I had a huge feeling that she was not real, or no one could see her except for him when, in the first part, he asked what her name was, and everyone looked back. I then discarded that idea when the teacher heard the "duet" and opened the cabinet to find her, and looked straight at her. I later regained this theory later on in the movie.
Secret 2 ! It'll answer all of our dying questions. People only made theories to fit the puzzle, because the movie didnt fully explain everything. Now Secret 2 will answer it all :D
I totally understand this movie, but isn't it cruel of him to abandon his father for a girl from the past? I cried badly when his father was running in pain to find him.
I'm really confused ..... what happened to the janitor?? In the past he was normal and in the future he was like severally disabled ..... why would they have that happen to him if they weren't going to explain how it happened??? @_@
@1412Bunny i don't think the janitor was 'normal' in the past... judging by the way he dressed and how he gets kinda bullied by the other kids... maybe as years progressed his disablity worsened?
i think jay chou cannot go back to the future since the old piano in the future already been demolished....which means,he juz going to be happy together with xiao yu in the past..haha!~~ happy ending..although the move is quite complicated,,,but still..the one of the best movie..^^!
I saw someone's theory that they were visiting each other so they wouldn't know each other and the cycle would repeat, I like this theory. I thought she didn't recognized him because he played too fast? o.o
@PamperoPam I think there is many interpretations, how I see it is that their love story is eternal. There is no end. The same story will go on forever since both of them time travel back and forth. When Jay went into the past, Rain didnt know who he was, so they had met. Then Jay left. Rain, went into the future to see him again, but the same scenario repeats; They meet and one wants to go see the other one but everytime one travels, the same new beginning repeats.
So, i think i get this. No one died in the end as Jay Chou time warped back to where Rain (XiaoYu) was still alive, therefore voiding whatever happened in the classroom (asthma attack). So it's actually a happy ending, since Jay and Rain lives together... Correct me if I'm wrong. Also anyone have news on when this is getting released?
someone commeneted that he played the song faster so he went too far back, to where xiaoyu doesnt even know who he is yet, and that makes sense (:
but what im wondering is how is HE seen by others, and what if his dad has a baby-him in 2-3yrs? would there be 2 jay chou's in the same time period? except one is just older by 20yrs? or would it be a different little boy and the course of time would be changed? (like the Butterfly Theory)
i'm wondering.how could he leave his father?i was crying throughout the scene when he played Time Travel Theme back. but i was crying even more when i saw his Dad running to find/stop him.they might be happy in the past. but how can the Dad live without his only son. he doesn't even have his wife anymore? or things will be changed wholly. like. the Dad will not have XiangLun as his son the moment jay went back in time. and have another one? this last part is touchy but it really confuses me :D
at first i became confused how can he appear in the photo if she is the only one that can see him...but, after watching it over and over i came up with a simple conclusion...she can only be seen by him because she's dead...and he can be seen by everybody and appear in the photo because he's still alive...there, problem solved...LOL
or he could have just gone back to an earlier time, yoy know, when she hasnt played the piece yet, which would explain why she doesnt know him (yet). Duh.
Actually xiaoyu knows him when he's back for her.. She is feeling touched and doesn't know how to express her emotion( can see her Geary eyes) so she looks down feeling awkward...
@cancertsk Are you sure? She seems like the type who would've jumped up to hug him or meet him. Plus, if you're regarding to the same 20 year time period, she already died from an asthma attack before he played the piano to go back in time.
@dosentmeanforever17 She has overdrawn be her emotions, based on what she has seen...that's why she's hurt and had gone back to her time...
The piano is destroyed in the future because of the renovation of that building, so it is understood that as Lu Xiang Lun decided to travel at the time of Xiao Yu,he could not be back in his time...he's stuck in the past... It's Jay who can see her in the future...
She has trust issues and he a very jealous person. So I guess if she thought that he found love with someone else, there's no point for her to be there.
The piano is there in the past, but he loves her so he wants to stay there.
I believe people can see him in the past, because I think that it only applies if you go forward in time, not backwards. If he wanted to go back to the present, he'd have to play it twice forward and once back to be seen.
@dosentmeanforever17 1) She can't just leave her mom, it's like can you just suddenly leave your mom in the past and leave her with worry and loneliness?
2) How do you know if the piano isn't still in the future?
3) The "Secret" doesn't say what happens when two pre-destined people play the music. Hence there could be loop holes in the rules of the "Secret".
You better watch again one more time . i will answer your questions .. sorry for my bad english first of all.
1) hmm doesnt matter really , thats the script
2) YES it is and ..... what?? whats your point??
