Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (303)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • These people so dont understand this book...oh my god. Its sort of offensive the way they are talking about it. >.<

  • These girls aren't not serious about the book... it seems at times they make fun of bella and edwards personality... really offensive to those of us who live this book...

  • see ww.breakingdawn2.info  ^_^ v

  • they r spoiling it X( STOP IT !! READ IT FIRST !!!

  • l was going to see what they have for the review but this suck they keep talking a lot some am like where did that come from ?! .. . sigh

  • this is sooo wrong they dont understand the book at ALL!!! :(

  • why no talking about jacob

  • YOU GUYS NEED TO GET A LIFE.... KRISTEN IS FINE THE WAY SHE IS AND EDWARD AND EVERYONE ELSE!!!!!!

  • So i decided to watch this instead of read the book because my gf wanted me to read the book before the movie came out. I stoped reading because Bella does nothing but piss me off and make me stop reading. But now im going to read it again, because it seems so much better than listening to all of u jabber on about how Edward is the perfect man. News flash he isnt at all...

  • All I can say is wow! They must feel stupid after reading these comments...DUH! Apparently, as everyone already noted, these women have never read the books. Talk about jumping on the bandwagon and not knowing wtf you're talking about! And FYI, he hasn't had a desire to kill her for like 2 books now soooo yeah, smh...

  • HONESTLY have you guys read the book....the preface where she is talking about giving her lif it has absolutely NOTHING to do with edward.....read half the book and it has to do with dying for her DAUGHTER RENESMEE!!! gosh have you read it

  • I wanted to watch it but it's too stupid.

    HOW are these women supposed to review a book if they don't know what it is about?

  • I think it's bullshit that they gave spoilers "Foreshadowing for birth scene."

  • i'm wondering why these particular women were picked to talk about this... cause they seem to hate both bella and edward

  • I am just now watching these and I didn't read all the comments, but I think you are way off on what the Preface was about. I think it had nothing to do with Edward wanting to kill Bella, I think it had to do with Bella and the baby.

  • Really? Are you serios? If you're going to discuss Breaking Dawn read the book first. Yo have no idea what you are talking about.

  • Book club ?

    ...HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • I think that all vampires have souls, and the Cullen definitely do, because they're the most gracious, kind vampires. I think that it's their choice to be good or evil, and if they act like they have a soul or not.

  • I'm not gonna start an HP vs. Twilight discussion, but...how am I on here? I was looking for the Hunger Games on the ClevverTV channel...

    Eeesh, when she puts the flap of the book like that....breaking the spine of the book....makes me wince. I hate it when people do that--THE PEOPLE ARE DESTROYING THE BOOK!

  • Masterpiece... Masterpiece? They called it a masterpiece...

  • most vampires soul, the cullens deffinetly a soul

  • OK they have no idea what they are talking about...

  • Seriously if ur going to criticize the book instead of actually discussing it ,then why even do this video? They should've gotten actual fans of the series to do the discussions ;)

  • Tanyas was not Edward's "sort of ex gf" you fucking idiots!

  • i really hope they removed the music while they read the book and when they talk because we can barely understand..

  • Is it just me or are you 4 all kinda tearing on Bella i mean saying she should be an emo and stuff and takling about how she is miserable is kinda silly because she may not be to you but for thousands of young girls she provides a rolemodel and you guys just basically said she is not fun or anything which just isnt true.

  • is the birth of bella n edwards baby on the first breaking dawn movie or the second 1? and does the first breaking dawn movie finnish on the brith scene or wat??????????????

  • olnly the cullens for sure :D

  • Is it just me or is the background moving ??

  • @DCAG62294 I believe it's the camera moving

  • LoL,this girls are so funny,they were like Aww Jacob,I really feel bad for him so hot I mean with that hot body his shirt off poor guy,LoL! ;D

  • I really liked when Edward's brothers came to get him for the bachelor party.... bella considering winning a tug-0-war with emmett, and when she asked what Jasper what they did for bachelor parties LOL! :)

  • they suck... :(

  • OK...here is a question that my daughter actually asked S Meyer at a book signing of The Host...(don't get mad at me) "What does Edward do when it is Bella's time of the month?"...Oh, yes she did ask that...they didn't answer the question...any thoughts?

