While I agree that Idina Menzel has more powerful vocals, I like Eden Espinsoa's emotion better. I don't see Eden performing but Maureen's frustration with Joanne.
Angel has OFFICIALLY begun dieing in this part.... Or, as I like to think of it, he's started the last leg of the journey to getting his true angel wings...
@TxAgDragongirl61190 as much as I've listened to the OBC before I saw the show, it was a great CD but then I saw a few different casts and then realized how much better some of those other casts were. I saw the orginal back in 98 or 99 at the Nederlander with most of the orginal cast and I have to tell ya is some of the on road casts were SO much better than the orginal. I have to give it up for the OBC for they are the ones that set the trend for the charactors but I've heard better thanOBC
OMG!!! Tracy and Eden are so sexy and wild, and they deliver an amazingly brilliant Take me or Leave Me....Their voices are so stunning, seriously, and seeing all that physical contact and shouting makes you imagine how do Maureen and Joanne are in more "private" situations hehehe :-)
Wow! I didn't even know it, but Renee Elise Goldsberry(Mimi) is said to bee expecting a baby boy in spring of '09. So she was pregnant while performing in rent! That's amazing!
I actually saw Eden in Wicked around 2 years ago in LA. She sounds similar to Idina live, more than on this recording. Both are awesome with their own defining moments though, I can't really compare. :)
surprisingly this Maureen looks and sounds very similar to Idina Menzel's Maureen! At first sight I hadto double check to see if that wasn't her!!!! I love the fact that somebody finally posted an updated version of Rent so I could see what I missed last year!
the woman who plays maureen is amazing, they are such a great couple on stage :)
SleeplessUkuleleGirl 2 months ago
sang tracies yes!!!!!!
marqjk1478 3 months ago
While I agree that Idina Menzel has more powerful vocals, I like Eden Espinsoa's emotion better. I don't see Eden performing but Maureen's frustration with Joanne.
swimmergirl3202004 8 months ago 5
@swimmergirl3202004 ohh this is eden??
broadwayxdude06 1 month ago
@broadwayxdude06 Yep.
swimmergirl3202004 1 month ago
@swimmergirl3202004 heard her sing. but i didnt know she did that song. and i had absolutely no idea what exactly it was that she looked like.
broadwayxdude06 1 month ago
"the clit club"...lol...AKA a lesbian club...thats halarious...tht was my first time catcing that!!!
Martichaj 8 months ago 6
This performance makes me realise just how awesome Idina Menzel is in comparison.
fleetfooted 10 months ago 8
Take me or leave me on glee was Awwwesome!!!!
DarrenCrisslover15 10 months ago
Angel has OFFICIALLY begun dieing in this part.... Or, as I like to think of it, he's started the last leg of the journey to getting his true angel wings...
MistressMizel 1 year ago 9
2 people dont wanna take Rent for what it is
gleekfan77 1 year ago 5
Wow there's some -great- acting from the Joanne in this version.
groovinhard 1 year ago 4
Idina sings this much better.
TxAgDragongirl61190 1 year ago 5
@TxAgDragongirl61190 as much as I've listened to the OBC before I saw the show, it was a great CD but then I saw a few different casts and then realized how much better some of those other casts were. I saw the orginal back in 98 or 99 at the Nederlander with most of the orginal cast and I have to tell ya is some of the on road casts were SO much better than the orginal. I have to give it up for the OBC for they are the ones that set the trend for the charactors but I've heard better thanOBC
Abonanno24601 10 months ago in playlist Rent: Live On Broadway
i love joanna's facial expressions!
plasticmailbox 1 year ago
raise your hand if you love rent
tmorea13 1 year ago 10
@tmorea13 both hands raised
merbethmango 1 year ago
2:31 I love how Roger and Mimi are just quietly watching from behind her!
nblsoccergurl 1 year ago 3
i had tears in my eyes during this :'( angel
XOmollynjadaOX 1 year ago
Comment removed
nblsoccergurl 1 year ago
TAKE ME OR LEAVE ME <<<< best musical song ever written!
