Added: 3 years ago
From: StShamus
Views: 1,893,675
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,383)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Got to say - this is not Metallica. Unless they have become suddenly very very VERY synth dependent. There appears to be a good deal of production values that are missing too. My best guess is someone mucking about themselves, and sticking Metallica's name to it as a joke.

    Having said that, its good enough rendition if done by somebody individually, or a garage group. Not Metallica though. Better re-branded as Rock Imperial Theme and be done with it.

  • Metallica or not.. this is magnificent.

  • if this was metallica, you wouldn't be able to hear it.

    youtube and every user would have been sued by lars and his merry henchmen

  • Comment removed

  • This is no Metallica, because the way the guitars sound like is much to deep...In any song of Metallica the guitars have such a bass like this song. And you can also hear that the way the drums is played isn´t the drumming-Style of Lars...there are too few cymbals and snare-hits and Lars often plays the cymbals together with the snare on 1 or 3

  • @XtremeChicken1 Its obviously a piss take. And with your indepth analysis of Metallica... Of which im a huge fan. You got fooled. I pissed myself (not literally) at your in depth analysis of something thats obviously a gag. This is no Metallica LMAO

  • i DONT know that the song here is metallicas, but i DO know they did the imperial march for one of the SW game sound tracks years back.

  • This is definitely not Metallica, it's more like an combination of Vangelis and Nightwish.

    But it's definitely AWESOME!

  • what a load of shit

  • im gonna dislike tis vid, JUST to make it look like a red lightsaber!!!!!!!

  • Epic song

    

  • Epic soundtrack fuses with epic music style...

  • omg people it doesnt matter whether its metallica or not. just enjoy the music for crying out freaking loud!

  • @tcp3059 It does matter. PEople don't deserve credit for things they didn't do.

  • SO GEIL, EINE EPISCHE MELODIE!!! DIE GITARREN GEBEN DEN REST!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Souns like harry potter in the beginning but when the guitar was playing thats EPICCC!!!

  • @msjohannesburg

    Got it backwards man, Star Wars' sound track predates Harry Potters' by a few decades.

  • Metallica or not Metallica watch Imperial March meets metal by 331erock..good shit!

  • @NexxaiM hells yeah Erock is the shit

  • lol... Metallica are making music in MIDI now? Thats not Metallica... Not in a million years...

  • it would be cooler if done purely with rock instruments, no orchestra

  • @FroggyBre

    I love how the two top comments aren't that anymore

  • fyi to the people who think that this isn't metallica, well this is. If you're too blind to check, they have this live.

  • @blessthefalllover1 you are ignorant. And if you are a metallica fan you are a terrible one. Any real Metallica fan can tell that the drums, bass and guitar sound NOTHING like Metallica. You are probably one of those idiots that thinks Metallica and Trans Siberian orchestra play together as well. Dumbass.

  • @CEnforce Except that metallica DID do a cover of the imperial march. and this is it.

  • @Mordraiv Wow. You are a horrible Metallica fan has no has no ear for what their playing sounds like! "Synth strings and synth guitars + drum machine?? Must be Metallica" wow, that makes you really really stupid and one of the worst Metallica fans in the world

  • Metallica. Hahaha :D

  • epica has a better cover ^^

  • This helped me find the droids I was looking for.

  • Don't thumbs me up, I don't wanna be up there with those jerks.

  • Nice cover, but this is definitely not Metallica.

  • Only two words describe this song Kick Ass

  • No way is this 'tallica

  • @mundanem o shut the fuck up -___-

  • Metallica has altered the song. Pray they don't alter it any further.

  • No way in hell this is Metallica

  • As amazingly done as this is, even Metallica can't make star wars cool.

    I'm sorry, but the camp costumes, the stupid looking aliens, the ham acting.. just no.

    I'm not saying the movies are shit. the effort that went into them is amazing. It's just that star wars is no where near the epitome of bad-ass that everyone makes it out to be.

    Apart from the death star. Even if it is just Abbadon's Planet Killer.

  • @PripyatSurvivor you will succumb to the power of the darkside

  • haha darth vader is dead .... well the actor any ways

  • @ABeam07 Actually David prowse is alive and kicking i got his book signed about 5 weeks back at my local waterstones bookstore =P

  • Just because Metallica HAS played this song, doesn't mean that this IS Metallica playing this song. lol

  • @gabefreeman I agree 100%. This sounds like some computer generated sadness.

  • wow. this is definitely not metallica. someone just learned how to use general midi on his sequencer.

  • My vote still goes to not being Metallica. When bands do covers, they still sound like themselves. This sounds nothing like Metallica. The guitar tone is all wrong. Also, the keyboard or synthesizer lead me further to believe that it isn't Metallica.

  • @v0dka360 Seriously? Don't bring Star Trek into the debate again. On that note however, as far as captians go: Janeway > Picard > Kirk > Sisko > Archer, IMO. THAT SAID, I consider Star Wars to be considerably equal to Star Trek in terms of originality.

