Brilliant - took me away from here for nearly 12 minutes! Anyone know the name of the trumpet player and whether the famous horn line was originally scored or improvised?
Hey, buddy, I've listened to the original version played by The Undisputed Truth and I guess it's more beautiful. I don't like covers since in general the cover band MURDERS the original version (that's to say, it changes everything). Anyway, The Temptations' one is okay. (GILBERTO SAUGEN do Brasil)
For all comments on my post where I 've found a lot of informations about the Undisputed Truth records and nice comments about the 11.51 version I thanks all of you
@roland0166 Thats what I have it on. It made my day when I found it. Was proper chuffed, spring in me step, etc. etc. Cost me 2 quid and a bacon roll at a carboot sale. XD
Actually, cmulwee001, there IS a compilation called PSYCHEDELIC SOUL. It covers the period of '68-73, and has the full album versions. As far as calling it a "cover" song, that's kind of debatable. It wasn't written or produced by The Temptations or The Undisputed Truth. Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong wrote it, and many of the songs of the day (not just Motown) where given to other artists. In the case of Temtations/Undisputed Truth, it's the same musicians & both are produced by Whitfield
All I know is that The Undisputed Truth's version came out in either January or February of 1972. It did fine on the R&B charts. but petered out at number 68 on the pop charts. The more well known Temptations version came out later that year in either October or November and was a huge hit.
The Temps and TUT did a LOT of the same songs. Besides this one there was "Ball Of Confusion" and "Smiling Faces(sometimes)"
I guess Whitfield wanted to milk it for all it was worth to make hits
@cmulwee001 I've not only I love listen to the music, but I'm also fascinated by the story behind the music, it makes you wonder if that what they say about their father is true or not, knowingly he's no longer there to defend himself. Neither of The Temptations ever said he was bad or good. I've never got a chance to see my dad either. I've seen the movie The Temptations.
@sandralawson18 I've never got a chance to see my father either, I was very young when he died. And sometimes mothers got habit of poisoning their children minds about their fathers, knowingly he's not there. Now, they all have to guess if he's bad or good, that's a pretty shame.
The song was first recorded by The Undisputed Truth. It didn't chart. But when it was handed over to The Temps, Neither Berry Gordy nor the two guys who wrote the song had ANY clue that lead singer Dennis Edwards' father really DID die on the 3rd of September, yet Dennis had to sing that line anyway, at least that's how it was depicted in the Temptations movie. Don't know how accurate the movie was though
@cmulwee001 I can easily relate to Dennis Edwards, because I've never a chance to
meet my father, either. I was very young myself when he died. I've hear all the bad things about Dennis Edwards's Father, but what about the good things about his father. I'm pretty sure he's not all that bad, as they claim It seems like the kids are doing the mostly bad mouthing about Dennis Edwards's father, knowingly he's not even there. I would be upset too. I don't know. I wasn't there.
It's high time this full length version got release on a Temptations "Greatest hits" or "Best Of", or "The Essential" collection. So far all greatest hits or best of have used the 6:57 single version. This complete 12 minute version is way better. BTW did any of you know that this song was originally recorded by The Undisputed Truth?. Yes, this huge hit song for the Temps is a cover version. A lot of people don't know that.
@cmulwee001 Hey, man, where can I hear this version of PAPA WAS A ROLLING STONE you've mentioned (played by The Undisputed Truth)? Can you post it here? ( GILBERTO SAUGEN from Brazil)
Well it is already here(not by me of course) on You Tube. Type in The Undisputed Truth, and then "Papa Was A Rolling Stone. The Undisputed Truth original is a MUCH shorter song, only about 3 and a half minutes(unless it's a single edit. But then
when Motown Execs decided that The Temps do a cover, they made it into a 12 minute epic. Even the single version is long, about 6 and a half minute. A local station where I live made their own edit of the Temps version, barely 3 minutes if that
@cmulwee001 Here's something for you; The Undisputed Truth originally recorded ''PWARS'', Temptations cover it. The Undisputed Truth's biggest hit. ''Smiling Faces Sometimes'' was first recorded by guess who... The Temptations! Talk about irony.