Idina & Tracie <<<<< best performers for the best musical song. :L x
erickarnb 1 year ago 11
Comment removed
nem1crlh 1 year ago
this has to be my fav rendition of take me or leave me :)
kibakiss123 2 years ago 5
oooo I love the live version of "take me or leave me" it's great!
youknowzach 2 years ago 7
i think this is the best joanne/maureen pair EVER!!
LuvTigerLuv 2 years ago 12
At least Tracie already knew the words. lol =)
musiclove4ever2000 2 years ago 7
It;s crazy how much Eden looks like Idina in the face.
jasonabroussard 2 years ago 14
"there will always be women in rubber flirting with me!"---- best line in the whole show!!!
smileysillygoose1 2 years ago 69
tracies face @ 1:O3 is Priceless!
BByxDipsy 2 years ago 11
I think it's so heartbreaking when at the end, the cast sings 'How do you measure/a last year on Earth' and Mark looks right at Angel
musicXobsessed 2 years ago
OMG!!! Tracy and Eden are so sexy and wild, and they deliver an amazingly brilliant Take me or Leave Me....Their voices are so stunning, seriously, and seeing all that physical contact and shouting makes you imagine how do Maureen and Joanne are in more "private" situations hehehe :-)
GiselleKan 2 years ago 6
at 2:52 when Maureen says "don't you want your girl hot!" ...look to the bottom left.... there's Lexi aka Mimi...... HER FACE IS SOOOO FUNNY!
rory1494 2 years ago
The actress playing Mimi is Renee Goldsberry and yes she looks like she is trying not to laugh.
ochiesabina 2 years ago
oh...i just noticed.... my bad... Lexi is the one on the Broadway Tour :)
rory1494 2 years ago
Lexi isn't in this production. I guess you mean renee lol.
BroadwayKidNamedJosh 2 years ago
...i corrected my self like....a month ago.... i confused this and the Broadway Tour (i confused the Live on Broadway with Broadway tour)
rory1494 2 years ago
oh, haha sorry.
BroadwayKidNamedJosh 2 years ago
its cool :D
rory1494 2 years ago
what is worg with angel?
rocknroll20024 2 years ago
He is dying. He has aids
greenhouse466 2 years ago
Comment removed
rocknroll20024 2 years ago
the guy who plays roger was he in a band cuese he has the voice
rocknroll20024 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hope so because he can't act.
larrydildo 2 years ago
It's the same way that Adam Pascal was discovered.
thoamsxxman 2 years ago
haha my fav kine is in this i never knew that. :)
camillesantiago 2 years ago 2
she kind of looks like the girl form ncis
rocknroll20024 3 years ago
AHAHAHA. Eden kind of looks like Abby here, she does. ;D
nunchakugirl 2 years ago 3
@rocknroll20024 \
Do you mean Tracie Thoms? - she was in Cold Case the entire run of the show
andreamy213 1 year ago
@andreamy213 Jesse L. Martin from the original production was on Law and Order for around 8 years.
darkhart1000 5 months ago
Wow! I didn't even know it, but Renee Elise Goldsberry(Mimi) is said to bee expecting a baby boy in spring of '09. So she was pregnant while performing in rent! That's amazing!
domellcun 3 years ago 4
You got the spelling right. :))
I actually saw Eden in Wicked around 2 years ago in LA. She sounds similar to Idina live, more than on this recording. Both are awesome with their own defining moments though, I can't really compare. :)
pamvillareal 3 years ago 9
surprisingly this Maureen looks and sounds very similar to Idina Menzel's Maureen! At first sight I hadto double check to see if that wasn't her!!!! I love the fact that somebody finally posted an updated version of Rent so I could see what I missed last year!
dougeenol 3 years ago 9
yeah, she is awesome, but I think Idina sings a little higher.
biggguy82729 2 years ago 4
yeah, i think so too
quiroz923 2 years ago
yeah she does a bit but not much
idinakristinwicked 2 years ago
Tracie is the sh*t!!! Love her
babydcc1 3 years ago 57
@babydcc1 I DEFINATELY agree with that!! Im glad they let her keep her role from the movie. She fits is oh so well!!! #TEAMTRACIE :-)
dsmitty882010 4 months ago
"...I said once more from the TOP!"
"I said NO!!"
lol!
DjUnoSagune 3 years ago 12
edn is so awesome!
jdthemindfreak 3 years ago 9