@jamesragnarok Is there a way for me to play this? I just want to laugh at how much of a rip off this is but i cant get past the char ID page on the sign up :c
I'm glad that someone in China would be brave enough to make a video exposing a plagiarized game like this. Seriously, China has gotta start making something more original, too. This TF2 ripoff just brings more shame to the already-shameful Chinese community.
I laugh my butt off my chair... man ... I was like.... WTH? No wonder why Japan and US look down on us.... why can't they "CREATE" something other than copying someone else's work?
to the maker: i loled. good work taking a shit on these fakers. and the dial on that flamethrower... its from the sydney sleeper from tf2. no surprise.
When he asked "Why does this place look like TF2's farm map?", before he even made an actual comparison, I just suddenly noticed that 'holy crap, this is Harvest!'
What pisses me off more about that is that it's not a offical Valve map - Harvest was made by Sean "Heyo" Cutino, a community contributer, and Valve added it offically. It's bad enough when you plagiarize off of a large company... but it's terrible when you take a honest, generous TF2 community member's work and utterly copy it.
this is hilarious.... I'm literally dying in my chair. I'm chinese and I think this is pathetic. Seriously, they're smart and all but communism makes them dumb when it comes to creativity.
While it's a blatant rip-off of TF2, there are things in it I like over TF2 like the loadout and vibrant graphics/textures. Though the graphics will probably make it difficult to differentiate between the map and players.
Its kind of funny that they slightly changed the classes as people started complaining. It's pretty obvious that its a ripoff, but its nice to see all of the similarities in one video.
I'm not sure Valve even can do anything about this, China never signed the world wide copyright agreements, it's legal for them to rip off whatever they want aslong as it's Chinese only.
Good video though, dude. And your English is great.
The dial for the flamethrower reminds me of a game called CA, another FPS though not anything similar to TF2 or the rip off: F***ing Crap game.
Good job, you have explained well. One of the best videos i've ever seen, no joke. I'm chinese too, though i cant remember alot of the chinese words now. :(
ok guys, you shouldnt blame every chinese for this, because most people ditched this game when they learned it was a ripoff, and plus, chinese people play tf2 in china. final fantasy, or some japan game, we americans play it, but if america makes a ripoff of it, surely many people will hate it, so that's whats happening in china, no one gives 2 shits about this game.
Good lord, this video makes me want to cry. Have you uploaded this onto Chinese video sites? Chinese gamers should know about this (bus somehow I think they won't care).
You guys are awesome. Thank you to everyone who created this video, edited it, and translated it. Seriously. I couldn't have spelled out everything wrong with this piece of trash better myself.
Also, ChaosWolf... I'm not even going to dignify that comment by responding to it. You obviously have no idea what makes Valve's characters great.
I do like their Sniper better, if mostly because it cuts back on all the gay pairing potential by having a female on the roster (hello, Valve, you hearing me?)... and the fact that a sexy woman in fuck-me heels is a lot more interesting than a grungy Aussie who pisses in jars.
By the way, my sister and I watched this video and noticed that the Firebat's character animation in the selection screen is a tweaked Demoman running animation. Even the way he holds the flamethrower is slightly similar with the hands moved slightly, however those are definitely the Demoman's legs running animation.
I can't wait for valve to take action for this game, the ultimate irony is if they made promotional items and reskin weapons/hats from final combat once the company who made it is sued for everything they got.
@jamesragnarok They should! If they let this game launch then there saying "we don't care if some incompetent shit company shamelessly rips off our brain child, and more rip offs can come from it."
I bet my TF2 backpack that if something like this was made in the US, they would sue that company in a heartbeat.
@jamesragnarok No the problem is that with Xunlei being in China it follows China's laws of copyright infringement...which isn't really enforced. So the best Valve can do is send a cease and desist and hope the boss of Xunlei does not fax a copy of his butt back.
@TheMaskedTomato Maybe so, but ones like this when the company claims they are being unique and are making a brand new game (and claiming there geniuses like this company is) Is not alright. Because it is clear that its made in the same engine (not to sure on that) and if not, it has similar sound effects, similar classes, character models, and gooey. And just because there are a lot of knock offs, doesn't make it ok.
