Mariah Carey - Heartbreaker Live at The Today Show 01 11 1999

[USDACertified]

Was ANY of this actually live? It doesn't sound live. Sounds like pre-recorded live mixed with cd vocals.

[ami7mina]

look at that guy with his hand on his forehead when Mariah was whistling hehe

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@lawlinat0r bitch, go suck a cunt and pipe down.

[MariahusherKatyperry]

I love the Rainbow erra she Danced around alot more :)



[stevefromPA2]

when matt lower had a hair

[ILoveMcWhMj4ever]

I Love you with all my entire Heart and soul, Forever and always....I Love you with all my entire Heart and soul, Forever and always.. CRT FOREVER

[thiff2010]

I luv that song ♥

[juicyclamlover]

awww.... look at all those point and shoot cameras... nothing digital was available (affordable) to the public then...

[airplanefreak27]

Not defending her or anything but think of how Mariah's life is - she's got all of these things going on, I mean it's all bound to catch up to her eventually (as it's done here) where her voice doesn't sound good at times.

[MrXSTANx]

fskfsofnsn. she sounds a mess. i believe this is when the drugs were starting to kick in. poor Mooriah

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@MrXSTANx I believe she was taking heavy drugs at the point, she was also drinking herself into oblivion, I'm dieing at the whistle note at the start lmfao 0:25 she sounds like a boiling RUSTY KETTLE ! haha, this entire performance was strained up until the point where the backing track kicked in and she started MIMING, as usual !

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@kaiyno 0:34 onwards this entire performance is a hot fucking mess LMAO !

[primohomme]

@XTINASDISCIPLE

Funny, we have many many MANY performances of similar or worst quality by your fave

Oops.

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@primohomme Typical delusional lamb behaviour, having to talk about someone else instead of discussing the matter at hand.

[primohomme]

@XTINASDISCIPLE

But hunny, isn't that what you always do? Trying to deflect attention from your fave's vocal flaws by attacking Mariah and others :)

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@primohomme 0:34 :(

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@primohomme 0:25 her whistle sounds like a kettle just finished boiling, her intonation at 0:34 onwards is just awful, STRAINING, OFFKEY, just awful, this is what you fans call amazing ? I'm dissapointed.

[iamblueneptune]

@XTINASDISCIPLE I'd rather hear this stuff all afternoon than hear Christina's shouting! So, what for you is amazing? Huh! Xtina? Get a life dude!

[lawlinat0r]

@XTINASDISCIPLE Still better than anything Straintina has or ever will do. Mad? Oh, and learn to spell.

[lc0309]

and her animals dare to come to the real queens of singing and complain about vocals #LOL they're so pressed it #MUSTHURT to know that your fave has been cheating on you for more than a decade by lipsynching her awful performances and being in constant use of her whistle register and her rusty kettle register LMAO

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@lc0309 #DEAD at her rusty kettle register at 0:25 LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, OMG this entire performance is A MESS, her intonation, is awful, STRAINING, OFFKEY, lord have mercy on my soul, this performances needs to be burned 0:42 onwards HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA, she really is an awful overrated amateur !

[lc0309]

@XTINASDISCIPLE i thought she had perfect pitch according to her old footage junkies i mean stans she always on pitch what happened there? rough start rough continuing rough ending it was a total mess another #fail for the woman that if is true that every failure is a lesson learned then must be the wisest woman on earth what a flop!

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@lc0309 I'm quite sure she used her "lipsynching register" for the last half of the performance, the start was a mess and then BOOM, her voice suddenly came back aka (backing track) !!! she really is shameless to be miming all the time like this, lmfao at her attempting to dance, her voice is dead, so sad, she showed so much promisee but her excessive over singing and pointless whistle notes in every song have killed her voice.

[pedy19]

@XTINASDISCIPLE LOL are you joking ? She was singing live on the second part as well. If you want some great performance from Mariah last year check "Emotions 2011" she sings emotions LIVE, you´ll see what dead voice means then lol.

[singtofeel11]

i would have fired the host. How could he mess it, when Madonna has nothing to do with Mariah????

[bojidar33]

Tsis is no Mariah!

[KLIFF55]

i love this song !!

to all the lambs in the US. mariah has two diamond albums, i'm not sure if her debut album went diamond but it's close 9x. Emanicaption is 6x, let's give mariah two more diamond albums !! hahaha

[rafabadboyBH]

2:07 IS WONDERFULL!!!!!

