Come Rain or Come Shine

[ShaneH]

Absolutely the most beautiful person, one of the most incredible voices and one of the best performances ever on Idol.

[seventeenboi]

pia toscano reminds me of kat mcphee though kat will always be my favorite

[jollyLlama793]

welldam.

[anggaring]

uyeeeaahh

[1990BJK]

Kat was sooooooo hot with her long brown hair why did she have to cut it and go blond?!

[doccguitarking]

She should have won American Idol.

[TheTinkerbell124]

she is great! just my opion but she should've won!

[dandres73]

she needs a short dress, or something more transparent on top .. or silicon high heels.. but she sings great

[MrHenzig]

I hate these shows. Look what they've done to you all! Fighting over weather she sucks or excells... She looks great and sings great, but that is my personal oppinion. If you can't deliver you're own opinion in a respectful way you should just keep it to yourself.

[qg6ff]

you should put her name in the title so people can find this vid!

[ohdamnson]

shes all looks and no meaning of the song, she is not into it at all, and is just singing for the camera. a good song, and she has a good voice, but not the right song for her

[venycal]

Amazing :)

[frazzler9]

any pitch problems? what you tink about the last 2 big notes?

[rjs5146]

p.s. she looks AMAZING in this video!

[rjs5146]

to all the kat haters, this was a FLAWLESS performance!!!! amazing

[Nassica89]

my fucking ears -_-

[NINTHMARINE]

I liked that very much...C.A.

[noboxerz]

what a sexpot

[edwizzles]

she looks beautiful in this

[phycology101]

I love the beat. kinda like a strip tease song but of course much classier and can't even compared to that filth, but still. HOT

[GreyEyesCrying]

lol, most cabaret jazz songs are like that ;)

but they are completely awesome.

[GreyEyesCrying]

lol, most cabaret jazz songs are like that ;)

but they are completely awesome.

[trueloveisnotreal]

i hate Katherine McPhee.. and she completely slaughtered a WONDERFUL judy garland song

[tekqist28]

couldn't agree with you more..

it's so awfull when they try to modernize classics like that..

[qg6ff]

shutup!`

[qg6ff]

you stupid

[qg6ff]

well, we hate you.

[trueloveisnotreal]

well, what do you know? Obviously nothing.

[qg6ff]

you obviously don't know either because guess what? that was a fantastic version.

[stuckinawall]

She looked gorgeous that night. And I've always thought that Randy said "props" in the end instead of "but", which is why he looked so confused when Paula asked him "but what?"

[Clairtjee]

Maybe he says 'perhaps' very quick.

[mabeluchi08]

Yes! It's definitely "props"... It's like a compliment! Couldn't agree with you more! :)

[qg6ff]

haha picking up the cup after your comment is definately a sign of "not knowing what to do" ex: @ 4:35 when Randy went to pick up his cup 'to take a drink' he never even ended up taking a drink haha

[BloodyRose3000]

It's true, she was the only one that year that could have pulled it off! Elliet is great, but there's ni way he could have done that song.

[cda345]

You've gotta admit that last note was off.

[Dramaroni]

hi, no it wasnt

[pointsandusky]

This is really really good, but I wish she wouldn't have attempted that last note. Ouch.

[Dramaroni]

you're not smart, that note was very much on

[pointsandusky]

Are we listening to the same note? Apparently not. What makes you so much more fucking qualified than I am? You're just an idiot fantard who thinks she hasn't ever hit a bum note, and she has hit plenty. But notice I said this was good, so quit

complaining dumbfuck.

[audition031]

0:10~0:13 funny and hot! (^_^)v,

[ebSleddsoLe]

wow lets see you sing, tadzio999

[Thomaso88]

That's a terrible argument to use, it clearly shows you do not know what you are talking about. First of all, most of us HEAR someone sing, although it is of coure possible that for your judgement looking good is more important than sounding good. (Continue on next post)

[Thomaso88]

Secondly, someone does not have to be able to sing better than her to justly criticize her. There is a difference between musical knowledge (eg. harmony, timing, etc.) and musical capacity (singing in tune). Many people have the knowledge, and knowledge is needed to justly criticize, not capacity.

