I listen to this version all the time, i checked your page from time to time disappointed you were taking a hiatus! i seemed to had missed you by about a year, but kept coming back to listen to your covers of Shiny (over and over and over) , Street Spirit, Stray Cat, and red riding hood! Glad to see you are back ! your covers are beautiful.
@mckendo83 - thanks :) I am trying to come out of hiatus... as funding allows. but I have a facebook now, and am seriously making an album this year if it kills me. come visit! ...facebook.../TheBrooke.TheBand
@thebrooke forgot to mention fade into you - which is how i found you in the first place. I heard your version of shiny before i had heard colin meloys even haha so you turned me on the the decemberists.
I downloaded your version from your website....thanks, I really love listening to your take on this song, makes me feel I'm sitting in a coffe house watching ya play...thanks again
If I remember... It's like a B but only two strings of it (so the last three strings are open), then Em -- and you go back and forth between for that measure or whatever it is.
if you want my covers, I posted them all on my site recently. just go to the link which is on my youtube profile/channel, and from there, go to 'music'.
@kyle02 - the guitar pickup? I can't remember the name of it off-hand.. you can buy mine off me if you want. I don't use it anymore. private message me if you like.
On a different note though, you have a good ecclectic musical output. I wonder who you think are your favorite bands. I would like to hear you cover Siouxsie and the Banshees, if you are interested. Their covers of "Wheels on Fire" and "Dear Prudence" are different enough to warrant covering in the Siouxsie Sioux version, in my humble opinion.
I've never heard the World on Fire cover. I'm not a big fan of their version of Dear Prudence, but I may cover the original one of these days. thanks for the wishes of happiness. same to you :)
Dang it...You're married aye?! Well, okay. Duly noted. Sad that I doubt I will ever meet a lovely girl who can play the guitar half as well as you, but I wish you all the happiness in the world.
kgargano - Colin Meloy actually found this already and wrote me a really nice myspace message. It's funny, I live in his hometown, in the same neighborhood where he grew up, which I didn't even know until he told me.
its useless to say how yr voice is beautiful since everyone has already done that.. and the guitar is great too.. this makes me feel really sad about my decemberists covers.
Your are a very buetiful girl...I think Ive found my soulmate...too bad I'm married.(just kidding)Great voice and you show a great pasion for the music you sing hope to see more from you.....
I genuinely didn't think anyone could bring anything more to the decemberists music being as brilliant as they are. I was mistaken, this is awesome. It equals the original!
Thanks everyone! I've tried replying individually to some of you but the tube says no, not allowed, then cackles maniacally. Lets see if this one sneaks past.
i also left you a comment that hasn't appeared. thanks tube. basically, you're so good, the bands should thank you for covering them. you've turned me onto things i may have not added to my collection..but your versions are even better to me in a lot of cases. bust some richard marx or nelson, i bet you could even make them enjoyable, and that's nearly impossible.
oh. my GOD!!! Youtube is so messed up these days. I keep replying to these comments, and they keep not showing up. I reply again. Again, no showy uppy. I'm sorry guys.. I'm just not in the mood to re-re-reply right now. if this goes through, then I'll try.
Good God, Brooke, you voice is so amazingly beautiful! You need to start putting warnings on your videos, I'm a 29 year old man with tears in my eyes after hearing just the first 10 seconds of you singing this song. I wasn't ready for that. Get your ass into a studio and start recording this stuff for real... NOW! What's stopping you?
I thought I heard a second voice too, an octave down. You mean like at 1:41? I think the low guitar strings create that illusion whene'er that melody line comes up.
