@mooch514 Alright first of all Luongo WAS the team Canada goalie. Tell me how he does not have to do with Canada winning in the first place. Second of all if Luongo choked every
playoff season then how did the Canucks get to the Stanley Cup Finals? You answer me.
@Blazermyth brodeur started off the games,,then luongo and brodeur shared the net,,luongo was in the last game,,he was shaky like a leaf,,every time they shot on him most people closed their eyes! if you remember correctly last year,,sneider played a lot of games..especially against the bruins because red light luongo kept getting pulled,,luongo let in 15 goals in 3 games against boston...and what did the cannucks win with luongo? fuck all.
im going to say one thing and i know people are going to try and beat me up on this.... most underrated goaltender who will be a hall of famer CHRIS OSGOOD. 400 wins and counting, scored a goal, second goaltender in the history of the NHL to start of the cup finals with back to back shutouts. fought Patrick Roy. isit 3 or 4 stanley cups.
@Speedysidewinder osgood sucks my balls. i think im sayin that cause im a blackhawks fan but you have to be able to make an alstar game to get in the top 10
@skateni2468 if you only knew bud. osgood has been in 2 or 3 allstar games. also i dont have respect for most blackhawk fans cause, who boos a legend like cheli when his number is being retired? that doesnt show very much class. so for you to say that osgood sucks doesnt effect me cause any person that reads this and knows hockey realizes that Osgood is a hall of fame bond goalie. numbers and preformance doesnt lie
@Speedysidewinder I think most people's problem with Ozzie is that he goes through streaks...when he's bad....he's pretty bad, but when he's good. He's PHENOMENAL.
Since you already started reading you cant stop. My name is Kalena. I have black hair, and green eyes. I am 13. I was abused my whole life. I have no ears or nose, because my parents chopped them of with a rusty fork. I am dead. I will show up in your room in 13 days and kill you by chopping off your body parts with a rusty fork unless you repost this on 5 pages. THIS IS NO JOKE!! If you do, something good will happen to you within 13 days. If you don't believe this, wait
What about Bernie Parent from the flyers he was amazing for 1974-76 if it wasnt for him flyers dont win those consecutive cups he had the most wins ever by a goalie with 48 in the non shootout era thats pretty impressive in my book he also won the con smythe,vezina and was a nhl all star.
I dont think Dryden should be 6 maybe 9 because when you look back on the teams rosters he was on. you can see that he had stiller defence in fron of him and Dryden played in the canadiens glory years
Brodeur at only 7? I know this video is a few years old but still, he should be no.1.
Not only because of his impressive records, but being at the top year after year, showing those butterflying robots what goaltending really is about..
I may be biased because of my adulthood watching Brodeur, but he is higher than 7. This is coming from a Wings fan. I would put him right up there with Sawchuck and Roy. Hasek was a close number 4 to those three greats.
@PJs920 First...sorry, my english is horrible. I wish you luck with translation! :-)) So...
I respekt your opinion, but I think "Vlado" Tretiak extraneous to TOP 10. He was higher-than-average, but not great. Jiří Holeček (czechoslovakia goaltender) said: "He wouldn't chance to be czechoslovakia goaltender, he wouldnt be for CZE national team good. Every goaltender which play for Soviet become higher-than-average.!" He had true...
@zachattack19955 with defensmen like scott neidemyer and scott steven and sheldon souray for 7 years he has to be good
luongo played with florida with a team that scored thrid least in the league while luongo faced the most shots and made the most saves in a season in nhl history and he stole the job from brodeur in olympics
Belfour and Hasek were on the hawks at the same time. The hawks had to make a tough call on who to keep. They decided on belfour cause they thought Hasek's flopping around "european" style wouldn't fit in the NHL.
@yodafan301 Your list way wrong too. Miller hasn't been around long enough, Luongo never goes anywhere in the playoffs, JS Giguer is no where near good enough to make a top 25 list, and Osgood had four good seasons, that's it. Brodeur has most of the records now too. He's almost Gretzky's comparison in the net at this point.
As a die hard Brodeur/Devils fan I must say that he is not the best goaltender of all time. I think that honor has to go to either Sawchuk or Plante because of the fact that they were both innovators and great puckstoppers who gave their teams a chance to win night in and night out. Hasek, Roy...the same could be said for them. Brodeur is certainly one of the most EXCITING goaltenders ever to play the game and surely one of the best and a first ballot HOFer, but falls short in the end.
Patrick Roy WAS an innovator. Among others, he changed the goaltenter style forever. I personally think he SHOULD be number 1. Hasek, maybe not as high in the list, but on it definitly.
Always thought Hasek was better than Brodeur. Hasek did not always have such a strong defensive team ahead of him like the Devils. Compare the two's save percentages. That is widely accepted as the best way to rate a goalie. Had Dom played for the Devils his whole career, hardly anyone would have scored on them.
Sawchuk played with an injury his whole career, severe depression, and I bet a whole list worth of stitches, scars, bruises, and fractured bones. Plus his arms were abnormally disproportionate. He ideally shows what a true goalie really is. A person who seems so dysfunctional in society because his mind is so focused on stopping a piece of rubber from crossing a line. It was his life, and he was magical. A true legend you would think was fictional. Amazing what one human can endure.
I would put any of the pre mask goalies ahead of any modern goalie. These were true warriors (or psychotics), because any modern goalie would most likely not play with no mask and the older equipment. Remember goalie is mostly a mental position, so knowing the puck can kill you on any shot must have been tremendous mental pressure. Modern equipment pretty much eliminates a lot of the chances of serious injury from shots alone. I say Sawchuk was the #1 all time, simply because he was Sawchuk.
@KILLAAAWHALE I agree the pre mask goalies had to be a bit on the wild side. It doesn't take a genius to know a cold, hard puck to the face is no fun. However, goalies today face similar fears. Players today are bigger and stronger than they were back in the day They also use curved blades and slapshoot. I'm not totally sure on this, but I may choose a weak wrist shot to the face over a powerful slapshot of a modern player to the collarbone, neck, or armpit.
