Talk about a nerdwar. Its actually a bit sad that i actually allready know all the details of both worlds, being my two favroite scifi things.
Ignoring questions of weapons, the real war is Ascended powers vs Force. As vader said, somthing along the lines of "Fuck your puny death star, i can choke you with my mind."
For one Cobalt, An ISD's Quad Turbo Lasers can fire 200 Gigaton blasts per shot, and is armed with several batteries all of which can be fired at the same time. It was also stated that The Deadalus's weapons cannot penetrate Neutronium which the ISD's use for armor in the form of Durasteel. No ship for Gate would stand a chance.
@NANOFORGE I'm not why you addressed this to me so late, but anyway, at no point was it said that a beam weapon or nuke cannot penetrate neutronium. The only thing they've failed at damaging critically was the Wraith superhive. Besides that, if they have the computer core to create Replicators, they can just unleash them on the empire and hit the self-destruct button a few months later. Fighting the empire would be good for them, they'd be able to increase their fleet.
@CobaltX07 Ah sorry if this was late. I agree with you that Star Trek ships are at the ass end of this. The Deadalus's Nukes are in the Gigatons and would blow a Trek ship up instanly as they can only take a few dozen Megatons. Star Wars is at the top end, The Acclamator class destroyer can take 360.000 Gigatons and the Mrkii ISD can take over 3 times as much as that. It would take over 300,000 Trek photons to get through an Acclamators shields.
@NANOFORGE I ran a similar calculation showing that even 3,000,000 photons wouldn't scratch the Ori. Granted this implies we take Carter's word that Prometheus can do at least half the speed of light and assume that ha'tak speeds are appropriately adjusted appropriately on screen, still Stargate shields can take alot of punishment, possible the only Sci-Fi TV-show that can take Star Wars ICS (which some people don't accept) punishment, but it all really depends on how you scale their weapons.
@CobaltX07 I agree on that, Star Gate is the only fictional universe that could take on Wars. The Deadalus's shields have taken planet pulverizing punishment before. Each of her nukes are 1.02 Gigatons each and many can be fired at once. Those Nukes only caused minimal damage to Wraith ships while Asgard weapons destroyed them with 3 shots. That would make Asgard weapons several thousand times more powerful than a single nuke. Ori Ships were one of the most powerful types of Gate ship aswell.
@NANOFORGE lol this is kinda epic but note that 'drones' are not affected by shields. Aurora-class ship with it's arsenall full of drones can kill like almost all ships u have seen in all the 6 Starwars movies. XD
well yea not that much but Aurora-class ships are like imortal with ZPM's and drones...
@GODWARS2 Yeah Drones can slice through anything. The Deadauls's Asgard Plasma weapons kill Wraith hives with ease too and Wraith haives take minimal damage to Gigaton rated Nukes. Star Gate could take Star Wars. However their are some universes neither of those two could take, Metroid and Dr Who for example.
You see them. Through out the films that the lasers have a very slow rate of fire. That of a semi auto weapon with the trigger being repeatedly pressed. Rather than fully auto and being held down.
I mean they COULD be fully auto, but the ROF is still horribly slow making for a less effective weapon. Semi auto is okay, it makes for better accuracy but with experience and control fully automatic weapons just throw more bullets at the enemy. Making them extremely deadly.
Sure, while Stargate team has P90s, they still have regular machine guns & pistols which are probably not going to hit their targets when a laser has more range & can go through walls easier making a wall used for cover worthless.
Look at how fast Jango Fett's duel pistols fire. They fire almost as fast as the cannons on his ship
Other "machine guns", as in Assault Rifles, Bull pups, sub machine guns and light machine guns are also very accurate, and also have a high rate of fire.
Also if you are talking about pistols, are you comparing them to the laser pistols in star wars? Because those things are even worse...
The weapons our armies use are very effective. Just because they don't shoot pretty colours like your science fiction doesn't mean they lose in a firefight.
Notice how I didn't mention any of the guns you mentioned besides rifles & pistols.
Once again, you're being silly saying the lasers are worst. Compared to the lasers of the bad guys in STARGATE which you have to charge up, the lasers aren't slow at all. The stormtroopers/ clone troopers blasters/rifles fire rapidly. Look at the battle scene again.
Plus, you keep bringing accuracy into this. Who cares? I guarantee you that Han Solo could kill McGyver in one shot. P90s do shit against snipers
I am talking about real life you moron. A P90 or other ballistic weapons used by our planets armies are better than the lasers and pieces of crap you see in star wars. Read my first reply to you.
I don't think I will since you've resorted to namecalling & are acting immature so now I'm going to politely end this conversation.
You can claim that I pussied out. I don't care, I don't know you personally & I'm honestly in no mood to argue over pointless shit.
You keep saying "our planets" when Stargate is just as fake as Star Wars. Sure, they have real-life weapons but I'm pretty sure there's no wormholes or Gor'Els but I'm done.
GOOD BYE & Thank You for this Unpleasant Conversation.
I never mentioned wormholes. I never mentioned Gor'Els. I said that the weapons we use are most likely superior to what we see in starwars. Yes. I did say our planet, and if you really need me to explain what I was saying, I was referring to the combined armies of earth. You heard of them? US Army, Royal Army and so on. They aren't fake, and our planet isn't either so I can say our planet.
Goodbye, It isn't fun arguing with someone who pretends you said something you didn't.
I just got back to my "computer screen" an hour ago. After doing other stuff through the day. If you're trying to imply I have no life, when I know otherwise and you have no idea. You've failed. This is just a fun waste of time. Finding morons who try and convince people how they are right when they know nothing about what they are arguing.
That wasn't "getting the last word in". That was responding to you saying I know nothing about Star Wars, implying I am talking about star wars as if I know about it. I'm simply informing you I wasn't talking about star wars. Just the lasers in it. Also it's funny how you also want to get the last word in. Hypocrite?
Depends if you take the lasers from the books or from the movies. The lasers from the books will beat a P-90. The lasers from the movies are worse then Col. O'Neill's baretta sidearm and can't hope to compare to the guns currently in use by the modern army. The P-90 with armor piercing rounds might also be superior then some of the book lases because of its sheer rate of fire combined with accuracy. Also, an F-302 or a jumper could take out the Death Star solving that problem.
If I may leave note, a lot of the Stargate ships are actually too small by comparison to Star Wars ships. The Ori Mothership for example is just a few meters larger than a Star Destroyer while the Daedalus class ships are smaller than a Coriellian Corvette.
