Added: 3 years ago
From: AnotherWorld82
Views: 192,329
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (238)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @xxashtonlee he also has a bans called piscifer. It sounds pretty different than both apc and tool. Check out their song the mission or the weaver and them tell me what you think ;)

  • @drummerbadass1 you're a fucking idiot. Maynard and amateur can't be in the same sentence. You obviously don't know WTF ur talking about so until you do, do us all a favor and shut up. Thank you. :)

  • Three Libras? Might as well call that the 3 douchebags with zero talent

  • @drummerbadass1 Whoa!!!! Stop looking in the mirror when you're writing YouTube comments. You may not be absolutely enthralled by this music, but its a total falsehood on ANY level, to say the people performing it have no talent. This is actually quite creative, and well done on a variety of levels. If you don't like it, just leave... don't slag it arbitrarily!!

  • @altareggo Alright. There OK . No big deal like people say. That's all.

  • @drummerbadass1 I guess there just wasn't enough autotune and asshole for you. If you're going to make ignorant comments, why don't you go masturbate to Ke$ha and leave music appreciation to the people who actually know what they're talking about.

    By the way, badasses don't live with their moms. I bet you wear sunglasses indoors too, you putrid fucking cunt.

  • @StatusSarcasm Who's Keisha????. Maynard could use autotune though. He isn't that good of a singer. They rightfully always bury his choked chicken throat behind all kinds of delay and phase cause , well, he's an amateur...I can even sing better than him. Word.. Happy to see you mad bro..hahahahahaahahah

  • @drummerbadass1 Ow. Your comment just gave me cancer.

  • Soooo beautiful <3

  • Damn... I got chicken skin.... awesome

  • I think tool and a perfect circle are more like two different pieces of maynard.

  • This sounds like a completely different song, but it's still fucking amazing.

  • This is the best thing I've ever heard.

  • I'm high. I love that fucking picture on this vid. And the way this band plays, and he sings puts me on a whole new level.

  • Can't believe i haven't heard this (version) until now

  • I think this acoustic version is the best i ever herd before

  • I like this version better than the studio version. I think it's because the addition of the lyric, "You will never see me" makes it so much more emotional... which seemed like it was impossible to do with the song in the first place.

  • Renewing my 5 year old fandom for A Perfect Circle, starting with the acoustic version 3 Libras.

  • yum!

    

  • Does anyone know what tuning and chords are used here? I'm having a difficult time figuring it out by ear.

  • Minor tune up

  • <3.

  • It's like a ghost of sorrow has possessed their instruments.

  • @LiliumCruorem you got that right

  • @LiliumCruorem It's like a ghost of lame ass comments possessed your keyboard.

  • @Cansololife you win the most dickish comment of the month award :D Please, tell us who your inspirations to be such a dick were.

  • @LiliumCruorem Uhmmm.... I'd like to thank my mom, she was a big inspiration to me. My dog, Fluffy, he helped me out of a lot of rough situations, and all the little people out there. I love you all; thank you for this award!

  • @Cansololife Hahaha, you're all right man. Thanks for being a good sport, most people would've just called me a faggot hahaha :)

  • @LiliumCruorem lol =D

  • @LiliumCruorem its like a ghost of dork has possessed your fingers

  • @dillsapldorf It's like the ghost of cock has possessed your mouth.

  • @Jumper754 heheheeeee...guess i had that comin...i still say the same ghost of dork has possessed your fingers too though.

  • 500th. Pow pow pow. On fiya.

  • That's some damned good stuff right there.

  • Difficult not to feel a little bit.... disappointed......\m/

  • It so...hauntingly beautiful.

  • Perfect circle is the sickest band of all time! They hit the spot with everysong, evertytime! I LOVE YOU PC!!

  • This is REAL music. :)

  • like this version alot more than the other. much more emotion and life

  • my ideia is, why have 2 ba ds that play basically the same way? :x

  • @OneManAndHisToaster Because each of the bands has a different style, and they don't really sound all that much alike. Plus they both kind of stand for different things. Tool was Maynard's side project, they only put out records every few years. It's just that somehow they got to be what was the best known band of Maynard's by the majority of people. Not sure how.

  • @xxashtonlee the reason why tool is more famous is because of the radio. the radio doesnt play a perfect circle songs...except one time i heard the outsider. but i guess that was because of the resident evil movie giving it popularity. but to me APC is a tad better :) only because i relate to it more. i think if APC got more radioplay it would be the more famous.

