Added: 3 months ago
From: MotorTrend
Views: 101,650
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (687)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • imo passat's a good choice

  • i think i cn do better than theses guys...i believe

  • whats that shitty sonic doing in there?

  • And its really a joke that a Passat wins over an Chrysler. I mean the Chrysler is 10 times better on every level ecxept fuel economy.

  • Best car for me Chevrolet Camaro or Cadillac CTS.

  • What's with the shitty reality TV music at 1:08?

  • I think the chrysler 300 stills the best

  • an i miev doing a quater mile..thats 20 mins of the this vid right there.. 42s to cover the rest is ambitious

  • ironicaly enough, you would have to pay me to drive these 2 "best cars" daily.

  • Proof that Americans knows absolutely nothing about cars !!!

  • @sheep44644 too bad that a few people at a british publishing company don't represent the entire American population...

  • i like ..like poll

  • VW: Lowered quality to drop prices.

    Chrysler: Improved cars in every aspect.

    VW wins car of the year.

  • Geez Angus, you still don't know how to pronounce Hyundai?

  • @11:38 It feels like an Indian Car? Jaguar and Land Rover are Indian cars. So are Mahindra and Tata SUVs which don't just work in the city but off the road as well. Racist @#$%

  • @Abcdef1797 are you retarded? Jaguar and Land Rover are English cars, dude? some of the best

  • @heemoii Jaguary and Landrover are under Indian ownership since 2008. If you haven't had access to news since then in the asylum, I am sorry for you.

  • @Abcdef1797 that doesnt make them any different in the real world. if you hadn't noticed, but since 2009, jags have been evolving into real rivals for the germans, if you havent had new to that since then, I am srry for you

  • @heemoii If I buy a printer, the printed material belongs to me. Similarly, if Jag and LR are under Indian Ownership, they are Indian cars. The reason why it makes a difference "in the real world" is because, as you said. From 2009 they have evolved into rivals for Germans, because since 2008(!) They are Indian Cars. Without that ownership, they would close down as SAAB did, IN THE REAL WORLD. If Indians had purchased SAAB it too would improve over time and next year compete wid Germans

  • these guys are obviously stupid lol the chrysler got secound? HOLY SHIT looking at it you, know it will be a bad car to drive/park and shit on fuel since its so heavy. fail motortrends.. fail. Secoundaly the dodge is good at handerling? u ever driven a bmw 3 series before? It wil handle 5000x better. Clueless people:) o well bies judges.

  • Screw all the negative comments there is only one thing that stands out to me....theses guys have the best jobs in the world..

  • Whr is Toyota Avalon or Nissan maxima, Altima

  • Car fans, youd think theyre all females becaus of the non stop bithcing and moaning like theyre on their periods.

    benchracing morons.

  • Fucking bullshit.

  • american cars are always going to be crap at handling till the either stop using leaf springs or let lotus do it for them

  • since when americans can understand the European cars?all the american cars are feeling heavy ,loud,big consumer,high engine and less torque,no innovation,no safety,no feedback,no handling,i mean are like Pamela Anderson...quite plastical modified!!!

  • fuck that i would have a 300C any day over a passat

  • Comment removed

  • American cars are geting better at handing hell ya...

  • soooo motortrend..... Where are the Mitsubishi Evo and the Subaru WRX STI?

  • where is the chevy Volt???

  • @tarigrs It won last year... I think some would be disturbed if it won 2 years in a row.

  • seriously?

  • Indian Car?? at 11:45 WTF.. Indian Cars are far better than GM cars.

  • We got a leaf :D 90+ miles easy!

  • 20 min of my life im never going to get back. I really think that that could of been judge differently

  • quite an impression? 3:31 no facial expressions lol

  • @DJR3PUBLIK Yeah... That was a joke....

  • you know what is sur prising is that none of the finalists are suvs or minivans. If you have 8 children what gives you the thought of buying a nissan leaf of chrysler 300? At least have one suv

  • @MrPorschecrm thats what suv of the year is for

  • All I've read about the 2012 Impreza is that it's an incredible new car..and yet the Sonic made it through past it?

    MT I am disappoint. Recommending a Passat as car of the year? have you ever looked at..I dunno..reliability surveys? the Germans dominate the lowest end of those charts being unreliable over priced piles of unreliable junk.

    Easy conclusion, car of the year should have been a; Ford, Crysler/dodge/jeep, Subaru, Toyota or Honda.

    You guys are nuts.

  • @SubaruHyena Reliability surveys are a joke, VW made one model which was dreadfull on reliability and it's the MK3 Golf/Jetta, 1993-1998. (I know, i have one, but wouldnt change it for anything less than a Quattro Audi)

    Name me one major flaw of any other model, except the coilpacks on 1.8T which is now fixed. Can you ?

