Ever since I was a teenager I wished for a true Pink Floyd reunion but now that the hatches have been buried and not tens like they were during Live8 and the meeting in this video, a real reunion is all but impossible (RIP Rick). This makes me sad, but I'm very happy for them that they lave largely put the past behind them and are friendly and even perform on each other's solo tours now. When you come down to it, their friendship is more important than what they do for us fans, isn't it?
Gilmour is by far my favorite guitarists. There is no "best" guitarists; there are fantastic guitarists in each genre. I mean, could you really compare David Gilmour to Chet Atkins? Gimour is more of a blues/rock genius, and his style is just /different/ from many others, focusing more on expressiveness. He wouldn't compare to Randy Rhodes' shredding style, nor Rhodes to Gilmour's in Pink Floyd's genre. They're just /different/ but very good in their own rite.The top n guitarists lists are bunk.
To me it seems like Roger really wants to put everything aside, but David is afraid to give up his ego. I mean look at him, for most of the talk he didn't even look at roger. It's hard though to put aside a conflict that's been present for 10+ years. They played together earlier this year at the O2 Arena and you could see that roger was happy they were preforming together. I would love to see them all tour together, but it seems it's too late now... RIP Rick Wright...
I love this video so f*cking much...can't believe i wasn't born in these great and psychedelic years....i wish i could go back in time to live through years at the same time than these guys...
Those lists are all subjective. But trained ears and players know there are better guitarists than others. Hendrix is without question #1. And you can easily say a player like jimmy page is a far superior player than gilmour. However gilmour was the perfect guitarist for Floyd. I agree the lists are not to be taken seriously.
we all grow out of each other......we're not here for the worlds amusement but our own lives eh?.........get over it......coke indeed........been there done that so what? poisonous gossip
me and Tiesto would love to do a show for a good pupuse with you great ARTIST,,,!!!! great to see you still realy into it,,,!!! my deepest respect,,,!!!
Archie Swalow in dutch Zwaluw,,,not to be considerd as the beast,,,!!!!!!!
just want to say hello to the mesenger`s not just a message in a botle,,,!!!
how uncomfortably numb do those two look together. How Bob Gelldof got them togther for Live 8 feck knows.I think that lays to rest any gossip about them working together again. Shame.
@RaptorLewis - I'm sure it was Gilmour too. His ex wife, that was with him for 20 odd years, lives in a tiny flat as he hid all his money off shore and she got next to nothing in the divorce. And the one daughter I've met from his first marriage seems to hate him when she talks about him - well she pretty much won't talk about him. He also had a massive coke problem too even till the 90's apparently. So not all Water's fault I'm sure.
Ok, they weren't about to jump into one anothers arms, but, at that stage (DG had just finished touring 'On An Island') things were still not great between them, if stories are to be believed. But the tone/body language seems quite conciliatory (the 'alright, luv?' at 0.45, and the hand on the arm at 0.48). But this is all a bit academic now, with the Waters/Gilmour/Mason reunion at the 02 'Wall' show. Let's hope things stay positive.
É bacana a gente ver estes encontros! Dois gênios da música pop que trocaram farpas por desavenças profissionais. "Brigas" dessa natureza ocoreram com Lennon x MacCartney, Roger Hodgson x Rick Davis, David Gates x Bread... Mas que no final tudo volta a velha base.
Rolling Stones top #100 guitarist list is a Joke! David Gilmour is one of the greatest of all time and they ranked him so low. What was that list based on anyway besides personal bias?
@twcox Yeah, that's crazy! One of the reasons why I never take these rankings seriously. To be honest you can't say someone is the best without a doubt. There are plenty of guys who deserve the top spot but Gilmour that low alone takes away all the credibility of this list, not to mention there are plenty of other flaws in it.
@nipo10847 Rolling Stone is total garbage, they put Smells Like Teen Spirit about 40 places above Stairway To Heaven on their top 500 rock songs list. 'Nuff Said....
@CthulhuDarkLord It's all about agendas bro. Never take them seriously. One thing I learned that your own judgement is the best parameter in opinionated things. RS should NOT hold much weight in smart people's brains.
@nipo10847 Actually, it is based on a borda count system. 100 musicians including Trey from Phish, Dave Mustane, Eddie Van Halen, etc ranked numerous guitarists based on numerous aspects including influence, playing style. It is the same voting system used in the Olympic figure skating; however, after numerous classes in strategy and logic, one realizes that bias can be introduced to any voting system. Cheers!
Big musicians, incredible work together and huge egos that destroy relationship. Lennon/ Macca was the same. But we all know that thanks to David and Paul, the fantastic bands were together such long time. John and Roger, persons with hard, complicated personalities, sometimes violent also.
It's a real shame that famous musicians cannot subdue their colossal egos and let go of their petty grievances with fellow band members for the good of the wonderful music they labored so hard to create together. It's especially tragic when said musicians are approaching the onset of their senior years. Such is life...
As someone who loves Waters and Gilmour both, I must point out that the earlier anti-Gilmour arguments citing his low ranking on Rolling Stone's "100 Greatest Guitarists" list have zero credibility. That this list includes Kurt Cobain and Kirk Hammett (etc., etc.), puts Keith Richards at #10, and omits such players as Ollie Halsall and Terry Kath - not to mention countless jazz, flamenco, country and classical guitarists superior to ANY rock guitarist - means it is not to be taken seriously.
Water is an incredible song writer. He made most of the songs i can`t stop hearing again and again. But i can`t stand his voice (well, i like his screaming on careful with that axe..)
Gilmour is an incredible musician. His performance is unbeatable, even today. I find his acoustig gig unbelievable. But very few songs he wrote pleased me at all.
They`re both really good at what they`re supposed to do. and we all loved the result of the combined work. period
@XnovemberrisingX No. I know you are stupid, but I never thought you are THAT stupid. A few cards short of a full deck? YES. Not the sharpest marble in the bag? WITHOUT ANY DOUBT. Dumb as a stump? YOU BET!
@XnovemberrisingX "I'm not really a video maker as much as I'm just an incredibly bored person with software" - No. You aren't an incredibly bored person with software. You are an incredibly BORING person with software, in unemployment limbo. Go figure.
Why don't you two idiots go to a neutral corner, blow each other, shake hands, and fuck the hell off, already? Neither one of you is a spokesperson for the partys you're arguing about, so your mindless drivel is a waste of space here.
@jonesy97 Why don't you mind your own business and stop trying to squelch discussion simply because your small mind can't absorb it? Try something smaller than the internets. Tiddly-winks comes to mind. Give it a shot.