3) She can see him in the past? no she cant. he wasnt even born! she see him in the future, she can travel back and forth whenever she wants to, the picture ?? she drew the picture in the past and yeah of course she had to play the piano again to get back to the past
@adil12ish in this movie she lives in 2 worlds .. past and present, as i said she can travel to the past or present by playing the "secret". You see the part when they dont meet each other ?? yeah thats the time she was at the past and live her real world ?? lol seems like your brain cant keep up with the simple complexity of the movie.
1) She went back because no one else could see her in the future
2) Yes, it should. I think it is, but there is no visual evidence for either side so I don't see why you are saying this. The time between the time after he finished the piece and when he got to the door of the room was now shown, maybe because they couldn't make it not boring.
3) If you go back in time, then everyone can see you; if you go forward in time, only the first person you see can see you(my guess).
@dosentmeanforever17 i might be a bit late with responding but heres what i think are the answers to your question (emphasis on 'i think)
1) she couldn't exactly just leave everything, i.e her mum, plus this was all new to her... i'd find it quite cool time-travelling every now and then
2) yeah, i don't think it said the piano wasn't there in the past 'cause it was destroyed in the future? but maybe that he just can't get back to the future
3) this is purely just a guess, but i think the blood
@dosentmeanforever17 *the blood drop at the end means that he now belongs to the past... and therefore lives in the past... (maybe his dad had him 20 yrs earlier? i'm not sure! haha)
i think it's good sometimes some things are left unanswered as it is open to interpretations
nonetheless i agree! it's a great movie with a great twist!
So he travel back to the past..He will see his Dad, who have the music sheet and the piano still there..Wonder if he can play that piano to time travel again?? Also his Dad will have a son in the future, which is him!! Sort of the Back to the Future I guess...
@beautyfyme no he did not die in the piano room, he successfully travel back in time to see Xiaoyu, and because he played the song faster, it went back to the time when they don't even know each other, but then the piano room was destroyed, so that mean he stuck in the past with her forever. And they become a couple because at the end, you can see two of them standing next to each other in the Graduation picture, Hope that helps :D
I like the movie but wouldnt this create a paradox? he goes back to save her because he found out she died because of that whole scene with the desk. I suppose he wouldve gone to her house after the ceremony but he wouldnt have done things the same way.
@LovelyMNGurl02 basically the whole story is about a girl who finds a sheet music that lets her time travel if played in the old piano room. if she plays the song slowly she goes forward in time. if she plays it fast she goes back in time. she goes forward to see the guy. they fall in love.and the only person that could see her when she time travels forward is the first person that she sees. then she dies in her time and to save her the guy goes back in time before he even met her.
@muktid This is just ur theory. Scientist didnt make a machine like that yet so we dunno. But ikno what ur trying to say. Like if i said "hi to you today" and u punched me because ur vietnam(no offence) and hi means someting bad. So i go back in time and fixed things up. Stopped me from saying hi. Now honestly if i stopped myself then i dont have a point of going back in time now do i? Ikno this isnt what ur trying to say but im trying to tell u that ur way doesnt work.
@jajajaja669 Noone will really know why, but I assume that because with all the deconstruction going on, XiangLun need to play really fast as the piano is going to be destroyed. That's why he went back to the time XiaoYu doesn't know him yet.
Not sure when Secret 2 will be out, with Jay Chou's tight schedule and all, but I doubt Secret 2 will have any relation to this movie.
@JenL0ve18 Probably not... like 2000 years later... another story of jay chou.... haha. I guess the faster he played the more years he traveled. There is actually another question. Its the riddle. All i understand was the first sight thingy so you should help me with the other lines. So first sight u already know what it is. But when xiaoyu tried to go back. She is still time travelin. So how does everyone see her. And Xianglun at the end. Is it just time traveling back that lets you see?
@jajajaja669 I guess that if you time travel back, everyone can sees you. Another theory is, since the piano has already been destroyed and XiangLun can't go back, he's stuck there and hence the riddle's rule breaks and everyone can see him.
It would be better if the girl hasn't been blinded by her wrong thoughts! I love the story so much...full of plot twist which makes the story more exciting...Jay Chou please release this film and your future film in the Philippines! We love you here...
This is a very amazing movie. make me cry my all. they proved that Love conquers both Time and space. Thumbs up to those people who made this movie :)
love this movie so much ... T^T such a beautiful story with beautiful piano pieces.
But the end is little bit strange ... I'm mean, on graduation day that girl gets to the graduation day in exact 20years, while the boy travels through time AFTER that day but gets to the time BEFORE graduation day ... you understand what i mean xD
And, if the girls dead, why does her mum thinks that her daughters still there? Hasnt she died or is her mum a psycho?
@NinjaGaloo On Graduation day, present, he plays the piece too fast, because he is rushed, by the demolition, thus, he travels a year before Xiaoyu discover's the piece in the past, because the faster he plays, the further he'll go back in time. Thus, he will never be in the present again when Xiaoyu travels time. Thus, Xianglun, is therefore, lost in time.
