raysonntag commented thus: 'The music is the bottom line and this piece is
BORING'
hmm well some people find relaxation boring,, some may find meditation boring, etc.
personally I feel this isnt as 'instant' as some of andrews other works such as 'andecy' and 'sunday morning overcast' these have more of wat u may call a 'hook' or 'melody'. But perhaps this peice has its place also
@BWPGuy Very true. There are awesome classical guitar players out there, and they may be good at making arrangements, but I can't recall John Williams (for example) ever writing something.
@Incisionator - actually I think he has ..a lot with his band SKY. Check em out...saw your main video btw ..very good and interesting...kinda looks just like one I did on my site...check it ...for a tune called Would You Have Done The Same...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
New Age nonsense. I defy you to sing whatever melody this is. Hint- none. Just guitar cheese, with slight generic celtic hints. Easy listening and playing. And posing.
this person is ignorant which is what sucks about this world. As soon as they hear something they cannot perform or dont understand they have to undermine it. Akin to bullies at schoolyards. Some things are too complicated for the common person to understand. this person should just listen to rap or hip hop, or raggae as it is simple for the simple minded commoner.
you are such a poor bloke. Andrew York got "Magna cum Laude" honorific words for both of his music degrees in two different Universities. Before commenting your crap, please give us an account of your background, or else be humble, York could play whatever "non-sense" as you said and still have all the merits to be listened to...And you, I'd dare to say you don't even know how to tune a guitar...;-)
You have no clue what "new age" music is if you call this by that gutless style.
YORK is among the finest of his generation. I hear NO TRACE of Celtic music here.
Your comment is so odd in that you have an appreciation of many great players (in your Favs)...so why the disrespect for York? This piece is clearly influenced by Eastern European music...maybe you just hate that style.
some people are just plain ignorant...all they create is what they leave in the toilet...that guy is allowed to make any face he wants...plus..he gets laid more than you
So-so piece. The performance would be greatly enhanced by a large paper grocery bag over the performer's head, so one would not be subjected to his goofy (and trite) facial expressions.
the facial expressions go with the territory, its called passion. I'd like to see your facial expression as you pull your head out of your arse to attempt to play the peice. please let me know when you are about post your next guitar peice and i will be glad to pass comment on it. dave.
Absolutely beautiful.
LickMyAxecom 1 year ago
york is a genius
SuperMagicMoose 2 years ago
i'd like tutorial for understanding of this song. feels as if i can only scim the surface or something.
GinoTheSinner 3 years ago
grande !!!
jonnyspinzo 3 years ago
raysonntag commented thus: 'The music is the bottom line and this piece is
BORING'
hmm well some people find relaxation boring,, some may find meditation boring, etc.
personally I feel this isnt as 'instant' as some of andrews other works such as 'andecy' and 'sunday morning overcast' these have more of wat u may call a 'hook' or 'melody'. But perhaps this peice has its place also
MysticReality 3 years ago
sounds like raysonntag is a "frustrated guitarist"...anyone with half a brain and competant guitar skills can see this is an amazing piece...
BWPGuy 3 years ago
well even alot of Mozart and other symphony shit starts out melancholy like right? this an awesome piece of music and i love it
bonasty1990 2 years ago
@BWPGuy Very true. There are awesome classical guitar players out there, and they may be good at making arrangements, but I can't recall John Williams (for example) ever writing something.
Incisionator 1 year ago
@Incisionator - actually I think he has ..a lot with his band SKY. Check em out...saw your main video btw ..very good and interesting...kinda looks just like one I did on my site...check it ...for a tune called Would You Have Done The Same...
BWPGuy 1 year ago
@BWPGuy He has a band ? That is very cool.
Incisionator 1 year ago
i totaly go to see him play live today it was sooooo freaking sweet
jimipage69 4 years ago
Nice! I was curious how York would sound when I saw a piece by him in Pumping Nylon (not good enough to play it yet). I like what I hear so far.
Your right hand is helpful to watch for me. You keep it nice and relaxed. Very impressive.