@MongoTheLloyd Tiddly winks? Sounds like the voice of experience. How do you play? You sound like the expert. Judging by your posts, that sounds right along those lines, age-wise. This is a public forum, asshole, so if your arrogant, insult laced posts that you call "discussion" are infringed upon, then tough shit, dick. Funny how you remark about other's posts, laced with insults, then you follow suit, and call them penis-worshipping fools, stupid, etc. You're so fucking transparent.
@jonesy97 Ah. The old "public forum" argument... by a clown that makes it using filthy language. Does stupid EVER get old? No. It doesn't. Yes, when it comes to recommending activities to the intellectually-challenged, like yourself and most Gilmour fans, I can come up with a few activities that might fit. Give it a shot, sporto... unless of course Tiddly Winks is over your head too. Who knows... you might LIKE it. It sures seems to be a good fit for you, from a distance.
FACT: Roger Waters has 37 individual writing credits to Gilmour's THREE, for DSOTM to TFC. FACT: Waters has more combined credits that the others COMBINED. FACT: Waters did the vast majority of the work (movie, created album concepts, stage show for the Wall). FACT: Gilmour is not one of the top guitarists. He ranks 82 of 100 rated by listeners, below J. Ramone and Trucks. FACT: Dave was a replacement guitarist, hired by Waters and had no claim to a brand/songs he didn't create.
@hanghang71 Gilmour DOES contribute "awful to the sound". I agree with THAT statement. No wonder Roger left and found guitarists who are more versatile to play with. The world is thankful for it!
I quote: "Despite strong sales the album received poor reviews. T. Sinclair of Entertainment Weekly gave it a "D", writing that "avarice is the only conceivable explanation for this glib, vacuous cipher of an album, which is notable primarily for its stomach-turning merger of progressive-rock pomposity and New Age noodling".
@MongoTheLloyd cont'd... RS's T. Graves criticized Gilmour's performance, stating that his guitar solos "were once the band's centrepieces, as articulate, melodic and well-defined as any in rock, [but] he now has settled into rambling, indistinct asides that are as forgettable as they used to be indelible" END QUOTE.
RAMBLING, INDISTINCT ASIDES. Forgettable. The Division Bell. Pink Fraud. That about covers The Division Bell. A "D" effort at best. Avarice... extreme greed. EXACTLY. Thanks Dave!
@MrOizo Yes. I can. See, Waters wrote the VAST MAJORITY of Floyd songs. Duringt WYWH, Gilmour didn't like the direction the band was heading in. It got worse after that album. He hated Animals... because of the politics. Then came The Wall. Same thing. He hated it. Too political. he didn't want to do a stage show. he wanted to go onstage, fart out his Numb solo, and leave. Roger fired Wright because Wright whined too much and was impossible to work with. Roger finally left the band. ...cont'd
@MrOizo I agree. Animals is, by far, my favorite Floyd/Waters album. Waters referenced the angst of the punk movement, and incorporated it and the politics of the day into a masterpiece of poetry. I like the other albums... but Animals is raw. A distinct and pleasant departure from the over-produced efforts like DSOTM and WYWH.
@MrOizo After Roger left the band, Gilmour brought Wright back and wanted to play Waters' songs, and touring as Pink Floyd. Roger objected and filed a lawsuit. Gilmour returned the favor. It went on for years. Eventually, the judge allowed Gilmour and the other 2 bums to use the name, because there had not been written agreements when the band was started that would have precluded it from happening. So Gilmour toured as Pink Fraud, bilking Floyd fans with bad re-works of Waters' songs/
@MrOizo At the end of the day, that is what happened. Gilmour's first 2 solo albums failed miserably, so he NEEDED Floyd... to keep income coming in. He had his girlfriend write songs for him... so he could have "new Floyd" material. Hence, The Division Bell. A retarded attempt to imitate the formula that Roger created. It didn't work. I challenge ANYONE to read the lyrics from ANY Fraud album, and compare it to of the actual Waters songs. There is no comparison to Waters.
@MrOizo I think Waters already wished it hadn't happened. I have seen at least one interview in which he expressed regret that things happened the way that they did. But he only had control over himself and his own behavior. He couldn't control Dave and the other two. DAve clearly wanted to lead the group... so he did. To what end? Greatest hit tours? Fraud albums w/ songs he wrote with his girlfriend that are hardly poetic and mostly laughable?
BTW... Division Bell isn't credited to Gilmour. Gilmour FAILED to share credits (the same argument Dave fans claim about Roger Waters) with Mason. Now THAT is funny. Furthermore, Dave's girlfriend/wife and many others get credit for that Pink Fraud rubbish. Dave couldn't write a song by himself to save his fat arse. Waters CAN and DID.
At to The Wall not being the same minus Gilmour... that isn't necessarily a bad thing. The Wall material sounds far better when played by Waters and the musicians he selects to play it. Yes... if I wanted to hear Gilmour's NUMB solo (that won't happen)... I always have the option to dig through my LP's to find the unused album that happens to have that replacement guitarist on it. Too much work for such little payoff.
DB-II, Snowy... they play better than Gilmour. In EVERY respect.
I'm with you Mongo! I saw the Wall live in 1980 and then in 2010. Even though Waters wrote most of the wall, The 2010 concert was not the same minus Gimour! No one can reproduce Gimour's sound or style! I also saw the Division Bell show in 1994 and it was a work of art, minus Waters! R.I.P. David Wright.
@t69gto Clearly, a highly confused fan of Gilmour. No shock. No surprise. Most of that lot are easily confused and distracted by shiny objects. If you think Division Bell to be a work of "art", you ain't with me. If you think Gilmour to be one of the world's top guitarists, you ain't with me. If you think one "Numb" solo makes up for the lack of real work on Gilmour's part between DSOTM and The Wall, you ain't with me.
Clearly, someone (you) is off his meds. Get back on them... STAT!
@MongoTheLloyd 2/3 of of the people posting here did not see the wall in 1980 and then in 2010. So that being said, the 2010 show which had a fill in guitar player for Gilmour. I forget his name but, he didn't come close to to the sound of Gilmor. He actually sucked! It's not all about the numb solo either. Mongo, speaking of meds, you are the one that needs them! STAT! Who cares who wrote the majority of "their" music. If Gilmour sucked so bad why did Wright and Mason stay with him?
@t69gto Waters has regular guitarists he uses... amongst them, Snowy White and John Carin. In the last Wall, Bramhall wasn't used but he brought on GE Smith and another. Being the very generous and forgiving soul Waters is, he even let Gilmour join for 1 show. I know... you forgot the names. Yeah.
I don't take meds and have no need for them. I am not the one with the heartburn over the thought that others have opinions and differing views... enough to sit day in and doy out, tring to silence it.