  • Awsome. From 0:01 to 2:47

  • To be honest, this doesn't sound much like Metallica at all. Granted; the composition is not their own, but generally bands tweak their covers to fully suit their genre and playing style, Ulrich's drums don't sound nearly as driving as they could, and there's hardly any striking electric guitar in it, as compared to, say, For Whom The Bell Tolls. Listen to the two and compare.

  • get the fuck out of here metallica and captain picard have an elite team to put down starwars

  • Star wars is too good for metallica, they should try the "we did it" song from dora the explorer

  • Just one word: "amazing". Or "wonderful", like you want.

  • SO PERFECT!

    

  • the power is not here!

  • que chido esta

  • lol I came back to try and get rid of my comment because about once an hour theres an asshole trying to tell me I'm wrong. WAAAAA THIS IS METALLICA!!! Fuck you. Who cares if it's metallica. It still sucks. Just like half of metallicas work.

  • @gabefreeman just die ok?

  • @gabefreeman Which ½ sucks? I like old school Metallica much more than their newer stuff, but I can't say I HATE anything they put out. For the record, I agree with you inasmuch as I don't think this is their work. \m/ Metal FOREVER \m/

  • @lordtonedeaf I don't hate it either, but from st anger on, it's just not good.

  • @gabefreeman I have to agree with you there.

  • @gabefreeman You're totally right gabefreeman, this absolutely is not Metallica playing this song

  • i love how the two top comments are: 1. this is not metallica and 2. this is metallica xD

  • @FroggyBre I love how wrong you are xD

  • I wish George Lucas would have them do one of the Star Wars game soundtracks :)

  • metallica is so awesome

  • 832 people are Rebel scum!!!!!!! IF YOU ONLY KNEW THE POWER OF THE DARK SIDE!!!!!

  • metallica+imperial stormtroopers=EPIC RIGHTOUSNESS!!!!

  • songs awesome :D

  • The Like/Dislike bar looks like a Light Saber.

  • @BRINKLover When the fuck has a lightsaber ever had a red HANDLE?

  • @JimmytheTexan1441 Since He made one

  • @BRINKLover That some sort of a sith-spear lightsaber?

  • @karih123 it's a green lightsaber with a red handle lol

  • @BRINKLover Yeah the red one is the Dark Side's one xD

  • Whether or not it is Metallica, it is still badass! Sith Empire Forever!

  • \.../(-_-)\.../

    

  • some people got a lotta time on their hands.. must be occupiers lol

  • it is too slow

  • Its too slow for Kirk hammet

  • it's not metallica but pretty good :)

  • @xmcmozartx oh but it is

  • omg, way to fucking slow!!! you cant headbang to this shit

  • is not metallica poser

  • No surprises. I could have sung this in my head having the exact same result. This can't be art. Guess it's crap.

  • WTF? This isn't Metallica >:S

  • total lächerlich....absoluter Fuck,müssen schon Sachen nachspielen,weil selber nix mehr kommt von ihnen...die Zeiten von Metallica sind vorbei.....

  • @venom8086 Ja, weil covern etwas total lächerliches ist, wenn man es als Cover vermarktet und nicht als eigene Produktion. Selbst 1997 haben sie mit Garage Inc. eine Menge gecovered. Nach deiner Logik hätten sie dann schon keine eigenen Titel schreiben können. Seltsam, dass sie bis heute immer noch die erfolgreichste Metal-Band sind.

  • @XXxironXX also ich höre diese Gruppe schon lange nich mehr,ich habe zwar noch die alten Scheiben auf Vinyl.."Master of Puppets" usw,aber kommt für mich nich mehr in Frage,es gibt weit aus bessere Bands die mehr drauf haben..zB Kreator,Slayer,obwohl Slayer auch stark nachgelassen hat,da kann man sich auch nur noch die älteren Sachen anhören,aber das Schlimme is ja,das die Leute diesen Coverscheiß noch kaufen....

  • Justin should sing this song.

  • thats pretty fuckin cool

  • ok 1. what the hell makes u think this is metallica. 2. dont talk bout metallica unless u no it ok.

  • this song rocks

  • This was made by a group of fans of Star Wars.

  • 815 people are from the rebels! lol :)

  • haters hate, its what they do.... although i will say it sounds like a Halloween song... amityville whoreshow again

  • is there a repeat button for ths?

  • @SeargentWhiskeyjack

    There is repeat dick for this.

  • what a shit

  • If you don't like Metallica or Star Wars, then why are you here?

    THIS IS metallica, i heard them on a stage. How come this song has so many dislikes?

    It is perfect. Thumbs up if you love Darth Vader.

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 Just one litlle detail mate, THIS IS NOT METALLICA!!!!!

