@theemrpoint123 The Galaxy class can fire ten torpedoes per second, nonstop, has a better shield grid, carries more antimatter (which poweres the phasers) and 500+ torpedoes. And it destroyed a Borg Cube without upgrades.
Voyager may have less Torpedoes but her are far more advanced mark 6 instead of mark 4 used by galaxy. there is no way in hell a galaxy has better shields,Voy shields survived beating from a tactical cube,Galaxy class shields got drained in 25 seconds exactly by a normal cube in Best of Both worlds. and if it has a more powerful core why cant i go faster ? LOL ill give you some time to think about it ;)
@miloootic The one with the Borg living free in a subroutine? What was so amazing about a hole in the Borg program? I watch every Star Trek: Voyager and Enterprise included.
voyager: heavy shields,modified and adapted borg tech,more tech overall newest class bio neural gel packs...14 phasers,massive speed and engine mobility. proof episodes: year of hell,unimatrix 0,dragons teeth,night...
@miloootic So, is that why Picard was the one who took command of SF in the Battle of Sector 001 and not her? Janeway wasn't in Delta quadrant yet AFAIR. Not to mention she got kicked upstairs while Picard is too proud to step down from his starship.
@MasterMacLeod what the hell are u talkin about,janeway wasent at the battle of sector 001...picard outrank her at that time...she was involved in the dominion war at that time...
@miloootic So Janeway was too busy at the Dominion War but Picard somehow wasn't because of unrevealed reasons? May I remind you that ALL of SF had to do with that war and the Ent-D/E crew was no exception? How did Picard outrank Janeway? They were both Captains, and no captain outranks another captain, no matter what ship are we talking about. You do not know if Janeway was there or not, but it wouldn't have mattered anyway. FC Borg would have annihilated her ship anyway. VOY borg are plotholes
@MasterMacLeod rofl,um do you know that in a combat situation involving many captains cammand falls in the hands of the ship with superior tactical ability...in sector 001 sovereign is the most powerful...and if ur talkin about janeways potentiel u should watch star trek nemesis,janeway made admiral before picard so shes pretty good. he outranks her at that time ugh omg just go search for the stardates...
@miloootic So I guess that must be why Picard took FORCEFULLY command of SF? That policy doesn't have anything to do with ranks. Picard still didn't outrank Janeway, yet he was so much more badass no one dared to dispute his leadership. And I tell you again, SF promoted Janeway to admiral because they didn't want her to take another starship ever, but they couldn't kick her out, so they kicked her upstairs. Meanwhile Picard ALWAYS refused his promotion, and that has been stated too many times.
@MasterMacLeod again u still dont understand...this is an army,a space army,they have rules and regulations,no one disputed his leadership becoz thats the rule,hes ship is the superior tactical vessel...the other part of your comment has nothing to do with logic and proof,its just your personel opinion...it seems ur another picard fan boy...
in addition janeway was made admiral(when ur admiral u dont lose ur ship as u stated above) coz she made first contact with over 100s of new species
@miloootic No. When Harriman took command of the Ent-B, he was outranked by a retired Captain of a DECOMISSIONED, LESSER starship just because he happened to be a leader. If the captain is a douché, it doesn't matter if his ship is the strongest, he will get not any authority whatsoever. Your supposed policies have never been stated onscreen. And yes, Janeway didn't lose her ship, but she lost almost the entire crew. That's worse, so they kicked her upstairs. And Picard/Kirk met more species.
@MasterMacLeod janeway lost her entire crew????rofl where did that come from? ur fabulating about picard/kirk so u just say whatever... she lost a few crewmen but that was minimal casualties...im pretty sure u have 0 proof about that. kicked upstairs???u keep repeating that....stating the same flawed argument doesent make it right...again u have 0 proof...
@miloootic I take it you never watched the VOY premiere? The crew you saw during the series WASN'T the crew Janeway used to have before the series. They were wiped out. Did Kirk lose his crew? No. Did Picard lose his crew? No! And the major consensus AGREES that Janeway was promoted to prevent her from commanding another starship EVER. Deal with it!
@MasterMacLeod again ur wrong voyager in the episode caretaker lost like 20 crewman that was it,u should really go back and watch the series....they were replaced with maquis (most of the maquis are former starfleet enlisted)
@miloootic YOU just saw 20 guys because your TV won't be enough to show a ship's population of 600+ people, don't be stupid. And the fact you're telling me that she replaced them with maquis anyway actually helps my point, not yours.
@MasterMacLeod ok im through arguing with you...your information about trek cannon is 0. an intrepid class (voyager) has a crew compliment of 150-200 max ok??? ugh we get it picard was good im not negating that,but janeway was an amazing captain,she was so determined,followed the rules and protocols,broke the prime directive to protect the crew,was willing to sacrifice herself on many occasions....im not gonna talk about janeway anymore coz u never watched voyager so its useless to talk.
@miloootic It seems you don't get sarcasm. It doesn't matter if VOY's crew was 200 or 2000, they won't be shown on TV EVER. BTW, nice description of mentioning whatever is expected of your average starfleet captain as if it somehow were some of Janeway's merits. It was her freaking job!
@MasterMacLeod she also made first allinance with the borg,charted star maps for an unexplored quadrant...she accomplished far more then he did,thats why...she admiral now hes not.
@miloootic The VOY borg act completely OoC and are Deus Ex Machina plot devices or complete tools, and the charting of starmaps of unexplored quadrants WAS her fucking job, which ARCHER had done before. And need I remind you Picard REJECTED admiralship ON SCREEN during GENERATIONS because when KIRK told him to, he said that he ALREADY had done so! Your selective memory sucks bigtime.
@MasterMacLeod ok ok picard rejected admiralship...so? is that supposed to be an argument? archer charted star maps.yes he did,but not in the delta quadrant...you have issues understanding what an uncharted,unexplored quadrant means....again u dont understand,ill rephrase what was said on screen in a star trek episode called equinox, in a combat situation involving multiple captains,cammand of the task force falls into the hands of the ship with tactical superiority...
@miloootic That's assuming the captain is qualified to take control. What if ENSIGN RICKY had been in command of Ent-E? Do you really think they would have let him take command of StarFleet? No, right? Your example fails horribly.
@MasterMacLeod any person to reach the rank of captain is qualified...and yes enseign whatever must have command expirience in order to be a senior bridge officer...if i can put a child on a sovereign class assult cruiser and tell it to push one button and fire a spread of quantum torpedoes on a weak inferior miranda class commanded by kirk he would get crushed....doesent matter whos commanding,if i were to have a race with a pro cyclist using my car and hes bike i would win...
@miloootic No. You might not remember when Crusher was left in command of Ent-D. All of her emergency crew were unexperienced noobs. So your point is null. What happens when you get your car to race against a pro cyclist but you crash your car against a tree, the cyclist would win ROFLing the entire time. Such a driver happens to be like Janeway.
@MasterMacLeod lets take for example,uss voyager,uss enterprise e,and a nebula class,all with 3 captains,and 2 romulan warbirds enter fed space,in this case the captain of the enterprise takes command of the fleet becoz hes vessel is a sovereign class assult cruiser supperior weapons capacity then an intrepid and a nebula....got it now....judging by your comments and your lack of cannon,and logical,information involving the show,i assume you never watched star trek voyager or ds9...
