Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (220)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • just beautiful. she's so relaxed and professional in front of a massive tv audience at 19 years old!!! brilliant performance of a lovely classic timeless song.

  • Its 2012 and I am still listening to this song!....One of my favorite Idols!

  • I wish she would do a full length version of this. 

  • Im not a fan of her. But this performance is an exception

  • MamaTrina is right. I could listen to this everyday!

  • Awesome!

  • the emotions that are conveyed through her vocal inflictions, facial expressions and body movements set her apart from the rest of the field that AI season.

  • Love her! Song is amazing!

  • I don't like it...but that's not to say she won't appeal to another crowd. Just not my style of music.

  • this just breaks my heart everytime I play it. So beautiful, so real, so brilliant. God bless her and keep her safe.

  • I simply love you, Fantasia. x

  • I Lovee Fantasia! Everything about her is Beautifull to me!! This performance was SPECTACULAR!! Kudos to my babes!! (Y)

  • HER HIGH NOTES GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS! SHES AMAZIN

  • incredible!!!!

    

  • This song still sends chills down my spine every time I hear it. Truly beautiful..I cried the first time I heard it. She is such a great artist and I hope she utilizes her talent to it's full potential. Just beautiful...

  • it beautiful it go through to your soul...FANTASIA SING THIS WHOLE SONG TOO WONDERFUL TO BE SO SHORT!!

  • "All I ever will recall of your life is all of your life with you"? I think she didn't have very long to learn this. And that first note sequence is inaccurate. Great voice but breathing in the middle of phrases is ugly.

  • @BambiAnneDear They have less than a week to cut the song down to 90 seconds or less, so it's possible that she forgot where the ending was cut. As far as the inaccuracy of the first note sequence, anything can happen with amateurs on a live stage performing before millions. Just because you don't prefer her breathing in the middle of phrases doesn't make it ugly -- it just means you don't prefer it. If you're a vocal coach, I'm glad you weren't mine.

  • FOR ALL THE PEOPLE WHO COMPLAINT THAT ALL FANTASIA DO IS SCREAM AND HOLLA...THIS SHOULDA MADE YOU SHUT THE HELL UP!

  • if your in arkansas on july 9 dont miss fantasia live in concert at the robinson center in Little Rock,AR

  • Awesoooommmmmmeeee!!!!!

  • it would be funny is i still could rite now today

  • Love it

  • she really needs 2 record this song

  • how could someone dislike this..... crack babies

  • if she made a an album of covers, she'd get my coins!!!!

  • attention idol fans the time as come to start requesting her new single "collard greens and cornbread" on your local radio station and buy it on itunes so let do it if this your favorite idol then support thanks

  • My favorite Fantasia's performance!

  • Such an emotional lovely song.

  • When I first saw this performance it sent chills through me..Fantasia is truly a brilliant artist. I swear I think I've listened to this about 100 times now...just beautiful.

  • Barbara Streisand 10 yeats before sings this at her concert with thousands in attendance. Babsfan has the vid.

  • I'm a white, middle-class 46 year old suburband housewife. Even though we may not have a single thing to connect on materialistically, she is, by far and away, one of my favorite singers/performers of all time - i.e. beyond Idol. Her emotion and talent are both amazing and inspirational. I hope she learns to recognize how beautiful she is - inside and out - vocally and otherwise.

  • She is so talented and beautiful, and she can Rocc a short do like nobody else in my candid opinion.

  • WOW!!!!!!!!! I love her

  • i really think that fantasia is the most talented idol ever

  • incredible. no one else can touch this amazingness

  • Fantasia you made me cry, it was simply beautiful.

  • This performance was so great I recorded it on VHS!! It started messing up and thought I had lost her singing this song forever!! Overjoyed to find it again and am gonna favorite it asap to never lose it again!! I love Barbara Streisand, Fantasia Barrino and this song!! God bless

  • Transcendent

    

  • singers like this only come along in twenty years or so, she's great

  • What's wrong with Paula's thumb??

  • @LOL7870 i think she accidentally cut it

  • I really cant get her version of this song out of my head, it's amazing!!! I want a recorded version so I can listen to it till I get tired of it. Which will be never. ;)

  • Why is it that that have her make albums that appeal to the younger generation? Can't they have her make just one CD singing this song,Summertime,and other songs that might appeal to someone my age? I'm 50 and I have money to spend too!

