This was a great video, I loved how the roles were reversed with Janet being Arwen (an elf) and Tamlin represented by Aragorn (a human lord) it had a nice irony to it that only added to the flavor of the song.
I rather this version now. I've heard the Sandy version over a million times now so I rather listen to by Steeleye Span and Pentangle to... But Fairport owns a special place in my heart! And the video fits with the tune to. When I had most of my mushroom days I used to listen to Fairport Convention 'cause their early records (up to Full House!?) are very mushroomie. ...and I take it, you northcountrygirlie will keep up making videos... otherwise my subscription would be in vain! :/
Loved it until it changed key (to accommodate switch to female vocal range) Now it's switched back... Breaks the spell & spoils it for me - sorry. But I'll sneak it onto me Ipod just anyway in case I have a change of mind or ears...
Loved it until it changed key (to accommodate switch to female vocal range) Now it's switched back... Breaks the spell & spoils it for me - sorry. But I'll sneak it onto me Ipod just anyway in case I have a change of mind or ears...
Loved it until it changed key right on 2:00... (to accommodate switch to female vocal range) Now it's switched back again... Breaks the spell & spoils the whole thing for me, sorry. But I'll sneak it onto me Ipod just anayway in case I have a change of mind or ears...
I think simonmedrano is off his rocker..."But I believe you could do better???" What is he...a teacher who whacks his students on the knuckles with a ruler??? If he were a REAL man (which I doubt), he would apologize to you. Of course, to him, that would be a big task! Anyway, great job on the video and song. I liked how you used the 2007 FC version (which I never heard before) instead of the 1969 FC version (which I'm very familiar with). Both versions, as you said, have their own merits.
I think this version lacks the folkadelic energy of the original, which along with Sandy Denny's vioce realy sold it in the first place. I love the clip though, Kat Blanchet could be my queen any day!
I've seen Fairport in concert quite a few times over the last 20 years, albeit not in the last few, and have never heard them do Tam Lin. Matty Groves always, but never Tam Lin. I'd always assumed they put it to one side after Sandy died, so thank you for uploading.
I was surprised at how well the LOTR matched up with the song. I expected to dislike it, as I love both Tam Lin and LOTR, but I thought it did justice to both. Would have prefered the Fairport Convention rendition of the song but you can't have everything. Excellent job -- well done!
This is horrible. I paused at 0:48 and should have done so earlier. Listen to the original version; it's far better. Better yet, buy the Liege and Lief CD.
I tried watching this video to the audio of the old version, and it synched amazingly well. [I start the video 3 or 4 seconds after the file I have of the old audio. The line in the song about the 2 roses comes just as the two flowers appear on screen. The audio ends a bit early, giving Fairy Queen Cate a little cool-down time.]
I don't dislike the video, and I know it's not so easy to make one, and it's a very time-consuming task. But I want to believe you could do better.
I also like this version.
I have the Fairport Convention's Liege & Lief album, and I really love both versions. They are differents, this one of course has a lot more presence, but think the other was recorded almost 40 years ago.
Wow, my favorite ballad, and I've always anted to listen to the FC version. Must admit I don't like this song, but the video is SO COOL! It fits perfectly! Well done!
P.S. I really like this video, it makes me see the Tam Lin story in a very interesting light! And I like your choice of clips from LotR (though I admit I started giggling when I saw Galadriel as the Faery Queen!)
Comment removed
shimojones 1 week ago
@shimojones Point taken.
1northcountrygirl 5 days ago
Excellent song! Great rythym and melody. 6 + 7 is very unusual and appealing.
HenryMuldrow 3 weeks ago
Sandy Denny's vocal on 'Liege & Lief" rocks so much harder.
grski88 5 months ago
Tam Lin the movie is at netflix!
tonkehar 8 months ago
AT LAST!!! people who love folk music and LOTR!!! perfect combenation!
georgieonmymind 1 year ago
This was a great video, I loved how the roles were reversed with Janet being Arwen (an elf) and Tamlin represented by Aragorn (a human lord) it had a nice irony to it that only added to the flavor of the song.
SanuraPet 1 year ago
I rather this version now. I've heard the Sandy version over a million times now so I rather listen to by Steeleye Span and Pentangle to... But Fairport owns a special place in my heart! And the video fits with the tune to. When I had most of my mushroom days I used to listen to Fairport Convention 'cause their early records (up to Full House!?) are very mushroomie. ...and I take it, you northcountrygirlie will keep up making videos... otherwise my subscription would be in vain! :/
GreatBonFire 1 year ago
The heart is & shall evermore be,the most daunting of battlefields.