@miloootic Again, if Mr. RICKY is in control of Ent-E because Picard had malaria that day, Riker was honeymooning, Data asploded, Dr. Crusher was in the med school and Worf/Geordi were trying to prevent the entire SF from being wiped out, nobody in their right mind would let him to take control of the entire fleet. I think it is you who saw the series, but didn't really pay attention nor have too much of a common sense.
@MasterMacLeod u just watched a few movies of star trek as it seems...and the borg barely appeared on screen only a few episode on generations...it was voyager that allowed us to understand the borg hierachie/the hive mind...so many episode in stv involved the borg and had the highest rating on tv...ratings went up evry time the borg appeared on voy,that was stated by the writers....the uss voyager made first contact with new aliens species,and just to give you proof go watch star trek episode
@miloootic No. VOY derailed the Borg characters horribly, and that's a major consensus. The hive mind was established in FC (you never saw it). And LOL @ comparing VOY's ratings to TNG's.
FC yes but it was never develloped,the entire borg perspective was revealed during voyager....we never saw any borg planets prior to scorpion episodes,we never saw any borg ships but cubes...in voy we saw probes,tactical cubes,queens ship....etc TNG was good of course it was but it was just plain boring sometimes...u barely saw any action or tactical situations....voy was far more active and exciting.
@miloootic How did the hive mind concept needed to be developed? A hive mind is a hive mind, plain and simple. VOY tried to make the borg become the next ferengi. And VOY wasn't anything but a blatant fanservice show, nothing was as deep as in TNG, TOS or DS9.
@MasterMacLeod called friendship one,and admiral and a starfleet proffesor stated that voy made the highest amount of first contact even more then james t.kirk......im not in the mood to continu this useless conversation...go watch more trek then argue...all your arguments lack coherent logic and cannon info...
@miloootic Of course if you are stuck 70 years away from home you have to meet more species, if you didn't you would suck at your job. Now, I'm not saying Janeway sucks period because that's not true. I'm saying Picard and Kirk are much much more qualified and better captains than her and THAT'S AN UNDISPUTED FACT.
@miloootic Just ask anybody on the street. Maybe a police officer. Or your mom/dad. And BTW I suggest you read CAREFULLY Picard's bio at Startrek.com and pay attention to what happened in 2364. Picard is better than the rest, and only Kirk comes close. Deal with it.
dont u kno whats funny u dont have to watch this video at all to know that voyager will win cause in all the voyager sceries voyger never gets destroyed damaged but keeps goin and interprise had to be self dectructed in a lot of epesodes/moiies
I saw that Riker was alive in next seen yeah but why Voyager wins all the time?? but they did take heavy damage,, where is Enterprise Vengence?hmmmm seems it should come about again since that was there time loop . what does everyone else think???good video anyways
Just watch the episode "The Survivors" and see what could Ent-D can unleash...the scene is shown in the related vids under Ent-D fights husnock. Sorry...VGR went off the rails in season 4, and the writers just started throwin everything but the kitchen sink into the story. Ent-D OWNS VGR any any battle thats based in reality...
Lastly "Ent D was destroyed by an old BOP while fighting with everything it had...VGR took on GOD and the prophets with no shields and survived without a bit of Janeway's hair outa place!"
First...If you count, during "Generations"...Ent-D took between 18 and 20 direct hits with no shields, including to the engines. (those were just the ones we could see and hear) Thats pretty good since we dont know the true output of the klingon weapons or of the enemies that attacked VGR.
"VGR has more advance power systems and survived in the Delta Quadrant"
Thats called WRITING. If it had been Ent-D out there, exact same thing. As far as the power. Episode "Booby Trap", Ent D had its energy sucked outa it for almost a day, til there was almost none left. As soon as force doing it was neutralized, Ent D powered right back up and unleased a torpedo salvo, a large one.
VGR spent most of the first season trying to get its power back. OWNED
LOVE the VGR fanboys and their delusions. "VGR has 13 phaser banks to Ent-Ds 12!"
Yeah, since the two main phaser arrays on Ent-D could wrap around VGR twice. Each bank is hundreds of individual emitters. Ent-D OWNS VGR.
"VGR has four torpedo lanuchers to Ent D's two"
Yeah, and Ent D can fire as many as 8 (canon) or 10 (Tech manl) at a time. Vgr's has NEVER shown to fire more than single bursts alternating between the two tubes either front or back. OWNED
I call BS !!!!!!!!!No way Intrepid class even competes with galaxy wtf???have you even played any of the games ?? Intrepid class not even close to excelsior
@mikekobbler Hm, for a start Voyager is equipped with 13 T-X Phasers. However Voyagers Phasers can only generate half of the damage the Galaxy classes due to power limitations. The Galaxy class was armed with 12 T-X Phasers. However Voyager had 4 Lauchers and the E-D had just 3 Lauchers. Voyager also endured months of punishment from weapons that could penetrate her shields. The E-D got it's ass kicked by a 20 Year old BoP that could penetrate it's shields. Voyager beats Galaxy.
The result: A small, deep space explorer with similar tactical and offensive capabilities to the Galaxy class (most likely pre-dominion war standards) while having superior sensors and scientific equipment. Overall, the capabilities will be limited to crew size, however the computing power, advanced dilithium swirl reacion chamber (basically the whole core is a reaction chamber), tactical and offensive capbailities were not hurt by having a smaller crew.
i've read some of these posts and to that i can reply: The Intrepid class ship was designed as a smaller, easier to build counterpart to the Galaxy class. The idea was to use the latest in Federation technology to create a smaller ship with larger ship capabilities that can be produced on a mass scale. Another reason for the downsize in size is to increase overall speed.
Yeah :D I like watching all Star Trek series and movies, but to be honest with ya Enterprise D have no match for Voyager and will easy be destroy, but this movie are taken by other clips believe me and it's not a real fight :p If it did goodbye Enterprise D
The Enterprise D is just not as tough of a ship. When Voyager was attacked for weeks by the Krenim who could penetrate their shields Voyager managed to survive attack after attack. The Enterprise D ran into one pos Klingon Bird of Prey that could penetrate its shields and it was destroyed. Voyager would kick the Enterprise D's ass because it is just a way tougher ship.
Even without the Borg enhansments to voyager, it would have 1. Intrepid class are smooth, swift and deadly. Galaxy class are slow, not so dangerous to a intrepid class ship. Voyager would win anyday without Borg technology Brillo vid
I was going to say good video but no... The video is horrible. Voyager would get obliterated... Enterprise is a superior ship and Picard is a million times a better captain.
oh god people are so dam stupid,galaxy class are slower then intrepid a lot slower. galaxy might have larger torpedo compliment and is bigger then voyager but voyager has bio-neural gel packs, extrem agility, and as seen in many episodes,voyager has amazing durability in battle ( unimatrix 0 borg tactical cube, year of hell....). voyager ftw. people who based their opinons on games like st bc or legacy would say enterprise but in the real deal its voyager.
Actuallly A Galaxy class as alot more fire power. Intrepid class ships are faster and have better shields and much more accurate sensors. When it comes down to it though Voyager has the advantage since it has been upgraded with Borg Technology. You are completely correct, The Enterprise may be larger and better in battle but then you have Voyager from Endgame..
@NANOFORGE Ignore my last comment, turns out Voyager actually has more firepower than a Galaxy Class. Voyager was also armed with 13 Type-X Phaser arrays aswell. The Ent-D was only armed with 12 of those. Voyager is also armed with Class-6 Torps that have a max yeild of 512 Megatons which can fire from 4 Lauchers. The Ent-D's Torps only had a max of 64 Megatons and could only fire from 3 Launchers. Voyager > Enteprise-D.
