@aetherJade It is -- it's because she's actually doing it live. A lot of artists take their songs down in keys when they sing them live and not with a pre-recorded vocal track.
Of Celine's entire career, this was probably her worst performance ever. That is saying alot beings this is still better than Miley, Madonna, Taylor Swift, etc at their best :P
@petergriffin9901 That is true, but she was also sick when she was in the UK. I don't know if she was sick here, but yes, she was doing this publicity, doing Vegas, and rehursals for the Taking Chances World Tour all at this time, and it took it's toll.
@scramasboy The ones she has troubles with are in Db (half step lower so it's easier to sing). If you see a live one and it's in D, it means she's doing ok vocally. Well.. you can hear it too once you listen. Still though, You gotta love how she sings that oooon the edge part. very soft very nice E flat
Celine dion is also REALLY pretty!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She my bigest idol I think. Yeah! People also always think I think that I sing like Celine Dion! That made me feel really happy :)
YEA CELINE!!!!!!!!!! She is my favorite singer! No other singers are better than her! I wanna meet her rrrrrreeeeeeeaaaaaaaallllllllllllllll bad (real bad) My favorite song by a female artist is My heart will go on FROM Celine Dion. I'm her fan!!!! Yeah!!!! GO CELINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This song was sung so flawlessly, but funnily enough, because it's celine dion, and only celine dion - when she falters the tiniest bit, we're like..uhoh, she's having a bit of trouble. God, this woman is amazing - this was a great preformance and I wish she would always sing it live. But I guess she has the reputation of that voice and she needs to keep it.
Everbody how have something to say about celine dont handle the song is crazy. I am so impressed of this women. Iam a singer myself. I know how hard this song is. I am not even going to try ;) Love you celine
celine had trouble with this song from the get go....when I saw her in the Manchester U.K. soundcheck she went over and over certain phrases;sometimes starting in a lower range...she's a sweetheart tho' she apologised to us for being late to the soundcheck........Man U soccer match caused traffic problems....
Right after this, she stopped singing this song live and started having it dubbed for a bit. I think it's just so low and so high, it's a hard song to sing live. I saw her live in concert earlier this year and she sang it live and was fantastic. She's got it down now.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am a HUge fan of Celine, I have been following her for years now, but we have to admit that this song, Live, is terrble. In the CD it sounds amazing, but the live performqnces are always absolutely pathetic, they sound terrible to me. I love her, but we also have to be critic. Celine cannot handle this song, we have to admit it. Of course, this my opinion
u got that right, because charice thinks bellowing is singing. can't blame the girl. she's brought up in this generation, so she's still doing her bestest best haha
@ohbabybabyify let's look Charice in her age of 40, see if she still got her voice like Celine still get today...Celine still the best at her age today =)
I don't think many people share your opinion... it's a hard song to performe live and she does a very good job... time after time as well the lower parts as the powerfull higher parts... maybe you'd prefer to hear her lypsinc to this song ? :-)
Amazing performance, but one thing is missing! the live music...It would be much more fun to have musicians on the stage, actually playing the music. Celine is awesome though
hey PJ. no offense but yes, celine needed a freshening up.
taking chances was a complete departure from her "signature sound". if you listen to the tracks back to back youll see that celine completely went for the same execution of kara's original. Celines is a version since kara wrote it. the breaths, the raspy intro etc. this is not and has never been in celines arsenal. im not saying its not great it is. you cant make something your own unless you change it. celine did it verbatim.
listen to the original version of this song. Kara Dioguardi ( yes the idol new judge) absolutely owns this. she wrote it and obviously gave celine her new style cause its an exact copy.
no offense to celine, shes great of course but this is nada compared to the original.
completely agree - i am a massive celine fan but i was familier with this version before hers came out and i was having real trouble adjusting to celine singing it. she can NOT handle this song live at all...it just falls flat - she could have done 10 years ago. Kara has more emotion in her voice and suits the song way better.
Dirk, Celine doesn't need to be given "new style" at all. She's been in the music industry for over 25 years and has her own style and character. Kara's version is great, but Celine made it her own.