And I never said this was something new, please keep your facts straight.
@6thhokagephil You do know that the Source engine is open source, right? And who gives two shits what they claim if everyone and their mother knows it's false? And as long as they do not charge money for this they are doing nothing illegal. Is it morally wrong? Well that just depends on your own personal morals, and personally, I don't even think it's worth wasting your time bitching about. Unless you suck Gabe's dick nightly, anyway.
@TheMaskedTomato We don't know know yet if there going to charge money for it. But if they charge for any aspect of this game it is wrong entirely. Also claiming something that isn't yours is always wrong. They should not be able to get away with it. It is called plagiarism. Being stationed in a different country does not justify it.
@6thhokagephil I hope you realize that plagiarism is not illegal, and whether or not one views it as wrong comes down to your own personal morals. And I should hope that you would be intelligent enough to understand that you cannot persecute others based on your own personal morals alone. Hell, up until the 18th century plagiarism was considered good and the right way to do things.
@TheMaskedTomato There's a reason why if you are caught plagiarizing in College you are not only failed, but the professor also calls you into the academic provost for academic dishonesty. Not illegal indeed.
And while Source engine is open source, that is the ENGINE, not the game. The game itself is what's being called out. If they made a source game with different models and class system no one would have complained. But Xunlei did and the damage was done.
@Lightscribe225 You too seem to be confusing morals with THE LAW. You are failed when plagiarizing because you aren't proving you learned anything, not because it's illegal.
And what damage? How can you financially impact a free to play game?
@TheMaskedTomato Because you are taking the IP of someone else, claiming it as your own, and distributing it. Which is plagiarism, which is considered fraud, which is illegal. See where I'm going with this?
And no, if I was confusing morals and law, then there would be no need for plagiarism to be recorded in a police record, which it is. You are thinking about cheating. I'm talking about directly taking someone else's published work and saying it was your idea.
@TheMaskedTomato Because you are taking the IP of someone else, claiming it as your own, and distributing it. Which is plagiarism, which is considered fraud, which is illegal. See where I'm going with this?
And no, if I was confusing morals and law, then there would be no need for plagiarism to be recorded in a police record, which it is. You are thinking about cheating. I'm talking about directly taking someone else's published work and saying it was your idea.
@TheMaskedTomato Like I said, if Xunlei simply used it as a basis for their new game, then replaced the animations, skins, map layouts, weapon mechanics, and class system, they would be fine. But the fact stands they aren't. And judging by the website, they aren't planning to.
And a f2p game can still turn a profit, which also compounds to my earlier statement that they are using Valve's work for their own gain. I don't know where you come from, but in most of the world, that is illegal.
@Lightscribe225 Not only does China have very relaxed copyright laws, but unless Xunlei charges for the game what they're doing isn't in any way criminal. Is it morally wrong? That's your opinion. But plagiarism is not inherently criminal in any way whatsoever. And Valve didn't invent class systems you fucking moron.
And if Valve really cared about people stealing their shit they wouldn't make it open source. Hell, I doubt Valve even cares.
@TheMaskedTomato Okay now you are just looking stupid by bring stuff like "fucking moron" to a debate. If it isn't inherently criminal, then why don't you prove me wrong, record an episode of some TV show, and post it on your channel, unedited in any way at all, and see how quickly it gets removed.
Again you aren't listening, the ENGINE is open source, and every game that ever used it credited Valve for it. Vampire bloodlines credited it to Valve. Vindictus credited it to Valve.
@TheMaskedTomato And no Valve did not invent the class system. I never said that, I have no idea where you got that. What Valve made were the class mechanics that are being used in Final Combat (Rocket using the Soldier's loadout, Fatman the Heavy's loadout), and worse, they are using the same skins. And it does not matter whether or not you charge for it. If you are distributing a product someone else made, WITHOUT crediting them, it is still criminal.
