just amazing!!! all the time i hear that song in my head~! l-o-v-e it!

  • This video's beautiful. Possibly the only tv youtube clip to ever make me cry.

  • Nice vid! I'm surprised I hadn't run across this song before now! It was quite the shock realizing a little way into it that this was actually written about the character. You put this together well -- great pacing and the clips you chose fit really nicely with the song. I really enjoyed it!

  • Was this actually written about this particular Rose? Because the entire time, I was sitting here thinking "How is this song SO perfect?!"

    I really did adore this video! It was uplifting and cheery, although it didn't let you forget that angle of sadness. This is probably the truest representation of the Doctor and Rose that I've ever seen.

  • YesGeoff Smith confirms this in a post on his website. Google Geoff Smith and go to the official website. Use the search tool in the top right hand corner to search the term Rose and you'll find the post. I wonder if he knew what he was getting into when he wrote it? Doctor Who fans around the globe constantly asking, "Did you REALLY write this for Rose?" Considering I bought the song immediately upon hearing it...(and I'm probably not the only one) I'd guess that he doesn't mind too terribly.

  • I love this song just because of the line

    "Tell your mum I said hello,

    Tell her sorry that I ever let you go."

  • This song gives me a nice warm feeling lol, i love it ^_^ I <3 rose, she's so great! She's so....FANTASTIC! ^_^

  • the greatest doctor and the greatest companion this show has had

  • This video is AMAZING!! It always makes me want to laugh and cry at the same time, and then go watch those seasons again. It's never the same without Rose, but it was her time.

  • I needed this. I play Rose in rp and she has been getting SO rejected by the Doctor. xD

    I love this SO SO MUCH.

  • rp? Whats that!!?

  • the first video I ever faved and still my favorite. It's totally brilliant and makes me cry every time. Thank you for sharing.

  • Man. Rose always looks so different in every episode

  • I found this vid like 3 years ago, and It's still amazing!!!

  • @ItsTheHappyness

    I think I found it 4 years ago, and I still like it too :)

  • @Larixlaricina for me it's 4 years ago now too xD

  • @ItsTheHappyness

    Fantastic, you mean, :D

  • Spoiler alert

    i hate this part in the episode were rose "dies" and she sees the doctor again and right when he was going to say rose tyler i love you he got cut off i hated that

  • It's soooo sweeeeet!!

  • fantasyic was one of the doctors fav. words..lol

  • beautiful....

  • This MUST have been written for Rose. Does anyone know for sure if it was? So perfect...

    And great vid! So well put together, it's adorable. I love it.

  • Yeah, the artist--Geoff Smith--wrote it specially for character of Rose. He has this vid on his website, I think =]

  • Yes, this song was written specifically about Rose.

  • I love it! I love it! I love it! The music is probably the most perfect piece of music for the Doctor and Rose. I should be on one of the sound tracks.

  • OMG. this is so adorable its untrue XD. thats so amazing how it fits with our doctor who rose exactly :D

  • Does anybody feel that this video was written specifically for Rose?

  • It really was

  • It was.

  • It was.

    I love this video, it fits so well!

  • Annoying? UGLY?! How freaking dare you?!

  • This song is perfect.... love it!!!

  • Is this song actually made for doctor who (roses character) or is it just an independent song?

  • I'm sure the song was wrote for the character.

    I love this video, it matches the clips so well :D

  • I read somewhere that it was written for Doctor Who. It certainly sounds like it anyway. I mean the 'fantastic' thing is just too perfect to be a coincidence.

  • Oh wow.  So beautiful. I love Doctor Who but most of all I love Rose. A wonderful job, thanks for posting it.

  • She's one of the kickass compainons the Doctor's had; what are you talking about?

  • But... for me, at least... that's part of her charm!

  • Wait...you don't like Jim Carey? And I've certainly never noticed any lisp, so i don't know what you're talking about!

  • That's because she is meant to be just an average person, she lives in some bommy flats and has a certain type of Londoner accent. It's actually not how Billie Piper talks, she's put on a voice for Rose Tyler which means it's meant to be like that. I really like this video, and Rose.

  • so cute

  • wuts the episode at 2:01?

  • the christmas invasion , david tennants first full episode

  • that song is so perfect for them!

  • This one of my favourite videos about the doctor. Ideal video. In what program you have created it???

    This magnificent, magnificent, and magnificent video. The song ideally approaches to video.

    This fine video. Many thanks to you for creation of this magnificent video

  • Beautiful.

  • still my favourte

  • This one of my favourite videos about the doctor. Ideal video. In what program you have created it???

    This magnificent, magnificent, and magnificent video. The song ideally approaches to video.

    This fine video. Many thanks to you for creation of this magnificent video

  • This one of my favourite videos about the doctor. Ideal video. In what program you have created it???

    This magnificent, magnificent, and magnificent video. The song ideally approaches to video.

    This fine video. Many thanks to you for creation of this magnificent video

  • I'm gonna go cry in the corner now...

  • Aww Thismade me Cry I LOVE ROSE BRING HER BACK :(

  • FUCK I HATE THE NEW GIRL COMMING TO SEASON 5 i saw one episode with her she is shit > :(

  • Adoro ver esta serie e quase chorei no ultimo episódio.