Celine chose to go for a "new sound". She was feeling like she needed to get more of an edge. She talked about it in interviews. That's what the whole album is like (the one with this song). She chose DioGuardi as a producer to help her find this edge she was seeking. People work with producers to gain a vision they feel would be helpful to them. If Celine didn't want this, she would have produced it herself with no arguments from anyone.
i agree that celine's version sounds extremely similar to kara's, but keep in mind that kara was the one who produced this song. and from the behind the scenes videos that came with her CD, kara was extremely nitpicky and had celine redo everything until she got it exactly to what she had in mind. so in a sense, celine is really great at giving the producers of her albums exactly what the want XP
Celine ALWAYS SINGS LIVE in her concerts. Guys watch er videos of her 2008 world tour. SUPERB!!! especially march-october. Her tour is still on going though till next year. Gosh it seems her voice is still very powerful after series of concerts to think she has a show in Vegas for 5 consecutive years. TRULY AMAZING! in her tour she easily hit her high notes. and i love her moves! She can sing and dance gracefully at the same time! awesome!
Celine Dion is legendary! She has "the one and only" voice. Nobody can sing like her. No wonder she was awarded the legendary award and also got the diamond award. She is hailed as the best selling female artist of all time. She is the most flexible artist I've ever seen. Can sing different types of songs. Can dance and sing gracefully at the same time. Also, she is very witty and humorous especially in her interviews. On top of that, she is humble unlike other artists. More power Celine!
look at that stage setting! Celine taking the world stage, on the universe singing for life on other planets! the wavering pieces of cloth over space. she's the one to take on that kind of universal stage!!
This is her best performance on TV - not liysynced. 100% live, there are subtle differences. Good singers make it sound similar every time - and she is better than good.... she is PHENOMENAL <3 Celine!
I love her peformances, whether she was lip-singing or not, because it's still her amazing voice you hear. She probably lip-sings it sometimes because she can't afford to use her voice too much or else it will get infected. Although it is nice to hear her sing live somtimes :)
god no!yes her voice changed but she didn't lost anything
for example:listen how she sings all by myself now and compare with an old live performance...she didn't loose anything ;p
And anyway,I think that she was sick at that time,I'm not sure but I know that there was a time (during her promoting "tour" of the tv shows before the beginning of her world tour) when she've been sick or something like that
i love when celine sings and cracks cuz i prefer a flawed live performance (Celine) than a perfectly recorded one (Mariah)
happybutt565 5 months ago
Comment removed
teeterc1 6 months ago in playlist Celine Dion
Is it just me or this is a key lower from the recorded?
aetherJade 7 months ago
@aetherJade It is -- it's because she's actually doing it live. A lot of artists take their songs down in keys when they sing them live and not with a pre-recorded vocal track.
OperaLover84 4 months ago
LEGEND.
805214 7 months ago
the good thing about weak sound is that, she's not lip-syncing :D and i love that
festivilicious 8 months ago
xtina and celine are both legends!
hurricaneioke 11 months ago
I must be deaf cuz i love the way she sings it here.
Jamaycon 1 year ago
the audio made her voice sound weaker than usual, its not celine's fault!!!
dbly88888888 1 year ago
Of Celine's entire career, this was probably her worst performance ever. That is saying alot beings this is still better than Miley, Madonna, Taylor Swift, etc at their best :P
scramasboy 1 year ago
@scramasboy This one isnt so bad, Id say the one on the X Factor was much worse... Celine overworked her voice during this period, it was weak
petergriffin9901 1 year ago
@petergriffin9901 That is true, but she was also sick when she was in the UK. I don't know if she was sick here, but yes, she was doing this publicity, doing Vegas, and rehursals for the Taking Chances World Tour all at this time, and it took it's toll.
scramasboy 1 year ago
@scramasboy The ones she has troubles with are in Db (half step lower so it's easier to sing). If you see a live one and it's in D, it means she's doing ok vocally. Well.. you can hear it too once you listen. Still though, You gotta love how she sings that oooon the edge part. very soft very nice E flat
Phewson60 1 year ago
Surely she was sick here... Her voice was unusually weak.
OneNobodyAND100000 1 year ago
This is the only song I have seen celine sing that she tends to have issues singing live.