@NANOFORGE at a time PER launcher. In a burst all at once (5 to 6), or a long rapid string of them. Voyager can alternate port/starboard one shot at a time for a max spread of 4. You've got to realize, there are reasons for classifications of warships based off of size and power. Intrepids are Light Cruisers. Akira's are Cruisers, sometimes called Heavy Cruisers. Galaxy's are Battleships and so are Sovereigns. Defiant on DS9 is called a "Destroyer", but is a full warship. Starships are weaker.
@NANOFORGE Starships are weaker vessels in each class than their warship counterparts. A Cruiser starship will not be as powerful as a Cruiser warship. Otherwise, why bother differentiating the two? Why was Defiant designed ground up as a warship where as Voyager wasn't if Voyager was better in a battle? Strategically (and as a VET myself) it would make no sense. Plot devices explains why Voyager did the impossible under normal common sense circumstances.
@NANOFORGE If you're gonna use time travel to upgrade Voyager (Endgame), then do the same for the Galaxy class too (All Good Things Come To An End). Don't pit a time enhanced Voyager, loaded with tech that most likely wasn't even standard issue on Intrepids of the future (If they were even still in production by the time Janeway made it to Admiral) against a Picard era Galaxy. Use the Capt. Riker version...Galaxy X, with three nacelles, and Phaser rail canon. Prob called a Type 20 Phaser by then
@NANOFORGE That canon blew ginormous holes THROUGH a Negh'var battleship with SINGLE hits. Right THROUGH the Negh'var's shields as if they weren't even raised. Totally wiped out said Negh'var in five hits. Capable of Warp 13, cloakable, and even though we didn't see it...most likely had Quantum upgrades. Oh, and don't downgrade speculate a Galaxy's torp output. It's a Batlleship, so it will get the top powered torps. Voyager would not under normal conditions, but even if it did..it can't fire 8
@miloootic Galaxy Class top speed Warp 9.6. Intrepid Top Speed Warp 9.9. Not a big difference....and remember, Intrepid is smaller, less mass, lighter, and has newer warp tech than the Galaxies. Still only .3 of a single warp factor increase in speed. Not much...
@Luvcreole they barely could reach 9.6 for 12 hours,in addition size in star trek does not matter,we clearly seen small ships have far more firepower the large ones (defiant,bop,jem'hadar bug ships,prometheus etc...) plus u are talking about mass in space???lol? in space if u generate more power u go faster therefore the ships who have higher warp speed have more powerful cores and more power to use and boost shields and weapons. intrepid is not a light cruiser or whatever other fan info u got
@Idazmi7 we are not gonna keep doing this :) you refuse to listen just coz your fav is the Galaxy XD my fav is Intrepid but i wouldn't say something unrealistic like it being stronger then the Prometheus or Sovereign ...i gave arguments over and over and Voyager has mark 9 warp core the Admiral himself said its more powerful then anything else the fleet has lol...and try to keep the trash talk to a minimum.
Oh man! I wanted Enterprise to win. Good video though. I could tell most of this was from different episodes, but how did you change what appeared on the viewscreen?
I think it would depend on whether Voyager could get in a critical blow before it was hit. It is more maneuverable and has newer tech but the Galaxy class is a monster. If the Enterprise got a decent hit in then I think it would be game over. I don't care as Janeway and Picard are both awesome.
What a clever video. Not really fussed about who would win in theory. I just thought that it was fun. And the advert at the start was hillarious! Cheers mate!
Galaxy are heavy cruisers almost all out battleships Intrepids are long range cruisers more self sustaining but compared to the heavy hitters of the Galaxys they wouldnt stand much of a chance. IE the dominion wars yea I know galaxys were blown out regularly but they were going up against dominion battle ships. So with Data and Geordi the Enterprise would kick Voyagers dorsal shields any day of the week.
@kage1979 Actually, not one Galaxy Class ship was destroyed during the Dominion war. they all survived, granted, we saw some taking some hefty damage. This is canon by the way.
@rossco010 Umm...what about the Odyssey? I do believe it was totalled in the first shots that started the war. By a 24th Century version of the Japanese Zero powered "Divine Wind" aka The kamakaze.
@Luvcreole The Federation wasn't in a declared state of war with the Dominion at the time the Odyssey was destroyed. The Dominion War began in Season 5, Odyssey was destroyed in Season 2.
@rossco010 Technically you're right, but the very act of attacking began the hostilities. It's kinda like Pearl Harbor. We weren't officially at war with Japan when they hit us, but those ships still were considered casualties of war. Just the first. The declaration was just to make it official that war between the U.S. and Japan was in progress.
@Luvcreole Well Pearl Harbour was technically a declaration of war. Why openly declare war when you can just attack by surprise? There's been plenty of incidents of one country attacking another without a state of war being declared. North Korea attacking the south only recently. Plenty of naval battles of the past also.
@kage1979 ah but you are wrong if you play star trek online you will know that science vessels like voyager can easily take out cruisers while escorts take out science this is because science vessels have more ability while cruisers are all about power and thus voyager out skills enterprise.
Voyager would have definatley won, the Galaxy's inferior technology made it less quick and smart then Voyager, which utilizes the latest Warp Core, more effective photons, Bio-neural gell packs, and the most awesumest captain ever! lol.
@FleetAdmiral08 Yeah, and while a "Arleigh Burke" class Destroyer is more advanced than even the updated Iowa class WW2 era Batlleships Wisconsin, New Jersey, or Iowa...you don't suppose the Arleigh Burke would stand a chance against any one of those battle wagons, right?
absolutely brilliant editing.......but ill tell you THIS, unless it was a large natural chested beauty, i woulda STRANGLED that msn contact for ruining my vid lol. had to rewind it to make sure i wasnt nuts......my msn wasnt even open lol
Despite the high-tech enhancements on Voyager, it really depends on what an Intrepid class starship is design for and is capable of versus what a base line Galaxy class platform is design for and capable of. My laptop is two years younger than my desktop and cost a bit more, but capability-wise my desktop still beats the heck out of my laptop.
Anyway, good video! Very smooth cuts that told an easy to follow story.
I have a few more comments for this video: it was very well made the scenes from other episodes, the only two things that bugged me were that riker somehow came back to life after one second. also that captain janeway and captain picard were great friends hmm does that give you something to think about?
In my opinion (I'm only saying this because The Enterprise D is my favorite star trek ship) I think in a real fight since the Enterprise D would have won the fight between the USS Voyager but that's my opinion
Actually I think youre right, the enterprise is the most advanced and acurate ship, the Voyager is not match for the Enterprise, also the Voyager was in te other side of the galaxy for YEARS the enteprise had a more modern version.
But give the USS Voyager it due it may not be the biggest ship in the Star Trek Series but as the saying goes it's not the size of the dog in the fight but it's the size of the fight in the dog the USS Voyager has had battle where they were outgunned
The USS Enterprise D is a Galaxy Class Ship The USS Voyager is a Intrepid Class Ship so the bottom line the Enterprise D would have been more powerful interms of Speed, Shields and Weapons
That's not entirely accurate...Voyager was the fastest ship built in 2371 (top cruising speed warp 9.975), bioneural circuitry (instead of the outdated isolinear chips on Enterprise-D), and Voyager would be more maneuverable as it is smaller (remember the smaller the ship the easier it is to maneuver; picture a speedboat and an aircraft carrier...sure the carrier has brute force, but it can't hit a small, fast target with much precision)...