  • @ClydineD Meyer has already answered that. Basically she said Edward is too much of a gentleman to mention it and two, she said that that is "dead blood" and it doesn't effect him.

  • @musicismymotive Thanks for clarifying that...I will pass it on to my daughter...but that does make since.

  • Do they have to state everything thats obvious? I mean Come on use your brain!!!!

  • Don't ruin that book you *#$%$*#(

  • i love team edward amd cullens

  • Vampires do have souls. Especially the Cullens. Think about it, there're people out there that go and murder people everyday, and then there're nice people who could never hurt a fly and get bitten by a vampire, it doesn't mean they don't have a soul. Like Carlisle did when he got bitten, he controlled himself and he is the nicest person ever who could never harm anybody. He then became a doctor and saves lives everyday.

  • WOW. They have no idea what they are even talking about. Leave it to dumbass clevverTV to pick THE WORST people to talk about this book...

  • THAT IS SO DUMB THEIR NOT EVEN TALKING ABOUT THE BOOK PLUS WHEN THEY DO (RARLEY) IT DOSENT MAKE ANY SENCE! WTF!?!

  • I don't think vampires have souls. But the Cullen's are another type of Vampire. So, Yes they do have souls.

  • Yes. I believe that vampires have souls. That is way the Cullen's are good and the others are not. It is a choice that every one of them had to make.

  • Isn't the preface about renesmee because Bella loves her so much, but she is technically killing her from the inside???

  • @lucyislawless18 yes, but i think they're trying not to give that part away. Even though the whole world basically knows that already, lol

  • @lucyislawless18 yeah you right. I don't kno what they were thinking

  • @lucyislawless18 omg thank you soo mcuh i never thought it like that......nice!!!!

  • Are you guys even fans of twilight? Cause you really dont act like it. For example, you guys said that its weird that Edward doesn't want to go to his bachelor party. You obviously dont know Edward. He is tired of being single! I mean, if you had been single for over a hundred years, you wouldn't enjoy it much either. And he was born in 1901. They had different morals back then. Guys didn't go to strip clubs or anything even close to that.

  • She is talking about dying for her baby, not her lover!

  • @jds520

    omg i know, that bothered me when they said that! but i guess there acting like the havent read it for people who are reading it for the first time mabye?

  • I missed it what did they do to the cover?

  • I honestly think that it's a possibility for all vampires in the books to lose their souls when their changed. They are driven to live a life of a vampire and feed off of humans. But with that being said, I think that once a vampire has chosen to reject their nature and become more civilized(i.e. drink animal blood instead), their soul is returned to them. Causing them to form true bonds of love. IDK... just my take on it.

  • can u read midnight sun online ? 

  • @xrachaelx1000 Yes you can:) Go to Stephanie Meyer's website and you can download it from there:) But it only goes up to just before Edward and Bella go to the meadow. Stephanie Meyer never completed it because someone hacked into her computer and tried to send it out online. She might finish it, she might not but I hope she does...

  • @LeleWahine808 no,she has finished it...i have read it already

  • @devahuti1 OMG! did she really finish it?? where can i read it??

  • @devahuti1 Really? I thought she never finished it cause it said so on her website. Can you tell me where you got it?

  • lmao, i chuckled literally the who way thru this. these girls are hillarious haha

  • i dident read the book and im finding all these ineresting facts on the movie, WOW EDWARD HAD A GURLFRIEND befor bella and shes at the wedding.... AWKWARD!!!!!

  • @sheashealicious12345 ...Edward never dated Tanya.

  • book clubs about vampire and human love... some people are so distant from the brink of reality it's appalling

  • @csm23232 uh ,that's what books are for, they are there to entertain you and help you to escape from reality for a little while. If I didnt have an outlet to help me escape the stress from my "reality" I would go mad. That includes entertainment in general, thats what its there for.

  • Good job! I love the part of the book about the car. She realizes just how much Edward worries about her safety. The night before the wedding is sweet. Edward & Bella just want to be with each other all the time. Jasper & Emmett are funny here too.

  • It pains me to watch them do that to the cover...

  • Hello people...... she referring to the baby that is killing her but that she will not give up because it a piece of Edward that he (& she) will never get a chance to have ever again . Get a clue or be quiet!!!!! Or just talk about the car some more.

