Comic Book Reviews: Uncanny X-Men #494 and Nightwing #140

[lionvclennon]

nightwing is the best man

[Kako8294]

X-men has been notorious for making time traveling a bit confusing in old comics and cartoons.

[BenReilly15]

I love Justin

He makes me laugh so much

X

[pglove69]

listen at that jewish guy like turns into the hulk i replayed that like 5 times - 10:11

[alhex123]

COOL NERDS LOL SOMETIMES IM LIKE THAT

[medicwheat69]

I've just picked up and read through issue 0-9 of the comic "Fall of Cthulhu" and it's great, story driven take and continuation from a grand H.P. Lovecraft short story. I'd love to hear your take on the comic, also there's a TPB with the first 0-7 issues out "I got lucky and found all the issues at my local comic shop instead of having to go with the TPB"

[LatinD]

Review, preview. And "thanks you"? WTH?

Regardless, entertaining as always. I still would love to hear you guys discuss series that are already complete, and give recommendations for would-be readers. So I'll insist in your comments section. :)

Thanks for sharing - you guys deserve more viewers.

[greenmonkey88]

demonic alex!!

[hellointernet]

Damn straight Marvel is the real universe bitches!!! Also, love the t shirt Justin. Augie March are amazing.

[JustinTyler13]

Yes! One of my top 3 favorite bands!

[Cotygeek]

I don't think Peter and MJ being married ruined Spider-Man, but it was just never written correctly. They kept showing MJ as just his wife caught in the background. She was never portrayed as a realistic person. They should have focussed in on making the marriage more realistic, and we would've had something that wouldn't need a retcon. It also seemed like everything went downhill after Romita and JMS left (except the whole gwen babies. Bad move JMS. Bad move).

[joshbotnik]

I've got mixed feelings about OMD. I felt the whole thing just came and went to quick. To do a retcon that big in only four issues, felt sloppy to me. Not that I like the idea much anyway. But, in its defence, I thought it was written well.

[pjperez]

I agree. It WAS written well. But it's ludicrous, offensive and wholly unnecessary. Felt like a way for the editorial team to get out of a box without having to be creative.

[SmileOnADog]

Which movie will I not be seeing? You get three guesses.

I'm glad the web shooters are gone. I'm glad that Harry is back. I think that the erradication of the marriage is hugest mistake Marvel has ever made.

[dabebop]

they need script writers and the middle guy needs sedatives.

[bubba152]

Thank GOD I'm not a Spider Man collector!!!!

[Oppp2]

WAR RAMBO!!

[GodofRoads]

I see that OMD got rid of some stuff that I was ambivalant to. (Organic web shooters, I didn't even think about that anymore) and the Other storyline was being ignored anyway, but even so it got rid of so much more that I actually enjoyed that when I weigh in on it I gotta go negative. I have always disagree with Joe Q about the Marriage between MJ and Peter and I always will.

[madsciiscrazy]

LMFAO HE CAN Go ON A DATE WITH HIS WIFE

[BlackPanther637]

I thought Shark Man was entertaining. And Thuderbolts is just a GREAT COMIC.

[odouglasj]

I'm a big fan of Nightwing. He's the original Robin. But he's grown up and moved on. He can't be "Boy Wonder" forever. But he doesn't want to be Batman Jr. either. I think he's a great character.

Visits from Superman can get tiresome, however.

[Daredevilfan182]

I watch Dcompose's Spider-Man 101: One More Day review the dudes a big spidy fan I saw people feakin out I just think its another move for Mavel to bring new readers which obviouly there great at otherwise I wouldnt be typin this. Anywho kool vid thanks again to Pulpsecret another great review.

[Daredevilfan182]

I dont follow Uncanny altough this Messiah Complex might change that fact. I heard NightWing is a great comic and Iv been meaning to follow up on it for a while now but Im just following to many titles at the moment. And isnt X-Force from waaayy back I think it ws Lighting Comic or something does anyone know?

[kingcanti]

Another great episode.