@KILLAAAWHALE although i agree with much that you have said, the game was ALOT slower. shots werent nearly as fast, sticks werent carbon fiber and capable of bending. though i agree that the old goalies are more warriors i dont think u can put all of them ahead of modern goalies. modern goaltending is alot better than it was, mailnly because of their predecessors. that being said, sawchuck, dryden, plante, parent, esposito, bower are some of thegreatestto ever play
@KILLAAAWHALE I DONT THIMK SO THERE KILLA NOT AS MANY SHOTS LEFT THE IF THE WERE MOSTLY AT ICE LEVEL AND THE PRESSURE FOR GOALIE TO BE GREAT JUST WASNT THERE. IT WAS ALMOST EXPECTED FOR THE GOALIE TO FAIL. FEW WERE GREAT BACK THEN, WITH THE TRAINING AND STAMINA OF TODAYS GOALIE NO WAY MOST OF THOSE PRE MODERN GOALIES COULD COMPETE. AND YOUR TALKING ABOUT THE DAYS WHEN YOU COULD WALK INTO THE NHL OF THE STREET IF YOU HAD SOME SKILLS. I DONT THINK SO KILLA.
@KILLAAAWHALE The game has changed alot, players are fitter and bigger and can shoot harder and can pick spots better and they shoot higher then they did back then
@KILLAAAWHALE that's not so true, back when we didn't wear masks we were unaware of the damages of being hit in the head, when we realized the danger we made masks, so they didn't really know that any shot could kill them, just any should could hurt like hell. Still, you have a great point
@KILLAAAWHALE it was a totally different game back them. if one of the modern goalies today played back then, they would tear up the league. its a much harder game today
its awesome watching the top 10 greatest players and watching them score these unbelievable goals..then flipping it around and seeing them get denied! lol
Really? Roy over Brodeur? I have a hard time believing this list considering the all time shutout leader is not number one...I mean come on, its only his job!
Maybe, but even considering it is all time. Putting Brodeur at #7 is enough to make me laugh. Especially considering they put roy (who has worse career stats than marty) at #1.
@kopposka11 this was brodcast during the lockout 2004-05. back then, roy had just retired and brodeur was still in the midst of most records. i'd say if the list was created today he would be among the top 3...
How is George Hainsworth not on that list? He is 3rd all time in shutouts with 94, and only played like 465 games (brodeur has 1025 and 103 SO's). Still holds the record of 22 shutouts in a season, and the 2nd highest total of 15, and an nhl record for lowest GAA of 0.92.
I guess because he played so long ago, he's not taken into consideration. He played when they didn't use masks, or huge pads, and he was only like 5'6 150 lbs.
Would be nice to see the guy get a little recognition at least.
i knew you were going to look up the stats. When plante played the venzia was given to the goaile who let up the least amount of goals. Now they have the jennings.
And you mean those 43 games he played with ottawa?
where he had 28 wins, 5 shutouts, a GGA of 2.09, and a save percentage of .925?
Clearly that is a terrible season.
Buffalo did not play the trap, they just had Peca and Adudette, who were back checking forwards to make it seem like that.
hasek started in detroit in the early 00s, and yes in the one year where they had that all-star team, they won the cup.
Brouder is the prodeect of an environment. And if he started at the same age as Brouder did as a regular starter, then he would be far ahead of brouder in wins and shutout.
i love Durnan. because of baseball when I was younger, I can catch good with both hands. I always wondered if I could do this as a goalie. Do you think it is still possible now? I'm thinking about buying two goalie gloves and trying it.
Brodeur shouldn't even be seven. His team won those cups, not because of him. Fewest shots aginst, fewest penalty kills, two hall of fame defensemen in front of him, how many can say that.
Show some respect man, questioning the all time wins leader doesnt make you smart, cool, or tough. Its obvious that every hockey fan would love to have Brodeur on their team. Also, getting less shots is often tougher. Oh, and every goalie on this list had great defensemen in front of them, its part of the game.
lol so I take it youre the goalie expert? These are world class athletes who can put up 50 saves in a night if they had to, so fatigue isnt a big issue most of the time. Now Im not saying 20 is ALWAYS harder, but think about it. Its harder to stay on your game if 10 minutes goes by without anything happening, then you get a breakaway. Goaltending is just as mental as it is physical. And yeah, any successful goalie has good defense, give me a counter example. Point is, he's not overrated.
Counter example, sure. I guess Scott Mellanby is the best left winger of all time because he has the most wins for a left winger in NHL history.
Because Brodeur has the most wins doesn't mean he is great goalie. He was a small part of a team just like Mellanby was. Brodeur was an average goalie on a great defensive team!
A highly conditioned and mentally trained athlete, then a ten minute break wouldn't make it harder!
Devils were well disciplined too, fewest penalties to kill!
Okay, first off, anybody with common sense realizes that wins are more connected with goalies than skaters because there aren't 3 other guys playing that position on a team during a game, thats why they keep track of wins for goalies and not really for skaters (though apparently you dug up some obscure statistic, you know what I mean). Second, the devils play defensive hockey, sure, but he's the key reason WHY they're so good. When goalies are better and give up less goals, the D looks better
Point #1...So if it's the goalie and not the D why Jersey is so good, why is it that the backups have good numbers as well? The Devils have ALL the best goalies in the NHL. Clemmensen is the second best goalie in the world then!
Point #2...A left winger has the game winning goal, two assists on great stretch passes, has four crucial blocked shots on the penalty kill, back checks all night, battles in the corners, plays the neutral zone trap perfectly, has a fight that changes momentum when they were losing.