  • @greenkidd529 No way man, Tool is more famous simply because they are better musicians. APC is great, but nothing new really in the realm of alternative rock. Just really, really good.

  • @TheBiddleMan

    you're right. hate comparing the two, but APC is good and Tool is just on a whole other level of good.

  • @El2lk No band can hope to touch Tool but if one had a cance it would be APC

  • WTF... this REALLY sounds a bit like tool, who thinks the same? :|

  • @OneManAndHisToaster That'd probably be because Maynard James Keennan is the lead singer of both bands, and his style pretty much influences them both, causing them to be pretty much interchangeable to people who don't notice the more subtle differences.

  • this resonates in my SOUL

  • amazing

  • Man this is really good!

  • swift

  • He's like a male siren!

  • They are amazing band with great epic tales of ancient battle cries of war poetry with a twist of gypsy melodies!!!!

  • perfect fucking song

  • I got shivers when I hear the violins... It´s a nice sensation indeed... Maynard have such a beautiful and strong voice, that´s why I love APC so much, cause they know how to touch our hearts when they are playing...

  • Keenan , the most expressive singer I've ever heard. I think he could sing about t the banana's peel and cause people(including me) desolation about that.

    Btw this version of 3 libras is wonderful although it lacks the final lines where she does not see him (my favorite part of the original one)

  • @TheMaximvm Maynard said the song is about 9 people, born around the same time. He called the song 3 Libras 1: because they're born around the same time and he wanted to spite them so he let it be 3 so the 9 could fight it out about who the song is about. This is what he said in his interview... it's pretty interesting.

  • Maynard is good.

  • I think Maynard could sing the abc's and it would resonate deep wthin my soul..... his voice and intellect are far too evolved for us to even comprehend thats why we are left in awe of the frequencies in which he resonates.

  • Goddess Paz i sway to your snake charming

  • Most bullshit i've ever seen on a youtube video.

    this song is awesome

  • I honestly really do like this version somewhat more than the original on the album! I dont know I guess it depends on the mood aswell. Its got this haunting yet still mystifyingly beautiful sound all together, definately more abstract than the other one. Either way I love them both and this band!

  • I guess, relationships are weird. It is torture but,.. eons above magnificent. You choose someone who seems like they will irate you the least but, at the same time, for me, someone different than yourself. A person to fill yourself into (giggity). Someone who is kind of like corner piece of puzzle and your another corner. You want those imperfections or annoyances to help you become a different person. To me, its torture and pleasure at the same time... at times it becomes unfathomable.

  • I don't get the whole "same level" & "real" thing. A hipster chick gave this as a reason to break up with me and as confused me ever since. To me, it matters not if you are "obvious" or "fake". I mean, why would I pick a girl who is spontaneous? That is usually a characteristic of an unstable person. I don't know. Maybe I am "fake" or "obvious", or at least enough for her not to talk to me anymore...

  • @supercoolninjayo you're dealing with what sounds like a pretentious hipster. I wouldn't even bother trying to figure out any meaning, because there probably isn't any. Hey, just like her.

  • @Aepotheosis I would assume so. Maybe I need to be known by less people? Maybe I need to have a body piercing and should go grab a Mac book on my eco-friendly bike with my converse sneakers... Maybe then... nah. I think I will just let the beatnik fad die out again...

  • @supercoolninjayo comment of the fucking year

  • @supercoolninjayo

    the meaning of "I threw you the obvious" means the connection of the soul. Whether she

    threw it at you directly or indirectly...it was there and open for her...a soul connection does not

    need to be talked about. It is just there...it is "obvious".... for two people to connect on a soul level,

    you both need to be seeing each other on a soul level. she probably saw through all your superficial masks and wounds and saw the real you...you probably couldn't see or hear her..

  • @maryannh87 Oh so she is superman now? And how does 'obvious' play into seeing someone's inner self?

    I mean, I saw her. We spent a lot of time together. I thought I knew who she was. I didn't realize I was in a trial or soul connection game. I thought I was in a relationship.

    My point being, I think she was going for obvious as in, I am too predictable. I don't think there is a metaphorical meaning behind each word. I didn't put on a mask for a best friend, nor was I 'wounded'.

  • @supercoolninjayo

    your asking how 'obvious' plays into all of this...that's why she left you.

    your oblivious to it all...seeing you with her third eye or the eye of the soul.

    this is more than just knowing someone's likes and dislikes.

    she saw the core of you which is a very rare thing to experience in life. she intuitively saw you

    or felt you. Not that I know her but this is the connection of the song. When you see someone on a soul level for who they truly are, that means you love them.