  • hahaha I too was completely obsessed with JTT!

  • in eclipse he was all i don't wanna kill u anymore cuz he thought she was dead for a 24 hours am i right ...thumbs up.

  • Vampires have souls, there just souls from hell.

  • Has anyone thought that the reason Vampires are still around is because they have souls? Isn't it when someone dies they lose their soul, but vamps are still here even though they have died. So I think they do have souls

  • Lets be clear about this...ANGEL and SPIKE had souls before it was all cool to be a vampire with a soul...lol just saying..

  • Just saying people its just an opinion

  • Okay twihards people have a right to their opinions and what's wrong of poking fun at the series when I read the preface I thought it was edward but then he doesnt have the urge to kill bella anymore I had no idea until later on in the book and I believe it was they're first time reading the book if I remember correctly most of the time book clubs are talking about books you never read before

  • i think the cullens have souls! they are soooooooooooooo nice and even TRY not to kill humans! contact me!

  • The music is soooo annoying!

  • Well, i don't like Twilight, so... i'm out :)

  • I think all vampires have souls.

  • whoever called bella a brat is a bitch! the girl in the all black shirt is such a bitch ,i dont like her at all :(

  • Clevvertv you must find people who actually knows about all the books! A real fan, who loves and feels the books. I don't like The way you talk about Renne's reaction, she understood and respected Bella's decision, because she really know her, Bella never had been the tipical teenager, she is mature! Btw sorry for my english is not my first language.

  • whoever called bella a brat is a bitch!

  • Clevvertv you must find people who know about all The book!! Real fan! I don't like The way you talk about Renne's reaction

  • I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU MADE A BOOK CLUB AND CANNOT EVEN UNDERSTAND THE BOOK. THE PREFACE ITS ABOUT RENESSMEE, NOT EDWARD. YOU GUYS ARE THE DUMBEST BLONDS EVER!!

    THIS IS A REALLY DEAP AND GORGEOUS BOOK IF YOU CAN READ IT RIGHT. TOTALLY DISSAPOINTED ON THIS VIDEO, I COULDNT EVEN FINISH WATCHING IT!

  • y start a book club if all your going to do is make fun of the book and its characters and not to mention piss off all the fans of the book!!! good job idiots! o and also at least get people that have read and love the books not two blonds that seemed like they would love to be any were else but there.

  • they found the 4 dumbest blonds on the planet !!!

    Seriously ??? read the book you idiots!

  • @Rene23Engelngel there no all blonde

  • @Rene23Engelngel actually one of them is brunette lol

    

  • @Rene23Engelngel Your pretty dumb...i mean, ones a brunette...and another is a dirty blonde....Getyourfactsright.

  • Ok, ClevverTV, please read the books before you do a book club. I won't list the mistakes you made since they have already been pointed out by may others, but remember true twi fans have the books several times over and know the story very well.

  • This was a disgrace to Breaking Dawn and the whole franchise.

  • esme didnt adopt them idiot they were all created into a family by carlisle

    bella isn't a girly girl-she doesnt do clothes and dresses and parties-U WOULD NO THAT IF U ACTUALLY READ THE SERIES

    he was from year 1? rly asss ur so dumb. edward has been living ALONE for 100 years...would u want to celebrate that? idiots

    they arnt semi exs-edward nvr showed intrest in her IDIOTS!and theyre family -COUSINS

    UGH YOU IDIOTS! IF UR GONNA HAVE A BOOK CLUB ACTUALY READ THE SERIES NOT JUST THE DAM SCRIPT

  • Is anyone bother by the fact that they are completely off in their comments 30 secs going into the conversation. seriously. -____-

  • @AlyxKarateChop i was these ppl are rly annoying me lol

  • EPIC FAIL!!!!!!!!!

  • seriously women get your facts right. just don´t make a video about something you don´t know anything about.

    1.like miel277 said the preface is about renesmee.

    2.the mercedes guardian is a fictional car steph created, it´s supposed to be something like the updated version of the mercedes guard.