[MCmimilamb247]

If the weather is warm then why the hell is Mariah wearing a big coat!!. Haha that why I love her. rotflmao

[Bemusedchicken]

rough start.

[vanessavermeij]

@pocholate Absolutely. But it´s normal, we all have a bad day. I sing and I have recordings of myself during live gigs that I would like to burn. This happens.

[FanaticoManiatico]

0:08 he's gonna say madonna!!!

[iiAmitx3]

@FanaticoManiatico i hate him if he was gonna say madonna

[JaninSweet1]

lol..this wasnt one of her best perfomances! voice is so tired and raspy..well still love her=)

[MariahCareyAngel1]

Great Whistle!! =)

[drunkdivamariahcarey]

TOO MUCH WORK SHE NEED REST!!!!

[tertra114]

3:54 LMAO guys look at the man in the audiance, did he just push securities head back, so that he could get a pic of Mariah lol

[iiAmitx3]

@tertra114 it's a known fact. mimi got da best fans.

[manchestertrash]

OMG so does what a legend!!

[09182055017]

@tertra114 haha i saw that,, so funny

[MCLambDahling3000]

They said warm weather! Why in the world is she wearing a big old heavy coat?! Oh, well, she's Mariah.

[Irvinismusic]

lord she sounded really tired on the live parts.. not to mention the pre recorded parts sounded wayyyyy to polished mixed with her tired live voice.. This deff wasn't her best.

[Crzymofo69]

WHISTLE LIVE!

[musicguy713]

yep this is the late 90's you can tell because of the shirt and all the disposable cameras in the audience haha, it would have been fun to be a teenager in the 90's and this is all live

[MusicallyUbiquitous]

I bet if she watched this performance, she'd cringe. Not horrible, but not amazing.

[JulianDaniEmilyShow]

@MusicallyUbiquitous forreal but atleaste the whistle was live

[caldancy2009]

people need to leave her alone she's been producing #1 ablums/singles for two decades and she is still astonishing even if her voice is fading a little she is still great name a modern singer than can hit those notes like her

[j0efus]

I don't know why she lipsyncs :( her voice is amazing though!

[Whistleregister99]

and you should also know that in all heartbreaker performances, the first high notes is always lipped but then sometimes she sings the rest live. shes not perfect because she has to rest her voice but shes a diva and clearly the best there is to keep singing especially now and keep going for her fans even though her career is slowly dropping :(

[ashrafd1]

@Whistleregister99 Yeah ryt... But she still @ number 1 !

[Whistleregister99]

im just sayin cuz nobody ever really talks good about her anymore like they used to

[aquamarine11500]

That doesn't mean her carrer is dropping,MC is still pretty popuplar.The only people who talk shit about her and say stuff like"she can't sing anymore" are Whitney,Xtina & Madonna stans.

She won't be going anywhere,she had a big comeback in 05 and is here to stay.

[promisuous88]

@aquamarine11500 That's not true..I was pretty embaressed watching her at michael jackson thing. So many people told me that she messed up bad, and I don't really know any whitney, xtina, madonna fans. We guys love to watch her jumping up and down in touch my body, but her music is repeting itself. Mariah has to use her voice in a new way, and make music that's a little more raw

[aquamarine11500]

@promisuous88 Not to offend but it"s people in particular like this who focuses on flawless vocals instead the emotions.If i had to sing in front of this ubber popular loved dead guy,whom was also my friend i would choke up too, therefore giving a shaky vocal performance.

Also u compare her earlier days to her music now,how is that repetitive?

[JulianDaniEmilyShow]

@Whistleregister99 because her newest album was kinda mediocre and went number 3 on the charts instead of number 1 and with the obsessed song people found her anoying a bitchy but dont worry she will come back with a new album and make more hits

[GUGU2101]

@Whistleregister99

I dont think her creer is slowly dropping take a look at michael's career and madonna's they have been around for like 40 30 yrs idk but her career can never drop now her voice can buuuuut she takes care of it soooo thts why she has tht wonderful voice tht we all love!!

[Whistleregister99]

she was singing over the prerecorded track on most of the song cause it sounds like two mariahs sometimes... but im pretty sure the high notes were live because she was feeling them and she wasnt acting too pretty and perfect in other performances during this era... she had to focus to get these notes so they were live... most other performances were prerecorded and the high notes were lipped

[jaypaidincash]

you can obviously see she was singing parts live..the whistles are live...so..

[t4headliners]

I dunno about the entire song, but parts where defenatly live. Specially the beginning and the whistles.