The goalie stops 19 of 22 shots and really played poorly.
glad to see turk broda get some respect for a change. most leafs fans think of johhny bower as the best leafs goalie of all time, but clearly someone actually knows a thing or two about maple leafs history.
sorry .. but who ever put this list together... knows very little about hockey.. this person knows ALITTLE about hockey. # what about george Vezina.. after all . he has a trophy named after hmmm.. but be a good goalie ok .let look at that list? hasek better than sawchuk? no way guy hasek should be on the list. but no way is he better than hall and sawchuk belfour broda tony o hasek broduer hasek hall roy sawchuk plante
Your written words are very poorly phrased, but am I reading it right where you say Hasek doesn't belong on the list? Are you absolutely nuts and what evidence do you want for Dom to be on there? I can give you plenty.
hasek no.2 wtf?! wtf?! he is amazing but he is tied for wins with osgood, and chris has played less than him! ridiculous belfour is better, hasek should be around number 5, thats just stupid that sawchuk, plante, brodeur, and belfour were all considered not as good as a player who has never played on a week defense team, and compared to alot of these goalies has a low sa total. just ridiculous
Just ridiculous is you saying Belfour should be higher than Dom! LOL. Wins are usually a team effort in any case and how about comparing Hasek & Belfour on save %, shut-outs, vezinas, and hart trophies? I rest my case.
Number one is def. a split between Roy and Hasek. Both of them brought teams not deserving to the Finals, when Roy won his Cups with Montreal he was the entire team, The team didnt deserve to be there. Hasek during his stint all he had was a bunch of thugs and wannabes. People say his saves were luck but nobody gets that lucky that many times.
People argue that Brodeur is the best but last season proved that with the trap system any goalie can put up good numbers.
@KaguyaShenku0 agreed! i think roy is the best, and hasek is a VERY close second. belfour is definetly in the top 10, maybe top 5 depending on who u talk to. i would put him at #5, 6, or 7 :)
Broduer is a jerk! He had an affair on his wife with her sister! No future Hall of Famer should do something like that. I hope Broduer never gets in to the Hall of Fame, his greatness was destroyed with that affair
Roy is definetly the best all of them, but Hasek? Everyone gets lucky sometimes, but Hasek deserves his spot as #2. It wasn't luck. he has his own unique style of play, just like Roy. If he was a butterfly goalie you wouldn't care less! He just has a one of a kind style!
There's a new book out there called "Lets Talk Hockey 50 Wonderful debates" that I picked up on amazon the other day and one of the chapters debates the top 10 goalies of all time. Here's the list, and I'll admit the author has some pretty decent arguments in his favour as well: 10. Dryden 9. Parent 8. Benedict 7. Broda 6. Hall 5. Brodeur 4. Plante 3. Hasek 2. Roy 1. Sawchuk I have no problem with that list. For those that don't know Clint Benedict you should!
10:Curtis Joseph 9:Ed Belfour 8Chris Osgood 7:Ken Dryden 6:Dominic Hasek 5:Jacques Plante 4:Glen Hall 3:Patrick Roy 2:Terry Sawchuk 1:Martin Brodeur Brodeur is number 1 because he broke the record for most wins and is 3 away from the most shutouts. He is a legend.
Roy will always be better than brodeur heres why...3 conne smythes most ever! 155 playoff wins! who cares about regular season wins, i calculated it and if brodeur won the cup the next three seasons in a row he still wouldn't have as many wins as roy in the playoffs, not to meantion when Roy stole the cup from Brodeur in 2001
This list is realyl messed up. Come on Ed Belfour? Seriously! He's a future Hall of Famer for sure but the game has been played for way too long for him to be top 10, there are too many great goalies to bump off.
In my opinion, a new book I just read "Let's Talk Hockey: 50 Wonderful debates" from amazon probably brings the best list out there and at least explains why other great goalies arent on there in the first place. Hey the top 10 list in that book at least has Bernie Parent on it
Roy is overrated?!...I dont even kno how to respond to that. Hasek is just a flopper who couldn't win a cup till he went to a STACKED detroit team..Roy CARRIED teams on his own..think about that
Dumb cluck. Hasek got lucky time after time?? That was one kick-ass lucky streak to win 2 harts, multiple vezinas, and lead the league in save % nearly every year he paid the vast majority of the season. Your ignorance is mind-boggling.
I don't agree with Roy being #1. With goalies like Sawchuck, Jac Plante, Hasek, Marty, and Dryden, I would've put him maybe at.... five... maybe 1 or 2 higher or lower.
Ken Dryden played only 6 regular season games his rookie season , he won all 6 games..then won 12 playoff games, to win the Stanley Cup ! and MVP. Ken Dryden, goalie Montreal Canadiens for 8 seasons, won 6 Stanley Cups, 5 vezinas .....Lifetime record 258 wins 57 loses 74 ties...lifetime G.A.A 2.24 Ken Dryden retired at age 31 !
Venzinas are sht right now Brodeur is great but come on he plays behind trap defense which ugh is a break as a goalie I also think the Soviet Union Tretiak is better than half the goalies on this list and where is HExtall!!!!
Although i'm a big Wings fan and wanted to see a repeat, i really wanted Broduer to win the cup because he broke Roy's record or Montreal to win the cup in their 100th season! Way to go, Habs!
I know all of that. I never said Brodeur is bad either. But he has not won any personal awards in the playoffs, and Conn Smythe Trophy is in my opinion the real heavy weight award in the league, along with Hart Trophy.
As for the shutouts, Brodeur has played his whole career behind a most often defensive system. Roy didn't, and he played 4 seasons in the 80's when the teams relied far more on offense than defense + the high scoring 92-93 season.
ken dryden #1..luongo stinks,,luongo is the most over-rated goalie of all time,,he won a medal,,,but he had nothing to do with it.
mooch514 1 month ago 2
@mooch514 LOL He had nothing to do with it? your one of the stupidest people i ever seen. Luongo was part of the team lmfao
Blazermyth 3 weeks ago
@Blazermyth and if you think luongo had anything to do with canada wining the medal..then you the biggest moron on 2 feet...luongo has won nothing.
chokes every playoff season ...you heard me.
mooch514 3 weeks ago
@mooch514 Alright first of all Luongo WAS the team Canada goalie. Tell me how he does not have to do with Canada winning in the first place. Second of all if Luongo choked every
playoff season then how did the Canucks get to the Stanley Cup Finals? You answer me.