  • Nostalgia's End

    12 - 25 - 09

    It's nostalgia-fest time and, even though the final episode of season 4 brought everyone back for what seemed to be the absolute last time, the final 10th Doctor episode is likely to do that again. Confirmed sightings of the Master, Wilf, Donna, Sylvia with confirmed attendances of Rose, Jack, Mickey, et al. Yes, the erstaz Doctor is supposed to be there too, along with Rose's baby!

  • The say what now?! Rose had a baby?!

  • hey I just repeated what I saw on the website, LOL

  • *cough* jackass *cough*

    Did I say that out loud?

  • apparently you did say that out loud jeff - to each their own. I liked Rose - and I don't think DW needs to 'get darker' like Moffet is supposedly taking the show. I've been watching for over 20 years and I feel it does best as an action/adventure type thing without all the angst. Sorry you disagree....

  • Actually, if you watch the episodes Moffat has done, they're not as dark as people seem to think. Scarier, maybe, but they tend to end on incredible highs.

    TEC/TDD: "Everybody lives, Rose! Everybody lives!"

    Girl in the Fireplace: Okay, I'll give you that one, but it wasn't dark...just sad.

    Blink: Scary, but really dark, and ended with Sally and Larry finally meeting the Doctor and apparently falling in love with each other.

    SITL/FOTD: Ends with everyone who died living in a sort of heaven.

  • Love it!

  • Missing you rose! Lovely video, great song!

  • How the bloody hell have I not commented on this?

    This is...beyond words. I cannot describe to you how brilliant this is. I cry every time.

  • we will miss you Rose!!!! greetings from México!!!! Fantastic Rose!!!!

  • I've just heard on 23rd March 2009 that Billie Piper is coming back as Rose in Doctor Who. It's alright twice with companions but after that I think once you've seen them twice in a new series then that's enough. I do like Billie Piper as Rose she is my favourite companion out of the 21st Century 2005 and 2006 series. Also got told that Donna is coming back too. We've seen enough of them companions really.

  • Where did you here that?

  • No, actually it's true. People have watched the filming. It's apparently New Years, 2005, months before she meets the Doctor. I assume she doesn't remember because the Doctor doesn't introduce himself, so she just assumes he's a random guy on the street and forgets about him.

    He also seems to be dying at this point, because there's a pic of him leaning against a wall, looking like he's in a lot of pain. The sad irony is it's the wall right next to where he landed in The Christmas Invasion.

  • Rose와 Doctor가 잘되길 바랬었는데.....

    season2,4 에서 i cried.

  • is this song really written for this specific character?

  • Yep!

  • you never know...check the date it was written/published. =]

    also....CHECK OUT MY CHANNEL FOR THE BEST DOCTOR WHO VIDEOS EVER!!!=]

  • Yes, it was. I e-mailed the Geoff Smith about it (his email addy is on his website), and he confirmed it. That made me quite the happy fangirl to find that out.

  • Thank you from Russia for this wonderful video!:)

    I'm a huge fan of Dr. Who & Rose Tyler and this video absolutely matches their relations.

  • I am happy to hear many people in the world love this video and this story,,me too..I like it so much...especially Billie Piper and David tennant..^_^

  • Comment removed

  • This song is so frighteningly spot on for these two characters and their relationship. From the obvious of her name to words/phrases ("fantastic", "my Rose", etc.)... it's truly unbelievable how amazingly it matches up!

    I loved watching this video. Great job. Thank you! :)

  • it matches up so well because the song was written for the character Rose

  • Oh God. Love this song. Love this video. <3

  • sniffs, it´s soo beautiful!

    is this song specialy made for doctor who?

  • Yeah, it is. Little fact: the singer, Geoff Smith, wrote this song especially for the character of Rose Tyler. I googled his name, and found it on his site or something.

  • ya its good

  • this mad me cry ;-)

  • thank you for a wonderful video that captures the beauty, spirit and love of both the Doctor and Rose. This video has always been my favorite Doctor Who and Rose video. I feel the love, the energy, the joy and excitement of traveling time and space and doing it with someone you love. I would do anything to be Rose Tyler. She is so beautiful and she is the only companion who will ever be the Doctor's true soul mate. I would be with him forever. I love you Doctor. Thanks again. Hugs Maggie

  • During my classes, I dream about the TARDIS taking me away and the 5th Doctor (my fav) sweeping me off my feet--and this planet, lol, and us being together forever. Your comment is gorgeous, exactly what I wanted to say but never found the words :)

  • I've never watched this show,what is about?I love B.Piper,I've seen her in Secret diary of a call girl.I have to watch this show absolutely!

  • Basically, Doctor Who is about a time traveler that usually has a human companion, and visits the most exotic places in the universe.

    Check out the wikipedia article about Doctor Who.

  • well, don't know if you've already gone and watched it but will tell you anyway. Rose( bp) is ordinary shop girl. A gorgeous 900 year old alien blows up her job and they go traveling around time and space together saving lives annoying queens and falling in love. they give up thier lives for each other. also has the gorgeous david tennant in series two! anyhoo, they fall in love, get separated for ever, angsty ending where rose tells him he loves her and he doent get time to say it back. sniff!