I'm impressed that there is an organ transcription for this piece. A number of years ago when I had access to a church organ the best I could find was a reduction for piano. So blessings to the woman who did this transcription. I hope she publishes it 'cause if I ever have access to a pipe organ again I'll buy a copy.
@gramps2matt Dorothy Papadakos was, until around 2002, the organist at St. John the Divine. I'm not aware of any publication of this particular transcription; I do know that she recorded several CD's (still available) featuring her compositions & improvisations. Last I heard, she was living & working in Wilmington, NC.
I don't think its possible to keep these things in tune. But what a cool job regardless :) I would do it as volunteer work, just going there every few weeks and tuning those monsters. I'd end up going deaf after a while even with protection I shouldn't wonder...
Are those Tubas really that powerful at 1:18 (relative to the 50" wind pressure State Trumpet), or is the mic just alot closer to the Tubas/the main organ than it is to the State Trumpets?
This recording is actually distorting my speakers... see Dorothy Papadakos' recording of this piece on the CD series "The Great Pipe Organs of NYC" for a slightly more balanced recording of this. Glad you posted this -- but the balance on the tubas is waaaay overpowering, at least on my lil sound system.
@sailormann1 I'm not an audiophile, just an organ-lover with a Zoom H2 digital recorder about the size of a cigarette pack. Yes, I was sitting (with my recorder) in the choir stalls, right under the main organ, so the tubas would, quite naturally, be closer to the recording source, given that the State Trumpets are a city block away from the main organ.
Overall, a very exciting rendition quite well recorded considering the situation, up to your usual very high standards. Thank you very much. BTW, the quoted 601' length is west rose window to east apse window; I would estimate that the State Trumpet is about 500' away from the rest of the organ, still a very considerable distance; and none of my comments are meant to detract from the size of the edifice, or the majesty of the sound. Thanks again!
Looked into Amazon on this recording device ... definitely quite the instrument to capture on location performances...! Bet one could take this unit at St. Sulpice and really do some capturing..!
I bet recording in the size of this venue is like recording the Midmer-Loch at Boardwalk Hall (Atlantic City Convention Center) in Atl. City (when that organ was fully functioning ) - so much magnitude to capture within the sheer limitations of the recording devices that it's really impossible to capture the complete aura of dynamics. The ear just has to be there personally to get the full experience. Congrats on the capture - it was fantastic!
@DSM1G90 All thanks due to my little Zoom H2. It's the size of a cigarette pack, but packs quite a recording punch (They're not paying me for this testimonial, BTW ;-)
When the final trumpets blow announcing the coming of our Lord, watch as the atheists fall to their knees not a moment after we who crave His return! The spiritual tsunami will have its intended effect.
You captured "it" . . I was there last summer, and it was 115 on the front steps . . Anyone who has been around the big east coast organs knows that Summertime tuning is "unique"
@Coandar It's extremely difficult to adjust my recorder to deal with the big sound close-up & pick up the State Trumpets. In addition, I'm not a recording engineer -- just an organ nut.
@a55b47 Before the recent Quimby rebuild, the recording 'sweet spot' in St. John was about 20 feet west of the Choir steps in the Crossing. This allowed the State Trumpet and the main instrument to be balanced fairly well. Now that the rebuilt instrument has more 'presence' in the room (due to a variety of factors), the sweet spot is farther west - closer to the State Trumpet.. During the recent recital series in Oct. of 2009 and Apr. of 2010, I found this was the best listening location..
@livzdave Thanks for the info. This was my first visit to St. J the D since the re-installation, & I sat in the choir so I could hear Bill Randolph give his spiel during the Monday organ demonstration. My daughter's looking seriously at Columbia as a college possibility, so I may be making more frequent visits to Morningside Heights ;-)
Golly, when that thing's out of tune it sounds like the horn on the Devil's ship!
TheMysticalOrgan 2 weeks ago
Very enjoyable thank you
osclarkos 3 weeks ago
I'm impressed that there is an organ transcription for this piece. A number of years ago when I had access to a church organ the best I could find was a reduction for piano. So blessings to the woman who did this transcription. I hope she publishes it 'cause if I ever have access to a pipe organ again I'll buy a copy.
gramps2matt 1 month ago
@gramps2matt Dorothy Papadakos was, until around 2002, the organist at St. John the Divine. I'm not aware of any publication of this particular transcription; I do know that she recorded several CD's (still available) featuring her compositions & improvisations. Last I heard, she was living & working in Wilmington, NC.
a55b47 1 month ago
It would be awesome to hear this magnificent tune when Christ splits the skies at the final call!
BigDaddyOldDude 3 months ago
The most majestic of instruments!
BigDaddyOldDude 3 months ago
Listen to the POWERFUL of this ORGAN. Wow! Bravo! They must have put a ORGAN BLOWER as large as the Empire State Building! POWERFUL...Yes!
Mighty! Awesome!!!!!!
Chesterbarnes1 4 months ago 2
I don't think its possible to keep these things in tune. But what a cool job regardless :) I would do it as volunteer work, just going there every few weeks and tuning those monsters. I'd end up going deaf after a while even with protection I shouldn't wonder...
eliotcantsing 5 months ago
Are those Tubas really that powerful at 1:18 (relative to the 50" wind pressure State Trumpet), or is the mic just alot closer to the Tubas/the main organ than it is to the State Trumpets?