  • @maryannh87 She waited until over a year to 'look into my soul' and than just gave the reason that I was too obvious and fake... That sounds slightly self righteous and narcissistic. I hate to sound cynical but, if the only group of people that will consider me a friend look at me as someone who is fake, and 'obvious' (still makes no sense to me.) than, fuck the world. Ill live in a cave. You pretentious, self absorbed, and ignorant hipsters have fun swimming in the Arizona Bay.

  • @supercoolninjayo

    dude, if she sent you this song, she must have had hell deep feelings for ya. don't take it personally or think she was judging you or thinking she was better...if this song reminds her of you, you were definitely perfect in her eyes...

  • @maryannh87 Oh you are under the impression she sent me the song! To be honest, she kept a very submissive view of music. If it was on, she would listen to it, never to really show her true feel for particular music.

    In any case, thanks for your input.

  • I love it... Kind of funny, kind of strange how certain songs (particularly this version of this song) seem to resonate more and more with the passage of time... Had not listened to this for at-least four years until tonight. Though I still know every note by heart, it seems so new, so much more profound and so beautiful. It's a hard thing to describe... when something resonates so deeply on such an ever changing spectrum.

  • amazing .. in every way! I didn´t know these recordings existed. they just made my day...no, they made my month :)

  • Good song.... sigh.

  • @MrdrummerSSU

    So, I see you really dislike anything that Mr. Keenan does. I'd really like to know if you have any reasons. Unless you're just a blatant troll, that is.

  • @MrdrummerSSU Your face is gay.

  • @MrdrummerSSU Plus this band is more sraight then you will ever be.

  • @DarkandCryptic See thats exactly I was thinking about today, we should just troll the trolls, they will never see it coming

  • @MMaeidlilniAW Nice, I'd like to do that. :)

  • @MrdrummerSSU i do not believe this band has sex with men or has any relation in the homosexual nature

  • @zero88777 indeed they dont. i have actually found 2 people who dont flame me with hate mail. I love this band, i simply find it humorous to have those quintessential worshipers of maynard hate on me (:

  • @MrdrummerSSU totally agree with you dude people are waaaay to obsessed with maynard

  • @zero88777 give respect where respect is due. Maynard is only a fraction of the band

  • @MrdrummerSSU exactly, he has even said himself that he dosnt like people to worship over him, thats why he preforms in the back, he wants people to focus on the music aspect, not just his voice

  • @zero88777 you sir, are an intelligent human being

  • @MrdrummerSSU I belive that Maynard has a great singing voice, but im more interested into the instrumental. I find it queit relaxing.

  • @stitch39212 agreed

  • @MrdrummerSSU i dont think u kno what quintessential mean...

  • Comment removed

  • @Ritinii You truly are an imbecile. Would you please READ my comments i posted before flaming me? thanks

  • awsomeness

  • whoa.

  • How can you make a perfect song even better? Make it acoustic, and throw in even more fucking emotion.

  • @CristianTane A-fucking-men

  • @CristianTane Haha same fucking thought! Don't for get the sexual luring from that violin...

  • you got that right 

  • cause you'll never see me. cause you'll never see me. cause you'll never see me, cause you'll never see me. you'll never see me. you'll never see me, you'll never see me. you will never fucking see me... . Oh well.

  • but i'll be right there waiting

  • genius

  • OMG, can not wait for the next tool cd, going to buy some of his wine and get waisted and bark at the moon.

  • @louisduloc Let me know if his wine is good.

  • Like wise!

  • This song is so engulfing...Greatness....

  • this is such a beautiful arrangement of this song. good upload!!

  • thank you for posting this, this is wondrous. where did this acoustic sessions come from and how does one get hold of it?

  • dont you think it's scary how a perfect circle can mirror the exact feeling of the listener in a song?

  • @soychinofuentes Indedd, this is magical, another level, a perfect song, a perfect band.

  • @soychinofuentes It's only the listener that is mirroring how they feel to themselves through the music.

  • @soychinofuentes like deftones on friday nights, in a club nearly asleep

  • @soychinofuentes

    You're simply deciding to listen to whatever fits the way you're feeling at the moment. This ain't rocket science, retard.

  • @soychinofuentes yes it is ... fuck that bitch :(

  • this is so beautiful wow, unbelievable, they would be fantastic to see live, wow.

  • some ppl were born to bitch! not sure how this can not be enjoyed but here we are. love the song and the band.

  • Inspired to "All Main Courses mix" by Massive Attack.

