Added: 1 year ago
From: LarockArtists
Views: 173,655
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (265)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I prefer a woman who is gorgeous, long dark hair, awesome figure with an amazing voice and who is so sweet and caring, Oh that's right, that is Pia Toscano :)

  • Pia: Season 10 winner

    Lauren: fat princess drama queen

    Scotty: eh..

  • I still prefer Leona's.

  • She no doubt is amazing and should have beaten Scott, but this is still nowhere as good as Leona's original live version.

  • Her voice is AMAZING! ♥♥♥

  • HOLY SHIT! she has a voice of a goddess

  • How can she be so perfect ? ♥

  • @2XmuchXxxkoka1n3 Maybe you should get a nose job and stop hating on a very talented woman.

  • Pia's amazing, breath taking. <3

  • @2XmuchXxkoka1n3 It would be terrible if we all had the same, surgically altered nose. You are fascist and materialistic, not to mention vain. And by the way, it probably aids her voice.

  • AMERICAN IDOL FAIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • PIA SUKS BALLS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @2XmuchXxkoka1n3 You can't even spell the word sucks. Your opinion is irrelevant.

  • @2XmuchXxkoka1n3 stop this

  • should have won! 

  • PERFECTLY !!! :*

  • Pia and Haley were the two best !

  • if she would of done this at american idol im sure she would of won. but all she did was sing ballets

  • @2XmuchXxkoka1n3 Learn to spell ballad and then maybe you will have some room to talk. Besides I personally consider this a ballad.

  • greatest voice ever on american idol, hate the fact that she didn't win.

  • she was very good... and a power's vocal also looking with the own style..,can going more's......!!

  • i love her and leona lewis...voices are off the hook

  • @modestangel56 im a teenager and i think she has amazing vocals. you're absolutley right tho they should't have voted her off of american idol she woulda won. and honestly who wouldn't be jealous of her voice?

  • I get the chills too..

  • Leona Lewis will always be the best at bleeding love x

  • I get chills when she sings.

  • Beautiful Voice Pia. You shouldn't have been voted off of American Idol! These little jealous insecure teenagers dont know what real music and vocals sound like. Pia Toscano 100% Amazing!

  • maaaannn the backups annoyed me gooooooosshhhh

  • my jaw fell open

  • omg, like she did everything perfect...

  • she simply eat them up i tell you, if she still through till the end, then scotty you dosen't have a chance, you can't even beat her in any way, she'e damn hot. and got superb voice i tell ya, but sometime american idols sucks. if you are cute but you got no talent other then drama then you are in the wrong line of audition.

  • she simply eat them up i tell you, if she still through till the end, then scotty you dosen't have a chance, you can't even beat her in any way, she'e damn hot. and got superb voice i tell ya,

  • She's a true Latin idol!

  • @ZerpaLuis she's greek I think

  • @lushfauna nope.... Italian american. Therefore, Latin!

  • @ZerpaLuis ummm well Itaians don't like be called Latin they don't see themselves as latin- Trust me, I know a few real well

  • @ZerpaLuis Well, you go ahead and tell your friends there is no use denying who they are, People of the Latin Heritage (Culture). The true Latins, along with the French, Rumanians, Portuguese, and Spaniards. -

  • @ZerpaLuis

    dont try to claim her she is coming to the black side

  • @applestar501 lol

  • Pia is the best. American Idol is officially a joke now!

  • I totally love anything she sings n can spend all night to listen to her!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she is great and will make it 2 the top

  • lauren and scotty have different voices to pia especially scotty so obviously they wouldnt sing it as good as the beautiful pia

  • wonderful!!

  • i hate how people didnt respond to her wonderful talent...

  • See the good thing and bad thing about pia is that she can ANYTHING. That's when you have the issue with who she's going to be as an artist.. and not knowing is very unproductive. I think her career would best be brought out if she did a more rock/ country album but still have some pop ballads in the mix.

  • Definitely she sang it great, she sang the best cover of bleeding love, the one that is closest to the original but still there are some mistakes on the high notes and her tone changes a bit it's not pure like Leona's. She deserves a great applause for this, i wish she could have sang it on idol, but it's far to say she is better than Leona, sorry but that's over exaggerating . No one tops Leona Lewis

  • @Endriking leona's great but i think pia topped her. leona's upper belted notes aren't that big and powerful, and she lacks soul/life in her voice. pia has a lot more personality in her.

  • First of all you all are dumb. Pia is the best and Scotty is country singer of course he couldnt sing this you dumb shit!

  • Who cares who sang it better, Leona from Uk and Pia is from America and its a good thing that someone from our country sings great!! two different style and beauty!!! And out of all the other Idol contestant no one could sing Leona songs better than Pia can!! Just Saying!!!!