The Decemberists are great, very beautiful music! And here we have an awesome cover of yours! :) Maybe you don't like the kinda muted sound of your guitar, but I think exactly this is YOUR special and unique sound! Damn, I love your music!
great voice, and nice interpretation :)
arandomlandon 1 week ago
I listen to this version all the time, i checked your page from time to time disappointed you were taking a hiatus! i seemed to had missed you by about a year, but kept coming back to listen to your covers of Shiny (over and over and over) , Street Spirit, Stray Cat, and red riding hood! Glad to see you are back ! your covers are beautiful.
mckendo83 1 month ago
@mckendo83 - thanks :) I am trying to come out of hiatus... as funding allows. but I have a facebook now, and am seriously making an album this year if it kills me. come visit! ...facebook.../TheBrooke.TheBand
thebrooke 1 month ago
@thebrooke forgot to mention fade into you - which is how i found you in the first place. I heard your version of shiny before i had heard colin meloys even haha so you turned me on the the decemberists.
mckendo83 1 month ago
cld u angle cam @ fret @ all time so i cld play with you?lol
davidlucy0327 5 months ago
This is still my favorite interpretation of this song.
i3skate 5 months ago
:) perfect
disidente86 4 years ago
thanks a lot brooke. i found the website and downloaded the songs. im looking forward to your first album. you're going to be huge!
killerkeller914 4 years ago
You are absolutely amazing.
moomers81 4 years ago
this is so beautiful.
tearyeyedhobo 4 years ago
what is her website? i want to download this.
killerkeller914 4 years ago
thanks. you, and everyone. :) did you find my website? all the MP3s are there. the link is in the video description.
thebrooke 4 years ago
This is just beyond amazing
TymonBrown 4 years ago
one word, brilliant
yblad 4 years ago
wow great voice
Calviano360 4 years ago
You really remind me of Emily Haines from Metric when you sing.
psychomode14 4 years ago 2
you've got great feeling while you sing :)
Souperlative 4 years ago
you are great.. love your voice!
mirjulf 4 years ago
I downloaded your version from your website....thanks, I really love listening to your take on this song, makes me feel I'm sitting in a coffe house watching ya play...thanks again
hollywoodtsc 4 years ago
I love this song, but his voice kind of grates on me in this one. Your voice is really perfect for this song.
crimsonaneurysm 4 years ago
lovely,thanks.
davethecrow 4 years ago
wow
thank you
kennjad 4 years ago
can you point me to the correct tab for this song.. everything i find is wrong and crap.
i cant figure out the chord after the cm7.
justinhawaii 4 years ago
If I remember... It's like a B but only two strings of it (so the last three strings are open), then Em -- and you go back and forth between for that measure or whatever it is.
hope that made sense. :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
I, like, just wish you would sing to me forever.
smokebombhill 4 years ago
yeah brooke..ive been waiting for my LP of covers by le brooke..wtf
withtheirmachines 4 years ago
if you want my covers, I posted them all on my site recently. just go to the link which is on my youtube profile/channel, and from there, go to 'music'.
thebrooke 4 years ago
I mean I posted them as MP3s. also some that aren't on youtube.
thebrooke 4 years ago
amazing.
you have a very beautiful voice
w06flor 4 years ago
Really nice version, love that someone covered this song.
lorus87 4 years ago
F-A-N-T-A-S-T-I-C :P
smilie14 4 years ago
...and i love YOU! Great voice!
Creediskcens 4 years ago
I had never heard of decemberists before your version. I'm seeing them in Wolverhampton (England) on friday as a new fan - cant wait.
They will do well to beat your version of shiny though!!
painterman272003 4 years ago
Great job.
Whats that guitar mic called and how much did it cost?
kylek02 4 years ago
thanks peeps :)
@kyle02 - the guitar pickup? I can't remember the name of it off-hand.. you can buy mine off me if you want. I don't use it anymore. private message me if you like.
thebrooke 4 years ago
You should do more Decemberists covers. This is amazing
thekingadrock46 4 years ago
you have a wonderful voice
spanwayhits 4 years ago
On a different note though, you have a good ecclectic musical output. I wonder who you think are your favorite bands. I would like to hear you cover Siouxsie and the Banshees, if you are interested. Their covers of "Wheels on Fire" and "Dear Prudence" are different enough to warrant covering in the Siouxsie Sioux version, in my humble opinion.
