New Order - Love Will Tear Us Apart [Live in Glasgow]

[ferretsareboss]

miserable twat on bass

[40ChampagneSupernova]

@ferretsareboss . He is now anyways, founder member of the bands Joy Division/ New Order. (Hooky) Peter Hook just been sacked from the band before the play a few reunion gigs before they play a few summer festivals. must be a nippy one that, lol

[darkwaverful]

finaly someone agree with me

Barney cannot sing

his voice don't fit in joy division songs

[fredcoook]

SIH: sing in heaven

[CALBERTOGOMES]

LINDA CANÇÃO!!!

[ewebug]

Fuken awful version that guy can't sing for shit.

[OzcarMtl]

I wonder if they still think of Ian while playing this song...

[tormunkov]

the primal genius minimalist truth of this music always tears me apart.

[Larsoti]

This video should be the explanation of the word "music" in dictionaries...

[TheMistermies]

fucking dreadful

[Dartorji]

Peter hook gère un pub .

[beanboyo]

Peter Hook is such a good bassist!

[housedubs1]

This brings back so many great memories from my early teens--love Joy Division and New Order!

[clarkjordan123]

Even Barney's hair is dancing along to this classic!

[monkeylordofdoom14]

I sooo wish i could have been there, or at any new order concert ever

i really hope they come to canada soon

[Kor1neto]

Omg, the same rhythm. I can't imagine how Stephen Morris feels while he's playing this song.

[birchy2k11]

how is this a cover? same band different vocals! Barney and ian are both legends anyway!

[MrStonecold69]

GREAT COVER

[AdiosBribon]

@MrStonecold69 Not a cover not even close..... 

[BiggusDickussss]

@nargarothfreak666 Cover? :o

[jeckeljoan]

I HATE the Word "Gothic"

[nargarothfreak666]

Wrong Key!

but nice nice cover :D

Cheers!

[FreyaFame]

sounds like their from 2011m years ago (: LOL

[pstrokeslibsarctic]

i miss ian

[ElCretino78]

What a great song...Ian Curtis we will never forget.

[WZYrover]

Ian is the gothic genius who stood like a monolith and sang about the pain he experienced. On the other hand, Barney, Hooky and company are a bunch of geniuses that hide the madness and pain behind seemingly cheerful music. JD and NO are just two sides of the same coin to me, and their music to me bares great similarity. I'd prefer Ian on Love Will Tear Us Apart, but imagine anyone else singing Sub-culture or Blue Monday is a pain.

[Bladerunner55217]

@WZYrover calm down and buy a smith shirt with some mod silver jewelry and some zodiac shoes lol.

[irishviolet14]

new order is joy division and I think they did Ian justice

[epsteinsmutha1]

Egh, no, higher key for Barney's voice.

Wrong! Still love the song and Joy Division/New Order, but this is too cheerful.

[Linear500]

@epsteinsmutha1 I agree.

[gabirjk1]

MADDDDCHESTER LIVE FOREVERR !!!

[JJORCHX13]

genial super banda ya era hora de que tocaran algo con lo que empezaron claro sin ian pero en suuuupeeeeer

[ChacaritaSenior]

Shit! they had to break up ... right when they were playing J D songs... that's sad.  But glorious wonderfull version this is.

[evade531]

this is a joy division cover right ?

[Ingenusernamesledig2]

@evade531 Right, but Joy Division are New Order exept for Ian Curtis who died in 1980.

[LeaSunShinee]

I'm glad that they're playing it in memory of the legend Ian Curtis, but it just doesn't feel the same as Ian would sing it. No one can top his raw voice of talent. <3

[BigFatBobberz]

It's not punk, it's something else that no-one can describe, it was fuelled by punk but i don't even think they would label this song as a punk song.

[Sorefame83]

@BigFatBobberz Post Punk

[FoxSwift1]

the works of Joy Division's should be played for the world its the best way to celebrate the legend Ian Curtis

[lmontesjr]

Ian Curtis :) Poor Guy... Thanks N.O.

[megasasquatchDUDE]

why is everybody jumping up and down to this song?

it should be: looking down at feet, stepping side to side, and taking the occasional drag off a cigarette.

no one know how to listen to punk these days.

[jenniferlaurenxo]

@megasasquatchDUDE sounds more like the 'goffs' from south park.

[josmdg]

@megasasquatchDUDE So, now there are derminate ways of listen to music? How should I listen to other kinds of music? Teache me, please.

[megasasquatchDUDE]

@josmdg I will *teach you gladly.

[34muggsy34]

@megasasquatchDUDE Ahhh the good old days.

[croftyben1]

i would of started crying when those blue lights started

[DJTryanB]

Love tore me apart. :(

[therealrockondon]

sounds pretty dam good..

