It would've been interesting to see her compete this season. I bet you Taylor would've been gone, or instead of Katherine in Taylor, it would've been Katherine and Carly, or Chris and Carly, or Elliot and Carly, or meh taylor and CARLY!! But she got the cooler stage in season 7, and she got the beatles!
Amy sings great live. So does Carly. I think Amy is better, but hey, Im not gonna bash Carly, shes great too. shes not copying Amy. Theyre both original rock singers. I really wish all the EV fans would respect Amy and just not compare the bands. And the same with the Carly fans. Please please, both of the sides just. chill out. Oh and they have covered a bunch of EV songs. but hey, half the band is ex-EV members, so theyre not really copying them, js. dont hate Carly or Amy.
n her looks, dressing n voice has been so totally trying to imitate amy lee...if this girl played some natural n genuine songs then v could hav respected her as she deserved...
@paranormalrockstar Lol, her looks? big freakin woop, she has black hair, pale skin, and beautiful eyes. So she has a goth style, doesn't mean she's going "Amy Lee" I love Amy and Carly, just because they are both beautiful gothic rock singers and Amy came before Carly doesn't mean a thing! It's like people say Amy is copying Sharen (from Within Temptation) just because she came before Amy/...
She does sound good n has a good voice but only if she stayed natural would I ahve respected her...for a singer, jsut having a good voice is not enuf but also to be a human respectable enuf, n earning that respect is thru what u do in life...n what she did was helped ben moody n co in their effort against amy lee, it's not just that but the imp. thing is that she's been lying taht they r not imitating EV, while they keep playing EV songs at concerts
She does sound good n has a good voice but only if she stayed natural would I ahve respected her...for a singer, jsut having a good voice is not enuf but also to be a human respectable enuf, n earning that respect is thru what u do in life...n what she did was helped ben moody n co in their effort against amy lee, it's not just that but the imp. thing is that she's been lying taht they r not imitating EV, while they keep playing EV songs at concerts
@paranormalrockstar They haven't played any Ev songs at any of their concerts. They've played their entire album, plus a Journey, Madonna, and Iron Maiden covers. They've covered two Ev songs that Ben wrote, one at the press conf. last summer and one at a bar when they did acoustic My Immortal. I really don't think that We Are The Fallen is "against Amy Lee." I saw them live, and they're were so energetic and really loved what they were doing. There's so much talent. Shame not everyone agrees.
@pete2k10 Thank you. I have my opinion and you have yours. Let's leave it at that. And, you know, there's this button called the "caps lock". Try it. Maybe people would take you seriously more often.
@pete2k10 erm...for the most part, Ben wrote and arranged alot of their hits, so don't hate on We Are The Fallen, Carly isn't an Amy, and you and I both know Amy can hardly sing live, unless she works out her voice...Where as Carly is 100% actual voice.....and also Ben left Evanescence so Carly didn't have anything to do with him leaving....and also mind letting off on the ''caps lock'' key? It may make people say hey, your mature, I think I'll listen to you..
@moyle1353 CARLY ISN'T A FUCKING GOD you delusional fuck. She sucks live too a lot of the times. GET YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR ASS. I don't care if people listen, cause I'm shoving it down their throats anyway like currently I am to you.
Why? Why on EVERY single video of Carly, do people have to be having the same, pointless conversation? I look at the comments to see how other people responded to the video, and here there are about a billion pointless argumentive comments about something that has no relivence to the video.
Can people not just get over it? Music is something to listen to and then form an opinion BASED on the music quality. And if you'd seperate it from political bull, maybe you'd see that.
@iLOVEChihuahuas123 I think she's an amazing singer and very talented. Also, I met her a few times during the Idol tour and she's a very nice and down to earth person. That's my opinion and I'm entitled to it.
WOW I spent YEARS looking for this, thank you SO MUCH
Chris201076 5 months ago
OMG she was much better back then
claus49 7 months ago
It would've been interesting to see her compete this season. I bet you Taylor would've been gone, or instead of Katherine in Taylor, it would've been Katherine and Carly, or Chris and Carly, or Elliot and Carly, or meh taylor and CARLY!! But she got the cooler stage in season 7, and she got the beatles!
idoltyler06 8 months ago
Amy could never do that.
TiaVampire 1 year ago 2
Amy sings great live. So does Carly. I think Amy is better, but hey, Im not gonna bash Carly, shes great too. shes not copying Amy. Theyre both original rock singers. I really wish all the EV fans would respect Amy and just not compare the bands. And the same with the Carly fans. Please please, both of the sides just. chill out. Oh and they have covered a bunch of EV songs. but hey, half the band is ex-EV members, so theyre not really copying them, js. dont hate Carly or Amy.
BridgetteMidgette 1 year ago
I really think that she would have won had her papers went through the first time.
rparker91 1 year ago 3
between all this Carly and Amy bickering, i think we are all straying away from the real problem... JUSTIN BIEBER!!!!!