@nikonone2000 Really?Thank so much for the news^^ I can't wait either...But Secret was in 2007 right?A sequel..4 years later?Hm,maybe it has something to do with the movie's story...CAN'T.WAIT :D
dude it would suck for jay chou if the relationship doesnt work out! Like, he would be stuck in the past and be forever alone because hes invisible to everyone else.... all just because he wanted to hit up that pussy
great movie, the only thing I would question is how everyone is able to see him in the end, i figure if she is only seen by one person when she goes to the future, he would only be seen by her (1st person he sees) when he goes back.. he probably wouldn't have shown up in the picture or something like that... nevertheless this was a joy to watch..now i must muster up some determination to learn these fantastic piano pieces..!
@MesmerozaLou because the piano in future was destroyed, the time travel rule was broken, so jay couldnt return back to future anymore and stuck forever in the past, and that was why everybody could see him.
@MesmerozaLou for me the reason for him showing up in the picture was because the old piano in the future with the old building was destroyed, making it impossible for him to return to the future.. making an effect that he will be there in past with Lu Xiaoyu. :)
Wow.... This movie is so amazing -3333 I cried, laughed, got scared lol it's amazing... America doesn't make movies like this~ just wow... Jay Chou, amazing~
all through this movie i cried because it was so sad.... now the tears on my cheeks are because i am overcome with happiness. :) i love the ending. hehehehe.
im amazed by the story,,the girl did die on their graduation day because of asthma..thats why you cannot see the old version of the girl in the future..but the boy went back to the past to meet her and so she was not dead because they met b4 the graduation and both graduated..
i bawled for the last 3 or 4 parts... AWH! :'( this is NOW my favorite movie..... even though it's heartberaking! but... they ended up together. yay! :)
@Rfurui its actually very simple. She died, yes, but what happens was when jay went back in time, it was BEFORE all the events occured. When the girl sees him, she doesn't know him, but still, they become friends later on.
im glad they are in deep love. i hope that i have a girlfriend like that, lovely,like to stick with her stead all the time,take her home every day. that would be perfect for me
It's not an ending I didn't like. It was just disappointing. And if they have not been together in the end, I would totally understand it because then it would have taught as about Life and not added to false hopes of romance. Really, she is the only one he talked to his entire life after going back to the past?? That's masochism.
so everything that he saw was just the past? and how is this relating to Jay's gf if he is the director and or producer of this movie btw?
shygrl17 21 minutes ago
I had a huge feeling that she was not real, or no one could see her except for him when, in the first part, he asked what her name was, and everyone looked back. I then discarded that idea when the teacher heard the "duet" and opened the cabinet to find her, and looked straight at her. I later regained this theory later on in the movie.
pinkaroundme 2 days ago
I love this movie. One of a kind story of great love. I'm so happy I found this. I love the story!!! -3
hipanda2 2 days ago
why did xiao yu not know xiang lun when xiang lun travelled to the past?
wolverine9162 5 days ago
The Sadest Part Is Seeing The Dad Run It Broke My Hard
linkinpark1234rocks 1 week ago
Secret 2 ! It'll answer all of our dying questions. People only made theories to fit the puzzle, because the movie didnt fully explain everything. Now Secret 2 will answer it all :D
ChompNom 1 week ago
I totally understand this movie, but isn't it cruel of him to abandon his father for a girl from the past? I cried badly when his father was running in pain to find him.
cientey 1 week ago
@cientey he can see his father in the past also, as he worked there as a teacher.
pinkaroundme 2 days ago
Omg! She actually died in her time and the guy goes back to the time even before they met to save her! That is effin DEEP!
*Overwhelmed with emotions* :')
rebelangels1994 1 week ago
Love-3
yaxiongjiayou 2 weeks ago
Love this movie sooo much!! :')
1412Bunny 3 weeks ago
I'm really confused ..... what happened to the janitor?? In the past he was normal and in the future he was like severally disabled ..... why would they have that happen to him if they weren't going to explain how it happened??? @_@
1412Bunny 3 weeks ago
@1412Bunny i don't think the janitor was 'normal' in the past... judging by the way he dressed and how he gets kinda bullied by the other kids... maybe as years progressed his disablity worsened?
tambbx 1 week ago
i think jay chou cannot go back to the future since the old piano in the future already been demolished....which means,he juz going to be happy together with xiao yu in the past..haha!~~ happy ending..although the move is quite complicated,,,but still..the one of the best movie..^^!
meynA1125 3 weeks ago
this is like the most confusing movie i have ever seen but the best one ever this is like my favorite movie ever very touching ending
Random159357258456 4 weeks ago
Two possible reasons why he was seen in the past:
1- the destruction of the piano room and piano sealed off the passage back to the future for him so he was stuck in the past
2- maybe when travelling to the past everyone can see you
Also, I think her expression at the end is like:
Xiao *faint grin* *nod* "hi, nice to meet you"
Xiang "what...? you don't recognize me?"
