It is racist - even more- Nazis book , because Art Spigelmann presents Polish prisoners of this horrible camp like swines ...which is Nazis way . This way German Nazis treated Polish people during their occupation of Poland - they beated Polish people , called them swines ( you Polish swine!) . This book breaks American law - I mean law forbidding discrimination of people because of their nationality ( Sec. 601, Civil Rights Act of 1964; 78 Stat. 252; 42 U.S.C. 2000d )
During WWII German Nazis killed or persecuted about 9 million Polish people ( I mean ethnic Poles )The Germans killed the most of 3 millions Poles . They made thousands executions killing hundreds thousands Polish people . They threw out from houses near 2 470 000 Poles . They deported to force work about 2 460 000 Polish people , part of them did not come back to Poland . The Germans destroyed millions Polish houses. The Germans burnt about 800 Polish villages
@muyaa That's the thing that struck me most about the book. The kids and I have tried to count the many exceptional things Vladek did, which kept him alive. All those things which kept him from being winnowed out with the rest. And imagine the physical stamina and force of will that such survival would require.
One hopes the Spiegelman genetics have been passed on...
SWINE ISNT BAD! God, the Nazis weren't swine for a reason. It was because the nazis (Cats) were feared (mainly) by the jews (Mice). I think you know about the relationship between cats and mice and how the cat dominates the mouse (unless its in a Tom And Jerry cartoon). Anyway, Artie wasn't being racist, it was just showing that a pig was a Pole just like a mouse was a jew and a cat was a nazi and a dog was a American etc. Just stop getting angry about it and read the book before you get angry.
A work of art. I like that it's not all about the Nazis and Jews, but about family and relationships. It makes me feel that I am reading about and actual person instead of just a writer. Also, it was very crafty of him to make people from different backgrounds different animals.
this book is sad and made me relise the kind of pain they whent through it wasnt just jews being chucked into camps it was a bit more emotional and complicated than i thought i wish this never happend but tha twould mean we would not have been born and possible a person more dangerous would have taken power. truely magnificent book = ]
I agree with Jeronimo. It's unfortunate that the words "comic" and "cartoon" conjure up connotations of laughter. Speigelman never intended his work to be "comic" in that sense, he simply chose a different and incredibly effective media for telling his father's Holocaust story. It's prime Holocaust literature - please read before you judge.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I Have read enough about this jewish scauvinist and Pole-eater. Art Spiegelman.He presented Poles as swines in his comics and that way he beahved just like Nazi . German nazists terribly persecuted poles and other Slavs, but necroracist USA reduces WWII only to Jewish holocaust - this is necroracism : racism towards not Jewish victims of WWII.Hitler called to total war against Poland but necroracist USA appreciates only jewish holocaust.
According to Generaplan Ost German nazists planned extermination millions Slavs including 85% Poles. That's way Germans made thousands massive executions killing Poles, burnt 800 Polish villages ( together with killing Polish peasants), Germans deported 2,8 millions Poles to force work in Germany, hundred thousands Poles closed in German camps, killed 200 000 Poles during Warsaw Uprising in 1944.
But Jewish schauvinist Art Spiegelman presented Poles as swines.. behaving just like Nazi swine.
It was his artistic choice to portray everyone in Maus according to Nazi stereotypes. Slavs were rabbits, French were frogs and both American and Russians were dogs.
He wasen`t persenting them as a swine in a bad way....he wasen`t trying to be raciest.......swines are also smart and heathy......calm down.....its like saying the Americans were dogs or bitchs....that it was raicestly choicen...but it wasen`t it was just a way of seeing.
all non jews are shown as pigs.. germans as cats english as fish and americans as dogs..
It would be interesting is someone would do a graphic book about the poles in Poles in Siberia & Iran or about the Katyn massacre or all the other things that happened in russia under stalin.
I totally forgot about this. I read this book when I was still a teenager. I only read it once, but it I was really impressed and I suddenly remember it now. I've never been that into comic books, but Art Spiegelman makes me want to change that.