[gildamx]

Superbe!

Cette sublime chanson est vraiment passée à la postérité,

et me fait toujours verser des larmes.

Merci.

[surfmb77]

I actually like this better than the original, it's better in a communal setting.  Who woulda guessed?

[PRECCIOUSSS]

its ok ,but its not ././.jjjjoooy division

[XanaxAbuse]

@TheLinnleah the fuck

[thelongandwindingroa]

New order is a bigger than to be put in this little hall, they are a big arena-band



[angeldestroy1]

such a beautiful cover for their own song, RIP Ian Curtis!

[theannoyingdevil2]

stop arguing and enjoy the music

[DoctorDoBuggerAll]

I wonder if Ian is ever there in spirit. Maybe, maybe not. We may never know. Not until we've passed ourselves anyway. I'm sure he'd be smiling anyway.

[ritnyc]

@Arkhandroid

"Honor"?

Oh, dear. Did you "discover" JD after hearing the Fall-Out Boy version or did one of the cool kids mention "Control" at prom?

[ritnyc]

New Order, of all bands, should know not to play this song. It just sounds so completely empty without him - missing it's entire emotional content which, sadly, resonated so strongly because of Ian's state of mind. The original is achingly beautiful. This is a pale echo which could have been performed by any dance band.

[Arkhandroid]

@ritnyc

Maybe they're playing it to honor their friend?

That alone is achingly beautiful. You sound like a superficial twat.

[alecahauf]

This is New order not old foggies, so why just 144,586 views

[darthsaya]

@alecahauf Hahaha maybe its better this way man! We dont want no unworthy ears listening to this!!!

Cheers!!!

[bigpoppaike6]

tbh without ian this song is terrible, emotional or not

[mikado622]

I love this song and i know Joy Division was not just Ian Curtis, But without his voice this just sounds 'wrong' not the same inpact at all....he will be missed for ever....

[bennynasherbaldy]

this song reminds me of watching the movie control and everytime i hear it, it reminds me of watching ian curtis and joy division for the first time

[danskin67]

i want to cry because new order butchered tghis song

[pjgh93]

@danskin67 Nah! This is their song as much as it was Ian's or Joy Division's. They're not playing it for themselves or the money - they're playing it for the fans and the collective memory of Ian.

[Kendif333]

@pjgh93 I almost cried when I listened to this live version...the youngers should listen to this instead of the shit they listen to. This is real music played by musicians, not machines !!!

[pjgh93]

@Kendif333 Seeing Hooky grinning at the beginning seemed to set the song off with less heavy memories. Hearing the crowd singing along is just sensational! In all, I think an excellent rendition and they've made it their own as New Order.

[TR1PACE5]

@Kendif333 same her bud ive never witnessed anything like that in my life i only wish i was at the gig myself!

[CristianKirk]

@pjgh93 Damn right.

[woodyfurball]

@danskin67 I wanna cry too cause I just DICK SLAPPED you, apart from the shouting of CMON, its a brilliant version, and THIS aint spwelled tghis, are you a Spwecial person? maybe a V.I.P? you have all the credentials to go on TV and get a boob job or maybe even further? can you can SHIT on ice? your incredible!

[PrettyTigerlilly]

@danskin67 WTF,... This IS JoyDivision, They changed the name after Ian's death. They are just playing it for the fans.

[mark97s]

live 80'

[biggametoday]

I don't know why, but I want to cry when I hear New Order's version of this song. Great job!

[pbrick6301]

oh man how emotional.

yawn.

[egillon92]

Quel massacre, Ian pourquoi es tu mort :o((((

[delonge5000]

those high pitched shouts have ruined the song

[covkip]

as much as this is a great song,only sounds right with ean

[MsSkullsandroses]

so amazing to see it taken from garage to stadium...with the lights, the smoke - makes such huge shifts in my emotions when i hear it - it seems fitting that it should get the big stage treatment...even though Ian is long rested... i wonder how he'd feel to know that so many people "got" what he was singing about... and for me...the original is the ONLY version..

[196177]

Manchesters best indeed..........BLOWS THEM ALL AWAY!

[deathbypowerglove]

At first I was gonna say despite the connections....it shouldn't be played again but what a fantastic job they did, and you know it had to be painful to play...New Order is great though. If we can't have Joy Division we at least of them

[juneNYCity]

IAN is proud!

[mrlebowski562]

this is epic.

[MrSach0611]

New order is in the only band that can play this song. And that's pretty ok !

[DollyBright]

Joy Division was what the women were called who were theere for sex with Hitlers top men

New Order refers to what Hitler was calling for when they won the war - it was going to be "A New Order" in the world

How can people who say they love New Order not know this

They are a fantastic group!!