From what I've heard, these are the lengths: DS2: 900 km diameter DS: (Original): 160 km diameter Executor: 19 km ZPM Hiveship: 14.5-15 km Atlantis: 4.8-5 km Hiveship: 3 km Ori mothership: 1400 meters SD: 1200 meters Mon Cal Cruiser: 1200 meters Ha'tak: 700 meters Daedalus class: 150-250 meters (actual length never stated) Corellian Corvette: 150 meters
Earth would win. Just have to beam some Mark IXs into the Death Star its its bye bye. Then they just have to hunt down the rest of the Empire Fleet until its all destroyed.
stargate ships have cloaking technologies and the stargate itself is superior to any ship as you can muster forces in your own territory before sending an attack.Thats also not to mention ascended beings that are godlike in their power.
Only railguns??? They have beam weapons, 230+ and possibly 800+ gt nuclear weapons, energy pulse weapons, plasma bombs, naquadah bombs, "prior" guns, lightning superweapon (unknown power), 1.2 gt man-portable nukes, ion cannons (different from SW version), drones that can ignore shield and rip through armor (though not anything thicker than 50 m) and and nuclear MIRVs. The SSD would be effective, the DS less so because a 302 can exit hyperspace inside the ship and nuke the main reactor.
@CobaltX07 and all that without divine intervention or assistance from an advanced ally (the Nox, Ancients, what remained of the Asgard, Friendly Wraith, friendly Replicators...)
WOW I just finished reading all these comments and realized one thing everybody missed. Star Wars take place a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away, while Stargate takes place in the present. You are all comparing technology from two different points in time.
Stargate ships have superior shield/weapons and advanced tech. They can go back in time,slows down time,go into alternate universe. Star Wars ships is hopelessly outclassed.
they could only defeat earth by shear numbers if they sent a few ships at atime then with the Tauri ships would kick their asses and wed create more ships and wed win but if they sent theyre entire fleet wed be fucked until our allies came to help
The Empire or any SW race would never be able to completely defeat Earth, because it can phase-cloak itself which makes it invulnerable to everything, apparently, even the ascended.
A interesting fight would be Adria vs. the Emperor or a Wraith ZPM Hive vs the Executor
phase cloack only works for a little while, what if the empire were to capture a stargate, wire it to the firing dish of the death star and instead of firing the beam thrugh space to the earth from orbit, park the death star (which is devoid of civilian contractors) in a seperate system dial earth and fire the death star's beam THROUGH THE STARGATE! the iris would melt instantly, and the beam would come through full blast and the empire would win.
Actually, the phase cloak lasts pretty much indefinitely as long as it's got a power supply (ZPM, artificial singularities, even 2/3 the US power grid will do it).
As for shooting the superlaser through a stargate, chances are they'll blow up the actual gate, even if they don't raw energy and powerful beams always destabilize the wormhole or make it jump rather than coming out the other side,even shot through unshielded, all it would do to a phase-cloaked planet is briefly blind someone.
i disagree, if they were to slowly dial up the output of the superlaser, they could destroy the iris of the receiving gate (earth's) and once they reached a certain threshold the connection could be maintained longer than 38 minutes (like when the Russians dialed that planet with a living ocean or something) and you are assuming that earth once again has access to a zpm, which judging from the way they run through those things on the show last slightly longer than Duracells.
They would still have to take the beam out of phase (which only requires the US power grid or possibly some neutrino ion generators) to the same level as Earth and adjust the DS beam so that the wavelength can get through, since raw energy has been shown to not be able to get through an iris or shield ("48 hours," "Chain Reaction," "Full Circle"). Also, as a last minute precaution, they can just beam the gate into space pointed away from Earth or have a 302 fly it across the solar system.
"Star Gate has advanced technology compared to Star Wars"
Star Gate soldiers still look like present-day SWAT teams. Technology in Star Wars consists of ships (rather than gates that must be working all the time), replicators, making billions of droids, cloning billions of troopers, going faster than the speed of light, being able to destroy a planet or solar system in less than a second, the list goes on.
Like Star Wars, Stargate can destroy planets and solar systems. It can also destroy galaxies. It's ships can cross between them in a matter of weeks or even seconds. Plus, a single SG replicator could bring the entire SW and ST universe, with the exception of those using bioships, to their knees in weeks with their ability to go from 1 to 1 trillion in 2 weeks and to incorporate all tech they come across into their ships, blocks, planets, and bugs. Not to even mention what the ascended would do.
Let's see, there is the Star Forge which means infinite ships. Centerpoint Station than can move and destroy planets like marbles (as well as destroy stars), Sith Lords can pull a sun's core out and use that as a projectile, Sun Crusher can destroy 11 star systems, and the list goes on. Replicators have the problem that kinetic weapons can kill them. It is good they can create different forms, but how would they go up against tons of supernovas?
in star wars there only threat would be the jedi, in star trek there only threat would be the borg. either way star wars and trek (of both who I am also fans to) would be screwed. Jedi are limited in numbers ad the federation would have no or close to no hope as the borg and replicators anniahlate everything in the universe as repliborgs. Lets put it this way, the Emperor and 5th or The Borg Queen and Repli Carter.
The point with the replicators is that they could take over all the Imperial tech. First of all, the human form ones are not vulnerable to kinetic weapons, and can also forcibly take information from Imperial mines. The smaller spider forms would spread throughout the empire. In order to crush the replicatos with supernovas, the Imperials would have to blow up all of their major systems. Plus, the reps would have their own tech to use against them, or they could simply take over a superweapon.
"ever heard of the sun crusher? it destroys solar systems"
It should be...
"ever heard of the sun crusher? it destroys star systems"
Yes, the supernova caused by the first crushed star (by the sun crusher obviously) created a chain reaction of supernovas in surrounding stars...so it destroys star systems.
ya know he did mention the death stars major weapon so get that right and Admiral Ackbar had to a moron to stay in the death stars path when retreating other wise he could have gotten away
If it weren't for that "70's crap" many CGI would probably not be possible. I know Pixar alone was created by Lucas. Lucas is even working hard on his scifi saga to make even more advances in film and what not.
come on star wars is the best. Yes for today the effect is "crap" but they remaster is in the star wars special edition and it preaty good. And image for the 70s it was a big advance in the movie tecnoligie even today they doest make better movie then star wars only fey are good.
De68d, what do you expect from Lucas in the 70s? He is kinda the person who made Pixar, so that means there was better bad graphics for the time. Then, Lucas updated the movies in like a 1994 release on VHS or DVD(I forgot which one).
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Stargate is nothing compared to starwars all it had was one movie although good. Still nothing compared to starwars. Oh also alot of worthless tv series with completly different actors then the movie so yea Stargate was practically destroyed by its tv series IMO.
Well, isn't THAT the stupidest, most idiotic thing I've ever heard.
