everyone should stop comparing Miles and Alex. They're both amazing songwriters, singers and performers. I don't see why one of them has to be better than the other.
ok, sorry i dont mean to spam or anything but my band Nettles from Edinburgh have just done an acoustic video of our song Thunder and Lightning, if you like us could you like this comment and get us to the top so we can get recognized a wee bit which would be appreciated ! you can download us on itunes too ! watch us here at /watch?v=5M7KcwMiYto :)
You can tell that this song was mainly written by Alex Turner and I prefer this version as it sounds more natural. However Miles sings it well and his version is better produced.
they wrote half of miles album together, but you can't judge that because you don't know what the input was, besides they are both top blokes! and they both sing this song very well, can't wait for the Last Shadow puppets next album!
I like this version better. But this is the first one I heard. It's nearly always the case that the first you hear will be your favourite. It's why covers rarely match up to the originals.
they both wrote it together .. and if you ask me, alex had more of an influence on it than miles did, it's more alexs melodic style than it is miles' .. by the way, the guitar in this is slightly out of tune
I personally liked Alex's cover of the song better than original version. Not saying miles wasn't good. They both have amazing voices. But I like Alex's voice more. But together they are the perfect package! :D
As always with a cover, almost everybody's saying that Miles does it better and of course he does ! but they're best friends so who give a fuck ? They both do it great, btw Colour of the Trap ( the album) is just a Pop masterpiece !
didnt think it would come to the point where alex is covering miles aha go miles! dont get me wrong Alex is an absolute god but miles is certainly closing the gap
I can't figure out who's is better, Miles' voice suites the song better but Alex has the better voice, and it's not really a cover 'cause i bet Alex wrote most of this tune.
@SteelCityHiitman Miles wrote this song in 2009 and played it with the rascals at sound city. the only change to the lyrics is the 3rd verse is now the second and he sings ''consider this now'' instead of ''consider this before'' also the chords changed a bit. I bet Al just sat along Miles and gave some inputs.
@pinko152 obviously you don't listen to miles kane, because then you'd know that he's able to write songs like this without the help of mr turner or anyone else for that matter
@liamswfc123 It seems very likely that is was a top comment then, it seems even dafter that we're having this conversation at all. Consider it over Liam old boy.
check out my band babe free rain!
Yeags54 2 weeks ago
ITS NOT TO LATE
AquilaNi1987 4 weeks ago
1:40 duck face fail! lol :) awesome tune though :))
ichbinAndrea 1 month ago
Guitar is completely out of tune dude :/
000Z9A 1 month ago
everyone should stop comparing Miles and Alex. They're both amazing songwriters, singers and performers. I don't see why one of them has to be better than the other.
rypeTmato12 1 month ago
The Guitar is not tune !!! it's very Hard !!!!!
brunobrusson 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please put WhiteRoseBandNE into youtube. If you love The Vaccines, Arctic Monkeys, Oasis & Coldplay you may love us.
Forever indebted.
WR x
WhiteRoseBandNE 1 month ago
F :)
gyula0523 2 months ago
MILES KANE IS THE BEST OF!!!!
gyula0523 2 months ago
Both versions are great, I can't choose.. They should sing it together!
li90lb 2 months ago 3
ains...me encanta
medeainmortal 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ok, sorry i dont mean to spam or anything but my band Nettles from Edinburgh have just done an acoustic video of our song Thunder and Lightning, if you like us could you like this comment and get us to the top so we can get recognized a wee bit which would be appreciated ! you can download us on itunes too ! watch us here at /watch?v=5M7KcwMiYto :)
Cheers guys !
LewisKorfanty 3 months ago
You can tell that this song was mainly written by Alex Turner and I prefer this version as it sounds more natural. However Miles sings it well and his version is better produced.
tduff91 3 months ago 9
they wrote half of miles album together, but you can't judge that because you don't know what the input was, besides they are both top blokes! and they both sing this song very well, can't wait for the Last Shadow puppets next album!
Rwswansea 3 months ago 4
Miles Kane's cover of this is good
pinko152 3 months ago 2
@pinko152
AHAH! I saw what you did there!
TheBobafett1993 3 months ago
I like this version better. But this is the first one I heard. It's nearly always the case that the first you hear will be your favourite. It's why covers rarely match up to the originals.