    3.bella does not think her life is in danger. she just realizes that edward loves her and wants her to be safe.

    renee wasn´t ..Not enough signs to write down the rest of the mistakes you made. no offence

  • ehhhh Twilight shit

  • @Thatguywhokill ehhh harry potter shit :)

  • If your going to do a book club use the hardback version versus the paperback. I think it helps with the authantisity. The part you read from the preface was about the baby Bella is going to carry Its similar to the preface to Twilight about Bella willing to die for Edward. The dream is about Bella protecting this GREEN eyed boy (like Edwards) from the voltori, then later after hearing the story about the immortal children the dream turn dark and the green eyed boy is on a pile of dead bodies.KS

  • this must have been done right after they got drunk boy i love you guys but did anyone look at this befor you posted it so they could tell you nto redo it

  • their kinda annoying other than that i love this book TWILIGHT SAGA!!!

  • ahhhh! excited! 

  • The Cullen's do have souls no matter what and Tanya better back off, that's Bella's man!!

  • I'm not suprised they're bashing the book, i refuse to believe that this book was apart of the series. I'd like to think Steph was on crack when writing this

  • Ahh I'm finally apart of a book club lmbo Thank you @ClevverTV!! #BDBC is awesome!!

  • I love your interpretation of Bella's bachalorette party cause i said the same thing lol she would be crying in the corner

  • for me the preface i believe that its about the child she is carrying rennesme rather than it being edward, i mean it is rennesme that is killing her from the inside out and she loves the child and any mother would die for their child

  • That was really, really lame.... not to mention second-hand embarrassing...

  • I can't believe I watched the first 7 min

  • there r two kinds of souls. evil and good. i believe everyone has a soul, even the vampires. the ones who go around killing and never feel guilty about it or just dont care of course have evil souls which u cant really do anything about. the cullens and vampires like them have good souls because they try not 2 hurt ppl and they just want as normal a life as possible. but not all vampires that kill humans have bad souls. some dont want 2 but feel they arent strong enough not 2 kill. it depends.

  • there r two kinds of souls. evil and good. i believe everyonee has a sould, even the vampires. the ones who go around killing and never feel guilty about it or just dont care of course have evil souls which u cant really do anything about. the cullens and vampires like them have good souls because they try not 2 hurt ppl and they just want as normal a life as possible. but not all vampires that kill humans have bad souls. some dont want 2 but feel they arent strong enough not 2 kill. it depends

  • i like twighlight abit but i dont want 2 admit it cuz of the crazy fans and cuz of the people that say twiglite it bettr than hp

  • they don't really sound like Twihards and they're always like "WE LOVE TWILIGHT" but yet they're putting down the characters...i thought this was supposed to be GOOD things about Twilight

  • i think it's sweet that he didn't want to go to a bachelor party. in the book he mentions that bachelor parties are for guys who are sad to see their single life end. he's been alone for 100 YEARS. i think he'd rather stay and kiss bella all night ;)

  • "she wants to get freaky in the sheets" LOL

  • have u guys even read the whole book??? u would know immediately that it's renesmee and not edward in the preface because she was talking about how renesmee is killing her but she loved her so she couldn't kill her own daughter for her life.

  • This is really funny! They're like bagging the book and the characters! lol

  • whats a soul

  • i think vampires have souls they mit not be good ones but they still have souls

  • Did anyone lese notice Joslyn is the only non-blonde one?

  • OMFG THEY HAVE NOOO IDEA WHAT THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT!!!! -_-

  • Stephenie Meyer address on her website that the Guardian isn't a car that exists, but is similar to one that does exist. And the before/after is for when she's changed, not the wedding.

    If you've read the previous books you would know what Renee meant by her saying Bella wasn't like most teenagers.

  • WHAT THE HELL.. Edward doesn't want to kill bella.. Are you completely mental?

  • @brentfordgirl090 i know right. when i heard they were doing this i thought ..finally they are doing something usefull with my time but oh no they are just screwing it up

  • Okay calm down about the preface people :O it doesnt actually say Edward or Renesmee, and they are not the only ones who were mistaken, i assumed it meant Edward too. It sounds kinda similar to the bit from the first twilight "But dying in the place of someone i love, seems like a good way to go" or word to that effect lol :)

  • I love that you are doing a book club but please get the facts right. Did you read the book? Or are you guys just reading it and reviewing as you go?????