Anaclypse 5 years ago
Amazing!
TLRfolyf 5 years ago
Nice piece. Thanks for posting? Do you have Numen as well?
stilleman 5 years ago
gerçekten çok güzel
reinodesilia 5 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
New Age nonsense. I defy you to sing whatever melody this is. Hint- none. Just guitar cheese, with slight generic celtic hints. Easy listening and playing. And posing.
kbkesq 5 years ago
You're quite a bitter cunt.
LikuX 5 years ago 2
I am so tired of people like you on Youtube. Arrogant Prick.
zmeadows87 4 years ago 2
this person is ignorant which is what sucks about this world. As soon as they hear something they cannot perform or dont understand they have to undermine it. Akin to bullies at schoolyards. Some things are too complicated for the common person to understand. this person should just listen to rap or hip hop, or raggae as it is simple for the simple minded commoner.
haolejohn 4 years ago 2
not every good piece of music has sing-able melodies. Melody is not always the focus.
SteveFeces 4 years ago 2
you are such a poor bloke. Andrew York got "Magna cum Laude" honorific words for both of his music degrees in two different Universities. Before commenting your crap, please give us an account of your background, or else be humble, York could play whatever "non-sense" as you said and still have all the merits to be listened to...And you, I'd dare to say you don't even know how to tune a guitar...;-)
evarela12 4 years ago 4
so are you saying you only listen to musicians who have respectable 'merits'?
If so then you really might want to question your own view on music before you start having a go at other peoples.
on a seperate note this piece is amazing
starcraft108 3 years ago 5
@kbkesq
@kbkesq
I could easily pick out the melodic ideas here.
You have no clue what "new age" music is if you call this by that gutless style.
YORK is among the finest of his generation. I hear NO TRACE of Celtic music here.
Your comment is so odd in that you have an appreciation of many great players (in your Favs)...so why the disrespect for York? This piece is clearly influenced by Eastern European music...maybe you just hate that style.
Rexicano 1 year ago
Excellent! Andrew is a true breath of fresh air. Practice makes perfect. This is proof.
MusicBoxBuilder 5 years ago
who needs stupid lyrics?
MrOCDhelpmee 5 years ago
great lyrics
lithium687 5 years ago
Body, fingers, music, a concert in motion.
ntrimm 5 years ago
Andrew York could play a broom handle and make it sound great!!
chrispark25 5 years ago
just great.feeling is most important stylewise on that,thats fine.
antissimo 5 years ago
rayyysoon ur boring! go watch ur MTV and call it music...fool
ferdinandand19 5 years ago
BWUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
kirkhetfieldburton 5 years ago
This guy is a great guitar player
Mfiguk 5 years ago
He's a great musician. I like almost all the CD's pieces :)
As for the bad vibes and posts, we'd like to see your creations and videos...hehehehe....easier to talk than do.....
hmurrieta 5 years ago
I'ts great to watch. The piece sounds as a big improvisation . The playing is really great. This is a artist!
johancomstedt 5 years ago
some people are just plain ignorant...all they create is what they leave in the toilet...that guy is allowed to make any face he wants...plus..he gets laid more than you
haolejohn 5 years ago
This piece doesn't go anywhere and it is repetitive even though melodic at times.
The performance is very good.
Seaofash 5 years ago
The music is the bottom line and this piece is
BORING
raysonntag 5 years ago
This is what all Classical Guitarists look like when they play. Wonderful piece.
LikuX 5 years ago
anyone who looks like they are having an orgasm when they play the guitar is really into it lol
nathinnizzle 5 years ago
A very very lively and creative peice, Congratulations and well done!!
elmario01 5 years ago
So-so piece. The performance would be greatly enhanced by a large paper grocery bag over the performer's head, so one would not be subjected to his goofy (and trite) facial expressions.
marvl 5 years ago
the facial expressions go with the territory, its called passion. I'd like to see your facial expression as you pull your head out of your arse to attempt to play the peice. please let me know when you are about post your next guitar peice and i will be glad to pass comment on it. dave.
davidjleach1 5 years ago