Epic Thanks for posting.
thefeepy 3 hours ago
Doesn't matter what color you are, if you lived in any intercity you knew this music thats how we rolled back in the day
Damon98335 4 days ago
Temptations...Forever
2916316 4 days ago
O U T STANDING! thank you.
NormusJohnson88 5 days ago
Brilliant - took me away from here for nearly 12 minutes! Anyone know the name of the trumpet player and whether the famous horn line was originally scored or improvised?
janquen 5 days ago
the guy who sang lead to this nearly refused to sing it cause it was really the day his daddy died
wcwnumber1fan 1 week ago
@wcwnumber1fan his name is Dennis Edwards, whose tenure with the Temptations launched them in a different direction.
rboflutz55 6 days ago
GOD DAMN! THE INTRO ALONE BABY! BLACK POWER!
HATEswag 1 week ago
Sweet!
MichaelaRed1 2 weeks ago
a 4 minute intro and a 12 minute version wow you won't find anything better..gets top marks
OMVC1957 2 weeks ago 16
Is there away of uploading it in 720p HD? The audio quality would be far better on youtube. Very nice version of this awesome song though!
tschouschai 3 weeks ago
i use to listen to this song...when i drive with my car at night. pure awesomeness
TheFirstGroover 4 weeks ago
fantastica for ever!!
spanishguitarfan1 1 month ago
142-0
clovisisabeast 1 month ago
125 likes 0 dislikes.. That's how i like it
RuhatOnder1 1 month ago
mine was a magician he just up and dissappeared
winnerdonna 1 month ago
@winnerdonna
mate, thats comedy gold.
N15gooner 4 weeks ago
@winnerdonna mine was a statistician, but we could never count on him
IndependentGeorge76 2 weeks ago
Hey, buddy, I've listened to the original version played by The Undisputed Truth and I guess it's more beautiful. I don't like covers since in general the cover band MURDERS the original version (that's to say, it changes everything). Anyway, The Temptations' one is okay. (GILBERTO SAUGEN do Brasil)
gsaugen 3 months ago
Comment removed
TheLiltre10 3 months ago
Great Timeless Classic!
marcorestivo82 3 months ago
The all-time greatest rhythm & blues hit ever! Nothing compares to this long version of "Papa......"!
JackKangaroo1 4 months ago
THUMB UP IF YOU SKIPPED TO 4:00 MINUTES
52jee 4 months ago
Hvala na pravoj verziji. Opasna stvar!
biljana2003979 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
youtube.com/watch?v=EhMT7NV6slw listen my cover guys and tell me your opinion!!! : ) hope you like it!!!
MaRiOs0888 4 months ago
went to the kitchen grabbed a cold beer came back without missing a beat
MrElbivisdetijuas 5 months ago 3
THE ALMIGHTY TEMPTATIONS...THE BEST SONG EVER WRITTEN XXXXXXX
Somme1916Somme 5 months ago 2
Inigualable, espectacular, Temptations uno de mis grupos favoritos hasta el final de la música.
mymanny2009 6 months ago
Turn it up!!!
sjr10011 7 months ago
cant g0 2 bed with this 0n! rewind!!!!
clearview360x 8 months ago
For all comments on my post where I 've found a lot of informations about the Undisputed Truth records and nice comments about the 11.51 version I thanks all of you
TSQD01 10 months ago 3
me encanto ,y nunca dejo de escucharla ,melodia acordes y sonido espectaculares uno de mis favoritos de temptations.
therosacl 10 months ago
ive been rockin/funkin out to this all night.too amazing.
thehoff37 10 months ago
The original version of this song was about 12 minutes long on their "All Directions" album, released in 1972.
roland0166 11 months ago
@roland0166 Thats what I have it on. It made my day when I found it. Was proper chuffed, spring in me step, etc. etc. Cost me 2 quid and a bacon roll at a carboot sale. XD
samwisethree 10 months ago
The original version of this song was on their "All Directions" album, released in 1972.
roland0166 11 months ago
The original version of this song was on their "All Directions" album.
roland0166 11 months ago
I love that song, was surprised to find a 12 min` version ..
thank you!