  • Leona sang it better and with much more passion/musicality, sorry Sweet P's

  • I would love to see Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina even attempt this song and sing it as well as Pia did...what a shame she didn't make it further.

  • @BeeRock200 just because they cant sing the same songs doesn't mean they aren't talented singers. Go ahead and see if rufus wainwright can sing a mariah carey song in her range.

  • Comment removed

  • im not a violent person...but....

    i wanna rip the mic out of Reuben Studdards hand ( on her left ) n shatter it over Paul Schaffers skull.

    ( on her right )

    just thought u should know

  • She is phenomenal, truly gifted. I hope that her dreams come true.

  • I'm sorry but no one can sing this song like Leona Lewis. She takes you on a emotional journey, Pia dosent, she has alot more dynamics than Pia! I think Pia is AMAZING dont get me wrong but not for this song i'm afraid.

  • @fang007vp not live

  • Way better than the original. Go Pia!<3

  • She certainly sings and sound better than what's her name...Leona Lewis.

  • @TheSportslover2010 GOOD COMMENT!PIA IS BETTER,DEFINITELY!

  • I like her band, HA!

  • Pia is better cause leona's voice was inhanced throughout the song.. maybe not much, but this is ALL pia! (:

  • she did a good version but not as good as Leona.

  • Leona Lewis won X factor the fact that she was good vocalist and with a touch of Mariah Carey style in her voice not a pitchy singer like Pia Toscano

  • @nikaledesma I DO AGREE THAT LEONA IS BETTER IN SINGING ''BLEEDING LOVE'' COZ ITS HER SONG.. BUT PLS. PIA PITCHY? IF EVER PIA IS PITCHY.. I WOULD RECOMEND YOU TO WATCH LEONA'S I'LL BE THERE, SORRY SEEMS TO BE THE HARDEST WORD, CHIQUITITA, COULD IT BE MAGIC, HOMELESS.. all are whiny, pitchy, shrilled at certain parts.. forced and thin.. lmfao, not a special ears to notice that.. leona is more PITCHY THAN PIA

  • @nikaledesma

    Pia's sense of pitch is way better than Leona's

  • lame crowd

  • Are u deaf ? Leona killed her by a mile!

    Pia can sing , no doubt , she's amazing but no one can be compared to Leona Lewis!

  • Not better than leona at all PLEASE! she can sing though

  • Pia u are the American Idol here in Uruguay Sud America we waitting for u album girl u are unique congra!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.

  • Pia is amazing!!!! I am so pissed she got eliminated!!!!

  • LEONA IS THE BEST CONTESTANT EVER!! NO ONE CAN TOUCH HER

  • @boomting24 leona is better than pia toscano, coz these was her song.. pia is ok.. and sorry .. no, leona is not the best contestant.. KELLY CLARKSON can mopped the floor with leona..

  • pia rocks.. whoever thinks she doesnt doesnt know shit

  • We have the same name. Yay! :D You're awesome Pia.

  • don't compare her to leona. leona sings octaves higher

  • Pia, you are so amazing. Don't think that since you got off Idol that you aren't brilliant. You were and still are one of my favorite singers. You're beautiful and talented! And by the way you sound better than Leona.. I love you Pia ! :) You are MY idol :)

  • U sound better than Leona.God bless you Pia.

  • DAMN! She should have sang this on AI. that was so so good im speechless.Pia is amazing and beautiful she can sing too.

  • amazing!!!!!

  • She's Wow!... 

  • wow, sounds like Leona!!!! beautiful!

  • this woman can really sing! i don't know why they voted her off the show! people don't really notice real raw talent these days anymore! I <3 Pia!

  • Leona is far better...ever listen to her sing Minnie Ripperton's hit "Lovin You?" Leona has a 5 octave range....no comparison. But Pia is very good!

  • @AnnNadine818 whiny leona has a 5 octave range? are you kidding me? no, leona is not better and her 'loving you' is the studio version. the highest leona has hit live in Eb6. it's not leona; it's mariah, who has got a 5 oct range. you are effing deluded and a clueless toddler. lol

  • @kelvinpyaeko

    How pathetic you are to become so offensive. I am sure you psychiatrist has meds for anger management and while you are at it, a class in social etiquette would be a wise choice. As for you musical listening abilities, I am afraid there is no cure. Alas, poor you. I wish you luck ....

  • @AnnNadine818 i just said the FACTS and the TRUTH and how come you couldn't admit your deluded statements? no back up, no argument with just lame reply. lol no cure for my musical listening abilities? i like how you turned the truth about you ON me (i.e..it's you who sucks at listening abilities and not being able to distinguish studio vs live versions) and again, come back to me ONLY when you learn how to read FACTS

  • like how annoying..the people who walk past her dont even look at her! I would have been like shiiitt that girl can sing!

