Added: 3 years ago
From: CharmedEpisodes101
Views: 30,488
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (128)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I knew it was a pilot episode starring Lori Rom but I've never watched it until now.. I don't really like her, Alyssa is better! And I don't like Andy at all! The house is cool, is it the real one?

  • dont liked.  Alyssa milano is the best!

  • Someone tell me how old lori was when she was doing the pilot... I am dying to know, she looks in her 40s.

  • noooo andy is ugly!!!!!

  • The girl who played Phoebe is a good actress but wrong for the part. She comes across as way too together and way too confident. I also like Alyssa's timing better. This girl rushes her lines too much.

  • yeah, they definitely moved up in their quality of actors. I'm really glad they did; I don't think the show would have made it as long. Alyssa is perfect for the role!

  • Dude. Maybe of I hadn't already seen Alyssa this would have been alright, by my gosh they are SO different and Alyssa is SO much better.

  • When she got a premonition she didnt even react like Alyssa did. Im soo glad they made a change.

  • I have to admit. Milano is the superior actress.  Ted King was the better choice, too, for Andy.

  • I am so glad this pilot never aired. They have no emotion whatsoever. It is just funny to watch the bad acting

  • THIS EFFING SUCKS

    THANK GOD THEY GOT NEW ACTORS AND BETTER DIALOG !!!!!!!!!!

    AND THEY CHANGED THE HOUSE TOO!

  • It is incomprehensible seeing somebody else playing Phoebe besides Milano! I am glad Rom ended up leaving before th show aired .It is even strange seeing somebody else play Trudeau..

  • I think demons took the old pheobe's emotions and acting abilitys cause this pheobe sucks

  • i see why they didn't air this pilot...

  • The dialog in this pilot is absolutely terrible. Their reactions to events seems really fake. I'm glad Alyssa came into the picture. even the music is bad.

  • i agree, to good looking to be andy as he looks as though he could be a demon. where'as the other andy has an honest face. you can trust he is a good guy thru  and thru.

  • Didnt that cat ended up trying to kill them later in the series?

  • This Andy is kind of hot...

  • Boo on the Crappy Pheobe and BOOOO to the fake Andy!

  • its funny to see how it could have been, but i prefer alyssa as phoebe,,

  • Lori Rom has no emotion in her voice. its plain and boring .. anyone else notice?

  • Comment removed

  • This very first show was filmed in the actual house . It's amazing how different the Real series, house is laid out with bigger rooms and added rooms on the first floor and the way the attic looks, regarding the windows.

  • Alyssa Milano was/is the best Phoebe! I am glad they diodn't kept this fake ho, she tried too hard

  • im not sure how to react from this pilot with lori i mean she seems to be a great actris however i think alyssa milano fits beta as there sister. but not bad at all.. :)

  • @joshuaCmyers I think we are all used to Alyssa playing the role. this actress looked older and wasn't a good actress. she was also a fool for leaving a potential hit show. How many people want a sot at being a working actor and she throws it away? Shannen should have stayed with the show and delt with backstage problems. We dont always like who we work with but think of the career the money and the perks. Where else in the world can u play another person and make a good living?

  • Lori Rom's a fool to back out of this show. Aaron Spelling had more hit shows then flops. To be lucky to have made it in show biz then throw away a chance to be one of the 3 Stars of a show how dumb. Lori Romis basically an unknown now.The career, fulfilling a dreamand good pay, are all blessings that many take for granted. Asfor the off the set tensions should've been over looked. Do your job then go home. Biz & personal is what they should've separated We dont always get along with co-workers.

  • I really wish they had kept the "regardless of their gender." part it would have cleared up a lot of confusion

  • My god,this girl is bad! Alyssa is waaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyy better!!!!

  • Thank U Aaron Spelling 4 recasting the character of phoebe

  • Does EVERY comment have to pertain to Alyssa and Lori?

  • lmao @ Andy.

    Glad they changed the actors.

  • much better with alyssa milano. alyssa is PERFECT!!!

  • Andy isnt too bad.

    And if he was chosen for the actual role, we wouldn't know any diffferent so..

  • Lori should have been Prue :\

    But her acting kinda sucked, so....

  • Ok just actual LOL'd at that Andy, the one that replaced him definately fit better!

  • Plus wtf?! What happened to the house? Its so small and ugly. Oh and the other Andy is better than this one. Where is Darryl?

