There used to be a video around here that showed here sing this live. However, it was later deleted or made private or something. But from what I heard, Autotune is doint its work very well. And btw, since she went into all the trouble of "singing" this, she should at least have tried to learn the words...
I'm not sure how I feel about this. She does well on the lower sections, the runs, and some of the higher parts, but it is clear that much of the coloratura material is not suited for her voice.
hani şehirlerimiz çarpık ve kültürsüzdür ya; hani binalarımız estetikten ve ferahlıktan yosundur ya; hani bazu apartmanların boyası, sıvası yoktur ya; hani bazıları karnını doyuramayıp en pahalı cep telefonunu blackberryi alır ya; bu da öyle birşey... bir rezalet, bir fiyasko bir kültürsüzlük örneği...
@falkolik oryantalist bi şeyler katmaya çalışmış anladım tabi olabilirde snlardaki o tekno pop mudur nedir bence çok kötü beğendiysen bilemem tabi zevk sonuçta
that's not original. there are only 4 female singers left in the world that have a super high voice. original song was maded in my country, Slovenia, and it's called -kraljica noči- but that's the same as queen of the night. but there are alot of diffrent songs also called kraljica noči, so if you want to see original then don't watch in on youtube because you will get something else. and don't send me messeges that l'm saying that sertab erener isn't good, i'm only saying that it isn't original
@ivancek11 Excuse me... What original are you tallking about? This is QUEEN OF THE NIGHT. It's aria from Mozart's opera Magic flute. There are many pop versions of this but original is OPERA ARIA, and not some slovenian song. And those SUPER HIGH VOICES are calld coloratura sopranos, and there are more than just 4 of them in the world because they are not dinosaurs to vanish. Soprano is high female voice and there are dramatic, liric and coloratura soprano. Go to opera and find one of them!
@MissGoldenAngelGirl Doesn't have a sense of music? On the contrary. This is very disrespectful to both Mozart and also Schikaneder who bothered to write the words for this aria.
@MissGoldenAngelGirl I'm not saying YOU are disrespecting Mozart and Schikaneder, I'm saying that Miss Erener, who is in many other ways a lovely artist, isn't respecting Mozart and Schikaneder when she distorts Mozart's music like this and disregards Schikaneder's words. The words for this aria is in German, btw.
@MissGoldenAngelGirl You know, opera was born in Italy in 17th century and the most popular opera composers are from Italy like Verdi, Puccini, Rossini, Donizeti, Belini, but also there are other composers from other countries that wrote operas like german composers Wagner and Mozart (who wrote this aria and it's on german since Mozart was born in Salzburg) and Bizet, Gounod (France), Tchaikovsky, Musorgsky (Russia) etc. Please don't speek about something you don't know anything about!
@MissGoldenAngelGirl And btw I am an opera singer and I have never heard of greek opera... LOL :)))) But I love Sertab and she is one of the greatest singers of the world and all turkish people should be proud to have her!!!
OF COURSE WE ARE! SHE WON EUROVISION 2006 WITH HER BEAUTIFUL VOICE! You could go check it on youtube. Just type in "Sertab Erener 2006 Eurovision Every Way That I Can". The pictures on 0:09 , 0:10 , 0:36 , 0:37 , 0:42 , 0:46 show that. :))
I'm Turkish and I love Sertab but this doesn't even come close to Lucia Popp's version of the magic flute... Sertab definitely has a great potential but she's not on a par with the true sopranos yet...
oh my god--what a load of old shite, reminds of britians got talent--a fat bloke and his son wobbling thier fat about on national tv--this is just as crass.
Pure genious!! I love this track because a) I am an opera singer since I started training at 17 and b) Because I am also a belly dancer since I was 19... so this tune embodies BOTH my favorite hobbies!!!
Niemand wird vergewaltigt ... Sie hat diese Version nie offiziell veröffentlicht, war im Studio einfach mal "lustig" drauf und hat das nebenbei aufgenommen ... Ich finde es lustig und interessant. Sie ist eine Popsängerin und ich finds toll, was sie alles mit ihrer Stimme machen kann.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
kadininin sesi mikrofondan bile zor duyuluyor ....sinek gibi ses ayrica pop tada meshur ettiler ya helal olsun sebnem ferah 5 basar ona hadi bye kapak olmustur yazdiklarim herhalde
this is the weirdest alternative version to the song, but her voice has more promise than most others doing strange versions... pity she isnt a soprano because shed be pretty good
@Sanbika89 That's her version! The main thing is that she can sing these sounds clear and beautiful. And if she want, she would sing along with the text, but it is HER version!
arkadaşım şu cahillerin düşündüklerini haklı algılamalarına izin verme bu cümlelerle....müzikten anladığını zanneden bu idiyotlar notalara eklenecek her bir yeni tınıyı baharat olarak değil orijinalliğe saldırı olarak algılarlar.senin yerinde olsam yazmazdım böyle.sertaba da ayıp bi yerde
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Horrible! Listen to Damrau! How could they Eurotrash beat Mozart. This girl moves the larynx on the runs, she's disgusting. Her high notes are unsupported dog whistles. Horrible.