Monkonmunky 1 year ago
@Monkonmunky I agree! It's a weird interval (the high note).
forbuss 1 year ago
it doesn't have much energy though T_T
SailorPerson 1 year ago
Celine dion is also REALLY pretty!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She my bigest idol I think. Yeah! People also always think I think that I sing like Celine Dion! That made me feel really happy :)
celinevote1 1 year ago
YEA CELINE!!!!!!!!!! She is my favorite singer! No other singers are better than her! I wanna meet her rrrrrreeeeeeeaaaaaaaallllllllllllllll bad (real bad) My favorite song by a female artist is My heart will go on FROM Celine Dion. I'm her fan!!!! Yeah!!!! GO CELINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
celinevote1 1 year ago
SO BEATIFUL
andrewfedd 1 year ago
please stop comparing charice to celine!!!!!!!!!!! excuse me, celine dion is idol of charice! -.-"
PreciousMariah22 1 year ago
It took her almost two mintues to smile.
neerrg 1 year ago
100% live here!!!! she is the best singing live.
elimoel1 1 year ago 4
she is pretty in here
carolinebernardo34 1 year ago
what a long way she's come from a small place in Canada :)
c6h12o6glucose 1 year ago
for someone so experienced in performing shes really awkward with her movements...
dojodog15 2 years ago
The Charice she wants to be Celine in her concerts, she only sings songs of Celine. But Celine is unique, it is the best!
CelineDionBRA 2 years ago 5
But Charice have a great future! If she sings Celine's songs it's very important because divulgate our Diva. Charice is Celine Fan. I love her!
lukinhascascavel 1 year ago
charice DOWN
CELINE UP
NO ONE CAN BE LIKE A CELINE DION
LOVE YOU CELINE
paulasimonify 2 years ago 9
This song was sung so flawlessly, but funnily enough, because it's celine dion, and only celine dion - when she falters the tiniest bit, we're like..uhoh, she's having a bit of trouble. God, this woman is amazing - this was a great preformance and I wish she would always sing it live. But I guess she has the reputation of that voice and she needs to keep it.
c6h12o6glucose 2 years ago 5
Simply the best, love you Celine.
82celinedion82 2 years ago 2
amazing
neocshs 2 years ago
i like it when she does the air guitar!
jesusjrd 2 years ago
God Celine ! Can't get enough of you.
nowandthen11 2 years ago 2
Everbody how have something to say about celine dont handle the song is crazy. I am so impressed of this women. Iam a singer myself. I know how hard this song is. I am not even going to try ;) Love you celine
cheppelin78 2 years ago 6
She didn't choose to go for a new sound, its that the song writers proposed to her.
Defyxx123 2 years ago
me loving this video to bits...x
allydatiggs1976 2 years ago
She's amazing, you don't know what you're talking about. She's always good!
P.S. She sang this song on my birthday
COOL4two 2 years ago
not a big fan of the air guitar.
StoneyEnd444 2 years ago
celine had trouble with this song from the get go....when I saw her in the Manchester U.K. soundcheck she went over and over certain phrases;sometimes starting in a lower range...she's a sweetheart tho' she apologised to us for being late to the soundcheck........Man U soccer match caused traffic problems....
serenedijon 2 years ago
Right after this, she stopped singing this song live and started having it dubbed for a bit. I think it's just so low and so high, it's a hard song to sing live. I saw her live in concert earlier this year and she sang it live and was fantastic. She's got it down now.
ryanarrowsmith 2 years ago
I actually think, she doesn't sing so bad that song live, but of course in the cd it sounds amazing...
vogelito93 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am a HUge fan of Celine, I have been following her for years now, but we have to admit that this song, Live, is terrble. In the CD it sounds amazing, but the live performqnces are always absolutely pathetic, they sound terrible to me. I love her, but we also have to be critic. Celine cannot handle this song, we have to admit it. Of course, this my opinion
abcde190 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
well charicem pempengco's live performances are amazing!!!!
donmacute 2 years ago
sorry, Charice is shit compared to Celine
ohbabybabyify 2 years ago 60
AMEN!