  • She sang this beautifully......and it is great to see Ryan Seacrest before the Woody Woodpecker hair....

  • Fantasia will be remembered for being on of the best vocalist of r&b!

  • attention fans request her new single "im doing me" on your local radio station so we can help her get up on the charts so lets do it you guys

  • my top 3 best season in AI

    1. season 3

    2. season 8

    3. season 7

  • im in LOVE ! <3

  • don t miss the second season of her new reality show "fantasia for real" which airs on vh1 sunday 10/9c i wouldnt miss out on this if i were you cause its gon be fire

  • Oh my...this is absolutely beautiful!!!! It sent chills through me...just amazing

  • Comment removed

  • new album in stories now

  • her highly anticipation album "back to me" hits stores on aug 24

  • I could listen to this EVERYDAY! I pray that Fantasia let go of everyTHING and every PERSON (loved ones included) that is a hinderance, a weight, a leech or a liability to her life and career and get back to being who Fantasia really is. No confusion, drama, pressure, guilt or shame, in Jesus' name!

  • @MamaTrina AAAAAMMMMMMMENNNNA!!!!!

  • Listen to the song-spend it with her, it goes fast. The storm you are going through shall pass. You will be alright. Love you Fantasia. youre #1 fan.

  • brilliant

  • Once again beautiful job and a great cover of an amazing classic...

  • wow this is just as good as barbra.

  • The baddest baddest. That's all I will say...

  • I knew straight away when she sung this she would win. Fantastic song and she sings it very well.

  • This gave me chills 

  • O M G!!!! Beautiful performance!

  • Beautiful.

  • I never watched this season but Fantasia always sings her Idol songs like she was already a star

  • vote for fantasia new video "bittersweet" on 106&park or 79922 so we can get her on the countdown you guys

  • i would love to hear her record this song...absolutely beautiful!!!

  • She is absolutely fabulous here.

  • --ilOVE fANtASiA...ENOUGH SAiD!!!!!!! :)

  • wow! <3

  • attention all fantasia fans lets go out and request her new single "bittersweet" or buy it on itune so we can help this girl on the charts

  • some of her tones remind me of the wonderful nell carter... shit now i'm sad...

  • An example of almost forgotten talent, almost drowned by the rises of the new talents nowadays..

  • A mother's love at display in this performance. absolutely perfect.

  • you just can not do better than Fantasia !!!!

    release her new album already !!!! stop wasting her time. put up or release her and let her go make records elsewhere.........how can this girl NOT release an album every 2 years is beyond me.........

  • don t miss fantasia on american idol tonight at 9pm eastern singing her new single "bittersweet"

  • fantasia new song "bittersweet" is out know on the radios and itunes so go and buy and request her single on the radio

  • i always loved this performance, best idol season ever.

  • She is perfect!!!!! No other way to put it!!!

  • Lord Have Mercy! To have a love for Soulful music is just AMAZING!

  • This song is one of my favorites and Fantasia brought tears to my eyes. I love this girl because she sing's with such passion.

  • love love love! my most favorite song ever written.

  • don t miss fantasia on the mo'nique show tonight on bet

  • @rashard418 Do you stalk her or something? Or are you just obsessed?

  • @KrisAllisonKelly4evr gurl stop hating! he ain't nothing more than a loyal Tasia fan doing what all these other artists fanbase stay doing. Thats why they so popular - we need MORE like Rashard! Kudos to you @rashard418

  • @antyfreeman2008 Who said I hate Fantasia? I don't, at least as a person, honestly I don't really like her voice. It's just weird, because I'm trying to piece together all the past seasons of Idol on YouTube, and on every single Fantasia video I watched, rashard418 was promoting her new single. I suppose "stalk" was the wrong term to use- loyal fans do always know about their fav singer's singles- but I would call it a bit obsessive to be promoting the single on every single video.

  • @KrisAllisonKelly4evr you don t need to worry about what im doing you need go back to kris allison or kelly clarkson page and worry about them

  • beautiful.... fantasia mentioning barbara makes me appreciate her even more....

    both have this exceptionally rare talent of letting their souls sing... other singers just "perform" and don't feel anything except their vanity.