If you really like pop music but Sertap r sanatçısıdı proven, but still I can do this kind of muzikte the best in pop music dalda so I prefer to listen to heavy rock in place
Granted her voice is beautiful, I have to agree with other people. She did not sing the song, merely sang the notes. She gets a score for trying though.
It is so much easier to sing these notes on one syllable than to sing words. All vowels sit in different places and to keep them consistent throughout the range required in this aria is incredibly difficult. While this woman undoubtedly has a lovely voice, she has not 'sung' the aria...it's a vocalise, nothing more.
Unfortunately the sound quality of the video isn't giving Sertab credit. Her voice is in real life fanstactic, I loved her music since I heard her in Ankara in 1998
it is interesting. her voice is good, yet it does lack a bit of clarity and maybe a little prettiness. she is a gorgeous girl. i see her in the vein of callas. in that callas was known more for her ability to deliver and present the music and not as much for her tone and quality. this genius lies in the interpretation somewhat similar to sarah brightman in that she redefines something that is already established as being more in the classical genre. very interesting.
Why have they added a dance beat? It really doesn't fit this aria. Maybe that's why they took out the words. She has a nice voice, but maybe she should be singing pop instead of opera, especially if pop is her main musical focus. i.e. I sing opera; I CAN sing pop, but it's better if I do opera. You'd be hard-pressed to find someone who could do both opera & pop EQUALLY well, because the 2 styles are like oil and water. This is not intended to be a negative comment, so please do not "retaliate."
to mkm576, they added the dance beat to add some turkish flavor :) you might not like it, but i think it went gracefully with it. well, i think if she had some lessons may be she'll be great at it, who knows... but i thought i was lovely.
Sertab's voice is flawless. Anyone, here, who makes negative, snooty comments about her not being up to the standard of this song shows themselves up to be seriously lacking in intellect as well as musical clout. I'd go away and read some musicial literature before I made such an ill-informed statement, if I were you. Which, thank God, I'm not.
I wouldn't call it trerribly bad, it's just that you can hear that she isn't using the proper support for her voice, and thus is probably faking it with studio magic. I've heard this sung live by terrific singers.. I would be very surprised if she could pull this off live.
Nothing against the singer, probably very good doing her normal stuff, just not ready for a piece like this.
All the negative comments here are full with evil,jealousy,and most of them wrong.Open a book learn something and then if you steel have the nerve post a comment other wise stay with you misery
that version is amazing. but ofcourse, maria callas and she cannot be compared. while sertab was at university, she studies maria callas too. and reaching a note is all about your body, its biological and about using the right techique. if someone says "you canot evet reach E", it is like "your hair isnt even yellow!" they are both nonsense
amazin... and that F!!!! amazing! somebody said... "She should also apologize to Mozart" ...bleh! I sang opera for years and I could say.. that's amazing...a good voice! yeah! she should sing in German or wherever... but the most important in this aria is the voice... remember, the most importan soprano called María Callas, never played this role cuz she can't reach to an F.... U should think about it!
Nonsense!!! Having high F does not make singer excellent!!! And don't dare to compare maria and sertab. One is an opera queen and the other is a .... i don't know what ;) This is not an appropriate role for maria callas even if she had a high F. Her voice was very dark for this role (medea,tosca or macbeth best suit her). And Sertab does not sing it with lyrics because it's easier to say o-o-o-o. I don't think she can reach high F with the lyrics.
Zahmet edip lirikleri ezberleseydi bari... Sesi kolaratur özelliğinin hiçbiri taşımıyorken nasıl bu ariette ya cesaret edebilmiş hayret ... Çok kötü..Amatörce ve vulgar...
Kolaratur özelliğinin hiçbirini taşımıyor mu? Sertab bu ariayı okuduğunda kolaratur olduğunu şan hocaları bile kabul ediyor. Bence bir araştır. Kötü söylediğini söyleyenebilir ama kolaratur özelliğini taşımıyor denemez. Fakat kolaratur özelliği derken çok başka şeyden bahsediyorsan bilemem. Kolaraturun özelliği fa diyezden dönüş yapan en tizleri veren kıvrak ses olması benim bildiğim ve Sertab geçen yıla kadar bunu yapabilen bir kolaratur sopranoydu.
And, Aretha Franklin did "Nessun Dorma:, and not too badly, either. Some (too many) think opera is to snobbish already. Put it in something they understand. I say, GO FOR IT! I would rather be singing that, than not singing at all. She has a God given talent, and she is using it. Good for her.