@krkgak No. Balding doesn't necessarily correlate to dignity, unless it is taken with other factors (fat, snaggletoothed, toad of a man). Another more important factor is the fact that Waters wrote the VAST MAJORITY of music, and did far more work for PF... while Gilmour the hired guitarist and non-founding member whined incessantly about the direction the band was taking, all the while becoming rich from it... and then having the nerve to sue for the name of a band he didn't found.
Waters - 37 solo writing credits from DSOTM to FC.
Gilmour - 3. Waters, solo credits and co-credits, 58. The other 3 members combined credits - 44, 14 less than Waters by himself.
Gilmour - ranked 86th of 100 top guitarists. Shares 1/2 grammy with Wright. Has his girlfriend write his lyrics. Did little in Floyd. Farted out a few Pink Fraud cuts and played greatest hit tours to bilk Floyd fans... one more time! Stole a brand he didn't create, since the band was successful when he was hired.
@MongoTheLloyd To rate lower than Johnny Ramone, or Derek Trucks... that pretty much tells what the world thinks of David Gilmour.
Had it not been for Syd's misfortune... and for the genius of Waters, the world would have never heard of Gilmour. When Roger concluded that he was carrying dead weight of 3 bandmates that failed repeatedly to contruibute, he should have cut the ties permanently during the WYWH sessions and bowed out. He made the last 3 by himself anyway. Why pay the lazy bums?
SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHERE TO GET THAT PICTURE OF THEM HUGGING IN 1975 PLEASEEEBWAUFKHSCVFSDyiHKLVJDwVHGHJSDHGFDHJSI8UDCYHGFHRJEKSOIUDCGFVBHDIOSKUHFYEOSKDCGFVBHDIOSHFJKDHGSHJKDFJHBFJKSJDHFSKJDHFGBVSDE!!!!!!!!!!!
@krkgak Because Waters is a dignified man, and he aged as such. Gilmour? What does he look like now? A fat balding snaggletoothed toad of a man? Well, there you have it!
Had Gilmour been dignified, perhaps his appearance would reflect it.
@davidbelkevitz1311 such sweet bitter sweet irony, here you are telling me to grow up while not being able to resist starting a youtube argument...and then you proceed by calling me a "dullard". How can I take such advice? But here's some advice for you... grow up and stop having a problem with people comparing great bands...esp. on a youtube wall. (Yes, I am aware that I didn't insult you back..oh but the temptation ...)
@codern Ok, a bit uptight I guess, but what's with comparing music? I hate people comparing rather than just enjoying. Was Sinatra better than Elvis? Hell, just love their style.
Without The Beatles we probably wouldn't have had such greats as Clapton and Pink Floyd, always remember who opened up the doors for British music to flourish.
@davidbelkevitz1311 1) Dont channel your hatrid among those comparing music. There are better way sto channel hatred. 2) Who says I (or those "comparing" bands) don;t enjoy the music. I most certainly do, which is what inspires me to want to appreciate bands enough to compare them. 3) Well, Sinatra and Elvis bored me so I cant comment. I found them to be performers to "appeal" to an audience rather than real compelling artists. So that's not a great example. 4) Now i must comment on that very
@davidbelkevitz1311 common outlook of "if there were no Beatles, there would be no"... i put nothing on that, because just as the Beatles "came to be" (and without the beatles to have them "come to be" in the 1st place) it shows that it's possible for any kind of band of artists to come to be. As a musician myself, I can safely say, its taste and personality, granted culture shapes your taste, but ultimately, you create the kinda of sound that appeals to you. Ild wager that artists in floyd
@davidbelkevitz1311 were not dependent or reliant on the artists from the beetles to enable them to create the sounds that appealed to them...regardless who might have opened any particular doors.
@davidbelkevitz1311 Huh? You gave me slack oh mighty one? Well thank you kindly for your slack, but I wasnt looking for you to give me anything. I was actually just trying to communicate with you but apparently in so far as you proclaim, I "hung" myself. I mean seriously dude, what kind of a troll are you? So according to you, I've hung myself & I know nothing about music. You know, you're really not so good at this whole advice thing.
@davidbelkevitz1311 what are you talking about? All the sudden you know me? I can easily say the same about you, you might be a great seasoned musician but you also seem to have a major character flaw. Perhaps this happens in mid-late life? Let me ask you, what do you proclaim 9with conviction) that I dont know. I havent the time or inclination to talk about music evolution from the 30s, to 50s rockn roll, to 60s psychedelic, to 70s prog rock, to 80s synth rock, to 90s grunge (loudness war) &
@davidbelkevitz1311 to the utter insipid shit "music" played today. But i can safely tell you this, i am well studied, and well educated and I dont think you know who you're talking to, and i really dont think you want to becuase I would dance circles around whatever "knowledge" you have acquired with music evolution (not "progression") mind you..through out the years.
@codern You may be a musician to a degree, I don't know, but educated you are not in basic English, which tends to slow my opinion of your education, as for myself, I am just a drifter of music and the times. I hail from Glasgow Scotland, but live in South Carolina now. I live for music in all genres, I enjoy the blues, country, bluegrass, whatever, music has been my compass and for that I am grateful, that's why I embrace all genres of music and art. slange.
@davidbelkevitz1311 1st. I dont make it a point to be grammatically correct on youtube, esp. for the "troll community". (If thats what your getting at) I rush my messages, typos are made ya knoe!! Well that's great you know what you love, I'm very happy for you. Now what that has to do with anything I've said to you, or how I've tried to reason with you, I have not a clue. But thank you for telling me about yourself and hey... keep embracing.
F#$@K ALL THIS BITCHING ................ Who needs enemies when you got fans like this ?? / Its time to stop this division bell from chiming .........Please , just enjoy their music !!
Syd and Rick are dead, Nick doesn't sounds good on drums since Meddle, Roger and David are looking like they are going to have peace with each other. But, even if those three reunite it wouldn't be Pink Floyd, Rick will always be missed, just like in Final Cut.
@Ekphrasys I think I can see where you're coming from but I personaly find that my favorite floyd album can vary depending on my mood.Sometimes I feel like listening to The Wall,Animals,The final Cut etc,but other times I feel like listening to Saucer full of secrets,Atom heart mother,Obscured by clouds etc.My comment about 1983 was a reference to Roger leaving.Floyd isn't floyd without Roger,Momentary Lapse was "ok" but Roger brought so much to floyd so they never been the same since. :( Peace
@Gaviathan Sorry, but Roger was killing the Floyd sound...Gilmour IS Pink Floyd (together with Rick)....There's much more Floyd sound in AMLOR and EVEN in the last David's solo album than in The Wall or TFC.... And do you know why? Cause in the last two official albums Wright wasn't there....And it can be heard... ^^
@Ekphrasys There's no doubt that they both brought something special to Floyd,but as far as personal preferences are concerned I think we're gonna have to agree to disagree.