  • Yes, quote it. Sang by Babs herself!!  I love Barbra and Fantasia!!

  • It touches your heart that she is singing it for a little girl. This is the song that I think won the show for Fantasia. GREAT VOICE AND WONDERFUL SONG.

  • I remember rewinding this back over and over again. It was so haunting, so subdued for Fantasia, and she sold it for me. I'd dig it if she put out a song like this on one of her albums. Maybe later on in her career, right?

  • Good luck getting this released. I would buy an album of songs like this IF they made one. Instead they have her make albums aimed at kids. Well they made an album for an adult(Susan Boyle) and look at the success! If Fantasia or Melinda made an adult album I'd buy it in a second. I also bought a Paul Potts CD. Current score Britain's Got Talent 2 Idol 0...and I still watch. AND Katelyn Epperly was NOT too slow,just not marketable for kids but I was totally loving it!

  • meh...I love the original with Dusty.

  • Can't stop crying - beautiful, I wish Fantasia the happiest of lives x

  • Exquisite

  • just beautiful...nothing else needs to be said, when raw talent express it self.

  • i cried...

  • Me Too!!

  • She sings like a "TRUE PROFESSIONAL" what a WONDERFUL SINGER.. I CRIED TOO!

  • This is for all the haters, fantasia can sing anything i mean anything can't say that for most artist today. So this proves that she doesn't have to scream when she sings. Her voice range is amazing. She should be at the top and everyone knows it. Please stop the hating and give this girl the credit she derserves. You can see in every performance how she just sing from the heart and with everythings she has, because this is what god wanted her to do with the special gift that he gave her.

  • Fantasia sings this song beautifully and just ticks every box.

    Did she win?

    I cried when I saw it the first time, I don't know why but I did, hehe.

    Thankyou for posting :)

  • @KissedxByxJonasxBros Yup! She won :)

    & will be putting out her third album Spring of this year! Go get her new single "Even Angels" on iTunes right now! :)

  • This is the best interpretation of this song I have heard!!!.....

  • are you kidding?? seriously??? You should hear the original with Dusty

  • without words...absolutely beautiful..

  • That last note is beautiful.

  • This one is flawless

  • who's latoya?

  • @dalishus09 Latoya London was another contestant that season. Check out her performances of Don't Rain On My Parade and All By Myself

  • don t miss fantasia vh1 show "fantasia for real" that airs jan11

  • I remember when this first aired. I was getting my nails done. Everybody in the shop was crying. This is an old song that I had never paid any attention to, honestly. But the way this girl SANG this doggone SONG! Lord! If it's not already on an album, Fantasia, RECORD this song, baby! Beautiful!!

    I'm crying again now. ;D

  • this brings a tear to my eye...love it

  • THIS GIRL IS TALENTED

    This performace is TOP NOTCH. She is just like gladys night. Its crazy.

  • Fantasia is such a beautiful singer...this is moving...I wish she could have sung the entire song...

  • This was the first time Fantasia singin made me cry and I dont usually cry when people sing no matter how touching it is. This song was very powerful when she sang it and dedicated it to her daughter.

  • Two words...A...Mazing!!

  • Sing Tasia.

  • I just wanted to add to my post. Susan Boyle I understand is going to have 'Cry me a River' on her album which I'll be buying,but I can't buy Fantasia's music if it's intended for youth

  • so dumb! listen to the music and use yr brain!!

  • I love Fantasia and her voice but she needs to make an album of this style of music

  • whats happened to her, i have never even her sing songs like this man, pure foolishness shes sang needs to leave that label

  • As good as the Barbra or Sarah versions-Brava!

  • she is pretty even thogh she has short hair. you ain't got to have long hair to be beautiful, hayyy!! lol

  • @jagboola u made me sad when u said that and idk why

  • @jagboola WELL Y U MADE THT COMMENT...

  • @jagboola so true

  • Just beautiful!!!!!

  • I sure wish Fantasia would make music like this now... I don't think she knows how gifted she is.

  • Her interpertation was simply beautiful..without any of that growling she does sometimes..or any other effects..I love Fantasia..growls and all..lol...But the pureness of this vocal is amazing...

  • i really loved this song as sung by fantasia...

    it was the favorite performances of her...

    really even if then i was not a fan during that season....

    but with this song... I became a Fantasian...

