I have seen Betty Buckley perform many times, both on Broadway and in concert, but I don't think I've ever been as moved as I am listening her sing these bootleg songs from Carrie. Thank goodness people had the foresight to record them. Too bad the show died an early death. Viva la Betty!
I love this song and what a fantastic scene-----Betty is so great. Definitely check out Kelley Mobley's performance in this scene---really awesome!!! All of her scenes leave you riveting!
im so glad they started reviving this show, the only problem i have with the changes ive heard is in this song, they take out carries pieces and its a complete solo. i like carries parts in here
Wholly merry mother of pearl! I'd heard a few tracks from this show and thought them appalling. Now, I have found a gem which now has me curious to see if in this rough there just might be a diamond.
I hope Betty Buckley is involved in the new revival they announced this week. MArin MAzzie is good but she doesn't have that Betty Buckley vocal range.
Unfortunately, I'm pretty sure Betty Buckley is too old for the show... (And her voice is no longer in this range...) I mean she could play Carrie's Grandmother I suppose... heehee
@johnfrank25 there will be no revival. recently announced that the reading was just to see where the show stood and unfortunately it will not return to the broadway stage or any stage for that matter...its very sad but true
ugggggggggh so creepy that "THEY'RE ALL GONNA LAUGH AT YOU!" god linzi is perfect as carrie, i hope sissy spacek didn't get jealous or somethign Dx that would be sad!
I think the musical as a whole was just destined to fail -- Stephen King's "Carrie", like many novels, just isn't meant to be put onstage, let alone with music.
That said, I really like this song -- Obviously, Betty Buckley pwns it just like everything else.
linzi is sooo carrie brought to life. she makes me cry in evening prayers and in eve was weak. Dx they need to fix this all up and it would be moving.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It really wouldn't though : /
The plot is already weak -- this is NOT Stephen King's best book at all. Unless they rewrote the entire story, there is really no way this could be a good musical.
i totally do not agree, i adore carries story line to pieces. angela bettis and linzi are the perfect perfect PERFECT carries. and honestly the plot just doesn't seem weak to me at all...but then again thats me, and its late so my brain is like half working xD and i haven't reread it in forever. but the plot just HELD for me. maybe just because i wanted it to, to see the outcast RISE UP AND KILL THE PROM AND CRACK HEAD MOM. *cough* once again, my apologies its very late xD
um, first off, i'm a fucking girl dumbass. you could've looked at my profile. and you simply don't understand, read the book. the girl gets her fucking way, just how it should be.
Oh crap... I wrote my comment wrong O_o... I was agreeing with you, saying the plot was good... I just put the wrong name for who was wrong... I should've said
AtLastOnTheGround doesn't know what he is talking about
But i will say, now that I know you're a girl... There wasn't a reason to be a bitch... It's a bit stalker-ish to check someone's profile if all you're doing is replying to them
I feel like it's because most of the good songs were Betty's. I don't think there are that many good songs in teh show that weren't sung by Betty Buckley.
The "they're all gonna laugh at you!" sounds like when Mario Cantone makes fun of that scene from the movie in his stand up. These songs are kinda crazy, and I wish there were more recordings of it.
well as the old saying goes, great musicals aren't written they are re-written, hope they start re writting carrie as it has some great potential, well thats just my oppinion.
but still, ive seen clips of this scene, and i dont think so many no's are necessary. the scene as i saw it she throws margaret into the chair after the first no, so the others are kinda silly. or maybe they changed the scene after stafford
Yeah, and it was one of the biggest and most expensive flops in Broadway history. Not so much because the show itself is bad (it's quite good, actually, especially the mother/daughter scenes), but because most every creative decision made in this particular production was wretched. The casting (outside of Carrie and Mrs White) was way off, the costumes and sets were hideous, the staging was confusing, and it was directed by a British guy who had no idea what a prom was or how to portray one.
Well, not all of the songs are amazing. Several songs are quite terribe. If it was ever redone, it would take some major redoing to the script a score.
I've been told that the problem wit the scoer is that all teh songs with carrie and margaret tend to be more operatic and the rest tend to be more pop-like. and that the combination of the two was a drastic failure. some of the other songs, particularly "In" arent that bad in themselves, but they dont work with the opeartic numbers, which are brilliant, although the song "Carrie" was WAY too long
Wow. This is really interisting. This song isnt too bad actually. Last night I found a copy of the working script and the opening night score. If they are working on a revival, i'm excited to see what they do with it. Of course it would need ALOT of work put into it but I think it has potential. Not to mention, I think Broadway is a bit more prepared for a musical like this than it was in '88
It's a solid show, despite the multitute of unfortunate choices made in bringing it to Broadway originally, but it would need some serious retooling to appeal to the sort of audience that goes to Broadway today. Uplifting girl power shows are all the rage now (Wicked, Legally Blonde, etc), and the message behind Carrie as is stands is that, essentially, all teenage girls are monsters.