I see your point and you do bring up some good points and if you were to have a Ford Mustang Cobra take on a VW Beestle you know that the Ford Mustang Cobra is the fastest between the two
But you have to remember that the Enterprise D could have the Saucer half split so it would turn into a two on one battle
But both ships are two of my favorites it just I grew up with the Next Generation so I have to go for my favorite ship I have three different verisons of the ship in my collection
Having the saucer split would be a horrible idea, they have no real power without the warp core, and now they'll need shields for two ships, while losing most of the power to their main phasers.
The two ships are comparable in weapons, but the edge goes to Voyager with speed and size, along with better technology and power systems on the ship.
I see now without the warp core the Enterprise D would be powerless, while we all been talking about Voyager and Enterprise D and their main phasers, warp core, warp speed, and the techonology of the respected ships we shoud throw in their captains
Captain Jean Luc Picard and Captain Kathryn Janeway we should threw in their skills and leadership in the battle
good point...also remember voyager was armed with Tricobalt devices....or....transphasic torpedoes and ablative hull armor....it also picked up a lot of Borg enhancements in the Delta Quadrant...i think voyager was more than a match for Enterprise
You are intitle to your opinion if you take what both captains went through like Picard becoming a borg as well as Janeway but still the two captains have face no win battles and still use great leadership
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Voyager was a product of bad writing and a dying franchise. They made up so many stupid techs and aliens to try and make the show survive that they turned it into a joke. Voyager is a lightweight, and its technology was at best a couple of years newer, but not more powerful. Its like pitting a 60s muscle car with 350 HP against a 2009 Corolla with an MP3 player. Enterprise would have taken damage, but would have obliterated VGR.
No bra, Voyager was more advanced than Entrerprise D. her armament was better aswell. Same with sheilding. with the borg upgrades and upgrades from a future time line, Voyager could have taken on half the Federation fleet and won.
What episodes? TNG: any shots where the crew has the shiny belts are from "Yesterday's Enterprise." The shots at the end where the ship blows up were from "Cause and Effect." The Voyager shots with the line of explosions on the top were from "Year of Hell." Not sure about the rest.
That was so good ! I would have give you 5 stars ! only one negative point. I heard your Msn messenger sometimes at the backround a little bit shame though but still giving you 5 points !!! Good work !!
This has been flagged as spam show
lol 00:01
carlos1rrr111 1 month ago
I think that Voyager would win... (let's take a comparison of tactical's just in case)
Galaxy class (USS Enterprise-D): 10 phaser arrays, 2 torpedo launchers (fore and aft), 250 photon torpedoes, high capacity deflector shield grid
Intrepid class (USS Voyager): 18 phasers (14 phaser arrays, 4 (additional, seperate) phaser emitters), 5 torpedo launchers (2 fore, 2 aft, 1 dorsal), 2 tricobalt devices, spatial charges, a dozen of transphasic torpedes, deflector shields, ablative hull armour
theemrpoint123 2 months ago
@theemrpoint123 The Galaxy class can fire ten torpedoes per second, nonstop, has a better shield grid, carries more antimatter (which poweres the phasers) and 500+ torpedoes. And it destroyed a Borg Cube without upgrades.
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
Voyager may have less Torpedoes but her are far more advanced mark 6 instead of mark 4 used by galaxy. there is no way in hell a galaxy has better shields,Voy shields survived beating from a tactical cube,Galaxy class shields got drained in 25 seconds exactly by a normal cube in Best of Both worlds. and if it has a more powerful core why cant i go faster ? LOL ill give you some time to think about it ;)
miloootic 2 weeks ago
@miloootic The Borg suck in Voyager. The couldn't adapt to crap, ever, and they even had a civil war. How does a COLLECTIVE HIVE have a civil war?
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
@Idazmi7 watch Unimatrix 0 and you will know. the problem is you criticize without watching the series kinda makes you ...
miloootic 2 weeks ago
@miloootic The one with the Borg living free in a subroutine? What was so amazing about a hole in the Borg program? I watch every Star Trek: Voyager and Enterprise included.
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
i new voyager would win it was thrown across the galaxy got new tec better sheads and better captain :D
mrmax2580 5 months ago
Riker Died but in the next second he back alive!?!?!?!?
borghome 6 months ago
comcast and the borg formed an alliance and gave us msn
kellyberry 11 months ago
I prefer Voyager over TNG but the enterprise is more than a match for Voyager.
Salvatore403 1 year ago
2:00
Chakotay got a message on msn!
me80822 1 year ago
voyager: heavy shields,modified and adapted borg tech,more tech overall newest class bio neural gel packs...14 phasers,massive speed and engine mobility. proof episodes: year of hell,unimatrix 0,dragons teeth,night...
e-D: massive size,10 phasers,massive structural integrity,compliment 250 photon torpedoes,crew compliment 1000 (increase repairs and damage controll)...
well both ships are verry strong and 2 of the best capt,but voy will evade hits and disable galaxy class fast...voy ftw :D
miloootic 1 year ago
thats what happens when you go on msn too much and your a starship captain :(
hawkmoth11 1 year ago
Geordi has sex with the warp core
Austindude3954 1 year ago
My two favorite star trek series :D Voyager is more modern and is almost better at everything. Even the uniform and interior of voyager is nicer.
TKproductionsTK 1 year ago
Maybe if pacard wasn't chatting to happyribbonsladygirl05 they would of won :P
ssxcdave1 1 year ago
Since when Janeway could beat Picard?
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod since forever
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic So, is that why Picard was the one who took command of SF in the Battle of Sector 001 and not her? Janeway wasn't in Delta quadrant yet AFAIR. Not to mention she got kicked upstairs while Picard is too proud to step down from his starship.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod what the hell are u talkin about,janeway wasent at the battle of sector 001...picard outrank her at that time...she was involved in the dominion war at that time...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic So Janeway was too busy at the Dominion War but Picard somehow wasn't because of unrevealed reasons? May I remind you that ALL of SF had to do with that war and the Ent-D/E crew was no exception? How did Picard outrank Janeway? They were both Captains, and no captain outranks another captain, no matter what ship are we talking about. You do not know if Janeway was there or not, but it wouldn't have mattered anyway. FC Borg would have annihilated her ship anyway. VOY borg are plotholes
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod rofl,um do you know that in a combat situation involving many captains cammand falls in the hands of the ship with superior tactical ability...in sector 001 sovereign is the most powerful...and if ur talkin about janeways potentiel u should watch star trek nemesis,janeway made admiral before picard so shes pretty good. he outranks her at that time ugh omg just go search for the stardates...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic So I guess that must be why Picard took FORCEFULLY command of SF? That policy doesn't have anything to do with ranks. Picard still didn't outrank Janeway, yet he was so much more badass no one dared to dispute his leadership. And I tell you again, SF promoted Janeway to admiral because they didn't want her to take another starship ever, but they couldn't kick her out, so they kicked her upstairs. Meanwhile Picard ALWAYS refused his promotion, and that has been stated too many times.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod again u still dont understand...this is an army,a space army,they have rules and regulations,no one disputed his leadership becoz thats the rule,hes ship is the superior tactical vessel...the other part of your comment has nothing to do with logic and proof,its just your personel opinion...it seems ur another picard fan boy...
in addition janeway was made admiral(when ur admiral u dont lose ur ship as u stated above) coz she made first contact with over 100s of new species
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic No. When Harriman took command of the Ent-B, he was outranked by a retired Captain of a DECOMISSIONED, LESSER starship just because he happened to be a leader. If the captain is a douché, it doesn't matter if his ship is the strongest, he will get not any authority whatsoever. Your supposed policies have never been stated onscreen. And yes, Janeway didn't lose her ship, but she lost almost the entire crew. That's worse, so they kicked her upstairs. And Picard/Kirk met more species.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod janeway lost her entire crew????rofl where did that come from? ur fabulating about picard/kirk so u just say whatever... she lost a few crewmen but that was minimal casualties...im pretty sure u have 0 proof about that. kicked upstairs???u keep repeating that....stating the same flawed argument doesent make it right...again u have 0 proof...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic I take it you never watched the VOY premiere? The crew you saw during the series WASN'T the crew Janeway used to have before the series. They were wiped out. Did Kirk lose his crew? No. Did Picard lose his crew? No! And the major consensus AGREES that Janeway was promoted to prevent her from commanding another starship EVER. Deal with it!
