Added: 3 years ago
From: ErickWithNoK
Views: 6,009
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (96)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Actually, you're just saying what the majority of people (teenagers) are thinking about this movie. So it is so "annoying". I would like to have listenned to a good review, I'm disappointed.

  • I think your review is a little bit useless and I really want to know why you liked the movie if you says the scene were too long and "annoying"! You're contradictory ! Do you just ask yourself one second why the scenes were long ? With much more maturity maybe, even if you didn't like the movie, you should have asked you more questions. The scenes are very long because the camera is supposed to be objective in Gus' movies. If you really want to see a long movie, just watch "Giant".

  • this interview MADE my day :L i just finished watching the movie no joke 5 mins ago and only watched it cause i'm a huge huge huge huge fan of Taylor Momsen the girl who played Jennifer and was in the Grinch as i'm sure you know by now and i thought considering she was 14 and doing a scene like the one she did with Gabe Nevins (Alex) she was very impressive! I 100% agree with everything you said and I COULD NOT STAND your one macy's acting... sweet JESUS it was bad!! dunno how she got the part!!

  • i agree "elephant" had too many long shots following people walking (and at the expense of a coherent ending even--he used up half the film with that crap) but i've seen this twice and it really didnt have more than a few seconds of that--smoke a doob beforehand, time seems slower and everyhting else zips right by--whole movies seem as short as half hour shows...

  • I definelty have to agree. The Long Shots of The Random people were very overly used, I did enjoy the movie and the review was pretty good to, Good Job bro,

    Dont let Negative Comments get to you, the constant bashing of strangers is kind of Pathetic.

    Also found out that the Movie was an Ad Lib script which explaind why the dialougue was slow.

  • I definelty have to agree. The Long Shots of The Random people were very overly used, I did enjoy the movie and the review was pretty good to, Good Job bro,

    Dont let Negative Comments get to you, the constant bashing of strangers is kind of Pathetic.

  • I liked the movie very much, ok not compare with the avatar and such big names but the movie was very well done really enjoyed the movie

    Fuck you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I liked it too even though it was kinda bad. During the skateboard shots i was paying attention to the incredible music playing with it.

  • Yer, this film was pretty bad. Couldn't believe when it ended. Take out the boring lingering shots and it would have been about 45 minutes long. Nothing happened.

  • Gus Van Sant is an artist. He brings out the youthful beauty in everyone. This film, "Paraonid Park", I find myself falling in love with this kid. 'nough said.

  • this movie was soo boring

  • i really liked this movie,they could have shortened some scenes but the acting made it feel more real,like real people.

  • @vincent6445 oh, god forbid..

  • your fuckin gay

  • This film felt really indie to me, I really liked that about it. I really thought it was worth a watch :) I never really pay attenton to directors (cept tim burton, he's amazing) i wanted to see it, because I liked the look of it, I do IMA at school so I can appreciate what the director was trying to achieve, and I think it was really well done :) only one line sticks out in my head "i don't like her either but getting laid is better than not getting laid" xD

  • i agree it had wayy to long shots of things. But it was a really good show

  • you dont have to like skating to like the movie i hate skating but the movie was aright. just say the skating comment because peoples are like i love skating but they hate the movie.

  • I loved this movie. I think most people write it off as a movie trying really hard to be artsy, and that it was a fail for gus van sant...but far from it. This guy directed ..good will hunting..milk...he knows movies..this doesnt obviously make the movie amazing, but what does is that he brought a style where I think he was purposefully trying to make it look student film..the crappy acting, the random music, the long artsy shots..its got his style fused with one you'd see a college kid make

  • Good review, its pronounced Gus Van "ZANT" though.

  • Comment removed

  • I loved the movie ! I dont understand why so many ppl didnt, but I guess it just became to complicated for them ! xD

  • This is movie is by far terrible and I think anyone who says they like it are just trying to impress their hipster friends. Just because it's Gus Van Sant, doesn't mean its good.

  • dude everyone has their own opinion and u have no right to judge that

  • Okay, I have no freedom of expression? I believe that's a right of an American citizen, but I could be wrong...