xsntt 4 years ago
I've never heard the World on Fire cover. I'm not a big fan of their version of Dear Prudence, but I may cover the original one of these days. thanks for the wishes of happiness. same to you :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
Dang it...You're married aye?! Well, okay. Duly noted. Sad that I doubt I will ever meet a lovely girl who can play the guitar half as well as you, but I wish you all the happiness in the world.
xsntt 4 years ago
Wow... I never thought I could love this song more, but after this, I do. I, too, would be pleased if I were Colin.
speakertone 4 years ago
if its not to foward wats ur myspace adress?
perzo449 4 years ago
it's on my channel, but it's /thebrooke13
thebrooke 4 years ago
i think umm... yeah... i think im going to marry you. is that okay?? :) but really, wowie wowow!!! so good.
gprentice303 4 years ago
gprentice303: Somebody beat you to it kid. But thanks for askin. :)~
and thanks for the enthusiastic comment. :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
haha. i sorta figured it out after watching the rest of your videos... the ring is a dead giveaway!
hope to see more videos soon!
gprentice303 4 years ago
I'm pretty sure Colin Meloy would be very, very proud...
kgargano 4 years ago
Thanks so much guys :)
kgargano - Colin Meloy actually found this already and wrote me a really nice myspace message. It's funny, I live in his hometown, in the same neighborhood where he grew up, which I didn't even know until he told me.
thebrooke 4 years ago
That's...INSANE! And awesome :)
kgargano 4 years ago
wow that was a really good cover. really nice voice.
the only mistake i saw was on the chorus when he sings LIED.. you played a Bm but its actually a b7.
but i really liked it
EvanB111 4 years ago
Please. PLay some Elliot Smith, you might like......
wheresmyslurpee 4 years ago
okay, i have not idea who this band is, but now i love 'em.... do you have any of your own stuff? curious to hear...
wheresmyslurpee 4 years ago
i luv u !!! :)
xrage611x 4 years ago
It's such a beautiful song... You have such a beautiful voice. Thank You Brook.
xaviertroendle 4 years ago
Where did you find those chords?
Great cover. I love the smokey bar, late at night, mellow kind of tone of your voice!
robertastrauss 4 years ago
Thanks Robert and everybody :)
Robert, you can get the chords to this if you follow the link I put in the description there.
thebrooke 4 years ago
Or wait, is it Roberta? Sorry. :)~
thebrooke 4 years ago
Yep, a lovely song by such a very talented song writer. Again, your vocals are wonderful. Beautiful.
N3XU551X 4 years ago
well how do you know how old i am?
i could be a 50 year old man for ll you know
((but dont worry, im not..))
emojuiceboxkid 4 years ago
oh god youre hot...
and you can sing...
hey, how old are you anyway?
emojuiceboxkid 4 years ago
I'm significantly older than you.
thanks though!
thebrooke 4 years ago
hey.. what about you covering engine driver by decemberists? I would love to hear it with yr voice..
well, just an idea, you probably are busy with the album thingy and stuff.. but it would be really nice anyway.
cron0 4 years ago
I love that song. I'd like to do it sometime for sure. :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
I'm actually a bigger fan of your cover than the actual song. Beautiful.
negativenone 4 years ago
that's silly... but I'll take it. hehee, thanks! :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
thanks :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
dear god..
its useless to say how yr voice is beautiful since everyone has already done that.. and the guitar is great too.. this makes me feel really sad about my decemberists covers.
cron0 4 years ago
noooo... don't feel sad! thanks though. Are your covers on youtube? I go check. :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
they are.. but they are not even close of yours. and my creepy guitar doesnt help.
cron0 4 years ago
wow brooke... i really liked it. Nice job.
boopsie18 4 years ago
very different from the original. I Like both. You have a nice voice :)
HoldeMaid 4 years ago
excellent..your voice is so soothing
scotch59 4 years ago
I like you people :)
Thanks for the kindness
thebrooke 4 years ago
Your are a very buetiful girl...I think Ive found my soulmate...too bad I'm married.(just kidding)Great voice and you show a great pasion for the music you sing hope to see more from you.....
hollywoodtsc 4 years ago
Your voice could probably soothe even a Tyrannosaurus Rex, and that's pretty rad. Keep it up!