Blazermyth 3 weeks ago
@Blazermyth brodeur started off the games,,then luongo and brodeur shared the net,,luongo was in the last game,,he was shaky like a leaf,,every time they shot on him most people closed their eyes! if you remember correctly last year,,sneider played a lot of games..especially against the bruins because red light luongo kept getting pulled,,luongo let in 15 goals in 3 games against boston...and what did the cannucks win with luongo? fuck all.
mooch514 3 weeks ago
@mooch514 Canucks beat the Chicago blackhalks, Nashville preds, and the san jose sharks with Luongo.
Blazermyth 2 weeks ago
@mrcoolbitessize hes won olympics
josheyboffey 2 months ago
this is completely one sided... brodeur is number 6? wTF!!! XD and where is luongo.
alexmini123 3 months ago
@alexmini123 Luongo isnt even that great, hes never won a cup, and hes really only had one dominant year
mrcoolmanbitesize 2 months ago
@mrcoolmanbitesize Shutup you fucking boston fan nobody cares...
alexmini123 2 months ago
@alexmini123 your retarded. luongo has awful stats and doesnt do shit in the playoffs, deff top ten goalie.
mrcoolmanbitesize 2 months ago
@mrcoolmanbitesize i agree,,,he is over-rated...
mooch514 3 weeks ago
@mrcoolmanbitesize i completley agree with u and he runs his mouth too much and hes a choke...... ima bruins fan btw
omarkole 2 weeks ago
where the hell is vernon
assaultman223 6 months ago
brodeur is number 7 everyone not 6
dan5166 6 months ago
Hasek at #2, Roy at #1, i agree with that, but the rest i think should be upgraded, put Broduer at #3
TheIcemancometh13 6 months ago
@TheIcemancometh13 I actually think Terry Sawchuck should be number 1 or 2.
TheDaleDenton 5 months ago
I remember this show! Good ole NHL Network
thefoxrox1 9 months ago
Dear God... Ken Dryden's glove save! Holy slapshot from Hell man!
larsen550 10 months ago
Pelle Lindbergh nr1
theredlibanese 10 months ago
Wheres Heaxtall?
16inyourplaybooks 11 months ago
im going to say one thing and i know people are going to try and beat me up on this.... most underrated goaltender who will be a hall of famer CHRIS OSGOOD. 400 wins and counting, scored a goal, second goaltender in the history of the NHL to start of the cup finals with back to back shutouts. fought Patrick Roy. isit 3 or 4 stanley cups.
Speedysidewinder 11 months ago
@Speedysidewinder osgood sucks my balls. i think im sayin that cause im a blackhawks fan but you have to be able to make an alstar game to get in the top 10
skateni2468 10 months ago
@skateni2468 if you only knew bud. osgood has been in 2 or 3 allstar games. also i dont have respect for most blackhawk fans cause, who boos a legend like cheli when his number is being retired? that doesnt show very much class. so for you to say that osgood sucks doesnt effect me cause any person that reads this and knows hockey realizes that Osgood is a hall of fame bond goalie. numbers and preformance doesnt lie
Speedysidewinder 10 months ago
@Speedysidewinder I think most people's problem with Ozzie is that he goes through streaks...when he's bad....he's pretty bad, but when he's good. He's PHENOMENAL.
But I will agree, very underrated
whatitdid 9 months ago
Where the hell is Curtis Joesph with his 4th all time wins?????
ThePokemonmaster333 1 year ago
@ThePokemonmaster333 its probably because he also holds the record for most losses.
just saying
Speedysidewinder 11 months ago
damn, the leafs a good a goalie as belfour was for us :(
Harry427 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Since you already started reading you cant stop. My name is Kalena. I have black hair, and green eyes. I am 13. I was abused my whole life. I have no ears or nose, because my parents chopped them of with a rusty fork. I am dead. I will show up in your room in 13 days and kill you by chopping off your body parts with a rusty fork unless you repost this on 5 pages. THIS IS NO JOKE!! If you do, something good will happen to you within 13 days. If you don't believe this, wait
synfulCB14 1 year ago
Ed Belfour :)
ActoneSUCKA 1 year ago
still wondering why Vezina isn't on the list... that name sounds familiar...
S3ymourButtz 1 year ago
What about Bernie Parent from the flyers he was amazing for 1974-76 if it wasnt for him flyers dont win those consecutive cups he had the most wins ever by a goalie with 48 in the non shootout era thats pretty impressive in my book he also won the con smythe,vezina and was a nhl all star.
boskey10 1 year ago
I THINK THAT RON HEXTALL HAVE TO BE FIRST!
LeBronJamesMVP236 1 year ago
I dont think Dryden should be 6 maybe 9 because when you look back on the teams rosters he was on. you can see that he had stiller defence in fron of him and Dryden played in the canadiens glory years
TheDemko6 1 year ago
where the hell is Tony O Esposito?
marcoloco21 1 year ago
Brodeur #1 Where is Evgeni Nabokov?
Lazaru33 1 year ago
Brodeur #1
Lazaru33 1 year ago
You just forgot the real # 1 : Vladislav Tretiak and what about George Hainsworth?
1globetrotteur 1 year ago
Brodeur at only 7? I know this video is a few years old but still, he should be no.1.
Not only because of his impressive records, but being at the top year after year, showing those butterflying robots what goaltending really is about..
1984Punx 1 year ago
roy is sooooooooo overrated why isnt tretiak on this list???
Slushyyy639 1 year ago
@Slushyyy639 Because Tretiak never played in the NHL. Top Ten -NHL- Goalies
nikcimex 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Slushyyy639 Because Tretiak never played in the NHL. Top Ten -NHL- Goalies
nikcimex 1 year ago
I may be biased because of my adulthood watching Brodeur, but he is higher than 7. This is coming from a Wings fan. I would put him right up there with Sawchuck and Roy. Hasek was a close number 4 to those three greats.
Lovaelihn 1 year ago
good list, but I would put belfour higher, and brodeur should be in the top three with hasek and roy
182below0 1 year ago
Nabacov (forgot how to spell it)
KevinDeleven42 1 year ago
I agree Sawchuk was the best. But where is George Hainsworth?