A lovely woman and an interesting rendition. Mozart probably would have enjoyed it. Part of his popularity was writing this in German, when Italian was the vogue. He wrote, dare I say it, popular music...it just happened to be opera in 1790. No TV, no cable, no Superbowl. Folks went to the theatre and to the opera for entertainment, much like we go to movies. Give her some credit. Streisand did it, too. No big deal. Look at it this way, she is bringing opera to lots of people.
hey people, this is just great, why are you that much narrow-minded? the original is a great masterpiece,i admit that, but you can not blame her because she created sth new by putting the great work into a new concept. respect.
There is something missing here. Let's see... what could it be? Oh yeah, THIS... Der Hölle Rache kocht in meinem Herzen, Tod und Verzweiflung flammet um mich her! Fühlt nicht durch dich Sarastro Todesschmerzen, So bist du meine Tochter nimmermehr. Verstossen sei auf ewig, Verlassen sei auf ewig, Zertrümmert sei'n auf ewig Alle Bande der Natur Wenn nicht durch dich! Sarastro wird erblassen! Hört, Rachegötter, Hört der Mutter Schwur!
What the hell was that! Ms. Erener needs to stick to her own genre and not screw around with great works of the masters. I think we need to honor the composer's original intent. Poor Mozart, rolling around in his grave like that. Shameful!
PS If one is going to sing "Der Hölle Rache" the least one could do is learn the damn lyrics.
It has nothing to do with whether she can sing or not. That is not the issue. Mozart wrote this piece with a specific idea in mind. I would no more like to see the "Mona Lisa" or Michelangelo's "David" defaced and that goes the same with music. Do we not owe the composer the same respect as we would a visual artist. Certainly, some pop artists such as Michael Bolton have ventured into the classical world. But he at least attempted to respect the composers original intent. Just a thought.
it is the worst i have ever heard... She is a fabulous singer for a specific field and she has proved it when she won the eurovision contest. But here, she took a machine gun and shot this magnificent and really hard to sing opera song. We cannot sing everything...
here the ''opera diva'' shows her ''talent'' in killing songs because she doesn't know the lyrics,her vibrato simply doesn't exist and for the top of the cake she wanted to make that beautiful aria an oriental song...putting the word opera and sertabin the same sentence is just an insult to all great composers...she sure has talent but for pop (not an insult)
There is nothing negativ in this singing expect for that she doesn't know the lyrics and her voice is tired. The one who has a few informations about the Opera and Voice can understand it easily...
Yeah, it really is.
SpiderTear 1 week ago
There used to be a video around here that showed here sing this live. However, it was later deleted or made private or something. But from what I heard, Autotune is doint its work very well. And btw, since she went into all the trouble of "singing" this, she should at least have tried to learn the words...
Tigerkos 1 week ago
I'm not sure how I feel about this. She does well on the lower sections, the runs, and some of the higher parts, but it is clear that much of the coloratura material is not suited for her voice.
TGTSTS 2 weeks ago
hah I LOVE IT!!!!
dotbishop 1 month ago
NO. NO. NO.
ChrissieBana 1 month ago
Fail..... if you're gonna sing this song one has to sing the words. Blaspheme against Mozart if you don't
SunnyWithGreenEyes 3 months ago
Arg, she totally butchers an amazing song.
SpiderTear 4 months ago
@SpiderTear its not that bad..
MsPingu112 1 week ago
hani şehirlerimiz çarpık ve kültürsüzdür ya; hani binalarımız estetikten ve ferahlıktan yosundur ya; hani bazu apartmanların boyası, sıvası yoktur ya; hani bazıları karnını doyuramayıp en pahalı cep telefonunu blackberryi alır ya; bu da öyle birşey... bir rezalet, bir fiyasko bir kültürsüzlük örneği...
vanderoost111 5 months ago
bu ses çok eski gibi!!!!!! bu ses gibi dünya yok 2011!!!!!
MsReis86 6 months ago
Stimme=Sehr schön
Version=verunstaltung des Original (ÄTZENDER MAINSTREAM POP)
PilleBlitzkrieg 7 months ago
@PilleBlitzkrieg Finde ich auch. :(
SaphiraSiLva001 5 months ago
jealous people.
loNdonTGB 7 months ago
All that techno junk just ruins this song.