DyingGrassPriest 1 year ago 29
n her looks, dressing n voice has been so totally trying to imitate amy lee...if this girl played some natural n genuine songs then v could hav respected her as she deserved...
paranormalrockstar 1 year ago
@paranormalrockstar Lol, her looks? big freakin woop, she has black hair, pale skin, and beautiful eyes. So she has a goth style, doesn't mean she's going "Amy Lee" I love Amy and Carly, just because they are both beautiful gothic rock singers and Amy came before Carly doesn't mean a thing! It's like people say Amy is copying Sharen (from Within Temptation) just because she came before Amy/...
moyle1353 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She does sound good n has a good voice but only if she stayed natural would I ahve respected her...for a singer, jsut having a good voice is not enuf but also to be a human respectable enuf, n earning that respect is thru what u do in life...n what she did was helped ben moody n co in their effort against amy lee, it's not just that but the imp. thing is that she's been lying taht they r not imitating EV, while they keep playing EV songs at concerts
paranormalrockstar 1 year ago
She does sound good n has a good voice but only if she stayed natural would I ahve respected her...for a singer, jsut having a good voice is not enuf but also to be a human respectable enuf, n earning that respect is thru what u do in life...n what she did was helped ben moody n co in their effort against amy lee, it's not just that but the imp. thing is that she's been lying taht they r not imitating EV, while they keep playing EV songs at concerts
paranormalrockstar 1 year ago
@paranormalrockstar They haven't played any Ev songs at any of their concerts. They've played their entire album, plus a Journey, Madonna, and Iron Maiden covers. They've covered two Ev songs that Ben wrote, one at the press conf. last summer and one at a bar when they did acoustic My Immortal. I really don't think that We Are The Fallen is "against Amy Lee." I saw them live, and they're were so energetic and really loved what they were doing. There's so much talent. Shame not everyone agrees.
rparker91 1 year ago
@rparker91 YOU'RE SO STUPID. GOING UNDER WAS MOSTLY WRITTEN BY AMY LEE ABOUT BEN MOODY. CARLY IS JUST TRYING TO BLEND THE HELL IN. FAKE FAKE FAKE.
pete2k10 1 year ago
@pete2k10 Thank you. I have my opinion and you have yours. Let's leave it at that. And, you know, there's this button called the "caps lock". Try it. Maybe people would take you seriously more often.
rparker91 1 year ago
@rparker91 YOU'RE WELCOME. I'M GLAD I COULD HELP. AND WHAT IS THIS MYSTICAL BUTTON CALLED "CAPS LOCK"? I'VE NEVER HEARD OF IT. PLEASE, DO TELL.
pete2k10 1 year ago
@pete2k10 Oh, I don't know if I could help you to understand. It'd take years for someone like you to learn how to do something so difficult.
rparker91 1 year ago
@rparker91 I THINK I AM UP FOR THE CHALLENGE MISTER.
pete2k10 1 year ago
@pete2k10 erm...for the most part, Ben wrote and arranged alot of their hits, so don't hate on We Are The Fallen, Carly isn't an Amy, and you and I both know Amy can hardly sing live, unless she works out her voice...Where as Carly is 100% actual voice.....and also Ben left Evanescence so Carly didn't have anything to do with him leaving....and also mind letting off on the ''caps lock'' key? It may make people say hey, your mature, I think I'll listen to you..
moyle1353 1 year ago
@moyle1353 CARLY ISN'T A FUCKING GOD you delusional fuck. She sucks live too a lot of the times. GET YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR ASS. I don't care if people listen, cause I'm shoving it down their throats anyway like currently I am to you.
pete2k10 1 year ago
Glad I found this video. I always wondered what she was like before Season 7. CARLY I LOVE YOU!!!!!!
absolutjared 1 year ago
Why? Why on EVERY single video of Carly, do people have to be having the same, pointless conversation? I look at the comments to see how other people responded to the video, and here there are about a billion pointless argumentive comments about something that has no relivence to the video.
Can people not just get over it? Music is something to listen to and then form an opinion BASED on the music quality. And if you'd seperate it from political bull, maybe you'd see that.
SomebodySasski 1 year ago 2
@SomebodySasski Its not pointless if you think about it. Its about carly's lies.
amyleeVSbenmoody 1 year ago
Was this the Taylor Hicks season? She would've totally owned his ass. Idk what people were thinking when they voted for him -.- Shame about her VISA
arturesteve 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
iLOVEChihuahuas123 2 years ago
Comment removed
bluefantasea 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
AMY LEE IS SO MUCH BETTER!!!!
MrHunter599 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fuck you carly. Amy is better than you. PERIOD.
perpetualstix 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I liked her better before she ripped on amy lee
DarkGaia77818 2 years ago
Carly is awesome.
cbotten106 2 years ago 6
this just made me a bigger carly fan. her voice is just amazing. :)
kristiegirl33 2 years ago 4
this audition was better than her 2nd 1
HalloweensCoarpse 2 years ago
Carly sounds awesome here. Can't wait for the We Are The Fallen album so we can hear more of her voice.
12345carlyfan 2 years ago 18
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@12345carlyfan Why do you like this fake ass bitch? i'm curious
iLOVEChihuahuas123 2 years ago
@iLOVEChihuahuas123 I think she's an amazing singer and very talented. Also, I met her a few times during the Idol tour and she's a very nice and down to earth person. That's my opinion and I'm entitled to it.
12345carlyfan 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
iLOVEChihuahuas123 2 years ago
She seems so normal here. She should've stuck with her solo album. Oh well. Now she has more haters.
was this before she was a plant?
iLOVEChihuahuas123 2 years ago
FINALLY!
CCisLUVx 2 years ago 4