1stinsailing 1 year ago
PJs920 1 year ago
@PJs920 First...sorry, my english is horrible. I wish you luck with translation! :-)) So...
I respekt your opinion, but I think "Vlado" Tretiak extraneous to TOP 10. He was higher-than-average, but not great. Jiří Holeček (czechoslovakia goaltender) said: "He wouldn't chance to be czechoslovakia goaltender, he wouldnt be for CZE national team good. Every goaltender which play for Soviet become higher-than-average.!" He had true...
KubikLaga 1 year ago
@yodafan301 Wheres Dryden?
PJs920 1 year ago
broduer is 1 no bodey is better every record beats roy records shows hes the best
zachattack19955 1 year ago
@zachattack19955 with defensmen like scott neidemyer and scott steven and sheldon souray for 7 years he has to be good
luongo played with florida with a team that scored thrid least in the league while luongo faced the most shots and made the most saves in a season in nhl history and he stole the job from brodeur in olympics
Liuyifeng19 1 year ago
@Liuyifeng19
zachattack19955 1 year ago
Belfour and Hasek were on the hawks at the same time. The hawks had to make a tough call on who to keep. They decided on belfour cause they thought Hasek's flopping around "european" style wouldn't fit in the NHL.
widwag 1 year ago
@yodafan301 Your list way wrong too. Miller hasn't been around long enough, Luongo never goes anywhere in the playoffs, JS Giguer is no where near good enough to make a top 25 list, and Osgood had four good seasons, that's it. Brodeur has most of the records now too. He's almost Gretzky's comparison in the net at this point.
HeavyD2544 1 year ago
ironz18 1 year ago
I think if this was a more modern video Brodeur would be much higher.
40cam 1 year ago
@yodafan301 fukn giguere hahahahaha
XxHockeyBoixX 1 year ago
this is of ALL TIME eceryone miller and luongo havent done anything great yet
XxHockeyBoixX 1 year ago
WTF?? y is broduer not no1????
theawsomestdude 1 year ago
u 4got kipper
tupluck699 1 year ago
hasek shounldnt be 2nd.. 5th is better,
TutorialCreators 1 year ago
at 1;58 he ges fucking rocked
oiler83fan 1 year ago
the only reason the devils are not the worst team in the world is because of Broduer
melissa41000 2 years ago
As a die hard Brodeur/Devils fan I must say that he is not the best goaltender of all time. I think that honor has to go to either Sawchuk or Plante because of the fact that they were both innovators and great puckstoppers who gave their teams a chance to win night in and night out. Hasek, Roy...the same could be said for them. Brodeur is certainly one of the most EXCITING goaltenders ever to play the game and surely one of the best and a first ballot HOFer, but falls short in the end.
theatlantisrise 2 years ago
Patrick Roy WAS an innovator. Among others, he changed the goaltenter style forever. I personally think he SHOULD be number 1. Hasek, maybe not as high in the list, but on it definitly.
moeses9030 1 year ago
Always thought Hasek was better than Brodeur. Hasek did not always have such a strong defensive team ahead of him like the Devils. Compare the two's save percentages. That is widely accepted as the best way to rate a goalie. Had Dom played for the Devils his whole career, hardly anyone would have scored on them.
overthehillsfaraway9 2 years ago
awesome, you are awesome
xx24carfan4xx 2 years ago
lov this vid! Broduer should be 4th
xx24carfan4xx 2 years ago
continued..
Sawchuk played with an injury his whole career, severe depression, and I bet a whole list worth of stitches, scars, bruises, and fractured bones. Plus his arms were abnormally disproportionate. He ideally shows what a true goalie really is. A person who seems so dysfunctional in society because his mind is so focused on stopping a piece of rubber from crossing a line. It was his life, and he was magical. A true legend you would think was fictional. Amazing what one human can endure.
KILLAAAWHALE 2 years ago
so what? Broduer 4 vezina trophies,3 stanley cups
xx24carfan4xx 2 years ago
I would put any of the pre mask goalies ahead of any modern goalie. These were true warriors (or psychotics), because any modern goalie would most likely not play with no mask and the older equipment. Remember goalie is mostly a mental position, so knowing the puck can kill you on any shot must have been tremendous mental pressure. Modern equipment pretty much eliminates a lot of the chances of serious injury from shots alone. I say Sawchuk was the #1 all time, simply because he was Sawchuk.
KILLAAAWHALE 2 years ago 13
@KILLAAAWHALE I agree the pre mask goalies had to be a bit on the wild side. It doesn't take a genius to know a cold, hard puck to the face is no fun. However, goalies today face similar fears. Players today are bigger and stronger than they were back in the day They also use curved blades and slapshoot. I'm not totally sure on this, but I may choose a weak wrist shot to the face over a powerful slapshot of a modern player to the collarbone, neck, or armpit.
PovertyRecords 1 year ago
@KILLAAAWHALE although i agree with much that you have said, the game was ALOT slower. shots werent nearly as fast, sticks werent carbon fiber and capable of bending. though i agree that the old goalies are more warriors i dont think u can put all of them ahead of modern goalies. modern goaltending is alot better than it was, mailnly because of their predecessors. that being said, sawchuck, dryden, plante, parent, esposito, bower are some of thegreatestto ever play
flooder57 1 year ago
@KILLAAAWHALE I DONT THIMK SO THERE KILLA NOT AS MANY SHOTS LEFT THE IF THE WERE MOSTLY AT ICE LEVEL AND THE PRESSURE FOR GOALIE TO BE GREAT JUST WASNT THERE. IT WAS ALMOST EXPECTED FOR THE GOALIE TO FAIL. FEW WERE GREAT BACK THEN, WITH THE TRAINING AND STAMINA OF TODAYS GOALIE NO WAY MOST OF THOSE PRE MODERN GOALIES COULD COMPETE. AND YOUR TALKING ABOUT THE DAYS WHEN YOU COULD WALK INTO THE NHL OF THE STREET IF YOU HAD SOME SKILLS. I DONT THINK SO KILLA.