  • I got married when I was 19, so did my brother and sister. My other brother got married when he was 30. We are all different, and all very happily married. These days many people consider it wrong to get married young, and I'm sure for alot of people it is wrong, but for some people it is the right thing to do :) By the way I agree, the before and after cars make awesome symbolism!

    p.s. the preface is totally referring to Renesmee, not Edward!

  • I love what you ladies are doing, but stop hating on Bella so much! Lol!

  • fyi they are caled immortal children

  • joslyn that part you read was not about edward it was about renesmee

  • why did you do that to the cover!!??

  • @iJmarch i honestly don't know what ur talkin bout can u please explain?

  • @MRSmaryann54321 at 00:52 she folded the cover of the book and i pity the book in that matter..

  • @iJmarch aww i see lol thanks

  • reread the entire series through 500 more times. as journalists u should be reporting true facts not made up crap.

  • ummm where in the books does it EVER say edward fought in a world war? these chicks need to learn to read properly... your whats wrong with journalism. edward was changed in 1918... and WW1 was from 1914-1918ish... and he died at 17.. so the war started when he was 13... what 13 yr old fights in a world war??? and i doubt carlisle, volturi would let a vampire fight in a war where they cant die? wouldnt someone notice that this guys getting shot at but he isnt dying at all? reread the books!

  • Have you not read Midnight Sun?? The thing between Edward and Tanya wasnt a hundred years ago. It was during Twilight, after he sees Bella for the first time, he goes to Alaska. He turns Tanya down and realises he has fallen for Bella

  • @lianneand3 wrong he goes there to escape killing Bella. Tanya attempted to be with Edward long before that. Yes she continued to like him, but nothing happen between them when he went to Alaska

  • @davelucena1 Have you read Midnight Sun? I know nothing happened between them in Alaska. I know he went there to escape killing Bella, but he realised he had fallen in love with her while he was there.

  • Anyone who truly had read breaking dawn knows that you have not .

  • In the twilight saga official ilustrated guide by SM it says that the Guardian is the only fiction car and it comes from the guard only with more features

  • u guys are so stupid.....

  • I AM DEFINITELY WATCHING THIS!!!!

  • i tihnk it s just the cullens and the other clans that have golden eyes

    the reason that i think that is because the cullens and other clans dont drink human blood

  • Team JACOB! <3

  • @ClevverTV dipshits that preface about the beloved was about renesmee. Think about it now and realize your dumbass mistake

  • okay if their getting paid for doing a friggin book club, they need to get ALL their facts straight.

  • Some vampires have souls, like the Cullens but I also think the vampires for the vampire diaries have souls too and in the preface she was talking about Renesmee not Edward

  • @Kitty27655 Of Course the Cullens have souls! How codl they not realize that thepreface is about Renesemee and not Edward?

  • TANYA WAS NOT EDWARD'S EX! she just had a crush on him..

  • he doesnt want to kill her. >.>

  • You have it wrong, It's Renesmee, but I also thought it was Edward before I started reading the book....

  • Um i think the Cullen's have soul's cause they are conscience of what they do while other vampires just look humans like something to eat. the preface was actually talking about Renesmee not Edward. Tanya is so not Edward's ex or semi ex ! Edward never liked her or had anything with her! so it isnt weird for Edward to invite her. as for Edward not wanting to go to the bachelor party i dont think it's weird, i think its fine that they want to spend time together! can't wait for the next episode!

  • :)

  • I CANT BELIEVE UR MAKING A BOOK CLUB AND DON'T GET THE FACTS RIGHT! WHAT U READ WAS ABOUT RENESMEE NOT EDWARD!! HE DOESN'T WANT TO KILL HER NO MORE!! RENESMEE DOESNT EATHER BUT SHE CAN'T HELP IT CUS SHE HAS TO GROW UP!!!!

  • @miel277 just what i was thinking SSOOOO RIght

  • @miel277 When I first read the book I assumed it meant Edward was killing her. I had no idea until later it was Renesmee.

  • @miel277 i think they mean the part about how he thirsts for her blood but i agree some of the facts are wrong and badly worded

  • @miel277 they didnt read the book I guess

  • @miel277 We know its just for those people who haven't heard, read the book or any website and watched the trailer.

  • @miel277 go read a real book, please.