@loombaron hahaha you are motherfucker devil. will you shut up. you aint no realy pink floyd fan if have this coment. if you delte this than you are a realy pink floyd fan.
rogers just thinking SHIT, pink floyd got better when he left. haha for me gilmour is the sound and voice of floyd, gilmours who i pay to go and see, not roger. no disrespect to roger though, he did write the wall after all.
@Corleonetone If it's the first time for a decade or two they are so close to each other, it's no bloody wonder that they are slightly uncomfortably in each others company!
But i would love to see a reunited Pink Floyd on the road
Awww..
Sirfev2010 3 days ago
That was sad...a shame that Roger went a different direction from David and the rest like Mr mason and mr wright
powerpro21 2 weeks ago
They don't even shake hands when they first walk up to each other. This was hard to watch.
JustOneOfTheRobots 2 weeks ago
Wow these guys were in the same band and yet it's so fucking awkward. Almost makes you want to cry.
74jailbreaker 2 weeks ago 6
I'm gonna sound like a total idiot asking this, but what's the last song that plays in this video?
thewriter1008 2 weeks ago
@thewriter1008
"Smile" off of David Gilmour's "On An Island"
AlbertoBdawgWilson 1 week ago
Such a great piece! I wish they'd never split. But everything happens for a reason.
SuperAM0 2 weeks ago
Ever since I was a teenager I wished for a true Pink Floyd reunion but now that the hatches have been buried and not tens like they were during Live8 and the meeting in this video, a real reunion is all but impossible (RIP Rick). This makes me sad, but I'm very happy for them that they lave largely put the past behind them and are friendly and even perform on each other's solo tours now. When you come down to it, their friendship is more important than what they do for us fans, isn't it?
kimvette1 2 weeks ago
Gilmour is by far my favorite guitarists. There is no "best" guitarists; there are fantastic guitarists in each genre. I mean, could you really compare David Gilmour to Chet Atkins? Gimour is more of a blues/rock genius, and his style is just /different/ from many others, focusing more on expressiveness. He wouldn't compare to Randy Rhodes' shredding style, nor Rhodes to Gilmour's in Pink Floyd's genre. They're just /different/ but very good in their own rite.The top n guitarists lists are bunk.
kimvette1 2 weeks ago
Tear-jerking
bigman7781 3 weeks ago
That makes me wanna cry
edgeinsmile 3 weeks ago
makes me sneak a tear everytime
yatestoon 1 month ago
Rolling Stone should be used in case of toilet paper shortage
Geemonster69 2 months ago 3
To me it seems like Roger really wants to put everything aside, but David is afraid to give up his ego. I mean look at him, for most of the talk he didn't even look at roger. It's hard though to put aside a conflict that's been present for 10+ years. They played together earlier this year at the O2 Arena and you could see that roger was happy they were preforming together. I would love to see them all tour together, but it seems it's too late now... RIP Rick Wright...
CthulhuDarkLord 2 months ago
@CthulhuDarkLord Really..? Stop judging. You obviously have no clue what goes on. None of us do.
ilinaeternity 1 week ago
whats the last song?
BludySkinz 2 months ago
@BludySkinz it's "Smile" from David's solo album "On An Island" ;)
soopawhoops 2 months ago
0:45 reminds me of the cover for Wish You Were Here
Terraforman 2 months ago
@Terraforman wow, did you come up with that all on your own?
dowdn 2 months ago
@Terraforman it's Echoes,in my opinion their best song,especially Pompeii version
jackmorefx 2 months ago in playlist david gilmore pink floyd
I love this video so f*cking much...can't believe i wasn't born in these great and psychedelic years....i wish i could go back in time to live through years at the same time than these guys...
dore666 2 months ago
Awkward?
Snotra 2 months ago
@1091Floyd21 wow, hehe, what an annoying asshole you are... XD
BroadswordTULL 2 months ago
@BroadswordTULL Well you must have read through about 1000 pages of comments to find what I said. What was it??
1091Floyd21 2 months ago
@1091Floyd21 nope. seen it by accident. anywayz, just a joke ;)
BroadswordTULL 2 months ago
@1091Floyd21 oh, what it was you ask... go find out yourself :)
BroadswordTULL 2 months ago
Pride....that and the firing of richard right by roger waters drove the band apart. Well now the mans dead..(RIP)...
snapmode5 2 months ago
david gilmour is legend
bestofpinkfloyd 2 months ago
Strangers passing in the street
By chance two separate glances meet
And I am you and what I see is me
kallio83 2 months ago
Those lists are all subjective. But trained ears and players know there are better guitarists than others. Hendrix is without question #1. And you can easily say a player like jimmy page is a far superior player than gilmour. However gilmour was the perfect guitarist for Floyd. I agree the lists are not to be taken seriously.
RommelEGH 2 months ago
we all grow out of each other......we're not here for the worlds amusement but our own lives eh?.........get over it......coke indeed........been there done that so what? poisonous gossip
marbleheadband 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
me and Tiesto would love to do a show for a good pupuse with you great ARTIST,,,!!!! great to see you still realy into it,,,!!! my deepest respect,,,!!!
Archie Swalow in dutch Zwaluw,,,not to be considerd as the beast,,,!!!!!!!
just want to say hello to the mesenger`s not just a message in a botle,,,!!!
hope you will facebook.com/aadje.zwaluw
Lucifera123zwaluw 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am an Anonymous composer who creates ambient instrumentals. If you like Pink Floyd then please check out my soundcloud by searching anon ymous
theanonymouscreator1 3 months ago
Dumbass egos, its the English way.
Bumble8700 3 months ago 22
@Bumble8700 haha:P
Pelleman666 2 months ago
@Bumble8700 I thought hanging on in quiet desperation was the English way?
thewriter1008 2 weeks ago
@thewriter1008 It is, my family came from England, thats what I was subjected too.
Bumble8700 2 weeks ago
@Bumble8700 Sadly this is true.
74jailbreaker 2 weeks ago
how uncomfortably numb do those two look together. How Bob Gelldof got them togther for Live 8 feck knows.I think that lays to rest any gossip about them working together again. Shame.
BoabWalker 3 months ago
I grew up with the Floyd and love each member indiscriminantly. Too bad Water's egos and personal demons shattered the band and their friendships.
Long live such great artists! Long live the Floyd!
RaptorLewis 3 months ago
@RaptorLewis - I'm sure it was Gilmour too. His ex wife, that was with him for 20 odd years, lives in a tiny flat as he hid all his money off shore and she got next to nothing in the divorce. And the one daughter I've met from his first marriage seems to hate him when she talks about him - well she pretty much won't talk about him. He also had a massive coke problem too even till the 90's apparently. So not all Water's fault I'm sure.