tm2sigg 11 months ago
@KILLAAAWHALE The game has changed alot, players are fitter and bigger and can shoot harder and can pick spots better and they shoot higher then they did back then
nuty1234 11 months ago
@KILLAAAWHALE have to agree with that. You have to be a complete psych job to sit infront of high speed rubber
KrazyLukaz 9 months ago
@KILLAAAWHALE that's not so true, back when we didn't wear masks we were unaware of the damages of being hit in the head, when we realized the danger we made masks, so they didn't really know that any shot could kill them, just any should could hurt like hell. Still, you have a great point
Leclwrd 7 months ago
@KILLAAAWHALE it was a totally different game back them. if one of the modern goalies today played back then, they would tear up the league. its a much harder game today
dgonchar98 5 months ago
its awesome watching the top 10 greatest players and watching them score these unbelievable goals..then flipping it around and seeing them get denied! lol
insolentMinx47 3 months ago
Really? Roy over Brodeur? I have a hard time believing this list considering the all time shutout leader is not number one...I mean come on, its only his job!
f18jock 2 years ago
No luongo? No Kipprusoff? Brodeur number SEVEN!? I think we can accept that this list is hardly credible.
KatanaSpirit 2 years ago
Dude, this is all time. No offense, but Kipper doesn't even crack that list. And Luongo is definitely questionable.
TehJuxtaposer 2 years ago
Maybe, but even considering it is all time. Putting Brodeur at #7 is enough to make me laugh. Especially considering they put roy (who has worse career stats than marty) at #1.
KatanaSpirit 2 years ago
Fair. Brodeur should be higher.
TehJuxtaposer 2 years ago
u pwn
xx24carfan4xx 2 years ago
lol! That's because this vid's old.
xx24carfan4xx 2 years ago
broduer best, they didnt get all of broduer's awesome saves
xx24carfan4xx 2 years ago
@xx24carfan4xx i quite agree - brodeur is the best goaltender to play the game of hockey in my opinion.. =)
blyson 2 years ago
@KatanaSpirit It'd be nice if you thought of the history of hockey, and not the best goalies of the last 5 years.
Mythicalmonstre 1 year ago
Luongo???!!!!!???
canuckfan12345 2 years ago
Where Kipper???
MrPronger1 2 years ago
This was pretty good. Hasek was a very good goalie but wouldn't make the top top of all time. But would prolly be in top 20
Trevortail 2 years ago
your an idiot, Hasek is one of the top
MsOkay13 2 years ago
martin brodeur 6 ?????
kopposka11 2 years ago 10
@kopposka11 this was brodcast during the lockout 2004-05. back then, roy had just retired and brodeur was still in the midst of most records. i'd say if the list was created today he would be among the top 3...
rollerhockeygoalie 6 months ago
@rollerhockeygoalie uhm...at least i think it was around the lockout...
rollerhockeygoalie 6 months ago
@rollerhockeygoalie ye
kopposka11 6 months ago
No Tony O???????...
ldhorricks 2 years ago
save at 2:00 would now be deemed as illegal
Thehouse88 2 years ago
no it wouldnt lol
kyle9918 2 years ago
Im pretty ignorant...why?
clevercomments 2 years ago
How is George Hainsworth not on that list? He is 3rd all time in shutouts with 94, and only played like 465 games (brodeur has 1025 and 103 SO's). Still holds the record of 22 shutouts in a season, and the 2nd highest total of 15, and an nhl record for lowest GAA of 0.92.
I guess because he played so long ago, he's not taken into consideration. He played when they didn't use masks, or huge pads, and he was only like 5'6 150 lbs.
Would be nice to see the guy get a little recognition at least.
Wedigar 2 years ago
how is brodeur not number 1
google78645 2 years ago
for all of you telling me that hasek should be in the top 10...
there have been alot of great goalies that played the game.. and i am sorry... hasek cannot match up with the top 10 in the game.
is hasek better than sawchuk??? doubt it
is hasek better than hall???? doubt it
is hasek better than roy?? doubt it
now is hasek better than joseph.. sure
and parent? sure
but to put hasek in the top 10... no
what did he do to make goatender better?
sorry hasek does not make the top 10
cougar331 2 years ago
Well he has a better winning percentage then Brouder.
He has a better carrer save percentage.
He has more vezina then any other goaile.
He was on a terrible team, and still put up numbers then Brouder, who played ina trap system.
And Roy who had an allstar team infront of him
monokolopo 2 years ago
i am not trying to start a fight here.. but when you say roy had an all star team in front of him..
what do you call the late 90s red wing team??
and when hasek was with the sabres.. they also played the trap.. only not as well at the devils..
hasek is a good goal tender.. but what happen in ottawa? he did not feel like playing??
and sorry..check the stats.. plante had 7 vezinas... hasek is close.. but not in the top 10
cougar331 2 years ago
i knew you were going to look up the stats. When plante played the venzia was given to the goaile who let up the least amount of goals. Now they have the jennings.
And you mean those 43 games he played with ottawa?
where he had 28 wins, 5 shutouts, a GGA of 2.09, and a save percentage of .925?
Clearly that is a terrible season.
Buffalo did not play the trap, they just had Peca and Adudette, who were back checking forwards to make it seem like that.
monokolopo 2 years ago
hasek started in detroit in the early 00s, and yes in the one year where they had that all-star team, they won the cup.
Brouder is the prodeect of an environment. And if he started at the same age as Brouder did as a regular starter, then he would be far ahead of brouder in wins and shutout.
monokolopo 2 years ago
@monokolopo
hasek also played in chicago. before being cut. and landing in buffalo
but if you want better goaltenders than hasek..
i will add tony epostiso, george hainsworth, just to name a few....