Nsmash2K 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sertab sings good, but how about Aziza )))
watch?v=8_vaXzMaOGA
javidgulijev 8 months ago
Comment removed
javidgulijev 8 months ago
Fantasticno ,za svaku pohvalu !!! MASTERPIECE
vrbas100 8 months ago
@vrbas100 Zaista neverovatno. Toliko svestrana u pevanju...
manebu11 8 months ago
berbat ya bu neeeee
marmara4 8 months ago
@marmara4 ne anlarsın sen!
falkolik 7 months ago
@falkolik oryantalist bi şeyler katmaya çalışmış anladım tabi olabilirde snlardaki o tekno pop mudur nedir bence çok kötü beğendiysen bilemem tabi zevk sonuçta
marmara4 7 months ago
that's not original. there are only 4 female singers left in the world that have a super high voice. original song was maded in my country, Slovenia, and it's called -kraljica noči- but that's the same as queen of the night. but there are alot of diffrent songs also called kraljica noči, so if you want to see original then don't watch in on youtube because you will get something else. and don't send me messeges that l'm saying that sertab erener isn't good, i'm only saying that it isn't original
ivancek11 8 months ago
@ivancek11 Excuse me... What original are you tallking about? This is QUEEN OF THE NIGHT. It's aria from Mozart's opera Magic flute. There are many pop versions of this but original is OPERA ARIA, and not some slovenian song. And those SUPER HIGH VOICES are calld coloratura sopranos, and there are more than just 4 of them in the world because they are not dinosaurs to vanish. Soprano is high female voice and there are dramatic, liric and coloratura soprano. Go to opera and find one of them!
User320g 8 months ago
She could at least bother to learn the damn lyrics, ugh poor poor Mozart
BleedTheWineUnholy 9 months ago
Poor Mozart!!!
idonperg 11 months ago
one word: awesome!
alextr75 1 year ago
@bananahamek you must have been bananas
celinn34 1 year ago
OMG WHAT THE F*** IS JUSTIN BIEBER DOING HERE
GET YOUR FU**ING COMMENTS OUT OF HERE AND PUT IT ON HIS VIDEOS!!!
SETAB ERENER'S VOICE IS AWESOME, WHAT'S THERE NOT TO UNDERSTAND???
and im sure those 193 people who unliked this video DOESNT HAVE A SENSE OF MUSIC!
my God....
MissGoldenAngelGirl 1 year ago
@MissGoldenAngelGirl Doesn't have a sense of music? On the contrary. This is very disrespectful to both Mozart and also Schikaneder who bothered to write the words for this aria.
MadonnaImperia 1 year ago
@MadonnaImperia
what??? im not disrespecting mozart os schikaneder
im telling all these people here to get their justin bieber comments out of here.
and well of course she's not singing the words because she doesnt know italian or greek she is turkish as well as i am
You know the words for opera's are usually italian or greek. it said on a play i went about music and mozart....
MissGoldenAngelGirl 1 year ago
@MissGoldenAngelGirl I'm not saying YOU are disrespecting Mozart and Schikaneder, I'm saying that Miss Erener, who is in many other ways a lovely artist, isn't respecting Mozart and Schikaneder when she distorts Mozart's music like this and disregards Schikaneder's words. The words for this aria is in German, btw.
MadonnaImperia 1 year ago
@MissGoldenAngelGirl You know, opera was born in Italy in 17th century and the most popular opera composers are from Italy like Verdi, Puccini, Rossini, Donizeti, Belini, but also there are other composers from other countries that wrote operas like german composers Wagner and Mozart (who wrote this aria and it's on german since Mozart was born in Salzburg) and Bizet, Gounod (France), Tchaikovsky, Musorgsky (Russia) etc. Please don't speek about something you don't know anything about!
User320g 8 months ago
@MissGoldenAngelGirl And btw I am an opera singer and I have never heard of greek opera... LOL :)))) But I love Sertab and she is one of the greatest singers of the world and all turkish people should be proud to have her!!!
User320g 8 months ago
Comment removed
MissGoldenAngelGirl 8 months ago
@User320g
OF COURSE WE ARE! SHE WON EUROVISION 2006 WITH HER BEAUTIFUL VOICE! You could go check it on youtube. Just type in "Sertab Erener 2006 Eurovision Every Way That I Can". The pictures on 0:09 , 0:10 , 0:36 , 0:37 , 0:42 , 0:46 show that. :))
MissGoldenAngelGirl 8 months ago
@MissGoldenAngelGirl Of course I know she won Eurovision!!! That's when I discovered her... She is amazing in every way... :)
User320g 8 months ago
Where are the words? Oh wait... what's up with all these things Mozart didn't write into the score???
thelightisahead 1 year ago
abominable pour ma part!!!!
je n'ai même pas pu écouter jusqu'au bout, 05 sc me sufisent a me casser les oreilles!
quel gachis......