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod again ur wrong voyager in the episode caretaker lost like 20 crewman that was it,u should really go back and watch the series....they were replaced with maquis (most of the maquis are former starfleet enlisted)
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic YOU just saw 20 guys because your TV won't be enough to show a ship's population of 600+ people, don't be stupid. And the fact you're telling me that she replaced them with maquis anyway actually helps my point, not yours.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod ok im through arguing with you...your information about trek cannon is 0. an intrepid class (voyager) has a crew compliment of 150-200 max ok??? ugh we get it picard was good im not negating that,but janeway was an amazing captain,she was so determined,followed the rules and protocols,broke the prime directive to protect the crew,was willing to sacrifice herself on many occasions....im not gonna talk about janeway anymore coz u never watched voyager so its useless to talk.
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic It seems you don't get sarcasm. It doesn't matter if VOY's crew was 200 or 2000, they won't be shown on TV EVER. BTW, nice description of mentioning whatever is expected of your average starfleet captain as if it somehow were some of Janeway's merits. It was her freaking job!
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod she also made first allinance with the borg,charted star maps for an unexplored quadrant...she accomplished far more then he did,thats why...she admiral now hes not.
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic The VOY borg act completely OoC and are Deus Ex Machina plot devices or complete tools, and the charting of starmaps of unexplored quadrants WAS her fucking job, which ARCHER had done before. And need I remind you Picard REJECTED admiralship ON SCREEN during GENERATIONS because when KIRK told him to, he said that he ALREADY had done so! Your selective memory sucks bigtime.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod ok ok picard rejected admiralship...so? is that supposed to be an argument? archer charted star maps.yes he did,but not in the delta quadrant...you have issues understanding what an uncharted,unexplored quadrant means....again u dont understand,ill rephrase what was said on screen in a star trek episode called equinox, in a combat situation involving multiple captains,cammand of the task force falls into the hands of the ship with tactical superiority...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic That's assuming the captain is qualified to take control. What if ENSIGN RICKY had been in command of Ent-E? Do you really think they would have let him take command of StarFleet? No, right? Your example fails horribly.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod any person to reach the rank of captain is qualified...and yes enseign whatever must have command expirience in order to be a senior bridge officer...if i can put a child on a sovereign class assult cruiser and tell it to push one button and fire a spread of quantum torpedoes on a weak inferior miranda class commanded by kirk he would get crushed....doesent matter whos commanding,if i were to have a race with a pro cyclist using my car and hes bike i would win...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic No. You might not remember when Crusher was left in command of Ent-D. All of her emergency crew were unexperienced noobs. So your point is null. What happens when you get your car to race against a pro cyclist but you crash your car against a tree, the cyclist would win ROFLing the entire time. Such a driver happens to be like Janeway.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod lets take for example,uss voyager,uss enterprise e,and a nebula class,all with 3 captains,and 2 romulan warbirds enter fed space,in this case the captain of the enterprise takes command of the fleet becoz hes vessel is a sovereign class assult cruiser supperior weapons capacity then an intrepid and a nebula....got it now....judging by your comments and your lack of cannon,and logical,information involving the show,i assume you never watched star trek voyager or ds9...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic Again, if Mr. RICKY is in control of Ent-E because Picard had malaria that day, Riker was honeymooning, Data asploded, Dr. Crusher was in the med school and Worf/Geordi were trying to prevent the entire SF from being wiped out, nobody in their right mind would let him to take control of the entire fleet. I think it is you who saw the series, but didn't really pay attention nor have too much of a common sense.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod u just watched a few movies of star trek as it seems...and the borg barely appeared on screen only a few episode on generations...it was voyager that allowed us to understand the borg hierachie/the hive mind...so many episode in stv involved the borg and had the highest rating on tv...ratings went up evry time the borg appeared on voy,that was stated by the writers....the uss voyager made first contact with new aliens species,and just to give you proof go watch star trek episode
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic No. VOY derailed the Borg characters horribly, and that's a major consensus. The hive mind was established in FC (you never saw it). And LOL @ comparing VOY's ratings to TNG's.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod the hive mind,was established in
FC yes but it was never develloped,the entire borg perspective was revealed during voyager....we never saw any borg planets prior to scorpion episodes,we never saw any borg ships but cubes...in voy we saw probes,tactical cubes,queens ship....etc TNG was good of course it was but it was just plain boring sometimes...u barely saw any action or tactical situations....voy was far more active and exciting.
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic How did the hive mind concept needed to be developed? A hive mind is a hive mind, plain and simple. VOY tried to make the borg become the next ferengi. And VOY wasn't anything but a blatant fanservice show, nothing was as deep as in TNG, TOS or DS9.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod called friendship one,and admiral and a starfleet proffesor stated that voy made the highest amount of first contact even more then james t.kirk......im not in the mood to continu this useless conversation...go watch more trek then argue...all your arguments lack coherent logic and cannon info...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic Of course if you are stuck 70 years away from home you have to meet more species, if you didn't you would suck at your job. Now, I'm not saying Janeway sucks period because that's not true. I'm saying Picard and Kirk are much much more qualified and better captains than her and THAT'S AN UNDISPUTED FACT.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
@MasterMacLeod how is that a fact???? that was never stated anywhere but in your opinion...
miloootic 1 year ago
@miloootic Just ask anybody on the street. Maybe a police officer. Or your mom/dad. And BTW I suggest you read CAREFULLY Picard's bio at Startrek.com and pay attention to what happened in 2364. Picard is better than the rest, and only Kirk comes close. Deal with it.
MasterMacLeod 1 year ago
LOL @ MSN Instant Messenger Alert on 4:00 !!!
ROVER25X 1 year ago
Riker was smoking magic marijuana right before he died.
Hedgehogstudioss 1 year ago
Voyager was a more tech advanced but smaller but i still think enterprise wouldn't stand much chance against voyager
stanic123 1 year ago
dont u kno whats funny u dont have to watch this video at all to know that voyager will win cause in all the voyager sceries voyger never gets destroyed damaged but keeps goin and interprise had to be self dectructed in a lot of epesodes/moiies
asdfgty6 1 year ago
I saw that Riker was alive in next seen yeah but why Voyager wins all the time?? but they did take heavy damage,, where is Enterprise Vengence?hmmmm seems it should come about again since that was there time loop . what does everyone else think???good video anyways
darian1968 1 year ago
uh, No. enterprise would crush voyager. and picard would crush that WOMAN
Indabaz 1 year ago
No stars, the Enterprise D would shove the Delta flyer up Voyagers ass and picard and riker would screw janeway
Blopdomia 1 year ago
did anyone hear? toyota built the enterpriseD
kellyberry 1 year ago
cool video!! thanks for entering!!