WillShakespeare2007 2 months ago 2
this group is just so classic to the fullest extent....the feeling of there music will
never cease.
tumak1966 3 months ago
soz i meant 0:45
666MattsGuitar666 3 months ago
awkward moment 0:47...
666MattsGuitar666 3 months ago
Ok, they weren't about to jump into one anothers arms, but, at that stage (DG had just finished touring 'On An Island') things were still not great between them, if stories are to be believed. But the tone/body language seems quite conciliatory (the 'alright, luv?' at 0.45, and the hand on the arm at 0.48). But this is all a bit academic now, with the Waters/Gilmour/Mason reunion at the 02 'Wall' show. Let's hope things stay positive.
AndyHN34 3 months ago
whats the name of the song at the end?
Edwards1323 3 months ago
@Edwards1323
it's called "Smile", it's on David's On an Island album
girlcrazymusicfreak 3 months ago
Como desearía que hicieran un último disco juntos...
MonteOlympus 3 months ago
É bacana a gente ver estes encontros! Dois gênios da música pop que trocaram farpas por desavenças profissionais. "Brigas" dessa natureza ocoreram com Lennon x MacCartney, Roger Hodgson x Rick Davis, David Gates x Bread... Mas que no final tudo volta a velha base.
Renato3466 3 months ago
I feel nostalgic...
7777777alf 3 months ago
Rolling Stones top #100 guitarist list is a Joke! David Gilmour is one of the greatest of all time and they ranked him so low. What was that list based on anyway besides personal bias?
nipo10847 3 months ago 38
@nipo10847 I thought Gilmour was #1 and Syd at like, 98 or something?
twcox 3 months ago
@twcox Huge correction - 82 for Gilmour - WOW!
twcox 3 months ago
@twcox Yeah, that's crazy! One of the reasons why I never take these rankings seriously. To be honest you can't say someone is the best without a doubt. There are plenty of guys who deserve the top spot but Gilmour that low alone takes away all the credibility of this list, not to mention there are plenty of other flaws in it.
nipo10847 3 months ago
Respond to this video... Huge correction - 82 for Gilmour - WOW!
twcox 3 months ago
@nipo10847
you're right.
Rolling Stones magazine are wankers.
They put "The Dark Side Of The Moon" far away behind all those noise makers.
One of the 3 best albums of all time.
RS must have been paid for that...
Bastards.
Thank you David, Rick, Nick and Roger.
youkounkoun2 3 months ago
@nipo10847 I gotta agree. his style makes alot of his solos sound alike, but what made his style work so well is I think the Band playing with him.
glaxko2 3 months ago
@nipo10847 #1.
buddy39914 2 months ago
@nipo10847 Rolling Stone is total garbage, they put Smells Like Teen Spirit about 40 places above Stairway To Heaven on their top 500 rock songs list. 'Nuff Said....
CthulhuDarkLord 2 months ago
Comment removed
nipo10847 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@CthulhuDarkLord It's all about agendas bro. Never take them seriously. One thing I learned that your own judgement is the best parameter in opinionated things. RS should NOT hold much weight in smart people's brains.
nipo10847 2 months ago
@nipo10847 I agree wholeheartedly.
Geemonster69 2 months ago
@nipo10847 82* position ....this is crazy dude :V......he deserve the top ten at last -.-.
01orochimaru10 1 month ago
@nipo10847 i thought he came out on #8.. what was his spot?
kevin7993 2 weeks ago
@kevin7993 Nope. Gilmour was #82.
nipo10847 2 weeks ago
@nipo10847 What list wouldn't be?
thewriter1008 2 weeks ago
@nipo10847 I dont het it either ..He's Incredible ..Fuckin blows away Page and Clapton
cjf7991 2 weeks ago
@nipo10847 Totally ridiculous, i think Gilmour's in the 70's or 80's, and Kurt Cobains in the top 10... Ludicrous
TheFloydGilmour 1 week ago
@nipo10847 Actually, it is based on a borda count system. 100 musicians including Trey from Phish, Dave Mustane, Eddie Van Halen, etc ranked numerous guitarists based on numerous aspects including influence, playing style. It is the same voting system used in the Olympic figure skating; however, after numerous classes in strategy and logic, one realizes that bias can be introduced to any voting system. Cheers!
Reddevil1421 5 days ago
there's a new rolling stone article out that tells how tense it still as during this time, and during the Live 8 performance.
unluckymonkeyboy 3 months ago
Big musicians, incredible work together and huge egos that destroy relationship. Lennon/ Macca was the same. But we all know that thanks to David and Paul, the fantastic bands were together such long time. John and Roger, persons with hard, complicated personalities, sometimes violent also.
leaperfish 3 months ago
whats the songs name at the end?
Fractur3dMirror 3 months ago
Comment removed
NathFilms 3 months ago
It's a real shame that famous musicians cannot subdue their colossal egos and let go of their petty grievances with fellow band members for the good of the wonderful music they labored so hard to create together. It's especially tragic when said musicians are approaching the onset of their senior years. Such is life...
spinocus 3 months ago
Wenn die Welt untergeht- PINK FLOYD SPIELT DAZU DIE PASSENDE MUSIK!!!!
Einmal Pink Floyd-immer Pink Floyd!
hallimann2008 3 months ago
Made me cry.
pfloydguy 3 months ago
I am glad to see Roger and David gathering together again....
marco29a 4 months ago
If this doesn't give you a lump in your throat for both David and Roger, then you don't understand the Floyd !
Big Fan for 35 years ^_^
usaSAVAGE 4 months ago
As someone who loves Waters and Gilmour both, I must point out that the earlier anti-Gilmour arguments citing his low ranking on Rolling Stone's "100 Greatest Guitarists" list have zero credibility. That this list includes Kurt Cobain and Kirk Hammett (etc., etc.), puts Keith Richards at #10, and omits such players as Ollie Halsall and Terry Kath - not to mention countless jazz, flamenco, country and classical guitarists superior to ANY rock guitarist - means it is not to be taken seriously.
xianshep 4 months ago
Ok. So, it`s a matter of taste, simply.
Water is an incredible song writer. He made most of the songs i can`t stop hearing again and again. But i can`t stand his voice (well, i like his screaming on careful with that axe..)
Gilmour is an incredible musician. His performance is unbeatable, even today. I find his acoustig gig unbelievable. But very few songs he wrote pleased me at all.
They`re both really good at what they`re supposed to do. and we all loved the result of the combined work. period
dalchaib 4 months ago
@XnovemberrisingX No. I know you are stupid, but I never thought you are THAT stupid. A few cards short of a full deck? YES. Not the sharpest marble in the bag? WITHOUT ANY DOUBT. Dumb as a stump? YOU BET!