@TheMaskedTomato I'll say it as many times as I have to, plagiarism, is theft of intellectual property, and perjury all wrapped up into a nice little package called fraud. Ever notice how some youtube videos are removed because of copyright infringement? Yeah, the law in action. Not some morally outraged person.
idk what he says but preeetty clear on his thoughts about that sniper gun lol great vid, been wantin to see this game for once.. Really isn't all that the same, my idea is that the people will play whats best.
這遊戲真可憐,抄襲抄到一模一樣,護士沒護士應有的樣子,看到她噁心的樣子就想用spy狠狠的在反面插她幾刀和鞭她屍
yyyy32103210 2 days ago in playlist Liked videos
連對岸網友都看不下去了
爛山寨遊戲趕快倒一倒吧!!!!!!!!!!
yuio8001 4 days ago
連對岸網友都看不下去了
爛山寨遊戲趕快倒一倒吧!!!!!!!!!!
yuio8001 4 days ago
Those jungle sounds at 3:07 - 3:14 is form Battlefield: Vietnam
(The older one) Lolol
MrTutti134 2 weeks ago
Xunlei: masters of doublethink.
TadRaunch 2 weeks ago
垃圾大陸狗最愛抄
wingto199296 3 weeks ago
噴火兵 is half life2 重力槍
laik98 3 weeks ago
中國就只會造山寨
jerry96820 3 weeks ago
其实国内腾讯的一款游戏 忘了名字了 也是抄的 抄的是Alliance of Valiant Arms Steam的免费游戏之一
t2050929 4 weeks ago
哥们儿 steam搜不到你啊 steam有好几个名字的 你都说说么
t2050929 4 weeks ago
@t2050929 原影片作者的話就叫做00912,我的話叫做|Rp|๖ۜJames Einherjar 孤寂
jamesragnarok 4 weeks ago
Nausea
cup866 1 month ago
THUMBS UP FOR TF2!!!!!!
levinchau123 1 month ago
06:36 But why did you use "Player who killed you" in the freeze-cam? F***~~!
(Can't stop laughing)
Theblackspy12 1 month ago
有12個人沒玩過TF2
s321901162000 1 month ago
Can you put english subtitles on this video?
noobkaka567 1 month ago
@noobkaka567 Please press the "CC" button
jamesragnarok 1 month ago 2
@jamesragnarok Is there a way for me to play this? I just want to laugh at how much of a rip off this is but i cant get past the char ID page on the sign up :c
CONKER17 2 weeks ago
@CONKER17 Since you need a China social ID number to register an account, there is little way for non-Chinese to play it.
jamesragnarok 2 weeks ago
@jamesragnarok well i figured out a way, i just wish i could understand the menus more XD
CONKER17 2 weeks ago
@CONKER17 From the top: account, password, confirm password, real name, social ID number, verification code.
Have fun! :)
jamesragnarok 2 weeks ago
wtf look at that shit, its 100% rip-off!
noobkaka567 1 month ago
The flamethrower reminds me of Halo 1
mycatisdumb99 2 months ago
contains content from team fortress 2 =.=
sean4019 2 months ago
Also, compare the advertisements.
NoNameLikeThisOne 2 months ago
The flamethrower reminds me of the one seen in the game Killing Floor.
SirKemper1 2 months ago
I mad.
Lalicure 2 months ago
那個油量表..
我會想到殺人地板(Killing Floor)的火焰放射器
ahghinwin 2 months ago
This is like, the only final combat video whose like bar isn't a light saber. I'm quite amazed.
bast963 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
大衝鋒噴火兵的火槍油表是HL2重力槍的表....
他媽的.太山寨了.....
a54123659 2 months ago
Comment removed
a54123659 2 months ago
大家反對大衝鋒,來挺tf2,只會模仿的豬滾開!!!
csoo1122 2 months ago 5
cao ni ma zong q len
minecraftopz1 2 months ago
好的評論
MrHaoWei 2 months ago
Surprised he didn't mention that they re-used nearly every sound file from TF2, including the announcer. D:
InuyashaGirl7291 2 months ago
Now I know why they copied TF2's... everything.