[TimBrodo]

00:01

[TimBrodo]

Love the song in this key a whole much more, but the original was just perfect

[Lukewilkins12345]

@thetway

maybe the crowd could sing it back to them, if it weren't for the fact that about 1% of people who were fans of joy division knew wtf ian curtis was saying, regardless of how amazing he was :)

[bazadata]

Joy devision and New Order were references to Hitlers regime. I think these guys take the piss pretty well.

[CartoonsAndGameShows]

I just figured out to play the main riff on my keyboard! WIN!!!!

[NittaSuper]

That's good.

[TheFatweegee]

Live in Glasgow - what venue?



[prose87]

@TheFatweegee

Carling Academy or O2 Academy as it is now called.

[TheFatweegee]

Live in Glasgow - what venue?

[thetway]

they should've just played and let the crowd sing it back to them

[xDeadMisfitsx]

@alexwlee they played Transmission and Ceremony, i count ceremony as a JD song cus Curtis wrote it and JD played it before New Order did, tho they never officially released it

[Festivum01]

Didn't the guys refuse to sing Joy Division 'stuff' for over years and years and years?

Beautiful version though, even without Ian (but isn't it the same with Syd and Pink Floyd?).

[PeaceOutAng]

oh dear... Ian should be the only one singing this.. RIP dude

[flashcashkris]

is that david brent on guitar?

[poli4007]

. Sorry Ian. Outrageous. Disrespectful. Circus.

[PhilSupernova88]

@poli4007 Idiot! I swear too many people forget that Hooky, Barney and Steve were in Joy Division with Ian and this is in no way disrespectful; it's a tribute to one of music's most tortured souls

[outfirstball]

@poli4007 why is it disrespectful? they were ian's mates and spent alot of time with him good and bad. they more than likely wrote the music for the song so why can't they perform a song that means so much to them???

[birchy2k11]

@poli4007 so youd rather he was just completely forgotten with all his music?

[ItsGrimUpNorth7]

New Order, Pink Floyd and the Manics are 3 great bands, who inmho got better and more productive after their founding members were no more.. im talking Ian Curtis,Syd Barrett and Richi Edwards... i dont mean that disrespectfully.. Quite the opposite.. weird tho all the same.

[VictorRechnageL]

@ItsGrimUpNorth7 More productive? Sure, better? Far from..

[jaycarryks]

Damn i wish i was there

[tiger135775]

I can only say that I hear a song concieved in personal pain and confusion, transformed into celebration. Who better to do this than the writers closest friends. This is Greatness, Respect it.

[xbrilliantstarx]

Every time they play this it's a tribute. Remember that.

[zNazaretu]

WTF GUYS?! Why would anyone do such a thing to Joy Division...

[kreepykrawlie]

@zNazaretu

are you serious? With the demise of Ian Curtis, the other members of Joy Division went on to form New Order. They are, the surviving members of Joy Division.

[zNazaretu]

@kreepykrawlie

"remaking" Joy Division is a blesphemy in my opinion, sorry :)

[kreepykrawlie]

@zNazaretu

This isn't a "Remake" of the song! this is the band performing the song they performed with Ian Curtis! Learn the history of Joy Divison and New Order, and you will see that this is not a "remade" version of the song or any other Joy Division songs they might play. Long Live Ian Curtis! Long Live Joy Division! Long Live New Order!

[ilidian309]

@zNazaretu asshole

[zNazaretu]

@ilidian309

love you too

[ilidian309]

@zNazaretu you are a blasphemy

[deccy11456]

@zNazaretu dude seriously - get some knowledge in music, New Order ARE Joy Division just without Ian Curtis so it isnt a re make its a song they wrote together and are performing in respect to him, they waited about 6 years to first perform this in tribute to him, and we salute them! R.I.P Ian Curtis!

[zNazaretu]

@deccy11456

What I meant to say is that I think that bands like Joy Division should not start performing again after they were dissolved. The same goes for ABBA and such. New Order will NEVER be what Joy Division was back in the days. And I do not mean just the music, but the whole cultural context.

And I must admit that I was not right about the remake thing, sorry for that, I was told that it is a new version of the song by a friend and I couldn't watch the whole video due to my lowbandwitch

[zNazaretu]

@kreepykrawlie

that exactly what they are : " the surviving members of Joy Division"

they are in my opinion in now way comparable to Joy Division

[rodrigosz97]

AMAZING

[SuperDraven69]

just no..

[Chavndemo]

That should have been all 4 members of Joy Division at Glasgow there in 2008... what could have been...