I did give you some credit! (roll eyes here).
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@XnovemberrisingX HAHAHAHAHA. The truth does hurt. Hope if left a mark.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@XnovemberrisingX "I'm not really a video maker as much as I'm just an incredibly bored person with software" - No. You aren't an incredibly bored person with software. You are an incredibly BORING person with software, in unemployment limbo. Go figure.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
Why don't you two idiots go to a neutral corner, blow each other, shake hands, and fuck the hell off, already? Neither one of you is a spokesperson for the partys you're arguing about, so your mindless drivel is a waste of space here.
jonesy97 4 months ago
@jonesy97 Why don't you mind your own business and stop trying to squelch discussion simply because your small mind can't absorb it? Try something smaller than the internets. Tiddly-winks comes to mind. Give it a shot.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd Tiddly winks? Sounds like the voice of experience. How do you play? You sound like the expert. Judging by your posts, that sounds right along those lines, age-wise. This is a public forum, asshole, so if your arrogant, insult laced posts that you call "discussion" are infringed upon, then tough shit, dick. Funny how you remark about other's posts, laced with insults, then you follow suit, and call them penis-worshipping fools, stupid, etc. You're so fucking transparent.
jonesy97 4 months ago
@jonesy97 Ah. The old "public forum" argument... by a clown that makes it using filthy language. Does stupid EVER get old? No. It doesn't. Yes, when it comes to recommending activities to the intellectually-challenged, like yourself and most Gilmour fans, I can come up with a few activities that might fit. Give it a shot, sporto... unless of course Tiddly Winks is over your head too. Who knows... you might LIKE it. It sures seems to be a good fit for you, from a distance.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
FACT: Roger Waters has 37 individual writing credits to Gilmour's THREE, for DSOTM to TFC. FACT: Waters has more combined credits that the others COMBINED. FACT: Waters did the vast majority of the work (movie, created album concepts, stage show for the Wall). FACT: Gilmour is not one of the top guitarists. He ranks 82 of 100 rated by listeners, below J. Ramone and Trucks. FACT: Dave was a replacement guitarist, hired by Waters and had no claim to a brand/songs he didn't create.
Facts is facts!
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd gilmour contributes an awful lot tothe floyd sound /end of
hanghang71 4 months ago
@hanghang71 Gilmour DOES contribute "awful to the sound". I agree with THAT statement. No wonder Roger left and found guitarists who are more versatile to play with. The world is thankful for it!
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
I quote: "Despite strong sales the album received poor reviews. T. Sinclair of Entertainment Weekly gave it a "D", writing that "avarice is the only conceivable explanation for this glib, vacuous cipher of an album, which is notable primarily for its stomach-turning merger of progressive-rock pomposity and New Age noodling".
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd cont'd... RS's T. Graves criticized Gilmour's performance, stating that his guitar solos "were once the band's centrepieces, as articulate, melodic and well-defined as any in rock, [but] he now has settled into rambling, indistinct asides that are as forgettable as they used to be indelible" END QUOTE.
RAMBLING, INDISTINCT ASIDES. Forgettable. The Division Bell. Pink Fraud. That about covers The Division Bell. A "D" effort at best. Avarice... extreme greed. EXACTLY. Thanks Dave!
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
Rogers was Stand OFF-Ish as hell in this clip... Can someone explain what really happened?
MrOizo 4 months ago
@MrOizo Yes. I can. See, Waters wrote the VAST MAJORITY of Floyd songs. Duringt WYWH, Gilmour didn't like the direction the band was heading in. It got worse after that album. He hated Animals... because of the politics. Then came The Wall. Same thing. He hated it. Too political. he didn't want to do a stage show. he wanted to go onstage, fart out his Numb solo, and leave. Roger fired Wright because Wright whined too much and was impossible to work with. Roger finally left the band. ...cont'd
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd but animals was such a masterpiece omg.........!!!!!!!!!
MrOizo 4 months ago
@MrOizo I agree. Animals is, by far, my favorite Floyd/Waters album. Waters referenced the angst of the punk movement, and incorporated it and the politics of the day into a masterpiece of poetry. I like the other albums... but Animals is raw. A distinct and pleasant departure from the over-produced efforts like DSOTM and WYWH.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MrOizo After Roger left the band, Gilmour brought Wright back and wanted to play Waters' songs, and touring as Pink Floyd. Roger objected and filed a lawsuit. Gilmour returned the favor. It went on for years. Eventually, the judge allowed Gilmour and the other 2 bums to use the name, because there had not been written agreements when the band was started that would have precluded it from happening. So Gilmour toured as Pink Fraud, bilking Floyd fans with bad re-works of Waters' songs/
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MrOizo At the end of the day, that is what happened. Gilmour's first 2 solo albums failed miserably, so he NEEDED Floyd... to keep income coming in. He had his girlfriend write songs for him... so he could have "new Floyd" material. Hence, The Division Bell. A retarded attempt to imitate the formula that Roger created. It didn't work. I challenge ANYONE to read the lyrics from ANY Fraud album, and compare it to of the actual Waters songs. There is no comparison to Waters.
That is what happened.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd What is sad is that these guys are getting old. When they are on their last breath, they're going to wish a fall out didnt happen
MrOizo 4 months ago
@MrOizo I think Waters already wished it hadn't happened. I have seen at least one interview in which he expressed regret that things happened the way that they did. But he only had control over himself and his own behavior. He couldn't control Dave and the other two. DAve clearly wanted to lead the group... so he did. To what end? Greatest hit tours? Fraud albums w/ songs he wrote with his girlfriend that are hardly poetic and mostly laughable?
Roger has my respect. Gilmour can bugger off.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
BTW... Division Bell isn't credited to Gilmour. Gilmour FAILED to share credits (the same argument Dave fans claim about Roger Waters) with Mason. Now THAT is funny. Furthermore, Dave's girlfriend/wife and many others get credit for that Pink Fraud rubbish. Dave couldn't write a song by himself to save his fat arse. Waters CAN and DID.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
YAWN.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
I like cheeseburgers.
dwilmer7 4 months ago
At to The Wall not being the same minus Gilmour... that isn't necessarily a bad thing. The Wall material sounds far better when played by Waters and the musicians he selects to play it. Yes... if I wanted to hear Gilmour's NUMB solo (that won't happen)... I always have the option to dig through my LP's to find the unused album that happens to have that replacement guitarist on it. Too much work for such little payoff.