The only good thing about the Stargate franchise is the original movie. SG-1, it's spinoffs, and its crappy second-rate movies are GARBAGE, and to EVER say they are better than any Star Wars movie shows that you have incredibly bad ****ed up taste.
the prequals were an abomination to all that is good and just in this world and all copies should be either destroyed or edited so that the only remaining scenes are the bits with Samuel L. Jackson and he credits.
stargate has better weponry and shildes specelly with the asgard beming teknologi. and they have allaies that would help them. starwars would onley have a little chanse if theyuse all there ships in one big attack.
If the Asgard were still around Stargate would hold their own ground. If the people in the Ori galaxy were to join in after the Ark of Truth Stargate would be better off than before. But for now it is Star Wars.
star wars and stargate ships are pretty evenly matched, if you include weaponary, shileds and armour, but the only reason star wars owuld win is because of sheer numbers.
1) Atlantis with its drones, puddle jumpers other ancient tech....
2) Dedalas class Starships (BC-304s) with their asguard weapons, beaming nukes aboard their ships, f-302s, some puddlejumpers...
3) well, if we are talking about an invasion of both the milkyway and pegasus galaxies, threatining all the inhabits, then theres Wraith Hive ships, crusers, the wraith them selves which would be beamed over via deadulus cause they r a common enemy/ cont
Covalent ships were destroyed by earth ships that were less advanced than other shows,so they would be destroyed quite easily. Stargate and Star wars ships would be pretty evenly matched but there are just so many ships in star wars that if only by outnumbering others they would win.
the problem is that there were way too many wraiths, and the ancients where few, it is also said in the series that one ancient ship could beat several wraith ships at a time, but they were just too many, not to mention that wraith tech is almost as advanced as ancient tech
I like stargate(kinda drifted from it though), but sg ships suck. Star trek, star wars, freespace, halo; ships from those universes would have free reign in the sg universe.
Not really, they SAY they stick to reality, but reviving dead bodies and ascending and having substances that provide more explosive force than antimatter at 100% efficiency(something that is truly impossible, I mean a football size object blowing up a star system) is as much rubbish as the rest. SG just falls short in firepower and corresponding defences. BSG too.
Well in terms of realism Stargate has 1 edge over other Sci Fis i know. They take into account the time dialation effect which occures when you move at near light speeds in normal space.
no way man, have you seen ori motherships, asgard, even the dedalaus? Even the covenent aren't as good. with one nuke thier shields flicker and are offline for a couple secs. you don't see that in sg
Like to know where you got that from (a book perhaps). At any rate, lets consider this. The covenant has glassed many worlds, melted the entire surface and sterilized the planet. Goauld CAPITAL ship weapons impact the ground with explosive and thermal force equivelant to light-medium artillery easily matched today, a cov assault carrier can lay down a stream of plasma that can melt everything in a path a couple hundred metres wide, and several kilometers long(time and again).
Sorry, but if 1 of those plasma cannons hit a goauld mothership, it's rip through it like butter, and even an ori mothership would only last a couple seconds. and plasma torpedoes measure in the gigatons of explosive force, power only matched on a couple occasions in Sg, but commonplace in halo of star wars.
that's why i don't talk about goauld, but about ancients and wraith. the wraith ships may suck a bit, but they are countless, the imperial fleet is only one, and can't cover the entire galaxy at the same time, the wraith could easily do that.
Yes ancient tech is better, but thats compared with other SG universe tech. Relatively speaking, it doesn't measure up in other universes. Some smart people did the math and worked out the energies involved, and the defensive/offensive tech tiers generally go BSG - SG - Trek - Halo - Wars. Star wars deals with RIDICULOUS amounts of energy, too much in my opinion, I don't like tech wanking taken too far like that, but still, wars wins our almost always in an argument like this.
there's also the ori in SG their shields absorb energy and transfer it into power, not like the shields of star wars, that only deflect it, and even the ancient shields, that are force fields. bottom line, ori shields are waay better than any of the shields in the other universes.
I don't see where the force field/deflector distinction becomes relevant. 2 names for virtually the same thing. On the topic of shields though, covenant shield tech is regenerative, so a ship could absorb massive amounts of firepower, but only take a brief time to completely recharge it's shields.
Ok maybe covenents guns are more powerfull, but ori and ancient shields are more powerfull (ori shields transfer attacking fire ino energy they use) plus the asgard and deadalus can stop time and make repairs then get back to the fight.
not stop slow down and not slow down either its going faster if your particles move at a faster rate u think faster which allows you to move faster which your just in a state which your molecules are moving faster then the particles of another object causing it to seem motionless
Perhaps you're right in some ways Jarsia, but you can't denie the majority of Stargate is immensly more realistic then ANY of the other shows. Besides, you can't truly prove any of the stuff in their show isn't possible, can you? But w/e, i'm only really defending Stargate because i love it and i'm not really a trekky fan.
Stargate is based around different kinds of mythology, such as the egyptian mythology where u see alot of pyramids and temples, thus the realisticness in it where as starwars are all from imagination
Atlantis charged with 3 ZPMs with a full armory of drones can singlehandedly destroy every single ship in the Starwars, Startrek, Battlestar Galactica comined... (including the death star), just to give you an idea of how strong Atlantis' shield is, it can stay in the centre of a sun for longer than 2 hours...
Heh. No drone would ever puncture the shields of an ISD, and the Death Star would pwn Atlantis. If Mon Cal shields can't hold back the Death Star, nothing can.
yeap, that's true, atlantis shields are inmune to everithing the other ships, including death star can trhow at it. they also have the asgard shields and teleport tech, which they use to teletransport, not nukes, but naquadah warheads into the enemy ships, with or without shields. and if you want more firepower, they count with the stargate destroyer.
Immiune to evrything. i gues the Ancients were stupid not to use the city ships against the wraith in open battles. since they wouldent take any damage...
now seriously a planet killing shot would obviously overpower the shields ZPMs or not. I dont argue that an ISD or even an SSD would be no match but the Death Star? please...
antlantis shields can hold being inside a sun, whichs is much pawerful that the Death Star ray, or anything man can create, besides, the ancients lost against the wraith because of numbers.
Inside a sun. if that hapened in an episode then my apologies (i dont have SGA on TV here so my info is based on a few eps from the net, SG1 and some stuff i read about on the net). still if the shield is THAT powerfull they could have sent a city ship or 2 against the wraith. after they depleated the drones they could have just keep raming them untill they are all dead or they run.
Wraith ships SUCK, an ISD, or sovereign class starship, or covenant assault carrier would mow through them. The death star laser actually holds the energy output of a star over a significant period of time, much more than 2 hours. BTW what ep was that from?
and the prometheus could easily take several SD before being destroyed, it is smaller, thus more manuverable and it can destroy the SD by teleporting naquadah warheads INSIDE the ships.
as much as i hate getting into this stuff again. SDs have shields and sensor jaming technology so i dont think transporters would be a problem. while as the Promethus realy is smaller it is still bigger than a Correlian Corvette.