MusicMan0007 2 years ago
u got that right, because charice thinks bellowing is singing. can't blame the girl. she's brought up in this generation, so she's still doing her bestest best haha
Creevie 2 years ago 2
oh yeah!that's sooooo right..
maridette29 2 years ago 3
@ohbabybabyify please try to be a little more respectful, Celine is a living-legend and Charice is just starting to realize her dream
CDionSpain 1 year ago 3
@CDionSpain Charice is fucked !
chicolua 8 months ago
@ohbabybabyify totally. couldn't agree more
festivilicious 8 months ago
@ohbabybabyify i agree soooooooooooo badly!!!!!!
Herculeslai 7 months ago
@ohbabybabyify let's look Charice in her age of 40, see if she still got her voice like Celine still get today...Celine still the best at her age today =)
fadzili910422 6 months ago
I don't think many people share your opinion... it's a hard song to performe live and she does a very good job... time after time as well the lower parts as the powerfull higher parts... maybe you'd prefer to hear her lypsinc to this song ? :-)
brujvh1 2 years ago
Amazing performance, but one thing is missing! the live music...It would be much more fun to have musicians on the stage, actually playing the music. Celine is awesome though
Kirkh666 2 years ago 3
hey PJ. no offense but yes, celine needed a freshening up.
taking chances was a complete departure from her "signature sound". if you listen to the tracks back to back youll see that celine completely went for the same execution of kara's original. Celines is a version since kara wrote it. the breaths, the raspy intro etc. this is not and has never been in celines arsenal. im not saying its not great it is. you cant make something your own unless you change it. celine did it verbatim.
dirkworld 2 years ago
listen to the original version of this song. Kara Dioguardi ( yes the idol new judge) absolutely owns this. she wrote it and obviously gave celine her new style cause its an exact copy.
no offense to celine, shes great of course but this is nada compared to the original.
dirkworld 2 years ago
completely agree - i am a massive celine fan but i was familier with this version before hers came out and i was having real trouble adjusting to celine singing it. she can NOT handle this song live at all...it just falls flat - she could have done 10 years ago. Kara has more emotion in her voice and suits the song way better.
cttwii 2 years ago
Dirk, Celine doesn't need to be given "new style" at all. She's been in the music industry for over 25 years and has her own style and character. Kara's version is great, but Celine made it her own.
PJSJ22 2 years ago 2
Celine chose to go for a "new sound". She was feeling like she needed to get more of an edge. She talked about it in interviews. That's what the whole album is like (the one with this song). She chose DioGuardi as a producer to help her find this edge she was seeking. People work with producers to gain a vision they feel would be helpful to them. If Celine didn't want this, she would have produced it herself with no arguments from anyone.
halaluani 2 years ago
i agree that celine's version sounds extremely similar to kara's, but keep in mind that kara was the one who produced this song. and from the behind the scenes videos that came with her CD, kara was extremely nitpicky and had celine redo everything until she got it exactly to what she had in mind. so in a sense, celine is really great at giving the producers of her albums exactly what the want XP
jfong252 2 years ago
hey jfong252,
I just watched the making of it as per your suggestion. You are totally right. I didnbt know Kara produced the hell out of it.
So yes, it sounds the same because Kara made it that way.
thanks for the heads up. Also how gracious of celine to allow Kara her vision. Now i get the whole picture.
It wasnt copying. I was Celine trusting her producer.
Brava.
Ps I have total respect for celine and her incredible talent.
dirkworld 2 years ago
dont diss Celine before you know the whole picture. Kara practically forced her to sing it her way even tho Celine didnt want to.
parachuteboi 2 years ago
i love her salut! :)
Defyxx123 3 years ago
Perfect , Just Perfect :)
brodyntay 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh what a mess :( she doesn't use to sing that bad!!! besides they put slow the song!!! she has a sad cow face her :( well i didn't liked it .alv
shortswamp 3 years ago
lul wut?
