Added: 1 year ago
From: BBC
Views: 101,968
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (155)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i hate this song much but i like what they did

  • WTFF!!!! Dont get me wrong I love England, used to live there on an af base but COME ON!!! Theses girls need to STOP butchering all these GREAT "AMERICAN" classic musicals!!!!! THEY SUCK!! These girls CAN NOT do american accents!!! They make my ears BLEED!!!!!!!

  • @1225Wicked They're going to be playing an American girl. Besides, if they got the role, they would've had six months to perfect their accent. Also, let's see you try to do a British accent.

  • @simsfreakable I used to live in England FYI so yes I can do a British accent, because I used to speak with one.

  • poor sophie, her dress was very short, so she didn't dance as much as steph, but steph's dress was much more longer than sophie... but both of them did a great job!!<3<3

  • bloody good xxx

  • this song didn't really suit Steph but thier both still really good actresses

  • lauren and danielle

  • Am I the only one who prefers Steph? :) I think she has a great personality in this, she knows how to put her soul into it and act really well, I found her fun and entertaining to watch, it makes me want to just get up and go wtih them dance on the stage :P

  • I love this :) without OTR and Steph inspiring me so much, i would never have taken up singing, or Drama, not have done solo performcances at concerts! :) xxxx I did this in a concert in March :)

  • Steph can certainly swing a towell !!

  • I'm surprised at all these comments, I thought that Lauren and Danielle got the better song and so expected them to be better, but I actually preferred this performance.

  • i like Danielle and Lauren's better- more fun, humorous just better.

  • This performance was brilliant, subtle, honest and both of them sung it beautifully! Danielle and Lauren are beautiful singers too, however I found their performance painful and forced - awful mellodrama, it was like watching Mean Girls: The Musical or something, and certainly not in a good way. I don't think 'Popular' suited them. But concerning voices, all four of them are beyond amazing, and utterly stunning performers on their own.

  • i agree the other performance was better, but i think this group didn't have as good as good a song as a duet. danielle and lauren actually had a sort of story that involved both of them, this song didn't have as much potential to do that.

  • Sorry but Danielle shouldn't have won! I was rooting for Sophie because she can act as well as sing but Danielle is just a singer. She sounds a but shouty at times as well.

  • I think Sophie's a better singer but Steph put in more expression :))

  • great performence!their voices go very well together!

  • Song choice is a major factor but I would rather end up in the bath with Steph and Soapy !!! Boom Boom

  • i love this song

  • i love sophie and steph but have to say that i liked lauren and danielles performance better- that might have something to do with the fact that i like their song better than this one anyway

  • Dit is zo veel beter dan Lauren & Danielle. Dit is gewoon heel goed gedaan.

  • mmm lucky if they get a job in Butlins, oh wait ALW is Butlins

  • this was such an unfair song choice, danielle and lauren got not only a better known song, but a more mordern and easier one, unfair much? steph was easily the most talented person in the competition and she went out this night because once more she was given a bad song :( xx

  • @VonniiKP It is indeed a difficult song. But I think they fared better than Lauren and Danielle. Steph is the most talented girl.

  • @thijsieh600 naturally Steph still shone in this performance, it just angered me how blatent favouritism was shown :( xx

  • @VonniiKP You could also argue the reverse - as Danielle and Lauren's song is recent the original performances are still fresh in the public's mind and therefore there is an awful lot of expectation on the girls to deliver the song as well as Kristin Chenoweth. Steph and Sophie had the opportunity to perform the hell out of this song and neither rose to the challenge all that well - something which the judges pointed out to them.

  • @welshcherry That could be true, however i still think that the other two being given a recent song was an advantage, as neither performance was as good as the original but at least the public could remember the original, as a large amount of the audience were younger people.

  • @VonniiKP True. I agree with you that Steph was much better than Sophie. I can see Steph doing very well in a comedy like Avenue Q (I would love to see her perform as Kate Monster!) or Mamma Mia. Sophie, although clearly a talented singer, always left me wanting much more from her performances.

  • One of these two should've won!!

  • Right then which way to the valley

  • ohhhh sophie.........

  • Sophie, for some reason. Reminds me of one of the ugly sisters from the disney Cinderella, but she's pretty. If that makes any sense

  • @xPeeriePixiex

    I think it's because they put her in green. Green is supposed to suggest unpleasant.. :S

  • @PinkBlossomxx I am xPeeriePixiex I changed accounts. No I think it's cause her hair is up.