  • Its the same house but they shot it from the oposite angle and further away from the wall so it looks smaller. Dunno about the kitchen though. I think they remoddeled it differently for this and the real take.

  • @misschazzie171 This was the real house. In all the other episode,including the aired pilot,they used a set.

  • @misschazzie171 Some of the scenes i guess were filmed in the actual house (the red one) ...so some of the rooms you see are legit! Which is kind of cool when you think about it :)

  • Phoebe is susposed to the spunky, freespirited, rebellious sister. Lori is taller than prue and piper, she is not prettier enough, she looks older than prue and piper, her voice is deep plus her premonition faces suck. Alyssa is classic. She owned that role. Lets just face it: Alyssa is prettier, she is the same height as prue and piper, she is funnier and prettier and she is not acting too hard. She goes with the flow. Alyssa is the best hands down. No argument.

  • People don't need to be more attractive in movies just they're the lead characters. They can just be themselves.

  • i don´t like the fact that this Pheobe looks older than Piper and Prue, than Piper ok, but not older than Prue!!!

  • I´m so glad that they chossed Alyssa for this job... Don´t think charmed would be so important for me, if she would play phoebe...

  • YUCK!!! The girl who played Phoebe isnt good she seems too fake. Kind of like she has no real emotion unlike Alyssa Milano. The guy who played Andy is an ok actor but just not right for this kind of role.

  • @dolphinluva77 u no thats kinda mean what if lori rom saw this what if u made her cry?

  • oh a different andy and is that a different cat and i think Alyssa Milano is better than lori at being phoebe i don't no why but i just do.

  • lori is too butch...

    i dont mind he in the first part, but shes really weird in the rest.

    im so glad they had to replace her

  • i agree, I don't even know how she won the role in the first place.

  • omg ive only watched abit and lori is doing my head in ahahaha alyssa is soomuch better and soo is the other andy lori really cnt act no offence

  • Alyssa is so much better

  • The thing I don't get is why Lori even originally took phoebe's part. She had to have known when she auditioned that the show was about witches.

  • alyssas premonitions were ditzy and gaspy. over acted.

  • no they were better. C'mon you gotta admit alyssa plays a better phoebe.

  • Who the fuck is that Andy guy, he sucks as hell...

  • The Andy in this is way hotter than the other one !! and Lori does the permonitions better, doesnt sound like a sneeze compare to alyssa's. However, Lori doesnt play the part half as well as Alyssa so i wouldnt swap her for the world. Would defo swap the Andy's though, YUMMY !!

  • haha its kinda funny how when she hits the car and she flys over[lori] but like you wouldnt get up so fast, i did it b4 :) but no offense to her acting, but she sucks and if she and that other fake andy dude stayed, this show would suck, alyssa and the andy now is the best for it :)

  • @superdork4ever right thats what im saying plus that is the main reason why i started watching the show cause it had alyssa in it. i am named after her. im so happy they got her at the last minute.

  • Bottom line: Lori can't act if her life depended on it. She's not even "acting" like she's getting premonitions when she does get them. Her facial expressions don't even change when she's having a premonition and she looks MUCH older than the youngest sister here. And she looks awkward when she stands and walks; maybe it's her height or something.

  • i think alyssa is better

  • I supposeyou're right. Well,Alyssa is my preference anyway :)

  • Ok so if she would have stayed Shannen may have never left and Rose may have never come to the show. Also in what was that season 3 and for however long, Alyssa Milano and Julian Mcmahon's chemistry was so good like seriously they steamed up the television. No one can play Phoebe better than Alyssa Milano. And there would be no Paige which would have sucked.

  • Comment removed

  • Dont say bad about Lori, I know you guys would love her too if she continued doing Charmed. lmao

  • Fake pheobe on here alyssa rules

  • i think alyssa is so much better as phoebe.

  • how could she act like a mother since she's the youngest sister..? duh!

  • I so like real episode better.

  • This really is'nt good.. I don't like this version. Her premonition's do suck!!!