    Problem is people heard the mk3 was unreliable, so now they think every vw ever made is unreliable..

  • @daver18qc Actually it's not just the Mk III golf that I've heard was unreliable, it's all the new Jetta, Passat and Tiguan(sp) models. People have a 2009 Passat that's been nothing but trouble, our Jetta has been a nightmare maintenance wise (all covered under warranty) two doors up the neighbors own a tuareg that's had tons of problems. Also every reliability survey I've looked at from 2008-2011 puts VW last.

    Not to mention test drives with things leaking or broken already.

  • @SubaruHyena Well i'm on 2 of the biggest north-america vw forums and there is not alot of problems in the mk5-mk6 section. Some paint problems because of the winter and the salt mainly. Anyway, as they say in the ad, "Are you made for volkswagen?" If not then it's more for me :D

  • the scion iq thing...or, Toyota IQ in the European/English World, is to small for American's? one of the idiots there was on about new rear crash standards...hmmm, considering the Euro NCAP has a higher pass standard than the American Equivalent, and the little IQ got 4 or 5 stars, then I dont see what he's on about, some people need to learn about the cars they're driving before making that kind of statement...that is all

  • how the hell was that hunk Chev Sonic make it that far?

  • they should do car of the year by class category. this made no sense whatsoever. whats the point in naming car of the year when you are comparing cars from $8000 to $100000 range.

  • @TheNipommu agree, i should be the winner of the best value for the money

  • Porque todo estadunidense adora chupar a própria rola?! O cara falando que o Charger foi "feito para aquilo", aquele carro é um lixo em curva e nego ainda fica impressionado. Foda.

  • wow, the #1 car is german garbage that will most likely have expensive problems later, and the runner up is a turd on wheels... i mean dodge.

  • conformist car the winner, whodathunkit?

  • anyone know what that red merc was?

  • OLD USELESS BITCHES

  • Rather narrow Minded group of men.Still good job.

  • 17:20 The American James may?

  • Save your time, go to 19:40 for the answer!

  • "its less dumb than Smart but its iQ still doesnt break the teens." hhahahaha i died

  • 3:27 dude is unfazed

  • id take a 300 over the VW

  • all i heard was chrysler...chrysler....chrysle­r, not biased at all

  • lame

  • Shouldn't this be 2011? As far as I know we're only 2 month into 2012..

  • where is the chevy cruze??

  • Anyone heard about a brand called INFINITI ??!!!

  • @dr7asans yes

  • The 300 should've one. Too bad they didn't do a "Will I look like a faggot when I drive it?" test.

  • PASSAT! That piece of problems!?! Jesus. Motor Trend.. unlike.

  • 300 should of won it

  • My car has a blinde spot warning system. It's called N.E.C.K

  • @fiatch500 i had a driving job once and the woman in charge of safety told me not to turn my head and look but only use the mirrors and when i told her she was wrong she wanted to argue with me

  • This is what happens when you don't take into consideration psychological group pressure.

  • ¿Passat? ¡WTF!

  • A dodge made for handling?? Ever drove another car?

  • @Tmozarela He must have confused it with the viper acr ; )

  • I'm reading the comments on this video and honestly, most of the comments are made by total idiots.

  • I wish there were more exciting performance cars involved in this... It seems like the contest was solely based on grabbing the attention of the average Joe and thus pleasing him with the average Joe of cars... But I can still see a lot of hard work went into making the video so well done. Just include some cars that incite the blood to pump a little faster, eh?

  • @petrolhead229 You are entirely missing the point of car of the year.

  • @petrolhead229 this is car of the year, I think they also have performance car of the year if that's what you're looking for ;-)

  • No Bugatti Veyron SS? What a loada bull.

  • This instant runoff balloting is bullshit. Passat is a nice car but it aint no 300.

  • I'm beginning to doubt the creditably of motor trend, I have to be serious here the passat is a good car, but if you put together all of its faults and greats i feel as if the faults some outweigh the greats on it. I like VW but I dont like how their extremely hard to upkeep! The TDi are reliable only if they are upkept well, but a passat? no no no this car is not as reliable as its TDi brothers or matter of fact as efficient! if you were going for bland why not something more accord or Camryish

  • although testing was great, standardized and what not but man, they have massive error in selection. and where the fuck are the jeep wrangler and other significant cars

  • @Jasshands1 they have test for SUV's and what not, just look it up on youtube, this is car of the year, not SUV of the year or whatever else

  • Hahaha I didn't even watch that vid, but skip to end looking for a winner come to find out its Sludge machine vs sludge monster....these guys are wacked honestly of all the real cars out there, too funny.