MsMacnini 1 year ago
@MsMacnini
Ah oui???
quelques rythmes orientales dans cette piece ne tuera personne mon bebe
anasassaad2 1 year ago
Epic fail!!
julesverne1828 1 year ago
@julesverne1828 he is justin bieber first mate.
mRamble 1 year ago
EPIC FAIL!
kosmatejajce 1 year ago
@kosmatejajce he is justin bieber.
mRamble 1 year ago
Sertab's voice is excellent and her rendition of this song sublime.
thebfunkthebfunk 1 year ago 2
189 people missed the like button I guess....
merdzina005 1 year ago
@merdzina005
U mean they are drunk
anasassaad2 1 year ago
@anasassaad2 Exactly haha xD
merdzina005 1 year ago
Sertab beyaw... Ne gerek vardı?
erginakif 1 year ago
I'm Turkish and I love Sertab but this doesn't even come close to Lucia Popp's version of the magic flute... Sertab definitely has a great potential but she's not on a par with the true sopranos yet...
oz83 1 year ago
this is an insult to mozart! 14 year old boys can sing this better
MarioJonasfan96 1 year ago
@MarioJonasfan96 that´s your opinion and robin schlotz can´t sing it better than sertab erener!!
halibelxXxsinan 1 year ago
@halibelxXxsinan yea probably not now because of a little bitch called puberty hehe
MarioJonasfan96 1 year ago
@MarioJonasfan96 okay?!?
in my point of view sertab erener sings it better than robin schlotz!
halibelxXxsinan 1 year ago 3
@MarioJonasfan96 show me one who can! lol
MsPingu112 1 week ago
C'est quoi cette merde !!!!!!
abracadabranque 1 year ago
Define: kitsch: bad taste + good intentions.
dabija123 1 year ago
Şu bizim Türkler...
Yabancılar bize hayranmış izlenimi vermek için... lütfen Ingilizce yazılar yazmasın buraya.
Filsje 1 year ago 3
cool
keriah17 1 year ago 2
oh my god--what a load of old shite, reminds of britians got talent--a fat bloke and his son wobbling thier fat about on national tv--this is just as crass.
ronaldosucks1 1 year ago
LOL
collegeboundmusician 1 year ago
0:17 what?!
NINING528 1 year ago 5
Gee...what a crap! Pure aria...
LimDul84 1 year ago
@LimDul84 racism still lives!
loNdonTGB 7 months ago
Pure genious!! I love this track because a) I am an opera singer since I started training at 17 and b) Because I am also a belly dancer since I was 19... so this tune embodies BOTH my favorite hobbies!!!
marniedrew 1 year ago 6
heyhab total lust bilder tauschen und chatn bin so einsam brauche dringend beschäftigung
AmeerahAmdis1 1 year ago
Niemand wird vergewaltigt ... Sie hat diese Version nie offiziell veröffentlicht, war im Studio einfach mal "lustig" drauf und hat das nebenbei aufgenommen ... Ich finde es lustig und interessant. Sie ist eine Popsängerin und ich finds toll, was sie alles mit ihrer Stimme machen kann.
makcaliboy 1 year ago
I liked it. No boundaries to music. And Sertab has a good pitch whatsoever.
Güzel Türkiye.
mroziewicz 1 year ago
This is crap !!
dimitri797 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kadininin sesi mikrofondan bile zor duyuluyor ....sinek gibi ses ayrica pop tada meshur ettiler ya helal olsun sebnem ferah 5 basar ona hadi bye kapak olmustur yazdiklarim herhalde
MultiTiner 1 year ago
am sure this record happens after she shaw the fith element
hahahahah!!!
narkiss69 1 year ago
me destruyeron el aria :S
rickwakeman123 1 year ago
this is the weirdest alternative version to the song, but her voice has more promise than most others doing strange versions... pity she isnt a soprano because shed be pretty good
aalg4c 1 year ago
Hey... it's quite fun to listen to. Love it!
This is good, it says music needs no language ;)
meiers 2 years ago 3
Someone didn't feel like learning the words...
Sanbika89 2 years ago 27
@Sanbika89
lmao to be fair, not worth it to learn german for one song she probably wont sing again
firegoat 1 year ago
@Sanbika89 That's her version! The main thing is that she can sing these sounds clear and beautiful. And if she want, she would sing along with the text, but it is HER version!
