Added: 4 years ago
From: Phatooine
Views: 792,078
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,900)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • As I read all of the responses to this, and holy shit, some of you are taking this waayyy too seriously, I should say that having witnessed a few real fencing duels by masters, this fight is one of the only really realistic fights in the film. Despite what Hollywood would like us all to think, most sword fights are over very quickly, often in a matter of seconds. And when two masters get together, if they are close to evenly matched, one tiny miscalculation is all it takes.

  • Why do people even argue which series is better (Original Trilogy/Prequel Trilogy)? I mean, both sets of movies have been made, and its not like you can just go back in time and prevent them from being created. Like them or not, its over, accept it. So why don't you people just grow up and stop bickering like children over a sci-fi fantasy movie?

  • @thehitman2500 lucas said he did sith lords dont drop lightsabers and definatly the emperor he also said jango fett did not die

  • 0:44 "Cant touch me, Bitch!"

  • @thehitman2500 dont ask me ask lucas oh and sith lords can sense presense he knew anakin would come and for his wrinkle face was worth it rule the galaxy

  • @wes6ify he could have ruled the galaxy anyway...with dooku not anakin.Well people already asked Lucas questions like what caused sidious' "transformation"?, Did Palpatine lose on purpose? etc...

    Lucas said that Palpatine DIDN'T lose on purpose.

    btw force lightning caused his transformation.

  • Those aren't three random guys. Two I don't know, but the guy on the right is Kit Fisto. And Mace was mirroring his moves, but not by using his "dark side" It's a lightsaber fighting style, utilizing strength and power over speed or precision. Those styles can be learned by any jedi.

  • some1 told me that Windu had both dark and light side with him, that the only reason he was a Jedi was because he can control him. That same person also said is why own Palpatine in this fight because he was using the dark side to Mirror his moves... im like no... then watching this fight over and over...he does...is this true...

  • @thehitman2500 i dont think so lucas also said he did on purpose HE WAS TRYING TO GET A NEW PADAWAN PALPATINE HAD HIM AT 51 BUT NEEDED HIM FOR SKYWALKER.

  • @wes6ify calm down dude.

    Palpattine didnt have have him at 51, when he tried to stab him windu easily block it and probably overpowered him. And how would he know Skywalker would come here in the first place? Even if he would lose on purpus he just made it worse making himself look weaker than windu. And he used all his power on his force lightning. He didnt know Windu would deflect it. (using vaapad) And if he did it on purpus why would he get himself weaker/looking older/scared by his lightnin

  • @mrbrick 241 yes cause he had him at 0:51 but stood there pointing it cause he needed windu to get a new apprentice so he purposlry threw his saber out the window and pretended to be stupid by using lightning on a lightsaber but worth it to be emperor.see what i mean

  • @wes6ify you are wrong it has been said by Lucas that Palpatine did not lose on purpous

    and not every lightsaber can deflect lightning.it was Windu's technique "Vaapad"

  • Mace couldn't be fucked waiting for Obi-Wan and Yoda to come back, so he just gave three lightsabers to some homeless guys he found outside and told them he'd buy them some food if they beat up an old guy for him.

  • never allow George Lucas to write action scenes

  • @TotalFedor because they kick too much ass?

  • this scene really pissed me off, how did some of the three greatest jedi swordsmen die like such bitch asses? I mean it looks like they all had the reflexes of a two year old

  • @starhawks1 The truth is they were not slow at all!

    Sidious used his teqnique dark rage. Dark rage is a dark side ability were the user can release his strongest fears,hate and anger making him a lot stronger and alot faster! So u see thats how he killed the so quickly.

    Or they were just a few drunk people in costumes lol

  • Mace Windu would have won this fight if he had said

    "I have had it with these motherfucking sith on this motherfucking Senate!"

