ONE FOR THE VINE - GENESIS

[michito46]

Lo lamento mucho pero me gusta mas con Phil en la voz y en la bateria

[irondaddymac]

this singer needs to practice to a keyboard and tune his voice -

[tobycat11]

This really floored me!. The vocalist sounds like pete. This prooves how wrong all the peter gabrial cry babies are about post "Rael" Genesis. As we true Genesis fans know, the chief song writers in Genesis Banks, Rutherford, and Hackett continued on beautifully without Rael. Especially with the more true to Genesis form and quality "Trick Of The Tail" record which was the follow up to the less well produced "Lamb" which ofcourse was not near the quality of "Eng. By The Lb"

[vampiroangelico]

I love Garden Wall, but I feel you guys have played this particular song much too fast....certain parts really sound rushed, and this style of music needs to be enjoyed at the right speed.

[gardenwall07]

thank you so much :-)..well i basically agree with you..especially that night i played lots of songs more fast..but just this one i don't find so much faster...anyway i admit it's my responsibility(drummer) because, you know sometimes i get too much excited playing this music that i adore..ehhhh...anyway also genesis were inclined to change the speed of the songs in the live act..sometimes faster others slower... :-)

[vampiroangelico]

Si, hai ragione, anche i Genesis lo hanno fatto in alcune occasioni, anche su Three Sides Live, ma per esempio su Seconds Out hanno mantenuto le velocita' dei pezzi piu' vicini alle versioni in studio, ed infatti lo preferisco perche' il periodo fra Trick Of A Tail e Duke e' il mio periodo preferito.

[gardenwall07]

ehhh effettivamente avrei dovuto notare dal nick che eri italiano ma ho risposto di fretta dall'ufficio facendo anche qualche errore di troppo in inglese..ok..si anche io preferisco assolutamente seconds out...ma per esempio anche li squonk e robbery sono qualche punto piu' veloci rispetto a quelle da studio...parlando di velocità, se senti le loro ultime esecuzioni di los endos in particolare nel reprise di squonk, sono di una lentezza incredibile ed il pezzo perde completamente in pathos...;)

[vampiroangelico]

Secondo me quella parte particolarmente in Los Endos aquista atmosfera....ma devo anche dire che il loro sound crea musica che ha qualcosa di magico, e cio' e' particolarmente vero nel live "Seconds Out". Beh comunque sia, voi siete un bel gruppo, ed io vivo in Florida e sto mettendo insieme un gruppo per fare roba progressiva fra Genesis, Pink Floyd e Marillion....sono gia' 30 anni che suono la chitarra in gruppi ed ora voglio fare qualcosa del mio genere preferito.

:-)

[BENJ1969]

Fine job! Take real balls to tackle a song like this, much less perform it well, and do it with the confidence this group seems to display. I've never seen a good Genesis cover band in my life, though I know several exist. They don't look to duplicate this gem as perfectly as Genesis, but they sure pull it off very well. My compliments.

[gardenwall07]

thanks a lot for your kind words..this was the very first time we played this song..glad you liked!!

[gardenwall07]

i'm very glad you enjoyed!! many thanks!!

[genesis2006]

Good musicians, but unfortunately the voice and the drum played part are not the best. It sounds like Gabriel singing Phil Collins.

[gardenwall07]

sorry..sometimes i forgot to reply in time..thanks a lot for your comment :-)

[M400fan]

Fantastic performance - brilliant to have two keyboards - the track is so multilayered with keyboards, you really need four hands! Lovely clean Mellotron!

[gardenwall07]

thanks a lot for this comment...very glad for your appreciation.. :-)

[gardenwall07]

p.s...sometimes one of our two guitarist gives a hand to keyboardist with another keyboard..  ;-)

[chamamaiden]

singer sounds more Gabriel than Collins... absolutely amazing voice

[gardenwall07]

thank you!!

[lookingfortalent2007]

Gabriel sings Collins

[goodtimes80s]

strumentalmente quasi ineccepibile! bravissimi! il cantante pero' è come se non conoscesse a fondo collins, a parte che probabilmente non è nelle sue corde..ma sono sicuro che con un po' di lavoro riuscirebbe a rendere molto meglio..sembra anche un po' a corto di voce ..ma sui pezzi di gabriel rende alla grande!!

[gardenwall07]

sono d'accordo con te..grazie ancora :-)

[LegacyProductionsOrg]

very clean sound. except for all those people talking. singer sounds like gabriel. right on.

[gardenwall07]

thanks a lot !

[Laminateddeffect]

You guys simply have great taste in music. Excellent choice.................one thing, whats up with the fog machine & why is it only covering the guitarist?.....more Dry Ice!!!

Nevertheless, great job guys.

[gardenwall07]

my friend i'm so sorry, for the delay..!! i totally forgot..it completely slipped my mind..anyway thanks for your kind comment..i can't tell you exactly what was going on with the fog machine..i only remember that it was a very windy evening and that the fog machine was very close to the guitarist..there were moments

during the concert that my friends couldn't see

their own instruments eh eh.. bye bye