to all commenting on how long this took(time or no. of strikes) leave video responses of you doing it, but this is a demonstration of a last-resort tinder, solar ignition would create an ember, but if you have to use this method you don't always have bright sun shine, but fire steel can create an ember too and does not need sun shine. He did a good job demonstrating oak scrapings as tinder, the reason for the video.
I don't get it. 30 strikes with a firesteel is a lot of strikes to get a flame. If a rod has 3,000 strikes that is a 100 fire-firesteel. Carry 2-3 mini-bics and you have 100s maybe up to 2,000 flames with no tinder, go right to small kindling. I don't get the firesteel thing except for the final backup. An 10x7 flexible page magnifier will give you a flame and it can last forever. Coghlans has a flint/striker permanent match that gives 1000s of flames on wick and 1/2 oz of light fluid, too.
@MrJoeyBoombotz Yes, there are many other fire-starter options. The firesteel is preferred by many because of its reliability, such as, countless sparks, no moving parts (could break or corrode), and it works when wet. Matches, lighters, magnifying lenses, etc... have more room for error as they can have more problems (get wet, break, weak Sun, etc...). This vid was to simulate no ideal tinder was readily available. If better tinder was used there'd be less strikes necessary to get flame.
@topguntin Yes, you're right! It's an old Swiss Army Knife that I use as a 'beater' knife (I abused it as a teenager). I designated the smaller blade to be the scraper so I'm not worried about the care of the blade.
That's a good suggestion. Also, the back of the saw blade or the edge of the awl tool work pretty well too.
@icychap Believe it or not the Swiss Army Knife blade is quite resilient. It stays pretty sharp. Doing the scrapings like this with the blade will dull it after awhile. A couple swipes thru one of those hand-held sharpeners works pretty well. This demo was to show tinder could be made if it couldn't be found (like in a survival situation). So, probably not the best thing do with a blade if you have other options. Worst case, use the tip end of blade for scraping so base of blade stays sharp.
@gundog5 Thanks for the quick response. Could you use the spine/jimping of a thicker knife to make the scrapings, or will they never be as fine as when you use the edge itself?
@icychap I'd think using the blade would give you the best results as you can get good thin flakes. It would depend on the knife, though. The saw on the Swiss Army Knife could also work to make saw dust. Give your idea a try (with a bigger knife) and see if it'd work. Maybe compare between using the spine and blade. If you can get reasonable results using the spine then it might be the way to go if you don't wanna risk dulling your knife.
Yep, I have several good firesteels. Guess I shoulda mentioned that I was using the mini-firesteel on purpose; Having it on the keychain as a contingency, but also need to practice and know how to use it if the need ever arises.
to all commenting on how long this took(time or no. of strikes) leave video responses of you doing it, but this is a demonstration of a last-resort tinder, solar ignition would create an ember, but if you have to use this method you don't always have bright sun shine, but fire steel can create an ember too and does not need sun shine. He did a good job demonstrating oak scrapings as tinder, the reason for the video.
blackbat1339 2 months ago
great thanks a nice thing to know Gwndfm
GWNDFM 3 months ago
I don't get it. 30 strikes with a firesteel is a lot of strikes to get a flame. If a rod has 3,000 strikes that is a 100 fire-firesteel. Carry 2-3 mini-bics and you have 100s maybe up to 2,000 flames with no tinder, go right to small kindling. I don't get the firesteel thing except for the final backup. An 10x7 flexible page magnifier will give you a flame and it can last forever. Coghlans has a flint/striker permanent match that gives 1000s of flames on wick and 1/2 oz of light fluid, too.
MrJoeyBoombotz 7 months ago
@MrJoeyBoombotz Yes, there are many other fire-starter options. The firesteel is preferred by many because of its reliability, such as, countless sparks, no moving parts (could break or corrode), and it works when wet. Matches, lighters, magnifying lenses, etc... have more room for error as they can have more problems (get wet, break, weak Sun, etc...). This vid was to simulate no ideal tinder was readily available. If better tinder was used there'd be less strikes necessary to get flame.
gundog5 7 months ago
Your ruining the edge of the knife. There is a slot at the base of the blade, you're suppose to use that for striking a firesteel.
topguntin 1 year ago
@topguntin Yes, you're right! It's an old Swiss Army Knife that I use as a 'beater' knife (I abused it as a teenager). I designated the smaller blade to be the scraper so I'm not worried about the care of the blade.
That's a good suggestion. Also, the back of the saw blade or the edge of the awl tool work pretty well too.
gundog5 1 year ago
Does making the scrapings ruin your edge?
icychap 1 year ago
@icychap Believe it or not the Swiss Army Knife blade is quite resilient. It stays pretty sharp. Doing the scrapings like this with the blade will dull it after awhile. A couple swipes thru one of those hand-held sharpeners works pretty well. This demo was to show tinder could be made if it couldn't be found (like in a survival situation). So, probably not the best thing do with a blade if you have other options. Worst case, use the tip end of blade for scraping so base of blade stays sharp.
gundog5 1 year ago
@gundog5 Thanks for the quick response. Could you use the spine/jimping of a thicker knife to make the scrapings, or will they never be as fine as when you use the edge itself?
icychap 1 year ago
@icychap I'd think using the blade would give you the best results as you can get good thin flakes. It would depend on the knife, though. The saw on the Swiss Army Knife could also work to make saw dust. Give your idea a try (with a bigger knife) and see if it'd work. Maybe compare between using the spine and blade. If you can get reasonable results using the spine then it might be the way to go if you don't wanna risk dulling your knife.
gundog5 1 year ago
Been looking for somthing like this the woods around me are just oak.
Thecoldwaterfall 2 years ago
that'd be much easier to get started with a good friesteel. But nice natural tinder!
AlexxMcGraw 2 years ago
Yep, I have several good firesteels. Guess I shoulda mentioned that I was using the mini-firesteel on purpose; Having it on the keychain as a contingency, but also need to practice and know how to use it if the need ever arises.
gundog5 2 years ago