Added: 4 years ago
From: CombatSpecialist18
Views: 198,135
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (581)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • nice :))

  • It's much better like this than English, along with the series being better in Japanese.

    But damn learning the song in Russian ain't easy...

  • Try to read literally the following text and you should have no problems with pronounciation.

    Prosti miñia madshi brat, ya tak pritavoi vinovat, puitatsa viernuts nirzia, tago shto vira zimlia.

    Kto snayet avon buitiya, pamon bui mñe naiti otviet, shestoko oshibsya ya, At smirti likortva ñit.

    Milaya mama nieshnaya, mui tak lubili tibia, no shie nashi sirui potrashisni buiri sia.

    Tebya soblaznil ya, prekrashnay naidishdoy, Virnut nashiminya cha, mui brat ya va tsom vinovat.

  • Ñie prash ñie pichal sia, starshy brat, ñie tyi odin vinovat, darrogoka u nas odna, Iskupim vinu da dna.

    Ñie ñiev chem tiba uprekot, i ya ñiabishu nichut, tiashek na grik, tachi bitsiñi vik.

    Milaya mama niesh aya, mui tak lubili tibia, no sie nashi sirui potrashisni buiri sia.

    Ya sam soblasnilsia, prekrasna nadishdoy, vrenut nash simivia cha, ya sam vo vsom vinovat.

    No shto shanam viela, ka buit? Kak so ispravit, zabit? Pritatsa vernut ñielsia, tago shto vira zimlia.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • The greatest anime song..... from the greatest anime ever made...... This song gets me so depressed and maked me love my mom even more..... Its so hard to listen to this song without feeling your heart being touched with emotion...... I agree. The only thing that FMA:Brotherhood lacked was ONLY this song. Or else it was equally good. The greatest anime sequel ever made....

  • @dark4krad it also lact the depth that the origional had, and it was a rush and it had a gay we all won ending, go teem go, no it was a terrible series half way in on brotherhood, this song wouldve helped alot tho'

  • you call that russian lyrics ?

  • Как же я люблю эту песню, и "Алхимика" Т_Т Так много плакала...

  • no offense this sounds jappanese

  • @swaggerthejagger1

    HOW?! pray tell, how?!

  • @swaggerthejagger1 ...no. You just hush, right now.

  • @swaggerthejagger1 Dude... O.o You're either trying to be offensive, or you've no idea what Russian and Japanese sound like, they're in no way similar.

  • russian : beautiful

    english : calming

    and no im not talking about hetalia ;)

  • Russia and his sad songs... *shakes head*

    And Japan composed this, too! Seriously, they need to lighten up.

  • @130cookies I just hope his heart didn't fall out while writing this.....

  • Anyone else try to sing along and fail miserably...?

  • @breathlessloveless not me, i'm russian, so that makes it a whole lot easier hahah~ as for the quality of my singing.. i'll just keep quiet about that. XD

  • @iCrazyAnnie I'm Serbian, and I understand quite a lot. :)

  • @breathlessloveless It takes a while, but you'll get it. It took me about a month and a half to get all the words right. I can sing this song entirely in english, & russian without messing up too badly. Keep practicing, it's always fun when somebody who loves the show tries singing it in english and you break into russian. lol

  • fail lyriks xD

  • I synched the russian with the english one and it sounded almost like a choir!!

  • if you understand russian you can see how well this song matches FMA

  • @MrJustakaz "how can i repay you, brother of mine? How can i expect you to forgive? Clinging to the past i shared our blood and shattered your chance to live". It was written FOR fma, so it makes sense that the lyrics match. And you don't have to understand russian, Ed's dub actor has sung an english versian of it.

  • listen to them both put togethor, english and the russian....I have tears in my eyes right now xD

  • Beast

  • I didn't understand but it sounds so beautiful, I cried T.T

  • This should've been ysed for Brotherhood.

  • i learned ed's part and now i sing it all the time and my music teacher is loke o.O what the hell are you singing???XD i love this song NOTE:im girl but this used to be my brothers user

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I hope my neighboors like this... :)

  • @evabellgardens me too :D

  • @evabellgardens

    mine really like it =D <33333

  • @kagomeotilia sweet x ]

  • i listen to this song every night before i sleep. even though the lyrics are sad, the music comforts me

  • @DStecks, I won't disagree with u because I think you're right.

