Added: 3 years ago
From: coloraturafan2
Views: 16,188
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (53)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nadia Krasteva great

  • @elderarce absolutely right

  • Just perfect.

  • Vibrant, deep and moving timbre is this of Nadia Krasteva. Fabulous dynamical modulation. And a so poetic presense.

  • I find damrau too loud here. Krasteva has a great voice. netrebko and garanca from badden badden was a better pairing. 

  • this song is very relaxing.... Specially Dina & Nadia gave their best...

    LOVE THIS SONG....

    BRAVA!!!!

  • This is one of the better renditions

    on here, but they are both mezzo's.

  • @robinajerowsky Diana Damrau is a lyric coloratura soprano. How you can even call her a mezzo is absolutely beyond me.

  • @tenor220 actually i do believe diana is a dramatic coloratura, by trait she plays more dramatic roles to lyric ones.

  • @aalg4c she's lyrcal Cororatura soprano! she can sing everithing!

  • @robinajerowsky Diana is definitely not a mezzo, have you seen her sing Queen of the Night? its crazy. I love her lol

  • Guess im saying what everyone else is. The make-up of Garana/Netrebko was a better match than this. Having said that, Diana is a far superior Soprano than Nadia in my opinion which makes me wonder how Garana/Damrau would have sounded.. Taking nothing at all away from Nadia, i love her. But i would love to hear a nice match for Diana with this piece.

  • I agree, their voices don't match well, and they get out of synch. with each other some times, which is jarring. I love DD's silvery tone, and indeed the mezzo has a nice dark richness, but they don't work together.

  • a little too dramatic, for my taste, compared to, schwarzkopf, caballe,sutherland,and of course garanca/netrebko. But still gorgeous, Diana overwhelming as ever

  • Truly beautiful, but I prefer the performance of Anna Netrebko and Elina Garanca. Anna as soprano and Elina as mezzo, it gives me goosebumps.

    But eventually Diana is the best alive soprano on earth.

  • @alejonightwish Netrebko as a very dark voice for sing with a mezzo! and Elina has a shiny voice for sing with Netrbko!

    This the best Dout for ever! Nadia and Diana!

  • Entre las arias mas hermosas... esta es la mas hermosa de todas!!!

  • I think Diana would sing this duet so much better with Joyce DiDonato, they have really good connection together.

    I love her, she's the greatest soprano of our times, but I don't like this duet.

  • For me only exists two mezzosopranos in the world: nadia krasteva and cecilia bartoli

  • All I can say is wow. I love this song and both of these singers. Diana is an amazing soprano and I rather like Nadia. And am I the only one who's noticed that both their names the exact same letters?

  • Wow. What an observation! Yes the names. Weird hey. And yes, Diana, amazing as always. She is finally getting the recognition she deserves. Greatest Female soprano the world has seen. So deserving of this title.

  • and where is T in diana damrau?

  • I meant first names,not full names..

  • Comment removed

  • Diana sounds beautiful, I don;t like the other lady

  • ahh this make me so sick...this should be a duet...but this is how it is in opera everyone try to sing louder or higher well...specially when it comes to women ...women they are so bitchy..i m a woman but i think that we all have to respect and admire someone elses voices or at least try to learn something ...soprano (weeping:(

  • hehehe you are so right

    and i find diana bitchier than the other lady in that way...

    she is the one trying to sing higher

    but i think this sounds really good =)

  • While this is a duet, it is not two sopranos, but one soprano and a mezzo soprano. One is supposed to sing higher than the other!

  • i wasnt talking about range or whatever it is...

    you can notice it like from instinct

    in spanish we call it sentido comun!!!

    torpe!!!

    jaja

  • @Kate0603 no.. this is a duet with a soprano and a coluratura

  • @blumajikboi

    Diana Damrau is a soprano, and Nadia Krasteva is a mezzo-soprano. Damrau has coloratura abilities, but she is always billed as a soprano, and she sings the soprano part. Not sure where you are getting the idea that Krasteva is a soprano, her voice is far too deep.

  • I love Nadia's voice. Are there anymore videos of her?

  • damrau is my personal fave soprano... she sucks at the flower duet...

  • or the recording equipment is _really_ bad here..? Why does it sound so terrible..it must be technically correct, right?

  • seems like they want to fight each other, to show people who is the best,, the pitch control of diana and nadia doesn't fit the song,, like water and soil..............

  • i have very high expectations of this song probably because this song made me LOVE opera. sad to say, this rendition is a complete mess. it seems as tho Krasteva is trying to outsing Damrau. they are obviously not singing toether. boris 1281 is correct so who's that bloody idiot who gave him a "thumbs down"? get lost

  • The mezzo is absolutely ridiculous in this part. She plays Preziosila and not Malika!!! But so is Damrau, she seems more like Malika's servant!!! Funny, Both voices sound nice, but only when they do not sing together. I think that the mezoo would make a fantastic Eboli or Carmen, but not Malika!

  • It is true, they are not singing together!!!

  • I concur. If we separated the voices and had them sing the parts by themselves it would sound great, They have no chemistry to gether, whatsoever.

  • Say what you will, I loved the performance.

  • What is up with that Mezzo? Her placement is way back and she's not letting the sound spin at all. No wonder this duet sounds off!

  • Yes, it does... The voices don't really match.

  • @eeli1 I've never heard and seen beter mezzo than Nadia!

  • @ApostolMilenkov so truth!! in my opinion she's better than Elina G.

  • Even I as a Damrau-blind-fan have to admit this aria has been done better by other pairs.. I liked Netrebko, Garanca.

    I just think their colors or whatnot blend weirdly.. doesn't sound too great :/

  • A+++++++++++++

  • first - thank you! Does this take place in France? Since Delibes was that French composer..

  • No, it didn't. This is a British Opera Festival.

  • "Lamke Flower Duet"??? :-)

  • Yes it is!!!!!

    So beautiful!!!!!

  • Coloraturafan wrote: "Lamke Flower Duet"! *lol*

    (I just know Lakme Flower Duett,.................)

  • Yes... I saw the mistake later...

    Beautiful anyway!!!

  • And the mezzo is Nadya not Nadia z)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more