BUT i am saying there have been over 100 goaltenders. and to say hasek belongs in the top 10..
no
billy smith has a better record, grant furh has a better record, what about beezzer or cujo?
if we make a top 20.. yes hasek it there
cougar331 2 years ago
i love Durnan. because of baseball when I was younger, I can catch good with both hands. I always wondered if I could do this as a goalie. Do you think it is still possible now? I'm thinking about buying two goalie gloves and trying it.
GIJimbo9 2 years ago
Brodeur shouldn't even be seven. His team won those cups, not because of him. Fewest shots aginst, fewest penalty kills, two hall of fame defensemen in front of him, how many can say that.
Brodeur, overrated!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
Show some respect man, questioning the all time wins leader doesnt make you smart, cool, or tough. Its obvious that every hockey fan would love to have Brodeur on their team. Also, getting less shots is often tougher. Oh, and every goalie on this list had great defensemen in front of them, its part of the game.
WMUsiv1 2 years ago
Maybe every hockey fan would love to have Brodeur, but not every goalie expert!
How many of those goalies had two hall of famers playing in front of them?
Getting less shots is harder? Sonce when? Ask the NHL goalies who average 33 a night if they would rather face Brodeurs 23 a night!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
lol so I take it youre the goalie expert? These are world class athletes who can put up 50 saves in a night if they had to, so fatigue isnt a big issue most of the time. Now Im not saying 20 is ALWAYS harder, but think about it. Its harder to stay on your game if 10 minutes goes by without anything happening, then you get a breakaway. Goaltending is just as mental as it is physical. And yeah, any successful goalie has good defense, give me a counter example. Point is, he's not overrated.
WMUsiv1 2 years ago
Counter example, sure. I guess Scott Mellanby is the best left winger of all time because he has the most wins for a left winger in NHL history.
Because Brodeur has the most wins doesn't mean he is great goalie. He was a small part of a team just like Mellanby was. Brodeur was an average goalie on a great defensive team!
A highly conditioned and mentally trained athlete, then a ten minute break wouldn't make it harder!
Devils were well disciplined too, fewest penalties to kill!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
Okay, first off, anybody with common sense realizes that wins are more connected with goalies than skaters because there aren't 3 other guys playing that position on a team during a game, thats why they keep track of wins for goalies and not really for skaters (though apparently you dug up some obscure statistic, you know what I mean). Second, the devils play defensive hockey, sure, but he's the key reason WHY they're so good. When goalies are better and give up less goals, the D looks better
WMUsiv1 2 years ago
Point #1...So if it's the goalie and not the D why Jersey is so good, why is it that the backups have good numbers as well? The Devils have ALL the best goalies in the NHL. Clemmensen is the second best goalie in the world then!
I think that just proved the point!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
Point #2...A left winger has the game winning goal, two assists on great stretch passes, has four crucial blocked shots on the penalty kill, back checks all night, battles in the corners, plays the neutral zone trap perfectly, has a fight that changes momentum when they were losing.
The goalie stops 19 of 22 shots and really played poorly.
Who gets the win?
Thank you for coming every one, try the veal!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
glad to see turk broda get some respect for a change. most leafs fans think of johhny bower as the best leafs goalie of all time, but clearly someone actually knows a thing or two about maple leafs history.
bmcclella2 2 years ago
belfour should be 4th
bskulldragon100 2 years ago
cougar331 2 years ago
that's such a hard and probably well debated list to put together
what about tretiak, dryden, cheevers, parent
steviedeedee 2 years ago
Your written words are very poorly phrased, but am I reading it right where you say Hasek doesn't belong on the list? Are you absolutely nuts and what evidence do you want for Dom to be on there? I can give you plenty.
bacardipardy 2 years ago
belfour sucks man fuck where the hell is he now ? damn indian
Pentictonbc 2 years ago
martin brodeur is the best now
suitelifeondeckowner 2 years ago
Where the hell is luongo
triplearmman3 2 years ago
What the hell has Luongo ever done? Oh ya nothing!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
What 15 year old put this list together?
cochranexyz 2 years ago
this video is years old before any of Martys Vezinas.
screechwashere 2 years ago
Osgood should be on there before Belfour ... everything esle looks good.. cant deny Roy and the hardware and that goes for Hasek and Broduer too.
kiker0909 2 years ago 2
hasek no.2 wtf?! wtf?! he is amazing but he is tied for wins with osgood, and chris has played less than him! ridiculous belfour is better, hasek should be around number 5, thats just stupid that sawchuk, plante, brodeur, and belfour were all considered not as good as a player who has never played on a week defense team, and compared to alot of these goalies has a low sa total. just ridiculous
beudslifer 2 years ago
Just ridiculous is you saying Belfour should be higher than Dom! LOL. Wins are usually a team effort in any case and how about comparing Hasek & Belfour on save %, shut-outs, vezinas, and hart trophies? I rest my case.
bacardipardy 2 years ago
Broduer put up good numbers his whole career and dont say it was cause of his defemce hes pure skill
zachattack19955 2 years ago
Curtis Joseph > all
RhoadsLivesOn 2 years ago
Damn right son
tstickpro 2 years ago
Best road hockey goalie maybe!
TheGoalieGuru 2 years ago
Number one is def. a split between Roy and Hasek. Both of them brought teams not deserving to the Finals, when Roy won his Cups with Montreal he was the entire team, The team didnt deserve to be there. Hasek during his stint all he had was a bunch of thugs and wannabes. People say his saves were luck but nobody gets that lucky that many times.
People argue that Brodeur is the best but last season proved that with the trap system any goalie can put up good numbers.
KaguyaShenku0 2 years ago 11
@KaguyaShenku0 agreed! i think roy is the best, and hasek is a VERY close second. belfour is definetly in the top 10, maybe top 5 depending on who u talk to. i would put him at #5, 6, or 7 :)
Slipknot5301 1 year ago
Broduer is a jerk! He had an affair on his wife with her sister! No future Hall of Famer should do something like that. I hope Broduer never gets in to the Hall of Fame, his greatness was destroyed with that affair
Roy is definetly the best all of them, but Hasek? Everyone gets lucky sometimes, but Hasek deserves his spot as #2. It wasn't luck. he has his own unique style of play, just like Roy. If he was a butterfly goalie you wouldn't care less! He just has a one of a kind style!