  • @dreamth3ator :C DAMNIT YOU BEAT ME

  • if i was mace this is what i have done:

    get 60 jedi knights and 250 clone troopers and tell them to stand by

    then contact the galactic senate and inform them of what anakin skywalker has told me- that palpatine confessed to anakin that he is the dark lord of the sith.

    tell the senate to call for palpatine's presence at the senate chamber immediately. As he makes his way, to the chamber, confront him with the 60 jedi and 250 clone troopers and order him to surrender and if not, kill him

  • so who was actually stronger wind or palpatine, because wasn't pal patine just doing that to try and get anakin to the dark side

  • @MrBrick241 hi. my guess is that windu was indeed stronger. anakin was not present when sidious got disarmed. the opportunity to still win this duell, by manipulating anakin presented itself when anakin arrived.

    but thats only my guess...... by the way, am i the only one who sees to old men fighting in slowmotion?:D

  • 0:55

    The "You bout to DIE!" Face

  • If only he had zapped them with lighning and proceeded to kill the first two in one swipe while they were in pain, that would have been way cooler. Stupidly done scene.

  • @draggeddownthehole Yes that would have been much better.

  • give it up fuckface u got Samuel L jackson against you

  • WORST JEDI EVER

  • Comment removed

  • Don't worry when Mace fell through the window, Iron Man caught him.

  • Kit Fitso dying had to be the dumbest thing I've ever seen.

  • was there any reason for sith lord to do that at 1:06??

  • Sigh. When will people realize that palpatine used a dark force power to kill them quickly. He also held back against Mace Windu in order to turn Anakin to the dark side.

  • This is ONE scene I hope George Lucas remakes

  • windu should have brought Anakin with him

  • when a lightsaber appears out of nowhere you know he means business

  • Corusant Police: Sir, the jedi councils best swordsman was found dead on the cement. The glass in palpatines chamber was shattered.

    Horatio: Well looks like Mace...

    *puts on sunglasses*

    Horatio: fell out the Windu.

    YEEEEEAAAAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • Master Kit Fisto did not die in the books or the expanded universe,or the clone wars cgi series. More proof that the Lucas prequels are shit. Lots of smelly shit.

  • of course... the black guy always dies.

  • @MightyBrain1000 LOL. Yeah but look at the bright side. It took until episode 3 for it to happen. LOL

  • Vapaad, ur not stoppin it

  • The way the 3 other Jedi's were supposed to fight was badly filmed.

    But Lucas wanted indeed to make a point: only Windu was a fully skilled Master able to handle the Sith.

    Too bad Anakin didn't join the group, would have been more exciting!

  • Great job portraying the jedi in this fight. Those three jedi that get owned are all jedi masters. So supossedly there atleast able to put up a fight not die like noobs.

  • Mace Windu took with him Jedis Noobs lool

  • I feel like almost every lightsaber duel in any film had such awful parts in them (i mean like the first 3 dying in this way too easily, him pointing the saber at his chest without doing anything...) EXCEPT for the qui gonn/OB1 vs darth maul...

  • Was at this point me and friends started a "fuck him up Windu fuck him up!" chant

  • and he talks with an english accent in this not a scot accent so i assume lucas wanted him to have an english accent, since the actor is a scot unless he lives in england or something..

  • you killed jango fett mace and this is what you get!!

  • I found Mace Windu's arm. It ended up in Jurassic Park.

  • mace windu deserved to survive fuck anakin

  • For people who don't know, when Sidious leaped through the air like a fuckin parkour championship cup holder, he Force Screamed, it's used to interrupt the connection between a person and the force, in this case it worked on 2 of the 4 jedi present, he immediately killed the two who weren't powerful enough to resist it

    Kit Fisto and Mace resisted it, but unfortunately in the cluster fuck that the fight was, Kit was killed with his saber in the air leaving only Mace

  • That demonic battlecry at 0:24 STILL makes the hairs on my neck stand up

  • windu, the best lightsaber-warrior ever!

  • he should have impaled him when he touched the grown

  • Mace is a dumbass, instead of holding a meeting with the Senate and authorize a arrest and investigation, he decides to take 4 guys to take on the worst Sith Lord.

    Why not tell someone about this IN CASE YOU DIE>

  • Fisto stinks...

