Miley Cyrus American Idol Mentor part 1

[LaurokaPlay]

look. stop bitching on miley. you can say whatever you want on her, that her show sucks, but a) shes much + than that b) u would kill to be in her show. she's an amazing not just singer, but actress, and she has a GREAT contralto husky voice. god knows how rare that is.

[Dusto22]

If Miley Cyrus was alowed to mentor on American Idol so should Taylor Swift.

[Dusto22]

If Miley Cyrus was alowed to mentor on American Idol so should Taylor Swift.

[4evacenation]

@Dusto22 you're right

[stygianmessiah]

i hate her personally and i think that her vocals isnt all that great.but u gotta respect her for her success and that she knows what it takes to make it in the business.thats all that matters really

[wayla711MJ829]

@stygianmessiah I kind of disagree...I don't think she has the best vocals either, but how hard could it be to make it in the music industry when you're dad is already a famous singer? It's not like she did it all by herself.

[stygianmessiah]

@wayla711MJ829 hmm it sort of makes sense but her fans are mostly kids and dont give a shit who her dad is anyway.hannah montana made her famous,which couldnt have been possible without her dad's connections, but she did worked her way for success by herself.billy ray could only do so much

[wayla711MJ829]

@stygianmessiah well yeah that's true, but I still don't think she would have made it without her dad's help. But idk...I guess she might have made it.

[HairAbouts]

@stygianmessiah (This is just my opinion and I also respect yours) Her vocals isn't great? I don't think that Disney and the whole world would love her if her vocals isn't great :)

[stygianmessiah]

@HairAbouts well her vocals is definitely good but isnt one o the best if u know what i mean.i just dont like the sound of her voice haha but thats my opinion

[njrulz20]

@HairAbouts exactly :D

[svensuperman789]

whoah its ellen :D

[Catanator]

oh god Dermot is soooo much better then Ryan Secrest

[mileyselenaluver28]

if you look closer you can see tish cyrus in the audience

[xXFCUNiiiT3DXx]

Follow Mileys New Twitter ( IVIileyCyrus ) without the brackets

[DominiqueJUK]

its not about age as she said. its about her music and ow sucessful she is. she could be 9 and have that much sucessful. so i dnt think people should judge her on her age... thats just my opinion

[TheGenerationRocks]

@DominiqueJUK I am so glad u r not tearing miley down...thx

[MilesDemetriaSelx]

oh my god. seriously people. grow up and get a life. everyone has there own opinions of miley. some people like her... some people dislike her... some people love her... some people hate her. i personally love her :) but everyone has their own opinion... theres really no point in arguing over it.

[jbmcmigsal]

a lot of people may hate her but she is very talented and she's gone a long way in her courier

[Onlymaybe7]

@Miley902101 How many times have I wrote that I never said she sucks????!!! Or is it that every time I wrote that you never read it? Yes I KNOW she's a good singer!! I never said she isn't! Why are you picking only on me? I didn't even said she sucks like the other people did on this page and you're picking on me. And my user name is something I randomly pick putting together 2 words I like and my favorite number. Any problem with that? Just like your Miley902101 because you probably like her!

[Onlymaybe7]

@Miley902101 I TOLD you I never said she sucks. Yes I know she can sing, she have a very husky voice different from singers nowadays which is why I think her voice is unique. I never said she sucks. Just leave at that and stop commenting me.

[ccwe23]

they should have like xtina or mariah or whitney or celine dion mentoring not hannah montana

[mooveonup21]

For those who say She is "too young and inexperienced," look at Ellen, she isn't even a singer or an artist or even a musician......shes a dumb lesbo with a talk show and she SOMEHOW is a judge

[gbritaney]

Her as a mentor I agree she is too young.

[Ashprincess2010]

u are just jelous of miley- onlymaybe7

[Onlymaybe7]

@Ashprincess2010 I'm not jealous, I was just pointing out my thoughts, and there are many others who agreed with me, why are you and Miley902101 picking only on me??? I never even said she sucks okay? In fact if someone told me she sucks I would probably even point out her good stuff to that person. So can you and Miley902101 just leave me alone already.

[tollywoga]

What year was this?

[Hannah4438]

@tollywoga 2010

[KayViMovies]

Her Being A Mentor Is A Laugh Next To Adam Lambert

[Kirsty4BFMV]

Although she is only young, she has got alot of experience and is undeniably talented. Obviously, she has been doing hannah montana for a long time now and also she has experience with her father.. :)

[SellyGomez96]

yeah, she is young, but she has had so much experience packed into her few musical years and these are what those people are going through, sudden fame and being quickly rushed into this fame thing so i think she's actually a perfect match. she was very humble and acknowledge her nervousness, etc. i think she did a great job.