  • Comment removed

  • To be honest I find it hard to choose between everyone because when it comes down to it they're all pretty similar. There voices are loud. They all act in the same comical and fun or sad and pure way. And they are all beautiful. They could all be Dorothy.

  • Comment removed

  • normally, i like stuff like this, but, i am just not a fan of their voices.....

  • Comment removed

  • Sophie is fab :D I thought she was by far the best vocally AND best actress. She was actually beleivable and natural where as some of the girls are fake. Steph was good but Sophie stole the performence even when she wasent singing! I really felt she wasentbeing credited enough but I like her :)

  • steph was amazing in this!! she was always my fav, tbh i wasnt too impressed with sophie but she still did great :) she was more right for dorothy than steph but steph has more talent

  • I agreed with Sheila when she said that the other number, Popular, was a bit easier to perform and make humorous, but I think this wasn't quite as good as it could have been. I didn't feel like I entirely believed them, whereas I did Danielle and Lauren. That might just be because Danielle and Lauren were my two favourites though!

  • This is like.............its so funny but also looks violent, I'd hate to be a man who upsets either of these two

  • luv those dresses, lolz x

  • love you sophie dont like south pacific but u were AMAZING

  • i added steph on facebook lol xxxxx

  • Klass and u both have really have strong voices

  • Danielle deserved to win ♥ xx

  • love sophie

  • :') fantastic steph was better with the acting but all together they wereboth fantastic

  • greatttttttttttttt

  • I much prefer Danielle's and Lauren's preformance, it was honest, enjoyable and funny. This is good, but I think the panel were right with the comments! Danielle was my favourite! Still is! <3 =]

  • sophie is great she should have won steph is not very good

  • @SuperCraig22 i agree sophie looks more confident and steph just wud be really good if she trried abit harder

  • i was for steph but she went out so then i was for sophie but they chose danielle i still cant believe it

  • im voting for sophie

  • Please vote for Sophie she is absolutly AMAZING , 09011212201 show SOPHIE ALL UR SUPPOERT , SHE NEEDS AS MANY VOTES AS POSSIBLE :D

  • really hope sophie wins, she has grown into a great, fun, loving dorothy!

  • i think danielle looks the part of dorothy and has a gr8 voice so she should win, sophie second, and lauren has the best so she could easily get a part somewhere else so she should go today.

  • steph does great acting in this love her

  • @XxXiceclimberXxX I hate steph

  • @simpsoaj03 hate is a very strong word

  • well i wanted steph 2 win and was very angry and upset when she left she was the no1 dorothy but now she gone danielle has to win, xx

  • @mariahcarey12345 I am not agrueing/disagreeing with you or anyone it's just I'd like clarification why people say such a one has to win? All 3 ladies are so talented it's unbeleivable. Unlike the Nancy show where Samantha was clearly the best yet failed to win.

  • @TheHughLundy can i say, no disrespect meant, but you say you need clarification about this then claim "Samantha was clearly the best" which in itself is completely your own opinion. I dont mean this to be horrible i just wana make a point cos you cant assert something like that, :)

  • @twinklefudge Thanks yes I didn't make the point clearly. I should of questioned if Danielle was the best(as you say in someone's opinion). The reason I should have asked was the 3 finalists of this show were so equally matched whereas I felt and still feel Samantha was miles ahead of the other two finalists who were only there was public favourites.Other people will disagree but that'slife.

  • @TheHughLundy Oh yh no I agree this one was much closer! I glad danielle won but can't say I'd have been disappointed if sophie or lauren had won x

  • dis was good but daniella and lauren were wayyy better i think danielle was the dark horse in the competion i want LAUREN A.K.A DORTHAY!!!! bt i don,t tink she will plz vote 4 her :D

  • Steph has a bit of a tired voice,

    It makes me mad,

    she can sing very pretty low,

    but if committed become higher,

    become too difficult for her,

    So I think they should look,

    and sophie, lauren, Dani or Ellie,

    Sophie is the best of Stephen and sophie

  • yes! Sophie is very good for... horror film!

  • i love sophieeeee:D her voice is unique!!!!!! but lauren and danielles was betterr but i want sophieee to win, im welsh sooo thats whyy:D!!!

  • Sophie is the weakest ling! Go home Sophie!

