So... his former star student kills his later star student, who is the mother of his newest star student, who is the enemy of his former star student?
Slughorn is the best teacher (with Lupin and Mcgonagall) EVER ! I mean he's so funny. And so kind. I loved when he said "Harry" with a little voice at the end of the last one.
You're a good boy," said Professor Slughorn, tears trickling down his fat cheeks into his walrus mustache. "And you've got her eyes… Just don't think too badly of me once you've seen it…"
And he too put his head on his arms, gave a deep sigh, and fell asleep.
One of the 5 top moments of the whole book series.
I like the story of the fish, it was a nice touch on the part of the film makers. I just love the way Lily is a kind of benign presence in the background all the way throughout the books. The way she still influences the living - Harry, Slughorn, Snape... This scene plays into that theme.
my favorite scene from this movie. so touching. and the acting so terrific. i also love the story slughorn tells, i love it so much in fact that when i won a goldfish on a fair two days ago i decided to name it Francis. i just think its a perfect name for a fish and it honours my love for harry potter :)
Really touching scene. Jim Broadbent is such a fine actor.
I find it fascinating how these respectable wizards would show great appreciation to the wizarding greats regardless of how evil they are or would become. Ollivander comes to mind as well. Even the Sorting Hat recognizes where greatness lies, inspite of morality.
I love this scene not just because it was so emotional, it will prove to anyone that being Slytherin doesn't equate to being"evil". And for the record, Hufflepuff has its own strong points too.
Honestly I prefer this scene over the book's version. I feel there really is just much more emotion with it. The whole fish story is kinda touching and sad and it really adds more depth to Slughorn's relationship with Lily Evans. This was definately one of the better of the movies.
@LordAntWarrior. Snape was justified to be pissed at James, but not Harry, he's a kid who had no idea what went on, just because Harry is the son of James, children shouldn't be punished over what their parents did.
@SolidGold1980 I agree, this is one of the few scenes I think is much better than it's book-counterpart. The emotion in this scene is fantastic, the music, everything.
I also quite enjoyed the Burrow scene in the middle of this film, with the Death Eaters, which wasn't in the book altogether, but it was so well-done that I didn't really care that it wasn't faithful.
@mckfrr I wasn't keen on the James character in his early years either- Snape is partially justified for his demeanour and outlook on life and the way he treats Harry. I actually feel more sympathy for the Snape character than James'.
Its so "weird" how hagrid isnt the same these days. like he isnt the same as he was on the first harry potter movies if u know what i mean. like back then he had a bigger part on the movies.
@Ycampus That's kind of how it was in the books- with the trio not taking his subject Care of Magical Creatures at O.W.L level; subsequently fewer scenes involving Hagrid were needed.
@LordAntWarrior Oh ok. But everyone has pretty much changed, but I guess that everyone was supposed to change, when they changed in the books right :D. But in the movies it just happens so fast like when theres different directors things aren't the same as they were in previous movies, like the spell "expecto patronum" was just like light in the 4th movie, but in the 5th movie there were these animals that were running everywhere :D.
@Baldenlong77 well yeah but in the movies the deer didnt like come out of harrys wand you know. i actually found it out my self already. but you know it was only this shield.
This esce is of my favorite because without Slughorn's's confession not habria there thrills d ederrotar to voldemort one of my preferred ones undoubtedly.
Slughorn- James Buchanan
Obliviate248 1 month ago
poof
vickenn31 1 month ago
So... his former star student kills his later star student, who is the mother of his newest star student, who is the enemy of his former star student?
maaneblomme 2 months ago
Poof
Depporgeus 2 months ago 3
I couldn't enjoy that much the whole thing about the fish and lily, because is like it's not real hahaha because is not in the book.
everlefreak 2 months ago
one of the best scenes to have ever come out of the harry potter franchise
MehEmoKittens178 2 months ago 5
Why this Slughorn not fat
scorpion136 3 months ago
"Poof"
skew96 3 months ago
Two people are Voldemort fan boys.
CplFoggyDewhirst 3 months ago
How can anyone NOT laugh at Hagrid passing out?^^
SingerTonya 3 months ago
Slughorn is the best teacher (with Lupin and Mcgonagall) EVER ! I mean he's so funny. And so kind. I loved when he said "Harry" with a little voice at the end of the last one.
TheSunset0 3 months ago
It's impossible But I want to have Snape in this scene...I want to know how he was when Horace said something about Lily Evans to Harry.
suelovepharaoh 3 months ago
OMG I WOULD DIE TO SEE MY TEACHERS DRUNK...OR PASSED OUT ON THAT MATTER,
janemlee93 3 months ago
They are so high.
mrsturkeyboobs 4 months ago
Would memories be reliable if you were drunk?
MaskedManMike 5 months ago
@MaskedManMike
He's magic.
ThebanPhalanx 5 months ago
The day he came down stairs when the bowl was empty, was the year he retired. Connection, anyone???
TheIlluminatus503 6 months ago
I love Hagrid!