Sertab Erener, you rock!
ladydefne 5 months ago
diana damrau ile sertabın şuanki yorumunu karşılaştırma yapmak cahillikten başka bişey değildir. harikasın sertap..
anilalos2009 2 years ago
It's certainly different. To my own surprise, I found myself liking it.
jlewis31510 2 years ago 2
oh no!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tartarafa 2 years ago
Mozart is rolling over in his grave
nellieou 2 years ago
i bet you can see him downthere
gbk84 2 years ago
turks make this beautiful arya like an arabic belly dans music!!
bangoramas 2 years ago 2
and it turned out lovely as well
makcaliboy 1 year ago
@bangoramas
you are a fucking monkey yor bastard
sayitm30 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is bullshit!
folieaxel 2 years ago
she performed this song in her album "Sertab Erener" in 1999. Ten years ago! she was kinda amator... she's much better now!
one of the bestest! ='D
titanayus 2 years ago 3
arkadaşım şu cahillerin düşündüklerini haklı algılamalarına izin verme bu cümlelerle....müzikten anladığını zanneden bu idiyotlar notalara eklenecek her bir yeni tınıyı baharat olarak değil orijinalliğe saldırı olarak algılarlar.senin yerinde olsam yazmazdım böyle.sertaba da ayıp bi yerde
gbk84 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Horrible! Listen to Damrau! How could they Eurotrash beat Mozart. This girl moves the larynx on the runs, she's disgusting. Her high notes are unsupported dog whistles. Horrible.
angelovocci 2 years ago
This is a disgrace to Mozart and the amazing women who have performed this piece without flaw.
shannonrj713 2 years ago
long live copy-paste :-P
Singinganneke 2 years ago
wtf that ruin the song !
Freutsich22 2 years ago
Orrifico e disgustoso!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Amadeus4ever 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
disgusting!
msinvincible2000 2 years ago
she is a perfect...
blackturk1 2 years ago
amator ses icin iyi
0ttomaniaC 2 years ago
amator??
whed005 2 years ago
She has got great voice!
Wooow! Go Turkey!
I like turkish people they are very generous and polite.
smiletolifeny 2 years ago 41
This has been flagged as spam show
herşey Allahın dilemesiyle oluyorsa zinadamı böyle oluyor. hani herşey Allahın dilemesiyle oluyordu?
Allahım bizi saptırma diyonuz mu? demek ki sizi saptıran kimmiş? Allah ne yapacağımızı önceden biliyor.
böyle imtihan olur mu? bilgi için ismimi tıkla
bettabiyat 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is the kind of music they must play in Hell.
HConstantine 2 years ago
Sertab belongs to heaven my friend.
BonusBond007 2 years ago
I like this version and here voice is amazing ;)
operaclassicc 2 years ago
sertab zaten küçük yaştan beri müzik eğitimi aldı...bunu söylemek size düşmez...kendisi de pop müzik sanatçısı olmak istediğini dile getirmşti..
zknks 2 years ago
belki küçük yaştan beri opera eğitimi alsaydı inanılmaz bir opera sanatçısı olabilirmiş.. yazık..
gencodiz 2 years ago
If you really like pop music but Sertap r sanatçısıdı proven, but still I can do this kind of muzikte the best in pop music dalda so I prefer to listen to heavy rock in place
wandess 2 years ago
wtf?
ANOTHERify 2 years ago
Granted her voice is beautiful, I have to agree with other people. She did not sing the song, merely sang the notes. She gets a score for trying though.
QueenNaiomi 2 years ago
Comment removed
AlexanderZographos 2 years ago
It is so much easier to sing these notes on one syllable than to sing words. All vowels sit in different places and to keep them consistent throughout the range required in this aria is incredibly difficult. While this woman undoubtedly has a lovely voice, she has not 'sung' the aria...it's a vocalise, nothing more.
rosinlr 2 years ago 2
so do it better or the same and why we dont see you on youtube you retarded mother fucker dick sucker loser son of a bitch.
cembone 2 years ago
Comment removed
dabija123 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree, there are some real clunky spots where her singing is flat. Not good at all.
IC2720 2 years ago
she is amazing!
Zadiel82 2 years ago 27
Unfortunately the sound quality of the video isn't giving Sertab credit. Her voice is in real life fanstactic, I loved her music since I heard her in Ankara in 1998
karinastrup 2 years ago 3
it is interesting. her voice is good, yet it does lack a bit of clarity and maybe a little prettiness. she is a gorgeous girl. i see her in the vein of callas. in that callas was known more for her ability to deliver and present the music and not as much for her tone and quality. this genius lies in the interpretation somewhat similar to sarah brightman in that she redefines something that is already established as being more in the classical genre. very interesting.
roberthayman 2 years ago
Why have they added a dance beat? It really doesn't fit this aria. Maybe that's why they took out the words. She has a nice voice, but maybe she should be singing pop instead of opera, especially if pop is her main musical focus. i.e. I sing opera; I CAN sing pop, but it's better if I do opera. You'd be hard-pressed to find someone who could do both opera & pop EQUALLY well, because the 2 styles are like oil and water. This is not intended to be a negative comment, so please do not "retaliate."
mkm576 2 years ago
to mkm576, they added the dance beat to add some turkish flavor :) you might not like it, but i think it went gracefully with it. well, i think if she had some lessons may be she'll be great at it, who knows... but i thought i was lovely.