[majkowataaa]

He can try but he will never fill Ian! Not in this song!

[kareeji]

Hooky! Everyone else from JD! WE LOVE YOU GUYS! I know nobody from that lot will ever see this comment, but we all will NEVER forget Joy Division and the impact it made on music.

[abagail4me]

Fucking amazing how they could pull off such a great rendition of this classic 28 years on.And to to think they would never touch the JD stuff in the 80's/90's,I'm glad they changed their minds eventually,

[pauer1001]

Joy divison new order absolutely awsome a lot better than recent music

[bhoyjack]

@giguchan Ha fair 1 mate. The Smiths amongst my favourite Manc bands too... Though New Order came from the good side of Manchester - the RED Side...

[seanoc123]

RIP Ian.

[ivdavo]

THANKS IAN CURTIS!!

[PRINCESSCRASH1]

love is making me put this song on repeat

[panditabanks]

JOY DIVISION/NEW ORDER/WARSAW/ THE BEST BAND IN THE WORLD!

[tailoredplus]

You can see the pain on their faces like they're all saying inside "here's to you, Ian"

[joepmitchell]

@tailoredplus my thoughts exactly..

[xTnT87]

@tailoredplus Are you sure? Or they are thinking, "fuck you Ian for screwing up our million dollar plan on the eve of our tour"

Just imagine someone taking your fame and money away the next morning you wake up like that.

[tailoredplus]

@xTnT87 man you're horrible. someone died man. I think they would be a bit less concerned about money when their friend died.

[xTnT87]

@tailoredplus Are you kidding me? No? He suicided which was selfish on Ian's part. Joy Divison was pissed as hell on him and anyone in their shoes should be too back then.

[tailoredplus]

@xTnT87 uhm.. that's entirely an opinion. I am not going to argue this with you cos you're clearly warped in this view.

[tailoredplus]

@AestheticalFiction I do have depression, jack ass.

[piperiu]

@xTnT87 don't judge.and Ian's decision upset the band,but not in the way "hey,how the fuck we gonna take the gig further?".that way was the producers way.or not.re-editing brings more money.R.I.P. IAN

[JackTheKiller89]

this is real music..¡¡¡

long live ian curtis¡¡¡ R.I.P.

:,(

[getsmith]

Joy Division was an unpolished band of kids who had yet to cut their teeth on their music talent. New Order became what Joy Division had only dreamed of becoming. Had Curtis lived Joy Division would have never seen the success that New Order did. (period)

[AngiieeOx]

absolute anthem ...nothing will ever be better than this tuneeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[hamburgler124]

electric drums!!? lame

[Zilencez94]

@hamburgler124 You obviously don't know anything about Joy Division...

[hamburgler124]

@Zilencez94 care to elaborate?

[csakesz182]

1:47... hmm... why i can't see any young boys or girls there? why have we sunk this deep, that youngsters don't listen to normal music? okay, don't be offended, i listen other genres, but the greatest band is Joy Division/New Order, but this is what i call music, not that 2 beats that loops through 4 minutes or so.

[madethis2comment]

@csakesz182 If it makes you feel better, I'm 15 and I would have done anything to be there :)

[Polyfusia]

@csakesz182 Probably because most concerts are drinking age and over to attend only, so they can sell liquor.

[imnorml904]

@csakesz182 i don't know about greatest band, but i do agree with you and i'm only 21. people growing up today have turned music into a monetary object. there is no love or feeling anymore. it saddens me that i feel like no great music with ever be created again, music that makes you feel good to be alive. LONG LIVE THE SIXTIES!!

[gogolplex74]

Ian curtis would be proud

[bhoyjack]

Manchesters best...

[vanpablo79]

tie, tie my kangaroo down again..... i was was very littlw when i first heard JD but what fantastic music.

[wftjet]

I think the only argument for them not playing this song is the analogy I've heard of AC/DC not playing "It's a long way to the top if you wanna rock and roll" anymore because that was a song identified with Bon Scott the former lead singer. But ultimately that's a decision left to the band themselves. New Order certainly can pack a concert hall without playing Love will Tear Us Apart at all. This song is a part of their history and it's good to celebrate it and their former bandmate with fans.

[RainPoetry]

I respect Joy Division, but my love for New Order knows no bounds. They are more my cup of tea.

[DaveyBoyEssexUK]

steve is fantastic on the drums!! oh dear not more crap about the Joy Division New Order being different bands geeez grow up!

[matthadfield8]

Quality song, but Curtis is irreplaceable.

[owenmeister]

The swans also has their own version of this song...but I like the version of New Order much better.. it's more lively than the swans.

[JohnsonFinland]

This cover kicks ass!

except for Ian curtis he's no longe