RedWingsify 2 years ago
bigphil399 2 years ago
Sundin456 2 years ago
SessionSakic 2 years ago
Kipprusoff has to be up there more and J.S Giguere is better than potvin
tstickpro 2 years ago
While I agree that Kipprusoff and Giguere are unbelievably solid goaltenders I don't believe they are better than the greats listed on this
redrun101 2 years ago
Joseph is better than belfour
tstickpro 2 years ago 2
I don't know they were truly good goalies but I had to go with one of them as number nine so it was Belfour.
Sundin456 2 years ago
Roy will always be better than brodeur heres why...3 conne smythes most ever! 155 playoff wins! who cares about regular season wins, i calculated it and if brodeur won the cup the next three seasons in a row he still wouldn't have as many wins as roy in the playoffs, not to meantion when Roy stole the cup from Brodeur in 2001
alexhamaliuk 2 years ago
This list is realyl messed up. Come on Ed Belfour? Seriously! He's a future Hall of Famer for sure but the game has been played for way too long for him to be top 10, there are too many great goalies to bump off.
In my opinion, a new book I just read "Let's Talk Hockey: 50 Wonderful debates" from amazon probably brings the best list out there and at least explains why other great goalies arent on there in the first place. Hey the top 10 list in that book at least has Bernie Parent on it
bigphil399 2 years ago
Broduer best out of all of them
IIITrogdorIII 2 years ago
Marty had the best system to limit the amount of rubber he faced...nowhere near the best...
ekimfloom 2 years ago
Roy is overrated! Hasek should be #1. Plus where's Grant Fuhr? He should be atleast top 5!
HockeyLover3598 2 years ago
Roy is overrated?!...I dont even kno how to respond to that. Hasek is just a flopper who couldn't win a cup till he went to a STACKED detroit team..Roy CARRIED teams on his own..think about that
ballssssssssssssssss 2 years ago
I agree...Roy was special while Hasek got lucky time after flopping time...but where are the other greats like Giacomin???
ekimfloom 2 years ago
Dumb cluck. Hasek got lucky time after time?? That was one kick-ass lucky streak to win 2 harts, multiple vezinas, and lead the league in save % nearly every year he paid the vast majority of the season. Your ignorance is mind-boggling.
bacardipardy 2 years ago 2
I don't agree with Roy being #1. With goalies like Sawchuck, Jac Plante, Hasek, Marty, and Dryden, I would've put him maybe at.... five... maybe 1 or 2 higher or lower.
MarkOfTheRebel 2 years ago
Ken Dryden played only 6 regular season games his rookie season , he won all 6 games..then won 12 playoff games, to win the Stanley Cup ! and MVP. Ken Dryden, goalie Montreal Canadiens for 8 seasons, won 6 Stanley Cups, 5 vezinas .....Lifetime record 258 wins 57 loses 74 ties...lifetime G.A.A 2.24 Ken Dryden retired at age 31 !
DaniThisChews 2 years ago
Venzinas are sht right now Brodeur is great but come on he plays behind trap defense which ugh is a break as a goalie I also think the Soviet Union Tretiak is better than half the goalies on this list and where is HExtall!!!!
rockinandrollin444 2 years ago
brodeur is a joke. letting in all those weak ass goals against the Canes this year with under 1 second left. hes done.
xAxiom720x 2 years ago
did you score an emptey net goal as a goalie and a goal against luongo so shutup
letsgosabers 2 years ago
Although i'm a big Wings fan and wanted to see a repeat, i really wanted Broduer to win the cup because he broke Roy's record or Montreal to win the cup in their 100th season! Way to go, Habs!
MarkOfTheRebel 2 years ago
wheres vernon?
elipepsibook3 2 years ago
nowhere, because hes a hack
xAxiom720x 2 years ago
Vernon was an ok goalie but not in top 10 of all time.
HockeyLover3598 2 years ago
loungo suck
chosaisharara 2 years ago
u suck
ajaykanwar94 2 years ago
Martin i dont think is 7th anymore
Doug1996104 2 years ago
..really???
Running4coffee 2 years ago
He should be 3rd
Jappeli026 2 years ago
belfour has to be in at least the top 5, for his earlier stuff at least...
BlueBombers4Life 2 years ago
Brodeur is #1 Goaltender
Patrick Roy is 31 WWF wrestler not goaltender
bladude12345 2 years ago
greatest is sawchuk then plante then dryden the broduer.
canadianhockey1924 2 years ago
Roy: 3 conn smythe.
Brodeur: 0 conn smythe.
Nuff said.
skalberg242 2 years ago
at least brodeurs kids dont go around starting fights with guys who clearly dont want to. that kid must take after his father eh? what a pussy
bladude12345 2 years ago
I fail to see what that has to do with Roy's 3 Conn Smythe Trophy's.
Fact remains the same.
skalberg242 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fine. Brodeur has 2 goals, Roy has 0
Brodeur Gold Medal in the Olympics, Roy no medal at all.
Brodeur 4 vezinas, Roy has 3
Most wins of any goaltender,
Brodeur far outpaces Roy in shutouts.
and Roy is a faggot.
I think I proved my point here.
bladude12345 2 years ago
I know all of that. I never said Brodeur is bad either. But he has not won any personal awards in the playoffs, and Conn Smythe Trophy is in my opinion the real heavy weight award in the league, along with Hart Trophy.
As for the shutouts, Brodeur has played his whole career behind a most often defensive system. Roy didn't, and he played 4 seasons in the 80's when the teams relied far more on offense than defense + the high scoring 92-93 season.
Brodeur is great, Roy is greater IMO.
skalberg242 2 years ago
The point is, you have to put everything in perspective. And all we have is our opinions at the end, I stated mine. :)
skalberg242 2 years ago
1:04 Im pretty sure that Ron Hextall managed to mount up 113 PIM during the 1988-89 season when playing for the Flyers.
theouterbanks 2 years ago 2