[Dragon92364]

RE: How would I feel if Marvel undid "one more Day" a year from now??? I wouldn't f***ing care! Straczynski & Quesada are both JERKS and have ruined the Spider-man franchise for the forseeable future, and it will be a long time before I bother with it again.

[drew227]

this show would be a lot better without justin

[PlushJake]

Alex smash!

[chemicaljordan]

One more day is a horrible way of getting rid of parts in the storyline.

Its like waking up one morning and the past 10 years of your life never happened.

And if you HAVE to do something like this, it should have been with many more characters and should have been more epic.

[118tariqkhan118]

thx man i think its all coming back to me lol

[delatexan]

What?! Youngblood copied a story from another book!? I'm shocked, SHOCKED, I say! And to think, such an original concept as Youngblood would DO such a thing!

Meh, wake me when there's actually a Youngblood #2...

And Nightwing rules, but what the hell does Superman want now?! Is he still peeved over Wings pulling the k-rock on him?

[energon]

Quesada said nothing changed except for Peter & MJ not getting married. The Other still happened, he still unmasked,but no one remembers who he was, he still had organic webshooters, Aunt May's home still hurned down, but is mysteriously back.

Ahh - I'm getting a headache.

[CjosephBell]

everybody has feet- nice. 5 stars for that one

[superguy04]

what super hero seems to hve hos past changed the most?

[Jimystic]

Lol @ all the RAGE in this ep.

I'm pretty sure they're gonna undo the One More Day storyline eventually and I don't think it's gonna be a year until they do so. Especially with all the angry fans. I'm just wondering how they're gonna undo it and I hope it won't be done in a crappy way. We'll see.

[energon]

Did you guys even read Marv Wolfmans run on Nightwing? Seems from your comments you tried Jones run,but gave up on it.

[bydee]

i'm guessing that quesada wanted ASM to be as convoluted as spidy3 movie. what do you guys think?

peace!

[BlackPhoenix06]

Great episode as always.

[andymort]

Re: One More Day -- Quesada said (in the interview Justin referenced) that the only thing different was, on their wedding day, for some reason Peter and MJ didn't go through with it. He says everything happened & people will remember them as being a couple, just not married. Which means the Clone Saga, The Other, Gwen & Norman -- all still happened. Of course, the Clone Saga was orchestrated BY Norman from over in Europe, as revenge for Harry's death. Which apparently also never happened...

[ahfldsj]

soon as joe q is out as E-I-C spidey will go back to the way things were before and this will all seem like a horrible dream.

^_^

[weker1]

Wellcome back Pete!

Fun Show and YEah That Hole New York Gotham Thing bugs THe hell out of me!

[MoreMelon]

love the show as always guys, you rock

[krootasaurusrex]

I've been disappointed with Youngblood in the past, so I have no interest in the revived series.

What happened to the shorter show? I liked those shorter format.

[azalben]

@krootasaurusrex: We don't know how to stop talking? In general, we're aiming for a shorter show, but sometimes, things engender a longer discussion.

[potmanbox]

i love nightwing :D

[FFTVS]

good show again....

So if Bishop succeeds in stopping his time line from happening, what happens to him???

[Dreadpirate46]

Welcome back, Pete!

I ordered Youngblood #1. Hopefully I'll like it, but I have my reservations.

As for One More Day, I just don't see why Marvel didn't just divorce Peter and Mary Jane. It would have made more sense than doing a huge retcon and I think would have been more accepted by the fans/readers.

[MarvelFan01]

hi guys love you show what do you thing about x:men emperor vulcan

[unrealnews]

You guys are incurable. At any rate, I think your should do an episode where you're each a beastie boy -- Pete as MCA, Justin as AdRock and Alex as Mike D. I'm into the current X-men storyline. It feels like it's been done properly finally... WITH HIS WIFE!

[superguy04]

The thing at the end was creepy.

[humanshapedplushie]

omg first comment!!!!!!!!!! luv the show!