  • this was on full metal alchemist??? :D

  • @ninjagirlninjagirl No... Well, yes. xD Remember the episode with Barry the Chopper, and when Ed was talking to Al about how he thought he was going to die? In the background this was playing..... And in more emotionally intense parts xD

  • The tab says Brat XD i don't that suits Ed or Al very much, but it DOES describe siblings XD

  • @loppytaffy

    brat in english is brother :)

  • @RiSoute Well done, considering it's the "Brothers theme" (even though it's not used in Brotherhood. Go figure)

  • @loppytaffy

    that means brother in russian....

  • @MrJustakaz i KNOW.

  • ochin kharasho!

  • So sad.. i love fma and fmab but fmab is sadder so sad... *SOBS*

  • The Russian sounds better, in large part, because you likely can't understand the lyrics. The lyrics are way too on the nose, and as a result sound foolish when sung in English. People will disagree with me on this, but I find any English version embarrassing to listen to.

  • Русские и Сербы – Братья навек!

  • i feel prowed to be russian

    its so awsome

    

  • its good but i wish it had nothing to do fma

  • Don't Forget 3.Oct. 11

  • @tehachi has your sister given up on you yet...? XD

  • @misspoppylol

    it's beautiful not beostiful or whatever you put lol and It's does sound soft and sweet *tear tear* T^T so beautiful!!!!

  • everyone thinks that russian is like all northen languages: harsh and barky

    but actually, its one of the softest and more beiatiful of any languages,

    even swear words sound sweet to those who dont understand :)

    and to those 15 dislikers; VSE SUKI

  • 0:00

  • The Russian version is by far the best...

    I want to hug my brother :'(

  • I can't understand russian, but so much emotions are vehiculed in this song, it's incredible.

  • I started watching Full Metal Alchemist a little while before my grandpa died. Believe it or not, this incredible cartoon, its themes of brotherhood, loss and coping with loss have helped me cope with my own and move on.

    It's actually a very deep show, with an original story and phenomenal music.

  • I've watched FMA 3 years ago and I really liked this soundtrack. But it is only now that it occured to me that it's an actual language. Back then I thought it just Latin sounding words that don't really mean anything.

  • Good thing i can understand russian...

  • It makes me cry...so beautiful :') *.* <3

  • This song makes me regret that I've decided not to study Russian. I live in Finland, and since Russia is our neighbour, we are often encouraged to study Russian. I suck at languages, so I won't bother, but... This is beautiful.

  • at 2:04 i thought that she said naruhodo which is Japanese for "i see" , at the time i wasn't looking at the screen and i was like i thought this was supposed to be Russian wtf.

  • Even better when you know Russian.

  • this osng is the only thing brotherhood is missing

  • @amoa93 This is sooooooooooo true! I prefer Brotherhood but this is the best thing that came out of each series! <3 FMA 4EVA

  • Yup... found this song randomly on YouTube, and now I have seen the whole series (the first one, not brotherhood).

  • i love how i know what hes saying because of the english version but i much prefer ^^^

  • Sucks that Brotherhood doesn't have this!

  • @JoeBiden01 If there's one thing I hate about Brotherhood, it's that ;w;

  • @JoeBiden01 I know :( Brotherhood beats the original in every aspect besides humor and this song... But brotherhood has better openings too...

  • @JoeBiden01

    Wrong. There is part of this song in the end of episode 63.

  • i have to admit, the russian version is better, but the english version was still done well

  • @Th3PineappleKiller they are not related, its like calling a close famliy friend aunty etc its a more personal relationship between the families but they are not blood related.

  • @Th3PineappleKiller

    eitherway they shouldve made some human transmutation together, it suckd how nothing really happened between the two. i guess the mangaka left it to the fanbase to decide the couplings in the end.

  • I find that many animes have excellent scores to serve as companions to the storyline and characters. FMA is no different.

  • When I watched my first episode of FMA this song came on...I got HOOKED!

  • @Th3PineappleKiller

    but wait. isnt she like, their cousin? from the mums side?

  • @Th3PineappleKiller

    wish that ed and winry actually kissed though >:@ , goes for both versions.

  • @Th3PineappleKiller

    brotherhood has the original ending, from the manga, so basically, it is the original one .

  • ? Wait a minute I was singing along (in English) and what does it translate to after 'don't cry for the past now brother mine neither you nor I are free from blame nothing can erase the things we did for the path we took was the same' and the chorus cause that's not in the English verision?