DB-II, Snowy... they play better than Gilmour. In EVERY respect.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
I'm with you Mongo! I saw the Wall live in 1980 and then in 2010. Even though Waters wrote most of the wall, The 2010 concert was not the same minus Gimour! No one can reproduce Gimour's sound or style! I also saw the Division Bell show in 1994 and it was a work of art, minus Waters! R.I.P. David Wright.
t69gto 4 months ago
@t69gto Clearly, a highly confused fan of Gilmour. No shock. No surprise. Most of that lot are easily confused and distracted by shiny objects. If you think Division Bell to be a work of "art", you ain't with me. If you think Gilmour to be one of the world's top guitarists, you ain't with me. If you think one "Numb" solo makes up for the lack of real work on Gilmour's part between DSOTM and The Wall, you ain't with me.
Clearly, someone (you) is off his meds. Get back on them... STAT!
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd 2/3 of of the people posting here did not see the wall in 1980 and then in 2010. So that being said, the 2010 show which had a fill in guitar player for Gilmour. I forget his name but, he didn't come close to to the sound of Gilmor. He actually sucked! It's not all about the numb solo either. Mongo, speaking of meds, you are the one that needs them! STAT! Who cares who wrote the majority of "their" music. If Gilmour sucked so bad why did Wright and Mason stay with him?
t69gto 4 months ago
@t69gto Waters has regular guitarists he uses... amongst them, Snowy White and John Carin. In the last Wall, Bramhall wasn't used but he brought on GE Smith and another. Being the very generous and forgiving soul Waters is, he even let Gilmour join for 1 show. I know... you forgot the names. Yeah.
I don't take meds and have no need for them. I am not the one with the heartburn over the thought that others have opinions and differing views... enough to sit day in and doy out, tring to silence it.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
Comment removed
t69gto 4 months ago
@krkgak No. Balding doesn't necessarily correlate to dignity, unless it is taken with other factors (fat, snaggletoothed, toad of a man). Another more important factor is the fact that Waters wrote the VAST MAJORITY of music, and did far more work for PF... while Gilmour the hired guitarist and non-founding member whined incessantly about the direction the band was taking, all the while becoming rich from it... and then having the nerve to sue for the name of a band he didn't found.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
Waters - 37 solo writing credits from DSOTM to FC.
Gilmour - 3. Waters, solo credits and co-credits, 58. The other 3 members combined credits - 44, 14 less than Waters by himself.
Gilmour - ranked 86th of 100 top guitarists. Shares 1/2 grammy with Wright. Has his girlfriend write his lyrics. Did little in Floyd. Farted out a few Pink Fraud cuts and played greatest hit tours to bilk Floyd fans... one more time! Stole a brand he didn't create, since the band was successful when he was hired.
Thief
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd To rate lower than Johnny Ramone, or Derek Trucks... that pretty much tells what the world thinks of David Gilmour.
Had it not been for Syd's misfortune... and for the genius of Waters, the world would have never heard of Gilmour. When Roger concluded that he was carrying dead weight of 3 bandmates that failed repeatedly to contruibute, he should have cut the ties permanently during the WYWH sessions and bowed out. He made the last 3 by himself anyway. Why pay the lazy bums?
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
So sad, I love them both....
PinnkFlooyd 4 months ago 18
SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHERE TO GET THAT PICTURE OF THEM HUGGING IN 1975 PLEASEEEBWAUFKHSCVFSDyiHKLVJDwVHGHJSDHGFDHJSI8UDCYHGFHRJEKSOIUDCGFVBHDIOSKUHFYEOSKDCGFVBHDIOSHFJKDHGSHJKDFJHBFJKSJDHFSKJDHFGBVSDE!!!!!!!!!!!
JCProductions75 4 months ago
Why couldn't Roger lose his hair instead of David?!
krkgak 5 months ago 2
@krkgak Because Waters is a dignified man, and he aged as such. Gilmour? What does he look like now? A fat balding snaggletoothed toad of a man? Well, there you have it!
Had Gilmour been dignified, perhaps his appearance would reflect it.
Roger's karma ran over Gilmour's dogma.
Woof.
MongoTheLloyd 4 months ago
@MongoTheLloyd Uh, no I don't think so. David Gilmour is a great guy, quite dignified. And balding doesn't correlate with dignity anyway.
krkgak 4 months ago
Great post. A touching moment.
roundaboutwrongway 5 months ago
Their body language was anything but warm.
jessicana77 5 months ago 9
old spice was in the air
20Mar1boro 5 months ago
Pink floyd eats Beatles...PERIOD!!!
codern 5 months ago
@codern Grow up and stop comparing great bands you dullard.
davidbelkevitz1311 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 such sweet bitter sweet irony, here you are telling me to grow up while not being able to resist starting a youtube argument...and then you proceed by calling me a "dullard". How can I take such advice? But here's some advice for you... grow up and stop having a problem with people comparing great bands...esp. on a youtube wall. (Yes, I am aware that I didn't insult you back..oh but the temptation ...)
codern 5 months ago
@codern Ok, a bit uptight I guess, but what's with comparing music? I hate people comparing rather than just enjoying. Was Sinatra better than Elvis? Hell, just love their style.
Without The Beatles we probably wouldn't have had such greats as Clapton and Pink Floyd, always remember who opened up the doors for British music to flourish.
davidbelkevitz1311 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 1) Dont channel your hatrid among those comparing music. There are better way sto channel hatred. 2) Who says I (or those "comparing" bands) don;t enjoy the music. I most certainly do, which is what inspires me to want to appreciate bands enough to compare them. 3) Well, Sinatra and Elvis bored me so I cant comment. I found them to be performers to "appeal" to an audience rather than real compelling artists. So that's not a great example. 4) Now i must comment on that very
codern 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 common outlook of "if there were no Beatles, there would be no"... i put nothing on that, because just as the Beatles "came to be" (and without the beatles to have them "come to be" in the 1st place) it shows that it's possible for any kind of band of artists to come to be. As a musician myself, I can safely say, its taste and personality, granted culture shapes your taste, but ultimately, you create the kinda of sound that appeals to you. Ild wager that artists in floyd
codern 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 were not dependent or reliant on the artists from the beetles to enable them to create the sounds that appealed to them...regardless who might have opened any particular doors.
codern 5 months ago
@codern I gave you some slack and you just hung yourself. You know nothing of music or its progression.
davidbelkevitz1311 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 Huh? You gave me slack oh mighty one? Well thank you kindly for your slack, but I wasnt looking for you to give me anything. I was actually just trying to communicate with you but apparently in so far as you proclaim, I "hung" myself. I mean seriously dude, what kind of a troll are you? So according to you, I've hung myself & I know nothing about music. You know, you're really not so good at this whole advice thing.
codern 5 months ago
@codern It wasn't advice, just years of dealing with people like yourself. Empty spaces comes to mind.