I didnt really like it, only because im a huge fan of star wars and star gate. I think that each movie's soundtrack fits so well for their respective movies. when i heart he stargate soundtrack in this, im like waiting for Ra or one of the Hobrus to jump out in their bad ass shit
anyone who says stargate is just stupid
070000591 2 months ago
Talk about a nerdwar. Its actually a bit sad that i actually allready know all the details of both worlds, being my two favroite scifi things.
Ignoring questions of weapons, the real war is Ascended powers vs Force. As vader said, somthing along the lines of "Fuck your puny death star, i can choke you with my mind."
slashngrab 9 months ago
SG > SW
oneil > Skywalker
azguard > Ewok
giggity giggity 50's giggity lol
1625w162d 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Free Energy is real and its here! The Oil companies are doing everything in their power to stop these
information. If you want a Free energy machine do a search in youtube for the LT MAGNET MOTOR , Join the
revolution!
slipshodcoqbgg 1 year ago
i dont see anything of stargate
yorammo 1 year ago
Comment removed
vinc9621 1 year ago 3
@vinc9621
wow you know how to spell good job
moshprod 1 year ago
Comment removed
sidarape14 1 year ago
@moshprod i speak french
vinc9621 1 year ago
@moshprod: An thats from the man who can't ^^ funny
noob2510 1 year ago
Not bad i wish they put the song into the movies lol.
K4L8 1 year ago
For one Cobalt, An ISD's Quad Turbo Lasers can fire 200 Gigaton blasts per shot, and is armed with several batteries all of which can be fired at the same time. It was also stated that The Deadalus's weapons cannot penetrate Neutronium which the ISD's use for armor in the form of Durasteel. No ship for Gate would stand a chance.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
@NANOFORGE I'm not why you addressed this to me so late, but anyway, at no point was it said that a beam weapon or nuke cannot penetrate neutronium. The only thing they've failed at damaging critically was the Wraith superhive. Besides that, if they have the computer core to create Replicators, they can just unleash them on the empire and hit the self-destruct button a few months later. Fighting the empire would be good for them, they'd be able to increase their fleet.
CobaltX07 1 year ago
@CobaltX07 Ah sorry if this was late. I agree with you that Star Trek ships are at the ass end of this. The Deadalus's Nukes are in the Gigatons and would blow a Trek ship up instanly as they can only take a few dozen Megatons. Star Wars is at the top end, The Acclamator class destroyer can take 360.000 Gigatons and the Mrkii ISD can take over 3 times as much as that. It would take over 300,000 Trek photons to get through an Acclamators shields.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
@NANOFORGE I ran a similar calculation showing that even 3,000,000 photons wouldn't scratch the Ori. Granted this implies we take Carter's word that Prometheus can do at least half the speed of light and assume that ha'tak speeds are appropriately adjusted appropriately on screen, still Stargate shields can take alot of punishment, possible the only Sci-Fi TV-show that can take Star Wars ICS (which some people don't accept) punishment, but it all really depends on how you scale their weapons.
CobaltX07 1 year ago
@CobaltX07 I agree on that, Star Gate is the only fictional universe that could take on Wars. The Deadalus's shields have taken planet pulverizing punishment before. Each of her nukes are 1.02 Gigatons each and many can be fired at once. Those Nukes only caused minimal damage to Wraith ships while Asgard weapons destroyed them with 3 shots. That would make Asgard weapons several thousand times more powerful than a single nuke. Ori Ships were one of the most powerful types of Gate ship aswell.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
@NANOFORGE lol this is kinda epic but note that 'drones' are not affected by shields. Aurora-class ship with it's arsenall full of drones can kill like almost all ships u have seen in all the 6 Starwars movies. XD
well yea not that much but Aurora-class ships are like imortal with ZPM's and drones...
GODWARS2 1 year ago
@GODWARS2 Yeah Drones can slice through anything. The Deadauls's Asgard Plasma weapons kill Wraith hives with ease too and Wraith haives take minimal damage to Gigaton rated Nukes. Star Gate could take Star Wars. However their are some universes neither of those two could take, Metroid and Dr Who for example.
NANOFORGE 1 year ago
@NANOFORGE DR who as in
' that frigging heavy is a Dalek '?
Haha Daleks are just epic LOL
GODWARS2 1 year ago
this would be a kickass crossover. especialy with teal'c seeing original trilogy nie times
UndyingHunter1 2 years ago
No freaking way could stargate pwn star wars.
The soldiers have machine guns not laser guns.
The ships are appear to have better shields then Rebel Alliance but a death star can take care of that
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
Yup stargate has more accurate guns, have you seen the crap stormtroopers are given???
muf321 2 years ago
Have you seen the amount of time that MacGyver's character has been shot despite having an accurate weapon?
LOL, Stormtroopers might not be all that but a laser gun & armor will win anytime over a P90
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
no you forget that to cut down on exspensives the empire gave the stormtroopers plastic armor. P90 beats plastic armor
UndyingHunter1 2 years ago
But would it honestly matter when you got laser guns & cannons compared to P90s?
Me thinks not especially if the Stargate team was going against the Trade Federation's Battle Droids
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
I'd take my chances against the semi auto laser cannons compared to the ROF of a P90...
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure no one would want to tempt fate with either gun in real life, LOL but cool beings
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
... are you retarded?
That wasn't the point. You are ignoring my point because you know I am correct, yet your ego is so sensitive that you can't stand being wrong.
My point was that the P90's would win because they have a high rate of fire. The laser cannons we see are semi auto.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
Comment removed
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
You see them. Through out the films that the lasers have a very slow rate of fire. That of a semi auto weapon with the trigger being repeatedly pressed. Rather than fully auto and being held down.
I mean they COULD be fully auto, but the ROF is still horribly slow making for a less effective weapon. Semi auto is okay, it makes for better accuracy but with experience and control fully automatic weapons just throw more bullets at the enemy. Making them extremely deadly.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
What's the ROF?
Sure, while Stargate team has P90s, they still have regular machine guns & pistols which are probably not going to hit their targets when a laser has more range & can go through walls easier making a wall used for cover worthless.
Look at how fast Jango Fett's duel pistols fire. They fire almost as fast as the cannons on his ship
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
Rate of fire. Also a P90 is very accurate. "Probably not going to hit their targets" shows just how little you know.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
Once again, you read it wrong. Read it again & you'll see that I was talking about the pistols & other machine guns NOT the P90.
I know enough to get my point across.
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
Other "machine guns", as in Assault Rifles, Bull pups, sub machine guns and light machine guns are also very accurate, and also have a high rate of fire.
Also if you are talking about pistols, are you comparing them to the laser pistols in star wars? Because those things are even worse...