  • yes you have freedom of expression but u shouldn't generalize people who like this movie as someone who want attention from their friends

  • thats a releif the movie is supposed to have those sucky skate vids whats the piont!

  • i think Paranoid Park was a horrible movie.

    Well,we got our opinions.

  • i love skateboarding and let me tell you that movei is boring dude. gosh

  • man i agree with you 100% on this review, one thing that also bugged me was tha main character like the kid has no emotions! on 95% of the movie he is like this: T_T

    is like,

    alex you suck! - T_T

    alex i love you! - T_T

    alex your mother is dead - T_T

  • his mom did not die

    at least i dont think?

  • hahah no his mom did not die i was just making a joke , how the he doesn't show his feelings and stuff

  • I suggest you to read more about film, basic classic screenwriting like The Poetics, Mckee, Field... classic literature and of course about critics, like Peter Solin... you basses you're comments on personal matters, you should do that and be a little bit more accurate, I mean, that long shots are a little hideous but they are very poetics i mean... It's trying to be realistic and directors usually do things just because, they're directors...

    You most inform to criticize.

  • I think the long shot are there in all his movies are to make it feel like it is a documentary. I pretty much die when ever I watch elephant when they are walking too.

  • I loved the trailer, i didn't like the film. I think i'll give it another try after your review.

  • I myself hated this movie. It was so boring. The only interesting shot was of the dying guard.

    The book is probably amazing, because this is a very personal thing, and the movie was just not able to convey his thoughts properly.

    We (me and my mum) ended up turning the movie off halfway through because we couldn't endure anymore!

    My suggestion...don't buy this movie. Rent it so that you don't waste 20 buck on a piece of crap that you may or may not like.

  • Awesome review I completely agree on everything you said, and I mean everything - Alex(annoying), acting (bad but enjoyed), long ass walks down hall(horribly boring and used as fillers). But I still liked it somehow.

  • i think you like everything

  • I think you could have done a better review for this movie, even though I still liked yourreview. This movie had boring suspense and the ending wasn't as great as I'd hoped it to be. It was a VERY long movie(I saw it on YT, it's different somehow) but I still really did love this movie. I enjoyed the long shots. I'd watch it again anytime so many people should see it.

  • Hi, I am from Estonia)

    What do I think about that movie... well if you want to know what a person feels when he caused someones death, read Fedor Dostojevskijs "Crime and punishment". It is a psychological masterpiece.

  • Oh My Mother Freaking God!

    I saw Paranoid Park!

    ILove Paraniod Park!

    I own Paranoind Park!

    That movie is fuckin sexy! I think that the dude that plays as Alex is fuckin sexy as well. I think his name is Gabe Nevins. Well, I just decided I'd share that bit of information with you.

    Oh, and you are totally right about those long ass skateboarding clips. They are fuckin annoying, but I absolutely LOVE that movie.

  • The way you review and talk about the movies is so anoying, i mean, you´re like 8 years old, what do you know about cinema to talk like if you were an expert.

    I don´t know... i just hate it.

    And by the way... long shots rule.

  • lmfao this is a joke right? this guy looks nothing near 8 years old. and just because you're young doesn't mean you can't have your imput on a movie. grow up ;/

  • what the fuck do you know about cinema?? you're 14 years old...I can you tell that the long shots are ridiculous?

  • i definitley have to agree with you. i thought the long shots of people walking and skating dragged on way toooooooo long. i didnt really think this movie was very good at all. i thought taylor momsens acting was pretty bad, i hate the way she says like soo many times, her acting makes the film seem unrealistic and unnatural. however i did like how the actors were actual teenagers and not some 20 something year old.

  • I saw it awhile back. And yeah, I do too have to agree with some of the things you said. I got so ANNOYED with the long scenes! But I couldn't help to laugh at some of the acting-heehee

    But overall is was an AMAZING MOVIE(:

  • lol if you liked skating you wouldn't have said that stuff.

    I would love it. I love skating.

    Not to sound too cliche, but it's my life.