Xiao *smile* "just kidding, of course I recognize you!"
instafication 1 month ago
great movie, feel sad for his dad
lety7544 1 month ago
I saw someone's theory that they were visiting each other so they wouldn't know each other and the cycle would repeat, I like this theory. I thought she didn't recognized him because he played too fast? o.o
ShiverMeTimbers0 1 month ago
Nvm youtube on ipod is messed up ( this goes to my prev comment)
duhHmong 1 month ago
....... My Birthday was yesterday and this came out or im just slow lol best piano player ive seen considering my self asian so proud of my race T^T
duhHmong 1 month ago
although we all know that when a old historic building full of old piano's will never be demolished it was a great movie
beapanganiban 1 month ago
Now Jay Chou start to make secret 2.
leekimhuang1 1 month ago 13
@leekimhuang1 When Those It Come Out
linkinpark1234rocks 1 week ago
@linkinpark1234rocks?
linkinpark1234rocks 1 week ago
Lol good movie :)
animedazer 2 months ago
@PamperoPam I think there is many interpretations, how I see it is that their love story is eternal. There is no end. The same story will go on forever since both of them time travel back and forth. When Jay went into the past, Rain didnt know who he was, so they had met. Then Jay left. Rain, went into the future to see him again, but the same scenario repeats; They meet and one wants to go see the other one but everytime one travels, the same new beginning repeats.
Really, this is a deep movie.
JomitraS 2 months ago
He changed the future.
PamperoPam 2 months ago
I meant the sequel*
PLATSIN 2 months ago
So, i think i get this. No one died in the end as Jay Chou time warped back to where Rain (XiaoYu) was still alive, therefore voiding whatever happened in the classroom (asthma attack). So it's actually a happy ending, since Jay and Rain lives together... Correct me if I'm wrong. Also anyone have news on when this is getting released?
PLATSIN 2 months ago
If only this could've been in major cinemas, WORLDWIDE. Great movie !! Kudos, Jay Chou, you've made another man cry. :DD
rdgison08 2 months ago 4
Nice movie
k0nGy3 2 months ago
someone commeneted that he played the song faster so he went too far back, to where xiaoyu doesnt even know who he is yet, and that makes sense (:
but what im wondering is how is HE seen by others, and what if his dad has a baby-him in 2-3yrs? would there be 2 jay chou's in the same time period? except one is just older by 20yrs? or would it be a different little boy and the course of time would be changed? (like the Butterfly Theory)
smileanjo 2 months ago
so did she not remember him atthe end or what???
steviebYaj 2 months ago
top comments, PLEASE stop giving out the ending of the mv before the loading is done and it ruins it for the rest of us :(
smileanjo 2 months ago
SUCH AN AMAZING MOVIE!!!!!!!!!! I CRIED MAN! LOL. SO GLAD THEY ENDED UP TOGETHER
OkamiKazeify 2 months ago
i'm wondering.how could he leave his father?i was crying throughout the scene when he played Time Travel Theme back. but i was crying even more when i saw his Dad running to find/stop him.they might be happy in the past. but how can the Dad live without his only son. he doesn't even have his wife anymore? or things will be changed wholly. like. the Dad will not have XiangLun as his son the moment jay went back in time. and have another one? this last part is touchy but it really confuses me :D
joekingster 2 months ago
at first i became confused how can he appear in the photo if she is the only one that can see him...but, after watching it over and over i came up with a simple conclusion...she can only be seen by him because she's dead...and he can be seen by everybody and appear in the photo because he's still alive...there, problem solved...LOL
motar94 2 months ago
@motar94
or he could have just gone back to an earlier time, yoy know, when she hasnt played the piece yet, which would explain why she doesnt know him (yet). Duh.
ijjibebeijji 2 months ago
@ijjibebeijji okay...i never thought bout that...you might be right!!thanks...
motar94 3 weeks ago
@DumbUsername8238 she has already died and he went into an earlier time period at which she doesnt remember him anymore.
kueevue 3 months ago
@DumbUsername8238 he didn't die for her. He went back in time
lunalilium 3 months ago
can anyone see him in the past??
Or for only one who see him at first?
muktid 3 months ago
can anyone see him in the past??
muktid 3 months ago
so sad :'(
miley345ana 3 months ago
Wow. I'm glad I watched this movie.. Even if it is 12AM right now.
xAiiRPLANES 3 months ago
Actually xiaoyu knows him when he's back for her.. She is feeling touched and doesn't know how to express her emotion( can see her Geary eyes) so she looks down feeling awkward...
cancertsk 3 months ago
@cancertsk Are you sure? She seems like the type who would've jumped up to hug him or meet him. Plus, if you're regarding to the same 20 year time period, she already died from an asthma attack before he played the piano to go back in time.
lunalilium 3 months ago
Actually
cancertsk 3 months ago
this movie is fuckin sad =( love it ♥
mrssrklove 3 months ago
This is the most amazing movie I hav ever seen I am crying so bad !!!