  • no way. leona will always kill it the best. She controls her voice better...... knowing when to go soft. PIA is always trying to go strong all the time and its alright.. but i like leona better

  • @princessnuggly cause pia's voice is more powerful lol

  • i love her

  • and on the chorus those guys cant sing it and make her sound bad they need 2 shut up!

  • how could the ppl there not be in front of the stage doin backflips leting out death screams and trying thier hardest not to faint

  • LOL that was way too good for whatever show that was!!

  • Outstanding vocal voice!!!

  • Nigel Lythgoe said that she wasn't a frontrunner and that she might have not connected with the audience.

    That idiot clearly didn't watch EVERY news site going nuts over the matter, thousands of tweets during the following hours and thousands and thousands of threads about the subject. It clearly goes to say that Nigel doesn't know what the **** he was talking about, he was just hiding the judges mistake... ¬¬

  • Damn she's so good!

  • This girl can sing her butt off, but this is the same thing when Jennifer Hudson was on American Idol everyone was surprise that she was voted off and made it big after that. Pia Toscano is going to the same way some people are haters.

  • OMG why didn't she do this song on idol?

    

  • OMG why didn't she do this song on idol?

  • she hits every note and more that alicia does!! Shes absolutely amazing!! cant believe she got voted off..

  • @Binners710 alicia? this is leona lewis's song

  • @kelvinpyaeko oops totally meant leona....i had just been listenin to alicia keys so i had her in my head..but the point still stands she hit all the same notes and more that leona did lol

  • @Binners710 yeah...i agree...she hit all the same notes better. i mean leona can't perform this good at live.

  • @Binners710 i agree. i think leona is good but her upper range is pretty thin and weak compared to Pia's, hers is much more powerful. Also, a lot of Leona's performances are so lifeless, Pia has more life in her voice.

  • She is absolutely amazing. I don't normally like women singers, but she sings just like the artists and that is what I look for when people sing. That is real talent right there. If I had TV/Cable I would have voted for her and James. Such a beautiful voice. At least she has demos now from American Idol which record producers will say I WANT YOU!!! Great Job Pia.

  • I love you pia

  • pretty good delivery. i don't watch idol. but i definitely love leona's voice better. the only thing i don't like about pia's voice is that it seems...shaky? it's strong but it kind of like trembles. not that it's bad at all!

  • @protennischic91 its because shes using vibrato...........

  • @NYredwhiteandblue

    yeah, that's it. sorry, i forgot what it was called. i don't like vibrato.

  • @protennischic91 uhm, but it's kind of a way of showing something that you are doing right. a lot of singers can't do it. even leona always does that. and her vibrato in slow intros are worse that what you might call pia's vibrato: too wavy

  • love you pia!! idk wtf is wrong with the voters. f*** american idol. you're gonna go on and do great things!!

  • @y2keisha00 UR SO RIGHTTTT!@!!!!

  • love you pia!! idk wtf is wrong with the voters. f*** american idol. you're gonna go on and do great things!!

  • wayy better than leona. sounde like she was autotuned :D pia is amazing, definitely shoulda stayed on wtf is wrong with america?!

  • she has a bright future ahead of her what a voice

  • how are people just walking past her??? lame ass crowd is right..

  • all shes doing is screaming!

  • 7 people would rather listen to Ashlee Simpson and Paris Hilton singing.

  • One of those times that I have no idea what is going through people's heads when they press the thumbs down button.

  • Of course it's not better than leona's, coz there are like so many freaking high falsetto notes there. Her lane is definitely powerful singing like whitney houston but you cant hear this and not say she's amazing coz her instrument is so flawless and her pitch is always perfect. BTW she did everything right on AI, people just didnt vote. Instead they chose to vote for people like scotty who i think his time is up

  • @nigelaquaria IKR all scotty sings is country, is it really that hard to sing something else

  • She sang the song, she is not better than Leona . All she had to do was be diverse with her song choices and she chose not to. I believe that was her biggest mistake and it was the demise of her idol journey

  • She sang the song, she is not better than Leona . All she had to do was be diverse with her song choices and she chose not to. I believe that was her biggest mistake

  • My jaw dropped when she hit those notes! America made a big mistake on voting her off! i was so pissed when i heard ryan call her name I will always be TEAM PIA!

  • Sad she was voted off American Idol! SHE WAS THE BEST SINGER!

  • Guys sign these two petitions to bring Pia back! They're going to send it to the producers and judges!!

    Google "petition save pia!"

    Or google "Vote for Pia"

  • she's a superstar! just like charice! they should sing together! Bravo!

  • Those who say this is better than leona's obviously hasn't seen leona's live performances. Pia is good but Leona is in a whole other class along with Mariah, etc.