  • @danutzpop Say that again and you're dead.

  • loved this.. so much fun :)

  • SOPHIE IS AMAZING, WINNER

  • i thought the other group was better still, that was good

  • I want either Sophie or Danielle to win i don't mind if Lauren wins because she is really good but i would prefer Danielle Or Sophie to win :) I don't think Steph was right for Dorothy she's right for the west end just not dorothy i can't quite put my finger on what character though. Steph i though was the weakest in the cemi finalls dont get me wrong she was good i just thought the other 3 were better :)

  • steph was so dorothy. lauren? no. fuck you, webber.

  • @Blehickurgh Steph was not dorothy though

  • MUCH BETTER THEN THE OTHER GROUP!!!!! The other song is better then this song..... but they made this song amazing :) SOPHIE FOR THE WIN :) x

  • Sophie did really well here!

  • Comment removed

  • sophie totally stole this.

  • Sophie's best performance, she was strong and really projected with loads of animation. Brilliant, I really hope she wins.

  • i liked Steph, its a shame she's gone ... but ... yeah, Sophie to win!

  • Wow sophie does Not look 17 she looks atleast 19 Imo anyway... I love how these 2 have become best friends... It's soooo cute :D

  • glad steph's gone. she really played on athe sweet/innocent card when frankly she couldn't sing well. she also alluded to her mixed race being a reason for a "different dorothy" which is not a reason. and she murdered her departure song.

  • @25fitguy I have to ask if we were watching/listening to the same Steph. Steph was one if not the most veratile vocalists in the competion. Nither oh so quite or this song were sweet inocence.If by her departure song you mean Somewhere over the Rainbow in my humble opion Steph did it a million times better than anyone else.

  • @25fitguy Complete rubbish. You obviously can't tell a brilliant and powerful voice when you hear one.

  • steph went home!! BOOHOO!! she was my favourite-i loved her voice and her acting and its a shame shes gone home! i have a 2nd favourite, danielle, and i want her 2 win now.

  • I think sophie did a better job she's got a good sense of humor.

  • This is my least favourite performance. When I watched it, all I could think of was 2 neandrothols waving clubs around lol. Which is too bad, cus they are both brilliant performers. I like Sophie better out of the 2.

  • @WittleWemza We are all entitled to our own thoughts when watching any performance. I have to say what I imagined was two fantastic lady ladies entralling a packed west end audience with another jaw dropping superb performance.

  • @TheHughLundy Yes we are entitled to our opinions and don't you forget it for you seem to question the opinion of those who don't share your own. But when you say you imagined 2 leading ladies on a packed west end, tell me did you think you were watching Flintstones the Musical? Cus I would totally agree with you.

  • @WittleWemza As I said everyone is entitled to their opinion I don't believe I said you were wrong or I was right I just gave you my opinion for what it's worth(I'm sure you will reply with some 'clever' remark).Seriously though would you have been impressed if it was the Flintstones musical.

  • Best two of the competition.

    :)

  • Comment removed

  • Sophie to win, she`s just phenomenal!!

  • Lol! Sophie looks like a giant compared to Steph!

  • come on steph :) i think lauren should go i didnt like here singing heven last night :(

  • Hmm. Both great singers.

    Sophie's actind just doesn't convince me however.

    Steph built up her emotions throught what can only be described as a very dull song. On the other hand, Sophie seemed the same all the way through. She just seems very 2D and I could only her imagine her playing the same characters. She seems to win on the heartfelt sad songs but no where else.

  • Loved it! Well done both of you!

    Would be a shame if the spoilers are true...I would like both of them in the final.

    Well...then I go for Sophie and Danielle for number one and two (and the other one the alternate/understudy)

  • Sophie to win!

  • yeah c'mon soph! i know sophie haha, shes in my school(:

  • I think Sophie really shined in this! She's simply amazing! :')

    Dorothy = Sophie Evans <3

  • We are very lucky to see two such talented performers as these two young ladies. There are some leading ladies who have appearing in musicals who could not compare favourabley with Steph & Sophie. Image who terrible they will be after they first major part.

  • This was really good, but I think the song choice was unfair, they should have done "One Short Day" from Wicked or something so that both groups had an upbeat song from a modern musical. Danielle to win! :)

  • Sophie's voice is absolutely STUNNING!!