POIPOI123ish 3 months ago 2
Oh my..Jay such a loyal man..ahh..the ending very dramatic..it make me crying..The great movie!!
faezawani 3 months ago
good movie!!!
cheezeydude 3 months ago
1) Why did she even bother going back? Why didn't she think of staying with Jay in the future before she thought he was with that other gal?
2) If the piano was destroyed in the future, shouldn't it still be there in the past?
3) She's the only one that can see him in the past? Yet he shows up in the picture?
...Nevertheless, great movie. It give a really great twist and a touching ending. (:
dosentmeanforever17 3 months ago 12
@dosentmeanforever17 She has overdrawn be her emotions, based on what she has seen...that's why she's hurt and had gone back to her time...
The piano is destroyed in the future because of the renovation of that building, so it is understood that as Lu Xiang Lun decided to travel at the time of Xiao Yu,he could not be back in his time...he's stuck in the past... It's Jay who can see her in the future...
elyrat 3 months ago 2
@dosentmeanforever17
She has trust issues and he a very jealous person. So I guess if she thought that he found love with someone else, there's no point for her to be there.
The piano is there in the past, but he loves her so he wants to stay there.
I believe people can see him in the past, because I think that it only applies if you go forward in time, not backwards. If he wanted to go back to the present, he'd have to play it twice forward and once back to be seen.
lunalilium 3 months ago
@dosentmeanforever17 i think the reason ppl cant see her in the future becuz she is dead. and he can be seen in the past becuz hes still alive.
kueevue 3 months ago
@dosentmeanforever17 1) She can't just leave her mom, it's like can you just suddenly leave your mom in the past and leave her with worry and loneliness?
2) How do you know if the piano isn't still in the future?
3) The "Secret" doesn't say what happens when two pre-destined people play the music. Hence there could be loop holes in the rules of the "Secret".
ClarebearStylin 3 months ago
@dosentmeanforever17
She's the only one that can see him in the past? Yet he shows up in the picture?
^ He shows up in the picture, but which part did it show that the girl was the only one who can see him?
ijjibebeijji 2 months ago
@dosentmeanforever17
You better watch again one more time . i will answer your questions .. sorry for my bad english first of all.
1) hmm doesnt matter really , thats the script
2) YES it is and ..... what?? whats your point??
3) She can see him in the past? no she cant. he wasnt even born! she see him in the future, she can travel back and forth whenever she wants to, the picture ?? she drew the picture in the past and yeah of course she had to play the piano again to get back to the past
adil12ish 2 months ago
@adil12ish in this movie she lives in 2 worlds .. past and present, as i said she can travel to the past or present by playing the "secret". You see the part when they dont meet each other ?? yeah thats the time she was at the past and live her real world ?? lol seems like your brain cant keep up with the simple complexity of the movie.
adil12ish 2 months ago
@dosentmeanforever17
1) She went back because no one else could see her in the future
2) Yes, it should. I think it is, but there is no visual evidence for either side so I don't see why you are saying this. The time between the time after he finished the piece and when he got to the door of the room was now shown, maybe because they couldn't make it not boring.
3) If you go back in time, then everyone can see you; if you go forward in time, only the first person you see can see you(my guess).
supergreatsuper 1 month ago in playlist More videos from TravDuong
@dosentmeanforever17 i might be a bit late with responding but heres what i think are the answers to your question (emphasis on 'i think)
1) she couldn't exactly just leave everything, i.e her mum, plus this was all new to her... i'd find it quite cool time-travelling every now and then
2) yeah, i don't think it said the piano wasn't there in the past 'cause it was destroyed in the future? but maybe that he just can't get back to the future
3) this is purely just a guess, but i think the blood
tambbx 1 week ago
@dosentmeanforever17 *the blood drop at the end means that he now belongs to the past... and therefore lives in the past... (maybe his dad had him 20 yrs earlier? i'm not sure! haha)
i think it's good sometimes some things are left unanswered as it is open to interpretations
nonetheless i agree! it's a great movie with a great twist!
tambbx 1 week ago
almost had me in floods of tears
Natenoooo16 3 months ago
one of the best! :D
dBeyonder 3 months ago
Holy shiy....this blew my mind...jay Chou never ceases to amaze me! This movie was awesome.
swimmerfurlife 3 months ago
Waaaoo great movie.....
25drcn 3 months ago
Why must the song be so long?!