He portrayed the Jews as mice and the Germans as cats because that is a predator/prey relationship. That and the Nazis described Jews as "vermin", which mice fit into. It's as much a story of Art's life as it is of his father, who survived the concentration camps. Maybe you should read it before you judge it.
i hate when stupid anime fanboys always say america or the west in general can't release good comic literature. they need to be handed a copy of maus which will hopefully shut their fucking mouths up.
but then again, the intellectual capacity of maus is probably too much for the anime/manga crowd to handle
fluffy, "intellectual capacity" concering comics and media is a pretty vauge descritption of a reader. What is the staple of this? I like manga and find the material very stimulating. I have also found that American Comics much of the time are an excuse for a soap box which I don't find as stimulating or entertaining.
this is my personal opinion but i really hate manga. i think it's filled to the core with gratuitous violence, unnecessary sex, and tons and tons of Japanese nationalism (just look at that anti-Korean one that was released a few years back). i agree, you will definitely find that in American comics (anything written by frank miller) but I think Maus trumps all that overrated and overhyped manga shit.
don't take it personally, i was just venting about stupid ass anime fans on youtube.
Yea, individual taste counts for allot. There are allot of titles with violence and sex and them. Don't forget there are "cute" titles as well. As for nationalism I am sure there are titles that represent this but my experience in reading there was actual questioning of the government such as Battle Royale in a fictional facist Japan.
No, its nothing personal. I just wanted you to know for some Manga is actually very thought provoking and stimulating. All reletaive right? Take care.
That was interesting. I really liked it. Excellent music, by the way. I love Pirates of the Caribbean! Amazing just how well that music fit the video.
"Obviously there is no meaning of history, that can be rescued having turned one's back to auschwitz, no truth of history, that can be defended having turned one's back to auschwitz and no god to be worshipped, having turned one's back to auschwitz." j.b. metz
"Obviously there is no meaning in history, that can be rescued having turned one's back to auschwitz, no truth of history, that can be defended having turned one's back to auschwitz and no god to be worshipped with one's back to auschwitz." j b metz.
"Offenbar gibt es keinen Sinn der Geschichte, den man mit dem Rücken zu Auschwitz retten kann, keine Wahrheit der Geschichte, die man mit dem Rücken zu Auschwitz verteidigen und keinen Gott, den man mit dem Rücken zu Auschwitz anbeten kann."
This has been flagged as spam show
It is racist - even more- Nazis book , because Art Spigelmann presents Polish prisoners of this horrible camp like swines ...which is Nazis way . This way German Nazis treated Polish people during their occupation of Poland - they beated Polish people , called them swines ( you Polish swine!) . This book breaks American law - I mean law forbidding discrimination of people because of their nationality ( Sec. 601, Civil Rights Act of 1964; 78 Stat. 252; 42 U.S.C. 2000d )
inika17 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@inika17
During WWII German Nazis killed or persecuted about 9 million Polish people ( I mean ethnic Poles )The Germans killed the most of 3 millions Poles . They made thousands executions killing hundreds thousands Polish people . They threw out from houses near 2 470 000 Poles . They deported to force work about 2 460 000 Polish people , part of them did not come back to Poland . The Germans destroyed millions Polish houses. The Germans burnt about 800 Polish villages
inika17 4 weeks ago
Art Spieglemen also died... in 1991
TheKhaoticKitty 11 months ago
@TheKhaoticKitty no it's wrong
soosdu29 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jews are rats, they deserved the holocaust ;)
SoyMejorQueTu 1 year ago
@SoyMejorQueTu just as jackasses are really jackasses and should be slaughtered and turned into glue?
Gamer4672 4 months ago
best book/comic ever red!
MATILDA800able 1 year ago
I read both books pretty good
Boot1998 1 year ago
I praise Maus as an amazing and tragic novel and that everybody should read it
Rest in peace Vladek and Anja Spiegelman
Hell6125 1 year ago
its my favorite comic/book =)
mynastylife 1 year ago
@ImmortalEye666 excuse me?
FRANKyyyyy100 1 year ago
i wanna meet him!!!!
shortkid614 1 year ago
Mala drives me MESUGAH! -Vladek Spiegelman
younameit34 2 years ago
I just finished reading it... I am still shocked...
elekenek 2 years ago
Really? It's true that it's quite touching, but what amazed me the most is the cleverness of Vladek Spiegelman!