TheIlluminatus503 6 months ago
perfect.. simply perfect.
juli1100 6 months ago
everyone loves lily, she's the most tender person in all the series, and she ain't a mary sue like ginny
animeheartofpassion 6 months ago
Poof
Parkourrocker777 6 months ago
I love it when Harry just slowly reaches down and steadies Slughorn's shaking hand. So much going on in this scene, it's amazing.
33rosyposy 6 months ago
Amazing acting, writing, and direction. Overall, one of the all-time great scenes in the series.
DanaAlston 6 months ago
Professor Slughorn was brave like Lily
Ms070769 6 months ago 3
And his wand
Snapped in two
Which was saaaaaaaaaaad!
Clap clap clap clap clap
hahaha
johnnyachernar 7 months ago 9
I once had a fish!
WoWhistorian 7 months ago 2
You're a good boy," said Professor Slughorn, tears trickling down his fat cheeks into his walrus mustache. "And you've got her eyes… Just don't think too badly of me once you've seen it…"
And he too put his head on his arms, gave a deep sigh, and fell asleep.
One of the 5 top moments of the whole book series.
worldsquiethere 7 months ago 7
I love Lily! Most underrated character in the Harry Potter world? I think yes.
archergrl1996 7 months ago
POOF
TheDragonslyr 7 months ago
Broadbent is fantastic as slughorn!
ChrisHighwind 7 months ago 2
beautiful thank you for posting. i cant believe its over
magicweaver12 7 months ago
But thats LIFE ... I suppose
TomVeeKae 7 months ago
this part always makes me laugh and cry it's just so funny lol:) and sad:'(
sunnygirl523 8 months ago 5
the song is Slughorn's Confession
thewhateverdude123 8 months ago
WHAT IS THE SONG CALLED??
DARKPOWERNICHLAS 8 months ago
best scene EVER!
DARKPOWERNICHLAS 8 months ago
whats the soundtrack?
SuperFazinator 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BUT THAT'S LIFE! I suppose! You go along and then suddenly...poof!
iChailyn 9 months ago
I LOVE this scene! So powerful!
TheIlluminatus503 9 months ago
Lilly the best mother ever <3
imperius31 9 months ago 5
this part is warm to me. harry is so good, no, perfect!!! <3 love it
imperius31 9 months ago
"be brave, professor. Be brave like my mother. Otherwise, you disgrace her. Otherwise, she died for nothing." i love it
iloveAppleiPod 10 months ago 6
I like the story of the fish, it was a nice touch on the part of the film makers. I just love the way Lily is a kind of benign presence in the background all the way throughout the books. The way she still influences the living - Harry, Slughorn, Snape... This scene plays into that theme.
phoenixfriend 10 months ago 2
this scene still brings tears to my eyes
LincolnPower27 10 months ago 3
@LincolnPower27 same for me...everytime i watch it :'(
Lesbibum 6 months ago
my favorite scene from this movie. so touching. and the acting so terrific. i also love the story slughorn tells, i love it so much in fact that when i won a goldfish on a fair two days ago i decided to name it Francis. i just think its a perfect name for a fish and it honours my love for harry potter :)
c5l5o5v5e5r5 1 year ago
who ever plays slughorn nails this scene
soxnation3419 1 year ago 5
@soxnation3419 couldnt agree more
LincolnPower27 10 months ago
@soxnation3419 Slughorn is played by Jim Broadbent...
Lesbibum 6 months ago
puff...
willewilleponken 1 year ago 2
Harry looked like a kid, siting on that chair and claping his hands xD
Guldressur 1 year ago
the one person who didn't click the like button was Hagrid.... only coz he missed such an awesome part!
JoeMcLuvin 1 year ago
lol harry clapping
dlohoh978 1 year ago 2
Really touching scene. Jim Broadbent is such a fine actor.
I find it fascinating how these respectable wizards would show great appreciation to the wizarding greats regardless of how evil they are or would become. Ollivander comes to mind as well. Even the Sorting Hat recognizes where greatness lies, inspite of morality.
392redienhcs 1 year ago
@woodyuniverse That is a dog that is really fluffy and could be held under one arm of the average five year old.
glitteryYtiger 1 year ago
You did the right thing, Horace.
4thtroika 1 year ago 20
@4thtroika Only because he was drunk.
BarkBarf 2 months ago
I love this scene not just because it was so emotional, it will prove to anyone that being Slytherin doesn't equate to being"evil". And for the record, Hufflepuff has its own strong points too.
geocross237 1 year ago 7
LOL the bit when hagrids head hits the wall is so funny its like "BANG knocked out"
charlieiscool1000 1 year ago 4
0:08 hagrid looks like that huge mummet the big blue scary 1
reecemnl 1 year ago
poof XD ! Amazing :P
JDreamProductions 1 year ago 5
Honestly I prefer this scene over the book's version. I feel there really is just much more emotion with it. The whole fish story is kinda touching and sad and it really adds more depth to Slughorn's relationship with Lily Evans. This was definately one of the better of the movies.
TheInstantClassic1 1 year ago 25
@TheInstantClassic1 i know what you mean
lilylunapotter77 1 year ago
@TheInstantClassic1 Better emotionally yes. But I hate how they left out some memories needed visiting and the battle in the tower
aamiller90 3 months ago
@TheInstantClassic1 I agree.