No, there was another version on yt where Buckley sings "that's what the boys always say" instead of "that's what the boys do" and some other different lyrics.
Well the two versions i have seen have the same lyrics, and my sheet music has the same lyrics, but maybe it was some sort of improv? If it did happen id love to see it ;)
I have an old vhs reel of a few of these performances. I sure wish the show would be retooled and revived. Of course Betty Buckley'd have to be recast.
A few years ago I had the pleasure of spending some time with Dean Pitchford and his partner in Santa Barbara. He was pretty mum on the subject of "Carrie" unfortunately . To those of you that were lucky enough to have seen the show, consider yourselves so lucky!!
Hehe...nope. 90% of the songs are crap. Those of us like it so much because it's so bad we can't resist. Although, only one woman I can think of could sing Betty's role. Carolee Carmello.
@jrbrook76 Hey there, I have most of the recordings of Carrie, and I've never heard of a workshop with Betty. There is one with Maureen McGovern, though. Are you sure yours is with Betty? If that exists, I might sell my soul to get a copy. ;)
Is the England production the same as the New York production, or was it totally different? Also, would you mind sharing some of the England production with us on Youtube...?
You should see the score - even the final version they were playing from on Broadway had so many scribbles - even the page indicated there had been mountains of changes.
epic. freaking epic.
rentobbesion 5 days ago
I have seen Betty Buckley perform many times, both on Broadway and in concert, but I don't think I've ever been as moved as I am listening her sing these bootleg songs from Carrie. Thank goodness people had the foresight to record them. Too bad the show died an early death. Viva la Betty!
Garmct 7 months ago
I love this song and what a fantastic scene-----Betty is so great. Definitely check out Kelley Mobley's performance in this scene---really awesome!!! All of her scenes leave you riveting!
nipperboy47 1 year ago
im so glad they started reviving this show, the only problem i have with the changes ive heard is in this song, they take out carries pieces and its a complete solo. i like carries parts in here
omnigeek13 1 year ago
Even Betty Buckley couldn't save this show. I thought she was invincible.
PeterBluth 1 year ago
i still get chills when carries screams no. if this ever gets reworked please dont take out that part.
sci5fre 1 year ago
Wholly merry mother of pearl! I'd heard a few tracks from this show and thought them appalling. Now, I have found a gem which now has me curious to see if in this rough there just might be a diamond.
forloveoffilm 1 year ago
proof the music is amazing, the staging is what sucks, and the costumes, and the dancing.
backstreetsbev 1 year ago
This song has haunted me ever since I first heard it. What music can do...
Lindow 2 years ago
what ever happened to Betty Buckley?
robertochowder 2 years ago
Ever heard of Google? She is not some "Where are they now" person, she never stopped working. Try IMDB too for tv/movie work.
karrezza 2 years ago
I hope Betty Buckley is involved in the new revival they announced this week. MArin MAzzie is good but she doesn't have that Betty Buckley vocal range.
johnfrank25 2 years ago
@johnfrank25
Unfortunately, I'm pretty sure Betty Buckley is too old for the show... (And her voice is no longer in this range...) I mean she could play Carrie's Grandmother I suppose... heehee
babeandandy 2 years ago
@johnfrank25 there will be no revival. recently announced that the reading was just to see where the show stood and unfortunately it will not return to the broadway stage or any stage for that matter...its very sad but true
TheBwayBoy 1 year ago
@TheBwayBoy aren´t we all glad you turned out to be wrong on this one :)
Jimsteinman 1 month ago
ugggggggggh so creepy that "THEY'RE ALL GONNA LAUGH AT YOU!" god linzi is perfect as carrie, i hope sissy spacek didn't get jealous or somethign Dx that would be sad!
RaWrZzZz 2 years ago
I think the musical as a whole was just destined to fail -- Stephen King's "Carrie", like many novels, just isn't meant to be put onstage, let alone with music.
That said, I really like this song -- Obviously, Betty Buckley pwns it just like everything else.
And Linzi does a great job in the role.
AtLastOnTheGround 2 years ago
linzi is sooo carrie brought to life. she makes me cry in evening prayers and in eve was weak. Dx they need to fix this all up and it would be moving.
RaWrZzZz 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It really wouldn't though : /
The plot is already weak -- this is NOT Stephen King's best book at all. Unless they rewrote the entire story, there is really no way this could be a good musical.