Jackie0516 1 year ago
ROFLMFAO!!!!! You guys crack me up with all of your arguing over which ship would win. XD
darthgreivous 1 year ago
Just watch the episode "The Survivors" and see what could Ent-D can unleash...the scene is shown in the related vids under Ent-D fights husnock. Sorry...VGR went off the rails in season 4, and the writers just started throwin everything but the kitchen sink into the story. Ent-D OWNS VGR any any battle thats based in reality...
BrandisLee 1 year ago
@BrandisLee ahem..."reality"???
were still talking about a sci-fi show that plays almost 400 years in the future right? ^^
Darky91939 1 year ago
@Darky91939 Oh yeah!!!...I just got that....damn...thank you for reminding me! Can you send me a book on how to be clever like you?!?
BrandisLee 1 year ago
Lastly "Ent D was destroyed by an old BOP while fighting with everything it had...VGR took on GOD and the prophets with no shields and survived without a bit of Janeway's hair outa place!"
First...If you count, during "Generations"...Ent-D took between 18 and 20 direct hits with no shields, including to the engines. (those were just the ones we could see and hear) Thats pretty good since we dont know the true output of the klingon weapons or of the enemies that attacked VGR.
BrandisLee 1 year ago
Oh yeah, there is more...
"VGR has more advance power systems and survived in the Delta Quadrant"
Thats called WRITING. If it had been Ent-D out there, exact same thing. As far as the power. Episode "Booby Trap", Ent D had its energy sucked outa it for almost a day, til there was almost none left. As soon as force doing it was neutralized, Ent D powered right back up and unleased a torpedo salvo, a large one.
VGR spent most of the first season trying to get its power back. OWNED
BrandisLee 1 year ago
LOVE the VGR fanboys and their delusions. "VGR has 13 phaser banks to Ent-Ds 12!"
Yeah, since the two main phaser arrays on Ent-D could wrap around VGR twice. Each bank is hundreds of individual emitters. Ent-D OWNS VGR.
"VGR has four torpedo lanuchers to Ent D's two"
Yeah, and Ent D can fire as many as 8 (canon) or 10 (Tech manl) at a time. Vgr's has NEVER shown to fire more than single bursts alternating between the two tubes either front or back. OWNED
BrandisLee 1 year ago
Niice... Voyager sustained heavy damage... but at least they won :D
CDRIeuan 1 year ago
I call BS !!!!!!!!!No way Intrepid class even competes with galaxy wtf???have you even played any of the games ?? Intrepid class not even close to excelsior
mikekobbler 1 year ago
@mikekobbler Hm, for a start Voyager is equipped with 13 T-X Phasers. However Voyagers Phasers can only generate half of the damage the Galaxy classes due to power limitations. The Galaxy class was armed with 12 T-X Phasers. However Voyager had 4 Lauchers and the E-D had just 3 Lauchers. Voyager also endured months of punishment from weapons that could penetrate her shields. The E-D got it's ass kicked by a 20 Year old BoP that could penetrate it's shields. Voyager beats Galaxy.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
The result: A small, deep space explorer with similar tactical and offensive capabilities to the Galaxy class (most likely pre-dominion war standards) while having superior sensors and scientific equipment. Overall, the capabilities will be limited to crew size, however the computing power, advanced dilithium swirl reacion chamber (basically the whole core is a reaction chamber), tactical and offensive capbailities were not hurt by having a smaller crew.
bboi83 1 year ago
i've read some of these posts and to that i can reply: The Intrepid class ship was designed as a smaller, easier to build counterpart to the Galaxy class. The idea was to use the latest in Federation technology to create a smaller ship with larger ship capabilities that can be produced on a mass scale. Another reason for the downsize in size is to increase overall speed.
bboi83 1 year ago
Yeah :D I like watching all Star Trek series and movies, but to be honest with ya Enterprise D have no match for Voyager and will easy be destroy, but this movie are taken by other clips believe me and it's not a real fight :p If it did goodbye Enterprise D
MoodMan35 1 year ago
Vivat Voyager!
atomotamerikara 1 year ago
The Enterprise D is just not as tough of a ship. When Voyager was attacked for weeks by the Krenim who could penetrate their shields Voyager managed to survive attack after attack. The Enterprise D ran into one pos Klingon Bird of Prey that could penetrate its shields and it was destroyed. Voyager would kick the Enterprise D's ass because it is just a way tougher ship.
leonmelnicoff 1 year ago
What's the episode where you see Voyager dropping out of warp @ 00.58 ?
Thanks.
NCC1701J 1 year ago
Even without the Borg enhansments to voyager, it would have 1. Intrepid class are smooth, swift and deadly. Galaxy class are slow, not so dangerous to a intrepid class ship. Voyager would win anyday without Borg technology Brillo vid
TKproductionsTK 1 year ago
Voyagers the fastest ship and is way better than the ugly enterprise with that ugly captain. Jainway is the best, she got her crew home
TKproductionsTK 1 year ago
I was going to say good video but no... The video is horrible. Voyager would get obliterated... Enterprise is a superior ship and Picard is a million times a better captain.
AchillesxHero 1 year ago
good battle, although if this had taken place during endgame lol one transphasic torpedo from Voyager oughta do it lol
cwag123321 1 year ago
dude freakin awesome
Creaturehugs 1 year ago
well done gr8
LeeJay07701 2 years ago
great video!!!!!
OskarSkywalker501 2 years ago
Yeah...but less yak,more splat
Dalbert342 2 years ago
oh god people are so dam stupid,galaxy class are slower then intrepid a lot slower. galaxy might have larger torpedo compliment and is bigger then voyager but voyager has bio-neural gel packs, extrem agility, and as seen in many episodes,voyager has amazing durability in battle ( unimatrix 0 borg tactical cube, year of hell....). voyager ftw. people who based their opinons on games like st bc or legacy would say enterprise but in the real deal its voyager.
miloootic 2 years ago
Actuallly A Galaxy class as alot more fire power. Intrepid class ships are faster and have better shields and much more accurate sensors. When it comes down to it though Voyager has the advantage since it has been upgraded with Borg Technology. You are completely correct, The Enterprise may be larger and better in battle but then you have Voyager from Endgame..
NANOFORGE 2 years ago
@NANOFORGE Ignore my last comment, turns out Voyager actually has more firepower than a Galaxy Class. Voyager was also armed with 13 Type-X Phaser arrays aswell. The Ent-D was only armed with 12 of those. Voyager is also armed with Class-6 Torps that have a max yeild of 512 Megatons which can fire from 4 Lauchers. The Ent-D's Torps only had a max of 64 Megatons and could only fire from 3 Launchers. Voyager > Enteprise-D.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
@NANOFORGE at a time PER launcher. In a burst all at once (5 to 6), or a long rapid string of them. Voyager can alternate port/starboard one shot at a time for a max spread of 4. You've got to realize, there are reasons for classifications of warships based off of size and power. Intrepids are Light Cruisers. Akira's are Cruisers, sometimes called Heavy Cruisers. Galaxy's are Battleships and so are Sovereigns. Defiant on DS9 is called a "Destroyer", but is a full warship. Starships are weaker.