The weapons our armies use are very effective. Just because they don't shoot pretty colours like your science fiction doesn't mean they lose in a firefight.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
Notice how I didn't mention any of the guns you mentioned besides rifles & pistols.
Once again, you're being silly saying the lasers are worst. Compared to the lasers of the bad guys in STARGATE which you have to charge up, the lasers aren't slow at all. The stormtroopers/ clone troopers blasters/rifles fire rapidly. Look at the battle scene again.
Plus, you keep bringing accuracy into this. Who cares? I guarantee you that Han Solo could kill McGyver in one shot. P90s do shit against snipers
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
When I said that, I was basing it on how accurate the Stargate team is which is often not always accurate.
Do you know how many times they've been killed? it's ridiculous & then they come back to life
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
Comment removed
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
We're not talking about the military or real life. We're talking about who would win? Stargate team & Gor'El or Empire & Rebels
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
I am talking about real life you moron. A P90 or other ballistic weapons used by our planets armies are better than the lasers and pieces of crap you see in star wars. Read my first reply to you.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
I don't think I will since you've resorted to namecalling & are acting immature so now I'm going to politely end this conversation.
You can claim that I pussied out. I don't care, I don't know you personally & I'm honestly in no mood to argue over pointless shit.
You keep saying "our planets" when Stargate is just as fake as Star Wars. Sure, they have real-life weapons but I'm pretty sure there's no wormholes or Gor'Els but I'm done.
GOOD BYE & Thank You for this Unpleasant Conversation.
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
I never mentioned wormholes. I never mentioned Gor'Els. I said that the weapons we use are most likely superior to what we see in starwars. Yes. I did say our planet, and if you really need me to explain what I was saying, I was referring to the combined armies of earth. You heard of them? US Army, Royal Army and so on. They aren't fake, and our planet isn't either so I can say our planet.
Goodbye, It isn't fun arguing with someone who pretends you said something you didn't.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
Comment removed
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
I just got back to my "computer screen" an hour ago. After doing other stuff through the day. If you're trying to imply I have no life, when I know otherwise and you have no idea. You've failed. This is just a fun waste of time. Finding morons who try and convince people how they are right when they know nothing about what they are arguing.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
LOL, hypocrite. You know nothing about Star Wars
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
I haven't made any points directed at star wars. Simply the laser guns seen in the films. It's funny how you can't understand that.
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
it's funny how you want to insult & get the last word in, LOL
SeanConnery9000 2 years ago
@SeanConnery9000
That wasn't "getting the last word in". That was responding to you saying I know nothing about Star Wars, implying I am talking about star wars as if I know about it. I'm simply informing you I wasn't talking about star wars. Just the lasers in it. Also it's funny how you also want to get the last word in. Hypocrite?
PlayWithDaveyyy 2 years ago
your forgeting about the zats and staffs that the SGC has stacked up in their arsonal
UndyingHunter1 2 years ago
Depends if you take the lasers from the books or from the movies. The lasers from the books will beat a P-90. The lasers from the movies are worse then Col. O'Neill's baretta sidearm and can't hope to compare to the guns currently in use by the modern army. The P-90 with armor piercing rounds might also be superior then some of the book lases because of its sheer rate of fire combined with accuracy. Also, an F-302 or a jumper could take out the Death Star solving that problem.
CobaltX07 2 years ago
Stargate 1 : 0 Starwars
webnull 2 years ago 8
If I may leave note, a lot of the Stargate ships are actually too small by comparison to Star Wars ships. The Ori Mothership for example is just a few meters larger than a Star Destroyer while the Daedalus class ships are smaller than a Coriellian Corvette.
Alpha17d 2 years ago
CobaltX07 2 years ago
Earth would win. Just have to beam some Mark IXs into the Death Star its its bye bye. Then they just have to hunt down the rest of the Empire Fleet until its all destroyed.
Cyclonus84 2 years ago
The Furlings would kick all their asses
LordAmbitious 2 years ago
Yes the Furlings
Wait.... I just thought of something....
Furlings vs Ewoks
amvhellLover 2 years ago
and star wars dose have sheilds they even have plant sheilds
SuperColt23 2 years ago
stargate ships have cloaking technologies and the stargate itself is superior to any ship as you can muster forces in your own territory before sending an attack.Thats also not to mention ascended beings that are godlike in their power.
maoristutuff 2 years ago
starwars would win they have bigger an better ships than stargate including the 19 mile long eclipes class super star destroyer
SuperColt23 2 years ago
exactly, the stargate ships only have railguns,(shakes head) so pathetic
turbolaserman 2 years ago
Only railguns??? They have beam weapons, 230+ and possibly 800+ gt nuclear weapons, energy pulse weapons, plasma bombs, naquadah bombs, "prior" guns, lightning superweapon (unknown power), 1.2 gt man-portable nukes, ion cannons (different from SW version), drones that can ignore shield and rip through armor (though not anything thicker than 50 m) and and nuclear MIRVs. The SSD would be effective, the DS less so because a 302 can exit hyperspace inside the ship and nuke the main reactor.
CobaltX07 2 years ago 12
@CobaltX07 and all that without divine intervention or assistance from an advanced ally (the Nox, Ancients, what remained of the Asgard, Friendly Wraith, friendly Replicators...)
ZuKahta 11 months ago
starwars has ion cannons wich disable sheilds and weapons
SuperColt23 2 years ago
and turbolasers
turbolaserman 2 years ago
WOW I just finished reading all these comments and realized one thing everybody missed. Star Wars take place a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away, while Stargate takes place in the present. You are all comparing technology from two different points in time.
Stinkface2 2 years ago 2
lets see....you are all little nerds!!! get a life...and a girlfriend...
FernfahrerUlf 2 years ago
Stargate ships have superior shield/weapons and advanced tech. They can go back in time,slows down time,go into alternate universe. Star Wars ships is hopelessly outclassed.
teramatmulia 2 years ago
Depends on the race. SW culd defeat Earth, Gould and Wraith, but the Asgards, Replicators and not to mention the Ori would be a real challenge.
larsblom 2 years ago
they could only defeat earth by shear numbers if they sent a few ships at atime then with the Tauri ships would kick their asses and wed create more ships and wed win but if they sent theyre entire fleet wed be fucked until our allies came to help
ChrisRoersma 2 years ago
The Empire or any SW race would never be able to completely defeat Earth, because it can phase-cloak itself which makes it invulnerable to everything, apparently, even the ascended.
A interesting fight would be Adria vs. the Emperor or a Wraith ZPM Hive vs the Executor
CobaltX07 2 years ago
phase cloack only works for a little while, what if the empire were to capture a stargate, wire it to the firing dish of the death star and instead of firing the beam thrugh space to the earth from orbit, park the death star (which is devoid of civilian contractors) in a seperate system dial earth and fire the death star's beam THROUGH THE STARGATE! the iris would melt instantly, and the beam would come through full blast and the empire would win.