AtLastOnTheGround 2 years ago
i totally do not agree, i adore carries story line to pieces. angela bettis and linzi are the perfect perfect PERFECT carries. and honestly the plot just doesn't seem weak to me at all...but then again thats me, and its late so my brain is like half working xD and i haven't reread it in forever. but the plot just HELD for me. maybe just because i wanted it to, to see the outcast RISE UP AND KILL THE PROM AND CRACK HEAD MOM. *cough* once again, my apologies its very late xD
RaWrZzZz 2 years ago
@RaWrZzZz No, You're right... The plot is not at all weak... RaWrZzZz doesn't know what he is talking about
babeandandy 2 years ago
um, first off, i'm a fucking girl dumbass. you could've looked at my profile. and you simply don't understand, read the book. the girl gets her fucking way, just how it should be.
RaWrZzZz 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh crap... I wrote my comment wrong O_o... I was agreeing with you, saying the plot was good... I just put the wrong name for who was wrong... I should've said
AtLastOnTheGround doesn't know what he is talking about
But i will say, now that I know you're a girl... There wasn't a reason to be a bitch... It's a bit stalker-ish to check someone's profile if all you're doing is replying to them
babeandandy 2 years ago
Why don't they just do a movie version of this musical?? I think that would be fun, kinda like a new Rocky Horror meets Showgirls. "-)
madfurby 3 years ago
I feel like it's because most of the good songs were Betty's. I don't think there are that many good songs in teh show that weren't sung by Betty Buckley.
blackpython 2 years ago
madfurby: I think it would be awesome if they did a movie version of the musical, but one of the three writers is refusing to release the rights.
RiverhawktheRouge 2 years ago
@RiverhawktheRouge which is Dean Pitchford
RadioCityChristmas 1 year ago
Though Betty Buckley is always amazing!
blackpython 3 years ago 2
The "they're all gonna laugh at you!" sounds like when Mario Cantone makes fun of that scene from the movie in his stand up. These songs are kinda crazy, and I wish there were more recordings of it.
blackpython 3 years ago
well as the old saying goes, great musicals aren't written they are re-written, hope they start re writting carrie as it has some great potential, well thats just my oppinion.
hefincarwyn 3 years ago
did we really need all of those "No!'s?
omnigeek13 3 years ago
This isn't a soundtrack recording, it's a recording of a performance, all the No's you hear are part of the dialogue
v1de0gamr 3 years ago
but still, ive seen clips of this scene, and i dont think so many no's are necessary. the scene as i saw it she throws margaret into the chair after the first no, so the others are kinda silly. or maybe they changed the scene after stafford
omnigeek13 3 years ago
do you have any pictures of carries had bursting into flames
madtv90210 3 years ago
i hope theres a revival
madtv90210 3 years ago
Me too! It would need a lot of work though!
broadwaybound4eva 3 years ago
Great song, bad musical
v1de0gamr 3 years ago
Was this the song where Carrie's hands burst into flames?
jammes122 3 years ago
yep.
dudewheresmydignity 3 years ago
I wouldn't exactly say that her hands burst into flames. It was more of a flicker of a flame in each upheld palm.
adknorth 3 years ago
Was Carrie seriously a broadway musical?? That's weird. lol.
TheGirlOnMars 3 years ago
Yeah, and it was one of the biggest and most expensive flops in Broadway history. Not so much because the show itself is bad (it's quite good, actually, especially the mother/daughter scenes), but because most every creative decision made in this particular production was wretched. The casting (outside of Carrie and Mrs White) was way off, the costumes and sets were hideous, the staging was confusing, and it was directed by a British guy who had no idea what a prom was or how to portray one.
buybackwhatyoustole 3 years ago
Well, not all of the songs are amazing. Several songs are quite terribe. If it was ever redone, it would take some major redoing to the script a score.
broadwaybound4eva 3 years ago
I've been told that the problem wit the scoer is that all teh songs with carrie and margaret tend to be more operatic and the rest tend to be more pop-like. and that the combination of the two was a drastic failure. some of the other songs, particularly "In" arent that bad in themselves, but they dont work with the opeartic numbers, which are brilliant, although the song "Carrie" was WAY too long
omnigeek13 3 years ago
OMG, I love this song...Betty Buckley is absolutely amazing!
abakusek 3 years ago 6
Wow. This is really interisting. This song isnt too bad actually. Last night I found a copy of the working script and the opening night score. If they are working on a revival, i'm excited to see what they do with it. Of course it would need ALOT of work put into it but I think it has potential. Not to mention, I think Broadway is a bit more prepared for a musical like this than it was in '88
broadwaybound4eva 3 years ago
It's a solid show, despite the multitute of unfortunate choices made in bringing it to Broadway originally, but it would need some serious retooling to appeal to the sort of audience that goes to Broadway today. Uplifting girl power shows are all the rage now (Wicked, Legally Blonde, etc), and the message behind Carrie as is stands is that, essentially, all teenage girls are monsters.
buybackwhatyoustole 3 years ago
there are rumors about workshops going on at the moment for a revival on West End. Can anyone confirm anything?