davidbelkevitz1311 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 what are you talking about? All the sudden you know me? I can easily say the same about you, you might be a great seasoned musician but you also seem to have a major character flaw. Perhaps this happens in mid-late life? Let me ask you, what do you proclaim 9with conviction) that I dont know. I havent the time or inclination to talk about music evolution from the 30s, to 50s rockn roll, to 60s psychedelic, to 70s prog rock, to 80s synth rock, to 90s grunge (loudness war) &
codern 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 to the utter insipid shit "music" played today. But i can safely tell you this, i am well studied, and well educated and I dont think you know who you're talking to, and i really dont think you want to becuase I would dance circles around whatever "knowledge" you have acquired with music evolution (not "progression") mind you..through out the years.
codern 5 months ago
@codern You may be a musician to a degree, I don't know, but educated you are not in basic English, which tends to slow my opinion of your education, as for myself, I am just a drifter of music and the times. I hail from Glasgow Scotland, but live in South Carolina now. I live for music in all genres, I enjoy the blues, country, bluegrass, whatever, music has been my compass and for that I am grateful, that's why I embrace all genres of music and art. slange.
davidbelkevitz1311 5 months ago
@davidbelkevitz1311 1st. I dont make it a point to be grammatically correct on youtube, esp. for the "troll community". (If thats what your getting at) I rush my messages, typos are made ya knoe!! Well that's great you know what you love, I'm very happy for you. Now what that has to do with anything I've said to you, or how I've tried to reason with you, I have not a clue. But thank you for telling me about yourself and hey... keep embracing.
codern 5 months ago
@codern your post hear made me just realize that we have become our fathers!!!!!
thiscreepingmalaise 4 months ago
does anybody here remember vera lynn?
STimo95 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
David Gilmour - Smile
matthewkinsman 5 months ago
David Gilmour - Smile
matthewkinsman 5 months ago
what's the song right at the end?
thelostpiranha 5 months ago
I lightens my heart to see Dave and Reg together...
But I miss Rick :( Could have done with seeing him play one more time
voodoochild1975az 5 months ago
AKWARD!
kumetalsmith 5 months ago
F#$@K ALL THIS BITCHING ................ Who needs enemies when you got fans like this ?? / Its time to stop this division bell from chiming .........Please , just enjoy their music !!
ozzybob 5 months ago 2
in tears.
DrPenusbutt 5 months ago
I think they should do something... for Rick...
Cloudz2789 5 months ago
wow, there must of been a massive fued that broke them up
Havers666 5 months ago
Fantastic!
n2motocross 5 months ago
Waters + Gilmour=Greatest song writing duo ever ,even better than Lennon McCartney.Love the pink floyd
IDontCareEitherOne 5 months ago 13
Roger seems the cold fish.......
rufinoman 5 months ago
Syd and Rick are dead, Nick doesn't sounds good on drums since Meddle, Roger and David are looking like they are going to have peace with each other. But, even if those three reunite it wouldn't be Pink Floyd, Rick will always be missed, just like in Final Cut.
KanonXD 5 months ago
no musicians like David and Roger
heavyrockfan98 5 months ago
Bury the hatchet guys,life's too short,the true Pink Floyd hasn't been heard since 1983 (with the exception of live 8)time is running out!!
Peace
Gaviathan 5 months ago 2
@Gaviathan The True Pink floyd hasn't be heard since 1977...Animals was the last TRUE floyd album...sorry...
Ekphrasys 5 months ago
@Ekphrasys I think I can see where you're coming from but I personaly find that my favorite floyd album can vary depending on my mood.Sometimes I feel like listening to The Wall,Animals,The final Cut etc,but other times I feel like listening to Saucer full of secrets,Atom heart mother,Obscured by clouds etc.My comment about 1983 was a reference to Roger leaving.Floyd isn't floyd without Roger,Momentary Lapse was "ok" but Roger brought so much to floyd so they never been the same since. :( Peace
Gaviathan 5 months ago
@Gaviathan Sorry, but Roger was killing the Floyd sound...Gilmour IS Pink Floyd (together with Rick)....There's much more Floyd sound in AMLOR and EVEN in the last David's solo album than in The Wall or TFC.... And do you know why? Cause in the last two official albums Wright wasn't there....And it can be heard... ^^
Ekphrasys 5 months ago
@Ekphrasys There's no doubt that they both brought something special to Floyd,but as far as personal preferences are concerned I think we're gonna have to agree to disagree.
Peace
Gaviathan 5 months ago
I wish I never saw this video....nothing about Pink Floyd made me sad but this.
slitherlock 6 months ago
A very strained meeting. Check the body language, roger keeps his hand firmly in his pockets at the beginning.
MrDahunn 6 months ago
This has changed since then!!!
Look for Gilmour being a guest of Waters in may 12 2011...
Can be found on youtube!
bramilan 6 months ago
They seem very hurt with each other.
Life crossroads are a bitch.
sosodevious 6 months ago
If the Police & Genesis could get back together (albeit temporarily) I don't see why these two couldn't do it either.
vodude 6 months ago
some sunny days or maybe...to the dark side of the moon!bye Richard!
angelo383 6 months ago
I would pay just about anything to see the remaining member in concert again.
neilhas 6 months ago
Is that Wright @ 0:32?
TopVersnelling 7 months ago
1:26 HAHAHHAHA david is the devil
loombaron 7 months ago
@loombaron hahaha you are motherfucker devil. will you shut up. you aint no realy pink floyd fan if have this coment. if you delte this than you are a realy pink floyd fan.
MrBjanka 7 months ago
it just brings tears...
badqual 7 months ago
Man, Two rock ledgends can't get along, Sad really, God I wish they would get back and put out a record
ljpelicano 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Such a bitter band...you think they were a bunch of females holding on too their grudges to the grave.
neilzep 7 months ago
rogers just thinking SHIT, pink floyd got better when he left. haha for me gilmour is the sound and voice of floyd, gilmours who i pay to go and see, not roger. no disrespect to roger though, he did write the wall after all.
twotellys12 7 months ago
The last picture of them in 1975 and 2007 <3
stophiemeister 7 months ago
...and just like other great marriages, they never last--Lennon & McCartney, Simon & Garfunkel. Sad!
tofoodood 7 months ago
damn...you can cleary see they're not comfortable near each other
Corleonetone 7 months ago
@Corleonetone If it's the first time for a decade or two they are so close to each other, it's no bloody wonder that they are slightly uncomfortably in each others company!
But i would love to see a reunited Pink Floyd on the road
trident1702 7 months ago
.... 1:21 ...
Slowsilvers7ms 7 months ago
@Slowsilvers7ms It's almost like Roger's wshing Dave to burst into flames/
opusvideo2001 7 months ago