LordAmbitious 2 years ago
Actually, the phase cloak lasts pretty much indefinitely as long as it's got a power supply (ZPM, artificial singularities, even 2/3 the US power grid will do it).
As for shooting the superlaser through a stargate, chances are they'll blow up the actual gate, even if they don't raw energy and powerful beams always destabilize the wormhole or make it jump rather than coming out the other side,even shot through unshielded, all it would do to a phase-cloaked planet is briefly blind someone.
CobaltX07 2 years ago
i disagree, if they were to slowly dial up the output of the superlaser, they could destroy the iris of the receiving gate (earth's) and once they reached a certain threshold the connection could be maintained longer than 38 minutes (like when the Russians dialed that planet with a living ocean or something) and you are assuming that earth once again has access to a zpm, which judging from the way they run through those things on the show last slightly longer than Duracells.
LordAmbitious 2 years ago
They would still have to take the beam out of phase (which only requires the US power grid or possibly some neutrino ion generators) to the same level as Earth and adjust the DS beam so that the wavelength can get through, since raw energy has been shown to not be able to get through an iris or shield ("48 hours," "Chain Reaction," "Full Circle"). Also, as a last minute precaution, they can just beam the gate into space pointed away from Earth or have a 302 fly it across the solar system.
CobaltX07 2 years ago
don't forget about ZPMs with regards to power
amvhellLover 2 years ago
great job i like the vid.
both great series/movies.
SallyMustang72 2 years ago
we all know that a space battle between starwars and stargate, that stargate whuld win.
they have far more advanced technology that the empire or th rebels.
SgtdawnFTW 2 years ago
"Star Gate has advanced technology compared to Star Wars"
Star Gate soldiers still look like present-day SWAT teams. Technology in Star Wars consists of ships (rather than gates that must be working all the time), replicators, making billions of droids, cloning billions of troopers, going faster than the speed of light, being able to destroy a planet or solar system in less than a second, the list goes on.
Darthstormtrooper60 2 years ago
and in Star wars they have the mandalorians who are trained from birth for war. they would kik stargates troopers ass easily
00Raptor277 2 years ago
Like Star Wars, Stargate can destroy planets and solar systems. It can also destroy galaxies. It's ships can cross between them in a matter of weeks or even seconds. Plus, a single SG replicator could bring the entire SW and ST universe, with the exception of those using bioships, to their knees in weeks with their ability to go from 1 to 1 trillion in 2 weeks and to incorporate all tech they come across into their ships, blocks, planets, and bugs. Not to even mention what the ascended would do.
CobaltX07 2 years ago
Agreed.
The Replicators basically raped the Stargate Universe...
No joke. They beat their ass so hard. LOL
But, they found a way and it took how many tries JUST to take them down.. Once?
About 10 tries.
AsianandBuddies 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think it was 3 times
xygthophase4 2 years ago
Let's see, there is the Star Forge which means infinite ships. Centerpoint Station than can move and destroy planets like marbles (as well as destroy stars), Sith Lords can pull a sun's core out and use that as a projectile, Sun Crusher can destroy 11 star systems, and the list goes on. Replicators have the problem that kinetic weapons can kill them. It is good they can create different forms, but how would they go up against tons of supernovas?
Darthstormtrooper60 2 years ago
in star wars there only threat would be the jedi, in star trek there only threat would be the borg. either way star wars and trek (of both who I am also fans to) would be screwed. Jedi are limited in numbers ad the federation would have no or close to no hope as the borg and replicators anniahlate everything in the universe as repliborgs. Lets put it this way, the Emperor and 5th or The Borg Queen and Repli Carter.
Dms12444 2 years ago
I doubt they can do the same with the Founders/changellings in the Dominion :P
larsblom 2 years ago
The point with the replicators is that they could take over all the Imperial tech. First of all, the human form ones are not vulnerable to kinetic weapons, and can also forcibly take information from Imperial mines. The smaller spider forms would spread throughout the empire. In order to crush the replicatos with supernovas, the Imperials would have to blow up all of their major systems. Plus, the reps would have their own tech to use against them, or they could simply take over a superweapon.
CobaltX07 2 years ago
stargate whuld win.
starwars doesent even have shields or any powerful weapons.
atlantis whuld beat the crap out of the death star.
it whuld just luanch a cupple of drones that goes some rounds in and out and the deathstar whuld go boom!
+ the deathstar doesent even have big weapons, it just have the megacannon and that cant hit atlantis cause atlantis is movable and stuff.
and 1 asgard oneil ship whuld beat the crap out of an entire starwars fleet.
there i have said mine! lololololololololol =)
SgtdawnFTW 2 years ago
"starwars doesent even have shields"
in empire strikes back a captain said raise shields. go figure.
"or any powerful weapons"
ever heard of the sun crusher? it destroys solar systems.
"1 Asgard O'Neil ship whuld beat the crap out of an entire starwars fleet:
omg your really sad. all sw ships have gigatonne to medium teraton weapons. star wars rapes star gate in every way.
troymarten 2 years ago
Never thought I would be doing this...Correction:
Instead of...
"ever heard of the sun crusher? it destroys solar systems"
It should be...
"ever heard of the sun crusher? it destroys star systems"
Yes, the supernova caused by the first crushed star (by the sun crusher obviously) created a chain reaction of supernovas in surrounding stars...so it destroys star systems.
Darthstormtrooper60 2 years ago
i think it was 3 times
xygthophase4 2 years ago
Including Atlantis, it was about 7.
AsianandBuddies 2 years ago
"SW has no shields"
From Return of the Jedi, "Sir, we've just lost bridge deflector shields", that means SW ships have MORE than 1 shield.
"Death Star doesn't even have big weapons"
That crater on the Death Star, it's a weapon...it destroys planets such as the one we are on.
"DS can't hit Atlantis because it moves"
Admiral Ackbar didn't say that when 2 retreating capital ships were blown up within minutes (Death Star recharge is annoying I bet).
"Entire SW fleet"
Includes Yuuzhan Vong.
Darthstormtrooper60 2 years ago
ya know he did mention the death stars major weapon so get that right and Admiral Ackbar had to a moron to stay in the death stars path when retreating other wise he could have gotten away
ChrisRoersma 2 years ago
lol the lightsaber bends
dagiantpoo2 3 years ago
Starwars pwnt stargate
nusucker 3 years ago
mmm... no ! stargate is better
miki21189 3 years ago 3
no it dosent
nusucker 3 years ago
3 movies and more than 200 episodes vs 6 movies ...
miki21189 3 years ago
300 episode and starwars has comics ,booksm clone wars serise in cartoonm then clonewars 3D then its 7 movies now and startreck 300 epi and 3 movies
nusucker 3 years ago
more than 200 because i was only thinking in stargate sg1.