  • i think i speak for alot of people when i say,

    the quality of production is great,

    but the outcome of the result is shit.

  • Haha, Chrysler 300 or the VW Passat... Think I'd rather just opt out, and buy an Alfa or a Jag.

  • well, that's democracy. but i would no more buy a passat then I would a chrysler product.

  • Nope, I don't think so!! A7 would not be a bad choise

  • The COTY has been a wise purchase by their respective manufacturers for years.

  • lol this made me laugh. Charger made for cornering. chrylser 300 and passat in top. wtf is wrong with people at motortrend.

  • charger "made for cornering".. what the.....

  • I guess that's what happens when you rate on averages.... You get the most bland car possible.

  • @Kryxtal makes sense..since average = nothing special..:D

  • when the chrysler 300 is one of the well placed contenders i know something is wrong in here.

  • They have messed up their by being too dramatic in presenting this video and also the way they have chosen cars seems really odd Mercedes C63 compared to a electric car not to a M3!

  • motor trend, I am cancelling my subscribtion! Question to the judges: how many cars do you really own, or do you just work for a car company.

  • I spend 20 minutes of my life checking this video just fot the passat was the chosen one! FUUUUCK

  • If you think about it what the hell is a Passat anyways?

  • Mercedes c classs is the best

  • Are you kidding guys. What is the Passat good for? It delivers nothing. Its a car for idiots.

  • Passat ... nice car, well built. I can only agree. A lot of fanboys here won't, though.

  • 2012 Volkswagen Passat. EYYUUUCCCKKK

  • Comment removed

  • OK really the Passat, the plainest car there. They must be smoking something!!

  • What a bunch of fucking twats, how do you look at all the cars out today and say the Passat is the best. Enjoy your nazi maintenance-nightmare mobile.

  • cocaine is a hell of a drug

  • wow Volkswagen won wow it sucks

  • passat isnt a bad car the cars are chosen for what is best car to drive on a day to day basis.

  • That would be an amazing job!

  • Resume in 3 words: Incredibly fucking boring.

  • In almost every comment I read people are saying this review is shit. I completely disagree. Everybody is different in what they want as a car. All motor trend is saying is that for your money the passat is better. sure you may think it's a gay car but come on guys. It's a great little car. Would I ever buy one? Hell no I wouldn't but that's just me. Everybody is different.

  • @11:39 F*&%$ U it sounds like an indian car you dirty yank!

  • no Daihatsu?????

  • only one can be motor trends car of the year... who cares,i don't buy cause your shit rag says a pussat is the car of the year.... a pussat???

  • passat? lmao

  • i knew motor trend is shit ...but now i have lost all respect for them...and will never read or watch their crap again...

  • motor trend is always a joke....their reviews are the worst...

  • pretty boring vid.. culdnt even last 4mins.. porn time

  • and that's why everybody likes Top Gear UK

  • much to many cars to choose from ... confusing

  • wow...that was painful to listen to that forced humor

  • 3:32 that guy doesn't seem too excited...

  • TO EVERYONE ON HERE..... u mad bro?

    Of course there's no real way to pick a car that will please everybody, but if you value the opinion of the source (I do) then you wouldn't have a real reason to go against them, and if you dont care about their opinion then fuck em.

  • Paused at 0:01 - now I'm going to guess they pick either something American or (this being motortrend) some economy car.

  • why weigh and calibrate when its done by the manufacturer

  • Wow... tie b/w a 4k lb tank that looks like shit and one of the worst looking VW sedans ever. My dad has a VW CC (passat coupe) and I can tell you that my Mazdaspeed 3 feels better made, from the way the doors shut to the overall interior despite the harder materials used, and lets not talk about performance. From the top cars they picked, the Audi A6 looked like the best pick

  • I vote Ford Mustang for car of the year! but that's just me ; D

  • what a fuckin joke

  • So who would rather have a passat over a C63??

    anybody, so thats 100% percent of the people would rather own a C63

  • Everybody should have their own car of the year. We are Human Beings with the usual bias. I'm pretty sure I Wasn't the only person who decided what in the world was the Passat the winner for 2012 Car of the year. I Will admit that there were a few cars that should have been here... 2012 Nissan GT-R (Which won car of the year in 2009), Atleast SOME Cadillac, etc. You don't have to listen to these people to win your heart over this car because it's COTY. No... I'll stand by and make my own COTY!

  • Surely the Range Rover Evoke must be in the top 53? it cant stop winning awards in the UK, and even if its not good enough to warrant the awards it gets, i'm 110% sure there are not 53 better from the last year?

  • Clearly Motor Trend Car of the Year does not mean car that an auto enthusiast would want.