  • 1:30 THIS IS SPARTAAAAA

  • George Lucas said that the wisest Jedi is Yoda and the most powerful is Mace Windu. From my point of view that sucks!, Yoda should be the most powerful after Palpatine.

  • 0:10 , Bitch, I am the senate!

  • Mace Windu gave 4 lightsabers 4 random people which he met on the streets of galactic city!

  • @antioeln I actually have a good reason why he killed the first 4 jedi masters so quickly

  • @assassin1911kya, why then

  • @akatsu24 Was high as shit, but its bcuz Qui Gon said "jedi can see things b4 they happen", thats why all the lightsaber duels are so cool and they have quick reflexes. but "the dark side clouds everything"-Yoda. so they cant see what palpatine's gona do, so they cant counter act his attacks. do you get what im saying or is it gibberish?

  • @assassin1911kya, nope ur making sense, but often times jedi are skilled enough swordsmen to not need to see the moves before they happen. theyre just skilled

  • @akatsu24 exactly why mace windu was still alive so thats a good point, thanks

  • @antioeln aint it 3???

  • @stebopign

    god ... you're right xD

  • @antioeln LOL thnx for the kind response :D

  • @antioeln Lol indeed, they suck balls, why are the only good jedis obi wan, anakin, mace and yoda?

  • @antioeln no even yoda run away from palpatine because he couldnt handle him

  • go on the brit!!

  • @Brady2k10

    sorry, what is a "Brit"?

    A Briton?

  • @antioeln a brit you know british guy, english guy, got an english accent so hes from britain a "brit"

  • @antioeln well hes not english, hes a scot, but still a brit

  • Comment removed

  • @TheOnePistol

    Yes I know !

    But I thought it would be a pretty funny joke :D

  • @antioeln Yeah I didnt get the joke at first, thats why I removed it. But you still got the message soemhow. :P

  • @antioeln I think you mean 3 lightsabers to 3 people.

  • Those jedis suck balls

  • Mace Windu only lasted because he was sing the Dark Side same as Sidious, it was part of his saber style, it needed the Dark Side to work right.

  • before this movie i thought dooku and vader were the most powerful sith in the movies i saw this .. i was wrong

  • Wouldve been so much cooler if palpatine said "it's treason" and the moment he got up he used lightning and killed the first guy, threw the 2nd guy out the window, lunged and stab kit fisto the moment he lands, and then fought windu (this time windu is on the offensive)

  • some people don't like the choreography in this scene. i disagree. i think that it's a good contrast from the obi-wan vs anakin duel (don't get me wrong, that battle is matched by none). it flows quite well... kind of like two old vets who are experienced enough to know they don't have to go all out to fight properly.

  • Mace Windu is cool in this! It should have been him and Qui-Gon duelling with Darth Maul in Episode I ?! Now that would have been awesome!

  • Never use Mace when you have a lightsabre

  • They def downplayed Kit Fisto, if he can block Grevious's 4 lightsabers he can block Sidious's one, or at least block it once.

  • lmfao Palpatines facial experissions aqre killn me

  • I figured out it was him back in the first one. Lucas should have cast someone without a butt-chin. So easy to recognize.

  • Kit Fisto was my favourite and he dies as it was nothing lol

  • @tehpeasant I FKIN KNOW RIGHT!??!

  • Kit Fisto was my favourite and he dies as it was nothing lol

  • MAYBE IS BECAUSE THEY WER CROWDED

  • What's with the the two Jedi dying at 0:28 and 0:29?!!! I've seen glaciers move faster...

  • @thegreatchimp Lol, for real. What the hell was Eeth Koth looking at? He's checkin' out Seasin Tin (I think the name is) right before he gets stabbed.

  • @BoardWhareHowse Ha! Or maybe they wanted to be one with the force...prematurely.

  • @thegreatchimp I hate that part. It looks stupid.

  • @thegreatchimp Apparently, those with the force have a seriously hard time with hesitation! These two "Jedi" just stand there and get killed much like Darth Maul just stood there and stared at Kenobi while he got cut in half! Yep, he just stands there and lets Obi-Wan slice him in two! Doesn't make any sense AT ALL!!! I wish someone with a brain would have choreographed some of these scenes!