  • This was not better than Leona's! Leona is amazing live

  • @TheReneg92 It's way better than Leona's.

  • Sings it much better than Leona Lewis does live. This is note for note with the studio version.

  • @PetrucciFan57 i agree!

  • @PetrucciFan57 Better than James La Brie would have done it eh?

  • @GhostGuitars

    LOL, don't you mean LaCheese?

    "Whooa-ohhh-ohhh, whooa-ohhh-ohhh, waaah-aahh-AAAAAAAHHHHH"

    --James LaBrie, "Learning to Live"

  • @PetrucciFan57 Haha I only realised earlier he has a cheese name.  He can sing well but such a lack of diction at the top...

  • wow she killed that song but those guys are ruining her performance

  • What a lame crowd I would have been freaken out!

  • @lushfauna its actually a better sign that they got quiet. . . that means that they started listening!

  • @lushfauna this is from january, so she wasnt rele known thenn

  • PIAFANS.COM!! for PIA TOISCANO FANS! MP3's, 300 picture FLASH Gallery, 100 Video FLASH Gallery, Forums, Jukebox of original music from Pia, Chat Rooms, Forums and More!!!! PIAFANS.COM !!! Come SUPPORT PIA!!!! PIAFANS.COM!!!!!

  • i think she's amazing! i'm from argentina and we see her from here too :) she's famous not only in the United States! i hope she has a succesful career and make all her dreams come true!! God bless you Pia!

  • i think she's amazing! i'm from argentina and we see her too from here :) she's famous not only in the United States! i hope she has a succesful career and make all her dreams come true!! God bless you Pia!

  • Why the hell are there people walking around they should be standing still and listen

  • You know, I think the main reason Pia enter AI is to become a national attention. Since 2002, AI has become the springboard of launching careers of future superstars. Winning the AI doesn't really guarantee that you going have a successful career. I think she is a market-type artist that going to sell albums. I hope she wins the AI. But, I am pretty sure record companies going to be all over her after this season over.

  • Pia is AMAZING! The beauty, talent, charm, personality, style, & that voice. To me, she's destined to be a huge star... & then some. Her voice just absolutely FLOORS me, one of the most pure, strong, & beautiful voices I've ever heard.

  • she is sooooooooo good!!

  • PIAFANS.COM !!! JOIN US AY PIA'S ONLY AND LARGEST FANSITE ON THE NET. DOWNLOAD ALL OF PIA TOSCANO'S PRE-IDOL MUSIC FOR FREE! ALL UPTEMPO!! AT PIAFANS.COM !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Much better than Leona!!! hahaha

    Pia is a DIVA!!!

  • I hope she sings this on stage.....she'lll slam everyone....

  • Wow she can sing...but can she entertain???

  • @butterclip who says she is an entertainer like britney or madonna? she is the SINGER with the voice. mariah carey, celine dion, whitney houston, kelly clarkson all sing. not crazily entertain like lady gaga by doing weird things or like beyonce like sharking her ass. case close

  • @kelvinpyaeko Well if all she can do is lift her kneeS up once in a while, that's freaking boring. Mariah, Celine and Whitney do more than just that. DON'T INSULT THEM.

  • @butterclip uhm, honey, what u need to know is that she is only at the beginning of her career. you know i am a big mc fan. but even mc in the beginning of her world tour, music box's tour, she didn't have the capability to entertain the audience wholly. tt's why she was criticized for that. but as times went on, she became the real artist. so give pia also some time. you people tend to go too far. haha

  • @kelvinpyaeko OK, sweet cheeks, well we'll wait and see if she can step up her game because everyone else competing against her is fairly inexperienced, but that excuse won't work for very long. Best of luck to her

  • funtastic!!!!thumb for pia

  • Pia, ♥ Pia

  • AMAZING!!!!

  • aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwweeeeeessssssssome­!

    

  • very talented ;)

  • THIS GIRL'S VOICE IS AS BEAUTIFUL AS SHE IS .NOT EVERY SINGER CAN MAKE THAT CLAIM.JUST SAYING IT AS I SEE IT.THINK ABOUT IT.THERE ARE NO COMPARISONS.SHE STANDS ALONE.TIME WILL PROVE THIS OUT.

  • she is great

  • To her fans - do you really gamble your money on this girl the fact that her genre is pop R&B which has a very stiff competition in the music scene . Katherine Mcphee only had one known song then she just vanished lol. What about her that vocally Katherin Mcphee is better than this out of tune, pitchy Pia Toscano.

    Teens are hit today like J B and Taylor Swift. Be wise in voting!

  • @nikaledesma can u stop posting that in every video, its very annoying. keep your own advice to yourself