Tristan, you make me so proud to live where i do. who'd have thought someone from my own back yard could impress such a force as Amanda. So geleous and so proud. :)
This is quite a powerful presentation, both visually and musically. The model train was a remarkable thing to include. We suddenly find ourselves marvelling at the human genius that can craft such things and, at the same time, commit such atrocities as those suggested by the yellow stars sewn to the clothing of some of the people in the historic stils. This is repeated in the use of the model bombers, so artisticly presented as marvelous toys, but marked with a symbol of horror. Marvelous.
Amanda, i love how you expose beauty in a romantic-goth atomosphere that is coated all throughout your music. To me, it shows how to have/make fun even when things can be ugly or just plain effed up lol. Your music makes me let go and be free of what ever is troubling me. It helps me tear down any expectations that I have been thrusted apon. You are so very clever!! Thankyou xx
Alice vs. Wonderland was awful. It had a ton of potential, and failed to live up to any of it. Maybe Janos should stick to music videos, as this is pretty snazzy.
i am hungarian :) it well to hear, read or listen the name of my home country.
TheVattacukor 1 year ago
oh gooood this is so beautiful i could listen to it for hooours!
wookywooky91 1 year ago
I think the music was absolutely wonderful, but the video didn't do very much at all for me.
adamrailsback 1 year ago
@adamrailsback
same ;)
wookywooky91 1 year ago
S z e r e t e t -_-) א ה ב ה
SHAKTIVVAAN 1 year ago 3
this is why i love the piano.
truly amazing, that such masterpieces are still being created in the world. reminded me of philip glass at part. still, just... -no words-
the video is a work in itself. the imagery just fits so well.
I really can't wait to hear more from Tristan :)
thegeneralsmuts 1 year ago
@thegeneralsmuts I agree on the glass comment. It's the same texture.
Arconeus 8 months ago
Loved the music and video, but I kept getting these odd clicks in the playback. Not sure if they were intentional or not.
keatonatwork 1 year ago
@keatonatwork
Me too :/
marguipico 1 year ago
@marguipico
If it is any consolation, the audio is available on afp.net without the clicks.
keatonatwork 1 year ago
hhhhhhhhhhmmmmmmmm
wookywooky91 1 year ago
omg, does anybody know where i can get the sheet music for this!!?!! this is beautiful!
jpourkav 1 year ago
this is so beautiful!
mykyjohn 1 year ago
Tristan, you make me so proud to live where i do. who'd have thought someone from my own back yard could impress such a force as Amanda. So geleous and so proud. :)
janieharmony 1 year ago
are you kidding?
elcaminodave1 1 year ago
Köszönöm Amanda és köszönöm Tristan! Ez csodálatos... (I'm Hungarian as János Szász...)
lalee681122 1 year ago 4
Beautifully haunting. Thank you.
CheekyMonkey1968 1 year ago
This is quite a powerful presentation, both visually and musically. The model train was a remarkable thing to include. We suddenly find ourselves marvelling at the human genius that can craft such things and, at the same time, commit such atrocities as those suggested by the yellow stars sewn to the clothing of some of the people in the historic stils. This is repeated in the use of the model bombers, so artisticly presented as marvelous toys, but marked with a symbol of horror. Marvelous.
leftysergeant 1 year ago
This brought me to tears no joke.
RoseWhiteRoseRed 1 year ago
Amanda, i love how you expose beauty in a romantic-goth atomosphere that is coated all throughout your music. To me, it shows how to have/make fun even when things can be ugly or just plain effed up lol. Your music makes me let go and be free of what ever is troubling me. It helps me tear down any expectations that I have been thrusted apon. You are so very clever!! Thankyou xx
allylovesbubbles 1 year ago
What a lovely music video. The images are very scintillating when mixed with that excellent music.
This just makes me want to make art. I love when I get that feeling.
derebin 1 year ago
beautiful:')
moeismyfriend 1 year ago
I cried. This is beautiful.
<3
Methanphedamine 1 year ago
Lovelyyyyy!
MAsterKakashi6 1 year ago
Alice vs. Wonderland was awful. It had a ton of potential, and failed to live up to any of it. Maybe Janos should stick to music videos, as this is pretty snazzy.
Sparrow15 1 year ago
Ahhh! That's beautiful! :D
BOomeek 1 year ago
Gorgeous!! I can't wait for my CD c:
skudisch970986302876 1 year ago
I was just transported to another time and place.
You amaze me, Amanda Palmer.
RealoveGSR 1 year ago
The piano in this is really inspiring dear.
AntiCliche 1 year ago
it's nice but I do prefer when amanda sings in her songs, but non the less it is nice
Justinjello 1 year ago
A beautiful piece of music.
yfnco 1 year ago
Well done!
mrblisterfist 1 year ago
liked everything before the pink and yellow thing with the clip art. the train sequence was especially good.
teverde579 1 year ago
Absolutely beautiful. <3
PrettyLittlePinup 1 year ago
That was beautiful.
Theprettything 1 year ago
Love you to pieces amanda, but that was weird to watch lol! I enjoyed listening to it thourougly however
TheVoraciousSnapmare 1 year ago
I love this song so much, I've been listening to it like mad the past few days.
HydeLeach 1 year ago