  • @5thgroupwannabe I know....(groan)... I just watched the death of Darth Maul....shameful stuff, and in an otherwise great fight scene. I'm just amazed that nobody picked up on such glaringly terrible moments when they shot these two scenes...guess the film crew were under serious pressure.

  • mace windu dies

    videos sucks

  • 0:58

    ノಠ益ಠ)ノ Y U NO HEADBUTT?

  • Lol, this is according to lore the most powerfull sith lord yet he managed to lose his lightsaber with a kick to the face. The ancient sith lords would be ashamed

  • Darth Sidious is more of a force based sith lord... >.> Why do they have to portray the Jedi as weak as hoes?

  • Multi battles are so fucking useless. Actually every prequel-movie has established that (Dooku vs Obi/Ana, Dooku vs Obi/Ana 2, Maul vs Qui Gonn/Obi). How about just send Windu into the 1on1 while the other Jedi Masters support him with force techniques and cover his back?? Instead of actually fighting in the front line and getting raped by a Sith Lord who is obviously much more powerful

  • those other 3 jedi must hav sucked!!! it didnt even look lik they tried!!!

  • strongest jesti/siths: 1Mace Windu 2 Darth Sidious 3. Yoda read in wiki about mace windu , his history and power lvl he is master in using lightsabers and he is one of strongest jedis ever and he is the one whou defeated darth sidius in fait battle (another 3 jedis has been defeated in 8 s.) i like samuel l. jacson (he is my favorite actor ;p) but battle of the strongest force users must be better ;(

  • First of all why did none of the jedi in the beggining even try? Second of all Mace won the fight, Anakin's just a dick.

  • I like the battle between Windu and Palpatine but obviously, the deaths of the other three Jedi are far too quick and far too easy.

    Also, I preferred the idea that the Emperor was disfigured b/c the dark side was eating him from the inside. That's a far more disturbing, effective concept than a battle injury.

  • One of the worst fight scene in cinema history.  Hire some Kung Fu guys from HK to choreograph the fight sequence, and get some stunt men doubles in there to do this scene justice. The other 3 Jedi masters look more uncoordinated than Jar Jar Binks, that was just weak. And Darth Maul looks 100X better than Darth Sidious, who's supposed to be the master, go figure.

  • Also, Mace Windu studied the Dark Side and was THE one and only master to attack a Dark Lord of the Sith!

  • Mace kicks ass...all that matters!

  • He beat the emperor and did not kill him while he killed Phet who wasnt a big threat! stupid prequels! Lando Calrissian>Windu

  • for an old man he was fucking shit up for a minute

  • the 3 jedi got trained and get killed easily.... i understand that they are fighting sidious but they should have let them fight a little longer and better so they can die in epic ways!

  • @comixgod50 Lucas needed a way to kill off the Jedi or episodes 4,5,and 6 would not have made sense. Sidious was actually able to do that, He was doing that to EVERY Jedi since episode 2. Sidious was doing this to all the Jedi across the galaxy when order 66 was given to the clones, That is why all the other Jedi were killed by clones with blasters. Sidious was powerful enough to defeat Yoda so the other Jedi were not much of a threat even if they were masters, they were not at the same level.

  • @ShadowKnight1025 how can yoda not defeat sidious while mace windu can? yoda never fought sidious to death because he always ran away. yoda was the most powerful jedi and sidious the most powerful sith and yet yoda was more powerful than sidious.

  • @debunker1905 It is true that Yoda is a very powerful Jedi,but if you watch his fight with Sidious you'll see that Sidious was victorious.Yoda lost his light saber,fell to the floor of the arena and ran.I know the movie made it look like Mace Windu was about to defeat Sidious.But that happened because Sidious was able to sense that Anakin was on his way,so he let the fight drag on and decided to use it to turn Anakin by making the Jedi look like the bad guy.Otherwise he would have killed Windu.

  • @ShadowKnight1025 have to keep in mind yodas like 900 yrs old or something like that..