This recording is actually distorting my speakers... see Dorothy Papadakos' recording of this piece on the CD series "The Great Pipe Organs of NYC" for a slightly more balanced recording of this. Glad you posted this -- but the balance on the tubas is waaaay overpowering, at least on my lil sound system.
sailormann1 5 months ago
@sailormann1 I'm not an audiophile, just an organ-lover with a Zoom H2 digital recorder about the size of a cigarette pack. Yes, I was sitting (with my recorder) in the choir stalls, right under the main organ, so the tubas would, quite naturally, be closer to the recording source, given that the State Trumpets are a city block away from the main organ.
a55b47 5 months ago 2
@a55b47 use audacity (free) and a nyquist fileter called clipfix (free). it will likely fix this.
dmph3 3 months ago
ethereal!! Stunning! Speechless!
accousticdecay 5 months ago
Overall, a very exciting rendition quite well recorded considering the situation, up to your usual very high standards. Thank you very much. BTW, the quoted 601' length is west rose window to east apse window; I would estimate that the State Trumpet is about 500' away from the rest of the organ, still a very considerable distance; and none of my comments are meant to detract from the size of the edifice, or the majesty of the sound. Thanks again!
trompettechamade1 5 months ago
You just made a masterpiece!!!!! I really love it!
Congrats Robert!!!!
MsContessina 6 months ago
Looked into Amazon on this recording device ... definitely quite the instrument to capture on location performances...! Bet one could take this unit at St. Sulpice and really do some capturing..!
DSM1G90 6 months ago
I bet recording in the size of this venue is like recording the Midmer-Loch at Boardwalk Hall (Atlantic City Convention Center) in Atl. City (when that organ was fully functioning ) - so much magnitude to capture within the sheer limitations of the recording devices that it's really impossible to capture the complete aura of dynamics. The ear just has to be there personally to get the full experience. Congrats on the capture - it was fantastic!
DSM1G90 6 months ago 2
@DSM1G90 All thanks due to my little Zoom H2. It's the size of a cigarette pack, but packs quite a recording punch (They're not paying me for this testimonial, BTW ;-)
a55b47 6 months ago
Anyway I can down load this on Itunes or MP3?
railroadjay1 6 months ago
@railroadjay1 I use TubeSock -- download-able for 15 bucks. You can then download audio & video -- or just audio.
a55b47 6 months ago
I would LOVE to hear this instrument in person!
zbaf6 6 months ago
even though the audio is distorted, I know it's because of the sheer power of this instrument, so I don't mind it.
tylergig 6 months ago
Trumpets need abit more weight behind them!
3dwurli 10 months ago
@livzdave:
Superb video/photos of both a Great Cathedral featuring that Trumpet Organ and a Classic American Composer Aaron Copland!
Visited Saint Johns about five years ago, stunned by it's sheer size and beauty.
Bigu47 11 months ago
Amazing power demonstrated by the great Trumpet Organ of a classic song by the renowned American Composer Aaron Copland.
Bigu47 11 months ago
Amazing in that the State Trumpet is almost 601 feet from the main organ...love it!
oofahman 1 year ago
When the final trumpets blow announcing the coming of our Lord, watch as the atheists fall to their knees not a moment after we who crave His return! The spiritual tsunami will have its intended effect.
SnoozeButton57 1 year ago
The sound of the State Trumpet never fails to make my eyes fill with water... its breath-taking. Absolutely breath-taking.
AMGBenzS65 1 year ago
Got to hear this in person in July. I had gosebumps the whole time. That 6 second reverbaration is simply amazing.
wpiv926 1 year ago
I can never get enough of that awesome State Trumpet stop and the incredible reverberation of the vast acoustics. Absolutely spin tingling
tamiasthechipmunk 1 year ago
Muy buena esta interpretación.
Un saludo.
lechanavarro 1 year ago
Excellent! Really nice pictures as well.
organblower 1 year ago
You captured "it" . . I was there last summer, and it was 115 on the front steps . . Anyone who has been around the big east coast organs knows that Summertime tuning is "unique"
SuperElBorba 1 year ago
Its not tuning :-(
engelbertschoormans 1 year ago
Terrific....
silverstartrucker 1 year ago
"Awe-inspiring" just hits it right! If only the recording was a little less distorted...
Coandar 1 year ago 2
@Coandar It's extremely difficult to adjust my recorder to deal with the big sound close-up & pick up the State Trumpets. In addition, I'm not a recording engineer -- just an organ nut.
a55b47 1 year ago 4
@a55b47 I know the feeling...but the recordings I made at the AGO convention a week or so ago came out great
bombarde1701a 1 year ago
@a55b47 Before the recent Quimby rebuild, the recording 'sweet spot' in St. John was about 20 feet west of the Choir steps in the Crossing. This allowed the State Trumpet and the main instrument to be balanced fairly well. Now that the rebuilt instrument has more 'presence' in the room (due to a variety of factors), the sweet spot is farther west - closer to the State Trumpet.. During the recent recital series in Oct. of 2009 and Apr. of 2010, I found this was the best listening location..
livzdave 1 year ago
@livzdave Thanks for the info. This was my first visit to St. J the D since the re-installation, & I sat in the choir so I could hear Bill Randolph give his spiel during the Monday organ demonstration. My daughter's looking seriously at Columbia as a college possibility, so I may be making more frequent visits to Morningside Heights ;-)
a55b47 1 year ago
It's glorious despite the distortion! I long for proper equipment for my videos!
irkibby 1 year ago
@a55b47 the best device to replay a good recording of this is a Class A triode without a transformer in the output.
gzaenker 1 month ago