  • jacklyn will never be a skilled vocally as this queen, tasia owned season 3 and u need to hear how much her vocals have grown since idol

  • she was small

  • "i like how she just sang it straight through with no vocal acrobats"

    Absolutely. Reminds me of Stevie Wonder, who can similarly captivate while singing a straight line. What it comes down to, IMO, is an absolutely sublime sense of rhythm; that's where Fantasia shits all over other vocalists. Listen to this a few times then try listening to ANY other version. It's hers now, IMO.

    Watch her full audition for Idol. She sings Killing Me Softly while snapping. Listen how she lays into that groove.

  • she sang proud mary by tina turner

  • "she sang proud mary by tina turner"

    That's what was broadcast, but it was almost an afterthought. The real audition was Killing Me Softly. Randy immediately starting moving to the rhythm, and Simon was completely absorbed, head titled, remarking afterwards, "You're one of the best we've ever had." He was actually concerned that it would hurt her in the competition; viewers like to see contestants grow on the show, and she was such a fully realized talent that she had almost nowhere to go.

  • Search "fantasia idol full audition".

  • love paulaaaaaaa

  • i like diana but i think fantasia was waay better. diana wasnt consistant in the competition

  • who is jaclyn?

  • What did he mean by "You and LaToya are just in a different league." Does that mean they're way better than the other three, or Fantasia's way better than LaToya, because the week right after, he told Diana she should be in the final two over LaToya?

  • Fantasia and Latoya are both in a higher league.

    That's pretty clear,no?

  • idk, He must've changed his mind in one week. That was a pretty quick jump over to the Diana Degarmo bandwagon. I always thought she had kind of a spark that LaToya didn't have.

  • this was the night she sealed the deal on the competition. no one could touch her after this.

  • oh my stars i freakin love this song !!!!!!!!!

  • soul...soul...and moh soul :)

  • Mane this lady is my Idol.... She gives me sooo much hope.... Shes beautiful, talented, and hasnt let her past get the best of her.... I LOVE FANTASIA!!!!!!

  • Thats My Girl !

  • what is paula wearing.

  • Product of poorly written contracts.. & the industry.

    Pure talent, genius actually. I'm still waiting to have this Fantasia in this day, instead of having to look back to Idol days.

  • Why isn't this Woman a HUGE STAR?! I adore Barbra S' and her versions punch me in the heart also. I didn't get to watch Idol this year, and I am sorry now. WOW she made it her own, I can only imagine how hard that is to do when a song is so intimately associated with a genius like Barbra. I just LOVE the fact that Fantasia's version is musically and even lyrically quite different from B's. It makes it easier for me to say look what these 2 AMAZING Women have created. Why isn't she a big star?

  • Fantasia - Love You SistaGirl - that's ONE of the songs I dedicated to my son - first and foremost though, it's Gladys Knight's "You're the Best Thing that Ever Happened to Me" - Praise God for our children!

  • malaysian idol JACLYN VICTOR IS THE BEST!

  • i just LOVE how BIG she got at the 1:20 mark

    SIMPLY BRILLIANT!!!!!!!

  • I completely agree. Its stunning, especially at that moment!

  • most underrated ai perfomance ever

  • Fantasia unplugged, c'mon J Records! Do I have to do your jobs for you?Fantasia's albums have been poorly promoted here in the UK but class will always shine through!

  • I've been looking for this song forever! I'm so glad I found it!

  • she reminds me malaysian idol jaclyn victor!

  • Yeah, but Jaclyn has a more powerful voice on high notes I think.

  • no, fantasia's range has really expanded since her surgery, u need to hear her, she is miles above jaclyn

  • power is not what makes a good singer. In fact, i tend to think that the really great singers are the ones who master the art of singing extremely delicately

  • I NEVEr said that power is what makes a good singer!!!!!!!

  • Very wonderful as always ..i never get tired of listening to this song

  • Fantastic. That was impeccable. I love that more than the Streisand version. BEAUTIFUL.

  • I just think this is one of American Idol's best performances ever!!!!

  • I agree!

  • Nice! I was not a huge fan but like her version of this song.

  • Wow!

  • Simon sucks at acting.. "honestly fantasia.." lol