SingerTonya 3 months ago
@TheInstantClassic1 is the story of the fish in the book?
carinah1236 1 month ago
Harry helping Slughorn get the memory into the beaker was very touching
MrPerfect2000Z 1 year ago
awwwww this always makes me wana give someone a hug lol
LittleMissAzula 1 year ago
@LordAntWarrior. Snape was justified to be pissed at James, but not Harry, he's a kid who had no idea what went on, just because Harry is the son of James, children shouldn't be punished over what their parents did.
mckfrr 1 year ago 6
Why is Slughorn's forehead pale, yet the rest of his face looks tannish? haha
punkinnugget 1 year ago
does anyone know what is the name of the song playing while Harry begins to talk about his mother? 2:02
Fader33 1 year ago
@Fader33 It's called "Slughorn's Confession". It's Track #21 on the HBP soundtrack.
punkinnugget 1 year ago
@punkinnugget Thank you! :)
Fader33 1 year ago
@Fader33 No problem!
punkinnugget 1 year ago
Harry's speech is so powerful in this! One of the best scenes from Harry Potter.
cupcake101 1 year ago 2
Thank you so much for posting this - I've been looking all over for this scene - one of my favorites!
buffnrub 1 year ago 2
this scene was actually way better in the movie than the book
SolidGold1980 1 year ago
@SolidGold1980 I agree, this is one of the few scenes I think is much better than it's book-counterpart. The emotion in this scene is fantastic, the music, everything.
I also quite enjoyed the Burrow scene in the middle of this film, with the Death Eaters, which wasn't in the book altogether, but it was so well-done that I didn't really care that it wasn't faithful.
LordAntWarrior 1 year ago
i love his expression to when harry says the bowl will be empty forever, he is like nooo!!! XD, but this scene made me cry at the midnight premiere
DeanWLover24 1 year ago
the beginning is so funny, but it's so sad. his story, i mean.
innlovable 1 year ago 3
"And suddenly...poof."
"Poof."
"Poof." Lmao, Harry looks like he saw the light.
RavensAndRitter 1 year ago
Whenever Slughorn tells the story with the fish i start crying...its so saaaaaaad :'(
juicyfruit57 1 year ago 3
Hahahaha, oh god, Harry just sits there and watch ehm sing, bahahahahaha!!!
R2R3L4 1 year ago 2
poor professor slughorn, he shouldnt blame himself no one knew he would turn into "He Who Must Not Be Named'
ThatGEEKChanel 1 year ago 2
@ThatGEEKChanel agreed. He didnt know at the time
smileyfan16 1 year ago
... and then suddenly POOF! rofl :)
MrsKeepRockin 1 year ago
BUT THAT'S LIFE!
digitalcolleen 1 year ago
what the fuck is this! seriously
gabriellex13 1 year ago
This is the only part of this movie that made me cry.
*sniff* Oh that metaphor.
the0amazing0joe 1 year ago
great work...! does anyone know the title of the song in the beggining?
MrSevereful 1 year ago
@MrSevereful odo the hero
dihardtwihard123 1 year ago
@dihardtwihard123 Thank you! :D
MrSevereful 1 year ago
Harry's mother was such a beautiful woman who touched everyone, lol, even Severus Snape! I'm glad his father grew up later on, though.
mckfrr 1 year ago 6
@mckfrr I wasn't keen on the James character in his early years either- Snape is partially justified for his demeanour and outlook on life and the way he treats Harry. I actually feel more sympathy for the Snape character than James'.
LordAntWarrior 1 year ago
Its so "weird" how hagrid isnt the same these days. like he isnt the same as he was on the first harry potter movies if u know what i mean. like back then he had a bigger part on the movies.
Ycampus 1 year ago
@Ycampus That's kind of how it was in the books- with the trio not taking his subject Care of Magical Creatures at O.W.L level; subsequently fewer scenes involving Hagrid were needed.
LordAntWarrior 1 year ago
@LordAntWarrior Oh ok. But everyone has pretty much changed, but I guess that everyone was supposed to change, when they changed in the books right :D. But in the movies it just happens so fast like when theres different directors things aren't the same as they were in previous movies, like the spell "expecto patronum" was just like light in the 4th movie, but in the 5th movie there were these animals that were running everywhere :D.
Ycampus 1 year ago
@Ycampus
It was always animals. In Prisoner of Azkaban Harry's patronus was a deer.
Baldenlong77 1 year ago
@Baldenlong77 well yeah but in the movies the deer didnt like come out of harrys wand you know. i actually found it out my self already. but you know it was only this shield.
Ycampus 1 year ago
Jim Broadbent is amazing. He made that work so well.
Dan52d 1 year ago
My personal favorite scene in this movie. Harry uses such powerful emotion!
Pureone13 2 years ago 71
This esce is of my favorite because without Slughorn's's confession not habria there thrills d ederrotar to voldemort one of my preferred ones undoubtedly.
vicent8920 2 years ago
one of the good scene in Harry potter
storboy 2 years ago 55