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 it doesn't even sound like metallica

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 So many haters on youtube. Can't appreciate good, geeky music when it bites them in the ass.

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 you're right....totally metallica \,,,/(>.<)\,,,/

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 Every single bit of this is synthesized music. If you had a musician's ear, you could tell the difference.

  • @SliderBlackrose you are correct sir.

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 This isnt Metallica tho.

  • @RedrumRedrumRedrum16 Cause people suck

    

  • lol who cares. This song sucks either way.

  • The trolls are just jelly cause you and I have seen Metallica do this live. and they have not.

  • This is Metallica, stop now...

  • ja pierdolę, czy nie możecie na chwilę zamknąć jadaczek i cieszyć się tak niesamowitą muzyką, zamiast kłócić się i bluzgać na siebie? Dorośnijcie, niech sobie niemcy żyją, ja też za tym krajem nie przepadam, ale to co jest w komentarzach poniżej to już absolutna szopka, wstyd mi czasami za Polskę...

  • Not Metallica

  • @objectivechristian this is metallica...

  • O kurwa...czy ktoś tu ma problem do Polaków? -.-

  • this isnn't metallica, it's trans siberian orchestra

  • Autant Metallica, je n'ai aucune affinité autant c'est version de la marche impérial est terrible !!

  • StS? love subway to sally : )

    greetings from Poland.

    Niemcy są zajebiści i chuj wam do tego polaczki jebane.

  • wal sie szwabie

  • Dude. Weak.

  • nice light saber

  • Not metallica

  • @gabefreeman i want to agree with you but it is Metallica feat. the trans Siberian orchestra, been out a day or two my man.

  • @gabefreeman this is metallica!

  • @gabefreeman this is metallica...

  • it rly is :P

  • @gabefreeman Nope. Chuck Testa

  • @gabefreeman

    This IS Metallica

  • @gabefreeman

    It is, actually. Breaking format is fun!

  • @gabefreeman

    your mistake - its really metallica

  • @VuvuzelaTerror, Do you feel better, now that you've told me something I already know? Either way, it's still shitty and made 100% on a computer.

  • no comments... -.-

  • Doesn't really sound like Metallica at all. The crunch of the guitars aren't right and the drums are too subdued. Lars would never allow all that other stuff to bury his drums like that.

  • 792 people are apart of the rebel alliance and must be destroyed. Join the dark side

  • sounds more cradle of filth than metallica :/

  • Każdy niemiec kurwą jest! / I fucking love star wars!

  • @wierzba1992 gosh you are so fucking dumb.unbelievable.being polish as well but you are a joke

  • @aeonova101 you can suck my balls asshole

  • @wierzba1992 proved it again haha

  • @wierzba1992 ty kurwa, spindalaj!

  • @Goombuu ssij mi jajca

  • another band who thinks its funny to fuck up st... and then i came at 0:45

  • Niemcy to idioci/ Sooo fuckin' awsome!

  • that no sounds metallica, a guy like me must be a creator of that song but is a good song

  • stop making metallica look bad they didnt make this pile of shit

  • ...Since when did Metallica do this? Which Album?

  • GREAT, i don't know what people are saying, its a great idea!

    now, heavy metal isn't everyone's thing but if your 12 to 16 and don't like it then at some point you will, go through a heavy metal phase that is,

    DON'T BE PUT DOWN StShamus ITS GOOD (for me)

  • :D Very Good :D

  • no offense

  • this sucked btw!

  • this brings shame to the real star wars!

  • is that true?

  • @MasochismMinorThreat i tore my down after St Anger....and burned it after Death Magnetic

  • haha....funeral :D

  • A cool idea; A horrible outcome

  • It sounds like Dimmu Borgir

  • LAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AME ASS

  • :Guys chill...its not that bad.

  • I've had an orgasm with this

  • fuck you all this song is good i think. it was the 1st song by metallica i heard, bro showed it to me and i think its fucking good.

  • >>> Bloody Lame!!! <<<

  • Comment removed

  • :nonmegusta:

    

  • Hah, if theyd screwed this up Darth Vader would be like: SCREW YOU YOU DONT STAND AGAINST THE THEME

  • @infestation20 Not even gonna sugar coat it...... That was dumb

  • It is metallica niggers

  • @akiraman26 never.

  • Ah.....Metallica and the San Fransisco Orchestra........a damn good combo if you ask me.

  • Now THIS is the power of the Dark Side...

  • metallica can't play this

  • No one can stand against Empire with this Theme

  • not metallica but nice

  • Who cares who made it. I assume all of you commented on this video not because your a douche but because you like it? Am I right? Cause some people like to ruin the fun other people. The internet is a harsh mistress, the best thing to do is give her the back hand and send her to the kitchen.

  • ...... not metallica

  • This track is an awesome BEAST !

  • Niemcy to chuje jebane / great metallica's song

    thumb up!