FortesquesEye 4 years ago
tight, could you send me the tabs?
astn135 4 years ago
This is lovely and mellow. Great cover!
onloop 4 years ago
I genuinely didn't think anyone could bring anything more to the decemberists music being as brilliant as they are. I was mistaken, this is awesome. It equals the original!
983gold 4 years ago
cover me. i'll sing one of yours, you sing one of mine, we'll put it on youtube see if anyone notices.
bittermint 4 years ago
Fcking nice/////////////////
Tajpek 4 years ago
Ok first of all I love the Decemberists, second of all I love your voice. It reminds me of Cat Power but not (if that makes any sense)!
Oh and your hand crafted soul infused bamboo pendants are rather snazzy!
BuckCompton 4 years ago
Thanks! I thought nobody called things snazzy anymore but me. :)
thebrooke 4 years ago
make the cd and i'll buy it
robbi23 4 years ago
really, really awesome.
mattm08 4 years ago
Have you ever heard of the band Stars??
you sound very familiar the the female vocals...beautiful
slaglesbagels 4 years ago
Sweet, sweet vocal. Try Across The Universe by John Lennon. Maybe some Karen Carpenter too...
LeilaniRocks 4 years ago
hmm....your awesome...just so you know..lol
:)
desertgirl913 4 years ago
Thanks everyone! I've tried replying individually to some of you but the tube says no, not allowed, then cackles maniacally. Lets see if this one sneaks past.
thebrooke 4 years ago
i also left you a comment that hasn't appeared. thanks tube. basically, you're so good, the bands should thank you for covering them. you've turned me onto things i may have not added to my collection..but your versions are even better to me in a lot of cases. bust some richard marx or nelson, i bet you could even make them enjoyable, and that's nearly impossible.
rivatoot 4 years ago
HA! nice suggestions. don't tempt me.
thebrooke 4 years ago
oh. my GOD!!! Youtube is so messed up these days. I keep replying to these comments, and they keep not showing up. I reply again. Again, no showy uppy. I'm sorry guys.. I'm just not in the mood to re-re-reply right now. if this goes through, then I'll try.
thebrooke 4 years ago
Good God, Brooke, you voice is so amazingly beautiful! You need to start putting warnings on your videos, I'm a 29 year old man with tears in my eyes after hearing just the first 10 seconds of you singing this song. I wasn't ready for that. Get your ass into a studio and start recording this stuff for real... NOW! What's stopping you?
zoathias 4 years ago
ooh man you have been realy bizzy lately,with al your new vid's!but hey it's pretty awesome.love the mysterious touch to it
dapf5 4 years ago
Really really nice. I love Decemberists, though I haven't heard this song before. You performed it superbly. P.S. nice website.
NamelessLT 4 years ago
Sounds layered with a second voice in places. Did you change the delay? Whatever you did, it sounds gooooood.
Lovely song -- I'd never heard it before, but I enjoyed it nonetheless. Only one thing remains now... an original Brooke tune for us to hear!
SicTransitGloria1982 4 years ago
I thought I heard a second voice too, an octave down. You mean like at 1:41? I think the low guitar strings create that illusion whene'er that melody line comes up.
acousvnt 4 years ago
thanks for letting me watch it.and it's nice!
wadimayuki 4 years ago
love it.
GottfriedGeist 4 years ago
really awesome :)
desertgirl913 4 years ago
The Decemberists are great, very beautiful music! And here we have an awesome cover of yours! :) Maybe you don't like the kinda muted sound of your guitar, but I think exactly this is YOUR special and unique sound! Damn, I love your music!
Kris
KrisShred 4 years ago
thank you. :)
thebrooke 4 years ago