Jimsteinman 3 years ago
There is supposed to be a revival in the latter part of 2008/early 2009
killoa2002 3 years ago
seriously? is this a fact? That´s some kick *ss news!
Jimsteinman 3 years ago
do you know that for a fact? would be some kick *ss news!
Jimsteinman 3 years ago
I MEAN IT, THATS THE GOING RUMOUR
killoa2002 3 years ago
hm dont believe it till it happens, then. that rumour has been going round since 2006
Jimsteinman 3 years ago
This one has a solid base to it though.
killoa2002 3 years ago
Don't they all?
LOL
v1de0gamr 3 years ago
The rumor was started because it was briefly workshopped in London around then. It didn't go any further than that, though.
buybackwhatyoustole 3 years ago
how sad
Jimsteinman 3 years ago
These two woman are phantastic!
The song is super!
Colloredo31 3 years ago
Can someone post the other version of the song with different lyrics?
MrMidwest 3 years ago
This version and the stratford one are the same, out for blood was origianlly crackerjack, is that what you mean?
killoa2002 3 years ago
No, there was another version on yt where Buckley sings "that's what the boys always say" instead of "that's what the boys do" and some other different lyrics.
MrMidwest 3 years ago
Well the two versions i have seen have the same lyrics, and my sheet music has the same lyrics, but maybe it was some sort of improv? If it did happen id love to see it ;)
killoa2002 3 years ago
Whatever it was, it was an electric performance. The audience went wild at the end.
MrMidwest 3 years ago
I'd love to see or hear it
killoa2002 3 years ago
Where can i get this???
killoa2002 4 years ago
I have the Entire Audio. Would be willing to Sell.
danzait 3 years ago
Is it complete without breaks?
killoa2002 3 years ago
Where can i get this???
killoa2002 4 years ago
Where can i get this audio, mine is missing the end?
killoa2002 4 years ago 2
Mine too.
jetset59 3 years ago
I have an old vhs reel of a few of these performances. I sure wish the show would be retooled and revived. Of course Betty Buckley'd have to be recast.
A few years ago I had the pleasure of spending some time with Dean Pitchford and his partner in Santa Barbara. He was pretty mum on the subject of "Carrie" unfortunately . To those of you that were lucky enough to have seen the show, consider yourselves so lucky!!
jamesrsfo 4 years ago
I have the manuscript and finished piano conductor scores in pdf...plus all the recordings...great fun!
jrbrook76 4 years ago 6
Don't you think the show could be brought back with some changes and be a smash hit?
jnewmark41 4 years ago 3
Hehe...nope. 90% of the songs are crap. Those of us like it so much because it's so bad we can't resist. Although, only one woman I can think of could sing Betty's role. Carolee Carmello.
jrbrook76 4 years ago
I definitely think it should be revived. Other than changing the staging they might need to change 2 or 3 songs and it'd be a hit.
cjmet 4 years ago 8
@cjmet Not to mention the ridiculous dance numbers.
Espeonpwnsuall 4 months ago
They recorded these songs? I had no idea
MT4Ever 4 years ago
This was directly from the sound board of a live performance. There was no cast recording.
jrbrook76 4 years ago
Is it from the same performance we hear here?
MT4Ever 4 years ago
Yep. I do however have audio from the workshop...just piano and betty
jrbrook76 4 years ago
I have never heard this workshop...would you share it? I really am interested.
jnewmark41 4 years ago
Will you share where you got this audio?
killoa2002 3 years ago
yeah...it'd be awesome if you could share it...:))
MT4Ever 4 years ago
@jrbrook76 Hey there, I have most of the recordings of Carrie, and I've never heard of a workshop with Betty. There is one with Maureen McGovern, though. Are you sure yours is with Betty? If that exists, I might sell my soul to get a copy. ;)
highbelter 1 year ago
Oh, awesome! This is the first time I've ever heard this song in an undistorted form (I have an mp3, but it skips). It really is beautiful.
RackhamRose 4 years ago
THANKS!!!!
jnewmark41 4 years ago
Thank you for sharing! :)
Out of curiosity, how many/which recordings do you have?
RackhamRose 4 years ago
I have the entire show....AND I have a DVD of the show in England with Barbara Cook. I prefer Betty Buckley.
jnewmark41 4 years ago
Is the England production the same as the New York production, or was it totally different? Also, would you mind sharing some of the England production with us on Youtube...?
broadwaybound4eva 3 years ago
It is nearly the same, but songS WERE REWRITTEN, AND RECHOREOGRAPHED, AND SOME DIALOGUE WAS DROPPED
killoa2002 3 years ago
well theres hope. that DOES sound good
Jimsteinman 3 years ago
You should see the score - even the final version they were playing from on Broadway had so many scribbles - even the page indicated there had been mountains of changes.
adknorth 3 years ago
Brilliant
MT4Ever 4 years ago 7
I AGREE !
jnewmark41 4 years ago