You're obviously a loony. :o
Charlesagee 3 years ago
omg that was so funny
i just fell out of my chair
sad cow face
so perfect
lol
gutlover77 3 years ago
u fukin twat, how dare u , she is a legend, an idol, i;d like to c u sing like her.
louloute9876 2 years ago
what the fuck??
i dont have the right to say something was funny its not like i said it so
!CALM THE FUCK DOWN!
gutlover77 2 years ago
A LEGEND ! YEAH !
streepilicious 3 years ago 5
LIVING LEGEND
triniboymike 3 years ago 7
Watch these videos of her world tour 2008
It's A Man's World, All by myself, Power of love, taking chances, I drove all night - very nice opening. More power Celine!
ClayToris008 3 years ago 2
Celine ALWAYS SINGS LIVE in her concerts. Guys watch er videos of her 2008 world tour. SUPERB!!! especially march-october. Her tour is still on going though till next year. Gosh it seems her voice is still very powerful after series of concerts to think she has a show in Vegas for 5 consecutive years. TRULY AMAZING! in her tour she easily hit her high notes. and i love her moves! She can sing and dance gracefully at the same time! awesome!
ClayToris008 3 years ago 2
Celine Dion is legendary! She has "the one and only" voice. Nobody can sing like her. No wonder she was awarded the legendary award and also got the diamond award. She is hailed as the best selling female artist of all time. She is the most flexible artist I've ever seen. Can sing different types of songs. Can dance and sing gracefully at the same time. Also, she is very witty and humorous especially in her interviews. On top of that, she is humble unlike other artists. More power Celine!
ClayToris008 3 years ago 4
she is legendary, she is my idol, i love her!!!!!
i wish i could meet her!!!
louloute9876 2 years ago 36
at 0:59, she say : To last. She prononciate to last but, on the record, it seems more like : to lest. Proove she don't lip sync!
nenu485 3 years ago 3
look at that stage setting! Celine taking the world stage, on the universe singing for life on other planets! the wavering pieces of cloth over space. she's the one to take on that kind of universal stage!!
Creevie 3 years ago
This is her best performance on TV - not liysynced. 100% live, there are subtle differences. Good singers make it sound similar every time - and she is better than good.... she is PHENOMENAL <3 Celine!
Oldgeezer103 3 years ago 3
I love her peformances, whether she was lip-singing or not, because it's still her amazing voice you hear. She probably lip-sings it sometimes because she can't afford to use her voice too much or else it will get infected. Although it is nice to hear her sing live somtimes :)
kaykeii 3 years ago
i know she lips this song sometimes
but she sounds so amazing live
i love you celine!!!!!
mcjl232 3 years ago
she lost a bit from the intensity and power of her voice
eFlyFowler 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
agreed.
BaltasKarys 3 years ago
god no!yes her voice changed but she didn't lost anything
for example:listen how she sings all by myself now and compare with an old live performance...she didn't loose anything ;p
And anyway,I think that she was sick at that time,I'm not sure but I know that there was a time (during her promoting "tour" of the tv shows before the beginning of her world tour) when she've been sick or something like that
catchita 3 years ago 2
amazing!!!!!
idk why she lipsynches this song alot! she can do it amazing live!
ohboyitskayla 3 years ago
I know! As opposed to some of the other perfs where she just mimics the song... This is actually live and she sounds GREAT!
lovesit9 3 years ago
Hands DOWN her best performance on this song on US tv, miss thing worked IT!!! LUV HER!!
spiceyhotbj 3 years ago
Wow this was so perfect vocally.
mellowboy 4 years ago 3
This is the best version /watch?v=QT1CRk_ggWE
iljc82 3 years ago
it's like she is afraid to sing high in other video's i've seen of this song
87jt 4 years ago
it seems like the best performance on taking chances!!! i luv her
kukkidhen 4 years ago
Amazing! She sings it so well.
ohboyitskayla 4 years ago
Very well done x
slmala999 4 years ago
that was perfect
scorpianm 4 years ago
Now it's PERFECT! You go girl!
nandoferri 4 years ago
BRAVO:) I knew she could sing this song good;)
palmelukta 4 years ago
wonderful song, thanks Céline
FrenchPrince84 4 years ago
Good one.
ronny83it 4 years ago
a good performance of taking Chances, she looks really rested!
ukmale1982 4 years ago 3
That was reaally goood!
celfanatic 4 years ago