    Voted for her soo much, hope she gets througgh! :)

  • Sophie To Win :D

  • I preferred this one to Lauren and Danielle's duet. This was fun and cute. I think L+D killed Popular, but that's just me.

  • WATS THAT SONG CALLED? PLZ TELL ME.

  • @ruwaida99 its called im gunna wash that man right out of my hair

    isnt tht a bit obvious lol

  • IT really annoys me how the Judges including AL-W are all ment to show emotions as there job, well cept CC cuz she's a singer, yet when they watch performances, they don't show a single emotion, i would be really pissed if someone didn't smile at my performace

  • @timelady1994

    You shouldn't give anything away when judging something like this, because primarily this is an audition. If you go anywhere for auditions, generally the panel of people auditioning you will stay blanked face with no expression, it's the professional thing to do. Although actually, saying that, ALW and John were really getting into Danielles 'Mambo Italiano' the other week. =]

  • @jamesakafurby I went for an audition for college the other week, and they had black faces, made me feel like I wasn't good enough, but I was so it was quite odd. And i haven't seen the mambo italiano one yet, ill have to look it up :)

  • @timelady1994 black faces xD LOL

  • i cant stand steph. shes gotta good voice but i cant really imagine her as dorothy clutching toto....

  • I love stephs smile :) and sophies great too, danielle is brilliant but i still think lauren has the best voice and should win :D but i love them all this year ;)

  • Seriously, who gives these songs. Sophie and Steph tried their hardest to colour and modernise this dated, annoying song from such an old musical, and although they sang it well and acted it well it will always be bland, whoever does it. Even if the 'comedy duo' [oh please] were to perform this they would have a hard time. I'm just suggesting to give Sophie and Steph better songs. Sophie to win though :)

  • sophie looks like nurse gladis emanuelle from open all hours

  • those outfits are awful aha but they both did a good job :)

  • Steph did it better i think :D

  • stephhh!!! :)

  • sophie is a-ma-sing! she just turned 17 last month and i reeeeally hope she wins!

  • @vidstar001 she was 17 feb 13th :)

  • @sophie628309 oh right lolz, day before valentines day

  • I've wanted sophie to sing this song For ages!! It really suits her So I'm happy she's done it :D

  • Tough song, terrible outfits, slightly uninspired choreography, yet great performances, particularly Sophie. Hope she wins.

  • well Annaarwen you didn't think the performance "stank" .... no-one with ears would think it "stank." Only reason claney could possibly have for saying it stank was the thumbs-up comments they've given to Danielle in the past. Not saying all Danielle fans are like that. ...not sure why you should read it like that?

  • I feel Danielle and Lauren got the better song, but these two did great if what they were given. SOPHIE TO WIN!

  • @claney01

    nasty comment but you're a Danielle fan, so that figures

  • @solidpotato I am also a Danielle fan, in fact I couldn't be more so if I tried, yet I loved this, I think they both shone in this number. Can you explain how that "figures"?

    When you find a nasty comment on here, there is no need to match it with your own.

  • Comment removed

  • SOPHIE TO WIN!!!!!! She is BRILLIANT!!!!

  • i can't believe sohpie's only 17, She's great :)

  • Jengenilou I agree with you! It was fun and I enjoyed it much more than the other two! Sophie is shaping up to be Dorothy for us!!

  • fun performance

  • sophie has grown so much on me and i want her to win!!! Steph is good but i dont see her being a believable dorothy, where as sophie can sing, move and act great! and she is BEAUTIFUL.

  • Stephs actions and faces are hilaarious!

  • I liked this. Didn't love it, but maybe that's because I'm not a fan of South Pacific. Both the girls done a great job though.

  • Loved this!!! I hate it how the panel praise danielle and lauren more than these two, i thought this was a more enjoyable and believable performance. Steph's great but SOPHIE FTW!!!!!!!! :P

  • @BananaGirl1300 This was awful compared to Lauren and Dorothy! (Yes, I said Dorothy)

  • @BananaGirl1300 nah danielle and lauren had a more fun and lively performance

  • Thought they were miles better than the other two, but the panel saw it different. God knows why - Danielle and Lauren overracting for all they were worth. Give me these two any day.

  • I liked this and I think Sophie actually out-shone Steph in this song.

  • @SuperJosh1002 lol yeah she did

  • my 2 favorite girls

  • @woodyactor1995 same here

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more