    Given that small list the 300 in SRT form would be the winner. How anyone in their right mind could put the Leaf in their top 10 list is beyond me.

  • I was excited the whole time and almost favorited this video, until I heard him say the Passat is the car of the year......(?)

  • What about the CTS-V or the ZR1 or the ZL1 or the GT500 Jepp GC SRT8 ?? the new GTR i know some of them are not new but u guys haven't tested it with these cars before ?

  • @chveymadnic

    It's not about which cars can smoke eachother on the quarter-mile or which can tear up the dyno test the best, it's just about the most reliable city car that the average road goer  could buy.

  • wtf between 53 cars they chose vw passat? who are these people

  • @mohammadazizeddin american, you never understand...

    

  • @mohammadazizeddin the big deal about the 2012 Passat is: 1 - it's made in USA at a time when real unemployment is over 20% and America is bleeding its last manufacturing jobs. and 2 - it is several grand cheaper than the old passat at a time when people are up to their eyeballs in debt. the judges made a wise decision. if the question was "best car" the winner would have to be a Porsche or a BMW but the question was "car of the year" ...

  • @mohammadazizeddin Thanks for saving me 20min

  • @mohammadazizeddin Professionals, that's who

    

  • @mohammadazizeddin americans

  • @mohammadazizeddin They are journalist that were paid by VW...

  • @mohammadazizeddin People who get paid very well by VW maybe!!!! :D

  • @mohammadazizeddin Because for price, and features and overall in all categories the Passat does the best job. I agree, I drove one and love it.

  • @mohammadazizeddin They put the names in a bucket and pull one. Thats how Motortrend works nowadays.

  • @mohammadazizeddin clever people

  • 300 is better

  • @fighthardnow tell me you are american... 300 is coffin on wheels....

  • lol, fuckin americans.

  • 3:28 "...made quite an impression", nice impression shown on his face...

  • A Passat? Really? Volkswagen isn't really impressive.

  • these people have no taste

  • the system they use to vote is extremely stupid

  • Comment removed

  • What Car won last year? It was the Chevy Volt wasn't it?

  • What a boring presentation.

  • 4:15 seriously MT? You thought a minivan would be a possible winner? F A I L ...and to the rest of you keyboard warriors, someday in the future (maybe) you'll realize how stupid it is to fight on the internet. smh

  • Masculine and VW Bettle just doesn't mix...

  • HONDA CIVIC SI!!!

  • I highly doubt they put reliability as a category. Chrysler in general has made unreliable cars in the past and present, with the exception of the RAM. If I'm correct, Chrysler vehicles received below average reliability scores. Same as German cars, with the exception of Porsche coupes and convertibles. Sure Germans can make downright luxurious cars, but you try and put 200k on the engine and transmission; it's just NOT going to work. 

  • I'm somewhat surprised that a US organisation shows this level of 'protectionism' of the local car industry, very brave, and thanks for the honesty.

  • The documentary was GREAT. But the whole event was terribly executed.

  • This is the problem with electric cars. They can't even hold a charge to compete on the same level as conventional gas or diesel engine. Honestly, until if/when this is even happens, they shouldn't even be tested. Electric cars are a joke. I'm holding out for more diesels and hydrogen cars.

  • "im not too sure if these carbon breaks work" oh god thats amazing... lol

  • Epic Fail

    

  • god sometimes i really cant stand Americans "if they sell that iq here they better change the rear safety" like only Americans are worth saving in a crash how does the rest of the world cope!!! I know lots of americans and they honestly believe the rest of the world live in mud huts or something, idiots

  • @jonny5777 no, we have a different driving environment here in America. everything is a lot more open and bigger in terms of design and spacing. a rear impact in the streets of london is gonna be different than a rear impact in the streets of los angeles or new york. he isnt being a snob, hes confronting the reality of it. you, on the other hand, are being ignorant.

  • @maximus9401 thanks for your reply i don't believe i was being ignorant as I have driven in all 3 cities and as far as i am aware the car isn't solely sold to city dwellers and a rear impact is the same no matter what side of the atlantic you are on. Americans do believe they are better than people in other countries you may not but a lot do, why else would you have a world series of baseball and not invite the world?

  • @jonny5777 I hope you realize that no matter where you go, you will always find people who think they are better than others. collectively, as I think you'd agree, much of the world hates Americans. so that's the whole world thinking they're better than us because they don't like the way we do things. yes, most Americans are ignorant about how people in other countries live, so they seem stupid. but then again, so does everyone else in their own respective countries.

  • @jonny5777 as for the world series....come on, America has large quantities of people from all over the world living there. technically, you can be American and from anywhere, so the world is invited. but yes, that choice of name is really dumb.

  • 300 All day long.