He did wanted to live, and I really admire that.
muyaa 1 year ago
@muyaa That's the thing that struck me most about the book. The kids and I have tried to count the many exceptional things Vladek did, which kept him alive. All those things which kept him from being winnowed out with the rest. And imagine the physical stamina and force of will that such survival would require.
One hopes the Spiegelman genetics have been passed on...
megaswenson 1 year ago
in slovenia was released 3 years ago
okoljevarstvenik 2 years ago
Just started reading Maus II,the first was so good,now this one I cant wait.
mawster88rsname 2 years ago
SWINE ISNT BAD! God, the Nazis weren't swine for a reason. It was because the nazis (Cats) were feared (mainly) by the jews (Mice). I think you know about the relationship between cats and mice and how the cat dominates the mouse (unless its in a Tom And Jerry cartoon). Anyway, Artie wasn't being racist, it was just showing that a pig was a Pole just like a mouse was a jew and a cat was a nazi and a dog was a American etc. Just stop getting angry about it and read the book before you get angry.
Iman446 2 years ago
A work of art. I like that it's not all about the Nazis and Jews, but about family and relationships. It makes me feel that I am reading about and actual person instead of just a writer. Also, it was very crafty of him to make people from different backgrounds different animals.
Iman446 2 years ago
I want to read the book!!!! These mice do what regular humans can't > touch the heart!
superCatia 2 years ago
it gooood book, I read it long time ago.
mahender6969 2 years ago
Do you have the book? In my country it is a recently released book.
superCatia 2 years ago
I bought mine in 1987. (Denmark)
Harkhoost 2 years ago
man Vladek (the survivor portrayed in the book) was a smart guy.
i wish i could have met him.
Sotar 2 years ago
this book is sad and made me relise the kind of pain they whent through it wasnt just jews being chucked into camps it was a bit more emotional and complicated than i thought i wish this never happend but tha twould mean we would not have been born and possible a person more dangerous would have taken power. truely magnificent book = ]
ThyUnknown 2 years ago
Great book, both of them were.
DerrickBouchard 2 years ago
if any one read watchmen they would like maus you would have it done in about 3 days
andybigmac123 2 years ago
what song is this?
theguywhomakesmovies 2 years ago
Pirates of the Carribean, Dead Mans Chest.
Harkhoost 2 years ago
THE MOST IMPORTANT COMIC EVER WRITTEN
jamesaellis 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stupid idea - make COMICs comics about holocaust ..
Holocaust wasn't COMIC...
SANARIA7 2 years ago
read it first please. this isn't a Comic. it's litrature.
jeronimo486 2 years ago 2
I agree with Jeronimo. It's unfortunate that the words "comic" and "cartoon" conjure up connotations of laughter. Speigelman never intended his work to be "comic" in that sense, he simply chose a different and incredibly effective media for telling his father's Holocaust story. It's prime Holocaust literature - please read before you judge.
Louiseaus 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I Have read enough about this jewish scauvinist and Pole-eater. Art Spiegelman.He presented Poles as swines in his comics and that way he beahved just like Nazi . German nazists terribly persecuted poles and other Slavs, but necroracist USA reduces WWII only to Jewish holocaust - this is necroracism : racism towards not Jewish victims of WWII.Hitler called to total war against Poland but necroracist USA appreciates only jewish holocaust.
SANARIA7 2 years ago
According to Generaplan Ost German nazists planned extermination millions Slavs including 85% Poles. That's way Germans made thousands massive executions killing Poles, burnt 800 Polish villages ( together with killing Polish peasants), Germans deported 2,8 millions Poles to force work in Germany, hundred thousands Poles closed in German camps, killed 200 000 Poles during Warsaw Uprising in 1944.
But Jewish schauvinist Art Spiegelman presented Poles as swines.. behaving just like Nazi swine.
SANARIA7 2 years ago
It was his artistic choice to portray everyone in Maus according to Nazi stereotypes. Slavs were rabbits, French were frogs and both American and Russians were dogs.
pytko3 2 years ago 2
He wasen`t persenting them as a swine in a bad way....he wasen`t trying to be raciest.......swines are also smart and heathy......calm down.....its like saying the Americans were dogs or bitchs....that it was raicestly choicen...but it wasen`t it was just a way of seeing.