They can't model or animate for shit. The flamethrower's model is ugly, its animation is robotic at best, and the fire particle looks terrible!
TheSonOfDumb 2 months ago
11:16
Wait a minute...
THE GODDAMN THROWING ANIMATION IS IDENTICAL TO BATTLEFIELD BAD COMPANY 2'S!
TheSonOfDumb 2 months ago
I'm glad that someone in China would be brave enough to make a video exposing a plagiarized game like this. Seriously, China has gotta start making something more original, too. This TF2 ripoff just brings more shame to the already-shameful Chinese community.
MarwanGC 3 months ago
Shame!
kolkolkolla 3 months ago
Thumbs up for this hilarious video.
FilHadi 3 months ago
7-12-2011 they have released saxton hale mode, but instead, they've replaced SH with a robot
a0001521 3 months ago
油表盤是抄 Half-Life 2 的重力槍
dnm432200 3 months ago
I laugh my butt off my chair... man ... I was like.... WTH? No wonder why Japan and US look down on us.... why can't they "CREATE" something other than copying someone else's work?
RLDacia 3 months ago
que pena es una vil copia de nuestro qurido juego tf2
emafolcksud 3 months ago
噴火器也抄襲farcry2
andy880819 3 months ago
to the maker: i loled. good work taking a shit on these fakers. and the dial on that flamethrower... its from the sydney sleeper from tf2. no surprise.
xe7rut 3 months ago
AHAHAHAHA, THIS IS COMEDY GOLD XD
*facebook*
jasonz777z 3 months ago
喷火器的压量表是从"Killing Floor"的喷火器来的。
jasonz777z 3 months ago
2:11 - 2:19 bottom left
the game is still in development, it isn't the final quality of the game.
don't take screenshots, capture videos and test it (?).
this is xunlei's excuse for not exposing their rip-off to the world.
but the most ironic thing is everyone is doing this
a0001521 4 months ago
When he asked "Why does this place look like TF2's farm map?", before he even made an actual comparison, I just suddenly noticed that 'holy crap, this is Harvest!'
What pisses me off more about that is that it's not a offical Valve map - Harvest was made by Sean "Heyo" Cutino, a community contributer, and Valve added it offically. It's bad enough when you plagiarize off of a large company... but it's terrible when you take a honest, generous TF2 community member's work and utterly copy it.
Penopat 4 months ago 23
@Penopat They probably don't even know the difference, just saw it in the game and copied it.
cyb0rg2 3 months ago
5:53 Speed hacker xD sweet
gratianray2 4 months ago
this is hilarious.... I'm literally dying in my chair. I'm chinese and I think this is pathetic. Seriously, they're smart and all but communism makes them dumb when it comes to creativity.
selan100 4 months ago 23
Its good to see a chinese with a sense of humor for nazis and english movies.
Luisin88 4 months ago
The best.
jamesfish05 4 months ago
The flame-throwers dial is like the One From Far Cry 2.
Yubera2K10 4 months ago
@Yubera2K10 Its a lot like the flame thrower in Killing Floor as well
alladoxas 4 months ago
@Yubera2K10 tf2 dispenser
ssun8 4 months ago
ORIGINAL GAME DO NOT STEAL
Grushvak 4 months ago
And yet this is a better game than Hat Fortress 2.
Squishy3 4 months ago
someone sure is mad
ShadowAonix 4 months ago
While it's a blatant rip-off of TF2, there are things in it I like over TF2 like the loadout and vibrant graphics/textures. Though the graphics will probably make it difficult to differentiate between the map and players.
HedjaHead 4 months ago
The flamethrower is from Halo for the PC, if I remember correctly.
ArrDoubleYouAy 4 months ago
So if it remotely resembles something from TF2, it's a blatant rip off. If it's original to the game, it sucks.
Gotcha malcontent chinaman.
BlackKnight03 4 months ago
Its kind of funny that they slightly changed the classes as people started complaining. It's pretty obvious that its a ripoff, but its nice to see all of the similarities in one video.
Purin1023 4 months ago
This game looks awesome compared to TF2. Enjoy your sausage fest.