TurkishKidd 2 years ago
she has already had lessons dude! she left conservatory in her last year to be a pop singer=') kapiş??
titanayus 2 years ago
buuuuuuuuuuuuuuh
aspropyrgos1 2 years ago
Sertab's voice is flawless. Anyone, here, who makes negative, snooty comments about her not being up to the standard of this song shows themselves up to be seriously lacking in intellect as well as musical clout. I'd go away and read some musicial literature before I made such an ill-informed statement, if I were you. Which, thank God, I'm not.
thebfunk 2 years ago
Sorry, I have to disagree. While I usually like her voice, it does not fit to this song.
You can clearly hear where it has been edited.
Seythia 2 years ago 2
It's so weird to not hear the words..
I wouldn't call it trerribly bad, it's just that you can hear that she isn't using the proper support for her voice, and thus is probably faking it with studio magic. I've heard this sung live by terrific singers.. I would be very surprised if she could pull this off live.
Nothing against the singer, probably very good doing her normal stuff, just not ready for a piece like this.
kashgarinn 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
çok kötü inanamıyorum utanmalı bence
sleepwalkerbsk 2 years ago
god music!bonne voix,!!!salut a toi,de vierzon
titiz1 2 years ago
Nice coloratura voice, a little dim though...
abelitro12 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no good weak voice -1/10
MartinKrauen 2 years ago
poor Mozart (
MrWolfring 2 years ago
All the negative comments here are full with evil,jealousy,and most of them wrong.Open a book learn something and then if you steel have the nerve post a comment other wise stay with you misery
tassos277 2 years ago
exactly !!
tosunbey 2 years ago
perfect!
zknks 2 years ago
It is Sertab Ereners voice.
streetstylegee 2 years ago
Somebody please supply this chick with the lyrics to this aria...
Oh! and how very accomplished of her to take the time and effort to distroy this aria.
Brava!
phoranea 2 years ago
Evolution has it's prices and that include music. You should check out the modern day CASTRATO in Briatain's Got Talent - Greg Pritchard
tongw7393 2 years ago
I loved it ;o)
KittyKat1334 2 years ago 3
I like it
osamalet 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This version is... hopeless? And Yes, Maria Callas and she cannot be compared.
SkislaJagoda 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what is this? she isnt even saying the words. ridiculous. and he F's arent very strong.
NicholieBugg 2 years ago
that version is amazing. but ofcourse, maria callas and she cannot be compared. while sertab was at university, she studies maria callas too. and reaching a note is all about your body, its biological and about using the right techique. if someone says "you canot evet reach E", it is like "your hair isnt even yellow!" they are both nonsense
bluegrooves 2 years ago
so succesful.. that is one of the hardest one.. congratulations to her.. the final is really awesome..
meforyu 2 years ago
Well, sure, this aria sounds better with lyrics. But I think this kind to perform this song is really great.
Mozart would love this, believe me!
DrHanLecter 2 years ago 2
ME ENCANTA - LOVE IT
rayuh87 2 years ago
who cares germanese lyrics, music is universal, if mozart was as close-minded as you, he couldn't be mozart, enjoy it:)
ayseculina 2 years ago
she can reach to a F !! amazing, great job!! love ya :D
tosunbey 2 years ago
amazin... and that F!!!! amazing! somebody said... "She should also apologize to Mozart" ...bleh! I sang opera for years and I could say.. that's amazing...a good voice! yeah! she should sing in German or wherever... but the most important in this aria is the voice... remember, the most importan soprano called María Callas, never played this role cuz she can't reach to an F.... U should think about it!
from Argentina
Marcelo
theblackvampire 2 years ago 2
Nonsense!!! Having high F does not make singer excellent!!! And don't dare to compare maria and sertab. One is an opera queen and the other is a .... i don't know what ;) This is not an appropriate role for maria callas even if she had a high F. Her voice was very dark for this role (medea,tosca or macbeth best suit her). And Sertab does not sing it with lyrics because it's easier to say o-o-o-o. I don't think she can reach high F with the lyrics.
sezgin86 2 years ago
It's very demanding and I don't want to be mean, but this doesn't cut it. I can't imagine a company using her as the Queen.
ZenPapageno 2 years ago
I thought Turks could speak German pretty well. She didn't even try.