ZhouFantastic 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great movie a must watch
ajosgenx 4 months ago
omg this movie had me cryin at the end. they need a sequel the whole concept of the movie is :')
newboyzizhot 4 months ago
So he travel back to the past..He will see his Dad, who have the music sheet and the piano still there..Wonder if he can play that piano to time travel again?? Also his Dad will have a son in the future, which is him!! Sort of the Back to the Future I guess...
bren5209 4 months ago
i feel so bad for the dad.. sniffle... snifle
godofsushi 4 months ago
*Looks for the "Repeat" button*
noviceboy55 4 months ago
oh-mai-FUCKING-gawd!!!! Jay Chou is legit!!! this old movie is one of the BEST films ever made. i hope Jay Chou will be in more of these movies.
MnMyAatWiNdClOuD 4 months ago
HELP!.. so did he die in the piano room?? meaning he survive back in time but he can never go back forward in time to where he use to be?
beautyfyme 4 months ago
@beautyfyme no he did not die in the piano room, he successfully travel back in time to see Xiaoyu, and because he played the song faster, it went back to the time when they don't even know each other, but then the piano room was destroyed, so that mean he stuck in the past with her forever. And they become a couple because at the end, you can see two of them standing next to each other in the Graduation picture, Hope that helps :D
khoifysh 4 months ago
@khoifysh right, thanks! another question, He goes back in time, and she is the first he sees, is she's the only one that can see him?
beautyfyme 4 months ago
@beautyfyme lol, i guess so, i don't get that part either, where they stand all together in the graduation pic, but yep i think so too. :D
khoifysh 4 months ago
@khoifysh I think others can too, base on the picture
beautyfyme 4 months ago
that was deep
PXssss 4 months ago
I like the movie but wouldnt this create a paradox? he goes back to save her because he found out she died because of that whole scene with the desk. I suppose he wouldve gone to her house after the ceremony but he wouldnt have done things the same way.
istolethisytaccount 4 months ago
Im reading everyones explanation, but im still soooooooooooooooooooooooooo confusdd
LovelyMNGurl02 4 months ago
@LovelyMNGurl02 basically the whole story is about a girl who finds a sheet music that lets her time travel if played in the old piano room. if she plays the song slowly she goes forward in time. if she plays it fast she goes back in time. she goes forward to see the guy. they fall in love.and the only person that could see her when she time travels forward is the first person that she sees. then she dies in her time and to save her the guy goes back in time before he even met her.
mtrxpnay14 4 months ago
@mtrxpnay14 Ooooooooooooohhhh...so that's what the story is about....LOL! Thanks so much!!!!! =) I kinda understand it now.
LovelyMNGurl02 4 months ago
@LovelyMNGurl02 glad to help :)
mtrxpnay14 4 months ago
But i loved watching it though. Love it! Jay chou is the best! Looooooooooooove jay chou!
LovelyMNGurl02 4 months ago
I am soooooooooooo seriously confused about the story.............
LovelyMNGurl02 4 months ago
how it would happen, there were two different pastes...
muktid 5 months ago
the past is already pasted, how can he change the past?
muktid 5 months ago
@muktid This is just ur theory. Scientist didnt make a machine like that yet so we dunno. But ikno what ur trying to say. Like if i said "hi to you today" and u punched me because ur vietnam(no offence) and hi means someting bad. So i go back in time and fixed things up. Stopped me from saying hi. Now honestly if i stopped myself then i dont have a point of going back in time now do i? Ikno this isnt what ur trying to say but im trying to tell u that ur way doesnt work.
jajajaja669 4 months ago
Someone Explain. Did Xianglun go back to the time where xiaoyu didnt know here or before she died from asma?
jajajaja669 5 months ago in playlist More videos from TravDuong
@jajajaja669 He went back to the time where XiaoYu doesn't know him yet.
JenL0ve18 5 months ago
@JenL0ve18 Wonder why he did that. Accident? No body knows. So ive heard that secret 2 will be coming out around 2013?
jajajaja669 5 months ago
@jajajaja669 Noone will really know why, but I assume that because with all the deconstruction going on, XiangLun need to play really fast as the piano is going to be destroyed. That's why he went back to the time XiaoYu doesn't know him yet.
Not sure when Secret 2 will be out, with Jay Chou's tight schedule and all, but I doubt Secret 2 will have any relation to this movie.
JenL0ve18 4 months ago
@JenL0ve18 Probably not... like 2000 years later... another story of jay chou.... haha. I guess the faster he played the more years he traveled. There is actually another question. Its the riddle. All i understand was the first sight thingy so you should help me with the other lines. So first sight u already know what it is. But when xiaoyu tried to go back. She is still time travelin. So how does everyone see her. And Xianglun at the end. Is it just time traveling back that lets you see?
jajajaja669 4 months ago
@jajajaja669 I guess that if you time travel back, everyone can sees you. Another theory is, since the piano has already been destroyed and XiangLun can't go back, he's stuck there and hence the riddle's rule breaks and everyone can see him.