ShadowOfLight3000 4 months ago
I'm not sure Valve even can do anything about this, China never signed the world wide copyright agreements, it's legal for them to rip off whatever they want aslong as it's Chinese only.
Good video though, dude. And your English is great.
DundletheViking 4 months ago
To all the retards:
Enable CC for English subtitles.
Melohalo 4 months ago
>Chinese
>Ripoff
WOW THAT SURE IS NEW.
Shoutenkou 4 months ago
You should add subtitles.
neverhoodyn 4 months ago
Well at least I'm glad people know they're being fed a poor imitation.
RamboStu 4 months ago
Why would valve bother taking action? a crappy chinese rip off isn't going to mean anything to them cause who's going to play it when tf2 is free.
BlueBlackInside 4 months ago
The appropriate action for Valve to take is to give the Pyro clown items
ParasiticFlame 4 months ago
So they ripped off a game that's free?
Brilliant.
AyeSpy90 4 months ago
TF2 but without the hats.
Whats the point?
Scorpiondesu 4 months ago
The dial for the flamethrower reminds me of a game called CA, another FPS though not anything similar to TF2 or the rip off: F***ing Crap game.
Good job, you have explained well. One of the best videos i've ever seen, no joke. I'm chinese too, though i cant remember alot of the chinese words now. :(
RedstoneWire 4 months ago
@RedstoneWire yeah combat arms sucked
The2ndAsian 4 months ago in playlist The2ndAsian's favorites
ok guys, you shouldnt blame every chinese for this, because most people ditched this game when they learned it was a ripoff, and plus, chinese people play tf2 in china. final fantasy, or some japan game, we americans play it, but if america makes a ripoff of it, surely many people will hate it, so that's whats happening in china, no one gives 2 shits about this game.
The2ndAsian 4 months ago in playlist The2ndAsian's favorites
This has been flagged as spam show
Good lord, this video makes me want to cry. Have you uploaded this onto Chinese video sites? Chinese gamers should know about this (bus somehow I think they won't care).
lindajing 4 months ago
Comment removed
lindajing 4 months ago
04:24 那藥瓶擺明是抄襲TF2裏某瓶黃色液體的啦~
skillless 4 months ago
I absolutely loved this video. You bring this message with honesty and humor.
Thank you!
KSArgentum 5 months ago
hl 3 hl3 hl3 please
MUYPHY123 5 months ago
there's only one I haven't seen in this video...
it'sss...
SPYYYYYYYYYY!!!!
ChaosCerberos 5 months ago
far cry 2 嗎
MUYPHY123 5 months ago
i want to cry in 1:36
ihavegun 5 months ago
Best in 14:18
ihavegun 5 months ago
I lol'd the swearing f part XD
drhax1234 5 months ago
Bad game EVER~!!!!!!
ihavegun 5 months ago
This rip off make me want to cry
eeveemaster1 5 months ago
TF2= Free, 9 epic classes of pwnage, 9999% playability, haz rocketjump/stickyjump
FC= not free, no medic/engy/demoman/scout, 1/2 playablity, no rocketjump/stickyjump.
BLAM THIS HORRIBLE FUCKING EXCUSE FOR MEDIA D:<
electrikiller117 5 months ago in playlist tf2
你好! 那油表盤我只知道在 Killzone 2 裡有出現在他們的噴火槍上! 不過那油表盤是真的拿來看還有多少油量的! 並不只是裝飾!
rclsm1021 5 months ago
@rclsm1021 那個好像是HL2重力槍上的儀表 但是不是油表盤
kwdjwd 5 months ago
太無恥了他媽的!! Valve告爛他們!!
rclsm1021 5 months ago
突擊兵的主槍是抄襲COD6的M16
asd8988665 5 months ago
Final combat shi bu shi chong zhong guo lai de ma?
Dui bu qi wo bu ke yi xie hua wen.
