Melanie Amaro sings I Have Nothing - The X Factor 2011 Live Show 1

[pawlis18]

super ... there is no such level in Poland as in the usa ... and she is amazing!! I hope you win!

[vukitetine]

she is really good but racher is better :)

[mariahubby]

shes okay , nothing special though

[n3ssah1]

Love her :)

[zeustruth]

she is more whitney more than anything. now thats saying something, but Stacy Francis is even more gifted.

[verojose34]

AWESOME i just love her she better win she is the best all who have negative things to say about her are just jealous i want to see you get up on that stage and do what she does best SING HER BUTT OFF!!!

[cynaamonj]

AWESOME!

[Happyhouse445]

She better win!!!

[bolobradas]

oops Albums !!!!

[bolobradas]

these smart ass remarks they must be family of the other contestant cause we all know 100% she got it her and Rachel Crow are gonna be toe toe winning the 5million but Drew will win more on ablums 

[bolobradas]

she just put Beyounce to shame !!!

[bolobradas]

she can get a no. 1 hit right now !!!! she put Janet Jackson,Mariyah,Whitney to shame well she is right at there level and above...she gonna win the 5 million i'm on XFactor now lol i know what there doing they all got a record and Melani theres no doubt you won .. your young and if sorry you eat clean you would be soo fine and the men would drew l

[Cristhiansoc]

THA't's how you do it.

[musicprro]

wow i like this beat

[Courtneyy1209]

Live show #1 and she already nails a whitney

song.

[mwhite0313]

The group going into the finals were all great. All of them. I hate to see any of them go home and not show up again. In fact, most of that group starting out, before elimination, were good!  Love them all.

[1218184]

Melanie has proved she is THE BEST!!! Her voice is soooo powerful delightful!!! Congrats Melanie.!!!! For me you are the winner.

[1218184]

Melanie has proved she is THE BEST!!! Her voice is soooo powerful delightful!!! Congrats Melanie.

[rosedoug]

zumepro....I hate to differ...and I am allowed my opinion....she has raw talent...without any training....when a singer can give me goosebumps or bring me to tears...then I think great...Whitney, Mariah, and Marc Anthony did that to me...so, I had same reaction with Melanie...and I think she has best voice on Xfactor....Josh and the older gent contenders too

[jennysmomma]

She is nothing special. She has a great voice but this song has been sung so many times and to me nothing stuck out to me. Drew is unique she makes the songs her own and she is only 14! With a voice like that already!

[mslady04]

@jennysmomma Drew is nothing special and does not have a voice like that regardless if she makes her own songs..its not a song writing show..It's a singing competition and Melanie has a powerful voice.

[71Bray71]

Melanie All the people is voting for you!! You're the best!! You'll be bigger!! Please people vote for her! She's the best!! Look a hear her voice is amazing y so much better that the anothers!

[JUSME96703HAWAII]

SOMEBODY GIVE THIS GIRL A RECORD CONTRACT......WE LOVE YOU MELANIE.......

[peeranutpika]

Mariah Amaro

[amartinez343]

Melanie Amaro is fuckin sexxi ;) and she sings so beautiful

[mainehime]

Amazing... I feel like Simon giving her a second chance made her push herself even further!!!

[rosedoug]

Melanie is just 'average'? are you tone deaf? She is en par with Whitney, Mariah...she is gifted...why she has so many people talking about her...more than any contestant on America's Got Talent or American Idol...I am sure you never commented on any other contestant on those shows...give props where deserved

[zumepro]

@rosedoug Melanie is humble, sexy and vocally above average, but I have to admit she is not en par with Whitney, Mariah, Beyonce, other Divas yet. So far the young singer of this generation that is en par / beyond with those Divas is Charice. Melanie is Definitely the best finalist on the X Factor though.

[thehappykadaw]

American Idol and America's Got Talent wished they would've found Melanie first! Honestly, if you think Melanie is just "average" after listening to her powerful audition, you are truly in denial.

[bosumibo]

Whenever I watch this movie, I will cry.

Wonderful voice!

[MrTonyman125]

and how does her personality not shine through? Have you seen her audition? She NAILED it! IN this performance she was using every ounce of control she had to not burst into tears. This was true passion it's the real deal, pure raw talent. Yall are just crazy if you don't recognize the talent here...crazy

[MrTonyman125]

she doesn't stand out?! MY FAT ASS SHE DOESN'T! You give any of the other singers on this show this whitney song and the only one that would even come close to being able to sing it would be Stacy but even stacy wouldn't do as good of a job as her. Some people just can't recognize true talent. I'd like to see your ass get up and sing whitney houston good luck. This chick is good enought o win and is extremely remembered. She is a star and i will buy her albums as for you what ever dude.

[bubba34839]

I can see it now it will be Melanie and Stacy head to head.Chris Rachel and Astro will go a long way

[mtawhiri]

I betcha Simon picked this song for her and as LA Reid .. it was predictable ...

Hopefully you'll be able to pick your own songs Melanie ... A more modern uptempo one... one to show your personality and versatility.

[thesparksplug]

Miss Melanie, you are here to win this thing. Clean up the act. There are persons like Rachel in the race.

Keep your confidence and energy up. That is where I see your strength dwells.

If you get through to the next round, please be happy and sing a happier song! At this stage of the game song selection is key.

[syuz999]

oleeeeeeeeeeee superrrrrrrrrrrrrr

[Jackson22622]

BEST FINALIST

[TheNatashaCortez]

she's the next Beyonce

[MrBAD97]

oh, and her voice does not stand out of the others. Its average.

[chrissy28118]

@MrBAD97 say what???? u crazy...lol

[MrBAD97]

She wont make it far. Yes, she can sing. But she's boring and unoriginal. She sings those big songs note by note, and cant even get them all right lol. She does not have star quality..Her personality doesn't even shine through her performance..

[thesparksplug]

@MrBAD97 I am thinking that she was not in the right state of mind and it came out in the performance. And she could have done something more energizing. But I disagree totally about lacking star quality. You need to see more of her other performances.

[gaby47]

so she's pulling the whitney card? lol

[beau4307]

Amazing! wow.

[reconbarbo]

She's a hottie

[biancaortiz09]

wtf ! dumbass shes gonna win it ... open your ears 

[4thefaithful]

@biancaortiz09 Go back and listen to the painflul sound at 0:39 seconds. She will not win it if she keeps that up. Josh Krajcik blew her away last night.

[Egle880129]

she`s cool, but no fun. Will not hold on for long.

[broesie60]

my favorits are josh and drew - but she is also very good.

[BURAKK2k8]

winner