[xxxSnowhitexxx]

Well, she could better but still she's good!

xxx

[ChaosIsSerene]

she's good singer but she sounds like a lil retarded singer here...no offense to all u katharine fans out ther...

[Ilovechristmas001]

She's singing in a jazz style - what on earth sounds retarded about that?!? Explain...I don't think I'm understanding what you're saying

[qg6ff]

shutup shes the best

[tadzio999]

Why can't she just sing ONE note for more than half a second. It's really annoying, cos then she might be bearable for more than ten seconds.

[OverDaFence]

whats the big deal here

[xkelly18]

it's such a great song! why did she have to change the notes around?!

[qg6ff]

tadzio999 that's just in the beginning....like Simon said she's a star!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and pretty damn hot! ;)

[tadzio999]

She is too breathy and histrionic - listen to Judy Garland's version at Carnegie Hall for effortless showbiz.

[OverDaFence]

listen to ninthmarine here on youtube

[qg6ff]

she's the best...if for whatever reason she reads this YOU ARE AND ALWAYS WILL BE THE BEST IDOL ON THE SHOW. and i'm not just saying that because i'm a fan cuz to be honest i don't remember being a fan of yours in the beginning..why i don't know but i am a big one now.

[quiescency]

"Feelin' free!" Haha. Ryan and Kat should tour around the country making small talk. Like Regis and Kelly. Omg even their initials match.

[WoodyAllenManiac]

I think Mandisa could do just as good as Kat with this song actually, I disagree with Paula's statement that only Kat could do it.

[panday5]

She's a real idol coz she has everything. The true idol.

[ShaneH]

One of my favorite performances of Katharine.

[staythenight]

why is she so pretty? I'm jealous of that XD

[tryingtosing]

lol!

[nicolega2001]

It was really good but for some reason I got bored towards the end. Go figure.

[satellitedish]

this is the song that she should of sang on the finale night.

[carriefanboy]

i 10000% agree with you. the minute it was announced that she made the finals, i crossed my fingers and wished. but alas, she went with the stripped-down "Black Horse & The Cherry Tree".

i hope Jordin doesn't make the same mistake. WHEN she makes it to the finals, she better do "I Who Have Nothing". last night was her starmaking moment.

[satellitedish]

The top 2 will have LaKisha and someone else but LaKisha will make it!

[panday5]

It's true, She should be more careful in choosing the song.

[rose218]

one of her best performances!

[SUNPERCH]

pretty girl nice voice however i would have trouble picking her out of a crowd,

[BreathofFreshInk]

Simon was right. This was a starmaking moment. Beautiful. Diva!

[liliaaaaaaaa]

great stuff nice song

[Spotlighter15]

She truly was a star after this. One of her best.

[MusicmanE]

thanks for posting this video. I wish Kat would put this song on her album. I heard Kat did this song on Ed McMahon's Next Big Star; do you happen to have the video of that performance as well (I'm very curious to see that one).

[blue0151]

im taped hehehe she should do stand up.she sortof reminds me of my english teacher

[chamnanpara]

For me, she seems to be like Miss Universe who is singing songs beautifully. I cannot believe she has achieve the amazing singing ability while being so so beautiful.

[blue0151]

wonder who that person she was thinking of was(nick cokas)not leaving any hints

[scrubs023]

beautiful!

[Crazy4redsox92]

She has an absolutely amazing voice. She looked so beautiful! I hope she has an incredible career:)

[jamminjake245]

KATHARINE IS SOOOOOOOOO HOT!

[Maryg06]

NNIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII­IIICEEEE  i loved it!

[spunkyhungry]

This is one of my favorite performances of hers. She sings the song so beautifully!

[sewwo]

Katharine is very nice and beautiful girl, I love her.

[jaymejean28]

amazing!