Officetipmt 5 months ago
I like the fact that 00912 is a fan of Mel Brooks' The Producers. You have good taste, sir! :D
Foxhack 5 months ago
that flame thrower do really look like the halo 1 pc version one, or am i wrong ... was so long ago i played it
MrSommar25 5 months ago
flame thrower kinda reminds me of that game where you go back in time your names cortez too bad i dont remeber waht it was called
JRMproductions123 5 months ago
你說出了我們的心聲
okppgl 5 months ago
You guys are awesome. Thank you to everyone who created this video, edited it, and translated it. Seriously. I couldn't have spelled out everything wrong with this piece of trash better myself.
Also, ChaosWolf... I'm not even going to dignify that comment by responding to it. You obviously have no idea what makes Valve's characters great.
2Foxxy4U 5 months ago
I do like their Sniper better, if mostly because it cuts back on all the gay pairing potential by having a female on the roster (hello, Valve, you hearing me?)... and the fact that a sexy woman in fuck-me heels is a lot more interesting than a grungy Aussie who pisses in jars.
ChaosWolf1982 5 months ago
@ChaosWolf1982 The character appears to have no personality whatsoever though...
Being a girl is not what one would call characterization
ColBarnaby 5 months ago
Dear China, quit being stupidly ignorant morons. Sincerely, the rest of the world.
KhFanaticProductions 5 months ago
Sniper Gum!
MyScorpion42 5 months ago
Worse, they even directly stole the Announcer sound files. Not just a ripoff, DIRECTLY RIPPED FROM TF2! Its even in some trailers. Wut.
MRWWAYSS 5 months ago
Fuck you Final Combat, rubbish!
stonebreaker99 5 months ago
我希望Valve能捍卫自己的知识产权,让这个游戏得到该有的惩罚
7887victor 5 months ago
9 ppl is Final Combat Fanboy,
Fuck you Final Combat.
murutattack 5 months ago in playlist murutattack's Favorited Videos
Comment removed
murutattack 5 months ago
why valve does not care?
simple
they didnt care
they didnt have proof
yet 80 % and above of all tf2 players(including chinese)
have approved that they should ban them
StrikaShot 5 months ago
hahaha lol, 1:36 that was nice expression to describe Final Combat
diazhungi 6 months ago
Holy~~Shit!
a0478786 6 months ago
just fucking kill me now 我不想玩一個垃圾山寨遊戲
mkl13031 6 months ago
That it ends with the "free to play" trailer is just awesome. Pointing people to the better game. :D
Ailure 6 months ago in playlist Ailure's Favorited Videos
12:16 It's a rip-off from Killing Floor. (从Killing Floor)
secretstream 6 months ago
那個噴火兵的劑量計.是KILLING FLOOR 的火焰槍.一模一樣
n46312742 6 months ago
不怕撞車嗎....
a0933246 6 months ago
They are fucking annoying liars, Step up and quit fucking ripping off the fat guy... I mean the really fat guy...
zaperatus 6 months ago
Check the Flamethrower's dial, it's a rip off from Half-Life 2's Gravity Gun.
I shit you not, my friends.
Nyaruato 6 months ago
Gravity Gun from Half-Life 2.
I shit you not.
Nyaruato 6 months ago
This should go nicely with video. When hitler finds out about Final Combat:
youtube.com/watch?v=n1Lh2584SCE&feature=related
SpoonyAus 6 months ago
I found out where that dial on the Fireclown's flamethrower comes from! Remember the Sydney Sleeper sniper rifle? There ya go.
blademasterjt 6 months ago 5
Lawsuit up!
1001111001 6 months ago
有8個人在迅雷上班
there are 8 people working in the Xunlei company
Politician2009 6 months ago 4
火焰兵的表是抄襲TF醫護兵的治療搶 :)
MrJLee0325 6 months ago
Comment removed
superguy297 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
By the way, my sister and I watched this video and noticed that the Firebat's character animation in the selection screen is a tweaked Demoman running animation. Even the way he holds the flamethrower is slightly similar with the hands moved slightly, however those are definitely the Demoman's legs running animation.