[emalee30]

lol shes lipsyncing . because u can here at the start of the song her real voice then the lip syncing starts..its a pre recorded version....shes pathetic

[ccwe23]

MC can still sing with the best it's just she doesnt sing that show off her vocal ability like she use to

check out her stripped version of always be my baby or we belong together

[ciswe]

I WAS THERE !! LMAO IT WAS FUN

[MissCharleeJeanae]

Rite go off ILUVMYLAY u my bitch Me love mariah too...and as for you LOOKM#UP1 u obviously dont know what singing is.....and mariah is in no way fat....mariah can sit any singer down that comes her way with no problem or hesitation....i love her as well she is my idol and cant NOBODY out sing MARIAH.....

[BFAN4EVER]

OMG I LOVE MC BUT WHAT HAPPENED

[lookm3up1]

smh Mariah cant sang any more live she sounds like shyt

[aquamarine11500]

this was 1999 ass hole.i bet your idol looks like shit and sounds like.

fuck off u rude bastard!

[lookm3up1]

Mariah cant sang any more y are yu mad just face iit ! N shes FAT !

[bfhfsuruyw]

whitney is a fat pig!!

[t4headliners]

OMG, LOL. If you call whitney a fat pig, then what is Mariah????

[bfhfsuruyw]

They both are, at least Mariah has been skinny before!

[iluvmylay]

bitch we aint talkin bout yo momma ! mariah is beautiful and sexy and can SANG her ass off , BITCH

[lookm3up1]

do you personaly know Mariah ?

Because your very upset . .LMAO

[iluvmylay]

wow what a come back, you have

the intelligence of a three year old it seems.

& no OBVIOUSLY i dont personally know here you dumb bitch , BUT i do personally admire & LOVE her. so when i hear negative ass fuckin hatin ass bitches like you, i reply with anger. anymore questions cunt ?

[jaypaidincash]

LMAO people are a trip..THEY COME TO HER VIDEOS AND LISTEN TO HER MUSIC..then they talk shit about her LMAO I cant stand fake ass fans or fake people

[lookm3up1]

YEA ME 2 !

[peachwalls]

Love this great live performance of Heartbreaker. In fact watching this has renewed my love for the song. I love her hair in this video and the whole look.

[Silversoul1989]

whistle or falsetto at the end???

[aquamarine11500]

whistle

[Stratusfaction4ever]

she has an amazin figure its curvy but not like really skinny like most singers or models

[Miyuri687]

the beginnig rocky but then shes not an early person and the voice doesnt warmup till the afternoon

[dfilboy]

the fans were so die hard! i could relate! i wish i was there too! lol xD

[Myacolusi]

this is soo 90's! best decade ever! the strapless the pants the hair .. everything

[VegasAcer]

@Myacolusi I agree, i miss it!

[halfpuppy1]

im going to see mariah on todays show on the 28th of this month i cant wait im mariahs HUGES FAN u dont even know im gonna get a front row seat

[iluvmylay]

u lucky ass ! OMG !!!! youre sooo lucky ! im JEALOUS ! lol

[MIMIFan001]

OMG Ur a lamb 2 and ur goin 2 go c her ur luckie u shud add me

[laceleatherxxx]

really 28th of spetember

[theemust]

the best whistles!

[OKzs]

I think the confetti was supposed come out earlier..like during the whistles or right after... I don't think she was too happy

"It is EARLY in the Morrrning!" LOL

[isiah58]

thank god, mariah is together!! this gets me so sad to watch!!! she was so much pain and conflict!! i love her man!!!

[theking312]

this is a horrible porfamance! ughhh she tried to mix prerecorded and her live voice to make it seem real!!!! ugh she had waaaaaay better heartbreaker performances!

[JamaicanFlava]

I agree. But it was clear when she was lipsynchin 2.

[FABIOSOS]

ahahaha that it man .........the man said Ladies and gentlemen mano aahahaha ...........but Mariah always beautiful and her voice goddanm she amazinggggggg singerrrrrr

[diazepam5d]

best performance of this song

[thatchickmimi]

why she's like that?she's insane here..oh..it's 1999 which is the time of her breakdown..but even it happen again and again...i still inspired by yours mariah!!i still listen to you!muwah!

[theking312]

she did not breakdown in no 1999! try 2001!

[PablitoMC]

WTF!The man said "Ladies and gentlemen Mado..Mariah Carey!" !!Listen carefully