[innadejavu]

you gays are all idiot ;x are you crazy shte is so young and she is so famous and has done so manyy ;x yes she is young and what ? shte may be a example how far they could become ;x and you can you do just a little pari of what she has ?? well i dont thing so .. because if you could you wouldn't be standing at the computer right now and telling what a girl can or cant do .. and if you could you would know that the talant doesent have age limit just think about that ...

[Kels91Lynn]

miley isnt age appropriate or experienced enough to be a mentor.. she's not recognized by the world solely on her music, shes a brand..

[mellebelle007]

i didnt like her at first but now i think she has become extremely mature and intellegent. Shes awsome!!

[VintageAntique]

She can't sing, they brought her onto the show to boost ratings.

[HairAbouts]

@VintageAntique Can't sing? Seriously? Oh well, maybe YOU can.

[ehmmahx]

shes been in the business for as long as some of the more experienced people.

[rosaliemusicxxxx]

@Onlymaybe7 i really agree......she is still VERY young....and whether they want to realize it or not....she still doesn't know as much about the music buisness....she's still way too young and very naive. they need to get older musicians who have been in the music buisness a long time....not her.

[hellobbyx]

@Onlymaybe7 i completely agree. i mean , shes a decent singer but being a mentor to a bunch of 20 year olds is just kinda weird.

[Kaylawrites]

@Onlymaybe7 lol i dont think shes any 'less experienced' than a lot of other artists today. she has accomplished more in her 17 years of life (work) than many others have accomplished in their 30-50 years of work. she is still number one

[Onlymaybe7]

@Kaylawrites Yes I know she's experienced and all but I just meant they should have picked someone older too not just more experienced. I think Miley have come a long way since Hannah Montana. But I still think they should have picked a different mentor. I didn't mean it in a mean way in any way.

[CamillaMusic]

@Onlymaybe7 a little MORE experienced? Have you been living under a rock for the last years?

[malicspook]

@Onlymaybe7 17 years experience isn't enough? ? wow! what planet you on?

[Onlymaybe7]

@malicspook OMG! Will people stop commenting me! I just post my opinion okay?! When was it wrong to post their opinions? If that's a problem to you then you must be from a different planet also! I didn't even say she sucks or anything. I think she's cool but just that a teen mentoring a bunch of 20's year old is weird to me. That's it! Gosh!

[Dusto22]

@Onlymaybe7 She has all the expierience she needs

[Onlymaybe7]

@Dusto22 Lol yeah i know that post was hella long ago dude. People keep replying to me. I think imma delete it.

[chrisbrzym]

when i found out that she was...THEIR...MENTOR...i almost died, but i didnt, cause i had to see this!!!! omgggg shes only 17 & giving them advice...they are like 10 years old than her &...older...wtfffff? sooo stoooopid! who agrees?? ugh, omgggggggggggg

[darkhorsefan15]

@chrisbrzym me!!! :)

[chrisbrzym]

@darkhorsefan15 lol yayyy! wooooo!

[DarkForcezLOL]

@chrisbrzym But in terms of stage presence, and how to connect with the audience, etc., I think she has the experience to share with these contetants.

[chrisbrzym]

@DarkForcezLOL nope. srry. she's just blah.

[Kirsty4BFMV]

@chrisbrzym so she is young...she has a lot of experience with her father and hannah montana. She is very talented and she was a great mentor..their is no need to be like that.

[chrisbrzym]

@Kirsty4BFMV YES there is. she is terrible. end of story. & she only got her fame from her father hellooo? & she got her SLUT-ness from her "role model" Britney spears. Nothing will ever make me like her

[Kirsty4BFMV]

@chrisbrzym I didnt say you had to like her i just wanted to open your mind which obviously didnt work.. She isnt terrible..why would she be so famous, have millions of views on youtube and become succeful? Erm britney isnt her role model..if you read interviews her role models are people who have become legendary and successful. Get your facts straight if you want to insult her, like i said i didnt say i wanted to make you like her..

[chrisbrzym]

@Kirsty4BFMV & one of those role models r britneyyy but whateverrr just hate her. enddd of story

[predatorop999]

miley cyrus cannot sing

[TheAimee7707]

gross.

[TheRealParodyPeople]

she's a very good singer. get it straight.

[wayla711MJ829]

@TheRealParodyPeople lmao!! yup she's top notch

[boucher21]

she isn't a good singer, but i really like her, she's pretty and seems like a genuinely sweet person