HotClubDeParis 3 months ago
@escapoligist its not miles' song they wrote it together
i prefer Alex's voice
thewatermelonsuk 3 months ago
I thought Alex had written most of it though.
allyandlarry 4 months ago 5
they both wrote it together .. and if you ask me, alex had more of an influence on it than miles did, it's more alexs melodic style than it is miles' .. by the way, the guitar in this is slightly out of tune
TheRandyTunes 4 months ago 6
@TheRandyTunes the guitar is not out of tune, the bottom E string is tuned down to the note D
acousticjamsesh 4 months ago
oo miles is better but alex sings this song so cute:)))♥
MegaAnna1210 4 months ago
If just his guitar were tuned...
oiergasdn 4 months ago 3
@oiergasdn jimi hendrix guitar wasnt tuned.....
evolutionist2010 4 months ago
@evolutionist2010 well. good to know. thank you, sir, for showing me this important piece of information
oiergasdn 4 months ago
love u
superfunksters 5 months ago
Alex's voice is a bit more pleasant than Miles', but both versions are great
keiwa11 5 months ago 9
WHHHY didn't he tune his guitar before he did this? I mean it's still amazing the way he sings it but.... alex... come on son
Vo0do0Lew 5 months ago
@XxLBainesLoverxX 8.000.000 people wouldn't agree
electricparanoia 5 months ago
Nice cover, guitar strangely out of tune tough
epsohapshiro 5 months ago
I personally liked Alex's cover of the song better than original version. Not saying miles wasn't good. They both have amazing voices. But I like Alex's voice more. But together they are the perfect package! :D
StellySisters 5 months ago 4
Brilliant
mikeyj2105 5 months ago
As always with a cover, almost everybody's saying that Miles does it better and of course he does ! but they're best friends so who give a fuck ? They both do it great, btw Colour of the Trap ( the album) is just a Pop masterpiece !
ArcticBuckley 5 months ago 2
if i didnt know the miles version i'd think this is great :)
creamycanarie98 6 months ago
didnt think it would come to the point where alex is covering miles aha go miles! dont get me wrong Alex is an absolute god but miles is certainly closing the gap
paulybigtime 6 months ago 2
Nice! Alex covering Miles!
lizvanderwaeren 6 months ago 4
I can't figure out who's is better, Miles' voice suites the song better but Alex has the better voice, and it's not really a cover 'cause i bet Alex wrote most of this tune.
SteelCityHiitman 6 months ago 4
@SteelCityHiitman Miles wrote this song in 2009 and played it with the rascals at sound city. the only change to the lyrics is the 3rd verse is now the second and he sings ''consider this now'' instead of ''consider this before'' also the chords changed a bit. I bet Al just sat along Miles and gave some inputs.
arcticmonkeysseven 6 months ago
to be honest i like this more
deeppurplefamily 7 months ago
of course Miles does it better, it's his song and he's the man. it's a really nice cover though!
escapoligist 7 months ago 85
@escapoligist actually Alex Turner wrote it together with Miles
Luc4sH4mm1ng 5 months ago 5
@Luc4sH4mm1ng I know, but he's singing it and it's on his album haha :)
escapoligist 5 months ago
@escapoligist no no no, read the discography - alex pretty much wrote his album
pinko152 4 months ago
@pinko152 I've got the album and it says that alex co-wrote 6 of the 12 songs, which makes your statement incorrect.
escapoligist 1 month ago
@escapoligist yeah we all know that 'co-wrote' is such a cover up for 'written by Alex Turner'
pinko152 1 month ago
@pinko152 obviously you don't listen to miles kane, because then you'd know that he's able to write songs like this without the help of mr turner or anyone else for that matter
escapoligist 1 month ago
Miles Kanes version is better
liamswfc123 7 months ago 9
@liamswfc123 how original.
ASH18YEARS 7 months ago
@ASH18YEARS how original do you want a comment stating my opinion?
liamswfc123 6 months ago
@liamswfc123 Dunno, maybe next time just click the thumbs up on the original comment instead of writing it again. It's only banter anyway pal ;).
ASH18YEARS 6 months ago
@ASH18YEARS probably wasnt a top comment then kid, hence why i'll have wrote it ;)
liamswfc123 6 months ago
@liamswfc123 It seems very likely that is was a top comment then, it seems even dafter that we're having this conversation at all. Consider it over Liam old boy.
ASH18YEARS 6 months ago
This isn't exactly a cover. He co-wrote the tune, along with five others for Miles' album.
PipesMusic 7 months ago 6
Miles Kane does it better
jestem0boska 8 months ago 43
@jestem0boska em no?
electricparanoia 7 months ago
@electricparanoia emm yes?
jestem0boska 7 months ago
don't think I need to state the obvious here (ahem, I like it better than Miles Kane version, ahem)
thelovestork 8 months ago
so perfect.
Jemerydi 8 months ago
thanks, I forgot to rec this.
mimilien 8 months ago
where did this come from ?
HollyRose941 8 months ago
@HollyRose941 Session at the french OuïFM radio during their venue in Paris this week.
frifridotorres 8 months ago
guitar a little out of tune? like it matters.
1:21 - even a bad hair day is still a regular persons good hair day
GlasgowSkate 8 months ago
@GlasgowSkate yes
mimilien 8 months ago