  • my favorite version

  • thanks you SOO SOO much for sharing this.. I couldn't find this version anywhere! I missed it. so passionate.

  • I could orgasm to music like this

  • This version is fantastic. So much dark feeling and emotion. I think I like it better than the one on the album.

  • They should do an mtv unplugged or something better. Cuz it would be awesome watch apc do an unplugged session. The song has a more emotional heaviness this way. Is soft, beautiful but yet so dark and powerful. Amazing!

  • i love this song, and blue......good job with the videos lol

  • jesus christ.

  • This song fucking owns. I don't give a shit what you brain dead people have to say.

  • One of theeeeeeeee best.  Yup.

  • Sehr geil! Besser als die Album version! ;)

  • Beautiful

  • best version!!(L)

  • The song, is exactly how I am with girls in real life. Intuitively, I read them, I throw them the obvious and they react exactly this...disappointing, to not be able to find anyone who is either real or at the same level

  • @cloud0123 I hear ya

  • me 2, ur not the only one in the world :)

  • @cloud0123 I know exactly how this feels, I did the same with the same chick for over a year man..

  • @cloud0123 2 years now and still trying ive showed her this song and she said she liked it i hope shes not lying cause this is my all time favourite

  • @cloud0123 i know exactly what you mean

  • @cloud0123 I feel you dude

  • @cloud0123 well that's prob cause you're too much of a little bitch for any girls to take notice of you.

  • @zoozoomkkz16 haha you're wrong. More like being noticed and then me testing them and general disappointment. Who's fault is that? Mine. Nice try though little internet warrior.

  • @cloud0123 This song makes me cry every time I hear it, and reminds me of how I treated my soul mate, and I regret it every day. Maybe one day they'll realize their mistakes.

  • @cloud0123 My struggle exactly

  • @cloud0123 thats because you hang out with superficial women........most of whom would not see the parody in my screen name.

  • @cloud0123 girls are written in a different language.

  • @cloud0123

    No lie. I posted some of the lyrics on my facebook wall when my g/f and I were in a rough patch and she thought that I had wrote her a poem. lol, women.

  • @jmangle hahaha, well, good for you. :)

  • @jmangle good lyrics...

  • @jmangle

    Same thing happened to me, man!

  • @cloud0123 i totally understand you.

  • @cloud0123 Sounds like the male version of me. =/

  • @cloud0123 This is what I love about Maynard's song writing. I never once thought of it as having that meaning. I always felt like it described the situation where you love someone and do things to get noticed and hope they feel the same way about you but all they see is you being nice to them. And in the end, this person you thought was pretty amazing had nothing going on up top.

    I guess Maynard's songs are more like Rorshach tests than actual messages.

  • @cloud0123 i can definitly relate

  • This is what true music is supposed to sound like.

  • this song is so beautiful. a lot of emotion. i always get the feeling of desperation, loneliness, and utter sadness when i listen to this song. maybe its just me. even still, the first time i heard 3 libras i cried. apc is a truly remarkable band, and while tool and ashes divide are great bands in their own right, no band out there can hold a candle to apc.

  • i gotta ask but are you a female??? Just because I'm male and LOVE APC, Pusicer, AD, but if i had to pick itd be hands down TOOL...Maynard has said that Tool is his masculine side wheras APC is his feminine side

  • @011lifeAdream235 yes i am

  • "you got that right"

  • best version yet!!!

  • This sounds like The Outsider.

  • I love this song...but I think I prefer the Mer de Noms version..

  • uhh your English is perfect and i agree tool is superior but its still maynard

  • omg. this is absolutely fantastic. i luv it

  • who the fuck cares about time signature

    this song is amazing just the way it is

    stop talking bullshit

    like if everything is perfect jeez

  • Fucking HEAVEN.... luv it

  • just...listen

  • This is really beautiful to me, And i've always like the original but there's just something about hearing the same songs in a different light i guess. idk really...

  • What are you people bitching? Just enjoy the music.

  • @chanoom right on. I couldn't find this version anywhere! I missed it. so passionate.

  • @allikat6 Yeah. Album version is good and all but, this really takes it.

  • This time signature conversation is ridiculous, but it sounds to me like 6/8 and 10/8 alternating. If that really matters to anyone. Also it's not anything new, and if you add that up you get 16/8, meaning it could be read as 4/4 with just an emphasis on 1 and the and of 2. Pretty basic beat here, APC doesn't really do anything innovative with time signatures, if you care about that listen to tool.

    Bottom line is it is definitely NOT in 3/4 or 6/8, you're leaving out 4 perfectly good 8th notes.