KingOfClay 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Absolutely horrendous. She should stick with pop. She's not capable of doing both. She should also apologize to Mozart.
mightyquincy109 2 years ago
bbbbbbbbbbbbeeeeeeeeeeeuuuuuuuuuuurrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
KOKAYT1 2 years ago
Zahmet edip lirikleri ezberleseydi bari... Sesi kolaratur özelliğinin hiçbiri taşımıyorken nasıl bu ariette ya cesaret edebilmiş hayret ... Çok kötü..Amatörce ve vulgar...
graveflora 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
gilxxxxx 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kolaratur özelliğinin hiçbirini taşımıyor mu? Sertab bu ariayı okuduğunda kolaratur olduğunu şan hocaları bile kabul ediyor. Bence bir araştır. Kötü söylediğini söyleyenebilir ama kolaratur özelliğini taşımıyor denemez. Fakat kolaratur özelliği derken çok başka şeyden bahsediyorsan bilemem. Kolaraturun özelliği fa diyezden dönüş yapan en tizleri veren kıvrak ses olması benim bildiğim ve Sertab geçen yıla kadar bunu yapabilen bir kolaratur sopranoydu.
gilxxxxx 2 years ago
And, Aretha Franklin did "Nessun Dorma:, and not too badly, either. Some (too many) think opera is to snobbish already. Put it in something they understand. I say, GO FOR IT! I would rather be singing that, than not singing at all. She has a God given talent, and she is using it. Good for her.
Vairguy09 3 years ago 2
Because singing with a microphone requires about 1/50 of the skill it requires to sing real opera unamplified with proper technique.
primohomme 2 years ago
A lovely woman and an interesting rendition. Mozart probably would have enjoyed it. Part of his popularity was writing this in German, when Italian was the vogue. He wrote, dare I say it, popular music...it just happened to be opera in 1790. No TV, no cable, no Superbowl. Folks went to the theatre and to the opera for entertainment, much like we go to movies. Give her some credit. Streisand did it, too. No big deal. Look at it this way, she is bringing opera to lots of people.
Vairguy09 3 years ago 2
Nice idea, but she can't really carry it off right. Just leaves you thinking "wtf?"...
Zeppelin4962 3 years ago
Your right, she just doesn't carry the notes properly. She should stay in her lower register. tsk.
IC2720 3 years ago
sese bak ya masallah
lxEstreLLaxl 3 years ago
hey people, this is just great, why are you that much narrow-minded? the original is a great masterpiece,i admit that, but you can not blame her because she created sth new by putting the great work into a new concept. respect.
abakahan 3 years ago
syphlitic mosquito? girl.... get a genre.
Philm54 3 years ago
wtf
Jdeezy6589 3 years ago
jpaise 3 years ago
What the hell was that! Ms. Erener needs to stick to her own genre and not screw around with great works of the masters. I think we need to honor the composer's original intent. Poor Mozart, rolling around in his grave like that. Shameful!
PS If one is going to sing "Der Hölle Rache" the least one could do is learn the damn lyrics.
jpaise 3 years ago 2
Who says she doesn't know the lyrics? Maybe she decided just to do it like this in this version.
And besides, you can hear her voice is trained and he obviously went to school to sing like this, and she surely sang it there... sheesh.
Mtanic 2 years ago
It has nothing to do with whether she can sing or not. That is not the issue. Mozart wrote this piece with a specific idea in mind. I would no more like to see the "Mona Lisa" or Michelangelo's "David" defaced and that goes the same with music. Do we not owe the composer the same respect as we would a visual artist. Certainly, some pop artists such as Michael Bolton have ventured into the classical world. But he at least attempted to respect the composers original intent. Just a thought.
jpaise 2 years ago 4
how do you know Mozarts specific idea in his mind? I want to learn mind-reading too, especially composers...
ayseculina 2 years ago
wow greate performance!
Siesta87 3 years ago
i thought its amusing hahaha
spongepastel 3 years ago
it is the worst i have ever heard... She is a fabulous singer for a specific field and she has proved it when she won the eurovision contest. But here, she took a machine gun and shot this magnificent and really hard to sing opera song. We cannot sing everything...
Spirosd2 3 years ago
ew....
wha the hell??
emptyXwords 3 years ago
GROSS!
twilliger123 3 years ago 4
what the heck is this darn monstruosity?
nickalternativo 3 years ago 3
here the ''opera diva'' shows her ''talent'' in killing songs because she doesn't know the lyrics,her vibrato simply doesn't exist and for the top of the cake she wanted to make that beautiful aria an oriental song...putting the word opera and sertabin the same sentence is just an insult to all great composers...she sure has talent but for pop (not an insult)
kotopoulo13 3 years ago 4
But she studied solo singing, why shouldn't she sing that, too???
Mtanic 2 years ago 2
There is nothing negativ in this singing expect for that she doesn't know the lyrics and her voice is tired. The one who has a few informations about the Opera and Voice can understand it easily...
gilxxxxx 3 years ago
its beautyfull!!!
hooajo 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Poor Mozart! This girl must stop singing... Stupid...
ot73nl 3 years ago
what a pity to take some "grande musique" to make such a mess . anyway she has a great voice .
tchebinai71 3 years ago
But she is a well-educated and capable coluratura soprano...
aalpan 3 years ago 2