TumbrelJockey 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
Fairport4Life 1 year ago
Why you put this scenes?who is interested in love scenes in lord of the rings?you made it look like a latinoamerican soap
markod1987 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Loved it until it changed key (to accommodate switch to female vocal range) Now it's switched back... Breaks the spell & spoils it for me - sorry. But I'll sneak it onto me Ipod just anyway in case I have a change of mind or ears...
redcrowdemon 1 year ago
Loved it until it changed key (to accommodate switch to female vocal range) Now it's switched back... Breaks the spell & spoils it for me - sorry. But I'll sneak it onto me Ipod just anyway in case I have a change of mind or ears...
redcrowdemon 1 year ago
Loved it until it changed key right on 2:00... (to accommodate switch to female vocal range) Now it's switched back again... Breaks the spell & spoils the whole thing for me, sorry. But I'll sneak it onto me Ipod just anayway in case I have a change of mind or ears...
redcrowdemon 1 year ago
These are the wrong kind of elves.
celzmccelz 1 year ago
u did a very good job. ;)
SuperZielke 1 year ago
I think simonmedrano is off his rocker..."But I believe you could do better???" What is he...a teacher who whacks his students on the knuckles with a ruler??? If he were a REAL man (which I doubt), he would apologize to you. Of course, to him, that would be a big task! Anyway, great job on the video and song. I liked how you used the 2007 FC version (which I never heard before) instead of the 1969 FC version (which I'm very familiar with). Both versions, as you said, have their own merits.
AdamsApple1963 1 year ago
sux
fruitman13 1 year ago
@fruitman13 Fruits tend to say so.
GreatBonFire 1 year ago
this woulda been so bad ass to have him singing Tam Lin's part, and Sandy Denny singing Janet's
toad1345 1 year ago
I think this version lacks the folkadelic energy of the original, which along with Sandy Denny's vioce realy sold it in the first place. I love the clip though, Kat Blanchet could be my queen any day!
raysteer 2 years ago
better by the girl on the cd.. still a good song.. she had a haunting quality, that fit things better
zenki36830 2 years ago
You mean Sandy Denny!
fingal42 2 years ago
I've seen Fairport in concert quite a few times over the last 20 years, albeit not in the last few, and have never heard them do Tam Lin. Matty Groves always, but never Tam Lin. I'd always assumed they put it to one side after Sandy died, so thank you for uploading.
onomatopoeia99 2 years ago 2
I was surprised at how well the LOTR matched up with the song. I expected to dislike it, as I love both Tam Lin and LOTR, but I thought it did justice to both. Would have prefered the Fairport Convention rendition of the song but you can't have everything. Excellent job -- well done!
virtucar 2 years ago
This is horrible. I paused at 0:48 and should have done so earlier. Listen to the original version; it's far better. Better yet, buy the Liege and Lief CD.
kenp3L 2 years ago
I tried watching this video to the audio of the old version, and it synched amazingly well. [I start the video 3 or 4 seconds after the file I have of the old audio. The line in the song about the 2 roses comes just as the two flowers appear on screen. The audio ends a bit early, giving Fairy Queen Cate a little cool-down time.]
theaphainetai 2 years ago
Gandalf drinks cider?
Dancingartichoke 2 years ago
Excellent version.
I don't dislike the video, and I know it's not so easy to make one, and it's a very time-consuming task. But I want to believe you could do better.
I also like this version.
I have the Fairport Convention's Liege & Lief album, and I really love both versions. They are differents, this one of course has a lot more presence, but think the other was recorded almost 40 years ago.
simonmedrano 2 years ago
"But I want to believe you could do better."
That's what my teachers always used to say!
1northcountrygirl 2 years ago 4
@simonmedrano Sorry I can't imagine anyone singing that but Sandy Denny, in Fairport. (I do like many other non-Fairport versions.)
BTW Sandy got it from Anne Briggs.
Yehudittx 11 months ago
As mysterious as the fact that there is no footage of Sandy singing Tam Lin...this is an interesting take on Tam Lin!!
sandydenny411 2 years ago 4
This video was put to the music perfectly! I love it!!!
BlueKoneko 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
1rachelc 2 years ago
as fast as go can she... so amazingly lovely! I actually love this version too.
ultramanification 2 years ago 2
I love both versions - each has its own merits and a different feel. This one is more exciting, Sandy's is gentler, more mysterious maybe.
1northcountrygirl 2 years ago
Wow, my favorite ballad, and I've always anted to listen to the FC version. Must admit I don't like this song, but the video is SO COOL! It fits perfectly! Well done!
Branween 2 years ago
The copy I have from Fairport has a woman singing. It sounds a lot better than this.
balaustine 2 years ago 2
that woman is Sandy Denny. She died very young so Fairport Convention lost a great singer.
doosjes82 2 years ago 7
Listen to the one with Sandy singing. The album is Liege and Lief.
Tamlin2308 2 years ago 3
Outstanding! And well done! Thank You Good Lady for posting, Will
AdriftNWo 2 years ago 3
P.S. I really like this video, it makes me see the Tam Lin story in a very interesting light! And I like your choice of clips from LotR (though I admit I started giggling when I saw Galadriel as the Faery Queen!)
coramunroe 3 years ago 4
Yeah ... and Elrond is wearing a corset - apparently middle aged spread is a problem even for elves...
1northcountrygirl 3 years ago 2
Who sings this version?
coramunroe 3 years ago 2
Simon Nicol and Chris Leslie alternately.
1northcountrygirl 3 years ago
Dunno but doesn't it sound like Ian Anderson (Jethro Tull)?
johnprentice49 2 years ago 3
Excellent, a well fitted version to Sandy's
Liege and Lief version and a nice video as well.
Never heard this one.
Tks and greets.
vanu49 3 years ago 3
A great hat-trick!! Well done.
jamesiegang 3 years ago