  • I'm gonna memorize this in russian then walk around the house singing, I can't wait to see their faces!

  • I like the Russian version better for several reasons, but number 1 would probably be that you get the two different brother's singing, for their respective parts, so the song is more complete and makes more sense - as well as that you get the whole song - a verse is missing from the English version.

  • MANY M0:00RE TIMES!!

  • I love this version!

  • I LIKE BOTH VERSIANS! This i beautiful, but i can understand it in english and makes me cry- this sounds happier than Ed apologizing to Al for everything gone wrong in English.

  • I enjoy this song SO much more than the english sung version, I actually have it memorized in Russian now (but i can't sing it half as fast!) Great song!

  • I FINALLY FOUND IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the first time i heard this song in FMA a few weeks ago i just had to look for it and i found it <3 I'm going to download this song and the english version to my phone now, thank you so much :'D <3 x

  • Thumbs up if o=you were singing the english version along with this one(:

  • As much as I love Vic, this version is so much better and gets you more emotional than his version.

  • Ivan Braginski like it :D

  • @tehachi i was thinking that same thing!! lol. Ivan~ *dreamy state* ;P''''

  • truly beautiful song :')

  • I can hear Vic singing the English version in the instruments...

  • DorogA  As in Russian for road.

  • i can play this song on so many instrument...its...such a beautiful song...... :'(

  • this song was made for fma in specific.

  • this song is beautiful but it brings me to tears because it brings me all the mistakes that ed did in the past and throws them in my face like i was ed v.v

  • Such melancholy.

    I have wonderful memories attached to this song and Fullmetal Alchemist in general, so this is really nostalgic.

    <3

  • who sing this song?

    

  • love it....is it on youtube?

  • best anime... best music... best memmorys...

    peace always...

  • My russian friend wants me to learn this song just so that I can sing it to her. She doesn't want to sing it even though she know Every.Single.Verse. And even the correct pronunications. So, thank you you get me one step closer to getting the song down.

  • I can totally follow this song. I can sing in Russian now! Thank You so much!

  • This reminds me of the time I used to watch FMA on tv... That was 6years ago... And the melancholic feeling is still here...

  • 13 people don't have a heart

  • I'm fluent in Russian, and I might be singing this for a contest on a website. :3

  • @TeenyDratini i hope you win ^^

  • @TheJasterRogue Like hell I will. Everyone else is so much more awesome than me. xD

    But I'm mostly doing it for the experience.

  • @TeenyDratini well try your best

  • I love this song so much!! This song actually started playing during the Eucharist while I was at church! Not kidding!! :OO

  • I understood some of that....

  • i have a brother, but hes all grown up, i wish i had seen this epic anime before and made our bond stronger, aah!, i wish those carefree days.....

  • I'm wondering why they took Russian as the original vocals?

  • @RaffoPhantom I think it has something to do with the origin of the anime. The counterpart of where the story takes place is germany, after all.

  • @RaffoPhantom Weren't they in Russia in the movie?

  • @GirRocks8 no that was germany....Hitler in Russia...:DDD

  • Russian version is the best !!!

  • beatufil mother soft and sweet once you were gone we were not complete back through the years we reached for you alas twas not ment to be my dreams are blind and mute I long to return to that time I followed with out a word my brother the fault is mine so were do we go from here and how to forget and forgive whats gone is forever lost now all we can do is live

  • and how can I make ammends for all that I took from you i lead you with hopeless dreams my brother I was a fool don't cry for the past now bother of mine neither you nor I are free from blame nothing can erace the things we did for the path we took was the same how can I expect to call you wrong how can I blame you for what I've done were both fools for our desires as we flew to close to the sun

  • How can I repay you brother of mine how can I expert you to forgive clinging to the past I shared our blood and shattered your chance to live. Knowing the laws I payed no heed. How can I return you wasted breath What I did not know has cost you dear for there is no cure for death. Beautiful mother soft and sweet once you were gone we were not complete back through the years we reached for you alas twas' not meant to be

  • I really like this song but i prefer the english one. just personal preference i have no intention of putting down either version they are both amazing

  • tried to sing this in Russian.......but i know no Russian whatsoever

  • I finally was able to sing this entire song in Russian, and now, I think I'm going to do this song for the school talent show next year and make everyone cry with it's pure epicness and sad orchestral rythm.