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@NANOFORGE Starships are weaker vessels in each class than their warship counterparts. A Cruiser starship will not be as powerful as a Cruiser warship. Otherwise, why bother differentiating the two? Why was Defiant designed ground up as a warship where as Voyager wasn't if Voyager was better in a battle? Strategically (and as a VET myself) it would make no sense. Plot devices explains why Voyager did the impossible under normal common sense circumstances.
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@NANOFORGE If you're gonna use time travel to upgrade Voyager (Endgame), then do the same for the Galaxy class too (All Good Things Come To An End). Don't pit a time enhanced Voyager, loaded with tech that most likely wasn't even standard issue on Intrepids of the future (If they were even still in production by the time Janeway made it to Admiral) against a Picard era Galaxy. Use the Capt. Riker version...Galaxy X, with three nacelles, and Phaser rail canon. Prob called a Type 20 Phaser by then
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@NANOFORGE That canon blew ginormous holes THROUGH a Negh'var battleship with SINGLE hits. Right THROUGH the Negh'var's shields as if they weren't even raised. Totally wiped out said Negh'var in five hits. Capable of Warp 13, cloakable, and even though we didn't see it...most likely had Quantum upgrades. Oh, and don't downgrade speculate a Galaxy's torp output. It's a Batlleship, so it will get the top powered torps. Voyager would not under normal conditions, but even if it did..it can't fire 8
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@miloootic Galaxy Class top speed Warp 9.6. Intrepid Top Speed Warp 9.9. Not a big difference....and remember, Intrepid is smaller, less mass, lighter, and has newer warp tech than the Galaxies. Still only .3 of a single warp factor increase in speed. Not much...
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@Luvcreole they barely could reach 9.6 for 12 hours,in addition size in star trek does not matter,we clearly seen small ships have far more firepower the large ones (defiant,bop,jem'hadar bug ships,prometheus etc...) plus u are talking about mass in space???lol? in space if u generate more power u go faster therefore the ships who have higher warp speed have more powerful cores and more power to use and boost shields and weapons. intrepid is not a light cruiser or whatever other fan info u got
miloootic 3 months ago
@miloootic Actually, the Intrepid is inferior to everything until they get dues-ex upgrades.
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
@Idazmi7 we are not gonna keep doing this :) you refuse to listen just coz your fav is the Galaxy XD my fav is Intrepid but i wouldn't say something unrealistic like it being stronger then the Prometheus or Sovereign ...i gave arguments over and over and Voyager has mark 9 warp core the Admiral himself said its more powerful then anything else the fleet has lol...and try to keep the trash talk to a minimum.
miloootic 2 weeks ago
@miloootic And my fav is the Constitution.
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
@Luvcreole Agreed. @milotoooic is just butthurt at fandom sizes.
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
lol at 1:58 you hear the MSN messenger sound cuz he's using a PCI tuner :D
coma9 2 years ago
Oh man! I wanted Enterprise to win. Good video though. I could tell most of this was from different episodes, but how did you change what appeared on the viewscreen?
ExtremeFaithInJesus 2 years ago
Hah, good stuff. Though you killed Riker and brought him back. Was sorta funny. Otherwise, nice attempt.
Spideymun 2 years ago
It's Riker's twin!
Sismiques 2 years ago
I think it would depend on whether Voyager could get in a critical blow before it was hit. It is more maneuverable and has newer tech but the Galaxy class is a monster. If the Enterprise got a decent hit in then I think it would be game over. I don't care as Janeway and Picard are both awesome.
vadershelmet 2 years ago
Best comment on this vid I have read so far . I concur with you that it would depend on multiple factors .
cameltowr1 2 years ago
What a clever video. Not really fussed about who would win in theory. I just thought that it was fun. And the advert at the start was hillarious! Cheers mate!
Servodude1 2 years ago
Galaxy are heavy cruisers almost all out battleships Intrepids are long range cruisers more self sustaining but compared to the heavy hitters of the Galaxys they wouldnt stand much of a chance. IE the dominion wars yea I know galaxys were blown out regularly but they were going up against dominion battle ships. So with Data and Geordi the Enterprise would kick Voyagers dorsal shields any day of the week.
kage1979 2 years ago 4
@kage1979 Actually, not one Galaxy Class ship was destroyed during the Dominion war. they all survived, granted, we saw some taking some hefty damage. This is canon by the way.
rossco010 1 year ago
@rossco010 Umm...what about the Odyssey? I do believe it was totalled in the first shots that started the war. By a 24th Century version of the Japanese Zero powered "Divine Wind" aka The kamakaze.
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@Luvcreole The Federation wasn't in a declared state of war with the Dominion at the time the Odyssey was destroyed. The Dominion War began in Season 5, Odyssey was destroyed in Season 2.
rossco010 5 months ago
@rossco010 Technically you're right, but the very act of attacking began the hostilities. It's kinda like Pearl Harbor. We weren't officially at war with Japan when they hit us, but those ships still were considered casualties of war. Just the first. The declaration was just to make it official that war between the U.S. and Japan was in progress.
Luvcreole 5 months ago
@Luvcreole Well Pearl Harbour was technically a declaration of war. Why openly declare war when you can just attack by surprise? There's been plenty of incidents of one country attacking another without a state of war being declared. North Korea attacking the south only recently. Plenty of naval battles of the past also.
rossco010 5 months ago
@kage1979 ah but you are wrong if you play star trek online you will know that science vessels like voyager can easily take out cruisers while escorts take out science this is because science vessels have more ability while cruisers are all about power and thus voyager out skills enterprise.
bgrs123 8 months ago
this is not good......
dspikey 2 years ago
Voyager would have definatley won, the Galaxy's inferior technology made it less quick and smart then Voyager, which utilizes the latest Warp Core, more effective photons, Bio-neural gell packs, and the most awesumest captain ever! lol.
cwag123321 2 years ago
No the Intrepid Class is a substitute to the Galaxy Class. The battle should be a tie.
DazhFX 2 years ago
i think the enterprise d would win becouse its bigger than voyager
jakel950 2 years ago
That was actually pretty good. I personally would have had Paris make an off-hand remark before Picard declared war.
Juptile 2 years ago
2:00 fail I heard MSN
3:20 riker is alive after dying?!?! WTF!
4:00 msn fail again
Otherwise epic!
I thought the enterprise would've won?
sonicisback 2 years ago 2
MSN killded the Ent makes perfect sense to me;)
cjrciadt 2 years ago 13
rofl Riker just died then he came back to life.
froobie45 2 years ago
maybe it was Thomas Riker lol
mirataku1 2 years ago
One word, spectacular!
FleetAdmiral08 2 years ago
Aculy the Enterprise Went Warp ?
To The other side of the universe
dur
JimmyJames81196 2 years ago
this is great!!! =D
you just missed 1 thing, first you let Riker die around 3:14. then at 3:18 he's alive and at his post. just so u know. =]
Elanor2001 2 years ago 3
Are you kidding me ?
These trashship called Voyager wouldn´t have any chance against the Enterprise D !
Booo !
XD
Hashakgig 2 years ago
You're forgetting one major thing... Voyager is more advanced than the Enterprise-D,
FleetAdmiral08 2 years ago
Whatever ! xD
Hashakgig 2 years ago
It is. Just look at the registry. They've also got gel-packs, which Galaxy classes don't, they have better offensive and defensive systems etc.
Also, one thing that stands out to me is that Kathryn is a better Captain (seen as though she made Admiral way before Jean did).
FleetAdmiral08 2 years ago
I Agree with that!