  • The first 2 jedi don't even put up a fight.

  • when this movie came out it was like the superbowl

  • 0:23 EPIC triple sideflip

  • Come on man. Kit Fisto is WAY better then that. Lucas did him an injustice here.

  • He shocked me, he mother fuckin shocked me

  • One of the reasons why Sidious was able to kill the three Jedi masters that easily was because he was using the dark side to cloud their minds, in addition to the fact that he was the most powerful Sith Lord in the galaxy for many years.

  • @ShadowKnight1025

    Dark Side to cloud minds? Sorry but I call bullshit, even if he is the best sith around at the time doesn't excuse the director to kill off characters like that so easily and unsympathetically. The whole movie sucked is pretty much why they died like that. Lucas had A class actors and failed to use them correctly.

  • I loved that green guy. Poor fella.

  • @MisterItai you mean Kit Fisto.... I know huh... he's cool i didn't want him to die either! LOL

  • its funny cause the black guy actually dies last

  • only mace fight like a real jedi the other 3 dont even try to fight..

  • suckiest lightsaber fight ever. He does stupid stabs that even a 2 year old can easily parry and yet kills them.

  • kit fisto, even when he dies, he still smiles

  • I am tired of the muthafuckin sith on this muthafuckin planet!!!!!

  • Mace Windu is the coolest of the Jedis. He's the only one with a purple lightsaber.

  • McDiarmid had a good stunt double.

  • ENOUGH IS ENOUGH I HAVE HAD IT WITH THESE MOTHERFUCKING SITH IN THIS MOTHERFUCKING SENATE

  • I like how people bitch about the other three jedi going down easily. Think about it from a directors perspective: How do you film a scene where 1 person fences against 4 and kills 3 of them in a "legit" way, without showing the killed people as noobs?

  • How did that old ass mutha fucka jumpa 15 feet

  • The reason why the three Jedi died so quickly is because of the fighting style Palpatine uses is new to them. Though, I agree that Lucas did a shit job with this scene.

  • Funny how Anikan arrives when Mace Windu has the total advantage.

  • @pokemontrainerxxx You sure about that? I think Palpatien could have held the force lightning indefinately.

  • @Poseidon500 Well..I don't know. I just think since Palpatines on the ground he's pretty much defenseless. And Mace Windu could just deflect the force lighting back at him.

  • @pokemontrainerxxx Yeah but.... "The Emperor" uses the force to see the future. Also, he faked being weak and defenseless to fool Anakin. He saw the whole thing coming, and was powerfull enough to blind the rest of the Jedi.

    I don't think people understand how powerful Darth Sideous was. He's largely considered the most powerful Sith lord of all time.

  • @Poseidon500 Well I guess I'll have to agree with you on that.

  • @pokemontrainerxxx I mean really, he started the clone wars from both sides, watched Anakin from day one, and was so powerful that he "unbalanced" the force itself. He forsaw the whole thing. His level of deception was amazing.

    But little did he know, that 'Force" itself was even more deceptive, and used Anakin to help bring about a rebirth of a new Jedi order. It was the Force itself that brought Anakin to the dark side, for the specific purpose of devieving the emperor.

  • yeah george lucas needs to go back and just totally redo this scene at a different location

  • 0:58 = rape face

  • HATED this battle. the jedi shouldve put up a better fight than that, and Windu died in a lame way >:/

  • I love the way the other Jedi are complete shits

  • I agree. Remember, none of these Jedi (even Mace) knew for sure who Palpatine really was when they came to arrest him. The whole group was obviously stunned when he drew his saber. Except for Mace, the rest of them were probably like "oh crap...is this really happening?" And by the time they would have recovered, it was way too late. I would say being in that room when all that went down would be much like being in the open ocean with a great white shark swimming around. :)

  • 3 of the best jedi get killed in 15 seconds? what?

  • @sabresman31 ahem read this in Palpatin's voice

    "You may be powerful Mace Windu, but you made the foolish error of bringing your allies, THEY ARE MERE NOOBS COMPARED TO ME!"