  • russian can be a very beautiful language ! <3

  • @StillerRabe i.agree.but.i.don't.understand­.why.russian.can.sound.so.nice­.but.german.which.is.somewhat.­similiar.but.never.has.sounded­.even.nearly.quite.as.nice..Pl­ease.prove.me.wrong.though..Al­so.my.space.button.is.broken..­..sorry..

  • @craigclb 1.) Russian and German are not at all alike. 2.) Both languages sound beautiful, if you're only knowledge of German is old WW2 movies then of course it won't sound nice. 3.) Buy a new keyboard

  • @StillerRabe What do you mean "can be" >:O

  • @StillerRabe

    Can be? XD It is :D

  • @StillerRabe than you

  • @StillerRabe

    you're right. I know russian because of my mother. my sister and my mother sang in russian for me sometimes, when I still was young.

    the song makes me even more sad, when i listen to it in russian, because i understand what they sing.

    it has more emotions for me, when its russian.

    so, youre absolutely right!

    *smile with tears in my eyes*

  • sudenly after listening to the end i gained a urge to behead those 13 fckers who didnt love this song i mean how couldnt you love your mother it dosent matter if shes bad or good its your mother dammit how could you not love her?!?!?!?!?!?!

  • @xxalexreaperxx How could love someone that beats you up every day and abuse you? How could you love a mother that have you just because of money? Tell me. Reall mothers care about their kids and i doesnt matter if they are same blood or not.

  • 13 people.....kolkolkolkolkol....­.=J=

  • @xKilaxChanx This comment...

    I die now

    XD

  • does it have to be sung in russian/not have the lyrical version behind it?

  • @LitleEvilness i need moving words karaoke in russian to learn this in russian >.< (i havent found oen yet on youtube)

  • great video!

  • :,D

  • some of those y's should be oo's

  • @SuperElewis 12

    

  • in soviet russia, BUTTON DISLIKES YOU!!!! D:<

  • @winrylovely in soviet russia, sad song sings you. 

  • @winrylovely Russian reversals, aye. :D

  • @winrylovely in amerika, peoplelike you consideret smart

  • @mindarinas In america, people like you are considered dumb.

  • @FreeSpiritAnime your comment is worthless without argument.

  • ... Who in their right mind could possibly dislike this song?

  • Hi. Can someone tell me if there's a japanese version of this song or is the russian the original? Anyways great song. <3

  • @NW7227711 the russian is the original. Apparently the author of FMA wanted it that way :)

  • I want this song played at my wedding. :)

  • I'm so sorry, my younger brother, I'm so guilty before you. One can't try to return What was claimed by the earth. The one knowing the laws of being Could help me to find the answer. I have mistaken so badly: There is no cure for death. Sweet, tender mother, We loved you so much, But all our efforts Were wasted for nothing. I tempted you With a beautiful dream To return our family. My brother, I am to blame for everything.
  • Oh, God. It removed, the line breaks. How to delete this thing?

  • @SuperElewis Now 12 people need to die

  • what a beautiful song!

  • truly one of the best songs EVER.

  • I've always wonder why there's no japanese version of this song. But I like how an anime used a song i russian, that's quite rare :3 And it's so beautiful!

  • makes me cry :'(

  • I'm proud to be half-russian :'D

  • Comment removed

  • @AppleCosplay

    I'm proud to be Brazilian, i really like the song though... lol

  • kna tah tah teh taratah. bah i cant sing along :P

    love the song though :)

  • @aricente i can sing it in english (kinda), except for the 2nd verse after the interlude (i dont reamember the words by heart becsue its not in the english version that i know; aka the english version also by combatspecialist >.<)

  • This may be one, if not the, most tragically beautiful song ever.

  • this song is beautiful, thanks for uploading!

  • better than english version.

  • @Just4Th3Lulz

    definitely. the english version sounds.....gay. the guy sounds gay. Nothing against gay people, most of them just have a distinguishable vocal pattern.

    plus, the chorus sounds amazing. Sung by like a bunch of kids it sounds like? it's great. very peaceful.

  • @InsonsInsontis You do know the english versian is actualyl sng by Edward's VA, right?

  • @loppytaffy

    oh...no, i didn't. I watch the japanese version of anime, so i didn't know. that comment kinda makes me look dumb, now, doesn't it? lol oops