JenL0ve18 4 months ago
@JenL0ve18 No he can go back. Just play alittle slower... ALOT SLOWER!
jajajaja669 4 months ago
@jajajaja669 If he did that, he probably will encounter another him. Lol.
JenL0ve18 4 months ago
@JenL0ve18 so true lol
jajajaja669 4 months ago
AWWW THE DADDY D:
xbumblejumble 5 months ago
It would be better if the girl hasn't been blinded by her wrong thoughts! I love the story so much...full of plot twist which makes the story more exciting...Jay Chou please release this film and your future film in the Philippines! We love you here...
elyrat 5 months ago
This is the best asian drama i've ever watched!!!
I likie it... no i dont... I LOVE IT!!
MsXxevolutionxxable 5 months ago
5:46 damn hot...
almamirobibi 5 months ago
he left his father alone quite sad movie :(
angruirong 5 months ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
he left his father alone quite sad movie :(
angruirong 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
he left his father alone :(
angruirong 5 months ago
he left his father alone :(
angruirong 5 months ago
he left his father alone :(
angruirong 5 months ago
This is a very amazing movie. make me cry my all. they proved that Love conquers both Time and space. Thumbs up to those people who made this movie :)
*Crying*
XYZSnow1 5 months ago
love this movie so much ... T^T such a beautiful story with beautiful piano pieces.
But the end is little bit strange ... I'm mean, on graduation day that girl gets to the graduation day in exact 20years, while the boy travels through time AFTER that day but gets to the time BEFORE graduation day ... you understand what i mean xD
And, if the girls dead, why does her mum thinks that her daughters still there? Hasnt she died or is her mum a psycho?
NinjaGaloo 5 months ago
@NinjaGaloo On Graduation day, present, he plays the piece too fast, because he is rushed, by the demolition, thus, he travels a year before Xiaoyu discover's the piece in the past, because the faster he plays, the further he'll go back in time. Thus, he will never be in the present again when Xiaoyu travels time. Thus, Xianglun, is therefore, lost in time.
BoeingDude777 5 months ago
that guy next to her in the picture doesn't look like him/ but it is??!? it doesn't look like him at all.. -_-
xelashouts 6 months ago
omg...that is soooooooo beautiful.
How can Jay Chou be this blessed.
A Pianist, Guitarist, Singer, and now he brings this.... omg I am speechless.
I am waiting for Secret 2.
RRimayi 6 months ago
oh my gosh. i don't usually cry but.... I'M CRYING! awesome movie.
oversleptgoddess 6 months ago
Oh.
Oh.
We.Need a sequel.
We.
Must have a sequel.
I.
Oh my.
blingblingshineshine 6 months ago 17
@blingblingshineshine Jay Chou is going to make a sequel. Can't wait.
nikonone2000 5 months ago
@nikonone2000 Really?Thank so much for the news^^ I can't wait either...But Secret was in 2007 right?A sequel..4 years later?Hm,maybe it has something to do with the movie's story...CAN'T.WAIT :D
blingblingshineshine 5 months ago
@nikonone2000 Are you serious!?!?!?! please don't get my hopes up if there isnt one :(
MrTennisMenace 2 months ago
@blingblingshineshine cant be a prequel, hes old now
thorhammer991 4 months ago
@thorhammer991 ignorant.
blingblingshineshine 4 months ago
This is.
This is why.
This is why .
We must never believe.
The past cannot be changed.
The future,
can save it.
blingblingshineshine 6 months ago
dude it would suck for jay chou if the relationship doesnt work out! Like, he would be stuck in the past and be forever alone because hes invisible to everyone else.... all just because he wanted to hit up that pussy
junjoo123 6 months ago 12
@junjoo123 dude, uncalled for
assassintwinat8 3 months ago 3
awesome!!! sad how she doesnt know him D;
NuisanceGuy 6 months ago
OMG! what a sad ending!!! I was crying my eyes out!!! T-T
moonleaf93 6 months ago
poor future dad. now he his son is gone.
myfunkychannel 6 months ago
now, i must learn the time travel theme
wisnu1231 6 months ago 3
sad. . . . im crying :(
yomashiki 6 months ago
:( . no words for this amazing movie
mamarracho50 6 months ago
lol our school tie is exactly the same as theirs
adadazzle 6 months ago
k now back to part 1 :D
lysjocksan 6 months ago
this movie made mr cry it so sad I watched it like 5 times it's so good
MISTA1WONG 7 months ago
oh mai gad. i got the chills for like 5 minutes....