  • The Movie was very very bad

  • i loved this movie!!!!!!

    :)

  • i liked this movie

  • Macy would look at the camera... it pissed me off so much!

    But the entire movie was super super close to the book, even the lines people said were the same.

  • nice vid, i agree with the stuff u said about the movie

  • I liked the movie ok don't really know why but I did.

  • to awnser your question about if it was improvised, yes it is...  Taylor Momsen commented on it and stuff. and i agree with your oppinion on that one girl, she keeps looking at the camera and she CAN'T ACT!!!!! :D

  • OMG i read this book adn heard it had a movie so i came online to watch some clips it seems so cool i would love to live my life like this and remember folow the highschool way of life: learn to kiss at 14 learn to drive at 15 LEARN TO HAVE SEX AT 16

  • YA CALLATE WE

  • where did u watch it?

  • This movie gives me the chills.

  • if your a skater like me you would realize that noone acts like that pussy ass whore alex the dude broke up with his gf for whatever reason and she gave him free sex hey free sex is tight son!

  • Wow i think the point of the movie went right over your head buddy.

  • nice english, I havent seen it yet but "Maybe ill liked it"

  • "I guess it's just something he likes to do so ... WHATEVER!" lmao.

    yeah i didn't like macy's acting either. she was just saying her lines like they were written.

  • i totally agreee with the extremly long shots of people and the long shots of people skatig i mean i think its kool to watch skatere but thats just to much and sorta liked the bad acting cause it was like what real live people talk like

    but that one girl macy just did not fit in the story like why the f*** was she in the movie she does not go good with the ever so hot gabe nevins

    but i did not mind the extremly long shots of gabe with no shirt on cause hes so hot like i already said

  • LMAO at how you gave HSM3 a "great" review, and you trashed this... You're amateur dude. You don't mess with Van Sant

  • I didn't like the movie. The ending. There wasn't even an ending. Gabe is hot, and Taylor is a really pretty girl though, but seriously the movie could've been better.

  • 1:30 MADE MY DAY

  • that movie was kinda gay.

  • the girl that played macy was just terrible

  • the fucking movie sucked i dont know what u fuck u are on.

    seriously it was the shittiest movie i have every seen

  • im sorry i have to say that he is an amazing director and he is subtle, obviously our generation is small minded and only enjoy the typical predictable films, AMAZING FILM. not a good review :(

  • Lmfao

  • @bacardi123yoyo I agree with you. Its so beautiful, capturing this real image of our generation. His direction makes you feel like you are in the film.

    I love his movies so much, especially elephant, for the unique way he films everything. And because the majority of the time he doesn't get trained actors, they are real, relatable characters.

  • hey!I'm an italian girl and it was really ausing hearing you talking,you are so nice! especially when you were talking about the skater's girlfriend!ahah

  • i agree with u here too i really liked this movie but there were some parts i didnt like too much but for the most part i really liked this movie and i liked the way it was done but i HATED the stupid skateboarding scenes and the parts where the kid was like walking to the bench i had to like fast forward i couldnt stand it but for the most part it was good

  • I must say I feel exactly the same as you, regarding the long scenes which i found annoying and the girl macy aswell she made me frustrated with her acting. However Gabe Nevins, Taylor Momsen madce this movie relatively good.

  • By the way, I loved the unresolved finale to the film. Why tie it up neatly, when you can give us all the gift of making up our own ending ourselves?

    Good on you, Gus.

  • Don't you say 'like' a lot?

    It's the exploration of a boy's psyche and his inevitable breakdown following the inadvertent murder of a security guard, as you say. So many people miss that, and say 'Where's the action??" etc, wanting car chases and gunfights and so on. Oh dear.

    I think the thing that you comment on - Van Sant's lingering shots of teens -- are a reflection of his adoration of the adolescent. He really loves you guys... if you know what I mean...

  • Great review...ive recently seen the film..and pretty much agree with everything you've said..cant wait for more reviews

  • I think your reviews are extremely boring.

    you talk way too fast, and you repeat things a lot.

    The girl who played Macy was a good actress. You wouldn't know anyway.