Hmen234 1 year ago
Comment removed
Hmen234 1 year ago
Actually, cmulwee001, there IS a compilation called PSYCHEDELIC SOUL. It covers the period of '68-73, and has the full album versions. As far as calling it a "cover" song, that's kind of debatable. It wasn't written or produced by The Temptations or The Undisputed Truth. Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong wrote it, and many of the songs of the day (not just Motown) where given to other artists. In the case of Temtations/Undisputed Truth, it's the same musicians & both are produced by Whitfield
bgbrezniak 1 year ago
@bgbrezniak
All I know is that The Undisputed Truth's version came out in either January or February of 1972. It did fine on the R&B charts. but petered out at number 68 on the pop charts. The more well known Temptations version came out later that year in either October or November and was a huge hit.
The Temps and TUT did a LOT of the same songs. Besides this one there was "Ball Of Confusion" and "Smiling Faces(sometimes)"
I guess Whitfield wanted to milk it for all it was worth to make hits
cmulwee001 1 year ago
@cmulwee001 I've not only I love listen to the music, but I'm also fascinated by the story behind the music, it makes you wonder if that what they say about their father is true or not, knowingly he's no longer there to defend himself. Neither of The Temptations ever said he was bad or good. I've never got a chance to see my dad either. I've seen the movie The Temptations.
sandralawson18 1 month ago
@sandralawson18 I've never got a chance to see my father either, I was very young when he died. And sometimes mothers got habit of poisoning their children minds about their fathers, knowingly he's not there. Now, they all have to guess if he's bad or good, that's a pretty shame.
sandralawson18 1 month ago
@sandralawson18
The song was first recorded by The Undisputed Truth. It didn't chart. But when it was handed over to The Temps, Neither Berry Gordy nor the two guys who wrote the song had ANY clue that lead singer Dennis Edwards' father really DID die on the 3rd of September, yet Dennis had to sing that line anyway, at least that's how it was depicted in the Temptations movie. Don't know how accurate the movie was though
cmulwee001 1 month ago
@cmulwee001 I can easily relate to Dennis Edwards, because I've never a chance to
meet my father, either. I was very young myself when he died. I've hear all the bad things about Dennis Edwards's Father, but what about the good things about his father. I'm pretty sure he's not all that bad, as they claim It seems like the kids are doing the mostly bad mouthing about Dennis Edwards's father, knowingly he's not even there. I would be upset too. I don't know. I wasn't there.
sandralawson18 1 month ago
It's high time this full length version got release on a Temptations "Greatest hits" or "Best Of", or "The Essential" collection. So far all greatest hits or best of have used the 6:57 single version. This complete 12 minute version is way better. BTW did any of you know that this song was originally recorded by The Undisputed Truth?. Yes, this huge hit song for the Temps is a cover version. A lot of people don't know that.
cmulwee001 1 year ago 14
@cmulwee001 just found that out on wikipedia before i came on to listen to it here.
thehoff37 10 months ago
@cmulwee001 Hey, man, where can I hear this version of PAPA WAS A ROLLING STONE you've mentioned (played by The Undisputed Truth)? Can you post it here? ( GILBERTO SAUGEN from Brazil)
gsaugen 3 months ago
@gsaugen
Well it is already here(not by me of course) on You Tube. Type in The Undisputed Truth, and then "Papa Was A Rolling Stone. The Undisputed Truth original is a MUCH shorter song, only about 3 and a half minutes(unless it's a single edit. But then
when Motown Execs decided that The Temps do a cover, they made it into a 12 minute epic. Even the single version is long, about 6 and a half minute. A local station where I live made their own edit of the Temps version, barely 3 minutes if that
cmulwee001 3 months ago
@gsaugen In fact if you look at the related videos on the side panel The Undisputed Truth's original should be there.
cmulwee001 3 months ago
@cmulwee001 Here's something for you; The Undisputed Truth originally recorded ''PWARS'', Temptations cover it. The Undisputed Truth's biggest hit. ''Smiling Faces Sometimes'' was first recorded by guess who... The Temptations! Talk about irony.
infernokid1990 2 months ago
Thanks TSQD01 . Good souvenirs. After 40 years still one of the best .
tolucawood 1 year ago 31
A brilliant Masterpiece of soul. Perfect groove, vocals.....soul...yeah...Masterpiece.
TigerRocket 1 year ago 3
I've been looking for the complete version of this song! Thanks for putting it up!
cmulwee001 1 year ago 4