Startrek has the original one (79 episodes), the next generation (178 episodes)... and the actors are not the same.
stargate also has stargate infinity in animation pictures
miki21189 3 years ago
OK I dont see why its name is star wars VS stargate, cuz it was just star wars clips and stargate music
clapsnake 3 years ago 2
agreed failed title
jhelmsorig 3 years ago
so graphics don't matter, the story is good.
dalek333 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
piece of crap origanal star wars has such gay graphics
akblue102296 3 years ago
If it weren't for that "70's crap" many CGI would probably not be possible. I know Pixar alone was created by Lucas. Lucas is even working hard on his scifi saga to make even more advances in film and what not.
Darthstormtrooper60 3 years ago 4
come on star wars is the best. Yes for today the effect is "crap" but they remaster is in the star wars special edition and it preaty good. And image for the 70s it was a big advance in the movie tecnoligie even today they doest make better movie then star wars only fey are good.
Procrastineux 3 years ago 3
De68d, what do you expect from Lucas in the 70s? He is kinda the person who made Pixar, so that means there was better bad graphics for the time. Then, Lucas updated the movies in like a 1994 release on VHS or DVD(I forgot which one).
Darthstormtrooper60 3 years ago
Well that was crap.
ablebravo 3 years ago
that was fucking stupid! don't just put the music over star wars. it's just a waist of time.
adultkenney 3 years ago
Army of Jedi's would own everyone :)
gi4ouR 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stargate is nothing compared to starwars all it had was one movie although good. Still nothing compared to starwars. Oh also alot of worthless tv series with completly different actors then the movie so yea Stargate was practically destroyed by its tv series IMO.
666RUS 3 years ago
Nope, they've had 2 movies, and the new one is better than all the star wars movies put together so stfu. And stargate series is good
jaysodude 3 years ago
Well, isn't THAT the stupidest, most idiotic thing I've ever heard.
The only good thing about the Stargate franchise is the original movie. SG-1, it's spinoffs, and its crappy second-rate movies are GARBAGE, and to EVER say they are better than any Star Wars movie shows that you have incredibly bad ****ed up taste.
Star Wars (original trilogy) = gold
StarGate (original 1994 movie) = electrum
Star Wars (prequel trilogy) = tin
Stargate SG-1, Atlantis, etc = vomit and shit
DuracellEnergizer 3 years ago
*Screams* Hey Listen you stargate and star wars are equal ans ATLANTIS AND SG-1 ARE NOT VOMIT AND SHIT!!!!!!
JasonStockert 3 years ago 8
I watched nearly the entire run of SG-1, and the early episodes of Atlantis's first season.
I stand by my statement regarding those TV series.
DuracellEnergizer 3 years ago
the prequals were an abomination to all that is good and just in this world and all copies should be either destroyed or edited so that the only remaining scenes are the bits with Samuel L. Jackson and he credits.
LordAmbitious 2 years ago
Darth Maul should be kept in too, and the pod race.
12ctcoloredpencils 2 years ago
The forces ties with ancinets and the empire ties with the ghould nobody wins its a draw
FireGaret 3 years ago 2
Stargate Rules starwars!!!Easy kick there asses with asgard tech they woud never penetrate their asgard shields!!!
Roursaren 3 years ago
stargate has better weponry and shildes specelly with the asgard beming teknologi. and they have allaies that would help them. starwars would onley have a little chanse if theyuse all there ships in one big attack.
(sorry if the spelling is bad i'm from sweden)
kalle129 3 years ago
If the Asgard were still around Stargate would hold their own ground. If the people in the Ori galaxy were to join in after the Ark of Truth Stargate would be better off than before. But for now it is Star Wars.
donnieharrison2 3 years ago
star wars and stargate ships are pretty evenly matched, if you include weaponary, shileds and armour, but the only reason star wars owuld win is because of sheer numbers.
BsGfAnLoRd 3 years ago
star wars wouldent win... Stargate would cause
1) Atlantis with its drones, puddle jumpers other ancient tech....
2) Dedalas class Starships (BC-304s) with their asguard weapons, beaming nukes aboard their ships, f-302s, some puddlejumpers...
3) well, if we are talking about an invasion of both the milkyway and pegasus galaxies, threatining all the inhabits, then theres Wraith Hive ships, crusers, the wraith them selves which would be beamed over via deadulus cause they r a common enemy/ cont
stargater94 3 years ago
omfg whers my previous comment... o well... stargate would win...
1) The Taruie - (idk how to spell that...) 1) Atlantis 2) Dedalus class Starships (BC-304s) with asguard weapons & Sheilds & Beaming tech...
2) the Wraith - 1) Hive Ships & Cruzers 2) with or without the help of dedalus, beam aboard wraith and suck the life outa them...
3) Asurans (if they were around and we befreinded them or they started attacking them....
4) Ori ships & Satalite
5)Asguard (if not dead...)
stargater94 3 years ago
Stargate wins...easy as pie.
genralbiatch 4 years ago 2
this is the stargate theme; how come its being played with Star Wars video clips
rckljohnson 4 years ago
i think you can take a loot at the title, its always a bad thing to choose videos randomly, cuz you know, maybe you can end up watching porn...
hl2tdm 4 years ago
Covalent ships were destroyed by earth ships that were less advanced than other shows,so they would be destroyed quite easily. Stargate and Star wars ships would be pretty evenly matched but there are just so many ships in star wars that if only by outnumbering others they would win.
MeatloafTwo 4 years ago
Man i love Stargate and Star Wars
RealisticTechnology 4 years ago 3
the problem is that there were way too many wraiths, and the ancients where few, it is also said in the series that one ancient ship could beat several wraith ships at a time, but they were just too many, not to mention that wraith tech is almost as advanced as ancient tech
changorgr 4 years ago
starwars ist nix im gegensatz zu stargate..
gdur44332 4 years ago
I love em both to death but I have to say, any Star Wars ship could pwn any Stargate ship.
Lorrdd 4 years ago 3
I like stargate(kinda drifted from it though), but sg ships suck. Star trek, star wars, freespace, halo; ships from those universes would have free reign in the sg universe.
Jarsia 4 years ago 2
Yeah, because SG is realistic, the rest are based on rubbish.
Vampiiire 4 years ago
Not really, they SAY they stick to reality, but reviving dead bodies and ascending and having substances that provide more explosive force than antimatter at 100% efficiency(something that is truly impossible, I mean a football size object blowing up a star system) is as much rubbish as the rest. SG just falls short in firepower and corresponding defences. BSG too.
Jarsia 4 years ago
Well in terms of realism Stargate has 1 edge over other Sci Fis i know. They take into account the time dialation effect which occures when you move at near light speeds in normal space.