Animeextreme25 2 years ago
@FleetAdmiral08 Yeah, and while a "Arleigh Burke" class Destroyer is more advanced than even the updated Iowa class WW2 era Batlleships Wisconsin, New Jersey, or Iowa...you don't suppose the Arleigh Burke would stand a chance against any one of those battle wagons, right?
Luvcreole 5 months ago
Lol at the "open a channel point"
ECAaxel 2 years ago 2
In a real fight, a Galaxy Class would destroy an Intrepid Class hands down, it just depends whether Voyager had the Borg upgrades...
LazyMatt0391 2 years ago
Picard's sheer epicness will cause every torpedo on the Voyager to spontaneously explode. Data's will cause the warpcore to go supercritical.
mitthrawnuruodo666 2 years ago
Lol, well said! xD
LazyMatt0391 2 years ago
absolutely brilliant editing.......but ill tell you THIS, unless it was a large natural chested beauty, i woulda STRANGLED that msn contact for ruining my vid lol. had to rewind it to make sure i wasnt nuts......my msn wasnt even open lol
IMDARKFIRE007 2 years ago
Despite the high-tech enhancements on Voyager, it really depends on what an Intrepid class starship is design for and is capable of versus what a base line Galaxy class platform is design for and capable of. My laptop is two years younger than my desktop and cost a bit more, but capability-wise my desktop still beats the heck out of my laptop.
Anyway, good video! Very smooth cuts that told an easy to follow story.
jarkoer 2 years ago
voyager would win because it is a newer class of starship than enterprise
legoboyABC 2 years ago
voyager would win really because you can't kill what you can't hit
LukeAlexanderMartin 2 years ago
I have a few more comments for this video: it was very well made the scenes from other episodes, the only two things that bugged me were that riker somehow came back to life after one second. also that captain janeway and captain picard were great friends hmm does that give you something to think about?
capoteo96 2 years ago
*Riker dies in a plasma coil explosion* *Next scene Riker is alive again!* LOL
EvergrimofSeraph 2 years ago 11
It's because he's magic!
lol
=]
trekky74205 2 years ago 4
@trekky74205 Riker is now down to 4 respawns
jamest35 1 year ago
its the same with janeway
KISSKID987 2 years ago
@EvergrimofSeraph its the sex appeal
Coldmystery 1 year ago
In my opinion (I'm only saying this because The Enterprise D is my favorite star trek ship) I think in a real fight since the Enterprise D would have won the fight between the USS Voyager but that's my opinion
Terryfan 2 years ago 2
Actually I think youre right, the enterprise is the most advanced and acurate ship, the Voyager is not match for the Enterprise, also the Voyager was in te other side of the galaxy for YEARS the enteprise had a more modern version.
capoteo96 2 years ago 2
But give the USS Voyager it due it may not be the biggest ship in the Star Trek Series but as the saying goes it's not the size of the dog in the fight but it's the size of the fight in the dog the USS Voyager has had battle where they were outgunned
The USS Enterprise D is a Galaxy Class Ship The USS Voyager is a Intrepid Class Ship so the bottom line the Enterprise D would have been more powerful interms of Speed, Shields and Weapons
Terryfan 2 years ago
That's not entirely accurate...Voyager was the fastest ship built in 2371 (top cruising speed warp 9.975), bioneural circuitry (instead of the outdated isolinear chips on Enterprise-D), and Voyager would be more maneuverable as it is smaller (remember the smaller the ship the easier it is to maneuver; picture a speedboat and an aircraft carrier...sure the carrier has brute force, but it can't hit a small, fast target with much precision)...
Anyway, my 2 cents!
gamerstud45 2 years ago
I see your point and you do bring up some good points and if you were to have a Ford Mustang Cobra take on a VW Beestle you know that the Ford Mustang Cobra is the fastest between the two
But you have to remember that the Enterprise D could have the Saucer half split so it would turn into a two on one battle
But both ships are two of my favorites it just I grew up with the Next Generation so I have to go for my favorite ship I have three different verisons of the ship in my collection
Terryfan 2 years ago
Having the saucer split would be a horrible idea, they have no real power without the warp core, and now they'll need shields for two ships, while losing most of the power to their main phasers.
The two ships are comparable in weapons, but the edge goes to Voyager with speed and size, along with better technology and power systems on the ship.
AllAlone0 2 years ago
I see now without the warp core the Enterprise D would be powerless, while we all been talking about Voyager and Enterprise D and their main phasers, warp core, warp speed, and the techonology of the respected ships we shoud throw in their captains
Captain Jean Luc Picard and Captain Kathryn Janeway we should threw in their skills and leadership in the battle
Terryfan 2 years ago
good point...also remember voyager was armed with Tricobalt devices....or....transphasic torpedoes and ablative hull armor....it also picked up a lot of Borg enhancements in the Delta Quadrant...i think voyager was more than a match for Enterprise
intrepidgalaxy 2 years ago
You are intitle to your opinion if you take what both captains went through like Picard becoming a borg as well as Janeway but still the two captains have face no win battles and still use great leadership
Terryfan 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Voyager was a product of bad writing and a dying franchise. They made up so many stupid techs and aliens to try and make the show survive that they turned it into a joke. Voyager is a lightweight, and its technology was at best a couple of years newer, but not more powerful. Its like pitting a 60s muscle car with 350 HP against a 2009 Corolla with an MP3 player. Enterprise would have taken damage, but would have obliterated VGR.
BrandisLee 2 years ago
Comment removed
kage1979 2 years ago
Using Sony Vegas Pro, it lets you basically play about with videos so you can produce different effects etc
trekky74205 2 years ago
24th century warp cores suck. one hit oh no we have a coolant leak. LOL
hoppers001 2 years ago 4
I like how Janeway turns into the doctor.. I heard that MSN sound and thought it was mine. Anyways this is pretty awesome
09TailedNarutoFox 3 years ago 2
I like how Commander Riker dies one minute and he's back behind the captain the next. LoL
Vampslayer420 3 years ago 9
Lol he's magic ;)
trekky74205 3 years ago
A wizard did it :P
ExplodingConsole 3 years ago 2
crap enterprise D would kick voyager ass
liammmcool 3 years ago 2
No bra, Voyager was more advanced than Entrerprise D. her armament was better aswell. Same with sheilding. with the borg upgrades and upgrades from a future time line, Voyager could have taken on half the Federation fleet and won.
TheLastHashman 2 years ago
yep... voyager rocks, and he would take out enterprise D, but it would not have a chance against enterprise E... my opinion
CptIgor 2 years ago
Janeway sounds pissed at 2:04
P.S. It's good for a beta
P.S.S. I would love to make one of these types of videos. Could you possibly show me how?
peperghost 3 years ago
Yeah sure thing, it's easy enough when you get the hang of it. I'm about to start work on another one. Any suggestions? =]
trekky74205 3 years ago
Woot you go Janeway!! :D 5/5
fiberglassboy 3 years ago
What episodes are they from TNG?
trekaniser 3 years ago
What episodes? TNG: any shots where the crew has the shiny belts are from "Yesterday's Enterprise." The shots at the end where the ship blows up were from "Cause and Effect." The Voyager shots with the line of explosions on the top were from "Year of Hell." Not sure about the rest.
HarmonicWave 3 years ago
That was so good ! I would have give you 5 stars ! only one negative point. I heard your Msn messenger sometimes at the backround a little bit shame though but still giving you 5 points !!! Good work !!
Darkjunior224 3 years ago
Thanks allot :D Never noticed that MSN noise till i uploaded it lol =]
trekky74205 3 years ago