I think it would be cool to have a survivor where there are only winners from past seasons that way the winner wouldn't be voted out just because they had won before
i totaly agreee, they all deseve 2 b allstars bar one or 2 (sandra diaz and twila) jerri and rob c are 2 ov the better survivors from a tactical point ov view! also jonathan and ami, coz there good at sturin the pot. can u immagine if there was a all star version with one tribe consistin all ov winners!!!!!
Rob C never got to choose who he wanted out. He always knew who he had to use to get out the person he needed, but he never got to choose who that person was. Todd got to choose who he wanted out when he wanted them out. He got whoever he wanted to vote out whoever he wanted, and they always listened. Nobody else in the history of the show was ever able to do that. every single time.
and I hate to break it to you, that Todd played a WAY better game then a lot of winners. He is most definately one of the most deserving winners in Survivor History. I loved how you put the winners on one tribe and seperated them from others. if mark brunett would ctach the hint, he'd do that also. btw excellent casting with this, best all star cop off Ive seen yet
Actually, Parvati was away better than Todd. She brought all the women together and took out all the guys. And no matter what, she knew she would win because she got along with everyone in her women alliance. Voting out Ozzy improved her chances of winning, especially when she brought Alexis and Natalie with her.
Most of them aren't actually on the all stars shows. This is just this person's list. Todd is definitely deserving of being an all star. The only reason he isn't is because there are no winners. Todd is easily the best player in the history of Survivor.
6 winners on one team though?
masspunk1983 9 months ago
I agree with everying! except for Richard Hatch, Rob C., and Stupid face Johnny Fairplay. My favorite players ever are Sandra, Todd, and James.
rvshawnee 1 year ago
@rvshawnee Oh and I almost forgot Yao Man Chan should DEFENITLY WITHOUT A DOUBT be a Survivor allstar he is my favorite player out of anyone!!!
rvshawnee 1 year ago
take away james and you'll be fine
tylerssurvivorblog 1 year ago
Russel Hantz greatest to play survivor
Piques13 2 years ago
hell yeah
SamBouchard31 1 year ago
If Rupert doesn't win Heroes V.S Villians I will kill myself.
TheMasterofVGs 2 years ago
@TheMasterofVGs
go kill yourself.coz sandra will win.
marialindaconsebido 1 year ago
I think it would be cool to have a survivor where there are only winners from past seasons that way the winner wouldn't be voted out just because they had won before
SamBouchard31 2 years ago 10
@SamBouchard31 Yea i agree
PainkillerZ1 2 years ago
Like it or not, they just did!
SirHaakon 2 years ago
My favorite of the intro are tom, sandra, rupert, james, and jonathan and your right where is ozzy at????
kkyolbee 2 years ago
where's ozzy!?
skydog34 2 years ago
eliza? :(
Guihahuha 3 years ago 2
i totaly agreee, they all deseve 2 b allstars bar one or 2 (sandra diaz and twila) jerri and rob c are 2 ov the better survivors from a tactical point ov view! also jonathan and ami, coz there good at sturin the pot. can u immagine if there was a all star version with one tribe consistin all ov winners!!!!!
mattyauld 3 years ago
5 of them were actually on Micronesia, and Parv won
bbandcbandkb 3 years ago
I worked on survivor All stars, Vanuatu and Palau. It is a really cool experience!!!(meet jeff and my husband!!!)
My favorite survivor is Rupert!!!
take care!!
slag03Z 3 years ago
Love Richard, Rupert, Jonathan, James and Colby.
Fairplay sucks, but needs to be in such a game
I dislike Sue and Twila though... Better let Eliza and Kelly Bigglesworth (Borneo Runner-up) replace them
bam859 3 years ago
Yes Brian Hiedink needs to be there. And if I see Rupert for a 3rd time I'll drop dead. Enough of that overrated brute.
CaptainXero 3 years ago 2
guys let me know this is survivor all stars after survivor vanuatu???...reply to me if u guys know pls!!!
boss5t3fan 3 years ago
That'd be gay being on survivor 3 times
kevmacd12 3 years ago
Jenna M and Parvati <33333
philtonfan 3 years ago 2
where is eliza she was a great player
enmanuelcruz4 3 years ago
Terrible picks for the winners and non-winners. James, Rupert, Johnny are the best, and Yao Man isn't even on the roster? Horrible pick.
matthieu124 3 years ago
no ozzy, terry or yau man??????
joshwanakamik 3 years ago
I know. :S Everyones making their all stars videos.... I want to make one! :> How do you make them?
earthynatalie 3 years ago
that would be a greta game but you need boston rob and amber in there.
jerbear0003 3 years ago
i agree.
tAsHiEzAwEsOmE 3 years ago
Rob C never got to choose who he wanted out. He always knew who he had to use to get out the person he needed, but he never got to choose who that person was. Todd got to choose who he wanted out when he wanted them out. He got whoever he wanted to vote out whoever he wanted, and they always listened. Nobody else in the history of the show was ever able to do that. every single time.
ilovekelly75 3 years ago
Aw... no Yau-Man Chan?
DarkFireYoshi 4 years ago
I loved how you put the winners on a seperate tribe to make it fair for them. Man, I wish this was real. I want Sandra back on the show!
hugaloaf 4 years ago
Oh man, I'm exited! They have some of my favorite people back on the show. It will be interesting to see how some of them are together.
LOL Richard is back. Oh boy. xD
S0cialButterfly 4 years ago
and I hate to break it to you, that Todd played a WAY better game then a lot of winners. He is most definately one of the most deserving winners in Survivor History. I loved how you put the winners on one tribe and seperated them from others. if mark brunett would ctach the hint, he'd do that also. btw excellent casting with this, best all star cop off Ive seen yet
cameronplaya7389 4 years ago
Actually, Parvati was away better than Todd. She brought all the women together and took out all the guys. And no matter what, she knew she would win because she got along with everyone in her women alliance. Voting out Ozzy improved her chances of winning, especially when she brought Alexis and Natalie with her.
xlameblamex 3 years ago
hate to brake it to you but todd is not an allstar
doglover4life909 4 years ago
Most of them aren't actually on the all stars shows. This is just this person's list. Todd is definitely deserving of being an all star. The only reason he isn't is because there are no winners. Todd is easily the best player in the history of Survivor.
ilovekelly75 4 years ago
That's a ballsy comment. I didn't see Todd but is he REALLY better than Rob C? Rob C fuckin ran the show from day 1
EUGENE4PRES 4 years ago
I would say Rob C is a close second.
ilovekelly75 4 years ago