LordDarthHarry 4 years ago
Trek does mention that, cept it' overcome there with a subspace field(or something).
Jarsia 4 years ago
no way man, have you seen ori motherships, asgard, even the dedalaus? Even the covenent aren't as good. with one nuke thier shields flicker and are offline for a couple secs. you don't see that in sg
Mvickvsdogs 4 years ago
Like to know where you got that from (a book perhaps). At any rate, lets consider this. The covenant has glassed many worlds, melted the entire surface and sterilized the planet. Goauld CAPITAL ship weapons impact the ground with explosive and thermal force equivelant to light-medium artillery easily matched today, a cov assault carrier can lay down a stream of plasma that can melt everything in a path a couple hundred metres wide, and several kilometers long(time and again).
Jarsia 4 years ago
Sorry, but if 1 of those plasma cannons hit a goauld mothership, it's rip through it like butter, and even an ori mothership would only last a couple seconds. and plasma torpedoes measure in the gigatons of explosive force, power only matched on a couple occasions in Sg, but commonplace in halo of star wars.
Jarsia 4 years ago
that's why i don't talk about goauld, but about ancients and wraith. the wraith ships may suck a bit, but they are countless, the imperial fleet is only one, and can't cover the entire galaxy at the same time, the wraith could easily do that.
changorgr 4 years ago
Yes ancient tech is better, but thats compared with other SG universe tech. Relatively speaking, it doesn't measure up in other universes. Some smart people did the math and worked out the energies involved, and the defensive/offensive tech tiers generally go BSG - SG - Trek - Halo - Wars. Star wars deals with RIDICULOUS amounts of energy, too much in my opinion, I don't like tech wanking taken too far like that, but still, wars wins our almost always in an argument like this.
Jarsia 4 years ago
i thought so, cause i saw on a website someone wrote like 3 trillion gigawatts vs 5 gigawatts
74205Defiant 4 years ago
yeah, sounds about right. I don't generally care enough to follow these debates any more, but I do remember a lot from when I used to.
Jarsia 4 years ago
there's also the ori in SG their shields absorb energy and transfer it into power, not like the shields of star wars, that only deflect it, and even the ancient shields, that are force fields. bottom line, ori shields are waay better than any of the shields in the other universes.
changorgr 4 years ago
I don't see where the force field/deflector distinction becomes relevant. 2 names for virtually the same thing. On the topic of shields though, covenant shield tech is regenerative, so a ship could absorb massive amounts of firepower, but only take a brief time to completely recharge it's shields.
Jarsia 4 years ago
Ok maybe covenents guns are more powerfull, but ori and ancient shields are more powerfull (ori shields transfer attacking fire ino energy they use) plus the asgard and deadalus can stop time and make repairs then get back to the fight.
Mvickvsdogs 4 years ago
not stop slow down and not slow down either its going faster if your particles move at a faster rate u think faster which allows you to move faster which your just in a state which your molecules are moving faster then the particles of another object causing it to seem motionless
lilazntown 4 years ago
Perhaps you're right in some ways Jarsia, but you can't denie the majority of Stargate is immensly more realistic then ANY of the other shows. Besides, you can't truly prove any of the stuff in their show isn't possible, can you? But w/e, i'm only really defending Stargate because i love it and i'm not really a trekky fan.
Vampiiire 4 years ago 2
Stargate is based around different kinds of mythology, such as the egyptian mythology where u see alot of pyramids and temples, thus the realisticness in it where as starwars are all from imagination
gold1510 4 years ago
I do not agree with you...
Atlantis charged with 3 ZPMs with a full armory of drones can singlehandedly destroy every single ship in the Starwars, Startrek, Battlestar Galactica comined... (including the death star), just to give you an idea of how strong Atlantis' shield is, it can stay in the centre of a sun for longer than 2 hours...
sovietdreadnought 4 years ago
Heh. No drone would ever puncture the shields of an ISD, and the Death Star would pwn Atlantis. If Mon Cal shields can't hold back the Death Star, nothing can.
Lorrdd 4 years ago
nope. Atlantis shields actually do something, they aren't 'deflector shields' they are actually force fields!
sovietdreadnought 4 years ago
yeap, that's true, atlantis shields are inmune to everithing the other ships, including death star can trhow at it. they also have the asgard shields and teleport tech, which they use to teletransport, not nukes, but naquadah warheads into the enemy ships, with or without shields. and if you want more firepower, they count with the stargate destroyer.
changorgr 4 years ago
Immiune to evrything. i gues the Ancients were stupid not to use the city ships against the wraith in open battles. since they wouldent take any damage...
now seriously a planet killing shot would obviously overpower the shields ZPMs or not. I dont argue that an ISD or even an SSD would be no match but the Death Star? please...
LordDarthHarry 4 years ago 2
antlantis shields can hold being inside a sun, whichs is much pawerful that the Death Star ray, or anything man can create, besides, the ancients lost against the wraith because of numbers.
changorgr 4 years ago
Inside a sun. if that hapened in an episode then my apologies (i dont have SGA on TV here so my info is based on a few eps from the net, SG1 and some stuff i read about on the net). still if the shield is THAT powerfull they could have sent a city ship or 2 against the wraith. after they depleated the drones they could have just keep raming them untill they are all dead or they run.
LordDarthHarry 4 years ago
Wraith ships SUCK, an ISD, or sovereign class starship, or covenant assault carrier would mow through them. The death star laser actually holds the energy output of a star over a significant period of time, much more than 2 hours. BTW what ep was that from?
Jarsia 4 years ago
and the prometheus could easily take several SD before being destroyed, it is smaller, thus more manuverable and it can destroy the SD by teleporting naquadah warheads INSIDE the ships.
changorgr 4 years ago
as much as i hate getting into this stuff again. SDs have shields and sensor jaming technology so i dont think transporters would be a problem. while as the Promethus realy is smaller it is still bigger than a Correlian Corvette.
LordDarthHarry 4 years ago
that was badass i love them both like children.
dexterme 4 years ago 2
I didnt really like it, only because im a huge fan of star wars and star gate. I think that each movie's soundtrack fits so well for their respective movies. when i heart he stargate soundtrack in this, im like waiting for Ra or one of the Hobrus to jump out in their bad ass shit
raven3o1 4 years ago
dude, its Stargate. One word.
skato101 4 years ago 3
meh
moshprod 4 years ago
Cool
omgCSIrocks4ever 4 years ago
well put-together
geeksquad4ever 4 years ago
Very good edition.
NagyBalazs 4 years ago
lol
timepiller 4 years ago
LOL... that was HELL-O cool.
But needed more STARGATE style moments... u know them running around inside Death Star... storm trooper fight... etc.
Bapman2099 4 years ago