    It doesn't have anything to do with the fact that I know her personally. I've seen her act, and she is awesome.

  • LMFAO AS SOON AS YOU WROTE "The girl who played Macy was a good actress. You wouldn't know anyway." I KNEW WHAT WAS COMING.

    I even though to myself "okay they insulted me and my vlogs, they just said the girl was a good actress, they must know her" and sure enough YOU DO!

    That just made my day lmfao, thank you XD

  • Okay wait, fuck dat! u already done a review on Elepahnt :) ill check it out! :D

  • Holy! shit i knew jenniferwas from somewhere. thats creepy. cindy lou o gawsh lmao.

    anyway , ur opinion is totally trrue.

    The whole walking bits i never get. But i did like the skate boarding, mainly cause i thought maybe this what alex could be thinking or something. wateva. Im glad u did a review on dis! erm did u like his other movie, Elephant?

  • Hey...do you wanna see a movie with "ridiculously stupidly" long shots? You should check out any movie by Hungarian Director Bela Tarr...his movie Werckmeister harmóniák (Werchmeister Harmonies). It has 38 frames and it's a 2 1/2 hour movie. Or his movie Satan's Tango (Sátántangó) which is 7 hrs long. I've only seen the prior one, and I personally loved it.

    Van Sant takes much inspiration from Bela Tarr so I'm not sure if you'd like it, but they are true works of art

  • Oh God, I'll pass for now.

    Maybe one day when I'm confined to a bed for a day I'll watch it.

    I have a life outside of watching movies haha, 7 hours is a bit on the long side.

  • yea but you know you could split it up over a few days. The first 10 minutes of Satan's Tango about is watching cows walking and mooing through a deserted town.

    And it's amazing.

  • I'll have to take your word for it haha

  • they just did an interview with taylor on NylonTV, and she said a lot of the script WAS improvised :D

    i wanted to see it...but the reviews i've seen/read have been ummm...not too good.;/

  • Why dont you watch movies on line?? so you can watch them over and over while they are still in the theater?

  • I do watch them online sometimes but I watched this one on iO because I saw it there.

  • ive looked at ur cloverfield and this review and u got some pretty good stuff haha

  • haha at 1:30 he was about to say "fuck these long shots of skateboarding and stuff" but he said "screw these long shots of skateboarding and stuff"

    i liked it though.

  • Lmao I don't think I was about to say "fuck" but I just listened and it does sound like that hahah

    I jave no idea what I was going to say!

  • oh haha

    alright :D

  • coool

    okay and by the way. you are hott <3

    ok,no xd

    thanks for the reviews :D

  • okay and by the way. you are hott <3

  • OMG i totally agree with you about that long skate boarding thing! i was sitting there and i was like ok come onnnn

  • i think you should review "jumper" i downloaded it a few days ago, and i truly thought it was one of the worst movies i had ever seen

  • ill be the first to admit, gus van sant is weird. but for some reason i like that. i dont know why, but i like long walk scenes :/ maybe its because im one of those girls that hates too much action or whatever. and ill also say, the acting in most of his movies, isn't good. he just picks people he likes and doesn't care what everyone else thinks it seems. but for some strange reason i keep watching his stuff. oh and btw, Elephant is #2 in the death trilogy. #1 being Garry, #3 being Last Days.

  • Yes, I have yet to see Last Days or GERRY, which I'm sure you'll probably realize you misspelled and be pissed hahah ;D

    I think Van Sant is a bit pretentious, but I did enjoy Paranoid Park ALOT.

    I'll probably decide my opinion on him after I watch Good Will Hunting.

    I'm not going to watch his Psycho remake because I'm sure it will make me want to stab him lmao

  • oh god psycho... dont get me started -_-

    and, fuck, i just realized i spelled it wrong.

    i really need to check paranoid park out soon. the way you put it made it sound like standard van sant stuff, which is what i like :D oh yeah and i ran out of space so i didn't get to say good job on the review.

  • i watched it, it ws pretty good.

    but i know what you mean about

    the long shots of nothing.

    its pretty annying.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more