MonakoSM 2 years ago
Its only one story about that terrible century..
all non jews are shown as pigs.. germans as cats english as fish and americans as dogs..
It would be interesting is someone would do a graphic book about the poles in Poles in Siberia & Iran or about the Katyn massacre or all the other things that happened in russia under stalin.
You can't tell all the stories in one book
6079smythw 2 years ago
SANARIA7 you really haven't a clue have you? Read the book before you comment on it.
almanacofsleep 2 years ago
I totally forgot about this. I read this book when I was still a teenager. I only read it once, but it I was really impressed and I suddenly remember it now. I've never been that into comic books, but Art Spiegelman makes me want to change that.
Naomi5362 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
For Germans Jews were rats or cockroachs. Why didn't he present Jews as rats or cockroachs?
Why didn't he present himself as hyena ? He earns money on holocaust .
SANARIA7 3 years ago
He portrayed the Jews as mice and the Germans as cats because that is a predator/prey relationship. That and the Nazis described Jews as "vermin", which mice fit into. It's as much a story of Art's life as it is of his father, who survived the concentration camps. Maybe you should read it before you judge it.
thefinewino 2 years ago 3
i hate when stupid anime fanboys always say america or the west in general can't release good comic literature. they need to be handed a copy of maus which will hopefully shut their fucking mouths up.
but then again, the intellectual capacity of maus is probably too much for the anime/manga crowd to handle
fluffynoses 3 years ago 5
fluffy, "intellectual capacity" concering comics and media is a pretty vauge descritption of a reader. What is the staple of this? I like manga and find the material very stimulating. I have also found that American Comics much of the time are an excuse for a soap box which I don't find as stimulating or entertaining.
dantedraco 3 years ago
this is my personal opinion but i really hate manga. i think it's filled to the core with gratuitous violence, unnecessary sex, and tons and tons of Japanese nationalism (just look at that anti-Korean one that was released a few years back). i agree, you will definitely find that in American comics (anything written by frank miller) but I think Maus trumps all that overrated and overhyped manga shit.
don't take it personally, i was just venting about stupid ass anime fans on youtube.
fluffynoses 3 years ago
Yea, individual taste counts for allot. There are allot of titles with violence and sex and them. Don't forget there are "cute" titles as well. As for nationalism I am sure there are titles that represent this but my experience in reading there was actual questioning of the government such as Battle Royale in a fictional facist Japan.
No, its nothing personal. I just wanted you to know for some Manga is actually very thought provoking and stimulating. All reletaive right? Take care.
dantedraco 3 years ago
manga is about pedophilia, rape and sexual torture.
7Row7enn7 2 years ago
Rofl amen. =)
nera789 2 years ago
I love the books.
They're amazing and horrid.
SkyeDizzle 3 years ago 9
That was interesting. I really liked it. Excellent music, by the way. I love Pirates of the Caribbean! Amazing just how well that music fit the video.
YamiMahoIsiri 3 years ago 4
"Obviously there is no meaning of history, that can be rescued having turned one's back to auschwitz, no truth of history, that can be defended having turned one's back to auschwitz and no god to be worshipped, having turned one's back to auschwitz." j.b. metz
sorry for the unsatisfactory translation.
RenaultVier 3 years ago 4
"Obviously there is no meaning in history, that can be rescued having turned one's back to auschwitz, no truth of history, that can be defended having turned one's back to auschwitz and no god to be worshipped with one's back to auschwitz." j b metz.
sorry for the unsatisfactory translation.
RenaultVier 3 years ago 4
"Offenbar gibt es keinen Sinn der Geschichte, den man mit dem Rücken zu Auschwitz retten kann, keine Wahrheit der Geschichte, die man mit dem Rücken zu Auschwitz verteidigen und keinen Gott, den man mit dem Rücken zu Auschwitz anbeten kann."
Johann Baptist Metz (cath. Theologian, Germany)
RenaultVier 3 years ago 5
Awesome books, one of the best I have ever read.
Great short 5/5.
DutchKat 4 years ago 7
ich liebe Ziegen herauf mein Ass. großes Material, das es mich unbehaglich bildet.
raydoll474 4 years ago 4