RoChanOne 6 months ago
Comment removed
RoChanOne 6 months ago
Comment removed
RoChanOne 6 months ago
I watched this whole thing not uderstanding it at all. Then with 5 minutes left, I was told that there were subs with CC,
Wuollet24 6 months ago
I can't wait for valve to take action for this game, the ultimate irony is if they made promotional items and reskin weapons/hats from final combat once the company who made it is sued for everything they got.
6thhokagephil 6 months ago 6
@6thhokagephil Still waiting... Looks like Valve don't even care about this :(
jamesragnarok 6 months ago 9
@jamesragnarok They should! If they let this game launch then there saying "we don't care if some incompetent shit company shamelessly rips off our brain child, and more rip offs can come from it."
I bet my TF2 backpack that if something like this was made in the US, they would sue that company in a heartbeat.
6thhokagephil 6 months ago
@jamesragnarok No the problem is that with Xunlei being in China it follows China's laws of copyright infringement...which isn't really enforced. So the best Valve can do is send a cease and desist and hope the boss of Xunlei does not fax a copy of his butt back.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@6thhokagephil Knockoffs of popular games are nothing new you fucking retard.
TheMaskedTomato 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato Maybe so, but ones like this when the company claims they are being unique and are making a brand new game (and claiming there geniuses like this company is) Is not alright. Because it is clear that its made in the same engine (not to sure on that) and if not, it has similar sound effects, similar classes, character models, and gooey. And just because there are a lot of knock offs, doesn't make it ok.
And I never said this was something new, please keep your facts straight.
6thhokagephil 5 months ago
@6thhokagephil You do know that the Source engine is open source, right? And who gives two shits what they claim if everyone and their mother knows it's false? And as long as they do not charge money for this they are doing nothing illegal. Is it morally wrong? Well that just depends on your own personal morals, and personally, I don't even think it's worth wasting your time bitching about. Unless you suck Gabe's dick nightly, anyway.
TheMaskedTomato 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato We don't know know yet if there going to charge money for it. But if they charge for any aspect of this game it is wrong entirely. Also claiming something that isn't yours is always wrong. They should not be able to get away with it. It is called plagiarism. Being stationed in a different country does not justify it.
6thhokagephil 5 months ago
@6thhokagephil I hope you realize that plagiarism is not illegal, and whether or not one views it as wrong comes down to your own personal morals. And I should hope that you would be intelligent enough to understand that you cannot persecute others based on your own personal morals alone. Hell, up until the 18th century plagiarism was considered good and the right way to do things.
TheMaskedTomato 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato
>I hope you realize that plagiarism is not illegal
Lol you cannot into intellectual property.
Anderasio 5 months ago
@Anderasio Plagiarism is not illegal. Go learn the law and stop trying to greentext on youtube you fucking retard.
TheMaskedTomato 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato
Yes, it very much is. And that's not greentexting, that's quoting.
Greentexting would be
>implying you're not a giant newfag
Anderasio 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato There's a reason why if you are caught plagiarizing in College you are not only failed, but the professor also calls you into the academic provost for academic dishonesty. Not illegal indeed.
And while Source engine is open source, that is the ENGINE, not the game. The game itself is what's being called out. If they made a source game with different models and class system no one would have complained. But Xunlei did and the damage was done.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@Lightscribe225 You too seem to be confusing morals with THE LAW. You are failed when plagiarizing because you aren't proving you learned anything, not because it's illegal.
And what damage? How can you financially impact a free to play game?
TheMaskedTomato 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato Because you are taking the IP of someone else, claiming it as your own, and distributing it. Which is plagiarism, which is considered fraud, which is illegal. See where I'm going with this?
And no, if I was confusing morals and law, then there would be no need for plagiarism to be recorded in a police record, which it is. You are thinking about cheating. I'm talking about directly taking someone else's published work and saying it was your idea.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato Because you are taking the IP of someone else, claiming it as your own, and distributing it. Which is plagiarism, which is considered fraud, which is illegal. See where I'm going with this?