  • Isnt Pheobe Supposed To Play The Role As The Youngest Lori Looks Like Shes The Mother Of The Charmed Ones

  • the original pheobe is more natural~

  • Ths person posted this episode on my birthday

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • and it looks so lame and hilarious wiuth lori behind prue towering over her like prue should be behind her. it looks too much also like im super woman, but in the aired version it looked more natural. is it just me or does jeremy remind anyone of freddie kruger when he calls prue "bitch'

  • Comment removed

  • prue's eye squinting is hilarious here

  • yeah lori's premonition's do suck, her face is like "omg im seeing thing""i see dead people" lol apart from the dead people bit haha

  • eww i hate this lori girl and that guy who plays andy ted is better

  • lori's premonition sucks. it's nothing compared to alyssa's. here her face gives a "oh...i'm seeing stuff" look while alyssa gives it the "gasp! i see something!" look that so much better.

  • Lori is alright i mean they gave her a chance didn't they? and she wasn't really that bad was she? well they made the script anyways so it wasn't her fault she didn't act it rite well it was because she failed but you shouldn't of made her unhappy if she is looking at the compliments and they even changed the scrip it with Alyssa and she got to be on t.v and she's famous but in a bad way by complimenting on her in a bad way

  • lori sucks... she looks older than the other 2 sisters and supposed to be the youngest???? Gimme a break

  • i think lori rom did a great job :) okay nothing compares to alyssa milano ^^ .. lori rom is tall, so what? .. i'm four years older than my little sister and she's much taller than i .. siblings can look different xD f.e. prue has blue eyes piper, phoebe and paige not

  • please watch resident evil film( animated version) lori rom is there!

  • wow the house is very different!

  • Yeah, but I think it was a different cat in real life.

  • the first andy looks kinda gay..

  • oh man, lori is so wrong for the part. i'm so glad she quit. charmed would have been over if she was still phoebe. her face for the premonition was terrible.

  • watch resident evil ( CG FILM )

  • dont forget that the changes in scenario are not the actors' fault.. cause after this piloıt they changed some bits of that too

  • some differences i can fit in this. Phoebe brought the book downstairs only 2 have em run back up? No point. When she got the premonition, she was supposed 2 touch the pot, but she didnt touch anything. What happened 2 da birthday candle? They were supposed 2 be running downstairs, and have Prue open the door, but Jeremy did b/c of the premo screw up.Lori's face sucks @ premonition, looks like she's takin a dump or something IDK, not right.Prue ALWAYS takes the lead, and phoebe did in the spell

  • Well, this is for the 3rd part too...

  • Lori Rom is too tall, her car accident may have been the only thing that was a bit better, and it was slowed down, but her premonition face is like she has nothing at all, like she expected it, even though this is supposed to be something new to her. She looks and sounds too old to be the baby, and she is too tall!!! She seems too stiff to be free spirited. They all seem younger than her, and they skipped the scene where Phoebe shows that Prue's powers triggered by anger. The other Andy's cuter

  • i am glad that they changed the lori to alyssa,theres no charmed without alyssa.

  • alyssa looks more like their sister than lori

  • Alyssa is Italian, idiot.

  • Oh man, Lori is so wrong for the part...I just didn't buy it when she hid behind Prue. A few scenes have been added or deleted too, like the missing pharmacy scene.

  • THIS PHEOBE iiS WACK...ii HAVE WATCHED EVERY EPiiS0DE 0F CHARMED..AND Mii ALYSSA iiS DA BESTFOR THAT CHARCTER!! !!!

  • i know alyssa is the best for pheobe

  • Yeah, I think that I like Alyssa as Phoebe too. I don't know if it's because I have watched Charmed with Alyssa in it first, before seeing this, or what.

  • im glad they changed pheobe's character...its funny seeing a diff andy too....this is weird ....lol but i love me some charmed and im glad it turned out how it did

  • alyssa is italian

  • I prefer Alyssa ...

  • OMG she doesn't even know how to have a decent premonition. where's the "HUHGHHGHG!!!!!!!!" and the eyes closed? BAD ACTING plus I can't see her getting hot with cole lolz

  • is it me, or did it skip the powerscene from part 1 to part 2?

  • YAE THE PART WHERE PiiPER iiS G0iiNG TO WORK..AND PHOEBE iiS SiiTiiNG 0UT SiiDE!!

  • this phoebe is a suck head

  • There is an another Andy Trudeau too.. and the deisgn look differnt, but I like the other own more than this design. Thanx for uploading, it's a funny video!!

  • I am glad they cast Alyssa mIlano

  • thanks for uploadin!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more