  • @sabresman31

    Why do the lightsaber fights suck ass in the actual movies? Then we got low budget, untrained youtubers that upload lightsaber fights that on par with martial artist flicks?

  • @comixgod50 Sucks that 3 jedi get killed off that unsympathetically and that easily, but I think you'd have a pretty hard time blocking a hit if you had no idea where the person was going to hit next too, especially if you were up against THE most powerful Sith Lord...If you don't like the movies,then what the hell are you doing wasting your time here? If you can do better,lets see then.Apparently, YOU don't have a movie with a huge fan base out there so maybe it'd be best if you just shut up.

  • @sabresman31 He must have had a lot of rage built up after all that waiting, my little green friend.

  • @sabresman31

    Of course. A whole army of jedi couldn't sense the presence of a sith lord nerby for over a decade.

  • @bbenjoe agreed dude i was thinking okay when are they going to finally realize that palpatine is sidous. dark side clouds eveything, my @ss clouds everything they could have easily sensed the dark side of him but they figured he isn't corrupt.

  • @sabresman31 the book makes more sense ... palpatine asks saesee to read his mind, and while he's concentrating he brings his blade down, and palpatine stabs him in the head. thats a little more believable than a jedi master just not defending himself

  • just think of it mace windu would have easily saved millions of peoples lifes if he would have killed palpatine quicker

  • My dog would've put up a better fight than those 2 Jedi noobs.

  • hmm fisto was waay to slow to fight sidious and his fighting style should be alot better,heck it should be double handed like mace's

  • @Noble6SPARTANB312 Palpatine did the force scream, stunning them. Kit fisto had some time to recover but not enough. Mace Windu did in time

  • type in obi-wan's bad joke it's funny

  • I wonder why Mace Windu brought the two Jedi noobs with him and why Palpatine changed his voice when he said 'I am the Senate.' Was there a particular reason for that? And was it possible that Palpatine lost because of old age? Lol.

  • @Kira121086 To answer your question about Palpatine's voice changing, I think it changes because in that statement "I AM the senate!" he's speaking as his true self, Sidious, which he no longer has to hide. If you pay attention he does this at other times in the movie, when he tells Anakin to kill Dooku, and when he talks about the dark side to Anakin he tends to speak as Sidious, rather than Palpatine. It's part of his dual personality/identity which he switches between in key moments.

  • worst 3 jedi in history. why put them if you're gonna kill em like shit anyway. George Lucas fail.

  • dang it mace just kill palpatine already. you had the perfect chance at 1:33

  • they'll make anyone a jedi master these days...

  • This fight looks very unimpressive. Pretty bad action acting...maybe could've used a few more body double scenes. They looked like retards circle jerking each other lmao.

    Sidious lost on purpose to draw Anakin to the DARK SIDE

  • @SoaringMuse

    Could'nt have worded it better myself,shame most people dont see the truth of it.

  • @LemmingoftheBDA2 Do you mean the part about bad action sequence of the part about Sidious being the strongest Sith ever?

  • @SoaringMuse

    Actually both

  • @LemmingoftheBDA2 Nice. There are some nice scenes though, Sidious vs. Yoda looked pretty legit.

  • @SoaringMuse

    Dont get me wrong,loved the film and the Obi-wan and Skywalker fight was epic too as like Yoda and Sidious,but the four Jedi masters V Sidious was bad ,the dialog was exellent and then the fight was not up to standard,two masters just stood there to be killed and the fighting was slow .

    This should have been the best fight as the films lead up to this point,but was not to be.

  • @LemmingoftheBDA2

    dude i dont even like starwars that much i just wanted to sample the funny sound the emp makes after he kills mace lol. but wtf man the way the emp fights is sick. every blow is a killing blow, its not that there slow, it's that he's a bad ass, and thats coming from some onewho doesn't like this shit that much, i like the idea but lucas is corny and lame, all the good ideas in the star wars movies he stole from other legends, story's and history.

  • @floatingsilent

    Have to disagree with you thereabou the speedof the fight,look at all the comments.

    Lucas isnt lame,Of course star