And no, if I was confusing morals and law, then there would be no need for plagiarism to be recorded in a police record, which it is. You are thinking about cheating. I'm talking about directly taking someone else's published work and saying it was your idea.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato Like I said, if Xunlei simply used it as a basis for their new game, then replaced the animations, skins, map layouts, weapon mechanics, and class system, they would be fine. But the fact stands they aren't. And judging by the website, they aren't planning to.
And a f2p game can still turn a profit, which also compounds to my earlier statement that they are using Valve's work for their own gain. I don't know where you come from, but in most of the world, that is illegal.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@Lightscribe225 Not only does China have very relaxed copyright laws, but unless Xunlei charges for the game what they're doing isn't in any way criminal. Is it morally wrong? That's your opinion. But plagiarism is not inherently criminal in any way whatsoever. And Valve didn't invent class systems you fucking moron.
And if Valve really cared about people stealing their shit they wouldn't make it open source. Hell, I doubt Valve even cares.
TheMaskedTomato 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato Okay now you are just looking stupid by bring stuff like "fucking moron" to a debate. If it isn't inherently criminal, then why don't you prove me wrong, record an episode of some TV show, and post it on your channel, unedited in any way at all, and see how quickly it gets removed.
Again you aren't listening, the ENGINE is open source, and every game that ever used it credited Valve for it. Vampire bloodlines credited it to Valve. Vindictus credited it to Valve.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato And no Valve did not invent the class system. I never said that, I have no idea where you got that. What Valve made were the class mechanics that are being used in Final Combat (Rocket using the Soldier's loadout, Fatman the Heavy's loadout), and worse, they are using the same skins. And it does not matter whether or not you charge for it. If you are distributing a product someone else made, WITHOUT crediting them, it is still criminal.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@TheMaskedTomato I'll say it as many times as I have to, plagiarism, is theft of intellectual property, and perjury all wrapped up into a nice little package called fraud. Ever notice how some youtube videos are removed because of copyright infringement? Yeah, the law in action. Not some morally outraged person.
Lightscribe225 5 months ago
@6thhokagephil It's a Chinese company, Valve can't sue.
MrCheapSunglasses 4 months ago
@6thhokagephil "Hi guys I dont like video games and am glad if a company sues another company, I also have a retarded naruto name because I am 12"
u mad?
flatronl1915SLG 4 months ago
@flatronl1915SLG I don't think so. I stopped caring about this a while ago. Troll harder btw
6thhokagephil 4 months ago
是說他剛選火箭兵後的無敵樣式 3:15秒
cortana711 6 months ago
Oh my, I think of chinese people little better now
dimserr 6 months ago
A well said comparison. And extra win for the The Producers! :D
sightswiftlifter 6 months ago
12:18 this copied Killing Floor,what the f***
katetem11 6 months ago 4
koth_harvest
katetem11 6 months ago
rip or not.. I'm quiet curious to see the spy
Yenaboi 6 months ago
It's copied off of the game Killing Floor. look it up
fleskhjerta3 6 months ago
Oh, yes, by the way: The dial on the Flamethrower is from Killing Floor.
RedShocktrooperRST 6 months ago
大冲鋒中的狙擊手的胸部會彈上彈下的:D
sampos 6 months ago
那油錶噴火器是抄襲知名大作遊戲HALO1是也!
pig12452 6 months ago
idk what he says but preeetty clear on his thoughts about that sniper gun lol great vid, been wantin to see this game for once.. Really isn't all that the same, my idea is that the people will play whats best.
djiminezgamer 6 months ago
@djiminezgamer Press the CC button and be amazed. :p
Excellent video btw, uploader is my hero!
Karnaj 6 months ago
A well done comparison video to expose this shameless rip for what it is. Good job!
SilentForceX 6 months ago
NICE
s9021305a 6 months ago
Meet the shittest rip-off in history...
ToxicLewin 6 months ago 2
據說在迅雷官網裡戳破謊言的會員帳號都被砍了。
aax20583 7 months ago
@aax20583 我上了迅雷官網看看,很多說大衝鋒山寨tf2的會員都被禁言或砍帳
ghostmw8 7 months ago
ripoff from battlefield heroes aswell D:<
TheLazycatProduction 7 months ago