95silverlover 7 months ago
great movie, the only thing I would question is how everyone is able to see him in the end, i figure if she is only seen by one person when she goes to the future, he would only be seen by her (1st person he sees) when he goes back.. he probably wouldn't have shown up in the picture or something like that... nevertheless this was a joy to watch..now i must muster up some determination to learn these fantastic piano pieces..!
MesmerozaLou 7 months ago 14
@MesmerozaLou im already know them :D
paabloo90210 6 months ago
@paabloo90210 thats amazing :)
MesmerozaLou 6 months ago
@MesmerozaLou because the piano in future was destroyed, the time travel rule was broken, so jay couldnt return back to future anymore and stuck forever in the past, and that was why everybody could see him.
angelikeita 6 months ago
Comment removed
cpaksyan 4 months ago
Comment removed
cpaksyan 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MesmerozaLou for me the reason for him showing up in the picture was because the old piano in the future with the old building was destroyed, making it impossible for him to return to the future.. making an effect that he will be there in past with Lu Xiaoyu. :)
cpaksyan 4 months ago
check Jay Chou at wikipedia.. you'll see how awesome he is.. ^_^
wwwmouse1dotcom 7 months ago
Wow.... This movie is so amazing -3333 I cried, laughed, got scared lol it's amazing... America doesn't make movies like this~ just wow... Jay Chou, amazing~
SarangehaeyoKevin91 7 months ago 2
waste of furniture and pianos in the building.....
local1114 7 months ago
all through this movie i cried because it was so sad.... now the tears on my cheeks are because i am overcome with happiness. :) i love the ending. hehehehe.
ilovemysixstrings 7 months ago
i cried multiple times...
fargone93 7 months ago
i dont get it....so she died right? but how did he travel back far enough to see her if shes dead? hows that possible?
chengaminizermetron 7 months ago
Brilliant Amazing Beautiful ... A Heart Stop performance. :3
du15que 7 months ago
WHY DID IT HAVE TO END!!! :(
2727202 7 months ago
@2727202 Supposedly Secret 2 starts filming in September:) So we'll have more soon :D
kabelcar1000 7 months ago
interesting thing about this scene was if he didn't play it that fast, he would have been so boned and gone through a failed attempt
kulong 7 months ago
One of my favourites...gonnalet my daughter watch this when she's old enough...:)
slashers32 7 months ago
im amazed by the story,,the girl did die on their graduation day because of asthma..thats why you cannot see the old version of the girl in the future..but the boy went back to the past to meet her and so she was not dead because they met b4 the graduation and both graduated..
slashers32 7 months ago 2
@slashers32 Meaning they'd only have 20 years to live together right? :( Since Xiao Yu died exactly 20 years later.
easypeasysqueesy 7 months ago
i bawled for the last 3 or 4 parts... AWH! :'( this is NOW my favorite movie..... even though it's heartberaking! but... they ended up together. yay! :)
rayrayofsunshineee 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THUMBS UP FOR THIS MOVIE !!!!! its amazing !! <3
01minhan01 7 months ago
Someone explain the ending to me D;
Im not sure I understood that well D;
Did the girl die on the desk? ;O
and pretty much what happens to the dad and the son? D;
Rfurui 7 months ago
@Rfurui its actually very simple. She died, yes, but what happens was when jay went back in time, it was BEFORE all the events occured. When the girl sees him, she doesn't know him, but still, they become friends later on.
So yeah, hope that helps.
daznpower 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great movie. I am sad that I lazed to watch this many years ago.
TheMisdirectingHand 7 months ago
poor dad , running in desperate to look for his son ! that made me cried
Taekcreed 7 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
one of the most beautiful movies I've ever watched
SeriChibi 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LOVE FOR THIS MOVIE!!!!!!
mmmgalaxychoc 8 months ago
man he played the piano fast
hotshotvang 8 months ago
@IROHny I think when he went to the past to see the girl that he loved, his dad was the teacher, so he still had his dad I think
miriamchoi99 8 months ago
FUCKING AMAZING MOVIE !!!!!!!!!!!
TechnlogyFreak 8 months ago 2
im glad they are in deep love. i hope that i have a girlfriend like that, lovely,like to stick with her stead all the time,take her home every day. that would be perfect for me
lolcabal 8 months ago
Comment removed
lolcabal 8 months ago
way to leave your dad, man.
IROHny 8 months ago 3
wow! i really like it!
yooriish 8 months ago
It's not an ending I didn't like. It was just disappointing. And if they have not been together in the end, I would totally understand it because then it would have taught as about Life and not added to false hopes of romance. Really, she is the only one he talked to his entire life after going back to the past?? That's masochism.
purplebasketful 8 months ago
@char334 so what happen to the father?
adikfatin 8 months ago
the son went in time and the father just stay where he is right before the building fell
hotshotvang 8 months ago